Farmers, Economists, and TV Preachers – They're Just Not Happy, Part 2
So, what other careers lend themselves well to the half-full/half empty conundrum? From my own viewpoint, albeit somewhat skewed, I think that both accountants and economic professors may stake claim to the half-full glass
As yet another fine example, lets look at Mr. Veedermann, the economist/accountant hired by my engineering firm, about half-way through my tenure there. I had always prided myself on bringing a successful project in on time and under budget, but with the addition of Mr. Veedermann, a dark cloud settled over the office. Suddenly, the money we didnt charge was labeled as lost profits, along with other nonsense.
I purposefully overbid the contract, Mr. Veedermann, so that we could make a profit, and get the job done under budget! I explained, when called on the carpet for leaving $1000 on the table on my water supply development project. That way, they may hire us to design the water treatment plant.
Lost profit! Every dollar you leave on the table is lost to us! Ill take that out of your marketing budget! he harrumphed.
But it isnt money that we spent on marketing, Mr. Veedermann. The job made a profit of a 2.4 multiplier! The job was more profitable than any other job in the office! I exclaimed in disbelief. We made 240% profit on the job. Our company standard is 220%! And we spent no money on marketing, they called US !
Harrumph! Lost profit is lost profit! You could have made more profit! he glared at me in disgust. I have to answer to our shareholders! I have a fiduciary responsibility!
But sir, can we calculate how much a higher percentage that $1000 would have made us in profit? I asked in despair.
He fiddled with his calculator, and said, The data isnt available at this time! Just make your projects come in, to the penny! Do you hear me? To. The. Penny. He glared at me, as if to make sure I understood exactly what he was saying. He looked at me, significantly, Your job could depend on it.
At my desk, I calculated what difference the $1000 would have made. It came to a total of 0.005 on the multiplier. About half of a percent. It was at this point, that scientists and economists diverge, at least in my book. I had worked very hard, standing and sweating outside in a cornfield, test drilling in the August heat, balancing the geologic realities with the costs of drilling to bring in a water well of sufficient quantity to meet the citys needs. And this guy cares only about the 0.5% we didnt charge? It was a bloody miracle we found water at all!
Did anyone bother to calculate the degree of goodwill I had left with my satisfied client? Did anyone bother to calculate the odds of finding a ding dang water supply way out in the middle of nowhere with no data and just a hunch? What was an additional $1000? Another 40 feet of drilling? A few bags of mud? My blood began to boil, and in the handwriting on the wall, I could see the end of my term of employment with this company.
It is the same thing today. Remember when prices went up about 20% because gas prices went up 250%? After the cost of gas went down, but the prices of goods in the stores remained 20% higher, the economists wailed and moaned about sticky prices.
Yep, sticky prices are really bad for the economy, in general. Then, as prices dropped just a bit, they wailed and moaned about de-flation and how that is bad for the economy. Folks, you cant have it both ways. But, I guess that is all relative, too. Unfortunately, to these guys, no matter what happens, it is bad for the economy. Their glass is definitely half empty.
Stay tuned for one last fine example of Einsteins theory!
Tags
Who is online
99 visitors

Well, part 2 of my own war on pessimism in business! And other things...
Thanks, y'all, for coming by to see me! And be sure to read, "The Birds, by Daphne du Maurier" -- I spent all afternoon typing it! Please leave a comment if you read it-- I'd really like to know what you think!
It's funny. It's hard to define the way my chosen path looks/views things. I'm a lab tech. I spend much of my time and energy making sure that numbers are accurate. making sure those numbers are as positivelyaccurateas I can be, is all that matters. They may portend bad news or good news depending on the perspective. There aren't 50 shades of gray...there are fifty gazillion.
Eh, we're scientists. We're supposed to be unbiased... Besides, I have to do the same thing. What is, is-- I can't change it. It is what it is.
This comment keeps disappearing. Why, I don't know!!! but ARGHH!
Thanks so much for coming by-- I'd better post before it disappears again!
There isNO better marketing tool than coming in on time and under bid; it's a virtual guarantee of future business, generating profits far in excess of the differential between the bid and the actual. Your Mr. Veedermann is incredibly short-sighted.
He was an A$$. I detested the man, and the whole office had to maintain his 'adjustments'. We lost even the coffee stirrers, which was ridiculous!
Plus, he had no idea how my kind of projects worked. I always, in bidding, gave myself some room as a 'fudge factor'. You never know when you'll hit an erratic, in drilling, and have to pick up and move over 20', losing the hole. I estimated 4 test holes at 260' per hole. It just worked out that I didn't have to drill much deeper than that-- but that was a miracle in itself. I had no idea where bedrock was, no idea what I was getting into, and balancing the costs of the drilling with the costs of the additional mud and polymer needed, and if we needed a larger screen, etc. UGH.
This same fellow spent all of one year's marketing budget on a "Must Have" project-- the design of an airport. We didn't get the job and weren't even in the running for it. Stupid.
I left shortly after that job bombed, simply because I couldn't market my projects, and, without billable hours, I was going to be fired anyway.
Sometimes, when you're placed in impossible situations, it's better to leave and go elsewhere.
Most of the accountants/economists I know are wonderful-- Heaven knows, we need them!
Just a few of them fail to see the big picture. Most farmers and ministers look at the big picture, too, I think-- Just a few of them see the down side to everything.
You hit the nail on the head, I think!
Y'all are REALLY lucky! I'd say, "Realistic".
Unless the relative humidity in the room was 100%.
A concept I believe to be true in every aspect of life.
How about if the glass starts out empty, then you fill it with Scotch, then drink exactly half. Is the glass now half empty, half full, or broken because you dropped it while reaching for the remote so you could change the TV off of that GODAMMED Lifetime channel!
Sorry, lost my train of thought there for a moment.
In guess unless they filled it full and drank 1/2 of it...
Hello.. another accountant here. Minor in economics.
But I came from a family business.
AsCaptainJack said:
Oh so true. And it's our job to make sure that, that profit looks as bad as it can on paper. At least from a cost accounting perspective. Neat tricks like LIFO and FIFO inmanufacturing..depreciationin your line of work. But that is usually understood in the office. We are to minimize the bottom line while staying within the code. That is supposed to make everyone happy!
I almost always used up my fudge factor-- because you can never, ever, tell about drilling. If you hit, you use more mud, you set a screen and casing, it has to be grouted in, ladidadida. If you don't hit, you still have to grout the hole... If you have a day of really bad weather, you can't be out in lightning, but everybody still gets paid something. If you hit an erratic, you had to move over and start again, because hitting a buried erratic could knock the bit over to the side and the hole wouldn't be straight. And on and on and on.
It was a blooming miracle that 1) we hit and 2) I still managed to come in under budget. This IDOT had no idea.
I know you get it-- but a lot of engineers don't. Geology is not like a road bed. It isn't even exactly 8" thick from stem to stern. It's all chance-- no matter how hard you try, you can't be 100% accurate. I've drilled a well, and then moved over 20' to drill a larger test well, and had completely different formations. To where I'd go and check the driller's log and have gamma run to make sure the log was accurate-- and they were. It is just that there was a bend in that ancient river, and I'm on the edge of it. Probably if I'd moved 20' in the other direction, it would have been the same...
The company I worked for specialized in things that, as a geologist, I didn't think was so great... Write the estimate for this or that, but use that or this, to come in at budget... My company, though, I have to say, did NOT do kickbacks. Thank God. I missed a lot of work that way, but I wasn't going to do it. Nobody ever got a new boat out of one of my projects.
Nor yours either, I'm sure!
It happens all the time, in these parts-- Under the table. I could probably tell you tales that would curl your hair... As a geologist, I was able to observe inner workings, but didn't have to partake. Once it was out of the ground, not my doings. I couldn't design a pipe system if my life depended on it. But, I designed wells...
The biggest is that the specs are written, specifying certain pipes, valves, and fittings. It is bid, using inferior product costs, then the contract is awarded to the lower bid. The company then change-orders their way to use the inferior products. If those change-orders don't go through, they still use the products, and since they are the inspectors of the work site, it never gets caught. Sort of like hiring the fox to guard the henhouse.
I KNOW you would never do it. You are honorable . Thank God the company I worked for was honorable. If there were shenanigans, I never knew it.
My jobs were always different, anyway. I never had to bid the engineering part, just the geology...
Thank God.
Geology is like standing on the roof of a 50 story building, that is the size of a street block. All you can see is the pipes that stand up on top, maybe the elevator shaft, or air conditioning unit-- maybe not! Now, find the dermatologist's office. You have no idea where it is-- no floor, no idea how large it might be, but you know it will have a few consultation rooms. You get 4 tries, 4 holes you can punch, like a straw, down to the ground floor. If you hit an air shaft, WRONG, it's not there... Hit the office part? You may be there, but not know it.
That's as close as I can describe it.
Again, I loved it. I understand your viewpoint completely. You, finding water on a hunch, are a genius.
LOL, FAR from genius! Lucky!
They had no idea what all was involved...