╌>

In Boston, our bloated surveillance state didn’t work

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  z  •  13 years ago  •  24 comments

In Boston, our bloated surveillance state didn’t work

Beefed-up expenditures and laws failed to stop the Boston bombing,
and did little to help capture the suspects

....The past decade has seen presidents, politicians conservatives and liberals alike champion preemptive policing laws such as the USA Patriot Act, FISA, NDAA 2012 and 2013, to Transportation Security Administration security practices and searches, to See Something, Say Something practices all in service to fighting the War on Terror. As a cable-news talking head cooed Friday morning: There are cameras and social media everywhere. There is nowhere to hide! That statement seemed indisputable: store cameras, street cameras, private cellphone cameras and videos could be integrated to give an astonishingly wide record of the tens of thousands of people who were at last Mondays event. Yet, the most important truth of that day seemed to be lost in the gush of self-congratulation: The explosion of the bombs confirmed that a massive extension of the surveillance-state did not protect people in Boston.

Remarkably, this message of the paramilitarized surveillance state was in no way challenged merely because it was inaccurate. By the time Massachusetts Gov. Deval Patrick ended the shelter in place request, the second suspect had still not been found. Suddenly, the Boston public was supposed to believe that they were magically safer after the lockdown ended than before. But lest one come to conclude that this suggested a failure of the militant and closely watchful surveillance state, Rachel Maddow, Erin Burnett and other cable news heads happily rushed to its vindication by triumphantly exclaiming the insightful fruits of the years-long See Something, Say Something campaign by the Department of Homeland Security.... http://www.salon.com/2013/04/22/in_boston_our_bloated_surveillance_state_didnt_work/

Recently, I was critical of a "gun rights" protagonist in regards to the governments responsibility to enact laws that prevent harm and how such laws cannot possibly protect us from ALL possible harm.

Here we have a case of surveillance mechanisms already in place as a result of the "Homeland Security" laws, that did not only fail to stop this tragedy but were of little help in apprehending the persons involved. Money for nothing as the song goes.

The difference here however, between gun ownership restrictions and the protection of the populace at large , comes down to who demanded such protection. The gun restrictions are basically " Vox populi" whereas the Homeland Security inspired surveillance came from our paternalistic government. The former merely "restricts" our rights while the latter, "intrudes" upon them.

I n this case, we (the people) have allowed a massive government incursion into our daily, private and public affairs, meekly surrendering our constitutional rights for the promise of safety...a safety any government cannot ever deliver. Making matters worse, the FBI was alerted by Russia's security services and chose to totally ignore their warning, which if they would have looked into, very well could have prevented this terrorist act.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

They were caught or killed within a four day window, identified with surveillence cameras. As to whether or not the incident may have been stopped entirely, I suppose we will have to wait a wee bit for that.

Not that I am always in their corner, but this is a case were the inter action of law enforcement and citizens paid off, they did a good job.

But I will not be picking my nose or scratcing my crotch in public anymore.

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

Publicsurveillancecameras do not deter crime. This statistic is known by law enforcement. What they use them for is to identify theperpetratorsso they canapprehendthem. It worked just this way in Boston. They were identified on cameras where the bombs were placed, identified (within hours) by people that knew them when the pictures were released. Again at least one of them was identified on a 7-11 camera after robbing the store and that is when police knew the area the two suspects were.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

Good idea. Tell the people that are killed and their loved ones, while all of this technology will NOT deter criminal action, you can rest (some in peace) assured we will capture whomever did this...maybe...and maybe be able to prosecute them, if we can be allowed to suspend their Miranda rights.

What a bunch of crock. In the meantime, we will allow all legal and corporate agencies involved in security, to view our public cameras at any time and for any flimsy reason.

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

Tell the people that are killed and their loved ones, while all of this technology will NOT deter criminal action,...

Oh great hyper-sensationalism... Not going to work. We arevulnerablein public that will never change.

if we can be allowed to suspend their Miranda rights.

Where were Miranda rights suspended?

In the meantime, we will allow all legal and corporate agencies involved in security, to view our public cameras at any time and for any flimsy reason.

Which is moreimportantidentifying criminals or not watching you pick a wedgie when you walk by an ATM machine? Do businesses and municipalities (and their insurance companies) have the right to protect their property or not? Should they not co-operate with other law enforcement departments?

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

I want to see the interview of anyone forced" outat gun point out of their homes to perform warrentless searches". I really want to see who that was. I am unaware that anyone complained about being forced out at gunpoint. I've heard interviews of people being asked by law enforcement to look around and people being asked to vacate an area that law enforcement was worried may have contained IEDs.

Considering the two guys were tossing them out the window of the car during that car chase and they found the one guy with a vestcontainingexplosives they had every right to err on the side ofcaution. I don't see any rights being trampled here, unless you can prove your claims of "force". Then I'll be right beside you.

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    13 years ago

You receive a knock at your door. Upon answering, you see a dozen policemen in full combat gear standing on your porch. One of them very politely asks, "Excuse me sir, could you get everyone inside the house to come out and may we search your house?" I suppose you could say no, but it's quite obvious that the question, no matter how politely asked, is purely rhetorical. So the effect is that you comply. Is the force any less real because it was implied rather than overt? Your responseto them is irrelevent; they will search your house.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago
  • Oh great hyper-sensationalism... Not going to work. We arevulnerablein public that will never change.

Fortunately, neither you nor I represent "We" which is the sum total of what people think. However, I side with those educated and reasonable people whom will NOT sell our rights for security.

  • Where were Miranda rights suspended?

Read the entire article for your answer.

  • Which is moreimportantidentifying criminals or not watching you pick a wedgie when you walk by an ATM machine? Do businesses and municipalities (and their insurance companies) have the right to protect their property or not? Should they not co-operate with other law enforcement departments?

Crimes against property and theft, is one thing....Capitol crimes, another. While all the cameras in the world could not have prevented this, simple human intelligence, like the FBI following up on a bona fide lead from another government, may have.

I'm not selling my rights down the hole just to have someone get caught after the fact, that is giving a lot for NOTHING. This entire fiasco is like a MSM snake oil infomercial, as it takes away the real onus here; technology did NOT prevent a major terrorist act.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

"Homeland Security", which is a misnomer, has duty to PREVENT, not apprehend. It is supposed to be proactive, NOT reactive. They played little if any part here other than what the MSM chose to falsely display.

Unlike the press or others whom are making excuses for ineptitude of our federal bureaucracy. This was a police operation from start to finish, and for them whom are sworn to "maintain the peace" is nothing but gratitude.

All the facts here are not known and will never be known, especially when it comes to federal involvement. When they actually do something right, it's an accident. However, the justified use of public cameras is getting pretty slim. The 1984 analogy is appropriate here.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

Counterintelligence is the only method of prevention. I don't expect the authorities will reveal the specifics any time soon. If they did it wouldn't be very intelligent, IMO.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

bloated surveillance?!!

it appeared to me our entire eastern block intelligence network is now putin!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Publicsurveillancecameras do not deter crime.

Well, that is true if you make the assumption that the two perps were only planning this one attack..

However, it now seems that this may not have been a one-time attack-- this was not a typical jihadi "suicide bombing". Rather, it now appears that they thought they could get away with it, and planned to carry out more attacks in then future. (And if that is the case, then the surveillance did indeed prevent future attacks-- and probably further loss of life).

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

While all the cameras in the world could not have prevented this,...

I'm glad we can agree on one thing.

  • Where were Miranda rights suspended?

Read the entire article for your answer.

[FROM THE ARTICLE]

What further cements this view of the Homeland as a Battlefield is the public, collective and casual insistence that a 19-year old should not be read his Miranda rights because an asserted public safety exception can be invoked in view of the fact that other IEDs or pressure-cooker bombs might have been set.

So no evidence that anyone's Miranda rights were voided only a suggested by unnamedsourcestheymaybe they could be. I do not agree with thisopinion All persons on US soil have the same rights.

...simple human intelligence, like the FBI following up on a bona fide lead from another government, may have.

From my understanding they did. They didn't have anything at that time. Was there error in intelligence then or did something further the guy down the loony road later? I don't know enough about the case to make adecision. I doubt you do either.

Or are you suggesting that once someone makes a claim thegovernmentkeeps tabs on people? Wouldn't that be aninfringementof privacy rights?

...technology did NOT prevent a major terrorist act.

It didn't and I don't think anyone here is making the case it did. Only that it aided in the identification and capture. But you are saying that a store, bank or city shouldn't put up cameras in the off chance someone does do somethingdestructive. Good luck with that.

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

You receive a knock at your door.

A knock at the door out of the blue is much different than what happened in Boston. Let's keep the conversations to what actually happened.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

You receive a knock at your door.

A knock at the door out of the blue is much different than what happened in Boston. Let's keep the conversations to what actually happened.

Aw c'mon evilgenius. When someone is trying to obsessively trying to push their political agenda--the last thing they need is for us to confuse them by stating the actual facts! Grin.gif

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

Watched the video. It gave no context and can only assume it was Watertown, because the article says it was. If they were going door to door checking everyone, why it that the only video? Why wasn't the person filming checked? Why is the only source from a person with a facebook page labled PoliceStateUSA?

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    13 years ago

Cameras in public are in line with the law. Any suspect activity in the sight of them or anything "overheard" while you're on the phone there is evidence. If I remember the legal speak correctly, it is considered under the "reasonable expectation of privacy" precedents and each situation is different.

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

Grin.gif

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

If the cops were pulling people out of homes by force as you claim there would be more than one fucking video online and every fucking redneck would have wood in their paints over it. Fox News would have it looping 24/7. Glen Beck and Alex Jones would be having heart attacks. So whatever Bruce. I'mskeptical.

I've already told the cops no -

Twice once at my door - Once looking for the neighbor lady that had a fight with her boyfriend and broke his wing mirror. Told them she wasn't there. Second time that same lady called on me - told them she was nuts and they thanked me for my time. Each time they wanted to "step inside" my house. I did not let them. I did offer them a cup of coffee however.

Once in a car (I was the passenger) my friend was doing 5 miles over the speed limit - tried to get him to sit in the squad car "while we sort it out". They called two dog handlers too trying to find drugs, but ended up let us go "with a warning". Neither one of us left the car for the whole 45 minutes.

And once at my place of business on a weekend where no one was there wind set off the alarm next door, they were already in with guns drawn. I ID'ed myself, explained the alarm was next door and goes off every time the wind blows and thanked them for stopping by. The lead uniform was an old friend of mine. Took 15 minutes. Told me tell the owner not to let the other employees put the door combo on the back of the back door.

I've never had reason to complain. When I do some lawyer will make some money.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago
  • And you see a difference in this?

Without a doubt. These restrictions are based on the "voice of the people" and their scope is very limited to a single clause of the 2nd Amendment and is narrowly defined as to not infringe on the basic right to own and bear arms and as such, is not easily abused.

Public Surveillance cameras, which were pushed on the public without their input, infringe on a multitude of civil and constitutional rights ( ... ) and are ripe for abuse ( ... ) by federal, state and local authorities.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

technology did NOT prevent a major terrorist act.

Going forward AP, I think you are going to find this to be a minor terrorist act. There are more, and worse in our future I'm sorry to say. Both organic, and from offshore.

The first line of defense is human intelligence. Some are going to parallel this to selling your neighbor out to the Gestapo, or KGB. LE can not be everywhere at once, nor do any of us want them to be, so what alternative is there? (I'm open to suggestions on this point.) From there, electronic intelligence/surveillance, and direct LE involvement take over.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    13 years ago

As a gun owner and 2nd amendment advocate, I see no problem in the mere restriction of selling firearms to a group of people whom have a documented history of violence either psychologically or behaviorally.

Drawing the line is easy enough when there is a preponderance of evidence to show a pattern of violence, violent behavior or recidivism culminating in violence whereby it can be proved that such behavior is more likely, than not.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

The installation and use of cameras has been driven by the need to 1) Reduce manpower regarding security. 2) To provide a record of activities of the area under surveillance as evidence to prosecute, or defend in a court of law.

Banks, and retail stores made use of them to watch their employees, and it spread from there. These institutions have the right to defend themselves against employee theft or robbery. I've installed cameras on production floors from a point of employee safety and fire prevention.

At this point, Cities are employing cameras for many of the same reasons that private companies do. All forms of crime are down since their peak in 1980. It is quite possible that video surveillance has something to do with that.

Progress is never free, you have to pay for it. Be it earning the right to vote, the ability to fly, or unlock the power of DNA, they all come with a price tag of something lost, and something gained.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

Well look at the first post on this article. Luther reacted the exact way they want us to, they want us to welcome more surveillance and want us to surrender our rights without question in the name of "safety".

They want us to just accept it without question like this

But I will not be picking my nose or scratching my crotch in public anymore.

Obviously by this statement, Luthur has already accepted it as the way things are....no question.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

That is not the spin the MSM is putting on it....go figure.

 
 

Who is online









133 visitors