╌>

GMO Hysteria

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  pat-n2  •  13 years ago  •  143 comments

GMO Hysteria

I want to start this off by saying I'm a huge fan of organic gardening. My own garden is organic. I can teach any apartment dweller with a balcony how to grow enough tomatoes, strawberries, green onions and lettuce to last an entire season. I love the tase of organic food.

But the GMO hype has gotten way out of hand. Have a problem with Monsanto's thuggery and business practices? Fine. So do I. But to condemn all bio-engineered crops as a result is sheer nuttiness. Funny thing...I don't hear people doing the same bitching about the varieties of seed corn that Pioneer puts out. (I can just hear the city slickers now: "Pioneer? Who's Pioneer? I haven't seen them in the news and the media hasn't told me how I should think about them yet.")

Do you like nectarines? Better not eat them. They are a genetically modified peach. How about tangelos? Better nix them, too. They are a hybrid between a tangerine and a grapefruit. And people are crazy for pluots (plum/apricot hybrid). Bottom line is that bio-engineered foods have been around for decades and no one took issue with them until the media told them to.

But lets take this beyond your own table and look at it on a national and worldwide scale. Here in Iowa, over 70% of the corn grown goes toward production of feed for livestock and that federal disaster known as "Ethanol". I have yet to hear a GMO basher explain to me just WHY they want to force these farmers to raise these crops ORGANICALLY, how they expect them to get the same yield and keep the prices the same. I also haven't heard a reasonable explanation forhow organically grown feed corn will make ethanol or swine feed "better".

On a worldwide scale: We feed many of the world's starving. How do you plan to continue to do this at the levels we currently do if farmers are forced to switch to organics alone? Again...I've never gotten a clear answer.

Lastly...just a funny observation. Many of the GMO bashers I know, are the very same people that go to the big box stores, load up on hybrid starter plants for their OWN garden and think nothing of it. When asked why they don't grow heirlooms, take the time to harvest the seeds, properly preserve them, start their own seedlings from those seeds indoors and then transplant them to their garden in the spring...their response is always the same: "It's too much work and I don't get as much produce". Yet they want farmers to do it on a 500 acre scale? That's rich.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

I've heard the hype. What I haven't heard is sensible alternatives. Anyone have some they care to share?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Why not just label it and quell the controversy?

Because the anti-GMO chicken littles have managed to turn those three little letters into the next swear word with all of their hype. It would be a marketing disaster to put "GMO" on the packaging.

I already see a lot of stuff labeled with "hybrid", anyway. If people don't know that "hybrid" is the same thing as "GMO", then they need to educate themselves. Also, drive down any country road in the midwest and you will see signs in crop test plots that say: "Pioneer Hybrid", "Stine Hybrid". Personally...I don't blame companies for not wanting to put "GMO" on their packaging. "Hybrid" is good enough. Plus...if people want to buy organic only, then they need to AT LEAST educate themselves about lables. There is already plety of information there to let someone know if a product is organic or not.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    13 years ago

Because people admit they arent scientists... and yet take something as simple as a label and freak out about it.

I wouldn't be against a label system... however, who designs it? Who establishes it? Who pays for it? Who actually holds companies accountable for labeling correctly?

How much is THAT going to cost taxpayers?

The thing about GMO is that it's a spectrum... there are plants that have been genetically modified so much, you can't even tell where they came from to begin with. I mean, have you ever seen the originalmaize plant? Probably not since it doesn't really exist anymore.

I could see a few clear cut sections to label

- plants that have been crossbred to be what they are (which really includes a lot of plants... some would argue every plant... so... good luck sorting out which is which)

- plants that have genes in them from other plants "surgically" implanted - which plants count as genetic surgury? does selective breeding give you surgical implantation? What about gamet crossbreeding?

- plants that have genes in them from other organisms "surgically" implanted - these would be a lot easier to label in theory... unless you are implanting a similar gene that just works better from a squidd to keepcell cytoplasmfrom freezing... it could be the same gene with a better promoter... couldnt tell the difference between the proteins...

- plants that have synthetic genes in them - synthetic because they were made? synthetic because they are two copies of the same gene already in the plant? synthetic because they were cross cut from two different gene pools?

It isnt so cut and dry as to slap a label on it. Plus, how much is too much? What if your corn product had 2% of one type of corn in it because they filled the grain silo with it once upon a time? How do you account for that? What if the food company mixes grains in production (like wheat thins?) and some of it is GMO, some of it isnt... what if some of it only has some GMO? What if one year the farmer is planting crop X corn and still has crop Y corn seed in the field? Are we going to burn the whole field because he cant estimate how much is X and how much is Y?

I mean really... the labeling thing is a cost monster if you really think about it. Not to mention the logistics... the system setup... the monitors required.

And the testing... what if there is a requirement to test it all? Holy cow... my GMP just fell off the truck in spasms at this one...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I'm not so sure that "genetically engineered" and "hybridized" are consistently synonymous terms. Hybrids that result from cross-pollination of genetically-compatible species are not "engineered," that is, they have not had specific changes introduced into their DNA by "science" -- that is, they are more in harmony with the concept of "natural selection."

Now before someone jumps all over that, let me state that I have a degree in biology and while my specialization is in limnology and not plant-genetics, I don't come to the conversation as a total novice.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

I'm not so sure that "genetically engineered" and "hybridized" are consistently synonymous terms. Hybrids that result from cross-pollination of genetically-compatible species are not "engineered,"

While that IS true, the term "hybrid" also covers genetically engineered plants. I gave a couple of examples in this article (nectarines, tangelos, etc)

In fact, I'd even go out on a limb and say that the majority of hybrids are the result of genetic engineering while those that result from natural cross pollination are in the minority.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

One thing I forgot to mention is that one of the most heavily genetically modified crops is cotton. Which I find ironic, since most of the GMO bashers are the same people who swear on "natural fibers" and 100% cotton for their clothing and it tends to be what they're wearing when they run down to Home Depot to purchase their flat of Burpee hybrid seedlings for their "organic" garden.

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

After the red dye #2 hysteria of the sixties, I figured I had ingested so many hot dogs and red M&M's that I was already a dead man walking, so eat what you may from that point on. That is to say that with all the stuff they are putting in foodstuffs these days, unless they cause the food on my plate to actually move of it's own accord I eat it and cease to think of it. Pretty soon when we go to Soylent Green it will all become moot. Unless you are going to grow your own as Pat does, who knows what things are going into the food system and perhaps we are better off that way.

But what would a story be sans some form of overstated drama to excite the populus, it would be the factsI suppose.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

But what would a story be sans some form of overstated drama to excite the populus, it would be the facts I suppose.

And we all know how "boring" facts can be, lol. Musn't have news without some element of chaos, dontchya know. Smile.gif

I'll believe people are really concerned about GMO's and aren't just using this as the "flavor-of-the-day" thing to bitch about when the stop using pancake mix, prepared pie crusts, Bisquik, all Kellogg's products...(including the 'healthy' cereals), Lean Cuisine, Jiffy Corn Muffin Mix, Roman Meal Bread, Home Pride Bread, 12 Grain Bread, Holsum Bread, any Nutri-Grain product, any Pillsbury product, any General Mills product, any Heinz product, any Kraft product, Vlasic pickles, Pace Picante Sauce, any Harvest Bakery product, Ritz crackers, Goldfish, any Pepperidge Farms product, Healthy Choice, Stouffers, Marie Callender's....

And that's just a short list.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Royal -

Cross bred plants (hybrids) are generally the result of cross pollinating two superior (in hardiness, yield production...whatever the end goal of the hybrid is). So in the purest sense of the word...."yes". Hybrids are genetically modified.

Naturally, there are rare exceptions to every rule. Occasionally, natural cross pollination will occur with no "intervention" from humans and produce a hybrid variety. An analogy would be like two Japanese people having a blonde haired child. Not likely to happen since there is basically no recessive gene for blonde hair in the Japanese native population, but it could still happen.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Organic food for Dummies (sorry Matt) By Perrie Halpern

There is a huge difference betweenhybridcrops and GMO crops. Hybridization is crosspollination. It occurs naturally when pollen from a specific type of plant is passed on to the by wind, birds and bees, etc. to another plant. Since the 1920's man has been helping this along by taking stronger strains of plants (let's say corn) and crosspollinatingby hand to produce stronger strains of plant. But it is still a natural process, with a bit of guided control.

GMO's are NOT a naturally produce seed or product. Wiki explains it well:

Genetically modified foods ( GM foods , or biotech foods ) are foods derived from genetically modified organisms (GMOs), specifically, genetically modified crops . GMOs have had specific changes introduced into their DNA by genetic engineering techniques. These techniques are much more precise [1] than mutagenesis (mutation breeding) where an organism is exposed to radiation or chemicals to create a non-specific but stable change. Other techniques by which humans modify food organisms include selective breeding and somaclonal variation .

They are created by altering their DNA unnaturally. Many times these crops are created to withstand huge amounts ofpesticide. That is whereMonsantocomes in. But I will get back to that.

GMO plants have been cleared by the FDA as safe. But since the food has only entered our markets since 1990, there is no long term studies on us. Furthermore, GMO animals have not been cleared for human consumption. That should set off some warning bells. Groups like WWF don't trust GMO foods and would like them banned or at leastlabeled.

Now onto Monsanto. Monsanto's GMO seed is problematic for two reason. The first is that theypatentedit. Now if seed cross pollinates naturally, as Iexplainedabove, to a neighboring farm, who is using traditional seed, if the next generation seed shows some DNA from Monsanto's seed, they sue the farmer, who can't afford legal council, since most are just family farms and are barely getting by. Their only other choice is to use Monsanto seed which means that the farm becomes theirs,basically.

The other issue with Monsanto's seed comes from it's use of GMO's to make a plant that is resistant to "Roundup", which isherbicidal. Monsanto farms drown their GMO resistant crops in Roundup, so that no other natural crosspollinationcan take place. If one was certain what GMO's can do to the human body, recent studies have shown what 'Roundup" does.

There are major questions to what Roundup does to plants:

Plant pathologist and retired Purdue University professor Don Huber has written a letter to U.S. Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack warning that a newly discovered and widespread "electron microscopic pathogen appears to significantly impact the health of plants, animals, and probably human beings." He said the pathogen appears to be connected to use of glyphosate, the key ingredient in Roundup.

And as a possible health risk to humans and cancer. In a highly debated study of rats, Roundup has been shown to cause tumors. The study is still under debate, but here are the links:

Personally, I don't want to take the chance. The idea of eating food that has been designed to withstand large amounts of toxic chemicals (Roundup clearly says this on it's package), doesn't sound healthy to me.

So let's go through that list of food that Pat mentions:

Pioneer a Dupont company, puts out both Hybrid and GMO's. It's corn stock is hybid. It's soy stock is GMO to withstand Roundup. They purchased the rights from Monsanto for the seed.

1992 Pioneer paid $450,000 to Monsanto for rights to genetically modified soybean seeds that are resistant to RoundUp herbicide .

nectarines are a hybrid and not a GMO. Peaches occurnaturallyso there is no need to by a GMO one, although they doexist. T angelos are ahybridfruit and not a GMO. BTW, it has the same drug interactions as does grapefruit, so please take note.

It should be up to the consumer to decide if they want to eat food that is a GMO. They should be labled as such, so that the consumer can make an educated decision. At the present they are not. Of course it is Monsanto that doesn't want such labeling. Not a shocker there. You can read about the dispute over labeling here:

OK.. now you have had an a full education. You make your own decision.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    13 years ago

But the cost to label isnt just the ink.

If there is no oversight, anyone could label their product with whatever they want... who is to prove them wrong unless money is spent?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

one of the most heavily genetically modified crops is cotton.

Rarely a "crop" on the menu, however. Wearing it is one thing, eating it is something else.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    13 years ago

Say there was an awesome breed of melons from holland that had this great producing power... Because it was produced in holand, they couldnt afford to import. The farmer who crossed the plant initially didnt have seed stock to sell to the world... so scientists studied the plant to find out it had a double copy of a specific gene.

They took a melon plant here and double inserted the gene to recreate the melon.

Would you consider a plant with a double insertion of the same protein to be GMO?

Would you label the holand melon ashybrid, while the local melon is labeled GMO?

If genetically they are the same, how could you test that they were different plants? How would you know if they were different plants? What would stop the company from not labeling the melon the way they wanted to?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Then why the big deal with a label?

I already answered that with one reason above. And Miss Demeanor answered it with an even better one.

I haven't even touched on foodstamp entitlements. Are you willing to have the costs double or triple so the poor can afford to buy their breakfast cereal and bread when Kellog's andGeneral Millsare forced to go "organic"?

And what about swine feed? Should manufacturers be forced to label that, too? I mean after all, if you eat a picnic ham from a pig that ingested GMO's in its feed, aren't you eating GMO's? How about pasture fed, so called "organic" beef? What if they were grazing on land that once had a tangelo tree on it? Label the beef as a GMO?

What if the non GMO corn was in a bin that had dust from a GMO crop in it? Is it now a GMO and should it be labeled as such?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

No.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

There is a huge difference between hybrid crops and GMO crops. Hybridization is cross pollination.

Yes it is. But as I have said repeatedly, rarely does that cross pollination occur naturally. Hybrids simply are not "natural" in most cases. Which is why the vast majority of them don't reproduce from their own seeds. They are a mutation and one that usually occurs because humans forced the issue.

If a person truly has problems with GMO's, they should have problems with hybrids too, since hybrids are almost always the result of humans cross breeding two plant species that they feel have superior qualities. And that is the very definition of genetic engineering.

GMO plants have been cleared by the FDA as safe. But since the food has only entered our markets since 1990

Thats a false statement. Many food manufacturers have been using GMO's for eons. Heinz, Kraft, Kellogs, General Mills...the list is endless.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

The only thing I can add to the discussion, based on the prior behavior of those involved, is that I don't trust any company to put my safety and welfare above profits and no, I am not anti-corporation.

Then all I can suggest is that you take this list to the grocery store with you and don't buy anything on it:

baby food

Nabisco (Phillip Morris) Arrowroot Teething Biscuits Infant formula Carnation Infant Formulas (Nestle) AlSoy Good Start
Follow-Up Follow-Up Soy Enfamil Infant Formulas (Mead Johnson)
Enfamil with Iron Enfamil Low Iron Enfamil A.R. Enfamil Nutramigen Enfamil Lacto Free Enfamil 22 Enfamil Next step (soy and milk-based varieties) Enfamil Pro-Soybee Isomil Infant Formulas
(Abbot Labs) Isomil Soy Isomil Soy for Diarrhea Similac
(Abbot Labs) Similac Lactose Free Similac with Iron Similac Low Iron Similac Alimentum

baking

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS baking mixes Aunt Jemima
(Quaker) Complete Pancake & Waffle Mix Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix Cornbread Mix Easy Mix Coffee Cake Betty Crocker
(General Mills) Pie Crust Mix Original Pancake Mix Complete Pancake Mix Buttermilk Complete Pancake Mix Muffin Mixes Banana Nut
Lemon Poppy Seed Blueberry Wild Blueberry Chocolate Chip
Apple Streusel Quick Bread Mixes Banana Cinnamon Streusel Lemon Poppy Seed Cranberry Orange Gingerbread

Cookie Mixes Chocolate Chip Double Chocolate Chunk Sugar Peanut Butter

Bisquik (Betty Crocker/General Mills) Original Reduced Fat
Shake 'n Pour Pancake Mix Shake 'n Pour Buttermilk Pancake Mix Shake 'n Pour Blueberry Pancake Mix Duncan Hines (Aurora Foods) Muffin Mixes Kellogg's All-Bran Apple Cinnamon Kellogg's All-Bran Blueberry
Blueberry Blueberry Crumb Chocolate Chip Hungry Jack
(Pillsbury) Buttermilk Pancake Mix Extra Light & Fluffy Pancake Mix (all varieties) Jiffy Corn Muffin Mix Blueberry Muffin Mix
Raspberry Muffin Mix Pie Crust Mix Mrs. Butterworths (Aurora Foods) Complete Pancake Mix Buttermilk Pancake Mix Pepperidge Farms
(Campbell's) Buttermilk Pancake Mix Pillsbury Quick Bread & Muffin Mixes Blueberry Chocolate Chip Banana Cranberry Lemon Poppyseed Nut

Hot Roll Mix Gingerbread baking needs Bakers (Kraft/Phillip Morris) Unsweetened Chocolate Semi-Sweet Chocolate German Sweet Chocolate White Chocolate Hershey's Semi-Sweet Baking Chips Milk Chocolate Chips Mini Kisses Nestle Toll House Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips Milk Chocolate Chips White Chocolate Butterscotch Chips
Semi-Sweet Chocolate Baking Bars

bread

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS Holsum (Interstate Bakeries)
Holsum Thin Sliced Roman Meal 12 Grain Round Top Home Pride
Buttertop White Buttertop Wheat Pepperidge Farms (Campbell's)
Cinnamon Swirl Light Oatmeal Light Wheat 100% Whole Wheat
Hearty Slices 7 Grain 9 Grain Crunchy Oat Whole Wheat
Light Side Oatmeal Wheat 7 Grain Soft Dinner Rolls Club Rolls Sandwich Buns Hoagie Rolls Thomas' (Bestfoods) English Muffins Original Cinnamon Raisin Honey Wheat Oat Bran Blueberry
Maple French Toast

Toast-r-Cakes Blueberry Toast-r-Cakes Corn Muffins Wonder
(Interstate Bakeries) White Sandwich Bread Country Grain
Buttermilk Thin Sandwich Light Wheat 100% Stoneground Wheat
Fat Free Multigrain Premium Potato Beefsteak Rye Wonder Hamburger Buns

breakfast

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS breakfast bars Kellogg's Pop Tarts (all varieties) Pop Tarts Snack Stix (all) Nutri-Grain Bars (all) Nutri-Grain Fruit Filled Squares (all) Nutri-Grain Twists (all) Fruit-Full Squares (all) Nabisco
(Nabisco/Phillip Morris) Fruit & Grain Bars (all varieties)
Nature Valley (General Mills) Oats & Honey Granola Bars
Peanut Butter Granola Bars Cinnamon Granola Bars Pillsbury
(General Mills) Toaster Scrambles & Strudels (all varieties)
Quaker Chewy Granola Bars (all varieties) Fruit & Oatmeal Bars (all varieties) waffles Aunt Jemima Frozen Waffles
Buttermilk Blueberry Eggo Frozen Waffles (Kellogg's)
Homestyle Buttermilk Nutri-Grain Whole Wheat Nutri-Grain Multi Grain Cinnamon Toast Blueberry Strawberry Apple Cinnamon
Banana Bread Hungry Jack Frozen Waffles (Pillsbury/General Mills)
Homestyle Buttermilk

cereal

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS General Mills Cheerios
Wheaties Total Corn Chex Lucky Charms Trix Kix
Golden Grahams Cinnamon Grahams Count Chocula Honey Nut Chex
Frosted Cheerios Apple Cinnamon Cheerios Multi-Grain Cheerios
Frosted Wheaties Brown Sugar & Oat Total Basic 4 Reeses Puffs French Toast Crunch Kellogg's Frosted Flakes Corn Flakes
Special K Raisin Bran Rice Krispies Corn Pops Product 19
Smacks Froot Loops Marshmallow Blasted Fruit Loops Apple Jacks
Crispix Smart Start All-Bran Complete Wheat Bran Complete Oat Bran Just Right Fruit & Nut Honey Crunch Corn Flakes Raisin Bran Crunch Cracklin' Oat Bran Country Inn Specialties (all varieties) Mothers Cereals (Quaker) Toasted Oat Bran Peanut Butter Bumpers Groovy Grahams Harvest Oat Flakes Harvest Oat Flakes w/Apples & Almonds Honey Round Ups Post (Kraft-Phillip Morris)
Raisin Bran Bran Flakes Grape Nut Flakes Grape Nut O's Fruit & Fibre date, raisin and walnut Fruit & Fibre peach, raisin and almond Honey Bunch of Oats Honey Nut Shredded Wheat Honey Comb
Golden Crisp Waffle Crisp Cocoa Pebbles Cinna-Crunch Pebbles
Fruity Pebbles Alpha-Bits Post Selects Cranberry Almond Post Selects Banana Nut Crunch Post Selects Blueberry Morning Post Selects Great Grains Quaker Life Cinnamon Life 100% Natural Granola
Toasted Oatmeal Toasted Oatmeal Honey Nut Oat Bran Cap'n Crunch
Cap'n Crunch Peanut Butter Crunch Cap'n Crunch Crunchling Berries

chocolate

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS candy Cadbury
(Cadbury/Hershey's) Mounds Almond Joy York Peppermint Patty
Dairy Milk Roast Almond Fruit & Nut Hershey's Kit-Kat
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Mr. Goodbar Special Dark Milk Chocolate Kisses Symphony Kraft (Kraft/Phillip Morris)
Toblerone (all varieties) Mars M&M (all varieties)
Snickers Three Musketeers Milky Way Twix Nestle Crunch
Milk Chocolate Chunky Butterfinger 100 Grand drink mixes and dessert toppings Carnation (Nestle) Hot Cocoa Mixes: Rich Chocolate Double Chocolate Milk Chocolate Marshmallow Madness
Mini Marshmallow No Sugar Hershey's Chocolate Syrup Special Dark Chocolate Syrup Strawberry Syrup Nestle Nesquik Strawberry Nesquik Swiss Miss (ConAgra) Hot Cocoa Mixes: Chocolate Sensation Milk Chocolate Marshmallow Lovers Marshmallow Lovers Fat Free No Sugar Added

condiments

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS Del Monte (Nabisco/Phillip Morris)
Ketchup Heinz Ketchup (regular & no salt) Chili Sauce
Cocktail Sauce Heinz 57 Steak Sauce Hellman's (Bestfoods)
Real Mayonnaise Light Mayonnaise Low-Fat Mayonnaise Hunt's
(ConAgra) Ketchup (regular & no salt) KC Masterpiece
(Clorox) Original BBQ sauce Garlic & Herb Marinade Honey Teriyaki Marinade Kraft (Kraft/Phillip Morris) Miracle Whip (all varieties) Kraft Mayonnaise (all) Thick & Spicy BBQ sauces
(all varieties) Char Grill BBQ sauce Honey Hickory BBQ sauce
Nabisco (Nabiso/Phillip Morris) A-1 Steak Sauce Open Pit
(Vlasic/Campbells) BBQ sauces (all) salsa Chi-Chi's
(Hormel) Fiesta Salsa (all varieties) Old El Paso
(Pillsbury) Thick & Chunky Salsa Garden Pepper Salsa Taco Sauce Picante Sauce Ortega (Nestle) Taco Sauce Salsa Prima Homestyle Salsa Prima Roasted Garlic Salsa Prima 3 Bell Pepper Thick & Chunky Salsa Pace (Campbells) Chunky Salsa Picante Sauce
Tostitos Salsa (Frito-Lay/Pepsi) All Natural All Natural Thick & Chunky Roasted Garlic Restaurant Style

cookies

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS Delicious Brands (Parmalat)
Animal Crackers Ginger Snaps Fig Bars Oatmeal Sugar-Free Duplex Honey Grahams Cinnamon Grahams Fat Free Vanilla Wafers
English Toffee Heath Cookies Butterfinger Cookies Skippy Peanut Butter Cookies Famous Amos (Keebler/Flowers Industries) Chocolate Chip Oatmeal Raisin Chocolate Sandwich Peanut Butter Sandwich
Vanilla Sandwich Oatmeal Macaroon Sandwich Frookies (Delicious Brands/Parmalat) Peanut Butter Chunk Chocolate Chip Double Chocolate
Frookwich Vanilla Frookwich Chocolate Frookwich Peanut Butter
Frookwich Lemon Funky Monkeys Chocolate Ginger Snaps Lemon Wafers Keebler (Keebler/Flowers Industries) Chips Deluxe Sandies
E.L. Fudge Soft Batch Chocolate Chip Golden Vanilla Wafers
Droxies Vienna Fingers Fudge Shoppe Fudge Stripes Fudge Shoppe Double Fudge & Caramel Fudge Shoppe Fudge Stix Fudge Shoppe Peanut Butter Fudge Stix Country Style Oatmeal Graham Originals Graham Cinnamon Crisp Graham Chocolate Graham Honey Low Fat Crme Filled Wafers Chocolate Filled Wafers Nabisco (Nabisco/Phillip Morris) Oreo
(all varieties) Chips Ahoy! (all varieties) Fig Newtons (and all Newtons varities) Lorna Doone Nutter Butters Barnum Animal Crackers Nilla Wafers Nilla Chocolate Wafers Pecanz Shortbread
Family Favorites Oatmeal Famous Wafers Fudge Covered Mystic Sticks
Honey Maid Graham Crackers Honey Maid Cinnamon Grahams Honey Maid Chocolate Grahams Honey Maid Oatmeal Crunch Teddy Grahams Teddy Grahams Cinnamon Teddy Grahams Chocolate Teddy Grahams Chocolate Chips
Caf Cremes Vanilla Caf Crme Cappuccino Pepperidge Farm
(Campbell's) Milano Mint Milano Chessmen Bordeaux
Brussels Geneva Chocolate Chip Lemon Nut Shortbread
Sugar Ginger Men Raspberry Chantilly Strawberry Verona
Chocolate Mocha Salzburg Chocolate Chunk Chesapeake Chocolate Chunk Nantucket Chocolate Chunk Sausalito Oatmeal Raisin Soft Baked Sesame Street (Keebler) Cookie Monster Chocolate Chip Chocolate Sandwich Vanilla Sandwich Cookie Pals Honey Grahams Cinnamon Grahams Frosted Grahams Snack Wells (Nabisco/Phillip Morris)
Devil's Food Golden Devil's Food Mint Crme Coconut Crme
Chocolate Sandwich Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter Chip Double Chocolate Chip

crackers

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS Keebler (Keebler/Flowers Industries) Town House Club Munch 'Ems (all varieties)
Wheatables Zesta Saltines Toasteds (Wheat, Onion, Sesame & Butter Crisps) Snax Stix (Wheat, Cheddar & original) Harvest Bakery (Multigrain, Butter, Corn Bread) Nabisco (Nabisco/Phillip Morris) Ritz (all varieties) Wheat Thins (all) Wheatsworth
Triscuits Waverly Sociables Better Cheddars Premium Saltines
(all) Ritz Snack Mix (all) Vegetable Flavor Crisps Swiss Cheese Flavor Crisps Cheese Nips (all) Uneeda Biscuits
Pepperidge Farm (Campbell's) Butter Thins Hearty Wheat
Cracker Trio Cracker Quartet Three Cheese Snack Stix Sesame Snack Stix Pumpernickel Snack Stix Goldfish (original, cheddar, parmesan, pizza, pretzel) Goldfish Snack Mix (all) Red Oval Farms
(Nabisco/Phillip Morris) Stoned Wheat Thins (all varieties)
Crisp 'N Light Sourdough Rye Crisp 'N Light Wheat Sunshine
(Flowers Industries) Cheeze-It (original & reduced fat)
Cheeze-It White Cheddar Cheeze-It Party Mix Krispy Original Saltines

frozen dinners

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS Banquet (ConAgra) Pot Pies
(all varieties) Fried Chicken Salisbury Steak Chicken Nugget Meal Pepperoni Pizza Meal Budget Gourmet (Heinz) Roast Beef Supreme Beef Stroganoff Three Cheese Lasagne Chicken Oriental & Vegeatble Fettuccini Primavera Green Giant (Pillsbury) Rice Pilaf with Chicken Flavored Sauce Rice Medley with Beef Flavored Sauce
Primavera Pasta Pasta Accents Creamy Cheddar Create-a-Meals Parmesan Herb Chicken Cheesy Pasta and Vegetable Beef Noodle Sweet & Sour
Mushroom Wine Chicken

Healthy Choice (ConAgra) Stuffed Pasta Shells Chicken Parmagiana
Country Breaded Chicken Roast Chicken Breast Beef Pot Roast
Chicken & Corn Bread Cheese & Chicken Tortellini Lemon Pepper Fish Shrimp & Vegetable Macaroni & Cheese Kid Cuisine
(ConAgra) Chicken Nugget Meal Fried Chicken Taco Roll Up
Corn Dog Cheese Pizza Fish Stix Macaroni & Cheese Lean Cuisine (Stouffer's/Nestle) Skillet Sensations Chicken & Vegetable
Broccoli & Beef Homestyle Beef Teriyaki Chicken Chicken Alfredo Garlic Chicken Roast Turkey

Hearty Portions Chicken Florentine Beef Stroganoff Cheese & Spinach Manicotti Salisbury Steak

Caf Classics Baked Fish Baked Chicken Chicken a L'Orange Chicken Parmesan Meatloaf with Whipped Potatoes

Everyday Favorites Chicken Fettuccini Chicken Pie Angel Hair Pasta
Three Bean Chili with Rice Macaroni & Cheese

Marie Callenders (ConAgra) Chicken Pot Pie Lasagna & Meat Sauce Turkey & Gravy Meat Loaf & Gravy Country Fried Chicken & Gravy Fettuccini with Broccoli & Cheddar Roast Beef with Mashed Potatoes Country Fried Pork Chop with Gravy Chicken Cordon Bleu
Ore-Ida Frozen Potatoes (Heinz) Fast Fries Steak fries
Zesties Shoestrings Hash Browns Tater Tots Potato Wedges
Crispy Crunchies Rosetto Frozen Pasta (Heinz) Cheese Ravioli
Beef Ravioli Italian Sausage Ravioli Eight Cheese Stuffed Shells
Eight Cheese Broccoli Stuffed Shells Stouffer's (Nestle) Family Style Favorites Macaroni & Cheese Stuffed Peppers Broccoli au Gratin
Meat Loaf in Gravy Green Bean & Mushroom Casserole

Homestyle Meatloaf Salisbury Steak Chicken Breast in Gravy

Hearty Portions Salisbury Steak Chicken Fettucini Meatloaf with Mashed Potatoes Chicken Pot Pie

Swanson (Vlasic/Campbells) Meat Loaf Fish & Chips
Salisbury Steak Chicken Nuggets Hungry Man Fried Chicken Roast Chicken Fisherman's Platter Pork Rib

Voila! (Bird's Eye/Agri-Link Foods) Chicken Voila! Alfredo
Chicken Voila! Garlic Chicken Voila! Pesto Chicken Voila! Three Cheese Steak Voila! Beef Sirloin Shrimp Voila! Garlic Weight Watchers (Heinz) Smart Ones Fiesta Chicken Basil Chicken Ravioli Florentine Fajita Chicken Roasted Vegetable Primavera

dressings/salad oils

none listed under GM modified

energy bars and drinks

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS energy bars Power Bar (Nestle)
Oatmeal Raisin Apple Cinnamon Peanut Butter Vanilla Crisp
Chocolate Peanut Butter Mocha Banana Wild Berry Harvest Bars Apple Crisp Blueberry Chocolate Fudge Brownie Strawberry Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip

drink mixes Carnation Instant Breakfast Mix (Nestle) Creamy Milk Chocolate Classic Chocolate French Vanilla Strawberry Caf Mocha

heat and serve meals

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS Chef Boyardee (ConAgra)
Beefaroni Macaroni & Cheese Mini Ravioli ABC's & 123's
Dinty Moore (Hormel) Beef Stew Turkey Stew Chicken & Dumplings Hormel Chili with Beans Chili No Beans Vegetarian Chili with Beans Kids' Kitchen (Hormel) Spaghetti Rings with Meatballs Macaroni & Cheese Pizza Wedges with 3 Cheese
Franco-American (Campbell's) Spaghetti O's Mini Ravioli
Power Rangers Pasta in Sauce

meat and dairy alternatives

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS meat alternatives Loma Linda
(Worthington/Kellogg's*) Meatless Chik Nuggest Morningstar
(Worthington/Kellogg's*) Harvest Burger Better 'n Burgers Garden Veggie Patties Grillers Burgers Black Bean Burger Chicken Patties
Natural Touch (Worthington/Kellogg's*) Garden Vegetable Pattie
Black Bean Burger Okra Pattie Lentil Rice Loaf Nine Bean Loaf
Worthington (Worthington/Kellogg's*) Vegetarian Burger Savory Slices dairy alternatives Nutra Blend Soy Beverage (Bestfoods)
Original Vanilla Apple Orange *A company letter states that they are in the process of converting to non-genetically modified "proteins" in all products.

meal mixes and sauce packets

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS Betty Crocker (General Mills)
Garden Vegetable Pilaf Creamy Herb Risotto Garlic Alfredo Fettuccini
Bowl Appetit Cheddar Broccoli Macaroni & Cheese Pasta Alfredo

Knorr (Bestfoods) Mushroom Risotto Italian Rice Broccoli au Gratin Risotto Vegetable Primavera Risotto Risotto Milanese Original Pilf Chicken Pilaf Rotini with 4 Cheese Bow Tie Pasta with Chicken & Vegetable Penne with Sun-Dried Tomato Fettuccini with Alfredo
Classic Sauce Packets Hollandaise Barnaise White Brown
Lemon Herb Mushroom Brown Onion Roasted Chicken Roasted Pork
Roasted Turkey

Pasta Sauce Packets Alfredo Four Cheese Carbonara Pesto
Garlic Herb

Lipton (Unilever) Rice & Sauce Packets Chicken Broccoli
Cheddar Broccoli Beef Flavor Spanish Chicken Flavor Creamy Chicken Mushroom

Sizzle & Stir Skillet Supers Lemon Garlic Chicken & Rice Spanish Chicken & Rice Herb Chicken & Bowties Cheddar Chicken & Shells

Near East (Quaker) Spicy Tomato Pasta Mix Roasted Garlic & Olive Oil Pasta Mix Falafel Mix Lentil Pilaf Couscous Tomato Lentil Parmesan Toasted Pinenut Herb Chicken Broccoli & Cheese Curry Pasta Roni (Quaker) Fettuccini Alfredo Garlic Alfredo Angel Hair Pasta with Herbs Angel Hair Pasta with Parmesan Cheese Angel Hair Pasta with Tomato Parmesan Angel Hair Pasta Primavera
Garlic & Olive Oil with Vermicelli Rice-a-Roni (Quaker) Rice Pilaf Beef Chicken Fried Rice Chicken & Broccoli Long Grain & Wild Rice Broccoli au Gratin Uncle Ben's (Mars) Long Grain & Wild Rice (Original & with Garlic) Brown & Wild Rice Mushroom Country Inn Mexican Fiesta Country Inn Oriental Fried Rice
Country Inn Chicken & Vegetable Country Inn Chicken & Broccoli
Natural Select Chicken & Herb Natural Select Tomato & Basil
Chef's Recipe Chicken & Vegetable Pilaf Chef's Recipe Beans & Rice Chef's Recipe Broccoli Rice

frozen pizza

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS Celeste (Aurora Foods) Supreme
Pepperoni Vegetable Four Cheese Deluxe Cheese Tombstone
(Kraft/Phillip Morris) Pepperoni Supreme Sausage & Pepperoni
Extra Cheese Stuffed Crust Three Cheese Totino's (Pillsbury)
Crisp Crust Pepperoni Combination

snack foods

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS Act II Microwave Popcorn (ConAgra)
Butter Extreme Butter Corn on the Cob Frito-Lay* (PepsiCo)
Lays Potato Chips (all varieties) Ruffles Potato Chips (all)
Doritos Corn Chips (all) Tostitos Corn Chips (all) Fritos Corn Chips (all) Cheetos (all) Rold Gold Pretzels (all)
Cracker Jack Popcorn Healthy Choice Microwave Popcorn (ConAgra)
Organic Corn (soy/canola oils) Mothers Corn Cakes (Quaker)
Butter Pop Orville Redenbacher Microwave Popcorn (ConAgra)
Original Homestyle Butter Smart Pop Pour Over Orville Redenbacher Popcorn Cakes Chocolate Caramel Orville Redenbacher Mini Popcorn Cakes Butter Peanut Caramel Chocolate Peanut Pop Secret Microwave Popcorn (Betty Crocker/General Mills) Natural Homestyle
Jumbo Pop Extra Butter Light 94% Fat Free Butter Pringles
(Procter & Gamble) Original Low Fat Pizza-licious Sour Cream & Onion Salt & Vinegar Cheezeums Quaker Rice Cakes
Peanut Butter Chocolate Crunch Cinnamon Streusel Mini
Chocolate Ranch Sour Cream & Onion Apple Cinnamon
Caramel Corn Quaker Corn Cakes White Cheddar Caramel Corn
Strawberry Crunch Caramel Chocolate Chip *Frito has informed its corn and potato suppliers that the company wishes to avoid GE crops, but acknowledges that canola or other oils and ingredients in its products may be from GE sources.

soda and juice drinks

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS sodas Coca Cola Coca Cola
Sprite Cherry Coke Barq's Root Beer Minute Maid Orange
Minute Maid Grape Surge Ultra PepsiCo Pepsi Slice
Wild Cherry Pepsi Mug Root Beer Mountain Dew Cadbury/Schweppes
7-Up Dr. Pepper A & W Root Beer Sunkist Orange Schweppes Ginger Ale juice drinks Capri Sun juices (Kraft/Phillip Morris)
Red Berry Surfer Cooler Splash Cooler Wild Cherry Strawberry Kiwi Fruit Punch Pacific Cooler Strawberry Orange Grape
Fruitopia (Coca Cola) Grape Beyond Berry Lemonade Fruit Integration Kiwiberry Ruckus Strawberry Passion Tremendously Tangerine Fruit Works (PepsiCo) Strawberry Melon Peach Papaya
Pink Lemonade Apple Raspberry Gatorade (Quaker) Lemon Lime
Orange Fruitpunch Fierce Grape Frost Riptide Rush Hawaiian Punch (Procter & Gamble) Tropical Fruit Grape Geyser Fruit Juicy Red Strawberry Surfin Hi-C (Coca Cola) Pink Lemonade
Watermelon Rapids Boppin' Berry Tropical Punch Smashin' Wildberry Blue Cooler Blue Moon Berry Orange Cherry Kool Aid
(Kraft/Phillip Morris) Blastin' Berry Cherry Bluemoon Berry
Kickin' Kiwi Lime Tropical Punch Wild Berry Tea Ocean Spray
Cranberry Juice Cocktail Cranapple CranGrape CranRaspberry
CranStrawberry CranMango Squeeze It (Betty Crocker/General Mills) Rockin' Red Puncher Chucklin' Cherry Mystery 2000 Sunny Delight (Procter & Gamble) Sunny Delight Original Sunny Delight With Calcium Citrus Punch Sunny Delight California Style Citrus Punch
Tang juices (Kraft/Phillip Morris) Orange Uproar Fruit Frenzy
Berry Panic Tropicana Twisters (PepsiCo) Grape Berry Apple Raspberry Blackberry Cherry Berry Cranberry Raspberry Strawberry
Pink Grapefruit Tropical Strawberry Orange Cranberry Orange Strawberry Banana V-8 (Campbells) V8 Tomato Juices (all varieties) Strawberry Kiwi Strawberry Banana Fruit Medley Berry Blend Citrus Blend Apple Medley Tropical Blend Island Blend

soup

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS Campbell's Tomato Chicken Noodle Cream of Chicken Cream of Mushroom Cream of Celery Cream of Broccoli Cheddar Cheese Green Pea Healthy Request Chicken Noodle
Cream of Chicken Cream of Mushroom Cream of Celery

Campbell's Select Roasted Chicken with Rice Grilled Chicken with Sundried Tomatoes Chicken Rice Vegetable Beef

Chunky Beef with Rice Hearty Chicken & Vegetable Pepper Steak
Baked Potato with Steak & Cheese New England Clam Chowder

Soup to Go Chicken Noodle Chicken Rice Garden Vegetable Vegetable Beef & Rice

Simply Home Chicken Noodle Chicken Rice Garden Vegetable
Vegetable Beef with Pasta

Healthy Choice (ConAgra) Country Vegetable Fiesta Chicken
Bean & Pasta Chicken Noodle Chicken with Rice Minestrone
Pepperidge Farms (Campbell's) Corn Chowder Lobster Bisque
Chicken & Wild Rice New England Clam Chowder Crab Soup
Progresso (Pillsbury) Tomato Basil Chicken Noodle Chicken & Wild Rice Chicken Barley Lentil New England Clam Chowder
Zesty Herb Tomato Roasted Chicken with Rotini Fat Free Minestrone
Fat Free Chicken Noodle Fat Free Lentil Fat Free Roast Chicken

tomatoes and tomato sauces

GENETICALLY ENGINEERED INGREDIENTS Del Monte (Nabisco/Phillip Morris)
Tomato Sauce Five Brothers Pasta Sauces (Lipton/Unilever) Summer Vegetable Five Cheese Roasted Garlic & Onion Tomato & Basil
Healthy Choice Pasta Sauces (ConAgra) Traditional Garlic & Herb Sun-Dried Tomato & Herb Hunts (ConAgra) Traditional Spaghetti Sauce Four Cheese Spaghetti Sauce Tomato Sauce Tomato Paste Prego Pasta Sauces (Campbells) Tomato, Basil & Garlic
Fresh Mushroom Ricotta Parmesan Meat Flavored Roasted Garlic & Herb Three Cheese Mini-Meatball Chicken with Parmesan Ragu Sauces (Lipton/Unilever) Old World Traditional Old World with Meat
Old World Marinara Old World with Mushrooms Ragu Robusto Parmesan & Romano Ragu Robusto Roasted Garlic Ragu Robusto Sweet Italian Sausage Ragu Robusto Six Cheese Ragu Robusto Tomato, Olive Oil & Garlic Ragu Robusto Classic Italian Meat Chunky Garden Style Super Garlic Chunky Garden Style Garden Combo Chunky Garden Style Tomato, Garlic & Onion Chunky Garden Style Tomato, Basil & Italian Cheese
Pizza Quick Traditional

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

While that IS true, the term "hybrid" also covers genetically engineered plants. I gave a couple of examples in this article (nectarines, tangelos, etc)

Wrong. They are hybrids done by traditional methods. GMO's mean actually chemically altering the DNA of fruit.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Mike,

The consumer should be allowed to know what they are eating. There is a reason that Monsanto is fighting labeling. Many people wouldn't buy GMO's if they had the choice.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Exactly Mike, and that is one of many issues I have a problem with.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Put another way

Wait a minute "If you think it's butter but it's SNOT ?

That can't be right, can it?

Oh but it's NOT

Oh, that's different isn't it?

Sorry Pat N, I'm feeling smart-ass today; I owe ya' one.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Yes it is. But as I have said repeatedly, rarely does that cross pollination occur naturally. Hybrids simply are not "natural" in most cases. Which is why the vast majority of them don't reproduce from their own seeds. They are a mutation and one that usually occurs because humans forced the issue.

Yes they require human intervention (although the do occur naturally, too, hence the huge varieties of tomato plants)They are created in one of two ways, neither of them requiring the actual altering of the DNA of the plant in a lab. The first is just your normal crosspollinationwhich requires nothing more than a cotton ball and a blooming plant. The other way is by grafting, which is cutting a branch off of one plant and grafting it onto another. Neither requires chemical alterations.


GMO plants have been cleared by the FDA as safe. But since the food has only entered our markets since 1990

Thats a false statement. Many food manufacturers have been using GMO's for eons. Heinz, Kraft, Kellogs, General Mills...the list is endless.

No it is not:

The first genetically modified plant was produced in 1983, using an antibiotic-resistant tobacco plant. In 1994, the transgenic Flavr Savr tomato was approved by the FDA for marketing in the US - the modification allowed the tomato to delay ripening after picking. [2] In the early 1990s, recombinant chymosin was approved for use in several countries, replacing rennet in cheese-making. [13]

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Which only goes to show what an uneducated consumer will buy. They are kept in the dark bylabeling.

Where did you find that list Pat? From an organic site I am sure, since I have seen it, too. There are plenty of new products out there that contain no GMO's. All one has to do is walk into a Whole Foods to find them. But there is the rub. Non GMO foods are more expensive and therefore hard for most families to afford.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

I haven't even touched on foodstamp entitlements. Are you willing to have the costs double or triple so the poor can afford to buy their breakfast cereal and bread when Kellog's andGeneral Millsare forced to go "organic"?

I should have known there was some other angle to this discussion. Just for clarification... my discussion is about the labeling of GMO's and not the social issues. As for people who use foodstamps, I am not suggesting that we increase the amount of the foodstamps. I am saying give consumers the choice.

How about pasture fed, so called "organic" beef? What if they were grazing on land that once had a tangelo tree on it? Label the beef as a GMO?

They are not supposed to be fed GMO food, hence the wordorganic.

How about pasture fed, so called "organic" beef? What if they were grazing on land that once had a tangelo tree on it? Label the beef as a GMO?

Don't worry that doesn't happen. Once the DNA of GMO food shows up and the Monsanto police find it, the product becomes GMO and property of Monsanto.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

hybridization - crossbreeding (individuals of two different species or varieties of an animal or plant breeding with an individual of another species or variety). This is a fertilization process and while it can be human-assisted, any genetic differences in the offspring (the hybrid individual) is naturally-occurring rather than the result of DNA engineering.

The offspring of such fertilization can result in significant differences in the chromosome numbers from those of the "parent" organisms which can often result in the hybrid being infertile.

In animals, the female hybrid animal can become pregnant, though not easily, while the male hybrid is completely sterile. Liger and tigon males are both sterile hybrids; female tigons and ligers are usually fertile. The mule, which is a result of crossbreeding between a female horse and a male donkey, is also sterile.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Robert,

You are a hybrid. The genes from two parents. But you were not a GMO. You were not created in a lab. Dolly the sheep is a GMO. So unless there is a clone of you somewhere, you are a naturally created hybrid.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Nice find Barb.. and OMG, Matt is about to use Scott seeds in my back yard. Well, this ends the argument for me. Sod it is!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

If the melonsexistsalready, there would be no need to do all this fancy insertion of the gene into our melons, since we would just buy the seed. The moment we start to mess around with the genes, there is apossibilitythat an unwanted gene could also be introduced and therefore would make that melon a GMO.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Which only goes to show what an uneducated consumer will buy. They are kept in the dark by labeling.

How? If the labelon a loaf of bread says anything more than "organic wheat flour, water, salt", one can assume it's a GMO. Are people really so dense that they need a hugelabel on the front of the package that screams: "Hi There! I'm a GMO! I'm the product your media warned you about!!!"

Can people really not educate themselves on what to look for on currently existing labels if they want to avoid GMO's?

Also..what would you like to see labeled? Do you think a non GMO crop stored in a bin that previously held a GMO crop should be labeled GMO? What are the parameters for this labeling everyone wants?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Perrie -

What is preventing people from knowing whether or not they are eating GMO's now?

If someone out there thinks a tangelo is a "natural" product...then I would say the onus is on thenm to educate themselves. It's all right there in a labels already. If a person knows what to look for. And a quit minute googling will tell a person what companies to avoid.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

I should have known there was some other angle to this discussion.

No angle, dearie. Which is why I didn't touch on it. And why I didn't touch on it in a previous article I did on organics. I just love the paranoid accusations coming from the admin of this site, though. Reminds me of a certain other site.

If you think there is some nefarious intent behind this article Perrie...just come out and say it instead of playing coy and grandstanding, OK?

Since your mindreading skills seem to be failing you today, the intent behind this article is the fact that I live in a heavy farming state and you people who freak out about GMO's...which have been deemed 100% safe, are trying to kill the farming way of life even more than it already has been. Of course, you east coasters, "life is awesome in New Yorkers" have all the answers to the Midwest, right?

Time to find a new site. It's really bullshit when admin accuses you of untrue bullshit.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

And what is wrong withlabelingthe food. Why should the consumer have to search the internet to find out what they are consuming? Who are you protecting, the business or the consumer? I happen to believe in Consumeradvocacy. I tend not to trust big corporations when it comes to my health.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

So in Perrie's mind...test tube babies are GMO's. Gee. I'm sure their parents would love to hear that.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Thank you for telling me what is in my mind Pat. That must be an amazing skill! LOL!

Test tube babies have only the DNA of their parents. One egg... one sperm. No messing around with the DNA of thefertilizedegg afterwards. Hence not a GMO.

Pat, I taught Biology for 20 years. I even worked in DNA lab as part of my training before I taught. This is one subject that I can cross my T's and dot my I's

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    13 years ago

The farmer who crossed the plant initially didnt have seed stock to sell to the world... so scientists studied the plant to find out it had a double copy of a specific gene.

I'm only posing this because this is real world. In the real world, a plant makes this awesome stock... and everyone wants it. Because it is unique... as unique as you are... there is no physical way to get it to seed enough to get exactly that plant, exactly every time, exactly as it was made.

That would be like me asking you to have enough offspring to populate an entire state of really neat yous...

Genetics is a little more advanced than sticking random genes in and hoping the right one fits... so I dont really know where the error would come in. Now... if they completely design the gene from scratch... that's different.

Again... I am not against labeling... it is just WAY MORE complex of an issue than people realize. WAY MORE!

I think a good one would be "genetically modified for chemical resistence"... that would be an excellent label... proving it... overseeing it... and actually making companies abide by it would be an expense that I have no resources for.

I mean... most of the GMO crowd doesnt trust the FDA... doesnt trust Monsanto... short of hiring another government (who would YOU trust?) to verify the labeling aspect... wtf logically can we do?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

GMO's...which have been deemed 100% safe,

Not so sure about that, Pat.

Unintended GMO Health Risks

Genetically modified foods: YES, you are already eating them. NO, they are not safe to eat.

Did you know... since 1996 Americans have been eating genetically modified (GM) ingredients in most processed foods.

Did you know... GM plants, such as soybean, corn, cottonseed, and canola have had foreign genes forced into their DNA. And the inserted genes come from species, such as bacteria and viruses, that have never been in the human food supply.

Did you know... genetically modified organisms (GMOs) are not safe. They have been linked to thousands of toxic and allergenic reactions, thousands of sick, sterile, and dead livestock, and damage to virtually every organ and system studied in lab animals.

Find out what the risks are and start protecting yourself and your family today!

Why isn't the FDA protecting us?

In 1992, the Food and Drug Administration claimed that they had no information showing that GM foods were substantially different from conventionally grown foods and therefore were safe to eat. But internal memos made public by a lawsuit reveal that their position was staged by political appointees under orders from the White House to promote GMOs. FDA scientists, on the other hand, warned that GMOs can create unpredictable, hard-to-detect side effects, including allergies, toxins, new diseases, and nutritional problems. They urged long term safety studies, but were ignored.[1] The FDA does not require any safety evaluations for GMOs. Instead, biotech companies, who have been found guilty of hiding toxic effects of their chemical products, are now in charge of determining whether their GM foods are safe. (The FDA official in charge of creating this policy was Michael Taylor, Monsanto's former attorney and later their vice president.)

Although these biotech companies participate in a voluntary consultation process with the FDA, it is a meaningless exercise. The summaries of the superficial research they submit cannot identify most of the health risks of GMOs.[2]

Genetic modification is radically different from natural breeding

In contrast to the statements of biotech advocates, FDA scientists and others affirm that genetic modification is not just an extension of the conventional breeding techniques that have been used by farmers for millennia. Genetic engineering transfers genes across natural species barriers, using imprecise laboratory techniques that bear no resemblance to natural breeding. Furthermore, the technology is based on outdated concepts of how genes and cells work.[3]

Widespread, unpredictable changes

Gene insertion is done either by shooting genes from a "gene gun" into a plate of cells or by using bacteria to invade the cell with foreign DNA. The altered cell is then cloned into a plant. These processes create massive collateral damage, causing mutations in hundreds or thousands of locations throughout the plant's DNA.[4] Natural genes can be deleted or permanently turned on or off, and hundreds may change their levels of expression.[5]

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Robert is not a hybrid as his parents are both of the same species. He and I disagree politically but I find him to be fully human.

There is a chromosome difference in male and female human individuals which determines the sex of the children (so-called X and Y chromosomes, XX=female, XY=male), but hybrids result from different species.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Matt is about to use Scott seeds in my back yard. Well, this ends the argument for me. Sod it is!

Is that SOD-omy?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Wrong. They are hybrids done by traditional methods. GMO's mean actually chemically altering the DNA of fruit.

"Wrong" backathya, babe. Tangelos and nectarines are GMO's. Really, Perrie...this habit you've developed of acting like you're an expert on everything since the site saw an influx of people is really unbecoming. (I know, I know...I have some ulterior motive again for saying that)

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

No angle, dearie. Which is why I didn't touch on it. And why I didn't touch on it in a previous article I did on organics. I just love the paranoid accusations coming from the admin of this site, though. Reminds me of a certain other site.

OMG Pat. That was totally uncalled for. When I am writing in black, as I am now, I am just another member here stating my opinion, which obviously you don't like. And yes, the moment YOU introduced foodstamps into the discussion on GMO's that is a new angel. That isn't paranoia... it's a fact. The fact that I am not taking this as an insult to my ethics, proves that this isn't like some other site.

If you think there is some nefarious intent behind this article Perrie...just come out and say it instead of playing coy and grandstanding, OK?

Talk abouthyperbole! Nefarious intent? Playing coy? LOL Pat.. how coy am I playing it, if I call you out on it?

Since your mindreading skills seem to be failing you today, the intent behind this article is the fact that I live in a heavy farming state and you people who freak out about GMO's...which have been deemed 100% safe, are trying to kill the farming way of life even more than it already has been. Of course, you east coasters, "life is awesome in New Yorkers" have all the answers to the Midwest, right?

You mean those same mind reading skills that you used on me in your comment to Robert? OK so here is a fun fact... NYS is an agricultural state. We are number 2 in apple production (Hence the big apple state) number 1 in Milk production.. hey that means we also grow corn and wheat... You do know that up state is all rural and farms, right, as is the most of Suffolk county on Long Island. So this isn't a case of the big city girl who wants to crush farmers. This is about corporations who have forced farmers to use corporate seed or be put out of business. And guess what.. Many midwestern farmers agree.

Time to find a new site. It's really bullshit when admin accuses you of untrue bullshit.

Oh please. I challenge your article with some science and then you introduce foodstamps and you put the blame that I am trying to accuse you of anything? If my comments were in purple you would have had a case... and even with the insults to myintegritythey are still not in purple. No one is making you move on, but yourself, which would be a shame. And again, I am only a member here when I post in black.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

That's from an agenda driven site, AMac. And while they make some good points, they are not the ultimate decision maker on whether or not a food is safe for human consumption. The FDA is. Anhd they have determined that GMO's are safe.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The PROFITEERS, be they the blood-money war kind, the energy companies and/or health insurance variety all are pimped by the legislators whose pockets they line.

Killing the planet one-citizen or one soldier or one ecosystem or one species-at-a-time is what profiteers do with no concern other than the bottom line.

That there is a resistance to labeling food products, that the legislator-pimps for the Canadian Tar Sands pipeline don't tell us what dangers are carried these are manifestations that can only continue because of the ill-informed, willingly duped populace. To be i.e. simultaneously pro-life and pro-pipe line is an oxymoronic state of mind predicated on ignorance.

Otherwise, I'm in a good mood today or I'd really kick some ass.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

It seems that whenever you are questioned upon your vast "intelligence" you become offensive in your approach, Pat. Accept the discussion without manifesting what isn't being manifested.

You've forgive me if your analysis of me...just like Perrie's unfounded suspicions of my "motives" for this article, carry little to no weight with me, right Jewel? Go critique someone who gives a happy crap.

Monsanto isn't just Genetically Modifying Crops it is guilty of over use of insecticides that cause great damage to the environment.

I believe I already said in the article that I also have issues with Monsanto. You apparently missed that part. But since you decided to pipe in...tell me, Jewel...just exactly how does one companies shitty business practices make all bio-engineered food "bad" and what is your alternative (which is what I asked in the article?) Or is this just something new to bitch about?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Well put Jewel.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Thank you for telling me what is in my mind Pat.

So what...turnabout isn't fair play in your little kingdom? I DO believe it was you that was implying I had some sort of "angle" regarding foodstamps for this article.

You reap what you sow, Perrie.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Robert is not a hybrid as his parents are both of the same species. He and I disagree politically but I find him to be fully human.

AWESOME way to explain it.

Tangelo = GMO (cross between tangerine and grapefruit...different species)

Robert = Organic? (cross between two of the same species)

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

enjoy your GMO's

I intend to. I love tangelos, graisens, pluots and Natural Harvest bread.

Best of luck with your homegrown, all organic wheat field, grinding stone and all natural baking powder with no preservatives for your bread.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Robert,

You are a hybrid.

Perrie...you are saying Robert is a hybrid and basing it on your "20 years of biology". AMac says he's not because his parents were of the same species. Can you explain why you think he's a hybrid?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

One thing our population has when it comes to feeding itself is they have relied upon fast foods and quick fixes that fill the void and nothing more.

Not sure what GMO's have to do with fast food and quick fixes since many, many products on the store shelves and in the fresh produce section would be deemed 'healthy' by anyone's standards and are GMO's.

Why eat processed and GMO foods

You know that "processed" and "GMO" are two different things, right? Why WOULDN'T someone on a tight budget eat a piece of fresh fruit that has been modified to be disease resistent and have a longer shelf life?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Until americans decide to take seriously the problem of unfettered consumption of oil, then the issue of the pipeline will remain. Instead americans demand that their gasoline be cheaper than water, and as a result, the need for keystone will exist.

One drives the other. Your logic is just going to lead to another oil crisis like happened in the 70s (either one of them). I am pretty sure you remember that one.

The oil crisis of the 70's was the result of a devalued dollar, 17% interest rates and price manipulation. We disagree on this one EI.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Let me jump in here and MODERATE but do so unofficially, more as a friend.

Can we keep comments more topical and less personal in nature?

Please.

 
 
 
Strangerthanfiction
Freshman Silent
link   Strangerthanfiction    13 years ago

Exactly Jewel, I agree with you 100%Grin.gif And A.Mac!

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Short and sweet: I have the right to know what I am putting into or onto my body, and in which manner it was produced.

Yes you do. So read the freaking label. If it says "Tyson"...it's genetically modified. If it says Kelloggs, or General Mills, or Hormel, or Kraft, or Heinz...it's genetically modified.

If the list of ingredients says "enriched" on it, it's likely genetically modified (most breads say "enriched wheat flour")

None of you who want labeling can answer the very simple question of what constitutes genetic modification, anyway. What would require a label, in your opinion? If grain from a non GMO crop was in the same truck that held a GMO crop previously, does that mean it's now "tainted" and should be labeled a GMO? What are the guidelines for this labeling y'all want?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Would love to. When administration quits accusing me of having ulterior motives for this article to bash the foodstamp system. That was uncalled for. And then to top it off, applauds others for being snarky.

Funny thing...she didn't even make a peep on my article about buying organic. I wonder what my ulterior motive was on that one.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Ummm... look at the time stamps Pat. I made this comment long before I read yours to me.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

And what is wrong with labeling the food.

For the last time...its already labeled. If you buy a loaf of bread that says "enriched wheat flour"...that flour is genetically altered. Same with any other product.

Does the consumer not bear ANY responsibility for knowing what they're ingesting? And you STILL haven't said what your thresholds are for requiring the labeling. If a crop has come in contact with a GMO crop, should it be labeled? Miss Diagnosed brought up a great example with maize/corn. Even so-called "organic" sweet corn has zero resemblence to it's maize ancestor. Should it be labeled GMO?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

OMG Pat. That was totally uncalled for. When I am writing in black, as I am now, I am just another member here stating my opinion, which obviously you don't like.

If you say so. From where I sit, it looks like you're using your own site for a bully pulpit.

Oh please. I challenge your article with some science

The gal who thumps her chest and says humans are hybrids and that tangelos aren't GMO's based on her 20 years in biology wants science. That's rich. And I'm just saying this to a "member of the site" by the way. Not an admin. Just doing what the site says I should do and "speaking my mind".

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

The PROFITEERS, be they the blood-money war kind, the energy companies and/or health insurance variety all are pimped by the legislators whose pockets they line.

I can actually agree with that. Hence, the reason I do what I can to grow as much as my own food organically. Which is far more that what the GMO bashers around here are willing to do.

It's funny. I point out that the GMO hysteria is overblown while simultaneously stating I encourage organic gardening. Suddenly, I'm a "GMO lover".

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Really, so you think that the OPEC nations refusing to sell oil to the US didn't have anything to do with it?

Manipulating supply for whatever reason(s) affects demand which inflates the price. Today the manipulation is primarily the work of the oil speculators on Wall Street, Goldman-Sachs for instance.

You want to fight back? Here's my plan. Pick one or two oil companies, say Exxon and BP. Have 20 million Americans start boycotting their gas stations. Eventually, what do you think they'll do to get their customers back how 'bout lower the cost of gasoline at their pumps?

The others will follow. Too much whining in America and not enough balls to tough-it-out. The NHL lockout could have been cut short had millions of hockey fans declared that "for every regular season game lost due to the lockout, we'll boycott an equal number of games when play resumes."

But God forbid some Boobus americanis hockey fans should have to read books for a hockey season instead of supporting the greed of owners and players.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Pat, gotta call foul on you a little. Perrie is commenting as a member, not as administration. What is she supposed to do, never make the slightest controversial comment

OK. That's fine then. I am more than willing to call her out on ludicrously stupid comments like "humans are hybrids" and "tangelos aren't GMO's" just like I would any other member. But I don't want to hear any comments from the peanut gallery on how she should be treated with more respect because she's an admin. That's happened a couple of times around here.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Mac,

Gonna dispute that. Let's talk about those tomatoes again. What is the difference between a Big boy tomato and a Beefsteak? They are tomatoes, but different breeds...hybrids.

Or dogs.. If I take a poodle andLabrador, I get a Labadoodle, a hypbred but still dog.

BTW almost everyone on earth (with the exception ofAfricans) have 3-4% DNA that is Neanderthal, which makes all of us hybrids.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Ummm... look at the time stamps Pat. I made this comment long before I read yours to me.

And what does that have to do with when I saw the various posts?

Back to the original topic. Can you, or can you not...tell me your alternative to these deadly killers like tangelos and nectarines?

What's your solution for feeding the world if we eliminate GMO's? Let 'em all starve to death?

Why do you think swine food should be organic?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

When administration quits accusing me of having ulterior motives for this article to bash the foodstamp system.

Pat, when an administrator or moderator comments as a MEMBER and not functioning in an "official" capacity, that kind of criticism is inappropriate. No one edited your comments nor removed any portion(s).

By all means disagree, rebut, etc., but do it member-to-member.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

I don't want to hear any comments from the peanut gallery on how she should be treated with more respect because she's an admin. That's happened a couple of times around here.

Pat no one has said that here and if they did I would tell them that they were wrong.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

By all means disagree, rebut, etc., but do it member-to-member.

As I stated elsewhere in this thread...I'm more than willing to do that. As long as the peanut gallery doesn't pipe in and say: "As founder of this site, you should show Perrie more respect"..which has happened on more than one occassion with a let-stoke-the-fires "thank you" from her.

If she's a member when she's in black, then she's a member. She can't be both at the same time.

So I will rephrase...I think that particular member showed a juvenile lack of class by claiming I had an ulterior motive about foodstamps based on one sentence I made and their comment amounted to nothing more than trolling.

There. Is that better? Smile.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

If you say so. From where I sit, it looks like you're using your own site for a bully pulpit.


How? Because I have a different opinion from you? Isn't that the point of a discussion? Sorry, but this is a subject that I am very passionate about.

Mac was wrong. Sorry Pat.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Now I am not so concerned about the plant/resulting foodstuff, it's that the plants now allow pretty much unfettered use of the herbicide, which is what I believe would be more identified with the resulting health problems.

That makes sense. I can understand people raising hell about herbicides and pesticides (and most fertilizers). They have been directly linked to health problems.

But freaking out about Total cereal, tangelos, Wheat Thins and Harvest Pride 12 grain bread because GMO's have been given a bad name due to Monsanto's shoddy business practices is a bit over the top for me.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Pat no one has said that here and if they did I would tell them that they were wrong.

With all due respect, Perrie...the last time that happened here, you thanked the individual. Which is precisely why I've been absent for a few weeks. I thought I'd give it another shot and see if things changed.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Charles....you said you have a right to know. I AGREED that you have a right to know and provided you with some ways that you CAN know. And that's a "cop-out"? Okkkkaaayyy.

Gee. I wonder if you're just looking for a fight? Nah. That couldn't be it.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

It matters not what precedes any given fertilization; if the male and female contributors that form the zygote are of the same species, the offspring is NOT a hybrid.

Dogs are all of the same species The domestic dog ( Canis lupus familiaris ). A breed is a variety within a species but still a member of that species. Even among humans, RACES are variations within one species, not hybrids.

In biology , a species (plural: species) is one of the basic units of biological classification and a taxonomic rank . A species is often defined as a group of organisms capable of interbreeding and producing fertile offspring. While in many cases this definition is adequate, the difficulty of defining species is known as the species problem . Differing measures are often used, such as similarity of DNA, morphology or ecological niche. Presence of specific locally adapted traits may further subdivide species into " infraspecific taxa " such as subspecies (and in botany other taxa are used, such as varieties , subvarieties, and formae).

Species hypothesized to have the same ancestors are placed in one genus , based on similarities. The similarity of species is judged based on comparison of physical attributes, especially their DNA sequences, where available. All species are given a two-part name , a "binomial name". The first part of a binomial name is the generic name , the genus of the species. The second part is either called the specific name (a term used only in zoology) or the specific epithet (the term used in botany, which can also be used in zoology). For example, Boa constrictor is one of four species of the Boa genus. The first part of the name is capitalized, and the second part has a lower case. The binomial name is written in italics when printed and underlined when handwritten.

Hybrids result ONLY from a fertilization generated by different species.

1.
the offspring of two animals or plants of different breeds, varieties, species, or genera, especially as produced through human manipulation for specific genetic characteristics.
2.
a person or group of persons produced by the interaction or crossbreeding of two unlike cultures , traditions, etc.
3.
anything derived from heterogeneous sources , or composed of elements of different or incongruous kinds: a hybrid of the academic and business worlds.
 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Mac was wrong. Sorry Pat.

Mac has provided a very detailed response that makes sense. I'm looking forward to you disputing it. Complete with definitions. I think it can be found on page 6 or 7 of this thread.

I'm sorry, but I'm more inclined to believe the information that is laid out in detail than believe: "The other poster is wrong".

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Yeah! Who NOSE who screwed up on that promo?

"If you think it's butter but it's SNOT it's Parkay."

Even NOSTRIL-damus couldn't have predicted that.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I haven't read the whole list, but someone please tell me "Wild Turkey" isn't there.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Back to the original topic. Can you, or can you not...tell me your alternative to these deadly killers like tangelos and nectarines?

They are not GMO's but hybrids. As for being deadly, that is what the whole GMO debate is about.

What's your solution for feeding the world if we eliminate GMO's? Let 'em all starve to death?

Most Heirloom varieties are hardy and will grow fine for their given places.

Why do you think swine food should be organic?

If you want non GMO's then you want them in everything, including pigs... since they are what they eat. If you don't care, then buy non organic pigs.

You are missing my point. As consumers, we areentitledto know what we are eating. Labeling is what I am about. And if Monsanto didn't think that this was a big deal, then they wouldn't be fighting against labeling.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

They are not GMO's but hybrids. As for being deadly, that is what the whole GMO debate is about.

I provided you with a link that clearly shows they are GMO's. You can plug your ears, scream LALALALALALALA!!! all you want and refuse to click on links, but tangelos, nectarines, pluots, graisens, etc...are GMO's whether you want them to be or not.

I know it's futile to provide more links, but I'm going to, anyway. I trust you will be able to provide counter-data that shows they AREN'T GMO's rather than you just running around, telling everyone they're wrong.

Hybrid corn, nectarines (which are genetically altered peaches), and tangelos
(which are a genetic hybrid of a tangerine and grapefruit) are all examples of
such breeding and selection. Food products produced through modern methods of
biotechnology such as recombinant DNA techniques and cell fusion are emerging
from research and development into the marketplace. It is these products that
many people refer to as "genetically engineered foods." The European Commission
refers to these foods as Genetically Modified Organisms. The United States uses
the term genetic modification to refer to all forms of breeding, both modern,
i.e. genetic engineering, and conventional.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

You picked those quotes carefully to prove your point and didn't include:

In general usage, hybrid is synonymous with heterozygous : any offspring resulting from the mating of two genetically distinct individuals

The third type of hybrid consists of crosses between populations , breeds or cultivars within a single species. This meaning is often used in plant and animal breeding, where hybrids are commonly produced and selected because they have desirable characteristics not found or inconsistently present in the parent individuals or populations. This flow of genetic material between populations or races is often called hybridization.

(biology)

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

any shenanigans on Wall Street have nothing to do with either Exxon-Mobil or BP, they make money regardless of the specific situation.

While I agree to a point, if there were boycotts as I described, both the speculators and the boycotted energy companies would be adversely affected. Speculators could manipulate supplies regardless, but the boycotted companies would still have to drive down oil prices in some way which would have a domino effect.

This has nothing to do with hockey. I like hockey, but guess what, I lived without it. But, and this goes back to my ORIGINAL POINT, the economy can't live without oil, and if steps aren't taken to ensure that supply, then you get what you bloody well pay for when shit happens.

The NHL boycott concept is an example of the strategy I described. And while the economy "can't live without oil," neither can the energy companies live with a dying economy. IT'S A SYMBIOTIC RELATIONSHIP THAT THE POLITICIAN-PIMPS ARE AWARE OF AND PRAY THE CITIZENRY WON'T COME TO REALIZE.

When demand is curtailed for ANY reason, there is a real or imminent SUPPLY GLUT. If legislator oil-pimp-shills thought a serious boycott were possible, the balance-of-power would shift to the public outrage and pro-action.

Far be it from me to use the phrase "Tea Party," but a real variation on that theme rather than the bullshit right-wing self-serving sham, would get big time attention from the paid off politicians that screw us continually.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

When administration quits accusing me of having ulterior motives for this article to bash the foodstamp system. That was uncalled for.

No it wasn't. If I had accused you first, before you made the foodstamp comment, then you would have a case. You introduced the foodstamp comment with how were we going to afford it without GMOs, and therefore it was fair game. As for saying something about an article about organics that I missed, well I'm sorry. But in fact, if you were saying buy organic, my only comment to you would be I agree.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

"As founder of this site, you should show Perrie more respect"..which has happened on more than one occassion with a let-stoke-the-fires "thank you" from her.

Pat, no one said that here. Not a single comment.

If she's a member when she's in black, then she's a member. She can't be both at the same time.

And I never said that I could be.

So I will rephrase...I think that particular member showed a juvenile lack of class by claiming I had an ulterior motive about foodstamps based on one sentence I made and their comment amounted to nothing more than trolling.

Nice one Pat. Calling me juvenile,classless and a troll. Please note... personal insults and still no purple.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Nice one Pat. Calling me classless and a troll.

Where did I call you classless and a troll, Perrie? I said you showed a lack of class and your COMMENT amounted to nothing more than trolling. Tweo things that you said were just fine and dandy on another article.

Yet you couldn't resist bringing up the threat of "purple" anyway, could you Perrie?

Please note... personal insults and still no purple.

I rest my case. You can't have it both ways. Tell me...just how many other "members" could have made that comment about 'purple' just now? ZERO.Make up your mind. Are you "just a member" when you post in black? Or is it a passive/aggressive wearing of both hats?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The third type of hybrid consists of crosses between populations , breeds or cultivars within a single species.

Then we're quibbling over terminology; the point is that in the strictest sense, hybrids result from two species I don't consider a "breed" etc., a hybrid, rather a morphological variation within the same species.

Is a Caucasian a different species from Asians, Blacks, etc. ? No. Races are populations within a species that are distinct in some way.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    13 years ago

Cell for cell, you are ~99% bacteria.

How's that for giving you the heebie geebies? :D

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

That's actually part of the problem. Does labelling food help if you can't understand the terminology?

Probably not. Thats why I think people should have to bear at least part of the burden on educating themselves. Really, all a person has to do is look for a few key words on their labels. "Enriched" is always a dead giveaway of a GMO. Or on the flipside...look for "organic" on the label to be safe.

There is so much rampant GMO hysteria going on out there, that a lot of the people freaking out about it, don't know that thanks to GMO's, we now have more insect resistent cotton which has reduced the need for pesticides (one of the REAL culprits, IMO) by over 80% for that crop or that GMO's are used extensively in oilseed crops where it's being used to reduce the production of the unhealthy oils.

All it is, is "gene technology" that tries to introduce a more insect resistent, drought tolerant, disease resistent plant.

Does organic taste better? Sure. Is it significantly "healthier"? There's no conclusive proof.

But GMO's are a necessity if we're going to continue feeding the world's starving and not run livestock farmers out of business.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Cell for cell, you are ~99% bacteria.

OK. That's just creepy. I'm picturing a low budget horror flick going on inside my body right now. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

No, you did not. Give me a list of every ingredient in the food and any method of production that alters the natural state of the food or adds to the ingredients and you will have provided me with the information I seek.

Well hell. That's an easy one. That would be everything.

Even planting the seeds or harvesting them 'alters the natural state of food'. I honestly can't think of a single plant...unless you include those found in the wild....wherein the natural state of the produce isn't altered, even by the most gentle, natural, organic techniques. Even drying and preserving heirloom seeds for the following season is an alteration of their natural state.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    13 years ago

I think that is that new fangled raw diet people go on and on about.

Grin.gif

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

I think that is that new fangled raw diet people go on and on about.

Don't even get me started.....17.gif

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Now a bowl of GMO sourced oatmeal, that is a different question.'

Only toothless old farts eat oatmeal. Grin.gif

And you wouldn't find me dead eating harvest pride 12 grain bread, but only because I find that they are quite frankly tasteless crap.

Yes, yes it is. But it makes a damn fine PB&J. Especilly when using GMO, JIF Chunky.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

With all due respect, Perrie...the last time that happened here, youthankedthe individual. Which is precisely why I've been absent for a few weeks. I thought I'd give it another shot and see if things changed.

Pat, I have norecollectionof the event. If you could please find it, so I can read the context of the discussion?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Pat, I have no recollection of the event. If you could please find it, so I can read the context of the discussion?

Are you serious? You want me to dig through every article I posted in from weeks ago to find it? Sorry. Not going to happen. It's not necessary, anyway. You just proved my point that you try to have it both ways with a comment you just made elsewhere in this article...while posting IN BLACK...and threatening "purple". Something no other member could ever do.

Now. I've attempted to get this back on the topic of GMO's. I request you do the same.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

John -

I thought it was cleared up back when I responded to AMac and I've made an attempt to get it back to the topic of GMO's since then. The other "member" (the only one who can make threats of *purple*) obviously doesn't want to move on.

Although, I WOULD like to know where I called ANYONE a troll. I thoroughly vetted awhile back, whether or not it was OK to say someone's COMMENT was trollish. I was told back then...by the very same person who is now calling it a "personal attack" and threatening purple...that it was A-OK to attack a person's comment. Apparently, those same rules don;t apply to that "member".

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

I rest my case. You can't have it both ways. Tell me...just how many other "members" could have made that comment about 'purple' just now? ZERO.Make up your mind. Are you "just a member" when you post in black? Or is it a passive/aggressive wearing of both hats?

5 other members could have said that. Every other mod. And since you were the one who accused ME of wanting it both ways. So I have to now point out to YOU when I don't get nor want any special treatment, since YOU accused me of wanting it. There is nothing passive aggressive about this. I am telling you head on, as a member that you insulted me, like any other member would do, when they are insulted. I am also pointing out to you, that no one here is makingspecialconsiderations for me, which is what you keep implying... no amend that...saying.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    13 years ago

Okay. Where all the hype comes from regarding GMO's is not from hybrids or cross pollination, it is from the perception (factually) that many of these foods are chemically altered rather than spliced, cross pollinated, etc.. Monsanto is an excellent example of a company chemically altering food to produce more and monopolize the industries they participate in. In contrast, a place like the DoA in Indio California using hybrid and splicing technology to create new strains. The distinction is clear. One is good, the other is horrible. ..and since it is the horrible version of GMO's most prevalent in the market, it is no small wonder that people are becoming more outraged at this.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

One is good, the other is horrible. ..and since it is the horrible version of GMO's most prevalent in the market

I have to ask. Is this comment speculative or fact based? Because I have seen no unbiased data that shows that chemically genetic engineered foods are more prevalent than just plain ol' genetically modified products. In fact, if I were a bettin' gal, I'd say the exact opposite is true.

As mentioned previously...I take issue with chemical modification. HOWEVER...freaking out about all GMO's because of Monsanto's business practices is waaaaayyyy over the top.

And I've noticed no one has yet answered my question on how they plan to continue feeding the world's starving if we eliminate GMO's.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    13 years ago

We arent even really trying to feed the starving. We pay farmers to stop growing crops because they wont sell when we should be having them grow more to send to starving people. That is not a profitable venture however. The whole, "we need more GMO's because of the poor starving people" is a straw man argument. It isnt real. In this, once again, companies like Monsanto are culpable. They are of course not alone. Tyson is one of the worst offenders on the planet as well, and there are several other companies doing the same shit.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

5 other members could have said that. Every other mod.

Which only reinforces my stance that you're trying to have it both ways while posting as a "member" in black. When you're in black, you are supposed to be a member and a member only. Not a mod. Members ONLY can not threaten purple, like you just did. If you want to threaten purple...just switch to purple.

I am telling you head on, as a member that you insulted me, like any other member would do, when they are insulted.

And out of the other side of your mouth, while posting as said "member" you are threatening me with purple, which no other 'regular' member can do. Hence, the reason you are trying to have it both ways.

If your insulted, fine. Be insulted. But pulling out the "purple"card when you're insulted is trying to have it both ways.

Now. I've asked you to get back on topic. I will give you the benefit of the doubt that you didn't see that request yet. So I will ask it one more time. If you don't comply..(again)...just who precisely do I report YOU to?

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    13 years ago

Personally, I'd like to see this get back on topic as well. I think the article is interesting, pertinent to life today, and in general, a worthwhile conversation/debate to have.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

We arent even really trying to feed the starving.

On the contrary. Nearly 100% of the seed we supply to third world countries to grow their own crops is drought resistent, pest resistent, GMO's. It's the only thing that will grow over there.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    13 years ago

Almost all third world nations have an infrastructure problem that creates these issues actually. I lived in a draught area, and we had dry farms that relied strictly on humidity and grew a plethora of food. The real issue with thrid world nations is always their governments. Properly allocated resources would prevent such rampant starvation, but instead, leaders tend to hoard in those environments, and promote warfare over welfare.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

I did get back on topic, Pat. And then somewhere else in this article I find I have to defend myself again.

You can report me to anyone. It has happened and I accept the consequences of that. Now with that cleared up, let's get back on topic as both you and Peter suggested.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Almost all third world nations have an infrastructure problem that creates these issues actually. I lived in a draught area, and we had dry farms that relied strictly on humidity and grew a plethora of food.

But as you pointed out, third world countries don't have the ability to do the same. Especially when you're talking about arid regions with low humidity.

The real issue with thrid world nations is always their governments. Properly allocated resources would prevent such rampant starvation, but instead, leaders tend to hoard in those environments, and promote warfare over welfare.

While I agree, I fail to see how that negates the fact that they do indeed, rely almost solely on GMO seeds for their crops, that doing so has helped reduce world hunger, and what you propose we replace these crops with if we say to the sharecropper in Zimbabwe..."Sorry. No more seeds for you."

I view this a lot like the DDT *crisis* a few decades ago. DDT was proven effective in reducing significantly, cases of malaria. Death due to malaria went down significantly. Then someone decided that the rise in cancer rates MUST be due to DDT useage, without a shread of evidence. So...the DDT stopped. Guess what happened? Deaths from malaria came back and the cancer rate remained the same.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    13 years ago

I just got a mental picture of a giant purple dildo fight...

Or maybe a purple star wars light sabre fight is more PC...

I'm going back to the dildoes.

No one save that quote for later... I will regret this post... aaagggghhhh

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    13 years ago

It seems to me that cases of cancer have actually increased quite a bit. While a percentage is genetic, many cases are bought about, or sped up by things like those DDT's and....diet as well. Now, I concede that is you are starving and desperate, you will probably eat pretty much anything you can. But, if you arent desperate, why would you? Why increase your chances at earning an early death? Cancer, heart disease, diabetes....three things that have reached epidemic status...not in third world nations, but in OUR nation. This can easily be traced to the various additives, chemicals, and so on that are consumed by people daily, or which they are exposed to regularly. Of course, it isnt exclusive to that. The biggest culprits are really excessive sugars, fats, and proteins. Nothing is had in moderation. But....many of those things are also modified. How many items can you find in your local grocer that dont contain high fructose corn syrup and/or partially hydrogenated oils. Not too many....that might seem like a different topic, but really, the discussion of GMO's in our diets also bleeds over into these things as well. What we're really talking about is whether a person accepts for themselves substandard food or not. As a rule, chemically altered foods are substandard.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    13 years ago

Too late. Quote saved and attributed to the correct source. :)

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    13 years ago

*Epic voice*

NNNnnnnnnnnnooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

I provided you with a link that clearly shows they are GMO's. You can plug your ears, scream LALALALALALALA!!! all you want and refuse to click on links, but tangelos, nectarines, pluots, graisens, etc...are GMO's whether you want them to be or not.

Those were not the orginal fruits we discussed. Here is the quote from page 7.

nectarines are a hybrid and not a GMO. Peaches occurnaturallyso there is no need to by a GMO one, although they doexist. T angelos are ahybridfruit and not a GMO. BTW, it has the same drug interactions as does grapefruit, so please take note.

Here is where I got the reference from:

It originated as a cross between a Duncan grapefruit and a Dancy tangerine?(same as Minneola described below?) W. T. Swingle of the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) is credited with creating the hybrid in 1911. When the Orlando tangelo was first cultivated, it was known by the name Lake tangelo. The trees of this variety grow to a large size and are easily recognized by their cup-shape leaves. Orlando tangelos are recognized as one of the more cold-tolerant varieties.

So only one of those other fruits were discussed previously.

Now to address your article from the FDA:

First, let me explain what we mean when we refer to food biotechnology or genetically engineered foods. Many of the foods that are already common in our diet are obtained from plant varieties that were developed using conventional genetic techniques of breeding and selection. Hybrid corn, nectarines (which are genetically altered peaches), and tangelos (which are a genetic hybrid of a tangerine and grapefruit) are all examples of such breeding and selection. Food products produced through modern methods of biotechnology such as recombinant DNA techniques and cell fusion are emerging from research and development into the marketplace. It is these products that many people refer to as "genetically engineered foods." The European Commission refers to these foods as Genetically Modified Organisms. The United States uses the term genetic modification to refer to all forms of breeding, both modern, i.e. genetic engineering, and conventional.

Notice that they make a difference between " conventional genetic techniques of breeding and selection" and " Food products produced through modern methods of biotechnology such as recombinant DNA techniques and cell fusion are emerging from research and development into the marketplace." It is the latter that I have a problem with, since they are actually messing around with the DNA cell structures. Unexpected outcomes are a realpossibilityand that is what I have a problem with.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Notice that they make a difference between "conventional genetic techniques of breeding and selection"

No they don't. Per your own copy/paste, they clearly state:

The United States uses the term genetic modification to refer to all forms of breeding, both modern, i.e. genetic engineering, and conventional.

Which is precisely the point I'm trying to make. Because of Monsanto's crappy business practices, people have become hysterical and think all GMO's are "bad". Genetically modified refers to ANY plant that has been modified genetically..whether by conventional or engineered methods.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

"Gregor Mendel, who is known as the "father of modern genetics", was inspired by both his professors at the University of Olomouc (i.e. Friedrich Franz & Johann Karl Nestler ) and his colleagues at the monastery (e.g., Franz Diebl) to study variation in plants, and he conducted his study in the monastery's 2 hectares (4.9acres) experimental garden, [10] which was originally planted by Napp in 1830. [8] Between 1856 and 1863 Mendel cultivated and tested some 29,000 pea plants ( i.e., Pisum sativum ). This study showed that one in four pea plants had purebred recessive alleles , two out of four were hybrid and one out of four were purebred dominant . His experiments led him to make two generalizations, the Law of Segregation and the Law of Independent Assortment , which later became known as Mendel's Laws of Inheritance."

Mac, all were peas and it's notice the process was hybrid

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

You are missing my point. As consumers, we areentitledto know what we are eating. Labeling is what I am about.

And you have yet to tell me what parameters you would place on that labeling, even though I've asked a number of times. If a non GMO crop travelled in a truk trailer that previously held a GMO crop, is it then 'tainted' and does it needa label? Should ALL corn be labeled GMO since it's no where near the same structure as it's maize ancestor? What would qualifiy a product, in your opinion, of having to carry the GMO label?

Even beef that qualifies for the "organic" label can be grainfed the last few weeks before slaughter. Should that change to labeling that beef as GMO beef?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

And you have yet to tell me what parameters you would place on that labeling, even though I've asked a number of times. If a non GMO crop travelled in a truk trailer that previously held a GMO crop, is it then 'tainted' and does it needa label? Should ALL corn be labeled GMO since it's no where near the same structure as it's maize ancestor? What would qualifiy a product, in your opinion, of having to carry the GMO label?

Most people would say that any veggy matter that has been altered in a lab on the cellular level would be what should belabeled. As for limits, I guess it goes to parts per million as they do with insect matter in our food, in the case of grains, and period checking of food marked as organic for other crops, which is not unreasonable since this is what Monsanto does

Even beef that qualifies for the "organic" label can be grainfed the last few weeks before slaughter. Should that change to labeling that beef as GMO beef?

True organic meat products are not supposed to be fed with GMO grains. But even organiclabelingis notstandardized.

As a consumer, here is a good guide for GMAs in our general food source:

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

all were peas and it's notice the process was hybrid

I can't argue with that; I think over time however, what Mendel considered a hybrid might now be more properly deemed a recessive individual.

IMPASSE (for now).

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

I disagree, since Medel is the father of Genetics.... but...

Impasse agreed... for now3.gif

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

It seems to me that cases of cancer have actually increased quite a bit. While a percentage is genetic, many cases are bought about, or sped up by things like those DDT's and....diet as well.

"Seems to you" doesn't constitute fact. And the facts are that Rachel Carson's book "Silent Spring"...which started the whole DDT hysteria in the first place, has been proven wrong by multiple sources. The woman should have been put on trial for mass murder, due to all of the malaria deaths she caused.

...

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

True organic meat products are not supposed to be fed with GMO grains. But even organic labeling is not standardized.

According to who? You? It's been standard practice with the USDA since they started "organic certification" that meat can be grain fed for up to two weeks before slaughter and GMO/non-GMO is not specified in that criteria.

So I'll ask again...on your labeling crusade, how would you like to see the meat labeled? Do you want to strip the organic certification label from a bunch of small family farms because they've done nothing wrong and adhered to USDA guidelines all these years?

And organic labeling is indeed, standardized. Very clear criterion has been laid out by the USDA and the FDA. Check their sites.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Get a life, Pat N.

I have one, thanks. Hope you're successful in that endeavor as well.

You know exactly what I mean.

Actually, I don't. You're talking in circles. You said you "had a right" (I'm having a hard time finding that *right* in the Constitution, but so be it) to know what's in your food. I agreed, and told you some ways you can decifer that by the label. You stuck out your lower lip, stomped your feet and said: "Thats a copout. What I REALLY mean is I wanna know ANY procedures that alter the product from its *natural state*!! That would be ALL food. When human intervention of any sort coaxes a plant to grow, confines it to a small area, harvests it...it alters it from it's natural state.

Again, you pouted and said it was a "copout". I don't even think YOU can clearly articulate what you want labels to say. It sounds like you want the packaging to be 10x larger so it can contain a label that reads like a book and you don't have to educate yourself on products.

Once again, your answer is a copout; nothing more and nothing less.

I think anyone reading through this thread will see the REAL copout is coming from the guy who keeps asking questions and then dismissing the answers with: "that's a copout".

 
 
 
Shub Orinuj
Freshman Silent
link   Shub Orinuj    13 years ago

need to get countries back into farming that left due to American goods being dirt cheap. America farmers will be able to grow less and maintain onlyAmericans. Is the world going to starve if this happens, no.

What would rather pay more of food or health bill?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

What would rather pay more of food or health bill?

You just gave me a great idea. I'd like to conduct an experiment. For six months (or however long the person who accepts this challenge specifies), I will eat nothing but GMO veggies and fruit and eat grainfed meat. My exercise and activity levels will remain at their current (fairly high) rate. My diet will not change. I will continue to eat less than 4 oz of red meat, 3 times a week and 2 servings of fresh fruits and veggies a day.

The person who accepts this challenge must eat nothing but organic meat and non GMO fruits and veggies. No cheating. Their activity levels must remain the same and their eating habits must not change.

At the end of the agreed upon period of time, we both go to the Dr. of our choice and report back to see which oneof us is healthier. Weight. Muscle mass. BMI. Cholesterol levels. Blood pressure. All of it must be reported.

Anyone game?

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Here's what we know; I feel that consumers have a right to know when the food they eat is not a natural product, such as plants that produce pesticides,

1) You DO see how your contradicting yourself by saying "here's what we KNOW", and then following it up with "I feel...", right?

2) Name one plant that produces pesticides. Pesticides are man made. No plant on earth produces pesticides.

3) There is a huge difference between plants treated with pesticides and GMO's. I've already said I'm not a fan of pesicides. By the same token, I have no problem with most genetically modified foods.

4) Pesticides are a no-no when it comes to ORGANIC food. Stop confusing organic and GMO's.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

What I haven't heard is sensible alternatives.

Why there are plenty of places to get non GMO seeds. Here is just one.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Isn't there a difference between genetically modified by breeding successive generations, (I'm thinking Mendel's pea plants), and genetically modified by inserting specific genes into the genome?

Somehow, one seems ok, and the other doesn't.

So, let's see. Scientists/horticulturists have bred azaleas for spectacular colors, longevity, and hardiness, but now they don't have any odor-- when the fragrance of azaleas were heavenly when I was a kid. Some of the Iris have been bred for longer bloom times, various beard colors, hues, shapes-- and they no longer smell as sweet, either. That is genetic modification, through selective breeding.

Siamese cats have been bred so that their eyes cross, and they are long and lean. But now, they can't see as well, and they have hip troubles. Same with a lot of dog breeds-- they have bred out the hardiness and bred in specific genetic difficulties. Also, genetic modification, through selective breeding.

Using gene splicing methods, scientists have changed the color of breeds of fish, so that they are unattractive to predators, but they taste like crap. Scientists have bred corn crops that are more resistant to pests, but who can tell anymore, because farmers use pesticides that have hydrolitic half lives of 180 days or longer...

I guess I'm confused. Maybe we should leave well enough alone and just let natural selection take over.

What really astonishes me is the level of hostility throughout the comments on this thread. Everyone seems to be very willing to gouge out each other's eyes. Oh well...

I had an organic garden, and my soil was awful. My one tomato fit in the palm of my hand, and I have small hands. The rest were eaten by some kind of bug whose larval stage ate the inside of the stems, killing the whole plant. The only cure for that is Severn. I didn't put any on it, because it was a grant, and I couldn't. But, had it been in my own backyard, I would have to do something.

I wish I had a spot for a garden here at my house-- I would try to grow heirloom tomatoes and other plants, just so they would taste like they did when I was a kid. I don't think that farmer's land can be as productive without chemical additives, and it is their living, after all-- but I sure do wish that they would pay more attention to what they're using, how to apply it, and what dosage to use.

I'm all for organic, but what is the organic that is being used? What does IT put in the ground and air? I have friends whose gardens are wonders of beauty. Stalks of celery that are tender and crisp, tomatoes overflowing the vines, carrots and radishes popping their shoulders up out of the soil, screaming, "Pick me! Pick me!" And I have friends that are likely more my type of gardeners-- they coax along a couple of tomatoes only for the squirrels to eat them before they're ripe.

I have no answers, but I do feel that maybe we need to be, in our own backyards, using more regular stuff, if only to keep the kinds of things alive. What I wouldn't give for an old-fashioned azalea bush, that smelled heavenly!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

LOL! I had an old-fashioned Siamese that wasn't cross-eyed, and in perfect shape until cancer got him. He was 16. BROKE my heart. My current Siamese/Burmese, has crossed-eyes, hip displasia, and is pigeon-toed. A genetic experiment gone bad. He's a rescue, and I love him dearly. But, I know he won't live as long as Mo. He is already suffering from old age affects at 7...

Sometimes, I think we're too much into changing things, and just need to let things be. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

yeah. I hear you!

Just because we CAN do something, doesn't mean that we SHOULD do something. Smile.gif

I miss my little Mo kitty and adore my little Boo-- who struggles to come up the steps with his twisted legs. It's not his fault. I'll take care of him for as long as he's not suffering, and then I'll help him go to heaven. He would do the same for me. Smile.gif

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    13 years ago

Pat,..while I like the article,..your commentto Perrieis uncalled for,...do you need to be reminded toagree ordiagreewith the comment but do not attack the commenter....

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

(sigh)....I see the 'defend admin' is still going on, and well over a week after we had ourt little tussle. I pop over to see whats going on and what's the last comment left on this article: "Shame on you, Pat! Evenb though the issue was resolved a week ago, shame on you for speaking your mind!" (as the site says to do)

Tell me, Lone....where did I attack Perrie rather than her comment? Or are you of the same mindset that if I say her comment amounted to "nothing more than trolling", I am therefore, calling her a troll? Because she certainly interpretted it that way, even though I clarified with her awhile back that stating a comment like that was A-OK on this site.

If you *like the article* so much, do you think that maybe...just maybe...you can bring yourself to stick to the topic of it, rather that rehashing something that Perrie and I already agreed to drop over a week ago?

On second thought, never mind. Don't bother. I will be on a plane to the Dominican Republic in 16 hours and won't be around to see it anyway. Possibly ever.

There is something really, really wrong with a site that moderates members in what's supposed to be an unmoderated group, has admin that flat out states that it's OK for 5 members to threaten 'purple', even when they are posting as members and not morerators, and people defend Admin. when they are posting as supoosed "members" at all costs.

And here I thought I'd be reading a comment about the article since everything had blown over long ago. Silly me. Expecting comments on actual articles around here, seems a little to much to ask for.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    13 years ago

Alright, enough Pat and Perrie bashing. It is my observation that the argument between both of them was inappropriate on both sides, and others adding to this argument have only dragged this out further. Please stay on topic. GMO's is the topic, and whatever tangents have been accepted from that base topic.

-Peter

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

If you *like the article* so much, do you think that maybe...just maybe...you can bring yourself to stick to the topic of it, rather that rehashing something that Perrie and I already agreed to drop over a week ago?

Yeah, I thought so, too.. until I read this:

There is something really, really wrong with a site that moderates members in what's supposed to be an unmoderated group, has admin that flat out states that it's OK for 5 members to threaten 'purple', even when they are posting as members and not morerators, and people defend Admin. when they are posting as supoosed "members" at all costs.

About that unmoderated group and your supposed understanding how the site works and that event... there was a IM that you were notprivyto, that was part of the issue. It was anunusualsituation, one that even Bruce acknowledged in the article in question. And to clarify, I didn't ban anyone. Peter put the individual on suspension for a very serious violation, an action I stand behind him on, given the circumstances. That is about as much full disclosure as I can give the membership, without breaching confidentiality, since we value that, even for asuspendedmember.

And no where did I ever:

flat out states that it's OK for 5 members to threaten 'purple', even when they are posting as members and not morerators".

I apparently made did make a vain attempt to explain what the limitations of the mods are, that you chose either to ignore or twist my words. Also, I am not the admin here. I am the Resident Adviser. A title that was carefully chosen by the community to show that I carry no special rank here other than to take carry out the will of the group.

So your comment here today, that I also thought had been put to bed even by your own words:

rehashing something that Perrie and I already agreed to drop over a week ago?

Is obviously you rehashing what happened and then some to a comment that was now days old.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    13 years ago

This argument needs to end now. It has gone well beyond the bounds of what is appropriate. I'm asking both Pat and Perrie to honor the impasse I saw called elsewhere here. If you have any further issues with one another or the site as a whole, take it to Heated Discussions or communicate via IM...or just move on to other conversations.

-Peter

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    13 years ago

Stay on topic??? Excuse me,..but how is responding directly to a comment made by the author of the article not staying on topic??? if the author changed the topic or went off topic herself then how is it against the rule to respond in kind or directly to her comment!!

"Speak your Mind..." oh wait that doesn't apply here does it.....So now we know only the author of an article can speak their mind,...got it....24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

\
The entire tangent is inappropriate. Any further additions by anybody to the argument that has taken place will be deleted.

-Peter

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Cited and Acknowledged Peter.

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    13 years ago

Not trying to start any trouble or to stir the pot as it were,...but I would like to clarify something. I said I liked the article,..and several people questioned why I had not left a comment about the article if I liked it so much.

I read as many articles as I can, some I just click on the like button some I leave acomment and others I just read and leave.I read articles from those of whom I don't care for, I read from those who I do like and I read articles from those whom I do not know.

leaving a comment that says I liked the article is much like eating a serving of peas. I like peas and I will tell people that I like peas,...However, unless the peas are prepared in such a way that is just remarkable I will just say I like the peas and leave it at that....LR

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

When I had a C-section, I ate about two handfuls of red jelly beans before I was cut off from food and water. Legend had it that if you did that, you got no gas afterwards. For me, it worked-- No gas. Something magical about those red jelly beans.

And gas as in inside, between your innards and your skin, not in normally gaseous places. Up around your shoulders and up under your shoulder blades. Quite painful, from what I hear... Smile.gif

 
 
 
Tony M.
Freshman Silent
link   Tony M.    13 years ago

I just stumbled upon NT after searching Google for the term "GMO Hysteria". I've read this thread and found it extremely informative, and relatively polite. Relative, at least to the conversations I've had on Facebook about this topic.

Please excuse me if adding to this thread a month after it was started is a faux pas here. On some boards it would be, but since I've found a crowd that can discuss this topic calmly and intelligently, I'd like to pose a question that I did not find an answer to.

The main argument of the anti-GMO crowd is that they have not been in existence long enough to know the long term danger. How long is long enough? Monsanto's 20 year patent on Roundup Ready is about to expire. If 20 years is not good enough, what is?

Am I wrong to assume that if the answer is "never", that the argument is based on a philosophical objection, not a scientific one?

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Spot on EI. Not many know that there are only four strains of Wheat that are made wide use of across the world these days.

Can you imagine what would happen to that source of food if someone were to develop a bacteria or virus that was capable of attacking just one of those strains?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

It seems that GMO's are tied to the bee coloney collapse syndrome

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    13 years ago

I know organic is a different category but, since many anti-GMO folks trust organic, you may be interested in the following:

Tuesday, 04 June 2013 12:49

Expert Questions Legitimacy of Organic Food Certification

Written by Alex Newman

The so-called organic foods industry may not be as natural as consumers have been led to believe, owing to a lack of serious testing and other major flaws in the system, according to a former inspector of organic foods in the United States and Canada who grew up on an organic farm. What the expert described as the globalist environmental movement George Soros, for example, and others like him is also deeply involved in promoting organic foods, he explained.

In an interview with The New American , Mischa Popoff, who serves as a policy advisor to the Heartland Institute and wrote a book exposing the inside story of the organic industry , explained that much of the certification process for organic produce today essentially amounts to a scam. The crux of the problem, he said, is that there is no field testing of organic crops or livestock anywhere in the world.

More:

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

How about pasture fed, so called "organic" beef? What if they were grazing on land that once had a tangelo tree on it? Label the beef as a GMO?

The term "Organic' on a food label has a definite meaning. The U.S. Dept. of Agriculture has very specific criteria that must be met in order for food to be labeled organic-- and they are strict about it. (I don't what all their standards are, but anyone who's interested can google it).

I have heard people wonder about how to tell if a particular item of food is GMO or not, since labeling food GMO is not required. However, there's one easy way to tell-- according to the USDA, food labeled "organic" must not contain any GMO ingredients. So if anyone wants to avoid GMO food, you can do so by buying only organic. (I do not know what criteria the USDA uses to define "GMO").

After reading up on food and health (and particularly toxins and additives) I decided to go vegan-- and also eat only organic food 95% of the time. I don't know all that much about GMO food, but if there's even a chance its not healthy that's sort of irrelevant to me as I eat only organic (and therefore not GMO).

So the term "Organic" on food has a definite meaning. (Although not all words on food labels do-- for example "All natural" is more or less meaningless).

 
 
 
Tony M.
Freshman Silent
link   Tony M.    13 years ago

It seems? What evidence do you have of a link? My understanding is that the connection is speculative at best.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Total cereal is bad for you, because it's processed crap.

That brings up an interesting point-- there are other important factors besides (or in addition to) GMO. As I mentioned previously, since I eat almost entirely only organic, GMO is not an issue for me.

I was unfamiliar with Total, so I googled to see the ingredients-- its not something I would eat!

Most Americans consume too much Sodium-- Total has added salt. It also has added sugar and added corn syrup. Most packaged foods have added sugar and salt. Why is this necessary?

It has non-fat milk added. There is a link between high consumption of dairy and increased risk of Osteoporosis and weak bones (contrary to the propaganda of the dairy lobby). Also, it appears that excess diary consumption may be correlated specifically with increased risk of Pncreatic Cancer. Obviously there's not a lot ofm it in Totl-- butt why is it necessary?

Monoglycerides are fatty acids that are added to increase shelf life and product stability.

Generally speaking, chemicals add as preservatives are not healthy. And we already have too much fat in our diet.

It also has added BHT, which I believe is not healthy. Plus other stuff.

Why all these extra ingredients?

And I beleive the grains are not organic.

And it has added vitamins and minerals-- not good.

Interestingly, tonight I went shopping at Whole Foods. They had Arrowhead Mills Shredded Wheat on sale-- I bought two boxes. (Full disclosure: Arrowhead Mills is a division of Hain-Celestial-- I own share ofnhat company Smile.gif ). After reading abut the ingredients in Total, I became curious-- just went to the pantry and checked the ingredients of that cereal-- got a big laugh.

Then I opened it and tasted it (never had this cereal before). Very tasty.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Now a bowl of GMO sourced oatmeal, that is a different question.'

Only toothless old farts eat oatmeal. Grin.gif

I used to eat a bowl of Oatmeal every day as a kid! (Of course by that time I already had teeth).

Seriously though-- whole grains are very healthy. Lots of fiber, anti-oxidants, and some good vitamins. Oats are especially high in soluble fiber-- that's powerfully the kind that lowers total cholesterol and I believe it lowers LDL as well.

And BTW-- generally speaking the more processed a food is, and the more ingredients it has, the less healthy it is. And, interestingly, generally speaking the more processed a food is, then higher the profit margin for the manufacturer (you pay for the processing). Most breakfast cereals have a high mark-up and nice profits for the mfgrs.

One nutritionist I know had this advice:

Never eat anything that has a label.

(Meaning a label with several ingredients. An exaggeration, but I see his point. Oat cereal should be Oats-- not Oats plus 5 or 6 or 10 0r 12ingredients. The odds are that all the preservatives, food colours, texturizers, emulsifiers, etc, etc are chemicals that may be linked to increased incidence of various diseases. As is excessive consumption of sodium, sugars, high fructose corn syrup. (Trans-fats are dangerous even when eaten in moderation).

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

organic doesn't mean anything in the US,

WTF are you talking about???

That sounds like something you just made up-- because actually, it does mean something. In fact, it means a lot!!!

The US Dept of Agriculture has specific criteria that must be met before something can be labeled ...

What does organic mean?

Simply stated, organic produce and other ingredients are grown without the use of pesticides, synthetic fertilizers, sewage sludge, genetically modified organisms, or ionizing radiation. Animals that produce meat, poultry, eggs, and dairy products do not take antibiotics or growth hormones.

The USDA National Organic Program (NOP) defines organic as follows:

Organic food is produced by farmers who emphasize the use of renewable resources and the conservation of soil and water to enhance environmental quality for future generations. Organic meat, poultry, eggs, and dairy products come from animals that are given no antibiotics or growth hormones.

Organic food is produced without using most conventional pesticides; fertilizers made with synthetic ingredients or sewage sludge; bioengineering; or ionizing radiation.

Before a product can be labeled "organic," a Government-approved certifier inspects the farm where the food is grown to make sure the farmer is following all the rules necessary to meet USDA organic standards. Companies that handle or process organic food before it gets to your local supermarket or restaurant must be certified, too. (Link)

Which raises an interesting question-- why do you keep posting false information on NT? If you don't know something-- why not admit it-- instead of making things up?

(And you've done this before. If you don't know something, either google to find the facts-- or just admit you don't know. That's nothing to be ashamed of.

Don't you realize that if you keep posting things that are not true, eventually more and more people will catch on, and your credibility on NT will suffer even more? )

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

If the list of ingredients says "enriched" on it, it's likely genetically modified (most breads say "enriched wheat flour")

I googled for the definition:

Enriched Food
A comestible/food product to which various nutrientse.g., vitamins and mineralshave been added to compensate for essential nutrients removed by refinement
Does that mean that adding vitamins to a food make it "GMO" (genetically modified)?
 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I know organic is a different category but, since many anti-GMO folks trust organic, you may be interested in the following:

Tuesday, 04 June 2013 12:49

Expert Questions Legitimacy of Organic Food Certification

Don't believe everything you read on the Internet!

That site is a really crackpot site run by extremist political crazies with a bizarre political agenda! About as much credibility as Alex Jones, or Veterans Today. (Frankly I'm surprised you posted a link from a weirdo site like that).

 
 

Who is online







106 visitors