Environmental genocide’: Native Americans quit talks over Keystone XL pipeline
Published time: May 18, 2013 14:00
Edited time: May 19, 2013 07:58
Leaders from 11 Native American tribes stormed out of a meeting with US federal officials in Rapid City, South Dakota, to protest the proposed Keystone XL pipeline, which they say will lead to environmental genocide.
Native Americans are opposed to the 1,179-mile (1,897km) Keystone XL project - a system to transport tar sands oil from Canada and the northern United States to refineries in Texas - for various reasons, including potential irreversible damage to sacred sites, pollution, and water contamination.
Although the planned pipeline would not pass directly through any Native American reservation, tribes in proximity to the proposed system say it will violate their traditional lands and that the environmental risks of the project are simply too great.
Russ Girling, CEO of TransCanada, the company that hopes to build the pipeline, has promised in the past that Keystone XL will be the safest pipeline ever built.
The Indian groups, as well as other activist organizations, doubt the claim, saying the risks involved in the project are too high.
In an effort to ease their concerns, officials from the Department of State agreed to meet with tribal leaders on Thursday in the Hilton Garden Inn in Rapid City, Michigan.
Before the talks could begin, however, tribal leaders walked out, angered that the government had sent what they considered low-level representatives.
In a press conference following the walkout, tribal leaders took turns criticizing the project, as well as the Obama administration.
"I will only meet with President Obama," Bryan Brewer, president of the Oglala Sioux Tribe, told the Rapid City Journal.
Others mentioned environmental concerns with the proposed pipeline, which echo the concern of environmental groups across the country.
Casey Camp-Horinek, an elder with the Southern Ponca Tribe based in Oklahoma, compared the pipeline and other environmental damage to the historical events that had decimated her people during European colonization.
"We find ourselves victims of another form of genocide, and it's environmental genocide, and it's caused by the extractive industries," she said.
Charles LoneChief, vice president of the Pawnee Business Council, headquartered in Oklahoma, said the public was misinformed about the pipeline's environmental risks.
Unlike a traditional crude oil pipeline, Keystone XL will pump oil that is collected from tar sands. To turn this substance into a transportable liquid, oil companies must add chemicals that environmental groups warn are highly toxic.
"That gets into our waterways, our water tables, our aquifers, then we have problems," LoneChief said.
The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has estimated that the Keystone XL pipeline will increase annual US carbon pollution emissions by up to 27.6 million metric tons the impact of adding nearly 6 million cars on the road, according to the Environment News Service.
Robin LeBeau, a council representative for the Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe based in South Dakota, pledged to protest against any construction, even if that meant standing in front of bulldozers.
"What the State Department, what President Obama needs to hear from us, is that we are going to be taking direct action," she said.
I believe this is going to be one of the biggest battles we are ever going to have, LeBeau added.
This is not the first time that Native American groups have spoken out on the project.
Leaders from ten Canadian and US indigenous groups gathered in Ottawa, Ontario in March to protest the construction of pipelines.
Tar sands pipelines will not pass through [our] collective territories under any conditions or circumstances, the tribes said at a press conference.
The tar sands pipeline that spilled a million gallons of toxic heavy oil into Michigan's Kalamazoo River last summer illustrates the dangers this type of uniquely corrosive oil will bring along the Keystone XL route.
The pipeline rupture in Arkansas and countless other tar sands oil spills across the United States have demonstrated the devastating real-life impacts that await us if the Keystone XL is approved. Tell Secretary of State John Kerry to revise his department's environmental review and reveal the true price we will pay in toxic pollution and climate havoc.
Tags
Who is online
80 visitors

We are all just tiny little voices, easily drowned out by the Obama steamroller. He will get his pipeline and we will be cast as nothing more than a few environmental kooks. The usual democrat voices who side with environmentalists will remain conspicuously silent, for as only Nixon could go to China, only Obama could get the pipeline accomplished without the usual fuss. Trans-Canada must be very proud of their guy.
Aren't you assuming that this pipeline will benefit Americans directly? While in all "free markets" oil goes to the highest bidder. A benefit to oil industry corporate slugs.
I would suggest concern for the environment all along the proposed pipeline benefits Americans directly. The risk v reward is not in our favor.
Good call 1 miscreant. While we take the environmental risk, Canadian oil will be shipped most likely to China after being refined at Texas refineries. Seems like eveyone wins except us.
I also firmly believe, that our environment defines us and is more threatened now than ever before. Without it, we will be looking for somewhere else to 'colonize'. We all no how that worked out. These Native American leaders have their heads on straight, IMO.
That's supposed to make me feel better? Yes, oil companies will make money (they always do). Like I said, eveyone will win except us.
EI, there is no "US oil". All oil produced, even that produced in the US, goes into the world market and sold to the highest bidder. That a country can target where its oil goes is a fallacy. We may indeed get some of the tar sands oil, but only if its in the lot we win the bid on.
(Exceptions are when an oil industry is nationalized, like in the case of Venezuela)
Maybe its just me, but I have a hard time considering multi-national corporations as one of us, even despite the US Supreme Court's ruling that corporations are people.
By all means, share them with the class. I wait with baited breath to discover the truth. However, words are one thing and deeds are another. The history of all oil and gas industry behaviors does not bode well for any article supporting it.
As far aswho's "play" it is, American Oil Companies spend the money, they reap the benefits. Most business operate that way. "Play" is another word for environmental disaster.
You didn't comment on the environment, why? I'm interested to know, what environmental regulations this pipeline will avoid? Will it be bound by the Clean Air and Water acts? Or will it act like the "Shale Plays" in the US?
Right on.
is stated as environmental.
I smell the trickle down theory of corporate profiteering. *sniff* Hey wait, that bells like pee.
Sorry, it was supposed to read "smells like pee".
It's supposed to mean, even if the money goes to American companies it doesn't mean it benefits "American people".
Companies are not the ones who will pay for the cleanup either.
I hear yathat environmental thing is a tough nut to crack.
Please explain "profits"? Whose profits? What profits? The only one benefiting from this are the corporations....you mean they are going to share those profits?
The tribes were right to walk out. It's the U.S. government inability to deal with things in a transparent way. Their claims that they consulted the tribes earlierwas bullshit and was proven to be so.
They (the tribes) learned how to play the game, don't deal with low level peon's.
The EPA report claims that there will be no enviromental impact, but it also states that the price of gas in the U.S. will not be affected, nor will the oil stay in the U.S.
The point of who owns the companies that are involved in this is moot. They are multi-national, and have no alligence to anyone but themselves, stockholders and the bottom line.In addition the Canadian government is working hand and hand with these companies. As far as I know, the U.S. can't just walk into Canada and start mining.
Of course the consumption is to high and must be cut back, but the XL Pipeline is one battle in an overall war. Win this one, and it slows the destruction of the enviroment.
IMO
Sadly, this is an issue that industry and the Feds really don't understand. Indian nations are just that - "NATIONS". Corporations/industry/Fed agencies do not have the authority to "Consult" because they were not one of the two parties in the treaty negotiation. Those negotiations were between two governments.
"In an effort to ease their concerns, officials from the Department of State agreed to meet with tribal leaders on Thursday in the Hilton Garden Inn in Rapid City, Michigan.
Before the talks could begin, however, tribal leaders walked out, angered that the government had sent what they considered low-level representatives.
In a press conference following the walkout, tribal leaders took turns criticizing the project, as well as the Obama administration.
"I will only meet with President Obama," Bryan Brewer, president of the Oglala Sioux Tribe, told the Rapid City Journal."
"Officials from the Department of State" BS BS BS Check out the U. S. Constitution - treaties between the U. S. and the tribal Nations are the law of the land. The treaties and many SCOTUS rulings have held that a tribes/Nation's "Traditional Lands" will be, at all times, taken into consideration for any Federal Action. The EIS that was completed did not.
The EIS also lists massive environmental concerns, so the comment -"The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has estimated that the Keystone XL pipeline will increase annual US carbon pollution emissions by up to 27.6 million metric tons the impact of adding nearly 6 million cars on the road, according to the Environment News Service." - alone should scare the shit outta everybody.