╌>

The Public Safety Exception to Miranda - FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  larry-hampton  •  13 years ago  •  17 comments

The Public Safety Exception to Miranda - FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin

police officers at a scene

After 44 years, the Miranda decision stands as a monolith in police procedure. 1 Its requirements are so well known that the Supreme Court remarked, "Miranda has become embedded in routine police practice to the point where the warnings have become part of our national culture." 2 And, although the Supreme Court has clarified and refined Miranda over the years, its central requirements are clear. 3 Whenever the prosecution seeks in its direct case to introduce a statement made by a suspect while in custody and in response to interrogation, it must prove that the subject was warned of specific rights and voluntarily waived those rights. 4 The penalty imposed on the prosecution for failing to prove that the Miranda procedures were properly followed is harsh. While some secondary and limited uses of statements obtained in violation of Miranda are permitted, such statements are presumed to be coerced and cannot be introduced by the prosecution in its direct case. 5

---------------------------------------------------------------------

The Supreme Court ruled on these facts that a public safety exception to Miranda existed. To understand how the Court reached this conclusion and the implications of this exception on the admissibility of the statement and the handgun, a consideration of a summary of the steps used by the Court is important.

The first step toward this conclusion was a discussion by the Court of the relationship between the Miranda requirements and the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. The Fifth Amendment provides that "[n]o personshall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself." 15 The Fifth Amendment "does not prohibit all incriminating admissions," only those that are "officially coerced selfaccusations." 16 In Miranda, the Supreme Court "for the first time extended the Fifth Amendment privilege against compulsory self-incrimination to individuals subjected to custodial interrogation by the police." 17 Thus, Miranda created a presumption that "interrogation in custodial circumstances is inherently coercive" and that statements obtained under those circumstances "are inadmissible unless the subject is specifically informed of his Miranda rights and freely decides to forgo those rights." 18 Importantly, the Court noted that Miranda warnings were not required by the Constitution, but were prophylactic measures designed to provide protection for the Fifth Amendment privilege against selfincrimination. 19

After providing this explanation of the relationship between the Fifth Amendment and Miranda, the Court explained that Quarles did not claim that his statements were "actually compelled by police conduct which overcame his will to resist." 20 Had police officers obtained an involuntary or coerced statement from Quarles in violation of the due process clause of the Fifth Amendment, both the statement and the handgun would have been suppressed. 21 And, in this regard, the Court explained that the failure to administer Miranda warnings does not, standing alone, make a confession involuntary in violation of the Constitution. 22

------------------------------------------------------------------------

According to the Supreme Court, the public safety exception is triggered when police officers have an objectively reasonable need to protect the police or the public from immediate danger. Because the standard is objective, the availability of the exception does not depend on subjective motivation of the officers. Legitimate concerns for officer safety or public safety prompting unwarned custodial questioning arise in a variety of contexts. A common factor that can be gleaned from the courts addressing this issue is the prior knowledge or awareness of specific facts or circumstances that give rise to the imminent safety concern that prompted the questioning.

~FBI~


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

good article

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Ya know, something like this might come in handy in saving many lives. Lets just say, oh for example, terrorists bomb some innocent civilians and law enforcement needs to be sure that there are no more hidden, undetonated bombs somewhere...

 
 
 
David Abrams
Freshman Silent
link   David Abrams    13 years ago

is it ok to mention how holders office and a judge interrupted the interrogation by fbi agents, without any warning they were coming?

why does eric holder still run justice?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    13 years ago

why does eric holder still run justice?

Maybe Eric turns Barack on.

I dunno.

 
 
 
David Abrams
Freshman Silent
link   David Abrams    13 years ago

i think it very curious how anyone can question someone of being a conspiracy nut, given all that holder and his group has had a hand in so far, and how much in the dark they keep all of us.

what other recourse does one have than to doubt anything and everything? to me, this seems a normal reaction, not extreem.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Good point. If someone would have told me a story like "Fast and Furious" a few years ago, I woulda laughed at them...nowwa days anything is possible.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    13 years ago

The prophylactic Miranda warnings therefore are "not themselves rights protected by the Constitution but [are] instead measures to insure that the right against compulsory self-incrimination [is] protected."

Nice and thanks Troll Hunter; that does more firmly give context.

 
 
 
David Abrams
Freshman Silent
link   David Abrams    13 years ago

a friend pointed out to me that there was no mention of possession of firearms in the complaint filed against the bomber....the very first thing that i thought of was 'fast and furious'

does that make me a conspiracy nut? i dont really know. maybe, or, perhaps, not.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    13 years ago

I'm just happy that Holder decided that the public was safe enough and that it was time to get in there and protect the Boston Marathon Bomber ...before he ended up saying something "wrong".

 
 
 
David Abrams
Freshman Silent
link   David Abrams    13 years ago

fair enough, i can only speak for myself. perhaps an increase in such occurances is a symptom of something other than mass hysteria? if there are many such theories, and i perhaps may assume they are increasing in number/followers, one must wonder why that is.

maybe its because people no longer believe our "leaders", or believe them less and less with each revelation/claim of national security or priveledge.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    13 years ago

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    13 years ago

True; good point.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    13 years ago

I think that EI was just stating additional information (might be wrong). But, yeah, once charges were brought, to make anything beyond that pointadmissible, the miranda was read.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    13 years ago

So the Miranda being read though enables the prosecution to useinterrogationevidence in court. In a case like this I suppose that any and all evidence is better.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    13 years ago

Thus you are free to keep your mouth shut.

It's important to understand that. It sheds light on why the public safety exemption was put in place, why and how it is useful, and why we as Americans, should be thankful for it.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    13 years ago

My position is he is a citizen and he should be treated as such.

He was and is being treated as a citizen.

My take is he should have been mirandized because there is no fool that would think that after being caught for the crimes when they have the public evidence they have, charges would be forthcoming......

The questioning before the miranda was not about building a case, it was aboutprocuringAmerican'ssafetyfrom other possible threats they may have had in place, or knowledge of.

They deliberately manipulated the law with the question of is he a citizen or a terrorist.

That is BS. There was no need to manipulate the law as the miranda exception is in place for situation such as this. Nowhere has there been any legalwranglingor attempts to discredit or disprove his citizenship by the USgovernmentor any of it's entities...I'd like to have a link to that if you have some.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    13 years ago

and that's another point, all danger was past and he was in custody, passed out in a hospital from loss of blood.

WHERE WAS THE PUBLIC DANGER? I don't see it.....

At least not to justify withholding Miranda warnings for two days.

Any claim that there was a pressing danger is a stretch to put it mildly in my opinion.

So you were/are more aware of possible terrorist threats than the FBI ? Wow, that's pretty fancy deduction and perhaps the Feds could use your help on one of their investigative teams. Up to that point NOBODY knew for sure what threats were where.

"Nowhere has there been any legalwranglingor attempts to discredit or disprove his citizenship by the USgovernmentor any of it's entities...I'd like to have a link to that if you have some."

Nowhere in any posting did I say there was any of the sort.

Sure you did ...

They deliberately manipulated the law with the question of is he a citizen or a terrorist.

And what's with the manipulation? The miranda exception is no manipulation, it IS a SCOTUSdecision and interpretation , and for good reason I might add. Are you saying that there was no threat to publicsafety? And you know this how?

 
 

Who is online

Gsquared


134 visitors