Defining Deviency Downward -- Planned Parenthood Official Argues for Right to Post-Birth Abortion
Alisa LaPolt Snow, the lobbyist representing the Florida Alliance of Planned Parenthood Affiliates, testified that her organization believes the decision to kill an infant who survives a failed abortion should be left up to the woman seeking an abortion and her abortion doctor.
"So, um, it is just really hard for me to even ask you this question because Im almost in disbelief," said Rep. Jim Boyd. "If a baby is born on a table as a result of a botched abortion, what would Planned Parenthood want to have happen to that child that is struggling for life?
"We believe that any decision that's made should be left up to the woman, her family, and the physician," said Planned Parenthood lobbyist Snow.
Rep. Daniel Davis then asked Snow, "What happens in a situation where a baby is alive, breathing on a table, moving. What do your physicians do at that point?
"I do not have that information," Snow replied. "I am not a physician, I am not an abortion provider. So I do not have that information.
Rep. Jose Oliva followed up, asking the Planned Parenthood official, "You stated that a baby born alive on a table as a result of a botched abortion that that decision should be left to the doctor and the family. Is that what youre saying?
Again, Snow replied, That decision should be between the patient and the health care provider.
Tags
Who is online
106 visitors

Thanks for posting the rationale.
Are you defending the practice or simply being a resource provider?
The defense brings to mind George Orwell's Animal Farm and its redefinition of terms; in this case changing ""infanticide" to "after-birth abortion" and "infants" to "fetuses."
With suchlittle concern for born live viableinfants, is it any wonder that homosexual "marriage" is becoming so popular? Where children become devalued as a marriage end, the primary purposes become simply love and sex. Not that anythying is wrong nwithy love and sex but those things have not been the only purposes of marriage and civilization.
In ancient times infanticide was called "child sacrifice." Today it is "after-birth abortion."
I am sure that there are at least four SCOTUS justices who would be sympathetic to this practice, as they are to "same-sex marriage." It is interesting to note that two of them are unmarried women. Undoubtedly the president supports this too.
I endorse your view.
My other point was that we are in a culture war and it consists of various battles. The times, they are a'changin'.
People are choosing up sides.
Did anyone here watch the video... or are we going with the text of the article?
Only one was shocked during this meeting. They were clarifying some issues.
Alisa LaPolt never said that thedecisionto kill an infant...who survives a failed abortion should be left up to the woman seeking an abortion and her abortion doctor. She did insist that the wording of this new bill to surrender the right of the mother to the child's was at issue. I happen to disagree with her, and agree with the firstemergencydoctor on the video. She was specifically, unspecific about what planned parenthood would do in this event.
To which this part is true:
"So, um, it is just really hard for me to even ask you this question because Im almost in disbelief," said Rep. Jim Boyd. "If a baby is born on a table as a result of a botched abortion, what would Planned Parenthood want to have happen to that child that is struggling for life?
"We believe that any decision that's made should be left up to the woman, her family, and the physician," said Planned Parenthood lobbyist Snow.
The issue here is who has the best interest of the child born alive.. the state wants to make sure that the child isrepresented, since as the emergencyphysicianstated, that since the woman is obtaining thisprocedure she wouldn't have the child's best interest.
At the last part of the testimony given Ms.LaPolt was asked why she opposed having the baby moved to a hospital setting, to which she replied, that the hospital may be over 45 min away in transport. I am not sure if this is a dodging point or not.
But what really disturbs me about this, is a whole bunch of you are debating something that you obviously didn't watch. And so the spin begins.
Len,
Did I just see you equate the disgusting practice of post abortionneglectto gay marriage?
And who has such little concern forlive viableinfants? Some fringe group of PPH? Not the state of Florida, since that is what this whole hearing was about. A new law that they want to pass, to protect the child.
Are you kidding me? in ancient times, these were live babies and adults given up to a god."after-birth abortion" as you have named it (no where in that video is it called that) has nothing to do with adeity, just gross personal selfishness. And somehow, you wrap this all up in a knot with gay marriage. How utterly gross and misleading.
No Len, you want people to chose up sides. Culture wars are created by mixing different issues together and making it about one. While I believe in the rights of gay people to get married, I in no way endorse the practice ofneglectinga baby born alive from an abortion. These are twoseparateissues and have no business being together. You are the one defining what is a "culture were there is none, by mixing the two emotional issues together.
Bruce,
I agree with you. But if you watched the video, no one mentions killing babies, or even not aiding them after birth. Now I agree, there is some dancing around this issue that Ms. Planned Parenthood, did, but she specifically did it, because that is what she wants to avoid... this specific discussion.
What I have a problem with is making up stuff. No where in that video, did they even come close to saying that they were going to kill a baby post abortion. In fact, the whole show was to dance around saying that.
Personally, I find it gross to let a struggling baby die on the table of a clinic. I agree with the concept that born alive, that the child has achieved personhood and should get all medical intervention that any other person would. The doctor'screedis "Do No Harm", and that applies to a live baby delivered during anattemptedabortion.
The whole gay thing is just nonsense.
John,
I agree with you. You have accurately described what went on during that hearing. But that isn't what Len said. He said:
Alisa LaPolt Snow, the lobbyist representing the Florida Alliance of Planned Parenthood Affiliates, testified that her organization believes the decision to kill an infant who survives a failed abortion should be left up to the woman seeking an abortion and her abortion doctor.
The word killed was carefully not used in that hearing. I like facts to be accurate. Those words were not.
john , i cant remember and frankly am too lazy go looking for it but are you not the one whom in a post , posed this question, something about someone choking to death, with people around that could render the needed life saving assistance , but no one doing so invoking moral outrage?
so following that line of thinking , shouldnt there be the same moral outrage , at letting a resulting live birth , simply die? just because the proceedure intended to end the life , failed?
>>Alisa LaPolt Snow, the lobbyist representing the Florida Alliance of Planned Parenthood Affiliates, testified that her organization believes the decision to kill an infant who survives a failed abortion should be left up to the woman seeking an abortion and her abortion doctor.
I called this "after-birth abortion" but if you prefer "murder" Iam all right with that. I said that people are manipulating/spinning language to minimize the consequences of their actions; hence my comparison to child sacrifice, theprevalent abortion methed of ancient times. The two are not much different resultwiseandlots of peopleinclude manypre-birth abortions in the comparison.
Since I happen to strongly oppose legalization ofhomosexual marriage I consider that issue also part and parcel of the changing times;a battle in the culture wars. As Justice Alito said, it is newer than the Internet and cell phones. Justice Kennedy also referreed to the newness of the idea. "We have five years of information to weigh against 2,000 years of history or more,"
John Russell mentioned Princeton bioethics Prof. Peter Singeras having"presented arguments for neonaticide for many years." Singer also sees nothing wrong with euthanasia, incest, homosexualityand bestiality; human sex with animals. He is a prophet of one side ofsaid culture wars and is picking up lots of followers.
Of incest, homosexuality, bestiality, and child sacrificethe Bible says:
"--- all these abhorrent things were done by the people who were in the land before you (Israelites), and so the land became defiled. So let not the land spew you out for defiling it as it spewed out the nations before you." (Lev. 18)
But I suppose that is only for ultra-right-wing religious zealots. It is now considered "hate speech."
Seed article>>Alisa LaPolt Snow, the lobbyist representing the Florida Alliance of Planned Parenthood Affiliates, testified that her organization believes the decision to kill an infant who survives a failed abortion should be left up to the woman seeking an abortion and her abortion doctor.
Perrie>>The word killed was carefully not used in that hearing. I like facts to be accurate. Those words were not.
"Kiilled" was not used but "kill" wascarefully used. So carefully you may have missed it.