US supports tribe in lawsuit to stop taxes on reservation
SEATTLE (AP) The U.S. Justice Department filed a motion on Tuesday asking to join the Tulalip Indian Tribes in a federal lawsuit against the State of Washington and Snohomish County that seeks to stop them from collecting millions of dollars in taxes from non-Indian businesses and people on tribal land so that the tribe can collect those funds instead.
The Justice Department said the tribes have a constitutional right to develop reservation resources without unlawful interference from state and local taxation.
The United States takes seriously the federal role in protecting tribal self-government, which has its foundation in federal statutes, treaties, and regulations, said Assistant Attorney General John Cruden, with the departments Environment and Natural Resources Division. To this end, we are committed to eliminating barriers, such as these, which hinder tribes from developing healthy economies and providing necessary governmental services on the reservation.
Alison Dempsey-Hall, spokeswoman for the Washington State Attorney Generals Office, said they cant comment on open cases.
Jason Cummings, Chief Civil Deputy with the Snohomish County Prosecuting Attorneys Office, said the tribe and county have a valued and respected relationship, and said they are reviewing the latest filings in the lawsuit and will discuss its allegations with our elected officials, and will respond accordingly.
The Tulalip Tribe filed a lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Seattle in June against Gov. Jay Inslee, the state and Snohomish County, arguing that they dont have a legal right to the $40 million collected annually in property, sales, use and other taxes for activities on reservation land that was developed and is managed by the tribe.
In 1990, the tribe devised a plan to develop about 2,200 acres of vacate lands next to Interstate 5 near Marysville, Washington about 35 miles north of Seattle. The land had been held in trust by the United States. By 2000, the tribe had chartered the Consolidated Borough of Quil Ceda Village and began the development process, the lawsuit said.
The land was vacant and lacked any infrastructure to support a village, so the board of directors launched a plan to design, build and install roads, sidewalks, parking areas, sewer, water and natural gas lines. They also built an electrical substation, utility and telecommunication lines and other needs.
The tribe spent tens of millions of dollars to develop the village, the lawsuit said.
Soon after, the Tulalip secured leases with Wal-Mart and Home Depot. It also constructed a retail center containing 16 storefronts which now host commercial tenants including a pharmacy, United Postal Service store, and restaurants, the lawsuit said. By 2012, the tribe had a casino, Cabelas store, and the Seattle Premium Outlets with about 140 subleases.
The tribe provides the day-to-day government services including police and fire protection, snow and garbage removal and a civil court.
About 6,000 people are employed within the Village, the lawsuit said.
Neither the state nor the county has participated in this development and neither has provided any services, the lawsuit said.
Yet, in 2013 alone, the state collected $37 million in sales and use taxes; $2.1 million in business and occupation taxes; and about $1 million in property taxes from the Village, the lawsuit said. A portion of the $40.1 million in taxes collected was shared with Snohomish County, the lawsuit said.
But none of those tax revenues were given to the Tulalip Tribe or the Village, the lawsuit said.
The state and county taxes interferes with Tulalips ability to exercise its sovereign taxation authority and deprives Tulalip and the Village of the opportunity to raise tax revenues to support infrastructure and essential government services and to ensure the health, safety and welfare of its members and those visiting the Village, the lawsuit said.
The lawsuit asks the court to issue an order saying the state and county taxes are a violation of the Indian Commerce Clause. It also asks the court permanently stop the state and county from collecting the funds.
The Justice Departments motion said the tribe has the inherent and federally recognized sovereign right to make its own laws and be ruled by them. Outside collection of taxes interferes with and frustrates Tulalips inherent right of self-governance and its ability to further economic self-sufficiency.

I've actually seen the center. Drove by it when it was under construction. A really nice center and investment for the tribe.
Going from memory here, but didn't congress say that when Indians were allowed to build casinos that they were not to be used as a revenue stream for the states. If my memory is correct, that went by the wayside, since Indian casinos pay the state taxes in different forms, one being the compacs that they have with the state that they are located in, and the tens of millions that they pay to the various states now.
This case will be interesting to follow. That's one hell of a lot of money. If the tribe wins, I wonder if the state of Washington will have to repay the money already collected.
A nice counter suit would be for the tribes to sue the state for all the upgrades that the tribe put in the center, and to charge the state for the on going up keepthat they pay for.
I believe you'll see that happen Kavika. Under Fed law, if the tribes earn the money from tribal enterprises, the tribes keep the money.
Regarding the casino - under the IGA, states are "required" to conduct conservations with the tribes who request gaming operations within the state- with the support and assistance of the BIA. If the two come to a mutual agreement, the state can then levy a "surcharge" on the tribe for gaming operations not to exceed 25% (which Cali takes full claim for) of the profit, not the net. The tribe/nation then has to pay Fed taxes (corporate) but they are not required to pay any county/local taxes as the property is on the reservation.
The tribes/nations, for the most part, "assist" the counties/cities through employment and funding varying administrative expenses that are of benefit to both - the county/city/tribe/nation such as funding for infrastructure of the schools, hospitals, roads, LE, etc..
Even though Slade Groton is out of public office, his legacy lingers on - and this is one of them.
Indeed, CA has done their best to get as much money as possible from the tribes. If I remember correctly ''The Terminator'' lost some court cases involving casino taxes.
Yes sir - in addition to the compact "tithe", Arnie baby wanted to tax the tribes/nations. SCOTUS told him to go get screwed.
And never a mention in national news media, even fleetingly, of the mega millions in donations the tribes/nations around the country give in charity to the states and local areas in which they are situated, or a place on the Today Show for the all female Indian elite firefighters, or the Indian firefighters who travel around the country to assist in battling wildfires.
I wonder how many of them are in CA right now?
Keep us updated on this tax lawsuit, 1stwarrior.
Ma'am - this will be one of my primary topics - much to the chagrin of some
All Indians are subject to federal income taxes. As sovereign entities, tribal governments have the power to levy taxes on reservation lands. Some tribes do and some dont. As a result, Indians and non-Indians may or may not pay sales taxes on goods and services purchased on the reservation depending on the tribe. However, whenever a member of an Indian tribe conducts business off the reservation, that person, like everyone else, pays both state and local taxes. State income taxes are not paid on reservation or trustlands.
Think the state forgot 'bout that.
Mimi - this will give you an overview of all the taxes "charged" to Indians.
But..but...but... I've heard all my life that Indians pay no taxes!!
Yeah - and we get free monthly money, free housing, etc..
I do!!!! Damn, I've really been missing out for a lot of years.
Where do I sign up?
Many states refuse to accept that Indian tribes are sovereign entities.
To what? Bring out the Winchesters, Henry Repeating Rifles, Colt .45's - exactly what a few Generals in the 1870's said - we've got the gun-power and can smash them into nothing.
The tribes protect the rights of their members through law-suits - that is one of the major functions of Federal Indian Law - defending the nation/tribe. That is one of the major requirements from SCOTUS - tribes are to defend their rights - even if SCOTUS rules against us.
Answered your question regarding needing additional protection - that's wut it'd bee fer.
This and other such questions have an underlying philosophical argument to be made, namely, since the Government of the United States essentially stole/commandeered that which was occupied (thus possessed/owned) by Native Americans, "developed reservation resources" logically, if not de facto legally, must not in any manner be usurped by state/local/Federal entities.
So true A. Mac - in addition, there's that little Indian Reorganization Act that "requires" the tribes/nations and Feds to develop reservation resources for the benefit of the tribes/nations.