╌>

Shock Video: California Police Break Into Home without warrant, Taze Homeowners

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  13 years ago  •  226 comments

Shock Video: California Police Break Into Home without warrant,  Taze Homeowners

The video begins with the cops standing on the mans front lawn looking in through the window having responded to a report of a noise disturbance called in by neighbors. Despite the fact that the couple are obviously not at loggerheads and no harm is coming to anybody, the police announce that they are going to break into the house without a warrant.

Why are you guys not coming out?, asks one of the officers, bemused at the fact that someone wouldnt follow orders.

Because we dont live in a police state, sir. Martial law has not been established in this country, responds the homeowner.

The officer then orders the couple to get down on the ground and put their hands behind their backs, adding, Were gonna kick in the door.

The cops kick down the door and enter the home with guns drawn as the homeowner exclaims, You have no right to be in here!

Despite the fact that the woman clearly has her hands in the air, a cop tazes her as she screams out in pain. The man is then also tazed.

I think the homeowners would win a law suit in this case.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Law suit!

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

well, it is calif.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

WTH do they think their doing..SUE THEM!!!

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

I am surprised they did not confiscate whatever they took the video with like the cops in CA did with peoples phones after they beat a man to death on the side of the road.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

My thoughts exactly! This is inexcusable, I will be interested to see how the law suit goes, I would be even more shocked if one is not filed.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

I am sure the guy would be tried for murder if he had shot them over this intrusion. Now if they weren't cops I am sure it would be an open and shut case in the homeowners favor.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Here's a legitimate question - why wouldn't he just open the door and explain to the cops that they were apparently sent on a false alarm? Yes, it is unfortunate the way that this ended, but it all could have been avoided - but that clearly isn't what the homeowners wanted - in fact, it appears that the homeowners got exactly what they were looking for. I don't generally side with the police, but in this case Ihave no sympathy for these homeowners who were obviously shopping for police brutality footage. Police have better things to do than spend time hanging around on the front porch of some asshole who hasn't the slightest clue how much freedom he does have as an American. Meanwhile, somewhere else in the city, a person is really being victimized while police are tied up with this bullshit.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

I disagree. He tried to explain through the screen door. The cops could see his wife and it was obvious there was no dispute going on. Then the cops were telling him to let them in, not just open the door. They had no warrant so the homeowner was within his rights, I would have reacted the same way, get a warrant or get screwed.

these homeowners who were obviously shopping for police brutality footage.

They did not call the police to come over. They stood up for their rights. If standing up for their rights got them the footage (and probably lawsuit) then justice is served. Police need to FOLLOW the law while enforcing it. Otherwise it is lawless thuggery.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

Welcome to the Modern Stress Monkey American Poleece State.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

I challenge that whole "without cause" crap. They were called to a disturbance. Who's to say that a lunatic wasn't in there holding a gun on all of them, telling them he would open fire if they didn't persuade the cops to go away. If that were to have happened, everyone commenting here would instead be commenting on an article about how worthless these police were for not insisting on verifying that nothing fishy was happening at the site of a disturbance that was called to their attention. Like I said, I'm not a big fan of the police, but in this instance I cannot in good conscience say that what these people were doing was innocent. They totally deserved what they got.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Bullshit. You and I both know that had they opened the door, stepped out on the porch, been cordial to public servants that arrived at their house for their protection, then chances are that nothing would have happened. By doing what they did, they created the appearance that something sinister was going on that the cops could not possibly see through a screen door. I've been in similar circumstances myself, and the police are not interested in making arrests and paperwork, they are interested in ensuring that a situation that was called to their attention is not going to escalate into domestic violence.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

You are basically saying they deserved to have their home raided because they would not allow unlawful entry to their home. Gee Hal what if I called about a disturbance at your house (doesn't matter if I am just a shit head neighbor that wants to cause you grief or not) and a bunch of cops with guns drawn were trying to force their way into your home. You would be A-OK with that right? Well hey, were do you live, let's do an experiment.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

Morally speaking, I do think that was within their rights but we all know how that would turn out. Screw with one of these guys and a million of em festooned in battle rattle will show up to shoot you and your dawg.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Did they arrive there randomly? No. It's not home invasion. Quit acting like this is some crooked cops shaking down the public. This was a set up. These people are damn lucky they didn't get shot, by creating a tense situation that didn't need to be.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Bullshit. The cops would have broke down the door just like they said they were going to.....see how easy it is to call bullshit this way? How do you explain them tazing the woman with her hands in the air Hal? How was that justified? Please explain.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Oh now it is a setup. SO the disturbance call was made by neighbors in cahoots trying to set up the cops. I wonder how they knew the cops would break in and give them great footage.... That sounds like a wacko conspiracy theory Hal, you're not one of THOSE are you?

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Get a fucking clue - they wouldn't have arrived with guns drawn, and I would have opened the door and dispelled what ever it was that they were mistaken about. I probably would have even let them in, if they wanted. Personally, I would have been more interested in what asshole sent in the false alarm. These are public servants whose job it is to fight actual crime, not waste their time with shitheads who seek to undermine their position. There may be a day when you want them on your side, and fucking with them like this is not a good way to promote a positive relationship.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Sorry, that comment is far too stupidto dignifya response.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

There may be a day when you want them on your side, and fucking with them like this is not a good way to promote a positive relationship.

If promoting a relationship means letting them do what they want regardless of whether it is within the rule of law or not, then it will NEVER be a positive relationship.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

6722_discussions.jpg Personally speaking, and my door mat might be a clue, I don't let LEO in my house without a warrant. I will go out on the porch and talk with them if I feel like it. I'm a peasant, not a serf.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

So, real cops would have said "fine sir, have anice day", and walked away? You would change your tune if someone had youat gunpoint and was warning you to convince the cops to go away. That is a situation that cops are trained for, and smart people realize that the smart move is to accommodate their request to make sure that there isn't a potentially violent situation happening behind the door.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

I'm sorry, but you are an idiot. There's really no reason to try and explain common sense to you. You just won't get it anyways. Go stroke your guns and whisper sweet nothings to your ammunition.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Amen! These "police" were not following the law.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Hal obviously doesn't care about what the laws say.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

I get the feeling the 4th is Void Where Prohibited By Law these days......

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Real cops would have gotten a warrant if they REALLY thought is was necessary.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

My dealing with LEO over the years has mostly been unpleasant, other than in conjunction with Vol Fire and S&E. That is one of the reasons I live way out in the woods. Live simply so the cops can't find you and all that.

Again, worth a peruse if you like ignoring the fourth or not.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

You would be the first onebemoaning howincompetent the system is that cops had to wait for a warrant to address a lethal situation that was happening under their noses.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

At least in California.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

You know what happens to innocent people that answer the door and talk to the police in situations like this? They don't get tazed, or shot. People who intentionally create situations like this make it worse for everyone else who is smart enough to defuse the situation with common sense. Fuck these people.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

The cops looked VERY determined to get in to me, and you never explained how they were justified in tazing the woman who had her hands up when they entered the home. Is that detail too much of an inconvenience for you Hal? Or are you just too much of an idiot to address it?

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Let's see, a guy intentionally isn't letting cops into his house as a result of a disturbance call,while he films the tense situation he is creating so he can post it as police brutality. There is no conspiracy, he's an idiot in plain view.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

I imagine it is very hard to explain the "two wrongs make a right" theory.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

What they want is to make sure there isn't an unstable domestic violence situation happening behind the door. Only an idiot sees this as cops doing what they want to do regardless of the law.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

She brought it on herself. No sympathy. If I'm on that jury, I'd recommend they hit her again for good measure.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Well guess what? He's an idiot with video evidence of police abuse of authority.

I bet the city doesn't think he's an idiot. I bet the city is wondering how much it's going to cost to 1) pay for the lawsuit 2) train police officersconcerning their duties tothe Constitution of the United States

DING DING DING give that man a prize! It is the cops that were the idiots in this case.

Sounds like you aresaying you can't think of a reasonable response to counter what 96 said.

It really is that obvious Hal.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Just more hypocritical bullshit from the anti-government crowd. I'm not a fan of every aspect of government, but at least I'm smart enough to pick my battles wisely - unlike the idiots in this video. These people are not oppressed, they are stupid.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

You are the idiot that keeps disputing the 4th amendment Hal, not me.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

She brought it on herself.

By putting her hands in the air? Looked like she was being cooperative once she realized these cops thought they were above the law.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

According to Hal whatever a cop wants to do is law.....no reading required. I don't expect he will ever get it. He is still arguing with me that these cops don't have to follow the 4th amendment.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

LOL - let me know when these cops get fired, okay? Let me know how big the judgment is for these poor, oppressed, good citizens is too. There is no way in hell that the actions were not justified by the police. For the last time - this situation could easily have taken place at the end of a shotgun being held on these homeowners from a criminal standing in the shadows, directing them to act in this manner. If they were indeed innocent victims of someone's hoax, then they should have been cooperative.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

perhaps he was a conservative

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

The people in the video were smart enough to know their rights and will probably be richer for it. The cops are the stupid ones in this case.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

Thanks for the article! Nice.

I had a Sheriff's Deputy come up here a couple of years ago. Luckily he didn't attempt a dynamic entry, just knocked on the door. He asked me if he could step inside and I just said, "No thank you sir" and stepped out on the porch. He just laughed and said he just wanted to see if I was serious about my mat. All in all, he thought it was pretty amusing.

He was astute enough to realize that I had no obligation to allow him entrance into my hovel and that not allowing such was not an admission to guilt or evile.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

That is an awfully large assumption. Besides all the cops would have to say is "we had to follow the law and get a warrant first". Period, end of story.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Now comes the part where you realize that I am right. Domestic violence is real, and people die from it, and it is the job of the police to stop it from happening. It is totally their business when someone calls in a domestic situation. If you had your way, criminals would rejoice in their new found approach to making cops leave their chaos without incident, so that they may continue on with their mayhem.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

If I had my way, LE would recognize and respect the Bill of Rights.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Good article...

who would want to live in a world where there were no limitations on when the government could come into your home, search your bank records, look through your medical records or your cell phone text messages or your email.

Would you like to answer this one Hal?

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

There is no good point whatsoever to 96's side of this argument. Cooperation with the police in this incident would have solved the problem. Instead, they insisted on pushing the wrong buttons. Choose your battles wisely.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Good for you and good for the cop!

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

By not opening the door, stepping out on the porch, and straightening out the innocent misunderstanding. Stop making me spell that out for you. It's not helping your case.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

Sadly, I think Hal may be correct in his assumption that whatever a cop wants to do is law. It does seem to be a reoccurring theme.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

You might want to ease up on the weed. Your paranoia is getting the best of you.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

You still believe in freedom and law and order, though.

He believes in it for cops for sure! Not so sure about us common folk though. LOL

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

The cops broke the law. This is a problem whether you want to admit it or not.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

I second that recommendation. Great read.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Which is exactly why you would be attacking the inefficiency and bureaucracy that lead to the death of innocent citizens.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Regardless of your misguided OPINION Hal, The homeowners were acting within the law and within their rights the police were NOT. These are the facts according to the laws of our country. If you want to argue the laws should change then fine, other than that you don't have a leg to stand on and neither will the cops if it goes to court.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Unfortunately for them, the couple will receive nothing but youtube hits from teabaggers and burn marks from a tazer, while the police will receive a continuous stream of paychecks for doing their job to protect and serve.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

I'm kicking your ass in this debate my mind...

I know all about the cheeba. I'm a huge proponent for legalization, but I don't partake. See? I'm not a shill for big brother, I just know what battles are worth taking on.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

If we have to ease up on the weed, you have to ease up on the beer or religion or whatever your personal choice of emotional morphine happens to be.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

It's both comical and sad that this is considered an ass kicking. This is the result of the dumbing down of America. Even criminals know that pushing police like this never ends well.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

The clip where they refused to step out on the porch to calmly dispel the confusion? That clip? Yes, I saw it.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Hal won't admit he has lost, hell he is still trying to argue that cops have the right to deprive you of your fourth amendment rights! BTW Hal you lost the debate because you either don't understand the law, or think that laws don't apply to police. Is this a result of "dumbing down"?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Which is exactly why I would say the cops did their job to the best of their ability given the restraints by law. Don't put words in my mouth Hal, it is obvious you are the irrational one in this discussion. No one is above the law, including cops.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

I can't see it either, probably is what they saw. lol

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Yes these videos seem to be springing up everywhere.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
I could have swore that it was a picture illustrating the justification for your empty, senseless argument.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
I will admit that I lost the debate when I meet you in the afterlife, after you were murdered by a home intruder who held a gun on you and told you "make that cop on the porch go away by using your 4th amendment rights or I swear I'll blow your head off" - which you did because you're an idiot, and then he killed you anyways as soon as the coast was clear - and you still insist that it was a good move to comply with your murderer. That's okay though - thinning out the gene pool is a natural part of the evolutionary process.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
All you "tyrannical gubamint" robots should try reading '500 Days' so you can learn where the assault on your Constitutional rights actually began.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
Some of us have jobs, family, a life, etc. Must be nice to sit around smoking pot all day though. Who's supporting your "independence"?
 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

I am not sure, but when they asked if there were children in the home and the reply was affirmative, that may have given them probable cause under California law. Might be some child protection law that was triggered by that response. (Why they had to protect the child playing in the yard is unclear.)

So, the Police may have been following the letter of the law when they gained entry forcibly, but violated the spirit of the law. Also, after gaining access, the man should have stated that he believed his Forth Amendment rights were being violated and that he was cooperating under protest. When the person who laid a hand on the officers arm did that, well, that can be considered provocation and resisting arrest and all bets were off at that point. You will note that no one was tazed until after he reached out to restrain the officer.

Yes one must pick ones battles, and one also must be cognizant of whatactionswill produce what results from a police officer. The big question here is were the police within their authority (we grant authority, we have rights) when they forcibly entered the home? As I stated above, they may have been within the letter of the law of the State of California given that they were responding to an incident of possible domestic abuse and children were present. Maybe.

I think that the video shows that there was no domestic violenceoccurringand the threat ofimmediateperil to officers or occupants of the home was not present. There was no clear and present danger. Therefore, I do not feel that the police were within the spirit of the law, even if there is such a law in CA, and that they were most certainly operating within the constitutionalguidelines either written or implied. IMO, this was a home invasion by the police. The people whose home it was acted pretty foolishly once it was clear that they were coming in, but just imagine the amount of adrenaline when three police officers show up at your door, demanding entry.

So, what should they have done? They got one part, at least, right when they told the officers that they were taking video footage of the event. They then should have requested a searchwarrant. When it became clear that the police were going to come in, they should have noted that it was a violation of their rights to do so.

Refusal of entry is not probable cause. Refusal to speak is not probable cause. Refusal to exit your house is not probable cause. If the police ask you to come out, tell them that you do not wish to come out. The police cannot legally compelyou to come out, whether they say they can or not. Make them get a warrant. Every time! (Love that doormat!) Even if you have nothing to hide and are a saint! Police ride over people because thepeoplelet them. We need to hold the police accountable for their actions on a consistent basis, and maybe then we will see a decrease of videos like this one.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
You got personal, and I dished it right back at you. I remember you from NV, and that crazy/scary profile you had there. Don't get me wrong, I've liked the majority of your contributions regardless of how abstract they are (I assume from the weed), but I scratch my head over your apparent drift into the tyrannical gubamint crowd.

Use those benefits when you need them, and I don't doubt that you do - but you're in with a strange crowd considering your source of income. If they had their way, there would be no such "socialistic" tit to feed off of. I plan on working until I simply can't get a job anymore, or die, or become disabled myself. One of my idols is my girlfriend's mother - she's 80 and just got laid off from the factory job she has worked at for decades. We laugh about her collecting unemployment. She will gladly go back if they call her back. It's no big deal for a single lady who still mows her own lawn and just painted her fence, at 80!

Sorry about you dog, btw. That sucks..... and yes, I chat on company time. I hate not being busy, so when when my duties are done I occupy my time here, since NV turned into a shithole. I was a beta tester and I didn't mind the changes. When it went live I couldn't stand it though. Didn't matter - they kicked me out anyways.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
I got the impression that you mistook my delay between comments as time thinking up a response,since you have continually insinuated that I'm getting my ass kicked in this debate. If that's not the case, then I misinterpreted your response to my snarky comment about BadFish's empty picture.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
Not to flatter you, but I remember randomly going to your page several times a year, during slow news days, to see if you removed your profile story, and thinking "this guy has balls to keep this here." As I recall, it involved a very unpopular word that starts with "r". I didn't disparage you for it, rather I saw it as an honest admission that the average joe buries in their psyche. I think we both are deeper than the average thinker. If we were neighbors, we would probably have regular fence chat over microbrews ... and you would more than likely have me participating in puff puff pass on a semi regular basis. :)I don't argue your point about Boston - I found the whole media portrayal thing disturbing as hell. I just refuse to admit that we Americans are now in tune with the whole CNN style of focused 'news' saturation. The more I am bombarded with it, the less significance it retains. It got to the point of pure, unadulterated fear mongering IMHO.As far as wealth distribution goes, the numbers don't lie. The middle class is under attack by corporate interests - as is the environment. Fuck Mitt Romney and the fuck the Republican Party for that matter. If there were a viable third party, I would support it. Because there wasn't, I went with the the obvious lesser of two evils.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

There is something not quite right about this story/video -- something in the voice of the homeowner. If it's legitimate and can be taken on its face value, then there's obviously a number of issues that appear to favor the homeowner. Still

I'd like to know who called the police and for what reason.

I'd like to know why the police ignored the question regarding a warrant.

I'd like to know more about the tasing

The video camera just happened to be ready to roll suspicious

Based solely on the video, the homeowner appears to have an airtight case of Fourth Amendment violations-plus

The Fourth Amendment ( Amendment IV ) to the United States Constitution is the part of the Bill of Rights which guards against unreasonable searches and seizures , along with requiring any warrant to be judicially sanctioned and supported by probable cause . It was adopted as a response to the abuse of the writ of assistance , which is a type of general search warrant , in the American Revolution . Search and seizure (including arrest) should be limited in scope according to specific information supplied to the issuing court , usually by a law enforcement officer , who has sworn by it . The Fourth Amendment applies to the states by way of the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment .

but I've represented a lot of people (prior to retirement) and learned early on that "slam dunks" are rare; I do admit readily that I am a cynic.

Let's see where this goes.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
Lol - you are entitled to the right to completely misunderstand the common sense that successfully guides matters in grey area. You can't create law that satisfies all the people all the time in all situations - therefore there will be instances where on the spot interpretation is required to meet the spirit of "protect and serve". These assholes were going out of their way to be difficult. Imagine if everyone in their (supposed) situation were to tell the cops to go away. There would no doubt be instances of domestic violence that get needlessly escalated just to protect some douchebag's right to be a difficult asswipe. Personally, I want the police to not let criminals control the situation. Someone called in a domestic disturbance, and it could have been resolved easily if not for some asshole's desire to irresponsibly test the grey area between the fourth amendment and public safety. People just love to point critical fingers at perceived tyranny, until it is their safety that is at risk.
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Sorry folks but that video doesn't really do it for me. There is too little information and too much video to make a call on this one.

On the surface it seems like the cops just knocked his door down, came in and tased the woman because they wouldn't come out, but it doesn't make much sense with the cop standing right in front of the window looking in without any fear for his life and then pursuing the action we see in this video.

I don't think I would have walked up to that window putting my life in jeopardy if I felt there really was a problem inside that needed my assistance as a police officer. If a policeman had knocked on my door under the same situation, I would open the door to see what he wanted as soon as I was confident he was a policeman.

I see no reason for not doing so in this situation. Something smells about this whole thing to me. Now I'm as big of a supporter of the 4th amendment as anyone you know, believe me, but we don't hire police officers to harm the innocent and there seems to be no reason to be so contrary as the homeowner appears to be to me.

I mean the police officer isn't there for no reason. He was given the order to check out a disturbance, evidently, and is doing so. His apparent stupidity for standing in front of the window is remarkable though.

If there had really been a crazed nut inside the policeman wouldn't be facing a law suit today, but could have very well been pushing up daisies.

Maybe he was hired by the judge who wouldn't hire that fellow who scored too high on the police test. I would say he probably needs to look into another profession because I don't think he is going to live very long in California in his current profession because there are some bad people who wouldn't video him looking into the window, but would blow him a way.

I see the homeowner promoting a scenario there must be something insidious going on inside or else he would have simply opened his door and talked with the police. I see the police assuming something bad was happening inside the house that needed their attention right away. Still can't get over the window watching though.

I don't believe the police should, with the little information I have, pursued the action they did, simply because of the 4th amendment. Something is missing here.

And we don't know what it is. We don't know who called, what was reported, if this was the first or one of many calls to this residence, the homeowners criminal record if any and many missing pieces of information. Actually there could have been someone holding a gun on these people and that was the reason they were reacting to the police the way they were. There is plenty enough of stupidity on both sides in this video.

I know some will say all that matters is the 4th Amendment and I can understand someone feeling that way, but we need more information to make an intelligent evaluation of this situation.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

It almost appears to have been scripted, staged -- like some of the discredited O'Keefe/Breitbart set ups.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Why would if make a difference if the homeowners called the police themselves as partof an investigative sting type of operation?

Two reasons; an intentional "false alarm" and entrapment possibly with the motive of generating a bogus propaganda video and/or bogus lawsuit.

And possibly "risking a catastrophe," "reckless endangerment."

I'm going with a "setup."

Regardless, I'll wager there's more to this -- but we'll see.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Think about it; a bunch of cops show up at your door

A typical reaction is "Why are you here; what's going on; we didn't call the police; what's this about, officer? Is there a problem?

BUT NO! This guy's ready with a video camera and a shit load of editorial commentary a la the NRA and 2nd Amendment lunatics who are convinced that Obama's coming for their guns so to prevent a police state they need to act militia-like.

I'm not questioning this family's rights -- I'm questioning a video that seems more like a staged piece of propaganda than a spontaneous chronicling of an event.

For openers, let's find out who called the police and why - who is this guy in the video (not his ID, rather if he has a history/agenda).

If he's clean and the video is exactly as it appears to be, then the police in the video need to be charged and prosecuted.

Is there more to this video that we haven't seen? Why didn't the police confiscate the video camera and destroy the "evidence"? I assume they knew they were being video recorded and looking like "a police state."

It doesn't smell right.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

Well, first off, to me it looked like the discussion had been going on prior to the point where the video started.

As to why the police did not confiscate the video, they might have confiscated the recording equipment, or not, there are several cameras that stream directly to the web. Also, there is the issue of children being present, which might have, in their opinion, given them the probable cause that was needed to affect direct entry.

Don't know, can't say.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Too many people here are willing subjects to the modern police state.

You don't just acquiesce every time a cop stands in front of you, otherwise, none of our Rights mean jack-shit.

You may or may not be correct about that and I'm not advocating acquiescence; rather I am addressing ONE VIDEO AND ONE INCIDENT -- the one regarding this particular discussion.

Every 911 call isn't probable cause.

But every 911 call that appears to be legitimate to the 911 operator has the potential to be exigent which is why there is not time to obtain a warrant.

And "exigent circumstances" allow police to proceed without a warrant.

I'm not saying the police in this video aren't culpable; I am saying that there are questions that need to be answered.

If the home owner is standing there, and saying "i didn't call you, I don't want you, and nobody here needs you", they can't just kick in the fucking door.

If that represents the entire scenario, I'm with you. We'll see maybe.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

The Camera starts with several officers already in the yard and it appears there was a conversation that lead to the homeowner to start taping, basically in the beginning he is saying I am taping this and asks "are you going to kick my door down without a warrant" or very similar, he is also saying "there is no domestic violence going on here" Which leads us to believe the call was for a domestic disturbance. There are definitely some questions I would like to know the answer to, it will be interesting to see how this shakes out, I think the cops have a lot of explaining to do.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

I've done some incredibly stupid things in my youth as well. Like you, I straightened out; but unlike you, I long for someone to invent a machine that can erase memories. Fortunately, my own errors have notimpacted me to the extent that they require an explanation in order to earn a living, but some of themsureplayed a part indestroying my credit report. :[ I look at it this way - I have learned some lessons via actual experience that most people can only "learn" from a book, or a tv show, or vicariously through someone else. You know the feeling, I'm sure.

You're good people too. Wrong, but good. ;)

There are plenty of justified instances to be outraged at police actions. Recently, I read about a man who was beaten to death by a group of officers while people recorded it in horror on their cell phones. Their phones were confiscated and never given back. I used to live in Virginia, where there is an actual law that if you can be seen through your house window drinking a beer in it's labeled container, you can bearrested forpublic intoxication. I've never heard of a case where it was used, butI believeit's purpose isto provide aloophole to enter a home and arrest a drunk who is being belligerent towards the police. I did hear of a case in VA where a man was arrested because he made the mistake of walking to his coffee maker in his kitchen butt naked for a cup of coffee at 6am. A child was walking to a bus stop and saw him through his window. These are cases where one can be outraged at police activity and terrible laws. A couple who refuses to walk out on their front porch and assure officers that the possibledomestic violence call they are responding to is a false alarm, and instead video records them breaking down the door in response to their suspicious baiting - that is a pair of douchebags who deserve no sympathy whatsoever. If you are a parent, and you teach your kids to act in this manner when a simple solution is available, you are not doing your kids any favors. That's how I see it, and I know I'm not alone.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

I was only referring to this video.....I don't have to use any politics to make my point. there's just not enough information presented to make an intelligent evaluation. I think if you re-read my comment above you should get that out of it.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

The fact remains, these people had no reason to do what they did other than to attempt to obtain controversial footage of police activity towards a suspicious situation of their own making.There is no reason to suppose that the police, in broad daylight, responding to a potential domestic violence situation, would have done anything other than ask a couple questions, verify that nobody is being hurt or threatened, apologized for the inconvenience, and said "have a nice day." They were baiting the police, acting like bad citizens, and keeping them from doing their jobs.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

It's not entrapment. The home owners obviously did not intice the officer to break the law. They merely offered them the opportunity to abuse their authority on camera.

We don't know that -- we have no way of knowing what occurred prior to the taping or even if we've seen the entire tape. I use "entrapment" generically here in that it, by definition, it is law enforcement that creates a set up entrapping an individual.

By definition entrapment

trick or deceive (someone), esp. by inducing them to commit a crime in order to secure their prosecution.

But if this scenario was contrived by the homeowner, that's a form of entrapment.

Police rushing in response to a 911 call creates the possibility of both "risking a catastrophe," and "reckless endangerment." The party making the 911 call, if it's fraudulent can be held responsible. It could be a totally separate incident on the way to answering the call.

In US law , endangerment comprises several types of crimes involving conduct that is wrongful and reckless or wanton , and likely to produce death or grievous bodily harm to another person.

The offense is intended to prohibit and therefore deter reckless or wanton conduct that wrongfully creates a substantial risk of death or serious injury to others.

18 Pa.C.S.A. 3302. Causing or risking catastrophe : (a) Causing catastrophe.--A person who causes a catastrophe by explosion, fire, flood, avalanche, collapse of building, release of poison gas, radioactive material or other harmful or destructive force or substance, or by any other means of causing potentially widespread injury or damage, including selling, dealing in or otherwise providing licenses or permits to transport hazardous materials in violation of 75 Pa.C.S. Ch. 83 (relating to hazardous materials transportation), commits a felony of the first degree if he does so intentionally or knowingly, or a felony of the second degree if he does so recklessly.(b) Risking catastrophe.--A person is guilty of a felony of the third degree if he recklessly creates a risk of catastrophe in the employment of fire, explosives or other dangerous means listed in subsection (a) of this section.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Had this been an actual instance where this suspicious behavior was being driven by a criminal in the shadows (but somehow surreptitiously recorded), and the police had lived up to your expectations and left the scene without true confirmation of their safety - and as a result the couple were robbed, raped, murdered, etc. - this article would be being posted here by the same person, using the same footage - except it would be all about how the police miserably failed to serve and protect. The comments would be something along the line of "I can't believe how stupid those cops were for not confirming their safety", and "the cops signed that couple'sdeath warrant", and "no sane person would tell the cops to leave - if those cops couldn't tell that this was a sign that they were in trouble then they need to be relieved of their duty". Police have a job to do, but some people just hate them so much that no matter how they do it, they will be chastised. That is what is happening here.

These are not good citizens. In fact, if some other crime were reported to have occurred while the police were being detained on this ridiculous "sting", the same poster here would have a seed filled with even more scathing remarks about the police, when the reality is that it would be these homeowners who were responsible for needlessly occupying the policemen's time.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Politics aside, my faith in law enforcement and the justice system has been shaken numerous times (first hand), so to a certain extent, I'm predisposed to accepting documentation such as in this incident without much fuss.

All I can say is when you've witnessed such things in person, it does change your perspective.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

I agree - I have witnessed first hand the police coming to my door, or the door of a friend's, in response to a possible domestic situation. If you answer it, and let them in, they can be of assistance in diffusing a situation before someone gets hurt. That doesn't necessarily mean that someone is going to jail. If someone is going to jail, then it is because they have assaulted someone else, or they have warrants. If it is a false alarm, there is absolutely no reason for not making that clear with a face to face confirmation. Doing what these people did is just stupid in my opinion.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

My agreement was with her last statement, and it wasmeant facetiously. I have had enough personal interaction with law enforcement to have perspective. I can only imagine the myriad ofshitty outcomes I avoided by not doing what the idiots in this video did. Answer the door, go outside and speak with them, and save yourself a miserable experience. If you take that approach, and it doesn't end peacefully, then you may have a case. If you want to be an asshole and bait the cops, good luck with that. Perhaps you will get your charges dropped, but you will suffer through a shit ton of misery, expenseand embarrassment in the process, all of which you brought on yourself with ignorant behavior.

I'm done talking about this. Those of you who think I'm wrong, go ahead and play your idiotic games with your local law enforcement and see where it gets you.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

If the circumstances were such that the police saved these two from a gunman holding a shotgun on them, would they have been breaking the law? Would you be chastising them or praising them then? It's a grey area that could EASILY have been negotiated by modicum of intelligent behavior. Instead, it was bungled by ignorant glory seekers.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Well, I hope you enjoyed those 14 years in prison. Sounds like they could have been avoided with a hair of humility and an ounce of patience, but God forbid that you be expected to bow down to the man. Prison is totally worth not having to do that, right? I suspect a good tazing or even a bullet would be worth it too.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

There's nothing like personal experience to predispose one to be on automatic when he/she reads or sees a video like this one. I understand completely.

I've been trying to get out of that mode, but I find it pretty difficult since I've witnessed even things that I wouldn't believe if someone else told me unless I hadn't already experienced it myself or witnessed someone else experiencing it. But this whole thing is something else to put it lightly. Even witnessing this video is unbelievable to me that both the police and the homeowner can act so stupid.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Your example isn't even remotely related to this article. Go seed an article using your examples of police injustice and I will gladly side with you. The clip in this article involves a couple who are going out of their way to bait law enforcement into violating their fourth amendment rights on camera. Here's some more of my opinion for you - they got what they deserved. On top of that, we know nothing other that what we see in the clip. There could be plenty more that we don't know. Maybe these people had outstanding bench warrants, maybe there was a meth lab in the house, maybe they had three teenage girlschained up in a bedroom - who knows. Regardless, what they did was wrong, and if the only reason they did it was to avoid being taken in on a bench warrant or to evade detection of other illegal activity, thenwhat they did is even lessjustified. If they want sympathy from me, then capture footage of being mistreated AFTER being cooperative.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago
So this reckless endangerment doohickey. Would that be like cops breaking into a home without a warrant and tazing a woman who may have had some serious health condition?

It could be, but I'm referring to a situation that starts with a bogus 911 call that puts law enforcement into motion; should some incident result, be it one that was unforeseen and/or one that comes about in direct conjunction with the "reason" for the 911 call, there are numerous scenarios under which police, innocent bystanders, etc. could become endangered or actually victimized in some way -- and all because of a bogus alarm.

Seems like to me your arguments all work both ways, and the pivot point is what laws were broken and by whom.

And yes, I can see it happening both ways.

We have only the video.

And it's clear unless you theorize a bunch of conspiracy stuff.

No, it's not clear what if you walked into a movie theater in the middle of a film that you knew nothing about and saw police beating the hell out of a character that looked like a regular Joe?

If you turned and left the theater, you might conclude that the movie was about "police brutality" -- but what if you walked in at the start of the film, or, stayed beyond the beating scene -- how many different stories could you imagine?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

So, a sting is an acceptable tactic. Just not one used against police very often. Though it's happened before.

No, it's illegal if a citizen contrives it to entrap.

In law enforcement, a sting operation is a deceptive operation designed to catch a person committing a crime. A typical sting will have a law-enforcement officer or cooperative member of the public play a role as criminal partner or potential victim and go along with a suspect's actions to gather evidence of the suspect's wrongdoing.

But and especially if the "sting" begins with a bogus 911 call

  • Citizens would have no legal sanction; Sting operations are generally reviewed by the city or district attorneys office to ensure that they follow all the proper legal procedures required for such an operation.

L.A. NOW

Southern California -- this just in

Previous Post | L.A. NOW Home | Next Post

Charges filed in 911 call that led to slaying by Pasadena police

March 22, 2013| 9:00 am
The 911 caller who falsely claimed that he was robbed at gunpoint the night Pasadena police shot and killed unarmed 19-year-old robbery suspect Kendrec McDade is due in court Tuesday to face misdemeanor charges that he lied to emergency dispatchers.

Oscar Carrillo, 27, is charged with one count of making a false report of a criminal offense and a second count of reporting an emergency knowing the report was false, a Pasadena city spokesman said.

If convicted on both counts, Carrillo faces a maximum sentence of 18 months in jail, his defense attorney, Andres Bustamante, told the Pasadena Sun .

Carrillo, who has already pleaded not guilty to the charges, is scheduled to return to court on March 26 for a pretrial hearing.

The city prosecutors office filed the charges after the Los Angeles County district attorneys office declined a request by Pasadena police to charge him with manslaughter.

Bustamante accused the city of prosecuting Carrillo as a way to redirect responsibility for McDades death.

I think theyre deflecting, Bustamante said. It seems to me the city feels obligated that [Carrillo] must take some kind or responsibility. Their position has always been that he set in motion certain events that lead to the tragic shooting of this African American teenager.

An internal review of the shooting incident , announced Wednesday, determined that the two Pasadena police officers who shot McDade during the robbery investigation one year ago acted within departmental policy.

And in December, an investigation by the Los Angeles County district attorneys Justice System Integrity Division concluded that the officers had a reasonable fear of imminent death or serious bodily injury and acted in lawful self-defense and defense of others in shooting McDade.

Investigations by the Los Angeles County Office of Independent Review and the FBI remain ongoing, according to police.

...

And

WAUKESHA CO. 33-year-old Aisha Jackson is accused of making fake 911 calls in order to avoid getting a ticket for her driving. She now faces seven criminal charges of falseemergency (911) phone use.

...

And

Pasadena Man Lies to Police, Gets Manslaughter Charge After Police Shoot Suspect

...

Get the idea?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

when there is video evidence, you gon't get to bring a bunch of speculative cases to bear.

The video is not necessarily "evidence" - if the 911 call is determined to be a set up, the video ironically might be used in evidence against the guy who made it.

Remember the O'Keefe/ACORN video?

Sometimes the hunter gets captured by the game.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

Perhaps I am just old as dirt and have had a longer time to witness the transformation of LE in this country, but I'd have to argue that, if not already there, we are a rats patooty from becoming a Poleece State. The militarization of LE has pretty much made Posse Comitatus a moot point in my humble opinion. We have traded a civilian entity for a paramilitary operation complete with military training and tons of mil surp rigs, weaponry and such. With the pounding the Bill of Rights has taken from the Patriot Act and the so called "war on drugs", it looks pretty organized from my perch on the socio economic ladder.

Maybe the myopia lessons the lower on the ladder one happens to sit, and just who the "serve and protect" applies to is an indication of where we are headed. Seemingly LE is, and historically speaking it's always pretty much been the case, designed to protect the assets of the haves from the have nots.

We may not currently be in the "V for Vendetta" territory but we are getting closer every day.

best your way

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

But you aren't really addressing one video and one event; you are registering a suspicision based apparently on the fact that some people know their rights and keep a video camera handy.

Disagree; the burden of proof is on the one making the allegation; if the video is what it appears to be, that's one thing, if it was contrived and put into motion by a fake 911 call, that's entirely different.

Every event must be considered on its own particulars.

But if the sheriff shows up you can bet your ass I'll have the camera on.

But if you called 911 to bring the sheriff and there was no emergency, and, it can be determined that your intention was to create an incident, then the video might be used against you.

I could also hold forth on the many instances of police brutality I've seen on Youtube and question him/her about those while I tried to decide if I wanted to go out on the porch where they could then legally pat me down for a weapon.

Did you see everyone in Boston just let cops into their homes with no warrant?

It matters not how many other instances you can cite; each situation is investigated and adjudicated based on attendant circumstances. And the police in Watertown were able to clear the homes because of exigent circumstances -- a criminal was last seen in the area and a police officer had been murdered.

Did you see the police being applauded by the citizens of Watertown after the apprehended the suspect without a warrant.

Exceptions to the warrant requirement

Exigent circumstance

There are also "exigent circumstances" exceptions to the warrant requirement. Exigent circumstances arise when the law enforcement officers have reasonable grounds to believe that there is an immediate need to protect their lives, the lives of others, their property, or that of others, the search is not motivated by an intent to arrest and seize evidence, and there is some reasonable basis, to associate an emergency with the area or place to be searched.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

can not really say much as to the video , unless thats the only evidence being presented . nothing has been said as to what happened up to the point that it started to be taken, what discussion if any took place before it started? Was any verbal statement made before the camera started rolling to make the cops think something wasnt what it should be? i sat on a jury several yrs ago where the deputies were called to a domestic , the man used the 4th as a defense or tried to, but the thing that turned that case against him was his utterance of a threat to the responding officers , so he was found guilty simply on that fact , having a constitutionally codefied and protected right does not leave one free to utter threats to law enforcement .

Now did the people have an obligation to talk to the police over a DV call? actually no they dont they can exersize the right to remain silent at any time , and cops do not have to state anything they say can be used against them in a court of law either ( miranda) unless they intend to place someone under arrest/apprehension. Nor was the people out of line ( if no threats or other agressive actions taken ) in refusing entry without a warrent( Mac , you pointed out about vehicle searches w/o a warrent i think the difference here is a domicile , vs a vehicle used on public byways , 2 totally seperate things )

As for a set up or civilian sting operation? highly doubtful really , but not unthinkable , and with todays technology and the advice to always get confrontatuions on video if possable , i can see somene having a camera handy , hell i have 3 grand kids that visit all the time , and i have a digital camera ( both on my phone and a seperate one ) handy and ready to go( all i have to o is flip the screens and they are recording )for some of the things they do ( that 2 yr old is gonna make AFHV one of these days ).

I dont think the whole story is being told just yet , there is a gap in information as to what happened from arrival on scene , to when the camera was started , so there is not enough information to determine what happened and whom would be deemed in the wrong or at fault . one thing i can and will say is the tazing was out of line for the simple reson that the individuals once the LEO got inside , made no efforts to resist and were being compliant and non threats , that appears to be an instance you didnt do as we demanded so now we are gonna shock your ass and cause some real pain extra judicial punishment , vindictiveness on the parts of the cops . time will tell if it ever gets anymore air time or reporting , i doubt it will but this seems to be happening more and more IMHO lately.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Mac , you pointed out about vehicle searches w/o a warrent i think the difference here is a domicile , vs a vehicle used on public byways , 2 totally seperate things )

Exigent circumstances apply broadly;

There are six major exceptions to the warrant requirement.

1. Search Incident to Lawful Arrest

A search incident to lawful arrest does not require issuance of a warrant. In other words, if someone is lawfully arrested, the police may search her person and any area surrounding the person that is within reach (within his or her wingspan). See Chimel v. California, 395 U.S. 752 (1969). The rationale is that the search is permissible as a protective measure.

EXAMPLE: John is arrested for driving while intoxicated after being pulled over for running a red light. A search of his car reveals 8 bags of heroin in the glove compartment and an illegal handgun in the trunk. The heroin is admissible evidence for which no warrant was required as the glove compartment is certainly within Johns wingspan. The gun found in the trunk, however, was not within his wingspan, and was the result of an unreasonable search. This evidence will be excluded.

2. Plain View Exception

No warrant is required to seize evidence in plain view if the police are legitimately in the location from which the evidence can be viewed. For example, an officer cannot illegally enter a suspects back yard and then use the plain view exception to seize an illegally kept alligator living in the pool. But, if on the premises to serve a warrant duly issued to search for marijuana plants, the alligator, if in plain view, can rightly (though by no means easily) be seized.

EXAMPLE: The police are called to Donalds house by neighbors who see him beating up his wife, Victoria. After properly entering the house (without a search warrant see emergency exception below), police notice Donalds prized gun collection hanging on the wall. Fortunately for the officers, the guns are not loaded. Unfortunately for Donald, many of them are illegal and Donald is arrested for battery as well as for the illegal guns, which are seized.

3. Consent

If consent is given by a person reasonably believed by an officer to have authority to give such consent, no warrant is required for a search or seizure. So, if a suspects "significant other" provides police with a key to the suspects apartment, and police reasonably believe that she lives there, the search will not violate suspects Fourth Amendment rights even if she did not live there and even if she, in fact, lacked authority to consent, . See Illinois v. Rodriguez, 497 U.S. 177 (1990).

EXAMPLE: Officer Warren knocks on a murder suspects door. the door is answered by the suspects 6 year old child, Timmy. The officer asks Timmy Is it okay if I come in and talk to your Dad? Hes expecting me. And then walks into the apartment. He then sees the suspect, Roland, sitting on the sofa oiling his illegal Tommy-gun, the suspected murder weapon. He arrests Roland for possession of the gun and seizes the evidence. Because Timmy, being a small child, was not legally able or authorized to give consent, the entry was illegal and the evidence will be excluded.

4. Stop & Frisk

Police may stop a suspect so long as there is a reasonable suspicion of a criminal act. The evidence necessary for reasonable suspicion here is something beyond mere suspicion, but is less than the level required for probable cause . If there is reason to believe that the person may be armed and dangerous, the police can also frisk the suspect. See Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968).

EXAMPLE: Officer P. Harkers peers often joke that he has something akin to a spidey-sense which tells him when folks are up to no good. While enjoying a cup of coffee at his favorite donut shop, Officer Harkers neck hairs stand up straight. He immediately goes outside where he sees Ivan walking down the street, carrying a small duffel bag. He orders Ivan to stop and drop the bag. When the bag falls, Officer Harker hears the clanging of metal against metal. He then frisks Ivan and discovers a hidden pistol in Ivan's pocket. He then searches the duffel bag and discovers ammunition and several illegal hunting knives. Despite the fact that Officer Harkers spidey-sense proved accurate once again, the evidence will be excluded as he can not articulate any reason why he stopped Ivan, other than his unusually active neck hairs.

5. Automobile Exception

Because vehicles are obviously highly mobile, a warrant is not required to search vehicles if police have probable cause to believe the vehicle contains evidence of a crime, the instrumentalities of crime, contraband, or the fruits of a crime. Although commonly referred to as the automobile exception, this rule applies to any vehicle, including boats. While in some ways, it is quite a broad exception, this rule limits the ability to search those areas which might contain evidence of the type suspected to be present. In other words, if police suspect that the occupant of a boat is smuggling people across the border, searching a small tackle box on board would not be permissible. However, if they were looking for drugs, they could search the tackle box. The rationale is that, if an officer has to take the time to obtain a warrant, the vehicle might be out of reach before the warrant can be issued and executed. See Carroll v. United States, 267 US. 132 (1925).

EXAMPLE: Officer Demidum has reason to believe that an abandoned car on the corner contains illegal drugs in the trunk. The car is missing all four wheels and is up on cinder blocks, and the engine was stolen long ago. Assuming that the automobile exception applies, Officer Demidum uses a crowbar to force open the still-working lock on the trunk. There, he finds 10 kilos of cocaine. Rushing back to the station house to show off the evidence to his Captain, Officer Demidum runs into Judge Sosad. Judge Sosad says You should have called me first. While its great to get the drugs off the street, unfortunately we cant use this as evidence against anyone. The search was illegal, as the automobile exception to the warrant requirement only applies when the vehicle is actually capable of being moved. Thats the whole point of the exception! A dejected Demidum continues on to the station, where he has to tolerate cars drawn in shaving cream on his locker for the next month.

6. Emergencies/Hot Pursuit

The rationale here is similar to the automobile exception. Evidence that can be easily moved, destroyed or otherwise made to disappear before a warrant can be issued may be seized without a warrant. Furthermore, if a suspect enters private property while being pursued by officers, no warrant is required to enter that property in order to continue pursuit, even if the suspect is in no way connected with the property owner.

EXAMPLE: While running from police, Fred enters Joes garage and the police follow Fred in. (They are not required to give up pursuit until such time as they can obtain a search warrant for the premises.) While in Joe's garage, police notice illegal drugs in plain view. They can arrest Fred for his crimes, and they can also seize the drugs and arrest Joe for possession of the drugs, even though Joe had nothing to do with Fred and the police were in Joes garage only because of the hot pursuit of Fred!

Unless the fact-pattern fits one of the six exceptions discussed above, a warrant is required for police to conduct a search or seizure. Note that for Exception 1, search incident to a lawful arrest, and Exception 5, the automobile exception, although no warrant is required, there is a probable cause requirement. For a search incident to a lawful arrest, the officer must have had probable cause for the original arrest. If the original arrest was unreasonable or unlawful, the evidence discovered from the search will be excluded as fruit of the poisonous tree (see the subchapter on the Exclusionary Rule). For the Automobile Exception, the officer must have probable cause to believe that the vehicle contains evidence of a crime, instrumentalities of a crime, contraband, or fruits of a crime, whether the vehicle is moving or already stopped. Exception 4 ("stop and frisk") does not require probable cause, but does require "reasonable suspicion." Only Exception 3 (consent) requires no grounds on the part of the police for making the search.

ExToWarrantReq1.gif

2003 - 2007 National Paralegal College

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

And cops violate the 4th amendment every day, even with all the loopholes. Remember, a violation of the 4th amendment results in ONLY the evidence obtained being deemed inadmissible. There may, however, be 1983 actions, but they are becoming more and more rare due to numerous higher court decisions protecting the government.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

thumbs_up.png

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

That's a big ass thumb.

6723_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

nice sumation of the exemptions Mc , but to your mind which of the exemptions would apply? about the only one i can even remotely see applying is the search after lawful arrrest , and as far as i know , not aquiesing to leo desires is not exactly grounds for arrest unless some other infraction has been committed , simply refusing to talk ( 5th amendment protection to remain silent and say nothing at all , is not a lawful grounds for arrest) so basically your saying the police can arrest anyone for anything such as saying they have nothing to say, and then conduct a search after the arrestwithout any warrent needed . since there was nothing in plain sight ( that we are made aware of )that is illegal or a danger, that consent is definitely NOT being given, no autos are involved, that leaves the arrest exemption or the emergency exemption , though there appears to be no emergency or hot pursuit evident that would lead to grounds for arrest in the first place . me ild go with the search after lawful arrest , even if the arrest appears to be unlawful and extremely flimsey . but hey those cops did teach them a lesson about respecting their perceived authority now didnt they?

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

Not that I advocate going by anything you see online but here's an interesting little bit from a defense attorney in regard to warrentless searches and such.

I think we have to assume that LE does not know the law. We have such a glut of law on the books it isn't really all that surprising but there you have it. A few years ago LE arrested a fellow up in Virginia for open carry, in an open carry state. So it goes.

Resist politely and you might not get a beating. Anyhow,

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

nice sumation of the exemptions Mc , but to your mind which of the exemptions would apply?

I won't venture to say because if the video is conclusive -- and I can't see how it could be minus the information regarding what/who/how the police were brought to the scene -- based solely on what the video shows, no exigent circumstances can be determined.

If I assume that a 911 call came i.e. from a neighbor, let's say because of loud voices that may have been perceived as a potentially explosive domestic dispute, then the police might claim "exigent circumstances."

But then, upon arriving at the home without a warrant (as with virtually all responses to 911 calls), the police saw no overt signs of anything out-of-the-ordinary, the obvious question would be, "why the apparent police-thug behavior?"

And that's where none of us can say definitively -- are we seeing the entire episode from the time the police arrived until they left -- has the video been truncated, edited -- was it a set up - a citizen-sting (which I would contend would be illegal)? Is there a police-cam video?

I believe there's much we don't know and I wonder if we'll ever have the whole story.

Good dialogue, Mark!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

In effect it allows the cops to do almost anything they want subject to a judges later determination of right and wrong....

But the police would need to satisfy a burden-of-proof regarding the so-called exigent circumstances. In recent years, video-cams on police vehicles have, in some instances, actually shown police to be lying about "exigent" circumstances.

That's not to say that police don't get the court's benefit of the doubt when all there is in the way of evidence is "hearsay."

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Now you're just boring me. These turds could have avoided all this, but they decided to be like that asshole brother that sticks his finger in your face in the back seat of the car, saying "I'm not touching you I'm not touching you". They deserved to get abused just like that brother deserved the good punch in the face he got. Now they're crying just like that brother cried to mommy, and like anydecent mother, any decent person watching this video will just smirk and say "serves you right for being a little annoying asshole."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Gotcha a nice skyscraper started.

I'm just answering the questions as they come in the thread. The only assumption I've made about this video is that, if this is all the information we're getting regarding the incident we can't make any assumption other than "we need more information."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Point of fact, a person would have to be a moron to call 911 trying to sting the police.

There is no shortage on morons!

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Law suit!

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

well, it is calif.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

WTH do they think their doing..SUE THEM!!!

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

I am surprised they did not confiscate whatever they took the video with like the cops in CA did with peoples phones after they beat a man to death on the side of the road.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

My thoughts exactly! This is inexcusable, I will be interested to see how the law suit goes, I would be even more shocked if one is not filed.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

I am sure the guy would be tried for murder if he had shot them over this intrusion. Now if they weren't cops I am sure it would be an open and shut case in the homeowners favor.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Here's a legitimate question - why wouldn't he just open the door and explain to the cops that they were apparently sent on a false alarm? Yes, it is unfortunate the way that this ended, but it all could have been avoided - but that clearly isn't what the homeowners wanted - in fact, it appears that the homeowners got exactly what they were looking for. I don't generally side with the police, but in this case Ihave no sympathy for these homeowners who were obviously shopping for police brutality footage. Police have better things to do than spend time hanging around on the front porch of some asshole who hasn't the slightest clue how much freedom he does have as an American. Meanwhile, somewhere else in the city, a person is really being victimized while police are tied up with this bullshit.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

I disagree. He tried to explain through the screen door. The cops could see his wife and it was obvious there was no dispute going on. Then the cops were telling him to let them in, not just open the door. They had no warrant so the homeowner was within his rights, I would have reacted the same way, get a warrant or get screwed.

these homeowners who were obviously shopping for police brutality footage.

They did not call the police to come over. They stood up for their rights. If standing up for their rights got them the footage (and probably lawsuit) then justice is served. Police need to FOLLOW the law while enforcing it. Otherwise it is lawless thuggery.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

Welcome to the Modern Stress Monkey American Poleece State.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

I challenge that whole "without cause" crap. They were called to a disturbance. Who's to say that a lunatic wasn't in there holding a gun on all of them, telling them he would open fire if they didn't persuade the cops to go away. If that were to have happened, everyone commenting here would instead be commenting on an article about how worthless these police were for not insisting on verifying that nothing fishy was happening at the site of a disturbance that was called to their attention. Like I said, I'm not a big fan of the police, but in this instance I cannot in good conscience say that what these people were doing was innocent. They totally deserved what they got.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Bullshit. You and I both know that had they opened the door, stepped out on the porch, been cordial to public servants that arrived at their house for their protection, then chances are that nothing would have happened. By doing what they did, they created the appearance that something sinister was going on that the cops could not possibly see through a screen door. I've been in similar circumstances myself, and the police are not interested in making arrests and paperwork, they are interested in ensuring that a situation that was called to their attention is not going to escalate into domestic violence.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

You are basically saying they deserved to have their home raided because they would not allow unlawful entry to their home. Gee Hal what if I called about a disturbance at your house (doesn't matter if I am just a shit head neighbor that wants to cause you grief or not) and a bunch of cops with guns drawn were trying to force their way into your home. You would be A-OK with that right? Well hey, were do you live, let's do an experiment.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

Morally speaking, I do think that was within their rights but we all know how that would turn out. Screw with one of these guys and a million of em festooned in battle rattle will show up to shoot you and your dawg.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Did they arrive there randomly? No. It's not home invasion. Quit acting like this is some crooked cops shaking down the public. This was a set up. These people are damn lucky they didn't get shot, by creating a tense situation that didn't need to be.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Bullshit. The cops would have broke down the door just like they said they were going to.....see how easy it is to call bullshit this way? How do you explain them tazing the woman with her hands in the air Hal? How was that justified? Please explain.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Oh now it is a setup. SO the disturbance call was made by neighbors in cahoots trying to set up the cops. I wonder how they knew the cops would break in and give them great footage.... That sounds like a wacko conspiracy theory Hal, you're not one of THOSE are you?

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Get a fucking clue - they wouldn't have arrived with guns drawn, and I would have opened the door and dispelled what ever it was that they were mistaken about. I probably would have even let them in, if they wanted. Personally, I would have been more interested in what asshole sent in the false alarm. These are public servants whose job it is to fight actual crime, not waste their time with shitheads who seek to undermine their position. There may be a day when you want them on your side, and fucking with them like this is not a good way to promote a positive relationship.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Sorry, that comment is far too stupidto dignifya response.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

There may be a day when you want them on your side, and fucking with them like this is not a good way to promote a positive relationship.

If promoting a relationship means letting them do what they want regardless of whether it is within the rule of law or not, then it will NEVER be a positive relationship.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

10391_discussions.jpg Personally speaking, and my door mat might be a clue, I don't let LEO in my house without a warrant. I will go out on the porch and talk with them if I feel like it. I'm a peasant, not a serf.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

So, real cops would have said "fine sir, have anice day", and walked away? You would change your tune if someone had youat gunpoint and was warning you to convince the cops to go away. That is a situation that cops are trained for, and smart people realize that the smart move is to accommodate their request to make sure that there isn't a potentially violent situation happening behind the door.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

I'm sorry, but you are an idiot. There's really no reason to try and explain common sense to you. You just won't get it anyways. Go stroke your guns and whisper sweet nothings to your ammunition.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Amen! These "police" were not following the law.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Hal obviously doesn't care about what the laws say.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

I get the feeling the 4th is Void Where Prohibited By Law these days......

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Real cops would have gotten a warrant if they REALLY thought is was necessary.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

My dealing with LEO over the years has mostly been unpleasant, other than in conjunction with Vol Fire and S&E. That is one of the reasons I live way out in the woods. Live simply so the cops can't find you and all that.

Again, worth a peruse if you like ignoring the fourth or not.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

You would be the first onebemoaning howincompetent the system is that cops had to wait for a warrant to address a lethal situation that was happening under their noses.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

At least in California.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

You know what happens to innocent people that answer the door and talk to the police in situations like this? They don't get tazed, or shot. People who intentionally create situations like this make it worse for everyone else who is smart enough to defuse the situation with common sense. Fuck these people.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

The cops looked VERY determined to get in to me, and you never explained how they were justified in tazing the woman who had her hands up when they entered the home. Is that detail too much of an inconvenience for you Hal? Or are you just too much of an idiot to address it?

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Let's see, a guy intentionally isn't letting cops into his house as a result of a disturbance call,while he films the tense situation he is creating so he can post it as police brutality. There is no conspiracy, he's an idiot in plain view.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

I imagine it is very hard to explain the "two wrongs make a right" theory.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

What they want is to make sure there isn't an unstable domestic violence situation happening behind the door. Only an idiot sees this as cops doing what they want to do regardless of the law.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

She brought it on herself. No sympathy. If I'm on that jury, I'd recommend they hit her again for good measure.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Well guess what? He's an idiot with video evidence of police abuse of authority.

I bet the city doesn't think he's an idiot. I bet the city is wondering how much it's going to cost to 1) pay for the lawsuit 2) train police officersconcerning their duties tothe Constitution of the United States

DING DING DING give that man a prize! It is the cops that were the idiots in this case.

Sounds like you aresaying you can't think of a reasonable response to counter what 96 said.

It really is that obvious Hal.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Just more hypocritical bullshit from the anti-government crowd. I'm not a fan of every aspect of government, but at least I'm smart enough to pick my battles wisely - unlike the idiots in this video. These people are not oppressed, they are stupid.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

You are the idiot that keeps disputing the 4th amendment Hal, not me.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

She brought it on herself.

By putting her hands in the air? Looked like she was being cooperative once she realized these cops thought they were above the law.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

According to Hal whatever a cop wants to do is law.....no reading required. I don't expect he will ever get it. He is still arguing with me that these cops don't have to follow the 4th amendment.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

LOL - let me know when these cops get fired, okay? Let me know how big the judgment is for these poor, oppressed, good citizens is too. There is no way in hell that the actions were not justified by the police. For the last time - this situation could easily have taken place at the end of a shotgun being held on these homeowners from a criminal standing in the shadows, directing them to act in this manner. If they were indeed innocent victims of someone's hoax, then they should have been cooperative.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

perhaps he was a conservative

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

The people in the video were smart enough to know their rights and will probably be richer for it. The cops are the stupid ones in this case.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

Thanks for the article! Nice.

I had a Sheriff's Deputy come up here a couple of years ago. Luckily he didn't attempt a dynamic entry, just knocked on the door. He asked me if he could step inside and I just said, "No thank you sir" and stepped out on the porch. He just laughed and said he just wanted to see if I was serious about my mat. All in all, he thought it was pretty amusing.

He was astute enough to realize that I had no obligation to allow him entrance into my hovel and that not allowing such was not an admission to guilt or evile.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

That is an awfully large assumption. Besides all the cops would have to say is "we had to follow the law and get a warrant first". Period, end of story.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Now comes the part where you realize that I am right. Domestic violence is real, and people die from it, and it is the job of the police to stop it from happening. It is totally their business when someone calls in a domestic situation. If you had your way, criminals would rejoice in their new found approach to making cops leave their chaos without incident, so that they may continue on with their mayhem.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

If I had my way, LE would recognize and respect the Bill of Rights.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Good article...

who would want to live in a world where there were no limitations on when the government could come into your home, search your bank records, look through your medical records or your cell phone text messages or your email.

Would you like to answer this one Hal?

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

There is no good point whatsoever to 96's side of this argument. Cooperation with the police in this incident would have solved the problem. Instead, they insisted on pushing the wrong buttons. Choose your battles wisely.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Good for you and good for the cop!

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

By not opening the door, stepping out on the porch, and straightening out the innocent misunderstanding. Stop making me spell that out for you. It's not helping your case.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

Sadly, I think Hal may be correct in his assumption that whatever a cop wants to do is law. It does seem to be a reoccurring theme.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

You might want to ease up on the weed. Your paranoia is getting the best of you.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

You still believe in freedom and law and order, though.

He believes in it for cops for sure! Not so sure about us common folk though. LOL

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

The cops broke the law. This is a problem whether you want to admit it or not.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

I second that recommendation. Great read.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Which is exactly why you would be attacking the inefficiency and bureaucracy that lead to the death of innocent citizens.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Regardless of your misguided OPINION Hal, The homeowners were acting within the law and within their rights the police were NOT. These are the facts according to the laws of our country. If you want to argue the laws should change then fine, other than that you don't have a leg to stand on and neither will the cops if it goes to court.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Unfortunately for them, the couple will receive nothing but youtube hits from teabaggers and burn marks from a tazer, while the police will receive a continuous stream of paychecks for doing their job to protect and serve.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

I'm kicking your ass in this debate my mind...

I know all about the cheeba. I'm a huge proponent for legalization, but I don't partake. See? I'm not a shill for big brother, I just know what battles are worth taking on.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

If we have to ease up on the weed, you have to ease up on the beer or religion or whatever your personal choice of emotional morphine happens to be.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

It's both comical and sad that this is considered an ass kicking. This is the result of the dumbing down of America. Even criminals know that pushing police like this never ends well.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

The clip where they refused to step out on the porch to calmly dispel the confusion? That clip? Yes, I saw it.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Hal won't admit he has lost, hell he is still trying to argue that cops have the right to deprive you of your fourth amendment rights! BTW Hal you lost the debate because you either don't understand the law, or think that laws don't apply to police. Is this a result of "dumbing down"?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Which is exactly why I would say the cops did their job to the best of their ability given the restraints by law. Don't put words in my mouth Hal, it is obvious you are the irrational one in this discussion. No one is above the law, including cops.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

I can't see it either, probably is what they saw. lol

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Yes these videos seem to be springing up everywhere.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
I could have swore that it was a picture illustrating the justification for your empty, senseless argument.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
I will admit that I lost the debate when I meet you in the afterlife, after you were murdered by a home intruder who held a gun on you and told you "make that cop on the porch go away by using your 4th amendment rights or I swear I'll blow your head off" - which you did because you're an idiot, and then he killed you anyways as soon as the coast was clear - and you still insist that it was a good move to comply with your murderer. That's okay though - thinning out the gene pool is a natural part of the evolutionary process.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
All you "tyrannical gubamint" robots should try reading '500 Days' so you can learn where the assault on your Constitutional rights actually began.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
Some of us have jobs, family, a life, etc. Must be nice to sit around smoking pot all day though. Who's supporting your "independence"?
 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

I am not sure, but when they asked if there were children in the home and the reply was affirmative, that may have given them probable cause under California law. Might be some child protection law that was triggered by that response. (Why they had to protect the child playing in the yard is unclear.)

So, the Police may have been following the letter of the law when they gained entry forcibly, but violated the spirit of the law. Also, after gaining access, the man should have stated that he believed his Forth Amendment rights were being violated and that he was cooperating under protest. When the person who laid a hand on the officers arm did that, well, that can be considered provocation and resisting arrest and all bets were off at that point. You will note that no one was tazed until after he reached out to restrain the officer.

Yes one must pick ones battles, and one also must be cognizant of whatactionswill produce what results from a police officer. The big question here is were the police within their authority (we grant authority, we have rights) when they forcibly entered the home? As I stated above, they may have been within the letter of the law of the State of California given that they were responding to an incident of possible domestic abuse and children were present. Maybe.

I think that the video shows that there was no domestic violenceoccurringand the threat ofimmediateperil to officers or occupants of the home was not present. There was no clear and present danger. Therefore, I do not feel that the police were within the spirit of the law, even if there is such a law in CA, and that they were most certainly operating within the constitutionalguidelines either written or implied. IMO, this was a home invasion by the police. The people whose home it was acted pretty foolishly once it was clear that they were coming in, but just imagine the amount of adrenaline when three police officers show up at your door, demanding entry.

So, what should they have done? They got one part, at least, right when they told the officers that they were taking video footage of the event. They then should have requested a searchwarrant. When it became clear that the police were going to come in, they should have noted that it was a violation of their rights to do so.

Refusal of entry is not probable cause. Refusal to speak is not probable cause. Refusal to exit your house is not probable cause. If the police ask you to come out, tell them that you do not wish to come out. The police cannot legally compelyou to come out, whether they say they can or not. Make them get a warrant. Every time! (Love that doormat!) Even if you have nothing to hide and are a saint! Police ride over people because thepeoplelet them. We need to hold the police accountable for their actions on a consistent basis, and maybe then we will see a decrease of videos like this one.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
You got personal, and I dished it right back at you. I remember you from NV, and that crazy/scary profile you had there. Don't get me wrong, I've liked the majority of your contributions regardless of how abstract they are (I assume from the weed), but I scratch my head over your apparent drift into the tyrannical gubamint crowd.

Use those benefits when you need them, and I don't doubt that you do - but you're in with a strange crowd considering your source of income. If they had their way, there would be no such "socialistic" tit to feed off of. I plan on working until I simply can't get a job anymore, or die, or become disabled myself. One of my idols is my girlfriend's mother - she's 80 and just got laid off from the factory job she has worked at for decades. We laugh about her collecting unemployment. She will gladly go back if they call her back. It's no big deal for a single lady who still mows her own lawn and just painted her fence, at 80!

Sorry about you dog, btw. That sucks..... and yes, I chat on company time. I hate not being busy, so when when my duties are done I occupy my time here, since NV turned into a shithole. I was a beta tester and I didn't mind the changes. When it went live I couldn't stand it though. Didn't matter - they kicked me out anyways.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
I got the impression that you mistook my delay between comments as time thinking up a response,since you have continually insinuated that I'm getting my ass kicked in this debate. If that's not the case, then I misinterpreted your response to my snarky comment about BadFish's empty picture.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
Not to flatter you, but I remember randomly going to your page several times a year, during slow news days, to see if you removed your profile story, and thinking "this guy has balls to keep this here." As I recall, it involved a very unpopular word that starts with "r". I didn't disparage you for it, rather I saw it as an honest admission that the average joe buries in their psyche. I think we both are deeper than the average thinker. If we were neighbors, we would probably have regular fence chat over microbrews ... and you would more than likely have me participating in puff puff pass on a semi regular basis. :)I don't argue your point about Boston - I found the whole media portrayal thing disturbing as hell. I just refuse to admit that we Americans are now in tune with the whole CNN style of focused 'news' saturation. The more I am bombarded with it, the less significance it retains. It got to the point of pure, unadulterated fear mongering IMHO.As far as wealth distribution goes, the numbers don't lie. The middle class is under attack by corporate interests - as is the environment. Fuck Mitt Romney and the fuck the Republican Party for that matter. If there were a viable third party, I would support it. Because there wasn't, I went with the the obvious lesser of two evils.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

There is something not quite right about this story/video -- something in the voice of the homeowner. If it's legitimate and can be taken on its face value, then there's obviously a number of issues that appear to favor the homeowner. Still

I'd like to know who called the police and for what reason.

I'd like to know why the police ignored the question regarding a warrant.

I'd like to know more about the tasing

The video camera just happened to be ready to roll suspicious

Based solely on the video, the homeowner appears to have an airtight case of Fourth Amendment violations-plus

The Fourth Amendment ( Amendment IV ) to the United States Constitution is the part of the Bill of Rights which guards against unreasonable searches and seizures , along with requiring any warrant to be judicially sanctioned and supported by probable cause . It was adopted as a response to the abuse of the writ of assistance , which is a type of general search warrant , in the American Revolution . Search and seizure (including arrest) should be limited in scope according to specific information supplied to the issuing court , usually by a law enforcement officer , who has sworn by it . The Fourth Amendment applies to the states by way of the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment .

but I've represented a lot of people (prior to retirement) and learned early on that "slam dunks" are rare; I do admit readily that I am a cynic.

Let's see where this goes.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
Lol - you are entitled to the right to completely misunderstand the common sense that successfully guides matters in grey area. You can't create law that satisfies all the people all the time in all situations - therefore there will be instances where on the spot interpretation is required to meet the spirit of "protect and serve". These assholes were going out of their way to be difficult. Imagine if everyone in their (supposed) situation were to tell the cops to go away. There would no doubt be instances of domestic violence that get needlessly escalated just to protect some douchebag's right to be a difficult asswipe. Personally, I want the police to not let criminals control the situation. Someone called in a domestic disturbance, and it could have been resolved easily if not for some asshole's desire to irresponsibly test the grey area between the fourth amendment and public safety. People just love to point critical fingers at perceived tyranny, until it is their safety that is at risk.
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Sorry folks but that video doesn't really do it for me. There is too little information and too much video to make a call on this one.

On the surface it seems like the cops just knocked his door down, came in and tased the woman because they wouldn't come out, but it doesn't make much sense with the cop standing right in front of the window looking in without any fear for his life and then pursuing the action we see in this video.

I don't think I would have walked up to that window putting my life in jeopardy if I felt there really was a problem inside that needed my assistance as a police officer. If a policeman had knocked on my door under the same situation, I would open the door to see what he wanted as soon as I was confident he was a policeman.

I see no reason for not doing so in this situation. Something smells about this whole thing to me. Now I'm as big of a supporter of the 4th amendment as anyone you know, believe me, but we don't hire police officers to harm the innocent and there seems to be no reason to be so contrary as the homeowner appears to be to me.

I mean the police officer isn't there for no reason. He was given the order to check out a disturbance, evidently, and is doing so. His apparent stupidity for standing in front of the window is remarkable though.

If there had really been a crazed nut inside the policeman wouldn't be facing a law suit today, but could have very well been pushing up daisies.

Maybe he was hired by the judge who wouldn't hire that fellow who scored too high on the police test. I would say he probably needs to look into another profession because I don't think he is going to live very long in California in his current profession because there are some bad people who wouldn't video him looking into the window, but would blow him a way.

I see the homeowner promoting a scenario there must be something insidious going on inside or else he would have simply opened his door and talked with the police. I see the police assuming something bad was happening inside the house that needed their attention right away. Still can't get over the window watching though.

I don't believe the police should, with the little information I have, pursued the action they did, simply because of the 4th amendment. Something is missing here.

And we don't know what it is. We don't know who called, what was reported, if this was the first or one of many calls to this residence, the homeowners criminal record if any and many missing pieces of information. Actually there could have been someone holding a gun on these people and that was the reason they were reacting to the police the way they were. There is plenty enough of stupidity on both sides in this video.

I know some will say all that matters is the 4th Amendment and I can understand someone feeling that way, but we need more information to make an intelligent evaluation of this situation.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

It almost appears to have been scripted, staged -- like some of the discredited O'Keefe/Breitbart set ups.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Why would if make a difference if the homeowners called the police themselves as partof an investigative sting type of operation?

Two reasons; an intentional "false alarm" and entrapment possibly with the motive of generating a bogus propaganda video and/or bogus lawsuit.

And possibly "risking a catastrophe," "reckless endangerment."

I'm going with a "setup."

Regardless, I'll wager there's more to this -- but we'll see.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Think about it; a bunch of cops show up at your door

A typical reaction is "Why are you here; what's going on; we didn't call the police; what's this about, officer? Is there a problem?

BUT NO! This guy's ready with a video camera and a shit load of editorial commentary a la the NRA and 2nd Amendment lunatics who are convinced that Obama's coming for their guns so to prevent a police state they need to act militia-like.

I'm not questioning this family's rights -- I'm questioning a video that seems more like a staged piece of propaganda than a spontaneous chronicling of an event.

For openers, let's find out who called the police and why - who is this guy in the video (not his ID, rather if he has a history/agenda).

If he's clean and the video is exactly as it appears to be, then the police in the video need to be charged and prosecuted.

Is there more to this video that we haven't seen? Why didn't the police confiscate the video camera and destroy the "evidence"? I assume they knew they were being video recorded and looking like "a police state."

It doesn't smell right.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

Well, first off, to me it looked like the discussion had been going on prior to the point where the video started.

As to why the police did not confiscate the video, they might have confiscated the recording equipment, or not, there are several cameras that stream directly to the web. Also, there is the issue of children being present, which might have, in their opinion, given them the probable cause that was needed to affect direct entry.

Don't know, can't say.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Too many people here are willing subjects to the modern police state.

You don't just acquiesce every time a cop stands in front of you, otherwise, none of our Rights mean jack-shit.

You may or may not be correct about that and I'm not advocating acquiescence; rather I am addressing ONE VIDEO AND ONE INCIDENT -- the one regarding this particular discussion.

Every 911 call isn't probable cause.

But every 911 call that appears to be legitimate to the 911 operator has the potential to be exigent which is why there is not time to obtain a warrant.

And "exigent circumstances" allow police to proceed without a warrant.

I'm not saying the police in this video aren't culpable; I am saying that there are questions that need to be answered.

If the home owner is standing there, and saying "i didn't call you, I don't want you, and nobody here needs you", they can't just kick in the fucking door.

If that represents the entire scenario, I'm with you. We'll see maybe.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

The Camera starts with several officers already in the yard and it appears there was a conversation that lead to the homeowner to start taping, basically in the beginning he is saying I am taping this and asks "are you going to kick my door down without a warrant" or very similar, he is also saying "there is no domestic violence going on here" Which leads us to believe the call was for a domestic disturbance. There are definitely some questions I would like to know the answer to, it will be interesting to see how this shakes out, I think the cops have a lot of explaining to do.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

I've done some incredibly stupid things in my youth as well. Like you, I straightened out; but unlike you, I long for someone to invent a machine that can erase memories. Fortunately, my own errors have notimpacted me to the extent that they require an explanation in order to earn a living, but some of themsureplayed a part indestroying my credit report. :[ I look at it this way - I have learned some lessons via actual experience that most people can only "learn" from a book, or a tv show, or vicariously through someone else. You know the feeling, I'm sure.

You're good people too. Wrong, but good. ;)

There are plenty of justified instances to be outraged at police actions. Recently, I read about a man who was beaten to death by a group of officers while people recorded it in horror on their cell phones. Their phones were confiscated and never given back. I used to live in Virginia, where there is an actual law that if you can be seen through your house window drinking a beer in it's labeled container, you can bearrested forpublic intoxication. I've never heard of a case where it was used, butI believeit's purpose isto provide aloophole to enter a home and arrest a drunk who is being belligerent towards the police. I did hear of a case in VA where a man was arrested because he made the mistake of walking to his coffee maker in his kitchen butt naked for a cup of coffee at 6am. A child was walking to a bus stop and saw him through his window. These are cases where one can be outraged at police activity and terrible laws. A couple who refuses to walk out on their front porch and assure officers that the possibledomestic violence call they are responding to is a false alarm, and instead video records them breaking down the door in response to their suspicious baiting - that is a pair of douchebags who deserve no sympathy whatsoever. If you are a parent, and you teach your kids to act in this manner when a simple solution is available, you are not doing your kids any favors. That's how I see it, and I know I'm not alone.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

I was only referring to this video.....I don't have to use any politics to make my point. there's just not enough information presented to make an intelligent evaluation. I think if you re-read my comment above you should get that out of it.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

The fact remains, these people had no reason to do what they did other than to attempt to obtain controversial footage of police activity towards a suspicious situation of their own making.There is no reason to suppose that the police, in broad daylight, responding to a potential domestic violence situation, would have done anything other than ask a couple questions, verify that nobody is being hurt or threatened, apologized for the inconvenience, and said "have a nice day." They were baiting the police, acting like bad citizens, and keeping them from doing their jobs.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

It's not entrapment. The home owners obviously did not intice the officer to break the law. They merely offered them the opportunity to abuse their authority on camera.

We don't know that -- we have no way of knowing what occurred prior to the taping or even if we've seen the entire tape. I use "entrapment" generically here in that it, by definition, it is law enforcement that creates a set up entrapping an individual.

By definition entrapment

trick or deceive (someone), esp. by inducing them to commit a crime in order to secure their prosecution.

But if this scenario was contrived by the homeowner, that's a form of entrapment.

Police rushing in response to a 911 call creates the possibility of both "risking a catastrophe," and "reckless endangerment." The party making the 911 call, if it's fraudulent can be held responsible. It could be a totally separate incident on the way to answering the call.

In US law , endangerment comprises several types of crimes involving conduct that is wrongful and reckless or wanton , and likely to produce death or grievous bodily harm to another person.

The offense is intended to prohibit and therefore deter reckless or wanton conduct that wrongfully creates a substantial risk of death or serious injury to others.

18 Pa.C.S.A. 3302. Causing or risking catastrophe : (a) Causing catastrophe.--A person who causes a catastrophe by explosion, fire, flood, avalanche, collapse of building, release of poison gas, radioactive material or other harmful or destructive force or substance, or by any other means of causing potentially widespread injury or damage, including selling, dealing in or otherwise providing licenses or permits to transport hazardous materials in violation of 75 Pa.C.S. Ch. 83 (relating to hazardous materials transportation), commits a felony of the first degree if he does so intentionally or knowingly, or a felony of the second degree if he does so recklessly.(b) Risking catastrophe.--A person is guilty of a felony of the third degree if he recklessly creates a risk of catastrophe in the employment of fire, explosives or other dangerous means listed in subsection (a) of this section.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Had this been an actual instance where this suspicious behavior was being driven by a criminal in the shadows (but somehow surreptitiously recorded), and the police had lived up to your expectations and left the scene without true confirmation of their safety - and as a result the couple were robbed, raped, murdered, etc. - this article would be being posted here by the same person, using the same footage - except it would be all about how the police miserably failed to serve and protect. The comments would be something along the line of "I can't believe how stupid those cops were for not confirming their safety", and "the cops signed that couple'sdeath warrant", and "no sane person would tell the cops to leave - if those cops couldn't tell that this was a sign that they were in trouble then they need to be relieved of their duty". Police have a job to do, but some people just hate them so much that no matter how they do it, they will be chastised. That is what is happening here.

These are not good citizens. In fact, if some other crime were reported to have occurred while the police were being detained on this ridiculous "sting", the same poster here would have a seed filled with even more scathing remarks about the police, when the reality is that it would be these homeowners who were responsible for needlessly occupying the policemen's time.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Politics aside, my faith in law enforcement and the justice system has been shaken numerous times (first hand), so to a certain extent, I'm predisposed to accepting documentation such as in this incident without much fuss.

All I can say is when you've witnessed such things in person, it does change your perspective.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

I agree - I have witnessed first hand the police coming to my door, or the door of a friend's, in response to a possible domestic situation. If you answer it, and let them in, they can be of assistance in diffusing a situation before someone gets hurt. That doesn't necessarily mean that someone is going to jail. If someone is going to jail, then it is because they have assaulted someone else, or they have warrants. If it is a false alarm, there is absolutely no reason for not making that clear with a face to face confirmation. Doing what these people did is just stupid in my opinion.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

My agreement was with her last statement, and it wasmeant facetiously. I have had enough personal interaction with law enforcement to have perspective. I can only imagine the myriad ofshitty outcomes I avoided by not doing what the idiots in this video did. Answer the door, go outside and speak with them, and save yourself a miserable experience. If you take that approach, and it doesn't end peacefully, then you may have a case. If you want to be an asshole and bait the cops, good luck with that. Perhaps you will get your charges dropped, but you will suffer through a shit ton of misery, expenseand embarrassment in the process, all of which you brought on yourself with ignorant behavior.

I'm done talking about this. Those of you who think I'm wrong, go ahead and play your idiotic games with your local law enforcement and see where it gets you.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

If the circumstances were such that the police saved these two from a gunman holding a shotgun on them, would they have been breaking the law? Would you be chastising them or praising them then? It's a grey area that could EASILY have been negotiated by modicum of intelligent behavior. Instead, it was bungled by ignorant glory seekers.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Well, I hope you enjoyed those 14 years in prison. Sounds like they could have been avoided with a hair of humility and an ounce of patience, but God forbid that you be expected to bow down to the man. Prison is totally worth not having to do that, right? I suspect a good tazing or even a bullet would be worth it too.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

There's nothing like personal experience to predispose one to be on automatic when he/she reads or sees a video like this one. I understand completely.

I've been trying to get out of that mode, but I find it pretty difficult since I've witnessed even things that I wouldn't believe if someone else told me unless I hadn't already experienced it myself or witnessed someone else experiencing it. But this whole thing is something else to put it lightly. Even witnessing this video is unbelievable to me that both the police and the homeowner can act so stupid.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Your example isn't even remotely related to this article. Go seed an article using your examples of police injustice and I will gladly side with you. The clip in this article involves a couple who are going out of their way to bait law enforcement into violating their fourth amendment rights on camera. Here's some more of my opinion for you - they got what they deserved. On top of that, we know nothing other that what we see in the clip. There could be plenty more that we don't know. Maybe these people had outstanding bench warrants, maybe there was a meth lab in the house, maybe they had three teenage girlschained up in a bedroom - who knows. Regardless, what they did was wrong, and if the only reason they did it was to avoid being taken in on a bench warrant or to evade detection of other illegal activity, thenwhat they did is even lessjustified. If they want sympathy from me, then capture footage of being mistreated AFTER being cooperative.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago
So this reckless endangerment doohickey. Would that be like cops breaking into a home without a warrant and tazing a woman who may have had some serious health condition?

It could be, but I'm referring to a situation that starts with a bogus 911 call that puts law enforcement into motion; should some incident result, be it one that was unforeseen and/or one that comes about in direct conjunction with the "reason" for the 911 call, there are numerous scenarios under which police, innocent bystanders, etc. could become endangered or actually victimized in some way -- and all because of a bogus alarm.

Seems like to me your arguments all work both ways, and the pivot point is what laws were broken and by whom.

And yes, I can see it happening both ways.

We have only the video.

And it's clear unless you theorize a bunch of conspiracy stuff.

No, it's not clear what if you walked into a movie theater in the middle of a film that you knew nothing about and saw police beating the hell out of a character that looked like a regular Joe?

If you turned and left the theater, you might conclude that the movie was about "police brutality" -- but what if you walked in at the start of the film, or, stayed beyond the beating scene -- how many different stories could you imagine?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

So, a sting is an acceptable tactic. Just not one used against police very often. Though it's happened before.

No, it's illegal if a citizen contrives it to entrap.

In law enforcement, a sting operation is a deceptive operation designed to catch a person committing a crime. A typical sting will have a law-enforcement officer or cooperative member of the public play a role as criminal partner or potential victim and go along with a suspect's actions to gather evidence of the suspect's wrongdoing.

But and especially if the "sting" begins with a bogus 911 call

  • Citizens would have no legal sanction; Sting operations are generally reviewed by the city or district attorneys office to ensure that they follow all the proper legal procedures required for such an operation.

L.A. NOW

Southern California -- this just in

Previous Post | L.A. NOW Home | Next Post

Charges filed in 911 call that led to slaying by Pasadena police

March 22, 2013| 9:00 am
The 911 caller who falsely claimed that he was robbed at gunpoint the night Pasadena police shot and killed unarmed 19-year-old robbery suspect Kendrec McDade is due in court Tuesday to face misdemeanor charges that he lied to emergency dispatchers.

Oscar Carrillo, 27, is charged with one count of making a false report of a criminal offense and a second count of reporting an emergency knowing the report was false, a Pasadena city spokesman said.

If convicted on both counts, Carrillo faces a maximum sentence of 18 months in jail, his defense attorney, Andres Bustamante, told the Pasadena Sun .

Carrillo, who has already pleaded not guilty to the charges, is scheduled to return to court on March 26 for a pretrial hearing.

The city prosecutors office filed the charges after the Los Angeles County district attorneys office declined a request by Pasadena police to charge him with manslaughter.

Bustamante accused the city of prosecuting Carrillo as a way to redirect responsibility for McDades death.

I think theyre deflecting, Bustamante said. It seems to me the city feels obligated that [Carrillo] must take some kind or responsibility. Their position has always been that he set in motion certain events that lead to the tragic shooting of this African American teenager.

An internal review of the shooting incident , announced Wednesday, determined that the two Pasadena police officers who shot McDade during the robbery investigation one year ago acted within departmental policy.

And in December, an investigation by the Los Angeles County district attorneys Justice System Integrity Division concluded that the officers had a reasonable fear of imminent death or serious bodily injury and acted in lawful self-defense and defense of others in shooting McDade.

Investigations by the Los Angeles County Office of Independent Review and the FBI remain ongoing, according to police.

...

And

WAUKESHA CO. 33-year-old Aisha Jackson is accused of making fake 911 calls in order to avoid getting a ticket for her driving. She now faces seven criminal charges of falseemergency (911) phone use.

...

And

Pasadena Man Lies to Police, Gets Manslaughter Charge After Police Shoot Suspect

...

Get the idea?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

when there is video evidence, you gon't get to bring a bunch of speculative cases to bear.

The video is not necessarily "evidence" - if the 911 call is determined to be a set up, the video ironically might be used in evidence against the guy who made it.

Remember the O'Keefe/ACORN video?

Sometimes the hunter gets captured by the game.

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

Perhaps I am just old as dirt and have had a longer time to witness the transformation of LE in this country, but I'd have to argue that, if not already there, we are a rats patooty from becoming a Poleece State. The militarization of LE has pretty much made Posse Comitatus a moot point in my humble opinion. We have traded a civilian entity for a paramilitary operation complete with military training and tons of mil surp rigs, weaponry and such. With the pounding the Bill of Rights has taken from the Patriot Act and the so called "war on drugs", it looks pretty organized from my perch on the socio economic ladder.

Maybe the myopia lessons the lower on the ladder one happens to sit, and just who the "serve and protect" applies to is an indication of where we are headed. Seemingly LE is, and historically speaking it's always pretty much been the case, designed to protect the assets of the haves from the have nots.

We may not currently be in the "V for Vendetta" territory but we are getting closer every day.

best your way

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

But you aren't really addressing one video and one event; you are registering a suspicision based apparently on the fact that some people know their rights and keep a video camera handy.

Disagree; the burden of proof is on the one making the allegation; if the video is what it appears to be, that's one thing, if it was contrived and put into motion by a fake 911 call, that's entirely different.

Every event must be considered on its own particulars.

But if the sheriff shows up you can bet your ass I'll have the camera on.

But if you called 911 to bring the sheriff and there was no emergency, and, it can be determined that your intention was to create an incident, then the video might be used against you.

I could also hold forth on the many instances of police brutality I've seen on Youtube and question him/her about those while I tried to decide if I wanted to go out on the porch where they could then legally pat me down for a weapon.

Did you see everyone in Boston just let cops into their homes with no warrant?

It matters not how many other instances you can cite; each situation is investigated and adjudicated based on attendant circumstances. And the police in Watertown were able to clear the homes because of exigent circumstances -- a criminal was last seen in the area and a police officer had been murdered.

Did you see the police being applauded by the citizens of Watertown after the apprehended the suspect without a warrant.

Exceptions to the warrant requirement

Exigent circumstance

There are also "exigent circumstances" exceptions to the warrant requirement. Exigent circumstances arise when the law enforcement officers have reasonable grounds to believe that there is an immediate need to protect their lives, the lives of others, their property, or that of others, the search is not motivated by an intent to arrest and seize evidence, and there is some reasonable basis, to associate an emergency with the area or place to be searched.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

can not really say much as to the video , unless thats the only evidence being presented . nothing has been said as to what happened up to the point that it started to be taken, what discussion if any took place before it started? Was any verbal statement made before the camera started rolling to make the cops think something wasnt what it should be? i sat on a jury several yrs ago where the deputies were called to a domestic , the man used the 4th as a defense or tried to, but the thing that turned that case against him was his utterance of a threat to the responding officers , so he was found guilty simply on that fact , having a constitutionally codefied and protected right does not leave one free to utter threats to law enforcement .

Now did the people have an obligation to talk to the police over a DV call? actually no they dont they can exersize the right to remain silent at any time , and cops do not have to state anything they say can be used against them in a court of law either ( miranda) unless they intend to place someone under arrest/apprehension. Nor was the people out of line ( if no threats or other agressive actions taken ) in refusing entry without a warrent( Mac , you pointed out about vehicle searches w/o a warrent i think the difference here is a domicile , vs a vehicle used on public byways , 2 totally seperate things )

As for a set up or civilian sting operation? highly doubtful really , but not unthinkable , and with todays technology and the advice to always get confrontatuions on video if possable , i can see somene having a camera handy , hell i have 3 grand kids that visit all the time , and i have a digital camera ( both on my phone and a seperate one ) handy and ready to go( all i have to o is flip the screens and they are recording )for some of the things they do ( that 2 yr old is gonna make AFHV one of these days ).

I dont think the whole story is being told just yet , there is a gap in information as to what happened from arrival on scene , to when the camera was started , so there is not enough information to determine what happened and whom would be deemed in the wrong or at fault . one thing i can and will say is the tazing was out of line for the simple reson that the individuals once the LEO got inside , made no efforts to resist and were being compliant and non threats , that appears to be an instance you didnt do as we demanded so now we are gonna shock your ass and cause some real pain extra judicial punishment , vindictiveness on the parts of the cops . time will tell if it ever gets anymore air time or reporting , i doubt it will but this seems to be happening more and more IMHO lately.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Mac , you pointed out about vehicle searches w/o a warrent i think the difference here is a domicile , vs a vehicle used on public byways , 2 totally seperate things )

Exigent circumstances apply broadly;

There are six major exceptions to the warrant requirement.

1. Search Incident to Lawful Arrest

A search incident to lawful arrest does not require issuance of a warrant. In other words, if someone is lawfully arrested, the police may search her person and any area surrounding the person that is within reach (within his or her wingspan). See Chimel v. California, 395 U.S. 752 (1969). The rationale is that the search is permissible as a protective measure.

EXAMPLE: John is arrested for driving while intoxicated after being pulled over for running a red light. A search of his car reveals 8 bags of heroin in the glove compartment and an illegal handgun in the trunk. The heroin is admissible evidence for which no warrant was required as the glove compartment is certainly within Johns wingspan. The gun found in the trunk, however, was not within his wingspan, and was the result of an unreasonable search. This evidence will be excluded.

2. Plain View Exception

No warrant is required to seize evidence in plain view if the police are legitimately in the location from which the evidence can be viewed. For example, an officer cannot illegally enter a suspects back yard and then use the plain view exception to seize an illegally kept alligator living in the pool. But, if on the premises to serve a warrant duly issued to search for marijuana plants, the alligator, if in plain view, can rightly (though by no means easily) be seized.

EXAMPLE: The police are called to Donalds house by neighbors who see him beating up his wife, Victoria. After properly entering the house (without a search warrant see emergency exception below), police notice Donalds prized gun collection hanging on the wall. Fortunately for the officers, the guns are not loaded. Unfortunately for Donald, many of them are illegal and Donald is arrested for battery as well as for the illegal guns, which are seized.

3. Consent

If consent is given by a person reasonably believed by an officer to have authority to give such consent, no warrant is required for a search or seizure. So, if a suspects "significant other" provides police with a key to the suspects apartment, and police reasonably believe that she lives there, the search will not violate suspects Fourth Amendment rights even if she did not live there and even if she, in fact, lacked authority to consent, . See Illinois v. Rodriguez, 497 U.S. 177 (1990).

EXAMPLE: Officer Warren knocks on a murder suspects door. the door is answered by the suspects 6 year old child, Timmy. The officer asks Timmy Is it okay if I come in and talk to your Dad? Hes expecting me. And then walks into the apartment. He then sees the suspect, Roland, sitting on the sofa oiling his illegal Tommy-gun, the suspected murder weapon. He arrests Roland for possession of the gun and seizes the evidence. Because Timmy, being a small child, was not legally able or authorized to give consent, the entry was illegal and the evidence will be excluded.

4. Stop & Frisk

Police may stop a suspect so long as there is a reasonable suspicion of a criminal act. The evidence necessary for reasonable suspicion here is something beyond mere suspicion, but is less than the level required for probable cause . If there is reason to believe that the person may be armed and dangerous, the police can also frisk the suspect. See Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968).

EXAMPLE: Officer P. Harkers peers often joke that he has something akin to a spidey-sense which tells him when folks are up to no good. While enjoying a cup of coffee at his favorite donut shop, Officer Harkers neck hairs stand up straight. He immediately goes outside where he sees Ivan walking down the street, carrying a small duffel bag. He orders Ivan to stop and drop the bag. When the bag falls, Officer Harker hears the clanging of metal against metal. He then frisks Ivan and discovers a hidden pistol in Ivan's pocket. He then searches the duffel bag and discovers ammunition and several illegal hunting knives. Despite the fact that Officer Harkers spidey-sense proved accurate once again, the evidence will be excluded as he can not articulate any reason why he stopped Ivan, other than his unusually active neck hairs.

5. Automobile Exception

Because vehicles are obviously highly mobile, a warrant is not required to search vehicles if police have probable cause to believe the vehicle contains evidence of a crime, the instrumentalities of crime, contraband, or the fruits of a crime. Although commonly referred to as the automobile exception, this rule applies to any vehicle, including boats. While in some ways, it is quite a broad exception, this rule limits the ability to search those areas which might contain evidence of the type suspected to be present. In other words, if police suspect that the occupant of a boat is smuggling people across the border, searching a small tackle box on board would not be permissible. However, if they were looking for drugs, they could search the tackle box. The rationale is that, if an officer has to take the time to obtain a warrant, the vehicle might be out of reach before the warrant can be issued and executed. See Carroll v. United States, 267 US. 132 (1925).

EXAMPLE: Officer Demidum has reason to believe that an abandoned car on the corner contains illegal drugs in the trunk. The car is missing all four wheels and is up on cinder blocks, and the engine was stolen long ago. Assuming that the automobile exception applies, Officer Demidum uses a crowbar to force open the still-working lock on the trunk. There, he finds 10 kilos of cocaine. Rushing back to the station house to show off the evidence to his Captain, Officer Demidum runs into Judge Sosad. Judge Sosad says You should have called me first. While its great to get the drugs off the street, unfortunately we cant use this as evidence against anyone. The search was illegal, as the automobile exception to the warrant requirement only applies when the vehicle is actually capable of being moved. Thats the whole point of the exception! A dejected Demidum continues on to the station, where he has to tolerate cars drawn in shaving cream on his locker for the next month.

6. Emergencies/Hot Pursuit

The rationale here is similar to the automobile exception. Evidence that can be easily moved, destroyed or otherwise made to disappear before a warrant can be issued may be seized without a warrant. Furthermore, if a suspect enters private property while being pursued by officers, no warrant is required to enter that property in order to continue pursuit, even if the suspect is in no way connected with the property owner.

EXAMPLE: While running from police, Fred enters Joes garage and the police follow Fred in. (They are not required to give up pursuit until such time as they can obtain a search warrant for the premises.) While in Joe's garage, police notice illegal drugs in plain view. They can arrest Fred for his crimes, and they can also seize the drugs and arrest Joe for possession of the drugs, even though Joe had nothing to do with Fred and the police were in Joes garage only because of the hot pursuit of Fred!

Unless the fact-pattern fits one of the six exceptions discussed above, a warrant is required for police to conduct a search or seizure. Note that for Exception 1, search incident to a lawful arrest, and Exception 5, the automobile exception, although no warrant is required, there is a probable cause requirement. For a search incident to a lawful arrest, the officer must have had probable cause for the original arrest. If the original arrest was unreasonable or unlawful, the evidence discovered from the search will be excluded as fruit of the poisonous tree (see the subchapter on the Exclusionary Rule). For the Automobile Exception, the officer must have probable cause to believe that the vehicle contains evidence of a crime, instrumentalities of a crime, contraband, or fruits of a crime, whether the vehicle is moving or already stopped. Exception 4 ("stop and frisk") does not require probable cause, but does require "reasonable suspicion." Only Exception 3 (consent) requires no grounds on the part of the police for making the search.

ExToWarrantReq1.gif

2003 - 2007 National Paralegal College

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

And cops violate the 4th amendment every day, even with all the loopholes. Remember, a violation of the 4th amendment results in ONLY the evidence obtained being deemed inadmissible. There may, however, be 1983 actions, but they are becoming more and more rare due to numerous higher court decisions protecting the government.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    13 years ago

thumbs_up.png

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

That's a big ass thumb.

10392_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

nice sumation of the exemptions Mc , but to your mind which of the exemptions would apply? about the only one i can even remotely see applying is the search after lawful arrrest , and as far as i know , not aquiesing to leo desires is not exactly grounds for arrest unless some other infraction has been committed , simply refusing to talk ( 5th amendment protection to remain silent and say nothing at all , is not a lawful grounds for arrest) so basically your saying the police can arrest anyone for anything such as saying they have nothing to say, and then conduct a search after the arrestwithout any warrent needed . since there was nothing in plain sight ( that we are made aware of )that is illegal or a danger, that consent is definitely NOT being given, no autos are involved, that leaves the arrest exemption or the emergency exemption , though there appears to be no emergency or hot pursuit evident that would lead to grounds for arrest in the first place . me ild go with the search after lawful arrest , even if the arrest appears to be unlawful and extremely flimsey . but hey those cops did teach them a lesson about respecting their perceived authority now didnt they?

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    13 years ago

Not that I advocate going by anything you see online but here's an interesting little bit from a defense attorney in regard to warrentless searches and such.

I think we have to assume that LE does not know the law. We have such a glut of law on the books it isn't really all that surprising but there you have it. A few years ago LE arrested a fellow up in Virginia for open carry, in an open carry state. So it goes.

Resist politely and you might not get a beating. Anyhow,

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

nice sumation of the exemptions Mc , but to your mind which of the exemptions would apply?

I won't venture to say because if the video is conclusive -- and I can't see how it could be minus the information regarding what/who/how the police were brought to the scene -- based solely on what the video shows, no exigent circumstances can be determined.

If I assume that a 911 call came i.e. from a neighbor, let's say because of loud voices that may have been perceived as a potentially explosive domestic dispute, then the police might claim "exigent circumstances."

But then, upon arriving at the home without a warrant (as with virtually all responses to 911 calls), the police saw no overt signs of anything out-of-the-ordinary, the obvious question would be, "why the apparent police-thug behavior?"

And that's where none of us can say definitively -- are we seeing the entire episode from the time the police arrived until they left -- has the video been truncated, edited -- was it a set up - a citizen-sting (which I would contend would be illegal)? Is there a police-cam video?

I believe there's much we don't know and I wonder if we'll ever have the whole story.

Good dialogue, Mark!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

In effect it allows the cops to do almost anything they want subject to a judges later determination of right and wrong....

But the police would need to satisfy a burden-of-proof regarding the so-called exigent circumstances. In recent years, video-cams on police vehicles have, in some instances, actually shown police to be lying about "exigent" circumstances.

That's not to say that police don't get the court's benefit of the doubt when all there is in the way of evidence is "hearsay."

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Now you're just boring me. These turds could have avoided all this, but they decided to be like that asshole brother that sticks his finger in your face in the back seat of the car, saying "I'm not touching you I'm not touching you". They deserved to get abused just like that brother deserved the good punch in the face he got. Now they're crying just like that brother cried to mommy, and like anydecent mother, any decent person watching this video will just smirk and say "serves you right for being a little annoying asshole."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Gotcha a nice skyscraper started.

I'm just answering the questions as they come in the thread. The only assumption I've made about this video is that, if this is all the information we're getting regarding the incident we can't make any assumption other than "we need more information."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Point of fact, a person would have to be a moron to call 911 trying to sting the police.

There is no shortage on morons!

 
 

Who is online


Snuffy


123 visitors