╌>

Ed Koch’s Tombstone -- My father is Jewish, my mother is Jewish, I am Jewish

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  13 years ago  •  68 comments

Ed Koch’s Tombstone  -- My father is Jewish, my mother is Jewish, I am Jewish

by Rabbi Benjamin Blech


With the words he chose to be inscribed on his tombstone, Ed Koch, the iconic New York Mayor who passed away last Friday, made it very clear how he wanted most to be remembered.

And they reminded me of a family disagreement in which I had to acknowledge that I was wrong and my daughter was right.

It was a number of years ago when my daughter Tamar was making plans to apply to law school. Having gotten a perfect score on her LSAT exam, the highest mark in the country, she wasnt nervous about getting accepted at one of the top universities. But she knew that an important element that would be considered by the very best schools was the essay she had to submit explaining why she had chosen law as a career and defining herself as a person.

When she told me she had finished writing it, I asked if I might see it. As I began to read it I found myself filled with apprehension. Her opening words were I am an Orthodox Jew. She continued by linking the Jewish love for law with its divine origin at Sinai. She explained that her love for Torah made her seek a way to seek the betterment of the world through a commitment to legal redress for the innocent and lawful punishment for the criminal.

Her presentation was masterful, yet I was afraid. Afraid because I was part of a generation that still bore the emotional scars of centuries of anti-Semitism. Afraid because I had lived through the years of the Holocaust and been forced to leave the land of my birth when a Nazi takeover threatened. Afraid because even though I now live in the land of the free I still didnt feel free enough to believe that my daughter could openly identify herself as an Orthodox Jew without subjecting herself to prejudiced repercussions.

I dont think you should send the essay in the way it is, I advised my daughter. Tamar thought about what I said. Respectfully she concluded she had to be true to herself. She decided that if by identifying herself through her faith she was closing the door to professional advancement, she would rather not enter those portals. And who knows, she added, perhaps the fact that I take pride in my heritage will be viewed as a positive.

Yes, my daughter did get accepted to every one of the top law schools in the country. Now fast forward a decade to learn the real end of the story. I was teaching a class at Yeshiva University when a young man knocked on the door. I immediately recognized him as a former student. Out of breath, he told me he rushed up from Columbia University Law School because he had to share the story of what had just happened in one of his classes.

The conversation had turned into a discussion about the required essays. Someone asked the professor, Now that were in the school, can you tell us what exactly you were looking for in those essays? The professor responded that he couldnt really put it into words but he could only give a general guideline by referencing what he felt was the best essay they had ever received. He recalled that it was written by some girl with a strange last name thats difficult to pronounce something like Blech.

If this is your daughter, my former student said, I knew youd love to hear the story.

I assured him that indeed it was my daughter, and that I was so grateful to him for sharing it with me. I also confessed how I almost messed it up by suggesting to my daughter that it was too dangerous to be submitted as written!

If taking pride in ones identity proved to be helpful rather than hindrance to Tamar, it is certainly instructive to learn how much this trait meant to the former Mayor of New York city.

As the eulogies are offered and the tributes pour in with a lengthy list of Ed Kochs accomplishments, there are so many things the mayor could have been proud of. Yet what Koch chose to stand in perpetuity as a summary of his lifes meaning were the last words of Daniel Pearl before he was brutally murdered by Pakistani terrorists: My father is Jewish, my mother is Jewish, I am Jewish

Two years before his death, in his personal blog in the Huffington Post, Whats On My Tombstone And Why, Koch told his readers that this was what he had prepared to be inscribed as his epitaph. So strongly did he feel about the importance of this recognition for every Jew that he added, I believe those words should be part of the annual services on the Jewish High Holiday of Yom Kippur, and should be repeated by the congregants.

Beneath this powerful expression of identity, Koch commissioned the inscription of the Shema in Hebrew and English followed by these words: "He was fiercely proud of his Jewish faith. He fiercely defended the City of New York and he fiercely defended its people. Above all, he loved his country, the United States of America , in whose armed forces he served in World War II."

Koch did not hesitate to define himself in this sequence a proud Jew, a loving New Yorker and a patriotic American.

In accord with his wishes, the words by his grave express with pride the last words of Daniel Pearl.

Is it merely coincidence then that Ed Koch died on the first day of February, the very day on which Daniel Pearl was murdered exactly 11 years ago?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Is it merely coincidence then that Ed Koch died on the first day of February, the very day on which Daniel Pearl was murdered exactly 11 years ago?

Probably; but, the words "Coincidence is God's way of remaining anonymous" (Albert Einstein) could explain it.

My personal preference for Ed Koch and all others would be this variation

"My father is a decent human being, my mother is a decent human being and I am a decent human being."

The contrived differences in the fundamental identity of humanity that yield the state of mind we call "religion," have caused much grief, mayhem and horrors in the world; better we should unite around our fundamental similarities which are inherent rather than contrived and sold to fearful masses by the power brokers.

In my opinion, any and all acts of love and human kindness could just as well be extended in the total absence of religion

with none of its many downsides.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

A common view -- but it assumes the world was perfect before religion "reared its ugly head," and that assumption is wrong.

It is a long story best told in the book, "Worldperfect; the Jewish Impact on Civilization" by Ken Spiro, link below:

Book description:

In pursuit of an answer to the question of what would constitute a perfect world, author Ken Spiro questioned more than 1,500 people of various backgrounds and religions. His findings revealed six core elements: Respect for human life; peace and harmony; justice and equality; education; family; and social responsibility. He then set off on a journey to find out why these were such common goals across cultural, economic, social and racial lines, and in the process, traced the history of the development of world religions, values and ethics.

As a rabbi, he paid particular attention to how Judaism impacted, and was influenced by, the course of these developments. The result is a highly readable and well-documented book about the origins of values and virtues in Western civilization as influenced by the Greeks, Romans, Christians, Muslims and, most significantly, the Jews.

The history of religion, presented in Spiros highly readable style, is a fascinating and timely subject, especially in todays volatile religious climate. Spiro divides his book into five engaging parts:

  • Where the Quality of Mercy Was Not Strained: The World of Greece and Rome
  • Against the Grain: The Jewish View
  • A Father to Many Nations: Abraham and the Implications of Monotheism
  • With Sword and Fire: The Rise of Christianity and Islam
  • The New Promised Land: Impact of Judaism on Liberal Democracies

Readers of all faiths will find that the elements of a perfect world can only be achieved by a common understanding of our mutual backgrounds and that our diverse religions are all merely branches growing from one single tree.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

it assumes the world was perfect before religion "reared its ugly head," and that assumption is wrong.

I don't believe any reasonable mind thinks the world was ever perfect; if each faith was working individually towards a common understanding, would it not make sense if they did so by assimilating and working as a common entity without guilt-tripping their believers on issues like inter-marriage and others -- issues that separate rather than unite?

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

I guess one's own tombstone is the last place where one can plan to have your last words on any subject. If this is how he saw himself, well, it's his business. Not mine.

I guess on mine, I'd put something like:

Peace! At Last!

Smile.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

The contrived differences in the fundamental identity of humanity that yield the state of mind we call "religion," have caused much grief, mayhem and horrors in the world; better we should unite around our fundamental similarities which are inherent rather than contrived and sold to fearful masses by the power brokers.

In my opinion, any and all acts of love and human kindness could just as well be extended in the total absence of religion

with none of its many downsides.

I would tend to agree.

However, in this case it might not be a case of religious identity, but rather ethnic identity. In a sense, "Jewish" ca have either of two meanings (or both)-- it could also describe a persons' religion, but it could also describe their "ethnic" identity.

Most other ethnic descriptions are not like that. For example, if someone says they are "French"-- obviously that is not a religion. (Most Frenchpeople-persons are Catholic. France used to be considered "a Catholic country". But there's a large Protestant minority, and over 10% of the population is now Muslim. They are all French. So if a person says they are "French" and nothing else, we don't know what religion they are.

"French" is a nationality, obviously not a religion.

Otoh, that person might not choose to say they are French, but that they are "Catholic"(and if that's all they say, we don't know what their nationality is).

"Catholic" is a religion, not a nationality.

But what if a person says they are "Jewish"? Are they describing their religious views and practices-- or their ethnicity? "Jewish" could mean either one. (or both).

I don't know enough about Koch to know which one he was identifying with here. (of course it could've been both).

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

Krish,

If someone calls themself a Jew, there's a pretty strong chance that they're Jewish, no?

Whether their identification is in a synagogue or a bagel joint, they're of the faith.

When they were being marched into the ovens, they were not asked, "Orthodox, conservative or reformed?"

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

You are the one who stated thar religion is responsible for "much grief, mayhem and horrors in the world."

Unfortunately, or fortunately,while there are commonalities between religions, there are also major irreconcilable differences. Judaism, in particular, is not merely a religion but also a nation/people. While the Covenant is open, aspirents must agree to circumcision (for males), immersion in a ritual bath and to commit to taking on the yoke of the commandments.

Intermarriage is fine for someone who has no strong convictions about his religion.It is common for irreligious people from two diffrent religions tointermarry.

But none of this precludes working together on common social/ethical objectives.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

The Jewish people/nation is not ethnically unique or restrictive. There are, of course, the European and middle eastern ethnicities. But there are also black Jews, Asian Jews, etc.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Did you ever see the tombstone on the old maid's grave?

"Who says you can't take it with you?"

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

They weren't asked either.

And when they were blown up in pizzerias, discotheqes, weddings and on buses, they also weren't ID'd as Sephardic, Ashkenazic or any other type of subcategory.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

That is true for a secular person.

You evidently do not understand hoe significant a religious person's identity and practice is to their behavior, very being and outlook towards the world.

It is not an incidental descriptor like being from Peoria.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

One of my friends responded:

"My father is Gentile.

My mother is Gentile.

I am a Jew."

(He is a convert.)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

If someone calls themself a Jew, there's a pretty strong chance that they're Jewish, no?

Yes.

But does it necessarily mean identifying with a religion-- or an ethnic group?

Recently this issue has arisen in an interesting context. When discussing the possibility of peace (Israel/Palestine), the Palestinian leadership (such that it is) has refused to agree to the existence of a Jewish state. Some people agree, because they like the idea of a theocracy.

In many cases they are thinking of other countries in the area who are theocracies (ex: "The Islamic Republic of Iran") and who therefore don't respect the rights of other religions.

However they are making two assumptions:

1. They assume that a "Jewish state", like so many of the Islamic states in the region, would not respect other religions. (Of course even though the Arabs are in denial, Israel is already a Jewish state, and they actually do respect the rights of religious minorities).

2. They also assume that a "Hewish state" means a theocracy-- an official state religion and no other religion allowed. But the meaning of a "Jewish state" is actually not a theocracy-- rather it means the country of the Jewish people--- a "people".. or a "nation".

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

Krish,

Those are specious assumptions, on a number of counts. Calling Israel a Jewish theocracy is like calling India a Hindu theocracy. Both the Jewish and Hindu cultures are proven to be pluralistic, tolerant (and capitalist) cultures. Meanwhile, the Arab nations that are not already 100% Islamic are taking measures to make themselves so. Add another double standard to the list.

Apartheid indeed...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

The Jewish people/nation is not ethnically unique or restrictive. There are, of course, the European and middle eastern ethnicities. But there are also black Jews, Asian Jews, etc.

I was using the term ethnicity" to mean a people with a common identity (not necessarily a a religious identity).

Here's the newest Ms Israel:

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I once knew a guy who was half Scotch-- and half water Grin.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Intermarriage is fine for someone who has no strong convictions about his religion.It is common for irreligious people from two diffrent religions tointermarry.

But none of this precludes working together on common social/ethical objectives.

Indeed it does preclude working together; when religious dogmas interfere with the love of individuals who wish i.e. to marry -- by guilt-tripping, coercion, and, as in Orthodox Judaism, MOURNING AS IF DEAD, the individuals who marry outside the faith, that is no royal road to common objectives!

Unfortunately, or fortunately,while there are commonalities between religions, there are also major irreconcilable differences.

They are only "irreconcilable" because the religious power-broker/establishment declares them so and enforces such hideous declarations though fear and sanctions. Because someone drops out of a womb labeled by a religion -- that's a reason for built in irreconcilable differences?

THEY ARE CONTRIVED and perpetuated by fear, dogma and superstition.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Len>>But none of this precludes working together on common social/ethical objectives.

>>Indeed it does preclude working together; when religious dogmas interfere with the love of individuals who wish i.e. to marry -- by guilt-tripping, coercion, and, as in Orthodox Judaism, MOURNING AS IF DEAD, the individuals who marry outside the faith, that is no royal road to common objectives!

I was not referring to an interreligiousmarried couple working together but to people in general. For example,a book of conversations between Pope Francis, then-Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio, and Argentinian Rabbi Abraham Skorka will be published in English in May.

Len>>Unfortunately, or fortunately,while there are commonalities between religions, there are also major irreconcilable differences.

>>They are only "irreconcilable" because the religious power-broker/establishment declares them so and enforces such hideous declarations though fear and sanctions.

There is the guy who said, "I don't belong to an organized religion. I'm Jewish." That joke is not a joke. Religious affiliation is voluntary and there are no brokers, rabbis or establishment twisting my arm. You have a grotesque view more typical of the time of the Inquisition than today.

>>Because someone drops out of a womb labeled by a religion -- that's a reason for built in irreconcilable differences?

An example of airreconcilable difference is a Christian's belief that one can come to God only through Jesus whereas, for a Jew, there is no middle man. This does not prevent both from working together to oppose Obama's forcing Catholic institutions to distribute contraceptives.

>>THEY ARE CONTRIVED and perpetuated by fear, dogma and superstition.

Nonsense! Belief is by intellectual conviction of the truth of one's religion and a religion generally includes rules just as any other organization. Dogma is what political zealots follow.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

lol!

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Great example! Thanks.

Ethnicity virtually always is a racial or physicalterm. I have never heard it used as you describe it. But I just looked it up and your definition is admissible.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

I cannot top that.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

You have a grotesque view more typical of the time of the Inquisition than today.

Actually, the Inquisition was a variation on the theme of religious dogma -- a most extreme variation but nevertheless, one that exemplifies the inherent dangers of blind faith and the-fear-of-God implanted into the believers by the power brokers.

It is religious dogma and doctrine that often require differences to be irreconciliable, that in order to keep the faithful from thinking for themselves and rendering the clergy irrelevant.

Belief is by intellectual conviction of the truth of one's religion and a religion generally includes rules just as any other organization. Dogma is what political zealots follow.

Not religious "beliefs" -- those are by edict and dictates and often include expressed or implied punishments for failure to adhere to them. Religious beliefs are the antithesis of intellectual conviction because they are imposed through fear and guilt and so-called "education" rather than acquired by intellectual pursuit of the truth and empirical information.

We clearly disagree, Len, but this is a good debate.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

"God is dead." -- Nietzsche

"Nietzsche is dead!" -- God

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

The bush that burned, but was not consumed, was a metaphor for the Israelite nation which would be burned in every generation but survive and excel with God's help.

The empires that burned Israel have all disappeared but Israel survives.

That, according to one person, is proof of God's existence.

Feel the flash of holy awe yet?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Feel the flash of holy awe yet?

There is more "evidence" of the existence of a "Creator" in a single leaf than in any/all of the institutions that segregate groups of humans in His name.

7118_discussions.jpg?width=721 A. Mac

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

If God created us perfectly we would be programmed robots, not humans, and deserve no credit for being perfect.

There is a parable that when God decided to give the Torah to Israel the angels protested.

"Why give it to them? They will not follow it and just screw things up."

God replied: "The Torah says, 'Be fruitful and multiply.' You cannot do that. It says, 'You shall eat and be satisfied.' You cannot eat. It says, 'When you sin, you shall repent.' You never sin. So, no, thanks. I will stick to My original plan."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

If a single leaf impresses you how much more so should a forest, the variety of life, the complexity of humanity and the universe?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

If God created us perfectly we would be programmed robots, not humans, and deserve no credit for being perfect.

Religiosity/religion exploits that concept to dictate to and frighten the masses as it sets itself up as "knowing what God wants and what God will do to them" if they don't play by the so-called "rules."

Religion tries endlessly to make us "programmed robots" and warns us against being too human.

"Unthinking respect for authority is the greatest enemy of truth."(Albert Einstein)

Einstein also said

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

The same God!

The Talmud asks, "Why did the Torah begin with Adam and Eve?" and responds, "So no one can say, 'My ancestors are better than yours.'"

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

If a single leaf impresses you how much more so should a forest, the variety of life, the complexity of humanity and the universe?

Len, how could you not understand that all those entities were implied?

And if the complexity of humanity and the universe is God's design, is he not offended by the religionists that try to thwart the complexity of the human mind and pigeon hole it into segregated houses of worship?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Thanks for your intelligent input.

I am not home now and will respond later; not a vow.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>the Inquisition was a variation on the theme of religious dogma -- a most extreme variation but nevertheless, one that exemplifies the inherent dangers of blind faith and the-fear-of-God implanted into the believers by the power brokers.

I will be the last person to rationalize the inquisition, or Crusades, or jihad.

Abusers of religion do not invalidate the idea any more than we should close the medical schools because of renegade doctors. As a Jew, somewhat familiar with the Bible and Jewish philosophy, I assure you that Judaismopposes violence, injustice, other evil, racial superiority, sexism androbotic thought.

What God wants of us most of all is to treat each other with consideration and kindness. A sin against a person is considered worse than one against God because it is a double sin; against both the person AND God.

As Psalm 118 says, "Thank the Lord for He is good. His lovingkindness is forever."

And the shortest psalm (117), in its entirety:

"Praise the Lord, all nations. Acclaim Him All you peoples. For His lovingkindness to us is strong, and His faithfulness is everlasting."

>>It is religious dogma and doctrine that often require differences to be irreconciliable, that in order to keep the faithful from thinking for themselves and rendering the clergy irrelevant.

You cannot hold any religion responsible for errors in others; or require it to reconcile with those errors. God created us with free will.

Len>>Belief is by intellectual conviction of the truth of one's religion and a religion generally includes rules just as any other organization. Dogma is what political zealots follow.

>>Not religious "beliefs" -- those are by edict and dictates and often include expressed or implied punishments for failure to adhere to them. Religious beliefs are the antithesis of intellectual conviction because they are imposed through fear and guilt and so-called "education" rather than acquired by intellectual pursuit of the truth and empirical information.

Religion ideallyreveals the truth -- a truth higher than that created by fallible humans. It is analogous to, in the great philosopher Emanuel Kant's words, "the categorocal imperative." Kant, though a non-believer,considered this higher than fallible empirical knowledge.

There is nothing wrong with reasonable fear and guilt. Proverbs says, "Fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom. Fools despise wisdom and discipline." (1:7) Governmnts prescribe punishment for infractions. Why should religion be different?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I assure you that Judaismopposes violence, injustice, other evil, racial superiority, sexism androbotic thought.

I think Orthodox Jewish women might view their second-class status somewhat differently. Ditto the son in the Haggadah who is labeled as "wicked" or "evil" because he dares to question before deciding how he believes. And the daughters are not even mentioned in "The Four Questions" in terms as to how they view the meaning of Passover and the seder.

Governmnts prescribe punishment for infractions. Why should religion be different?

And governments that are run by religions are usually brutal and tyrannical. Look what's happening in America because of pandering to the religious right -- all manner of legislation for the common good is down the toilet.

Religion ideallyreveals the truth -- a truth higher than that created by fallible humans.

And what makes the humans in the clergies any less fallible than the rest of us ignorant schmucks? Nothing! The fear they promote as coming through them form a "higher" source frightens the fearful masses into believing. It's insidious in the name of God, to derive power and status by portraying Him as vindictive.

Reality is an insecure place and religions literally and figuratively exploit that phenomenon.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

A nearly universal rule among almost all religions in some form or another.

Don't forget atheists and agnostics - we like that expression too. However, it does have it's limitations, so it's hard to claim it as the most unifying expression there is. Afterall, we all have unique tastes, and different cultures have wildly different traditions and practices. For example, an Islamist may be more concerned about whathappens to them inthe afterlife than what happens to them in this life, which isprecisely how they become so readily recruited for suicide bombing missions. I don't wish to have them rationalize any interaction with me by using the golden rule.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>I think Orthodox Jewish women might view their second-class status somewhat differently.

This reply is out of order because there was no "Reply" link under your message.

You are wrong about Orthodox women. I am surprised you write this after reading the seed articleabout the proudly Orthodox, and highly accomplished, daughter of Rabbi Blech. You may be thinking of the liberal-women's view of Orhodox women which, like many liberal ideas, is also wrong. In my Orthodox congregation we have women who are physicians, psychologists, lawyers, programmers, human-resources managers, as well as wives and mothers. They are as happy as the men.

>>Ditto about he son in the Haggadah who is labeled as "wicked" or "evil" because he dares to question before deciding how he believes.

For a gentile, you know lots about Judaism, albeit a distorted view. You also have this wrong. If you read the Haggadah, you will see that he is not labled as wicked because he dares to question. The wise and simple children also question. The difference is that the wicked child asks in a scornful, challenging manner as if he is withdrawing and disassociating himself from the group.

>>And the daughters are not even mentioned in "The Four Questions" in terms as to how they view the meaning of Passover and the seder.

What are you talking about? Sex is not mentioned in the Four Questions.

A little learning is a dangerous thing.

Len>>Governmnts prescribe punishment for infractions. Why should religion be different?

>>And governments that are run by religions are usually brutal and tyrannical. Look what's happening in America because of pandering to the religious right -- all manner of legislation for the common good is down the toilet.

How is the "religious right" "brutal and tyrranical?" How does the government "pander" to it? Your hyperbole is over the edge. If you talk of some Islamic nations you have my agreement. What you may consider the "common good" is debatable even by non-religious people.

While Israel is not a theocracy it has democratic values. Even in the ancient Jewish commonwealths, if one person was executed by the Sanhedrin in over 90 years, it was considered a cruel court.

Len>>Religion ideallyreveals the truth -- a truth higher than that created by fallible humans.

>>And what makes the humans in the clergies any less fallible than the rest of us ignorant schmucks? Nothing! The fear they promote as coming through them form a "higher" source frightens the fearful masses into believing. It's insidious in the name of God, to derive power and status by portraying Him as vindictive.

Clergy may be fallible but, speaking for my own religion,the source documents are far more reliably true than works of humans; even recognizing that some of them contain parables, folkloreand disagreements. "The seal of God is truth. (Talmud Sabbath 55a)"

>>Reality is an insecure place and religions literally and figuratively exploit that phenomenon.

Politicians do also.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

I do not know anyone who is frightened. Do you?

You keep coming up with outlandish assertions.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>if the complexity of humanity and the universe is God's design, is he not offended by the religionists that try to thwart the complexity of the human mind and pigeon hole it into segregated houses of worship?

Complexity does not mean disorganized randomness: and houses of worship are not segregated. You are welcome to visit mine.

The Orthodox Maimonides scholar, Rabbi David Hartman, has written, Maimonides (Rambam) believed that man is incapable of having positive knowledge of God. (Maimonides: Torah and the Philosophic Quest, Pg. xiii). Hartman states Rambams attitude towards authority as follows:

A religious tradition which insists on uncritical subservience to its norms of behavior an beliefs tends to generate a specific human type which, in many ways, is incompatible with an intellectual love of God. --- The individual guided by reason would find himself isolated within the community which demanded an uncritical acceptance of its beliefs (ibid. Pg.102).

Rambam cautioned that there are limits to philosophy, and tradition has always recognized the difference between arguments from authority and arguments from reason: If you do not deceive yourself into believing that there is a demonstration for matters that have not been demonstrated; --- If you do not aspire to apprehend that which you are unable to apprehend, you will have achieved human perfection ---(The Guide, I, 32).

Rambam, like Nachmanides, believed in creation, ex nihilo. In reference to the universe --- scripture employs the verb, bara, which we explain as denoting He produced something from nothing (The Guide, II, 30). Once an individual admits that miracles are possible, as Rambam does by accepting the doctrine of creation, then, from a strictly logical perspective, it makes no difference whether he admits one or 1000 miracles (Hartman, Pg.158).

Allegiance to community, and to its recognized authorities, may be the source of mans understanding of the world and of God if it can be shown that tradition-based convictions are never in discord with the proven truths of reason (Hartman, Pg. 123). Even absent these sources, however, Abraham rejected the teachings of his father and milieu solely on the convictions which he gained through reason. --- Reason not only provides Abraham with demonstrative knowledge of God but is also the source of his attack on idol worship. --- By reflecting on nature one comes to realize that, without recognizing God as the source of existence, the universe is unintelligible (ibid, P 58).

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>Except that Adam and Eve were the progenitors of specifically Jews.

You need a course in Religion 101 as you are totally wrong here.

Adam and Eve were the first modern humans and everone is descended from them including people of all races. They were not Jews. More recently we are all descended from Noah as other humanity perished in the great flood. Noah also was not a Jew.

The Torah tells us of three covenants made by God. The first, made after the flood, was with all humanity; Jews didn't exist yet (Gen. 9:1-17). In exchange for man's observance of the Noahide covenant God would never flood the entire world again. This covenant stipulates the Seven Noahide laws.

In the second covenant, made with Abraham, God promised, "to make you a great nation ... to bless them that bless you and curse them that curse you; and in you *ALL* the families of the earth shall be blessed." This blessing incorporates the principle that the Lord of Israel is also the Lord of the world. The covenant with Abraham, like that with Noah, is also for the benefit of ALL humanity.

The third covenant was with Israel. This covenant involved the giving of the Torah on Mt. Sinai (Exod. 19:1-8) At this time God told Moses to say to Israel, "You have seen what I did to Egypt, how I bore you on eagles' wings and brought you to Me. Now then, if you hearken to My voice indeed and keep My covenant, you shall be My treasured possession among all peoples. Indeed, ALL THE EARTH IS MINE, but you shall be to Me a kingdom of priests and a holy nation." (Exod. 19:4-6)

God selected and delivered the Jews, and gave us the Torah to educate us. But while He did all this for our benefit it was NOT ONLY for our benefit. "... all the earth is Mine, but you shall be to Me a kingdom of priests and a holy nation." Like the other covenants this one has a strong UNIVERSALISTIC component. We were chosen NOT for privilege but for DUTY; to set an example. "It is not because you are the most numerous of peoples ... indeed you are least of the nations ... (Deut. 7:7)."

The Revelation at Sinai is the historic midpoint between creation and redemption. The Torah is our road map; a guide to facilitate the constructive outcome of this journey.

God, in His wisdom, has assigned roles to different entities just as, in a family, each member has a different role. The husband is not any better than the wife just because he may work outside full time while she works inside full time and a half. I do not call Judaism a family because, if it were, it would be closed to outsiders; yet the Covenant is open. While we do not prosyletize, anyone is welcome to join, if they are willing to assume the yoke of Torah. A convert and a born jew are exactly on the same level.

Christians, Muslims and others should know that, The Lord is close to *all* who call Him, to all who call Him sincerely. He fulfills the wishes of those who fear Him; He hears their cry and delivers them. The Lord watches over *all* who love him, but all the wicked He will destroy. My mouth shall utter the praise of The Lord, and all creatures shall bless His holy Name forever and ever. (Ps. 145:18-21)

As Rabbi Yitz Greenberg has written, The [Jewish] covenant is potentially a model for an absolute commitment that does not deny the validity of other commitments and religions. It is a model of tremendous importance in this age when the growth of communication and power has created a unitary world in which one has to reconcile absolutes through pluralism or risk all-out collision and destruction. (The Jewish Way, Pg. 71, Summit Books Div., Simon and Schuster, 1988)

And from Rabbi David Hartman: "I do not argue against the viability of secular humanism. Nor do I claim that a system of ethics must be founded on the authority of divine revelation. Nor is the viability of Judaism established through a critique of other faith postures. The discussion of Judaism is always internal to the Jewish experience and in no way pretends to show how Judaism or the Jewish people are unique or superior to other faith communities.

"I argue strongly for the significance of Jewish particularity, not for its uniqueness. The covenantal election of Israel at Sinai ... should not be understood as implying a metaphysical claim regarding the ontological uniqueness of the Jewish people. I do not subscribe to the view that a serious commitment to the God of Israel and Torah requires one to believe that the Jewish people mediate the only authentic way for the worship of God... I only explicate a way in which the tradition can encourage a spiritual direction through its emphasis on the covenental relationships of Israel with God." ("A Living Covenant -- The Innovative Spirit of Traditional Judaism," Pgs. 3-4, The Free Press, a division of Macmillan, 1985)

We are a people with a covenant, though this people includes folks of all races, and those who convert in are considered as if they were present at Sinai. As a people, we consider history and community as well as theology and philosophy. Obviously, someone converting in needs to accept the theology and philosophy.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

For a gentile, you know lots about Judaism, albeit a distorted view. You also have this wrong. If you read the Haggadah, you will see that he is not labled as wicked because he dares to question. The wise and simple children also question. The difference is that the wicked child asks in a scornful, challenging manner as if he is withdrawing and disassociating himself from the group.

You'd be surprised what I know about Judaism.

The "wicked" son is labeled thus because he excludes himself from the dogmas when questioning ... he does not ask "why do we," rather, why do "you". He is not necessarily disassociating, rather inquiring about what he has dogmatically been expected to accept without objective scrutiny. He is deemed "wicked" by the insecurity of those who need validation without questioning.

How is the "religious right" "brutal and tyrranical?" How does the government "pander" to it?

With so many being simultaneously pro-life, pro-gun, pro-war, pro-torture, pro-death penalty, anti-environment, anti-social safety net -- connect the dots. But you misrepresent what I wrote; I ascribed the brutality and tyranny to governments controlled by religions. You made the conflation, not I

Governmnts prescribe punishment for infractions. Why should religion be different?

What are you talking about? Sex is not mentioned in the Four Questions.

Only SONS are identified in the Four Questions; there is no mention as to what daughters think or feel or what they ask/question.

Clergy may be fallible but, speaking for my own religion,the source documents are far more reliably true than works of humans; even recognizing that some of them contain parables, folkloreand disagreements. "The seal of God is truth. (Talmud Sabbath 55a)"

There is no verification of such reliability; the Talmud is a work of man.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I do not know anyone who is frightened. Do you?

Then why atone for anything and do so in large numbers on Yom Kippur, attendance numbers not seen in most synagogues on even the Sabbath?

And why did Michelangelo paint his Last Judgement on the back wall of the Sistine Chapel as opposed to the traditional above the altar? I'll tell you why in order that those leaving the mass would see a vision of hell as the last thing they'd see on the way out.

Fear and religion are inseparable and guilt.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Len>>I do not know anyone who is frightened. Do you?

>>Then why atone for anything and do so in large numbers on Yom Kippur, attendance numbers not seen in most synagogues on even the Sabbath?

It is exactly the possibility of atonement that precludes being frightened. If there were no possibility of such we would indeed have reason to be frightened.

>>And why did Michelangelo paint his Last Judgement on the back wall of the Sistine Chapel as opposed to the traditional above the altar? I'll tell you why in order that those leaving the mass would see a vision of hell as the last thing they'd see on the way out.
Fear and religion are inseparable and guilt.

Perhaps Christians had doubt about the efficacy of belief in Jesus as removing sin. BTW, Michalangelo was anti-Catholic and was forced to do his Sistine Chapel art. While not a Jew he encoded lots of Jewish ideas into his painting.

The very same Rabbi Blech, who wrote the seed article here, has written a book on this subject.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

flameaway, I could say the same thing about my Grandfather, but that wouldn't be true. He was one of the loveliest people I have ever known, but he wasn't God. Smile.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

It is exactly the possibility of atonement that precludes being frightened. If there were no possibility of such we would indeed have reason to be frightened.

It does if you approach it as a form of collective confession that actually asks/hopes to be "Inscribed in the Book of Life" for another year. I'd say there's a bit of fear in such a request.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>It does if you approach it as a form of collective confession that actually asks/hopes to be "Inscribed in the Book of Life" for another year. I'd say there's a bit of fear in such a request.

While Jews afflict themselves on Yom Kippur (You shall afflict yourself. Lev. 16:29-31, 23:27-32) with a 25-hour fast and spending virtually all day, 10 hours,in prayer, it is not a sad day; not the saddest of the year. That day is the 10th day of the lunar month of Av, which is used for another 25-hour fast and on which we mourn the destruction of the temples.

During the ten-day period from Rosh Hashana through Yom Kippur, also known as the Days of Awe, or Days of Repentance, Jews focus on their personal behavior. They perform Khesh-bon hanefesh, literally an accounting (or audit) of the soul.

Tradition dictates that each person act as if he were on trial for deeds of the prior year, and that his life hung in the balance. This state could lead to panic were it not for their conviction that God, at once King and Judge of the universe, is merciful and gracious; that He desires, not the death of the wicked, but a sincere change in direction that leads to life. Life is a major theme of the season. By confronting the prospect of his mortality, the Jew becomes more thankful for life, and sensitive to the importance of using it wisely.

The first step of repentance is, as you said, "collective confession" of sins.

During Yom Kippur services confession is in the plural. We have done such and such. The principle is that all Jews are responsible for one another. On Yom Kippur the public declaration comprehensively lists sins in Hebrew alphabetical order from aleph to tav (a to z) in both a short-form (one word successively for each sin) and long-form confession (a sentence for each).

...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confession_in_Judaism#Al_Cheyt.2C_the_...

Both the short and long versions are recited over half a dozen times on Yom Kippur. That is partly why it is a 10-hour service on a 25-hour fast day.

All the above is in addition to other Yom Kippur general prayers and hymns for forgiveness, and in addition to requests for forgiveness that we make at each of the three weekday services all year long.

Again I emphasize that Yom Kippur is not a sad day and we are confident, not frightened, that our appeal will be accepted. It is a dialectical event that can be appreciated only when it is experienced.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>You understand that I don't consider the Torah an unimpeachable source, right? This does not mean I dismiss it's value as a historical document or the philosophy evident within it's text. It's actually quite beautiful. Like math or philosophy or anything that organizes complexity.

Why am I not surprised:-? There is lots of evidence of its historical accuracy; archaeological findings, DNA studies. The very level of detail included concerning genealogy, geography, architectural details in chapter after chapter gives credence to its reliability as history. Why would a mythmaker, when writing and preservation was excruciatingly difficult, want to put so much detail in a scroll? Who would want to take so much care to preserve it generation after generation, if they did not believe if from tradition?

>>First it is impossible for the evident 'racial' characteristics to have developed in the time frame referenced by the Judeo/Christian tradition. That type of selection doesn't happen in a few centuries it happensin tens of thousands of years in isolation.

What is your source for these assertions? What race were Adam and Eve; Noah? The Bible does not say this or tll the race of most of its characters. How do you know it is "tens of thousands" vs. simply thousands? After the time of the Tower of Babel the people were scattered and different languages developed. The racial divisions were present in Moses' and Solomon's time because there are references to Black people. Moses' wife was Black, the Queen of Sheba was Black and the Tribe of Dan was Black.

>>Of course then you have the problem of Noah or Uta-Napishti from the epic of Gilgamesh. Because according to myth everyone is actually descended from this guy and his wife, not Adam and Eve. That means that the 'racial' distinctions had even less time to come into being.

Gilgamesh is clearly myth but the myth could be a greatly distorted version of the actual flood. Again, the Bible does not say what Noah's race was.

>>I merely disagree that God need be included in those contributions, even though I recognize that you will consider that a vast contradiction.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>I merely disagree that God need be included in those contributions, even though I recognize that you will consider that a vast contradiction.

Norman Lamm, former president of Yeshiva University, wrote, For many --- God is irrelevant, and secularism triumphant ---. However, for many others the will to believe is alive, but not the commensurate ability to believe. Such people are intelligent and concerned ---.

Since Kant, we do not accept the validity of the classical proofs of Gods existence ---. Faith is therefore accepted in its narrower, theological sense as religious faith. Lamm discusses various kinds of faith. He says that cognitive faith is not an abstract, static acknowledgement of truth; it is a violent struggle in the attainment of [truth]. I begin by believing despite doubt; I end by believing all the more firmly because of doubt.

"Faith is thus a dialectic process, not an established fact an inner encounter between yes and maybe, between the exclamation point and the question mark. --- The truth which faith affirms is not given to us for the price of mere assent; it is the prize for which we must engage in a fierce intellectual struggle. Doubt becomes, not an impediment, but a goad to reinvestigate and deepen cognitive faith assertions. --- The path to the knowledge of God is strewn with the rocks and boulders of doubt; he who would despair of the journey because of the fear of doubt, must resign himself forever from attaining the greatest prize known to man.

Lamm then asks the question, Can God doubt? Does he sometimes oscillate between affirmation and denial? Now, of course, I do not mean to ask if God believes in God. --- The question is legitimate and valid in the affective and truest sense when the object of the Divine concern is man. The drama of human existence is predicated upon the divine grant of freedom to man. --- The built-in risks of an ethically autonomous being are imiplied in the symbolic homiletic parable about the debates between the Heavenly hosts as to whether such a creation ought to take place. The deadlock among the angels was broken by Gods vote in favor of the creation of man. He knew man might fail; yet was willing to take His chances on man. God had, or has, faith in man. --- But faith always implies the possibility of doubt. If, then, God has faith in man, He can also doubt man. [Biblical evidence: Adam and Eve, the generation of the flood, the Golden Calf, etc.] Is Gods trust vindicated?

This then is how our own doubts may be transcended, if even for a fleeting moment, which may be worth all eternity: by the realization that we may well be the objects of Gods doubt.The fullness of faith may be attained when, instead of doubting God, we come to the sudden and terrible awareness that God may be doubting us; that our human existence has yet to be affirmed by God who may not be convinced of its worth; that God may have lost faith in us because we have betrayed Him. That must be the focus of our concern.

What a tragic fate! - to be tossed between the torment of doubting God and the terror of being doubted by Him. The way of the faithful Jew in this last [part] of the 20th century is not an easy one. Not for him is the facile peace of mind of those for whom religion is but a psychological crutch; nor for him is the perverse security of the nihilist who has resigned himself to utter, hopeless meaninglessness. His way is not easy - but it is sublime, and it is sacred. He risks the bitter waters of faith --- but he knows he must persist in love until there will shine on him the light of the King of all life. in the words which the profound Spanish philosopher, Miguel de Unamuno, concluded his masterpiece, The Tragic Sense of Life:' --- and may God deny you peace but give you glory!'

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Why would a mythmaker, when writing and preservation was excruciatingly difficult, want to put so much detail in a scroll? Who would want to take so much care to preserve it generation after generation, if they did not believe if from tradition?

Why would a fiction writer or film maker do the very same? To convince, impress and do so for posterity perhaps. I'm not saying that all "sacred scrolls" are fiction, but I don't think we can rule out editorial embellishments especially when asking the masses to accept on faith. There's an inherent conflict-of-interests when it comes to religion and its insiders.

Regarding Adam and Eve first it was the two of them, then the sons then off goes the banished Cain to the Land of Nod and suddenly we find all those other folk.

Gaps.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

There is no Reply link next to your latest message so I am replying ouit of order.

You are not at fault. I have been in your shoes and was dragged into belief kicking and screaming. I say "belief" and not knowledge because we cannot know for sure. While you could therefore call me "agnostic" one cannot live in an unstable agnostic milieu. It has to be living either like a believer on nonbeliever. I gradually transitioned from the latter to the former.

The secret is study. The Talmud says, "An ignoramus (religiously speaking) cannot be pioius." For me that means the Tanakh (Old Testament), commentaries and books on Jewish philosophy. That dooes not mean I no longer have doubts but, as the Lamm article I posted says, I believe notwithstanding those doubts.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The Talmud says, "An ignoramus (religiously speaking) cannot be pioius."

That to me reflects a conflict-of-interests. It's organized Religion deriding those who might not embrace organized religion.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Out of order again (no Reply link)but here is my reply to a later post of yours:

Len>>Why would a mythmaker, when writing and preservation was excruciatingly difficult, want to put so much detail in a scroll? Who would want to take so much care to preserve it generation after generation, if they did not believe if from tradition?

>>Why would a fiction writer or film maker do the very same? To convince, impress and do so for posterity perhaps. I'm not saying that all "sacred scrolls" are fiction, but I don't think we can rule out editorial embellishments especially when asking the masses to accept on faith. There's an inherent conflict-of-interests when it comes to religion and its insiders.

First of all, many of the things in the Bible have been verified. For example, I think you know that all Cohens/those malesof the Priestly tribe, are descended from Aaron. But what you don't know is that DNA studies have shown that, of those who identify as Cohens today, over 90% share a gene marker that has been traced to a common ancestor, likely Aaron. Of non-Cohens, a far smaller percentage share this marker. The chances of these findings happening at random is greater than one in 10,000.

The foundation of Judaism is a mesorah -- a national historical tradition based on the fact that every Jew alive at the time of the revelation at Sinai personally experienced Gd speaking to the assembled Jewish nation. It was not miracles, but the unbroken 3300-year transmission of this experience, which stands as the single greatest demonstration of the truth of Judaisms claim that God gave the Torah to the Jews and, through them, to the entire world.

Our ability to verify historical accounts is based on various kinds of evidence, the most important being the number of eyewitnesses. Based on the standard of the number of eyewitnesses, we can divide historical claims into four categories:

Type A: Personal Experience of One Person. If the claimed event actually occurred the individual would have been the only eyewitness. The claim to historical validity would rest solely on his testimony (as in the movie, Contact).

The atheistic heroine has a "conversion" at the end,
when she finds herself having had a 'mystical' (but real) experience that no one believes, because she cannot provide evidence.

Type B: Small Groups Experiencing an Event: The number could be anywhere from two to a thousand.

Type C: Events Experienced by Large Numbers: Requires a very large number, roughly 50 thousand or more, to witness the event. Only this type of claim has even the possibility of being a national historical claim. The greater the number, the greater the veracity.

Type D: Events Witnessed by an Entire Nation.

Which type is most believable and makes the most sense? Type A claims are completely unverifiable. Type B claims are clearly better than Type A although they are still inferior to Type C. The claims of Christianity are in the B class with the numbers who witnessed miraculous events claimed as being up to 500.

Type C claims have myriad numbers of witnesses and must be taken seriously. Moreover, when an event is part of a nations history, it will soon become an unquestioned national historical fact since so many will be testifying and telling their children about it. These kinds of events constitute what is commonly known as history. If a person tried to make a Type C claim for a fictitious event he would have great difficulty getting hundreds of thousands of people to believe that there were eyewitnesses to events that never actually happened. The Holocaust is in this class. There are many Holocaust deniers but they are dismissed because there are simply too many witnesses.

The Type D claim is the most robust kind; the easiest kind to verify. If true, then everyone in the national group will know it at the deepest level of knowledge, since everyone (of that generation) was actually a witness. The next generation will also know the event occurred both because their own parents, direct eyewitnesses, told them, and because everyone else in the nation is either a direct eyewitness or the offspring of one. It is hard to imagine such an event passing from the nations memory even hundreds or thousands of years later.

How would it be possible to fool an entire nation into believing that they experienced something that never happened or which had been completely misrepresented? How could they all be so completely fooled so as to transmit the story of the event to their children generation after generation without others denying the historicity?

Judaism is the only religion that is based on a verifiable claim in the above sense. All other religions claims are not so verifiable, being based on Type A claims. The Jewish historical tradition has been preserved and passed down through written records or oral traditions that have been fully accepted as true by the nation itself. In addition, independent corroberation and archeological evidence both lend strength to the historical claims, though neither are prerequisites for reliable verification. The Revelation at Sinai is at least as verifiable as any other major event in ancient history.

Judaism, among all the worlds religions, attributes no significance to claims of miracles as a basis for its truth. For the Jew the fact that Christianity claims that Jesus performed miracles, in front of small groups, has absolutely no bearing on the religion at all. Maimonides wrote, ... Israel did not believe in Moses ... because of the miracles he performed. For when ones faith is based on miracles, a lurking doubt always remains that it is possible these miracles were performed through [magic tricks.] Moses performed his miracles because they were necessary, and not as proof of his prophecy... What then is the basis of Jewish faith? The Revelation at Sinai which we saw with our own eyes, and heard with our own ears, not having to depend on the testimony of others ... and therefore [the Torah] says, Face to face Gd spoke with you (the Jewish people).

Maimonides then sets forth the fundamental principle of the historical argument:

The Revelation at Sinai itself is the sole proof that Moses prophecy (the entire Torah) is truth... Before this event they did not believe with a faith that would have endured forever, but only with a belief that would have eventually been followed by doubt and suspicion.

Not a single other religion makes a Type D claim . Virtually every other aspect of the Torah has been borrowed or copied by the Gentile world: circumcision, ritual bath (baptism), dietary restrictions, Sabbath and the Sabbatical year. Modern western social and legal systems are largely based on Torah foundations. Social equality, criminal justice, charity, brotherhood, labor laws, fair-wage guidelines, and loving ones naighbor are all derived from this 3300-year-old Torah.

One thing that has *not* been lifted by other religions, either directly or with modification, is the foundation of the system; the idea of a Type D Revelation to the entire Jewish people, the idea described in Duet. 4 as follows:

Even if you inquire about times long ago, going back to the time that Gd created man on earth ... has anything as great as this has ever happened, or has the like of it ever been known? Has any people ever heard Gd speaking out of the fire, as you have, and survived [to tell about it.] Has Gd ever ventured to bring one nation out of the midst of another with such tremendous miracles, signs, wonders, war, a mighty hand and outstreched arm, and terrifying phenomena, as Gd did for you in Egypt before your very eyes? You are the ones who have been shown; so that you will know that Gd is the Supreme Being, and that there is none besides Him. From the heavens you heard His voice disciplining you, and on earth He showed you His great fire, and that you heard His words from the fire. (Deut.4:32-36)"

The Torah is making two distinct claims in the Deut. quote: First that the entire Jewish nation heard Gd speak at Mt. Sinai (50 days after the Exodus). Second that no other nation, throughout history, can make this claim; either in the past or in the future.

Before analyzing the veracity of these claims consider: If God were to introduce Himself to a large group of people, and establish a permanent religion, which method would make more sense: to transmit it directly to each and every person individually or to transmit it to a prophet who would relay the message? Obviously the former is the more credible means.

Inasmuch as a national revelation is the best way to begin a religion, why is it that Judaism, among the thousands of religions, is *unique* in making this claim? Furthermore let us assume that the Torah was written by a human author, forging the document in Gods Name. As the forger predicted that no one else would make this claim, the best claim, why did he think that others could not similarly make such a claim?

There are two possible instances when the Torah could have been given: either at Mt. Sinai as the Torah itself claims, or at any other time. Consider the first instance!

Assume that Moses and a committee went up the mountain and spent 40 days inventing the Torah. Then they returned and presented it to the nation. What would have happened next?

Where did you get that? the Israelites would ask. It says right in here that God gave it to *all of us.* Moses would answer. Clearly this is a hard sell. It is hard for a small group to lie about the experience of an entire nation. Even bible critics do not claim that Moses put forth a false claim like this.

Suppose that the Torah was given at a later date. Let us say that Ezra the scribe or King Josiah appeared a thousand years after the alleged date of the Revelation and presented the Jewish people with a lost Torah. Several Bible critics subscribe to this theory. The people would ask, Where did you get this from? Ezra would say, Read it. It says right here that God gave this Torah to the entire nation a thousand years ago. The people could ask, Where was this Torah yesterday? How come we never saw or heard of it before? My father of grandfather never mentioned it.

Ezra could respond that the event did happen a thousand years ago but that it was forgotten, or the Torah was lost and just found. First, how could such an earth-shattering event such as God revealing Himself to an entire nation be forgotten? Second, not only is it impossible for a religion and nation to forget its founding experience, but the Torah itself promises that it will never be forgotten:

When they are beset with many evils and troubles, this song (of Moses) shall testify for them as a witness, since it shall not be forgotten by the mouths of their descendants. "

If it had been forgotten, this in itself would disprove the claim of Divine authorship. If God wrote the Torah, how could it be that His statement is proven false? The Dead Sea Scrolls reveal that the Torah we read today is virtually unchanged from the 2000-year-old fragments found in the Dead Sea caves.

Therefore, at no time would it have been possible for such a fabrication of the Torah to have been perpetrated in a believable way. The fact that the majority of the Jewish people, for the past 3000 years, have accepted this claim as their history can only be because it is true. And that is the reason why there is only one nation and one religion in the entire world that can make the claim of National Revelation.

Peace and blessing,

Len

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I think you know that all Cohens/those malesof the Priestly tribe, are descended from Aaron.

Maybe; but how many Levites and Israelites go to the Torah fraudulently as Cohains for the status/ego trip?

Our ability to verify historical accounts is based on various kinds of evidence, the most important being the number of eyewitnesses.

But with so few Red Sea eyewitnesses still living, isn't it possible that some embellishments have been added and perpetuated.

If God were to introduce Himself to a large group of people, and establish a permanent religion, which method would make more sense: to transmit it directly to each and every person individually or to transmit it to a prophet who would relay the message? Obviously the former is the more credible means.

If God is all powerful and capable of virtually anything, why would he not have imbued his "introduction" into all He created? Why "relay" when one can deliver personally?

It was not miracles, but the unbroken 3300-year transmission of this experience, which stands as the single greatest demonstration of the truth of Judaisms claim that God gave the Torah to the Jews and, through them, to the entire world.

What then would you call the Ten Plagues and the Parting of the Red Sea if not "miracles"? And wasn't Moses' punishment for not explaining that a particular phenomenon (Stick>Snake) was God's miracle and not that of Moses?

Still don't agree, Len but this is a really interesting debate.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>how many Levites and Israelites go to the Torah fraudulently as Cohains for the status/ego trip?

I must be winning because you are scraping the bottom of the barrel nowSmile.gif

It is not even deserving of a response. I know all these guys in my synagogue personally and there are very few of them; sometimes none. We have fewer Levis than Cohens.

>>But with so few Red Sea eyewitnesses still living, isn't it possible that some embellishments have been added and perpetuated.

"So few?" You should have said "no." About two million participated; 600,000 men and their families. They had lots of decendents in every generation.The Bible says:

Deut. 4:9 But take utmost care and watch yourselves scrupulously, so that you do not forget the things that you saw with your own eyes and so that they do not fade from your mind as long as you live. And make them known to your children and to your children's children: 10The day you stood before the Lord your God at Horeb, when the Lord said to Me, Gather the people to Me that I may let them hear My words, in order that they may learn to revere Me as long as they live on earth, and may so teach their children.

Deut. 29:9You stand this day, all of you, before the Lord your God your tribal heads, your elders and your officials, all the men of Israel, 10your children, your wives, even the stranger within your camp, from woodchopper to waterdrawer 11for you to enter into the covenant of the Lord your God , --- 13 I make this covenant, with its sanctions, not with you alone, 14but both with those who are standing here with us this day before the Lord our God and with those who are not with us here this day.

Our belief today is responsive to the command for every parent to transmit the events to their children. How could a cabal invent this and have it believed and followed by an entire nation? It would have withered and died early on if not true.

In several places, in the Torah, the Hebrew for the word, "you," and related verb conjugations, are in the singular when the plural would be more proper gramatically speaking. The explanation is that each individual Israeli is being addressed rather than the group as a whole.

Len>>If God were to introduce Himself to a large group of people, and establish a permanent religion, which method would make more sense: to transmit it directly to each and every person individually or to transmit it to a prophet who would relay the message? Obviously the former is the more credible means.

>>If God is all powerful and capable of virtually anything, why would he not have imbued his "introduction" into all He created? Why "relay" when one can deliver personally?

Because, if God is omnipresent and smotheringShe removesour free will.

The possibility of evil derives exactly from free will, which is one of the salient factors that characterizes man as being in Gods image. For God to protect us perfectly from evil would be to make us robots. Deut. 32:11 compares Gods protection of Israel to that of an eagle hovering over its young. The word yra-khayf, hovering, is used in only one other place in scripture, Gen. 1:2, ... and Gods spirit hovered (mra-kefet) over the face of the waters. The metaphor is that of an eagle staying sufficiently close to offer protection, but not close enough to smother. This is like a parent allowing a young child to try to walk and take the risk that he will fall. At the same time, the parent tries to help the child learn to walk. This God did through Revelation.

The same God who created the wicked has created a means for the wicked to repent and give up their wickedness. If they do not take advantage, they are fools. This theme is presented again and again. For example inProv. 1:20-33:

This wisdom cries aloud in the street; she raises her voice in the squares. She calls at the head of the noisy marketplace; at he entrance of the city gates she utters her words: How long, you simpletons, will you love being misled? And how long will scorners delight in their scorning, and fools hate knowledge? Turn back at my reproof; behold I will pour out my spirit into you, I will make my words known to you. Because I have called and you have refused, I have stretched out my hand and no man paid heed, but you neglected all my counsel and would have none of my reproof... For the waywardness of the simpletons shall slay them and the complacency of fools shall destroy them. But whoever listens to me will dwell securely, and be tranquil without fear of evil.

The viewpoint ofProverbs is not inconsistent with that of the Pentateuch:

Sin crouches at the door; its urge is towards you, yet you *can* be its master (Gen. 4:7).

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Len>>It was not miracles, but the unbroken 3300-year transmission of this experience, which stands as the single greatest demonstration of the truth of Judaisms claim that God gave the Torah to the Jews and, through them, to the entire world.

>>What then would you call the Ten Plagues and the Parting of the Red Sea if not "miracles"?

What are called "miracles" are in reality extremely unusual natural events that happen coincidently at significant junctures. Archaeologists have found evidence for the plagues and I have articles on the subject.

In our own generation the rebirth of Israel, in fulfilment of prophesy, is considered a miracle by many. Let me show you a fascinating relatedScriptural coincidence.

"When all these things befall you -- the blessing and the curse that I have set before you -- and you take them to heart amidst the various nations to which The Lord your God has banished you, and you return to The Lord your God, and you and your children heed His command with all your heart and soul ... then The Lord your God will restore your fortunes and take you back in love. He will bring you together again from all the peoples where The Lord your God has scattered you. ... And The Lord your God will bring you into the land that your fathers possessed, and you shall possess it; and He will make you more prosperous and more numerous than your fathers. (Deut. 30:1-5)"

Those mystics among us may be interested in noting that one of the verses just cited, Deut. 30:3, is the 5708th verse in the Bible.

"And The Lord, your God, will restore your fortunes and take you back in love. He will bring you together again from all the peoples where The Lord your God has scattered you."

The year 1948, which saw the dream come to pass and the prediction become reality, was none other than the year 5708 from Creation of Adam and Eve, on the Hebrew calander.

>>that a particular phenomenon (Stick>Snake) was God's miracle and not that of Moses?

Pharoah's magicians also did "tricks." Illusions, popular today, were present then also. The Bible recognizes this and warns to not believe miracles if they teach to worship another God. It further says that God iis testing you.

"If there appears among you a prophet or a dream diviner and he gives you a sign or a portent saying, Let us follow and worship another god -- whom you have not experienced -- even if the sign or portent that he named to you comes true, do not heed the words of that prophet or that dream-diviner. For The Lord your God is testing you to see whether you love The Lord your God with all your heart and soul. Follow none but The Lord your God, and revere none but Him; observe His commandments alone, and heed only His orders; worship none but Him and hold fast to Him. As for that prophet or dream diviner, he shall be put to death; for he urged disloyalty to The Lord your God -- who freed you from the land of Egypt and who redeemed you from the house of bondage -- to make you stray from the path that The Lord your God has commanded you to follow. Thus will you sweep out evil from your midst. (Deut. 13:2-6)"

>>Still don't agree, Len but this is a really interesting debate.

Time consuming but interesting and challenging!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I must be winning because you are scraping the bottom of the barrel now

I didn't know we were competing -- just having a discussion. Bottom of the barrel or not, that any religion has a perceived status/ hierarchy based on lineage belies the basic tenet of devotion to God.

"So few?" You should have said "no." About two million participated; 600,000 men and their families. They had lots of decendents in every generation.The Bible says:

Len, I was joking, being sarcastic for emphasis. And my point is that allegedly God-generated "miracles" do in fact get cited as "validation" for the faith.

Our belief today is responsive to the command for every parent to transmit the events to their children. How could a cabal invent this and have it believed and followed by an entire nation? It would have withered and died early on if not true.

Transmitting of so-called "commands" is inherent to indoctrination; such transmission discourages questioning and finding one's own way. Truth must always be subject to scrutiny and investigation otherwise it can be deemed propaganda or dogma.

The same God who created the wicked has created a means for the wicked to repent and give up their wickedness. If they do not take advantage, they are fools. This theme is presented again and again. For example inProv. 1:20-33:

Depends on what one deems as "wicked." You and I already discussed the "wicked" son in the Passover Haggadah. To the hopelessly indoctrinated, "wicked" could mean someone who is un-indoctrinated -- someone who dares question.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

In our own generation the rebirth of Israel, in fulfilment of prophesy, is considered a miracle by many. Let me show you a fascinating relatedScriptural coincidence.

And some see it as an abomination, Len. The Satmar and theNeturei Karta believe that since the Messiah hasn't come, Israel shouldn't be. It's all in theinterpretationof the Torah. So as to the wicked son... that too, is up tointerpretation.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Great to have your contribution, Perrie.

Len>>In our own generation the rebirth of Israel, in fulfilment of prophesy, is considered a miracle by many. Let me show you a fascinating relatedScriptural coincidence.

>>And some see it as an abomination. The Satmar and the Neturei Karta believe that since the Messiah hasn't come, Israel shouldn't be. It's all in the interpretation of the Torah. So as to the wicked son... that too, is up to interpretation.

We can hardly use those groups as models. The NK, with only about 1500 members worldwide,activly oppose Israel to the extent of meeting with, and praising, its enemies in photo ops. Their leader, Moshe Hirschwas paid $50,000 a year by Yasser Arafat to be his "Minister of Jewish Affairs." This means running around with his beard, payes and knickers at anti-Israel demonstrations claiming real Jews do not support Israel as a Jewish state. While claiming they are Torah observant and pious in their condemnations of Israel, these phonies work on Saturdays appearing for the ISM and other anti-Israel groups at demonstrations.They have been shunned by the Media and condemned by oother Jews; even by the Satmar sect.

The Satmar sect is more traditional anti-Zionist for thhe reason you state. They walll themselves off from the broader Jewish community, including Orthodox Jews who view Israel positively. They shuun television, newspapers, secular education, other viewpoints and cultural traditions. They are a non-normative minority I do not consider as "wicked."

Don't forget that Israel was envisioned and founded primarily by secular Jews. Even Reform Judaism was originally anti-Zionist.

The first chief rabbi of Israel, R' Abraham Isaac Kook ZT"L, comparedIsrael's founding to the building of the Holy of Holies, the inner sanctum, of the Jerusalem Temple. Even though only the high priest was permitted in just once a year, it was built by common laborers. R' Kook thought the secularism of the original Zionists simply reveals the cunning of the Divine in furthering the plan of history.

Yehoshuah Liebowitz ZTL, the brother of the celebrated biblical scholar, Nehama Liebowitz who taught my rabbi in Israel, was between the Zionist/antizionist extremes.On one hand, he is a Jewish patriot who rejected the Jewish subservience to alien political rule. But one is hard pressed to find a harsher critic of Israeli chauvanism. Hecriticized many sacred Jewish ideas as idolatrous. He considered the Jewish people unique not because the Torah says so, but because of the decision of the Jewish people to use the Torah as the basis for worship. He noted that Gods miraculous involvement in history did not result in a sufficiently committed people, as the Tanakh itself records. He considered it idolatrous to substitute loyalty to the State of Israel for loyalty to God; to emphasize survival of Judaism over worship of God. For him, Jewish nationhood has significance only because the Commandments and worship of God are of the utmost significance.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago
>>I didn't know we were competing -- just having a discussion.
Didn't you see the smiley face?
>> that any religion has a perceived status/ hierarchy based on lineage belies the basic tenet of devotion to God.
It is a heirarchy of function, not of status. The priests and Levites (and rabbis today) serve the people; they do not rule over them.

>>And my point is that allegedly God-generated "miracles" do in fact get cited as "validation" for the faith.

Not by Maimonides!

>>Transmitting of so-called "commands" is inherent to indoctrination; such transmission discourages questioning and finding one's own way. Truth must always be subject to scrutiny and investigation otherwise it can be deemed propaganda or dogma.
It depends on "truth." If a parent teaches a child to be good and the child questions tthe teaching, turning to drugs and crime, how is that better than had the child been "indoctrinated?"

Abraham questioned God when God declared His intent to destroy Sodom and Gomorrah. "Shall not the Judge of all the earth deal Justly?" After providingseveral alternatives that did not apply, Abraham "returned to his place." (Gen. 18:23ff)

Israel means to fight with God; meaning having improper theological thoughts. It also means to fight for God. You can fight with God and for God but you cannot ignore God. The Talmud, like Supreme Court decisions,is full of disagreements. Best known are those between Hillel and Shamai. But there have to be axiomatic truths in a religion. Even including disagreements, the Bible is axiomatic.

Not all Jews agree so we have various sects. There are even a dozen or so Orthodox sects. This is a barrier to unity. Many rabbis would rather discuss theology with Christians or Muslims than with Jews from other sects.

Len>>the wicked has created a means for the wicked to repent and give up their wickedness. If they do not take advantage, they are fools. This theme is presented again and again. For example inProv. 1:20-33:

>>Depends on what one deems as "wicked." You and I already discussed the "wicked" son in the Passover Haggadah. To the hopelessly indoctrinated, "wicked" could mean someone who is un-indoctrinated -- someone who dares question.

Questioning is not a problem as I have stated. It is a matter of where you draw the line. 2000 years ago the questioners began another religion. 1350 years ago, still another.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>The "wicked" son is labeled thus because he excludes himself from the dogmas when questioning ... he does not ask "why do we," rather, why do "you". He is not necessarily disassociating, rather inquiring about what he has dogmatically been expected to accept without objective scrutiny. He is deemed "wicked" by the insecurity of those who need validation without questioning.

Your opinion that he is not dissociating! For centuriesthe wicked childhas been interpreted as dissociating. You are obviously spinning toadvance your pov.The point is clearly not to suppress questioning.A majorpurpose of the seder is to encourage children's questioning.

>>With so many being simultaneously pro-life, pro-gun, pro-war, pro-torture, pro-death penalty, anti-environment, anti-social safety net -- connect the dots.

You have connected them incorrectly. No one is "pro-war," and pro-Second Amendment is not simply "pro-gun." Obama was "anti-torture" but now he has substituted "pro-death without trial."

I am pro-environment but anti environmental craziness a-la uni-bomber and his ilk. Similarly for the safety net which should not mean from the cradle to the grave.

>>Only SONS are identified in the Four Questions; there is no mention as to what daughters think or feel or what they ask/question.

Sex of the questioner is not mentioned and girls frequently ask. Hebrew grammer uses the male plural when mixed sexes are meant.

Len>>Clergy may be fallible but, speaking for my own religion,the source documents are far more reliably true than works of humans; even recognizing that some of them contain parables, folkloreand disagreements. "The seal of God is truth. (Talmud Sabbath 55a)"

>>There is no verification of such reliability; the Talmud is a work of man.

The Talmud is 2000 years closer to the source than we. There is much archaeolkogical verification as well as DNNA verification.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The wicked son, who asks, "What is this service to you?", is characterized by the Haggadah as isolating himself from the Jewish people, standing by objectively and watching their behavior rather than participating.

Therefore, he is rebuked by the explanation that "It is because God acted for my sake when I left Egypt." (This implies that the Seder is not for the wicked son because the wicked son would not have deserved to be freed from Egyptian slavery.)

Where the four sons are illustrated in the Haggadah, this son has frequently been depicted as carrying weapons or wearing stylish contemporary fashions.

So, one deserves to be enslaved by an oppressor because he OBJECTIVELY questions?

This to me, is the ultimate and eventual and inherent danger of organized religion.

By the way, in Rabbinic Judaism, the Talmud is endlessly questioned by scholars.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>The wicked son, who asks, "What is this service to you?", is characterized by the Haggadah as isolating himself from the Jewish people, standing by objectively and watching their behavior rather than participating.

Therefore, he is rebuked by the explanation that "It is because God acted for my sake when I left Egypt." (This implies that the Seder is not for the wicked son because the wicked son would not have deserved to be freed from Egyptian slavery.)

That is correct. It is hyperbole. But the blood on the doorposts allowed God to pass over those Israelite homes. The blood of the Paschal lamb signified rejection of the Egyptian gods/idols which were sheep. If an Israelite did not commit to theoutward idol rejection,by putting the blood on the doorpost, the firstborn in that home would have been killed. I have no idea if any family did that but that is the basis of the retort to the wicked child.

>>Where the four sons are illustrated in the Haggadah, this son has frequently been depicted as carrying weapons or wearing stylish contemporary fashions.

There are thousands of published Haggada types with different pictures and different translations; even different versions. Only the Orthodox Hebrew text is sanctioned. Artists take liberties. I have Haggadahs biblical scenesw and otherswith no pictures at all.

>>So, one deserves to be enslaved by an oppressor because he OBJECTIVELY questions?

"Objective" is YOUR term. Subjective is more appropriate.

This to me, is the ultimate and eventual and inherent danger of organized religion.

By the way, in Rabbinic Judaism, the Talmud is endlessly questioned by scholars.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Len>>It is exactly the possibility of atonement that precludes being frightened. If there were no possibility of such we would indeed have reason to be frightened.

>>It does if you approach it as a form of collective confession that actually asks/hopes to be "Inscribed in the Book of Life" for another year. I'd say there's a bit of fear in such a request.

Not "a form." It IS a collective confession as I showed before. Jewish public prayer is in the plural as we are all responsible for one another. I also quoted Proverbs 1:7 -- Fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom. Fools despise wisdom and discipline."

Presumably you had at least some fear of your parents when growing up. In real life bad things happen to many sinners. Their wives divorce them, they get tossed into prison; they even are killed.

On Yom Kippur we say, "Repentance, prayer and charity avert the stern decree." You may be interested in the following YouTube, "Who Shall Live,"that dramatizes a key prayer for Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur. It shows the frailty of life; all the bad, and good, things that happen to people; the stern decree and its aversion. It is three years old but still meaningfully current. Following is a link to a translation of the prayer and an explanation of its tragic origin.

...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>This to me, is the ultimate and eventual and inherent danger of organized religion.

If it were a free-for-all Judaism, as known today, would have long ago been displaced by Christianity.

>>By the way, in Rabbinic Judaism, the Talmud is endlessly questioned by scholars.

What else is new? The Bible is also endlessly questioned by "scholars."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

If it were a free-for-all Judaism, as known today, would have long ago been displaced by Christianity.

If you equate objective thought with a free-for-all (as religions traditionally have), you have identified an inherent danger of ethnocentrism and the oxymoron known as "religious thought."

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

"Objective thought" is in theear of the listener.

There is a biblical chapter about objective thought. Jews who deny the authority of the Torah and Talmudare emulating the rebel, Korah (Num. 16).He thought things should be more democratic where his objectiveopinion should count as much as the establishment's byMoses, Aaronand the Sanhedrin.

"You have gone too far! for all the community are holy, all of them, and The Lord is in their midst (Num.16:3)," said the rebellious leaders to Moses and Aaron. "Why then do you raise yourselves above The Lord's congregation?" The Midrash (exegetic parables)provides homiletic interpretations of what was going on here. The nature of the issue is the authority of Moses to interpret the law and the validity of his interpretations. According to the rebels, it can be interpreted by anyone using objective common sense. Rashi discusses the following clever ploy of Korah (Rashi, Num. 16:1):

Korah assembled 250 men and women dressed in robes of pure blue wool. They asked Moses, "Does an entirely blue garment still require fringes?" (This refers to Numbers 15:38, which requires fringes on the corners of garments, and a blue thread to be attached.) Moses affirmed that it did. "Is that logical?" they jeered. A robe of any other color fulfills the fringes requirement merely with a single blue thread. Surely a completely blue garment should not require yet an additional blue thread!

The midrash provides another example: "Does a house full of Torahs still require a mezuzah on the doorpost (Deut. 6:9, 11:20)?" Korah asked. "Yes," replied Moses. "If a brief section of scripture, placed in the mezuzah, satisfies the requirement, surely a room full of Torahs, containing the same portions should! Such decisions are not from the Torah but are your own conceptions." Korah insisted that Moses' logic violated common sense.

Then Korah used a parable to demagogically show that Moses' laws were beyond endurance: "A poor widow had a field. When she came to plow it, Moses frobade her to plow with an ox and an ass together. When she began to sow, Moses forbade her to use mingled seeds. At harvest time Moses ordered her not to reap the corners of the field, or gather the gleanings, but to leave them for the poor. He also demanded the heave offering for the priests, and the tithe for the Levites. The woman sold the field and bought ewes, hoping that she might remain undisturbed. But when the sheep's firstling arrived, Aaron demanded it as his due. At shearing time Aaron demanded the first of the fleece. Eventually the frustrated woman slaughtered the sheep and, in her anger, consecrated it to the sanctuary, whereupon it all fell to Aaron. 'Such men,' Korah concluded, 'are Moses and Aaron.'"

You wouldn't be descended from Korah, would you Mr. M?Smile.gif

According to Rabbi Joseph Soloveitchik zt"l, "Korah argued, in these challenges, that the inner emotional experience was paramount. "God desires the heart." The outer deed is secondary to the inner feeling. In this context, the commandment lacks its own integrity and sanctity, and is no more than a useful tool for eliciting an inner experience. Actually it is the external mitzva/commandment, not the inner experience that is primary. The Torah acknowledges a tension between objectivity (the external mitzva prescribed by halakha/Jewish law) and subjectivity. Both interact, ... and are inseparable..."

Why doesn't halakha give primacy to the emotion, to the inner feeling? ... First, the religious emotion within a single individual is volatile, ever changing and untable. Second, each person experiences things differently. The varying feelings would produce varying rituals over time, and destroy the mitzva's identity. No monistic communal service of God would be possible since group worship presupposes a unifying consistency.

Also, it is difficult to differentiate the intensely-felt hedonistic frenzy from the intensely felt religious experience. Hypnotic experiences, those of the arts, or of drugs may be confused with religious experiences. ... The essence of idolatry is this confusing of secular stimulation with actual bonding with The Lord.

The Torah wants the religious experience to emerge out of itself, out of a religious awareness and not out of aesthetic craving or external stimulants.... The religious experience is autonomous and independent. It follows upon and reflects the deed, not the reverse. To pray and then to dance and sing -- yes. To dance and sing in order to pray -- no!

Use of common sense in religion is like using common sense in physics. Aristotle was wrong when he believed that objects fell because they had weight. This theory was disproven by Galileo and Newton who showed that heavy and light objects fall at the same acceleration rate. They substituted a logos with conceptualization of reality for a common-sense approach.

Similarly, halakha has its own logos. It is more than a mere collection of laws, in the same way that physics is more than a mere collection of laws. Both are autonomous, self-integrated systems. Consequently, halakha need not conform to the dictates of common sense reasoning anymore than mathematical or scientific conceptualized systems need accomodate themselves to common sense.

The Jew must move from action to feeling. This achievement is veiled in mystery, but such is the power of a mitzva. Korah wanted to do to halakha what Aristotle did to physics. So too , all the critics of Jewish law today who believe the halakhic system to be irrelevant or legalistic. We have one God, one Torah, one form of worship. Communal worship should be constant and not buffeted by the winds of fashion, or subject to the moods of diverse individuals.Moses contended that Korah's emphasis on the primacy of the emotions would destroy the religious identity of the people and result in fragmented sects. The fact that Jews of all times, and from different parts of the world, are able to worship together is directly due to the constancy of form which is controlled by the halakha.

One of the Talmudic sages was traveling in the desert where he was shown the place where Korah and his followers were engulfed. Putting his ear to a crack in the ground, the rabbi heard voices cry, "Moses and his Torah are true and we are liars."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

"Moses and his Torah are true and we are liars."

No conflict-of-interests there. (sarcasm)

Use of common sense in religion is like using common sense in physics.

Here we may agree, Len. There is no place for common sense in organized religion; that would lead to objectivity.

Physics like other sciences, subjects itself to testing and retesting to determine that which is true and that which may have initially been deemed true but upon subsequent objective scrutiny, is not.

If the early scientists like Ptolemy and Copernicus were subsequently found less than correct, religious "scholars" may well be need to be corrected from time-to-time.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Len>>Use of common sense in religion is like using common sense in physics.

>>Here we may agree, Len. There is no place for common sense in organized religion; that would lead to objectivity.

Like Korah's objectivity.

>>Physics like other sciences, subjects itself to testing and retesting to determine that which is true and that which may have initially been deemed true but upon subsequent objective scrutiny, is not. If the early scientists like Ptolemy and Copernicus were subsequently found less than correct, religious "scholars" may well be need to be corrected from time-to-time.

The Church held that the earth was the center of the universe. Jews interpreted the beginning of Genesis as meaning the universe was formed ex nihilo; from nothing. Maimonides and Nachmanides documented this before Copernicus. They lived in the eleventh and twelfth cdenturies.

But the Bible is not a science text. It is about behavior. Human nature has not changed for many thousands of years and the bad behavior the Bible sought to correct is present now just as it was then though the names have changed. I began another thread on this topic.

The biblical judgments about behavior have withstood the tests of time though many are rationalizing and institutionalizingacceptance of the bad behavior of pre-biblical times that the Bible forbids.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The Church held that the earth was the center of the universe. Jews interpreted the beginning of Genesis as meaning the universe was formed ex nihilo; from nothing. Maimonides and Nachmanides documented this before Copernicus. They lived in the eleventh and twelfth cdenturies.

Nothing can be formed from nothing. And the Church that put Galileo under house arrest for showing that the moons of Jupiter were not geocentric that CHURCH is a RELIGION.

But the Bible is not a science text. It is about behavior. Human nature has not changed for many thousands of years and the bad behavior the Bible sought to correct is present now just as it was then though the names have changed. I began another thread on this topic.

Yeah! Thousands enjoyed the Inquisition for its thwarting bad behavior!

The biblical judgments about behavior have withstood the tests of time though many are rationalizing and institutionalizingacceptance of the bad behavior of pre-biblical times that the Bible forbids.

You may have noticed that the bad behavior continues, some of it by religious folks.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>Nothing can be formed from nothing. And the Church that put Galileo under house arrest for showing that the moons of Jupiter were not geocentric that CHURCH is a RELIGION.

You will not get me to defend the medieval church. All the bad behavior you mentioned was by them.

From Robert Jastrow's book, God and the Astronomers:

"... scientists cannot bear the thought of a natural phenomenon which cannot be explained, even with unlimited time and money. There is a kind of religion in science; it is the religion of a person who believes there is order and harmony in the Universe, and any event can be explained in a natural way as the product of some previous event; every effect must have its cause; there is no First Cause ... This religious faith of the scientist is violated by the discovery that the world had a beginning under conditions in which the laws of physics are not valid, and as a product of forces or circumstances we cannot discover. When that happens the scientist has lost control. If he really examined the implications, he would be traumatized. As usual, when faced with trauma, the mind reacts by ignoring the implications -- in science this is known as "refusing to speculate" -- or trivializing the origin of the world by calling it the Big Bang as if the Universe were a firecracker.

"Now we would like to pursue that inquiry farther back in time, but the barrier to further progress seems insurmountable ... for the scientist who has lived by his faith in the power of reason, the story ends like a bad dream. He has scaled the mountains of ignorance; he is about to conquer the highest peak; as he pulls himself over the final rock, he is greeted by a band of theologians who have been sitting there for centuries."

Robert Jastrow (September 7, 1925 February 8, 2008) was an American astronomer, physicist and cosmologist. He was a leading NASA scientist, populist author and futurist.

He was the first chairman of NASAs Lunar Exploration Committee, which established the scientific goals for the exploration of the moon during the Apollo lunar landings. At the same time he was also the Chief of the Theoretical Division at NASA (195861). He became the founding director of NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies in 1961, and served until his retirement from NASA in 1981. Concurrently he was also a Professor of Geophysics at Columbia University.

After his NASA career he became a Professor of Earth Sciences at Dartmouth College (19811992), and was a Member of the NASA Alumni Association. Jastrow was also a Founder and Chairman Emeritus of the George C. Marshall Institute, and Director Emeritus of Mount Wilson Observatory and Hale Solar Laboratory.

 
 

Who is online






111 visitors