School suspensions: Does racial bias feed the school-to-prison pipeline?
Two students set off fire alarms in the same school district. One of them, an African-American kindergartner, is suspended for five days; the other, a white ninth-grader, is suspended for one day.
- An African-American high-schooler is suspended for a day for using a cellphone and an iPod in class. In the same school, a white student with a similar disciplinary history gets detention for using headphones.
- Two middle-schoolers push each other; the white student receives a three-day, in-school suspension, while the native American student is arrested and suspended, out of school, for 10 days.
Civil rights groups have been saying for years that school discipline is not meted out fairly, citing examples like these reported last year from around the country by the US Department of Education.
High rates of suspensions and expulsions for certain groups particularly African-Americans, Hispanics, and those with disabilities are evident in data gathered nationally by the Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights (OCR). - http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Education/2013/0331/School-suspensions-Does-racial-bias-feed-the-school-to-prison-pipeline
In general, I disagree that racial bias has an overall effect in school suspensions and that " school to prison " is an ideological and emotional catch phrase manufactured by the media.
Because there is so much information and incomplete data contained in this article, I'm only going to take only one point to illustrate by objection.
The crux of this article is dependent on 'aggregate data' which is in itself, a warning sign of potential problems.
- It lumps urban school districts where minorities generally live with suburban and rural districts where they are not and where minority attendance is much higher.
- The actual data that this article was based on is obfuscated within the USDE and OCR web sites and not available as one coherent report.
Here is an example of how aggregate data can be deceiving. If you take all the murders in the mid-west cities with populations over 100,000 over the last ten years, it will show an increase in that crime. However, remove Chicago IL from the equation and that crime flat lines. Remove Detroit MI next and the crime of murder shows a decrease. Two cities can skew an entire perspective on hundreds of cities. And so it does with school suspensions, but as there is no way to gauge that in regards to race, one can insinuate whatever one pleases at this point.
While the article does provide food for thought, it is hardly conclusive and inherently flawed.
Tags
Who is online
99 visitors

It may be a case of parental involvement (or lack of it) in a given situation rather than a racial bias. Inequality seems to be more of a financial matter than a racial one in my opinion and can be seen outside of the school system on a regular basis.
O.J. Simpson, Michael Jackson are cases in point, had neither the funds to mount such a defense both would have been incarcerated most likely. As it turns out justice may have prevailed in both instances.
I can definitely say that in the first example the two punishments should be switched. A Ninth Grader definitely knows what he did was wrong. The approx. 5 year old Kindergarten child might know truly understand how wrong it is to set off a fire alarm and should be told. Also not same school so different disciplinarians as well.
The second example, both are wrong but cellphone and an ipod are more wrong than just the headphones but detention and their gear taken away till after detention would of sufficed.
The pushing incident is not enough info, who started it? Being arrested is more than a little overboard, if he/she/they had weapons involved it might of been different.
I think a case of re-education of some teachers may be in order. If teachers cannot be impartial they should not be allowed to teach. All students should be treated equal, if one needs more help with school work than another that is a different issue but in general day to day children should be treated the same regardless of background. Also parents should be part of the disciplinary process as well, work with the school to find the most effective way to deal with what they did that was not acceptable.
I also agree that a lot of these studies are skewed and that the example regarding the murder rate is a good one.
Very interesting and food for thought
I had two unsaid points in posting this;
Also, there are so many other factors that enter into suspensions, making a blanket statement then offering only two choices is at best, disingenuous journalism.