Compromise: Political Poison
Special to L. Neil Smith's The Libertarian Enterprise*
Let the other guy offer compromises. Think of them as rungs on the ladder you're climbing. Keep your own goals fixed firmly in your mind and make sure you never move any direction but upwards That's how the other side got where they are. It works. L. Neil Smith
As American kids grow up, authority figures all around thempublic school teachers, local and national political leaders, the broadcast and print media, ministers and priests, and other useless busybodiesare always very enthusiastic about the idea of compromise.
Compromise, these Judas goats and stable ponies always proclaim in the most glowing terms, is the one absolutely indispensable, magical key to living and working within that best of all possible political worlds, a democracy. If everybody takes a stance and won't budge, if nobody is willing to give at least an inch (if not a mile), why, then nothing will ever get done! This, of course, overlooks the obvious fact that there are a great many circumstancesalmost all of which involve government in some wayin which nothing ever should get done.
Somewhere around the fourth grade, if we have anything like half a brain left after all the indoctrination, we begin to notice certain things about this compromise bonnet-bee that make it clear that it is something less than the wonderful notion its proponents always say it is.
The first is that, since neither side can reasonably expect to get what it really wants. The best that anyone can ever hope for, from a properly engineered compromise, is that both sides will wind up equally dissatisfied. This is not, I submit, an acceptable way to run a civilization. It is a recipe to guarantee the perpetuation of bitter conflict, creating the ideal breeding ground for politicians (like puddles for mosquitoes), for whom solved problems are a threat to their livelihood.
The second thing one notices, thanks to the left-wing politicians in Congress who are usually the principal advocates of compromise, is that it always seems to be the other guy who's supposed to be willing to give way. (Sort of same the way you and I never get to be "others" when "others" are the entities we're supposed to live to serve.) It's the leftists' opponents who are always accusedusually at big press conferences and in newspaper columnsof being stiff-necked and unwilling to accept even the most reasonable, "common-sense" amount of legislation.
Somehow, it always turns out to be reasonable, "common-sense" legislation that will tear another great bleeding chunk out of the Bill of Rights. (Observe, too, that the only time the left wing gives a rat's ass about the Bill of Rights is when the right wing is in power.)
The third thing that even a nine-year-old kid notices is that, having finally been badgered and brow-beaten into accepting a glorious compromise of some kind, whoever has been sucker enough to do it will be expected to do it all over again, the next time the subject comes up.
"What's mine is mine," goes the saying, "and what's yours is negotiable."
Which is exactly how we ended up in the mess we're in now.
For example, many of us are old enough to remember clearly, as children, watching and listening to the American Medical Association cravenly give way, one step at a time, to slimy leftist politicians of course they would have called it "compromise"until today, even if Americans succeed in repealing "Obamacare", they will still be afflicted with a situation (it never deserved to be called a "system") that is neither free market nor socialist, but combines the worst aspects of both. Which is why we need total separation of medicine and state.
Now I ask you: if a fourth grader could see all of that clearly, what's wrong with the bucket-headsthe glorious leadership of the National Rifle Association comes to mindwho still can't see it as adults?
Time and time again, the NRA has allowed itself to get bloodied and humiliatedalong with us and our rightsbecause its leaders dull-wittedly believe they can negotiate (read, "compromise") with the sworn enemies of freedom, collectivists who want us dead. The badguys know exactly what they strive forabsolute elimination of private weapons ownership in America, almost certainly, history warns us, as a prelude to the kind of mass killing called "democide"while the NRA doesn't have a clue what it's supposed to be fighting for, and never did.
I guess we'll eventually see whether the Tea Parties and the next few elections can manage to teach them anything. Somebody badly needs to knock them over, sit on their chests, and scream down their hairy nostrils that any compromise at all with evil isguess what? evil!
Don't believe it? Then let's try this simple thought experiment. Suppose that a crazed serial killer invades your home. Somehow, he gets the drop on you. (You did have your carry-piece on you, didn't you?) He then ties you to a kitchen chair. You see that he's done exactly the same with each member of your familyfor our present purposes, let's say that you have a spouse and three kids. The killer then tells you that he's looking forward to eviscerating your spouse and your three children while you watch, and then doing the same to you.
Clearly, this is an evil idea.
You reply that you would rather see your family and yourself unharmed.
This is a good idea.
The killer admits that he can see your point. He'll offer you a compromise. He'll only kill two of your family, and you get to choose which.
Okay, is this compromise a good idea or a bad one? While it allows two members of your family to stay alive (provided the killer keeps his wordand we haven't gotten around to discussing your life, yet)it implicitly demands that you go along with the deaths of the other two, and even requires that you to seal the deal by doing the choosing.
So much for "the lesser of two evils"; there simply ain't no such animal.
But if you still think it's a good idea, then you belong in the NRA, which let our enemies pass the National Firearms Acts in the 30s, the 1968 Gun Control Act, the "cop-killer bullet" ban that lets government to tell us what kind of ammunition we can purchase in order to defend ourselves from it, the Brady Bill and Ugly Gun and Adequate Magazine Ban in the 90s, and recently, HR 2640, the "NICS Improvement Act" which tightens the noose around our necks just a little bit more, all because, reportedly, they were fearful that something worse might pass.
So they compromised.
Ain't compromise swell?
But the NRA is far from alone in its idiotic eagerness to make compromises with evil. In 1977, when I was a member of the National Platform Committee of no less freedom-oriented an organization than the Libertarian Party, I warned my colleagues and compatriots that the insufferable violations of everybody's unalienable individual, civil, Constitutional, and human rights most of them had just experienced in the process of flying to the convention city of San Francisco "security measures" were just getting started at the nation's airports and seem mild, today, by comparisonrepresented the beginning of a fascist regimen that would eventually spread out to engulf the entire country.
I was laughed at. They laughed at methese "leading thinkers" of the freedom movementand proceeded to mouth exactly the same, lazy, security-state excuses that you hear so commonly coming from the "useful idiots" that you see in "man in the street" interviews on government-sanctioned television news. And in the thirty-something years that have followed, not one of those former committee members has ever thought to acknowledge that I was right, and far ahead of my time.
Some thinkers in the general freedom movement suggest that, in a broader sense, it is all of us, to one degree or another, who are guilty of advancing tyranny, simply by being willing to make deals with it. We're always too polite with individuals who are evil, crazy, or just plain butt-stupid, meekly going along with their outrageous nonsense instead of dealing with itand themappropriately. How would Thomas Jefferson have responded to a demand that he surrender urine and other intimate bodily substances before he was allowed to have a job, an idea that would have had our ancestors priming their flintlocks?
Without pausing to read the damned thing, the Congress passed the USA Patriot Actwhich, for all intents and purposes, cancelled out the Bill of Rightsand scarcely anybody so much as whimpered. But this kind of travesty was hardly unprecedented. Before that, it was warrantless wiretapping, no-knock raids, RICO (designed specifically to deny legal representation to the accused), and legalized black bag jobs of the kind the Watergate burglars went to jail for. Of course now they can enter and search your house and never even tell you about it.
All because most of us are just too bloody polite.
In a matter of less than twenty years, our campuses, the media, and then our places of business were taken over by a kind of social disease we now call "political correctness" in which it's considered unacceptable to call a thing by its true name, to want to know who started the fight, to judge individuals by their actual abilities or virtues, or to enjoy anything that might make the most hypchondriacal lunatic among us whimper or sniffle that he's allergic to anyone who smokes tobacco, wears perfume, or even thinks about consuming peanut butter.
What we should have done is laugh in our correctors' fascistic faces, gone right ahead telling ethnic jokes about each other, and sent the hypochondriacal loonies off to their bins. Our moral sword and shield should have been the Bill of Rights. Insteadbecause we were too dadblasted polite againwe allowed them to walk all over us.
We're also too ready to compromise on an international level. No matter what position you may take on immigration issues (I'm an open borders guy, myself), one thing is beyond doubt: there is a conspiracy to flood our southwestern statesArizona, New Mexico, southern California, southwest Texaswith enough foreign nationals to seize them politically and deliver them to Mexico. This conspiracy is taking place in broad daylight, with the full knowledge and support of the Mexican government, and we're too damned polite to do anything about it.
It's called "La Reconquista"the reconquestand it festered first in the academia-decayed minds of far-left Hispanic professors in border-state universities. And it's a lie: for the most part the lands in question never belonged to Mexico to begin with; the plan is that they never will. Instead, the advocates of la Reconquista yearn for their very own socialist paradise called "Aztlan", where the economic system that killed tens of millions through arctic exile, political execution, and good old fashioned starvation, the system that failed in Russia, virtually destroyed eastern Europe, and is being rapidly abandoned by China will be given a good old college try all over again.
You know, I don't mind people reinventing the wheel from time to time, but when they keep insisting on reinventing it square, it gets annoying.
The solution is an easy one. The President should simply declare that any Mexican state that ratifies the American Bill of Rights by a two-thirds supermajority may join the United States. (Just to be fair, we should make the same offer to Canadian provinces, as well.) Believe me, that will start brushfires it will take the Mexican government a century to put out, and we'll hear nothing about "La Reconquista" ever again.
And therefore we won't have to compromise with it.
There are, in fact, two kinds of compromise, trivial and moral. A trivial compromise concerns issues unrelated to questions of good and evil. "What shall we have on our pizza?" is an excellent example. (Yes, I know some people think anchovies are evilmore for me.) So are "What movie shall see tonight?" and "Where shall we take our next vacation?"
There's nothing bad with this trivial kind of compromise. It's how marriages and friendships manage to survive. Knowing that, the enemies of freedom try to make the other kind of compromise they want you to makea compromise between good and evilseem as ordinary and trivial.
So let me offer you this simple pair of moral and political guidelines.
First, if a political proposal is made that weakens or destroys the Bill of Rightsyou must never accept the other guy's word about thisor if it generally threatens to limit or damage individual liberty, then it's evil. It cannot be compromised with. It can only be opposed and ultimately obliterated by any and all of the means at our disposal.
Second, as libertarians know, if a proposal calls for government (or any other) use of force against anyone who hasn't initiated force first, or plainly offered to, it's evil, and it cannot be compromised with.
If you try, all you'll end up with is more evil.
A final thought. There are some freedoms that are so fundamental, so vitally important, that they must never be subjected to voting, to the passage of legislation, or to the latest whims or fads of judges at whatever level. That's why the Founding Fathers (some of them, anyway) insisted upon a Bill of Rights, so that some individual rights would be sacrosanct, set above politicamong those rights, freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom from search and seizure, freedom from drumhead and kangaroo courts, freedom of religion, freedom to assemble, and most notably, the freedom to own and carry weapons.
None of these are properly subject to any political process of any kind, nor is it appropriate to ask police chiefs or other cops what they think of them, or to conduct public opinion surveys about them. The Bill of Rights was written specifically to protect free exercise of our rights from the whims of authority and an ignorant or hostile majority.
Obviously, it didn't work out that way in the end, and the primary reason it didn't was compromise. Now, if we want any of our freedoms back, what we have to give up is compromise. We need a Constitutional amendment, just as an example, that puts real teeth in the Bill of Rights, severely punishing it.
Obviously, it didn't quite work out that way in the end, and the reason it didn't was compromise. Today, if we want any of our freedoms back, what we have to give upwhat we're called upon to sacrifice, if you willis compromise. We need a Constitutional amendment that will put savage teeth in the Bill of Rights, severely punishing anybodyany politician, any bureaucrat, or any policemanwho attempts to violate, eliminate, or get around the highest law of the land.
And there can be no compromise about that.
A fifty-one year veteran of the libertarian movement, L. Neil Smith is the award-winning author of more than 30 books, including The Probability Broach, Ceres, Sweeter Than Wine, and Down With Power: Libertarian Policy In A Time Of Crisis. He is the Publisher and Senior Columnist of L. Neil Smith's The Libertarian Enterprise, now in its 17th year online. He is also the Senior Editorial Consultant to JPFO. * Slightly different versions of this essay appeared on the website of Jews for the Preservation of Firearms Ownership, for which it was originally prepared, and in Down With Power: Libertarian Policy In A Time Of Crisis, winner of the prestigious Freedom Book of the Year Award for 2012-2013. Original material on JPFO.org is copyright, so that it cannot be used or plagiarized as the work of another. JPFO does however encourage article reproduction and sharing, providing full attribution is given and a link back to the original page on JPFO is included: http://jpfo.org/smith/smith-politicalpoison.htm . Visit the L. Neil Smith archive on JPFO.org.
Tags
Who is online
122 visitors

The constitution is a shining example of compromise...
ANd the people who wrote it were forced to compromise to get it passed- that compromise was the last good one ever made. It is called the Bill of Rights.
The small minded, self-centered and the selfish are the ones that fail to grasp the concept of compromise. They have no concept of the term "WE" and scoff at the idea of team effort. Somehow they have reached the conclusion that their ideas and hide is more valuable than everyone else around them.
Lets try another compromise... Say the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
Neale,
This nation was built on compromise. Our founding father's had to compromise just to get the Declaration passed.. and not by a majority, or even a super majority, but by aunanimousvote. There were no liberals or conservatives. They couldn't even agree that England was the common enemy. But they hadjust a common dream.
The reason that the word compromise has gotten such a bad name is the condition of this country. We have become so polarized that each extreme looks at the other ones with almost the same level ofdisdainthat we used to reserve for our real enemies, like the USSR during the cold war. But now we look at our own country men in that same way. How utterly disturbing.
I am not a liberal. I am an independent. But I do believe just like most things in life, compromise is not a black or white ethos, but rather one of shades of gray. There are times to compromise and times not. But to declare compromise blanketly, the net result of brain washing, an evil thing, well then someone did a wonderful job of making you look at over half of your country men as the enemy. You almost leave me wishing of days of the Cold War. At least we didn't look at each other as the bad guys.
Opinions are a nice thing. But compromising with evil is evil. The CRA '64 wasn't compromise. It was an attempt at ending a piss-poor compromise that led to Jim Crow, the KKK, and segregation. People who compromised on that were the Democrats, who opposed it, but knew they had to appear to care.
Compromise of your principles, IF you actually have them, is evil, no matter what excuse you choose to use.
Sept 5, 2011, I wrote the following-
Compromise- a word most foul to those of us with principles.
Lately, the news has been full of demands that the Republicans "compromise" with the Democrats. Of course, the Democrats never volunteer to compromise with Republicans, do they? Now, while I'm not a fan of EITHER major party, if there were only two of them and no other options, I'm farther right of Republicans on most fiscal issues, and left of Democrats on SOME social issues. Fortunately for me. I have the Libertarian Party to belong to, so compromise ain't-a-gointa happen. Compromise is the single biggest evil there can be in politics. Well, if you actually have principles, it is. You want examples?? I've got a million of them, but here are a few to chew on.
We'll start with Obamacare- ENTIRELY un-acceptable. Read the 10th Amendment to the Constitution. Go ahead, I'll wait for you! What, you couldn't find it? Okay, I'll save us BOTH some time- here is a link to the entire Bill of Rights (BOR, hereafter in this article), because we're going to need it! The 10th amendment specifically states that if the Constitution does not specifically grant a power to the federal government, or specifically deny a power to the state governments, the Federal government is denied that power. The federal government is not, anywhere in the Constitution, permitted to require individuals to purchase ANYTHING! Therefore, the federal government CANNOT require the "individual mandate" that is the backbone of Obamacare. Now, the individual states are not prohibited from doing this, therefore, the Massachusetts healthcare law, as long as it doesn't violate the Mass. Constitution, is entirely legal. So, ANY compromise that allowed Obamacare to function at a federal level, violates the 10th Amendment, and is therefore, a violation of my principles of adherence to Constitutional law. Now, there ARE those who support Obamacare (about 30% by most recent polls). And there are some who want to see some changes made to it, but are opposed to some parts of it (about 15-20% in polls I've seen). And the other 50% just plain hate it, period. Some hate it for the same reason I do, others for other reasons. But here's the question- IF Obamacare violates your principles, WHY THE HELL would you compromise to make it less of a violation? It's like being pregnant- either you are, or you aren't. There is no such thing as a "little bit pregnant", is there?
Now, on to one of my biggest bugaboos. Victim Disarmament Laws (what those of you who support violating the 2nd Amendment call "gun control laws"). Remember the link? Go read the 2nd Amendment. I'll wait! Got? Cool. So, who are "the People" so mentioned? Each and every individual American Citizen. The Supreme Court said so, as early as this-
"The People" is referring to individuals. NOT states, the federal government, nor government employees only. So, now you're going to bring up the "well Regulated Militia". First, what is the definition of a militia? NO, it's NOT a bunch of survivalist whacko's plotting to verthrow the government or re-enslave blacks or purify the "white race". Nope, those may be CURRENT definitions of the militia, but they are definitely NOT the definition in the terms of the day. See this- (United_States) . Here's the relevant part:
Today, this would be automatically expanded to include women, who are no longer banned from the rights of full citizenship, as they were in the 1790s, and it would include blacks, who weren't even human at that time. So, having shot down two of the three arguments to allow these Victim Disarmament laws, we move to the final roadblock. "Well Regulated" Again we must go to the definition of the times. Go here: .
So, with all these precedents and definitions to back up the 2nd Amendment, the compromises of the NRA to help "lessen the severity" of Gun Control laws or to help ban certain types of ammo and weapons, or to push for Concealed Carry Laws violates the Constitution. Again, compromise is evil- the federal government cannot "control" that which "shall not be infringed." And, since the states cannot violate the Constitution, THEY can't license guns, or control where they may be carried, or control HOW they may be carried. And, the last-ditch efforts of the Victim Disarmament people is "Well, they couldn't foresee high-capacity handguns and machineguns, or they would have written the 2nd Amendment differently. THEY meant only flintlock rifles." Nope. They said "ARMS". The definition of the times is here: .
I think that sums it up, don't you??
Let's pick one more area where "compromise" is (me being sarcastic) "Oh so necessary" in order to be "reasonable". Economic Justice (also known as "Social Justice"). The government "re-distribution of wealth. " What it actually is is the government confiscation of private property without recompense. Remember that pesky Bill of Rights? Re-read the 5th Amendment.
Where is the "just compensation" for taking what one person owns, inherited or earned, in order to give it to others? Again, there isn't a Constitutional justification. Compromise IN ANY FORM violates my principles, and it won't happen.
Now, I'm sure there are those out there sharpening their keyboards and preparing to justify compromising my principles on one or more of these instances (or others!!). Have at it!
I wrote this then, and I still mean it now. Whether you like it or not, I happen to KNOW it is the truth.
Luv ya, babe. But I disagree. See my reply above to FlyNavy.
All through your diatribe Neal, all I read from you are the words Me, and I, I, I.
I'll leave you with this since it might be the best shot there is to impact your closed mind.....
Our Constitutions begins with: "WE THE PEOPLE......"
Luv ya to, but I have to disagree, too. I read what you wrote to Fly and you do know that what most people have are belief and not principles. The USSR had their principles too, you know, and I am pretty sure that they viewed us as pretty darn evil.
Now if this was a discussion about doing something that we feel is evil for the sake of compromise, I would agree. But it isn't. It is aboutpoliticalexpedience. One side painting the other side as evil.
Well, I have never done anything that I have felt was evil, but I have compromised. I have weighed the value of doing so very carefully. I can look at other people's beliefs and although I don't agree with them, I canrespecttheir right to have them and I am willing to put aside some of my beliefs to compromise.
We all know real evil when we look at it in the eye. Right now I feel that it's this partisanship that is tearing this country apart. Us in the middle, watch in disbelief as two extremes think nothing of pulling this country asunder for their own political beliefs... I mean principles.
There are no truths when it comes to the Constitution. That is why we have SCOTUS. In fact, there is very little in life, that is an absolute truth.. least of all the Constitution, a documentbrilliantlywritten by men andinterpretedby men. A document made possible by compromise.
They were forced to compromise during the writing of the document itself . To label all compromises after the Bill of Rights as not good or presumably bad, is to deny reality for the sake of ones point of view.
Are you sure that you want to back this hyperbolic opinion?
The single principle that we should have as citizens of this country, is to move this country forward in order to better the lives of our citizens.
The failure to compromise on issues and some personal principles is counterproductive to both.
Like bouncing marbles off a sidewalk Mickey.
You are correct. It DOES begin WE, the People. We is INDIVIDUALS. If the group violates the rights of the individual, We, the People, no longer exist. It is the government determining the fate of the individual. you're damn right I say "ME" and "I". The smallest minority IS the individual.
Well with over 300,000,000 souls presently occupying our little land, it would be difficult to find a handfull to agree on anything let alone everything. Hence compromise.
In my opinion it is not the notion of compromise that is at fault, it is the idiots that we collectively elect and their agendas that are the villans in this American Tragedy play.
I'll be honest, Perrie. I do not care about the SCOTUS. It lost it's last shred of relevance (not that it had much left by then) when it ruled Obamacare "Constitutionalbecause it is a tax". From day one Obama and his cronies swore it was not and never would be a tax. Then, to shove it down our throats, they are happy to call it a tax. it is NOT a tax when you are fined for NOT buying something. The SCOTUS said that if it was not a tax, it would be unConstitutional. SO, because the IRS is the fine collector, they ruled it a tax. Nice bullshit, but it IS bullshit.
I respect the Constitution. But I will not ride it blindly into oblivion. The Constitution does not grant rights. It acknowledges them. I DO have the right to own weapons for personal defense. Against ANY enemy. Even the government. just as our forefathers did in 1776. Pass a law against it, and I still have that right. Pass a new amendment against it and I still have that right. Our government has been chipping away at the Constitution for decades. The fact that some people claim that to be "compromise" does not make it good.
I compromise on trivial things all the time. I AM, after all, married with children. But my principles will never be compromised again. I compromised and voted the lesser of two evils when I voted for McCain. Last time. I'm sorry to be this blunt, and I mean no offense. But I will not compromise on principle. And in politics, there is ONLY principle.
FLY- so what you are saying is that I should accept surrendering certain principles, such as some liberties and freedoms, becasue they arev "personal", for security and safety, huh? Ben Franklin and I disagree with you.
So much for putting your country first Neale.... way to go!
Correct Mickey.... I'm gonna need a much bigger marble!
Glad we all don't have your driving sense of citizenship and patriotism Neale.
I can agree with this part of your statement, luther, even if I can't agree on the rest! You see, you STILL have the notion that we NEED the government to do far more things than is actually true. Defend the borders. Protect individual rights. That's about it. NOT defend marriage, protect us from drugs, feed our children, educate our children, regulate our industries, provide housing and income for the poor, or force us to buy health insurance (or mandate what is included IN that inrurance). The problem is that far too many of you think the government is our caretaker, rather than our servant.
My country does not have the right to take my rights away because YOU think I should surrender them "for the good of others". What about the good of the individual? MORE damage to "the People" has been done "for their own good" than for any other reaso except for religion (which also, come to think about it, uses exactly that same reasoning!)
Here's the funny part- I'll fight to defend the country. I just won't surrender rights to do so. IF I have to surrender the rights that were used to define this country in order to "preserve" this country, then this country has failed.
Another Hitler, and I'll be on the front lines fighting. But I will never surrender individual rights to make other Americans feel "safe".
You want to detail again what rights you've lost Neale.... for the record.
Neale,
You chose not to not to believe in SCOTUS because of a ruling on Obamacare. But when you do that, you have decided not to follow your own principle, since SCOTUS is part of the veryConstitutionthat you say is your principle. There have been many decisions made by SCOTUS that I disagree with, but because I so believe in the Constitution, I live with them (including one that my cause my husband to lose his job). We don't get to pick and choose the parts we abide by... and since that is the point that I think you are trying to make here, you have just gone against your own principle. The reason that I support the Second Amendment, isn't because I'm a gun owner. I am not. But I am a strictConstitutionalist, and the Second Amendment is part of that document. Changes to that document is a slippery slope. And while you find the 2nd to be one that defines this nation I find the 1st to, and I'd be damned if anyone tried to legislate it away. On the other hand, a ruling from the Court, I would abide by.
But to have principles one must take the good with the bad in the Constitution, and not pick and choose, and no matter what decision SCOTUS makes, it is the law of the land, according to that document.
How DARE your country take away YOUR right to own black people! wait ... what are we talking about?
I myself have no need either, but I can see were others may. My thought is not to give but to help those that truly are in need. There are many times when the government is needed, ie. Sandy, Katrina etc..
We may have a similar train of thought, mine is not Darwinian though. Like I said 300,000,000 all shapes and sizes.
That's L. Neil Smith. NOT Neil L. Smith
Other than than, there's nothing we agree on, John. So, where are YOU willing to compromise? Specifically, now. Lay out your exact belief on the 2nd Amendment. Then, tell me exactly what compromises you are willing to make. You already know what I personally support. Soexactly what beliefs of YOURS are you willing to compromise in order to reach your precious consensus. Put your money where your mouth is.
A natural emergency, if the states ask for help. fine. But that is a two edged sword. People are lazy. how many times did we see people in New Orleans say "I need the government to help me survive this!" How many people from Katrina had to be forcefully evicted fromFEMA housing after the disaster was over? It took until February, 2012, OVER 6 YEARS, for people to leave their trailers. Bitching the whole time, the last few had to be evicted. They had become dependant on Big Brother. Government becomes the provider.
I am not heartless. I am kind to strangers, I never kick a dog, kids all love me. my Cub Scouts from 10 years ago still stop me on the street to say thanks for what I did for them. But I AM Darwinian, in that people who REFUSE to try deserve no help. Call me cold. I do not support taxpayer funded re-habs for drunks and druggies, UNLESS THEY SIGN A REPAYMENT CONTRACT BEFORE VOLUTARILY ENTERING. I think the so-called illicit drugs should be legalized, and allow the addicts to go on an orgy of drugging. Then sweep up the ODs, toss'em in Potter's Field, and get on with life. Severely punish ANY impaired act which endangers others. But I am not willing to compromise on rights. You have the right to fail. You have the rigth to try. You have the right to starve, if you choose not to try to support yourself. You DO NOT have the right to tell those who DO try and DO succeed that they somehow owe you a living. Oh well, I have digressed. Later, my friend.
WTF? Where did I ever say I have a right to own ANY human being? Never have, never will. I hold firmly to the ZAP- Zero Aggression Principle- where we hold that NO ONE, FOR ANY REASON, has the right to initiate aggression against another. Violence is for SELF DEFENSE ONLY. Slavery is aggression. Rape is aggression. Murder is aggression. kidnapping is aggression. Theft is aggression. Voting to steal from one and give it to another is aggression. ANY attempt to use force, whether it is simply majority rule, a fine, or guns and clubs, to force another to do something they do not wish to do, is anathema. My right to swing my fist ends before it contacts your nose.As does your right to swing your fist. PHYSICAL HARM IS VERBOTEN EXCEPT FOR SELF DEFENSE.
The 13th Amendment was created to end slavery. This wasnt a cut and dry issue, obviously, as half the country still felt it was their right to treat slaves as their property. It became an amendment, because the previously back-breaking work of slaves that free Americans didnt want to do themselves was slowly becoming increasingly mechanized through industrial innovation. This jostled the American moral psyche enough to shine light on the fact that their Constitution was in need of revision to keep up with the times.
The issue of altering the 2nd Amendment doesnt even come close to having the same impact on society as the abolition of slavery in one case an entire race of people was released from bondage, in the other hardly any change is being asked for, and it is for the good of society. Nobody is proposing to take away your right to bear arms we are simply asking that the line that demarks legal guns and illegal guns be revisited based on the how appropriate certain guns are for the public to own. We are asking that all individuals be deemed worthy of owning guns with appropriate background checks. We are asking that laws be enacted to counter the illegal sales of guns that we all know is happening. This is all based on real world impacts of these certain guns, certain individuals who shouldn't own guns, and certain gun markets - all leading to situationsin which society has repeatedly suffered. Fighting tooth and nail to keep the situation as is, is akin to those who fought tooth and nail to keep slavery legal.
Nice try, Perrie. But an epic fail. If the SCOTUS rules something to be Constitutional and rules wrong, I will never accept it. They ruled unConstitutionally in Dred Scott. The United States Supreme Court decided 72 against Scott, finding that neither he nor any other person of African ancestry could claim citizenship in the United States, and therefore Scott could not bring suit in federal court.
The SCOTUS has ruled unConstitutionally before, and will again. And when their ruling directly contradicts the Constitution's written words, they need to be forced to re-consider. The problem is, there are NO strict constructionists on the SCOTUS. Which is all there should be. Not Conservative and Liberal. NOT a single justice making the difference. There is a ton of writings from those who wrote the Constitution as to why they said what they sdaid. there is an additional ton of writings from those who refused to ratify the Constitution without the addition of the Bill of Rights. The Articles of Confederation were good enough, but the Constitutional Convention took it upon themselves to trash the whole thing and create a federation rather than a confederation. Without the guarantees provided in the BoR, we would never have gotten as far as we have.
As to the very founding document, the Declaration of Independence, the compromises undertaken to ensure unanimity guaranteed 90 more years of misery for slaves, and a huge injustice. Evil compromise again!.
So sorry, not gonna tolerate that!!
The 2nd Amendment has been drastically curtailed since NFA '34, where my right to own short barreled shotguns, a Tommy gun, or a silencer/suppressor were subjected to massive infringements. The 16th Amendment was not actually ratified correctly, so every bit of income taxes I have ever paid to the federal government are a violated right to my private property. my right to protect myself while travelling has been completely stripped if I use air transportation. My right to walk down a street without being under warrantless surveillance is gone. my right to see all the evidence against me has been stripped (police are no longer required to even show you the radar readings). My right to own and carry arms are further restricted when I travel in my car, since every state has different laws, and it is virtually impossible to know all of them. well, that's a good start.
Answer MY question, which I asked first. Then I'll cheerfully answer all those you just posted.
Hal- do you REALLY think that abolition solved problems? REALLY?? Because Jefferson compromised when writing the Declaration, 90 more years of slavery were permitted. Had the 2nd Amendment been fully enacted, those slaves would have possessed the means to prevent Massa from givin' dem darkies a whuppin. After the 13th passed, had the 2nd been properly enforced, there would have been no sharecroppers, no Jim Crow laws, no KKK, no need for the ERA, because the blacks would have possessed the means to protect themselves from racists and other trash. There would have been no need for the 13th had we followed the Constitution without compromise. The Civil War would never have happened had we not compromised to create the strong federal government.
Neale,
We've gone to "Epic Fail". Sorry. That is just your opinion, and no better than mine. Just because you pick and choose what part of theConstitutionyou will follow, why should anyone else not pick what's not important to them? You are only proving my point. The Dread Scott case was pre-civil law, and slaves were considered property in certain territories. And although the case is repugnant to us now,emancipationhadn't happened yet. So the court ruled correctly given the current law of the land. And you might not like our justices.. and neither do I, but that is of little matter. We can't pick apart what we like in the Constitution, or the whole thing falls apart, including the 2nd Amendment.
As for the Declaration of Independence... that was no compromise. The issue was independence.Jeffersonand Franklin chose to have the anti-slavery clause put in. They never expectedJohn Rutledge to catch the clause. And without the south there would have been no United States. You can't equate the grounds on which a country was born with the document that is meant to spell out the law of the land.
Franklin himself understood that issues need compromise. He said that "revolutions come into this world likeillegitimatechildren, half improvised and half compromise. We have provided for theimprovisation for this issue. We are looking to the man in the chair (Hancock), to provide the compromise." And although we did fight a bitter war later, without this compromise, there would be no nation. Do not confuse one issue with another.
Egilman speaks for me in this instance. Well said, Sir.
Egilman,
All that may be true, and frankly, I am not fond of the court. Yet it exists bodyexistsas part of theConstitution. And once we start to take apart one part of theConstitution no matter how it came into being.. the rest is a slippery slope.
Cool! I'm epic!!!!!!
Gonna hafta agree to disagree. We just look at the same event differently.
The National Collaborator's Association writes more gun laws than the Democrats do.
Not at all true. Compromise allows a dictator the room to operate. If you never grant him the compromise that allows him to gain power, you never have a dictator to begin with. Comparing libertarian to a Chinese communist dictatorship or an Islamic government is absolutely asinine.
Well, well, well that would be entertaining if it were satire. Unfortunately, it isnt, so it falls under the banner of veiled racism. In one breath you are speaking of massa givin dem darkies a whuppin, and in another you are suggesting that arming slaves would have fixed their dilemma. I guess rather than amending the Constitution to ensure voting rights to women, we should have just made sure that women were sufficiently armed when they approached the polls for the first time . and met up with armed white men and armed darkies. Guns are the answer to everything, huh? Have you ever bothered to think your bizarre ideologies out to their logical conclusions? Or is there just no such thing as logic in the absence of a gun in your world?
There WAS some satire in the statement, Hal. "We hold these truths to be self evident- that all men are created equal". Had we, as a nation, lived up to these ideals from the start, the slaves would not have been slaves anymore. They, too, would have been American citizens. Permitted to own and carry weapons, to protect themselves from, among other things, racists. No one would have been able to successfully keep them from voting, or kept them segregated. if TJ had written "All PEOPLE are created ......." we might have gotten women recognized as citizens earlier.
I have never overlooked the faults of the Founding Fathers. Jefferson and Washington among others owned slaves. Washington used the army to beat the shit out of farmers in order to collect taxes. And there are certainly more faults. But they tried. They ALSO left the means to correct their faults and compromises. MY choice would have been no compromises, though I realize that might mean we remained a British posession. Those compromises, however, caused MANy of the problems we still fight today.
Apart from your disdain for the Articles Of Confederation (which, with the Declaration of Independence, was the only thing passed unanimously), I like what you said. The "problem" with the AoC was no strong federal government. For a damn good reason- the original 13 colonies were each sovereign states (nations) united to support each other. Any member could freely leave. The Constitution, which was NOT unanimous, and required much "tweaking in order to get ratified, was NOT the original intent of that meeting that later came to be called a Constitutional Convention. it was called to fix a few problems, NOT create a federal government.
Once a strong federal government was foisted off on us, the Constitution was amended immediately (remember, many states refused to ratify without those 10 Amendments) to reduce the federal government's powers over the states and the individual. Now, we are faced with the need to try to keep those necessary freedoms or face the final extinction of the american way of life. I find it telling that over the last 30 years, that we have gone from just a handful to 39 states that are "Must Issue", Shall Issue", or Constitutional Carry. While I disapprove of carry licenses (they are an infringement, being required to pay a fee and get permission to exercise a Constitutional right is in and of itself unConstitutional), it is a good sign that only 11 states still are not on the bandwagon. Sadly, I live in one, but I digress. My wife is slowly beginning to acquiesce to my desire to move. Seeing Obama's Victim Disarmament laws gat shot down is nice, but the fact that only 46 of 100 senators respect our Constitution is sad. It is even sadder that our president is in total disdain of it, and scolds us for not allowing him to violate our rights.