╌>

Is Marriage Constitutional? I Say "That's Irrelevant"

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  swamijim-sez  •  13 years ago  •  19 comments

Is Marriage Constitutional?  I Say "That's Irrelevant"

In hisdiscussion titled "Is Marriage Constitutional? I Say No... ", Mike opened with the question:

What is "marriage" anyway?

Marriage is a word with more than one single simple definition, SS(which you knew when you started this circus, you crafty devil; thats part of the reason your thread is heading into its fourth day of tail-chasing).

Among other ways of answering:

Marriage (for the two principals investing in it) is a public declaration by two individuals of a relationship of emotional commitment, which relationship they hope & believe will be a permanent condition of partnership. For the principals, declaring a marriage is a statement to the tribe/community of the principals sincerity in their allegiance and a pledge of dedication to one anothers welfare. (As youve observed elsewhere in your post, many individuals perceiving themselves to be in a condition of emotional commitment do not feel the need to make such a public declaration of their partnership.)

But that aint the whole story

Marriage (for the tribe/community in which it occurs) is a public acceptance & sanctioning of a condition of contract, which involves 1) recognition that two previously separate individuals within the social body have chosen to form a new conjoint entity (a couple) as part of the tribe/community structure, 2) a ceremony for legitimizing or formally according that change of status and the admission of a new conjoint entity within the social body, and 3) a mechanism for extending certain privileges in behavior which are sanctioned by the tribe/community within the conditions of the marriage codification. (The list isinclusive, not exclusive.)

Point 1 is relatively innocuous in terms of the discussion youre promoting in your post, and Ill pass on that one for a while. Points 2 and 3 are extremely significant, with ramifications that certainly bear on the case(s) presently before the SC and on your (IMO) somewhat hyperbolic and disingenuous presentation in your thread. Im going to address what I see as those ramifications beginning with point 3, which I believe is the most cogent for this discussion.

Regardless of whether theaccording and codifying structures are religious or civil/secular, recognition of a marriage contract by the tribe/community always confers several privileges (rights?) and imposes (or at least implies) certain obligations/restrictions upon the conjoint entity (and the individual partners) which are (at least formally) withheld from the separate individuals by tribal consensus standards. Sexual conduct is the simplest exampleprior to the development of reliable birth control methods, sexual behavior almost always resulted in procreation. Unrestricted procreation without mechanisms to assign some responsibility for the care & well-being of offspring were a clear threat to the viability of the tribe/community, so sexual access/conduct was restricted within the social body. Marriage conferred the privilege of socially-accepted sexual access, while imposing socially-expected obligations regarding care of the offspring. (Fidelity within the marriage contract is a concomitant social aspect of sexual privileges/obligations: males are expected to limit their sexual behavior so as not to engender offspring with females for whom they have not declaredresponsibility under the tribal sanctions; females are expected to limit their sexual conduct so as not to produce offspring except with the male who has chosen responsibility and declared this within the community.) Legitimacy of offspring is another example of social sanctions attendant to sexual behaviorchildren produced as a result of sexual conduct within a marriage contract have certain status & privileges within the community which are not accorded to the offspring of sexual behavior not sanctioned by the tribe (a little more on that aspect later in this piece).

NOW we get to the really sticky part issues of property.

How shall the conjoint entity manage the accumulation of goods accrued within the marriage contract and how do social sanctions impact on those decisions? In many societies for thousands of years, part of this arrangement was fairly simple: unmarried females were the property of males who had spawned them & accepted the personaland tribally-imposed obligation for their care. When another male expressed desire to form a conjoint entity with a female & assume that responsibility, the female then became his property, with attendant obligation for her care & well-being. (A man with an especially desirous female [sexual attractiveness and/or a skill-set valued in female roles: cooking, weaving, etc.] might demand goods in return for the loss involved in the female leaving his household. A man with a less desirous female [less attractive and/or less skilled], or an abundance of female offspring, might offer goods to increase likelihood of another male taking responsibility for her.) When a male head-of-household died, his property went to control of his legitimate socially sanctioned heir, including the widow property (along with obligation for her care & well-being); if the male head-of-household had no heir, his property typically went to control of his closest male relative, with the same obligations.

As societies became more complex, social mechanisms and sanctions regarding control of property began to change, and status & privileges of female partners of a conjoint entity changed (at least to a degree). When a male head-of-household died, he might elect to bequeath control of his accumulated goods to the female head-of-household, who then attained an unusual status within the social body: she became (effectively) independent propertynot equal in status or privileges to males, but accorded control of the goods accrued by the partners during the course of the relationship. It was customary & expected that the widowed female head-of-households function was basically to act as custodian of the accumulated goods until such time as a) a legitimate male heir became of age & assumed control of the property, or b) the female entered into a second marriage, at which time the accumulated goods became property of the male partner (and she lost her independent status). Note that this option was not available to females who had not been part of a socially-sanctioned conjoint entitya woman who had lived in a partnership not formalized by a marriage contract became a non-entity when the male died; his property typically passed to control of his closest male relative (illegitimate male heirs usually could not inherit either), who often did not have social obligation to care for the widowed female.

In very recent history, we have seen a sea-change in some societies; adult females (slowly) were accorded a new & very different kind of status & privileges, in essence being recognized as not-property, becoming independent entitieshaving the same legal standing as a male (at least, theoretically & [mostly] legally). We should note here that the evolution of female status & privileges (in societies where the changes have occurred) have almost exclusively been the result of formal changes in the codified social sanctionschanges in legal statutes largely brought about by government action, or conversely by changes in government statutes brought about by legal action.

Itssignificant in this discussionto recognize that changes in female status & privileges have almost exclusively occurred within and been the result of civil/secular regulation, not through conversion or modification of religious beliefs or attitudes. In many countries where conservative religious beliefs are intermingled with law and government, the status of females has essentially not changed in 3,000 years. Even now many of the more conservative Christian sects generally do not accord females status or privileges equivalent to males and in some respects still regard females as quasi-property. In our own country, due to the peculiar structure of states rights, states where legal & government processes are strongly influenced by conservative religious factions are still able to circumvent or abrogate the status and privileges of females that are sanctioned at the national level.The point is that in societies which have become more secular, sanction & codification of the marriage 'contract' (and the female's status within it) has shifted away from the purview of religious standards and into the context of civil/secular social mechanisms.Savage Saint maintains that civil sanctions (government codification) ofmarriageshould be abrogated and (presumably) thrust back into the realm of religious doctrine. I suspect that ladies concerned with being relegated to the status of property and potentially subject to FGM may disagree.

So where in hell is the Swami going with all this, you might ask? (And probably are if youve stuck around this long.)

Pretty simple Ive focused on females, but most of the points concerning the gradual change of status, privilege and socially-sanctioned behavior certainly apply to the civil status of black folks in our society.

Sixty years ago, the Supreme Court took up considerations of inequality, denial of social status and restrictions on privilege of behavior, where discrimination was based on skin color. The issues were about the 'civil rights' of a segment of the population who had been stigmatized and disenfranchised, and who sought through the mechanisms of law and government for recognition, accordance, sanction and codification of equality inthe privilege of accessing the same schools as people who werent black, the privilege of sitting in the same part of the bus as people who werent black, the privilege of using the same water fountain as people who werent black.

The Supreme Court wasnt being asked to grant those rights, it was asked to recognize that people of color possessed those rights, that the rights would not be accorded in the absence of statutes which at least began to enumerate them, and to sanction & codify procedures to assure equality in exercising those rights. While government and law do not grant rights/privileges, government and law are mechanisms by which society recognizes, accords, sanctions and codifies privileges & rights.

Now thats about black folks, but most of the points concerning the gradual change of status, privilege and socially-sanctioned behavior certainly equally apply to the civil status of LGBT folks in our society.

This week, the Supreme Court takes up considerations of inequality, denial of social status and restrictions on privilege of behavior, where discrimination is based on gender orientation. The issues are about the 'civil rights' of a segment of the population who have been stigmatized and disenfranchised, and who seek through the mechanisms of law and government for recognition, accordance, sanction and codification of equality inthe privilege of accessing the same social contract as people who arent gay, the privilege of visitation of dying loved ones the same way as people who arent gay, the privilege of filing taxes and bequeathing property the same way as people who arent gay.

The Supreme Court isnt being asked to grant those rights, its asked to recognize that LGBT people possess those rights, that the rights will not be accorded in the absence of statutes which at least began to enumerate them, and to sanction & codify procedures to assure equality in exercising those rights.

Is Marriage 'Constitutional'? Probably not... it wasn't mentioned there by the Founding Fathers. They didn't have much to say about access toa water fountain or a seat on the bus, either. What they did address were mechanisms through which society could recognize, sanction and codify civil laws to promote the welfare of persons who are 'created equal', possessing 'inalienable rights' including 'the pursuit of happiness', which might involve simple things like getting a drink of water, a seat on the bus, or even a marriage license like anybody else's.

I find it ironic, astonishing and outrageous that many of the same folks who will insist that the government uphold the right of any LGBT person to get a license, buy a gun and be able to shoot somebody, will turn around and insist that the government deny the right of LGBT people to get a license, buy a ring and be able to love somebody.

Its too bad that a well-regulated marriage isnt necessary to the security of a free state


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Ouch, you made my head hurt, but well stated and presented.

For me it is a non issue anyway, I feel all should be free to enjoy the happiness or miseries of marriage as they see fit. Wit to one side, this will be a done deal, if not soon then shortly, then they can move on to the next what should be a non issue subject. Marriage is a matter of the person, not the public, in my opinion anyway.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Whatever marriage is or isn't religiously or socially is no longer the issue here. It's just a contract. As I see it, the issue is three-fold. First, does the Federal Government have ANY right to regulate marriage in any way, shape or form. I believe the answer is absolutely NO - as evidenced by the fact that the States have always regulated it and then there is the 10th Amendment. (Unless some moron wants to argue this on the Commerce Clause, since it is a contract) The second issue is this: In light of the Equal Protection clause, can the states discriminate against gays with respect to marriage. I believe the answer is yes - IF they can prove that gays are a special group - like marrying a first cousin is forbidden. If they cannot, then they can't discriminate. Finally, the third question is this: do ALL other governments have to recognize same-sex marriages LEGALLY entered into. Again, I believe the answer to be yes. Does Virginia have to recognize the fact that Pennsylvania gave me a driver's license? (again, a privilege, not a right). Absolutely they do. What's the difference with a marriage license?

So, in short, the Fed Gov has no right to legislate anything about marriage, the states do. If the states decide gays can marry, then ALL other governmental entities should have to acknowledge that as an absolutely legal binding contract for everyone - including the IRS.

Just my two cents worth

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Swamijim sez    13 years ago

luther--

Tnx for dropping in. Yeah, I know it's long-winded & verbose, which is why I didn't try to jam it in on SS's thread. While I agree w/ you that this in some senses at least ought to be a non-issue, I see that for folks dealing with what amounts to currently 'legal' discrimination in issues of terminal visitation, property & inheritance, it's a major ass-kick of an issue. Apart from that concern, it also irritates me that this whole storm-in-a-teacup is largely generated by some folks' fear and/or hostility in concert with other folks' need to impose conservative literalist religious standards on somebody else's behavior. It seems odd to me that people don't want the gov't peeking into their gun cabinet, but want their pastor in somebody's elses bedroom closet...

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Swamijim sez    13 years ago

Good morning B... tnx for taking the time to make a comment.

I'd agree with the essence of your first statement-- the real issue isa matter of who can or can't enter into what is essentially a civil contract. Unfortunately, as soon as we've entered into the area of 'access' to the benefits of a civil contract, we're in the realm of civil law, and access to provisions of civil law takes us right into 'civil rights' (at least that's my perspective of the legal daisy-chain, anyway). I may be totally out in left field on this, but I have to assume that's the rationale for all the shenanigans we're witnessing right now.

I think the crux of the matter is tied in to the potential for conflict between your 2nd & 3rd points. IF indeed all states 'had' to recognize a same-sex marriage license issued in another state & therefore apply the same standards in matters of taxation, hospital visits, inheritance, etc, this would indeed become a non-issue. LGBT folks could simply marry where it's legal & their rights & privileges would become 'portable' like your driving privileges. However, we have a situation where there's not much evidence to assume that such a condition would exist. In fact, it's fairly certain that would NOT be the case; states would be 'free' to deny the license & thereby deny any 'rights' or privileges conferred by it. In fact, it seems likely that the DOMA was jammed through in an effort to forestall exactly the common-sense scenario you're describing: control the definition of 'marriage' and you've ipso-facto controlled all the privileges and/or 'rights' subsuming from use of the word....

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

Pretty much my take as well. I'll most likely go to the other side (not today) still attempting to figure humans out.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    13 years ago

Well thought out and very well presented Jim.

Our opinions on this matter are too closely aligned for me to be able to add anything of note, except perhaps my applause and a two finger whistle of appreciation. :-)

Thanks for posting your thoughts on this subject. I look forward to reading a lot of feed back on this, from a lot of different views.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Swamijim sez    13 years ago

Afternoon AH, appreciate your checking in... tnx and a tip of the Swami's turban for your kind feedback; I figured you & I were pretty much on the same page w/ this one. I know this is kind of a tediousread, but laying the groundworktook some build-up to get where I needed to reach in making the point(s).

I hope some folks respond to having a 'counterpoint' on SS's piece...

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

I'm sorry, Egilman but your argument falls short in that PROPERTY rights are specifically addressed under the Constitution. Marriage most specifically si not. Ergo..... not so much.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Swamijim sez    13 years ago

Good afternoon, Egilman... tnx for checking in, and a big tip of the Swami's turban for providing a very stimulating & enlightening addition to this discussion. Your response is definitely the direction I was trying to get to in my post, and I'm delighted that you can supply a more erudite presentation of those concepts than just SwamiJim's opinion.

I hate to display my ignorance by admitting that I'm not familiar with Leach's work, but it's true... I don't know it. Would you be good enough to give me a a title or source for the essay you've quoted? I'd like to have a 'short cut' rather than doing a Google and then trying to filter down to try and find it.

Tnx once again for a really relevant and interesting contribution. 113.gif

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    13 years ago

Marriage most specifically si not. Ergo..... not so much.

Perhaps the word Marriage is not used in the Constitution but fourteen times since 1888, the United States Supreme Court has stated that marriage is a fundamental right of all individuals assured and protected under the "Due Process" clause of the Fifth & Fourteenth Amendments. ( Link )

Of course once DOMA & Prop 8 are thrown out the next case that will be decided by the S.C. will be one where a same sex couple gets a legal marriage in California with all the rights every other married couple enjoys only to lose those rights when they move to say, Texas.

They will win their rights back under the equal protection clause of the 14th and this whole shameful period will finally be behind us.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

I suspect the high court will rule against DOMA BUT, here's the kicker, it will do it in such a way as to still leave the question of same sex marriage, wide open.

Consider this, the question of same sex marriage, is a job for the legislators, not the courts, to decide. In this case SCOTUS is being asked to decide an issue that is constitutionally germane to the duties of congress, which the high court does not like doing.

Our do nothing congress is so fricken lazy, cowardly and dysfunctional, it is trying to abdicate their powers to the judicial in order to save face with constituents within their district. DOMA is an excellent example of a law that was crafted to be constitutionally challenged therefore throwing the onus on the courts instead of congress. Like with Roe v Wade, congress can just wash its hands and say que, sera, sera then blame the courts for legislating from the bench.

Same sex marriage is not constitutionally irrelevant IF it is the will of the people to make it relevant in all 50 states, but going through the courts is not a good way to make such laws. Congress does not want to that.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Swamijim sez    13 years ago

SS-- I've been waiting to hear from you all day (sigh, bats eyelashes)

Seriously, I appreciate your checking in and taking the time to offer some feedback. As I noted in my response to your original post, I decided to take this route to put my thoughts out, as I figured injecting it as a lengthy comment to your discussion would be the equivalent ofchucking a big-ass rock into your swimming pool.

A couple of responses to your comment--

The utilitarian in me, however, is opposed to gay marriage. Not because I care, but because some people do care. It has meaning to them...

I'd make pretty much the same argument, except headed in directly the opposite direction. I don't have a big axe to grind about LGBT issues 'cause I'm hetero, so gay/lesbian concerns don't impact me personally. But 'some people do care'...Sanction of their involvement & relationships has a lot of meaning for gay/lesbian folks, not just in emotional terms, but in terms of financial issues, healthcare vitiation, survivorship benefits & beqeathal to name just a few. So there are people on both sides of the debate who care & have meaningful concerns. I guess the crux is: do the needs/wants of the many outweight the needs/wants of the few? How many people have to be holding the shit end of the stick before their concerns are meaningful enough to respond to? (Not expecting you to come with an answer, just my thoughts...)

I gotta say your Point 3 strikes me as kind of humorous. You and I both indulge ourselves in enough agit-prop that dissing somebody else's activist rhetoric is akin to gagging on a gnat while swallowing a camel. I recognize & respect your statement about promoting 'compromise' and I have no doubt you're sincere about that, but you gotta admit it's a little ironic coming from the guy who also said 'Let's burn down the village to save it'.

Delving a little further into that issue: Tempers are definitely inflamed on both sides of the debate and proclamations from both sides do get pretty vitriolic. Part of the reason I chose to frame my discussion in the manner I have is because I didn't want to just poke a stick into everybody's anthill and watch all the furor. My perception is that most LGBT folks aren't tarring everybody with the broad brush, as your Point 3 seems to imply. There are very vocal extremists lobbing incendiary grenades from both sides, but most gay folks aren't screaming 'bigot' at "everyone" who doesn't recognize their concerns any more than most heteroes are yelling 'pervert' or 'pedophile' at "everyone" pursuing social sanction of their relationships.

Final note on this point (damn I'm running off at the keyboard again): My perception is that at least a fair percentage of the statements made by some anti-gay folks are rooted in fear of and prejudice against LGBT behavior. I recognize that there are issues of religious beliefs tied into that attitude, but understanding of the roots of fear and prejudice doesn't rationalize or absolve prejudicial behavior. Denying individuals (much less an entire group) access to civil privileges granted to others, on the basis of fear & prejudice, is by definition "bigotry", whether the civil privilege is exercising the sovreign franchise, buying a house or getting a marriage license like anyone else's. A person can use the bible to justify anything, from slavery to stoning an adultress to death to having a bear tear children to pieces for mocking a prophet. Being able to cite a scriptural referent for it doesn't justify such practices or mean that it's not 'really' bigoted behavior.

Whew...(huff puff wheeze)... time for the Swami to climb down off the soapbox and give sombody else access... tnx again for your comments SS.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Swamijim sez    13 years ago

AH-- tnx for the response here (and kudos for getting that link in). Really appreciate your participation on this one.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Swamijim sez    13 years ago

(Retro reply to Egilman back on pg 1)

Tnx for the info (and links) E. For some reason I wasn't able to squeeze in a reply under your comment...

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Swamijim sez    13 years ago

Aeon--

My hunch is that you're right, AP, which will leave society in a continued mess. If SCOTUS pulls and end-run while Congress is doing the same thing, it's going to be the judicial/legislative equivalent of the Keystone Kops... frenetic activity, plenty of car crashes, no result.

...the question of same sex marriage, is a job for the legislators, not the courts... Same sex marriage is not constitutionally irrelevant IF it is the will of the people to make it relevant in all 50 states...

In theory I'd agree w/ you, but in practice I think it's going to take judicial action at the Federal level to cut the Gordian knot on this one. For one thing, I doubt that 'the will of the people' could get the Reps & Sens of all 50 states to hum "Yankee Doodle" in unison, much less do anything meaningful. In addition, there's that 'states rights' can-of-worms lurking out there, like a semi stalled across a railroad track... you can already picture the train wreck.

Tnx and a tip of the Swami's turban for chiming in, AP...

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Swamijim sez    13 years ago

Quick final though on one of your earlier comments...

...(corporations are people under the law, but I don't see humans marrying corporations in the future)...

Of course not, E-- corporations aren't interest in marrying anyone, only screwing them...

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Swamijim sez    13 years ago

Bruce-- tnx for dropping in, bud; still trying to deal w/ your video implant (video download w/ a hardline & modem is as frustrating as watching paint dry)

I guess that all depends on what your definition of "is" is

"I know what 'it' means when I find something," the Duck replied, "It' would be a worm or a frog. The question is, what kind of 'it' did the Archbishop find?" (Lewis Carroll, Alice in Wonderland)

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Swamijim sez    13 years ago

I'm not real sure about how to respond to this one, SS, cause I can't see where it's going...

Comments thus far demonstratethat manyfolks do see the definitional aspect as complicated, which makes the the conservative DOMA agenda look both simplistic and out of touch with a significant percentage of society's perceptions & concerns. Some of what you've said above seems contradictory or at least more diffuse than what was presented in your own original post, though maybe that's just stuff you chose not to include in your discussion presentation for some reason.

Setting aside that you did 440-some words and 44 lines of backing & filling, my perception is that the most significant aspect of this comment is as follows:

People like me, don't give a shit...Why would I?...As long as they don't look to me for blessing or help, we'll all get along just fine.

Maybe I'm oversimplifying it or missing some other point you're trying to make. If I'm reading you right, cause it sounds to me that a declaration of total indifference to a legislative, judicial and social SNAFU that's impacting a helluva lot of people is the real heart of your position, although 'real heart' seems like a somewhat misplaced phrase...

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Swamijim sez    13 years ago

Sorry chief, but my Bullshit Alarm is sounding loud & heavy on this one. You're dancing around like a duck on a hot plate at this point, just letting off shotgun blasts of contempt in pretty much every direction you turn. On top of that, you're not even attempting to offer any validation or even a point of reference for the stuff you're spouting. I suppose that's fine if what you want to do is just vent the opinions, but then, you've a post of your own to do that...

Your Part 2 rap was (more or less) pointing out that there are multiple overlapping & conflicting 'definitions' of what a marriage is-- now you seem to be saying that you want all the definitions to be mutually exclusive, but don't present a point about why that should be or how it would move things any closer to the 'compromise' you claimed you were looking for. If some folks' concept of marriage is from a religious angle & a divinely-instituted covenant, why is that an intolerable conflict with civil 'benefits' in areas of taxes, insurance rates, survivor issues or anything else? Looks suspiciously like a straw-man presentation to me...

I'll grant you that the single-dwelling extended family is pretty much scarce as hen's teeth, and the nuclear family is certainly suffering from Future Shock, but I don't agree that the concept of 'family' is dead. And I flatly don't see how you got from 'family is in deep trouble' to "Marriage is a failure in our society..." If there's a bridge that runs fromyour first unsupported statement to the equally unsupported conclusion, SwamiJim sez it's in your imagination-- I ain't seein' it.

Next, IMO you are just totally out in left field with that rant about "Gay Marriage zealots". Thefocus of gay marriage issues currently in front ofSCOTUS(that is where this whole diatribe started, isn't it?) has absolutely nothing to do with LGBT folks trying to 'force' anyone else to 'accept' their lifestyle. Most of the gay people I know basically don't give a rat's ass about whether or not a bunch of folks 'accept' their lifestyle or not-- what they do want is NOT to have their civil privileges/benefits curtailed or outright denied because a percentage of others just don't like gay people. Putting quotation marks around a statement you fabricated, and then attributing that supposed attitude to the entire LGBT population, is beyond feeble & manipulative SS-- it's just blatant bullshit. The arrogant attitude you're trying to pin on gay people is actually a helluva lot closer to the conservative extremist position-- the rabid anti-gay folks are the ones who want to deny a bunch of other peoples' civil benefits and say "deal with it, get over it, and suck it you bitches!"

Final point and I'm done-- your 'final solution' "would be to remove "marriage' from the public arena. Delete it." We've just been through pages of comment adressing how the concept and the word 'marriage' are woven into the fabric of American society-- socially, legally, politically, economically, on & on. Unless you've got your hand on the Magic Wand or you're ace buds with the Genie of The Lamp, there's not a snowball's chance in hell of undoing all those interconnections simply by whipping upsome silver bullet called'civil union'. On top of that piece of absurdity, I'll guarantee you that the same folks who want to deny civil sanction to LGBT couples would simply drop the word 'marriage' like a hot rock and start the same insanity all over again over what constitutes an acceptable 'civil union'. That's just a linguistic re-hash of the same bullshit tactics people tried to use to maintain suppression of black folks' civil liberties; it smelled then and it's still rank now...

I gotta say that IMO, your Part 2 and Part 3 haven't done squat to contribute to where I'd hoped this discussion would go when I launched it 13 hours ago; if you intend Part 4 to be more of the same, please spare me (and anyone else who's looking for a meaningful dialogue here). I had the courtesy not to wade in and pull a hijack on your threat, bud-- return the favor...

 
 

Who is online







106 visitors