Texas Mom Outraged After Finding Stunning Question About 9/11, Terrorism on Her Son’s 5th Grade Test
A Texas mom is furious after discovering that her sons school is teaching students that the United States is partly to blame for the 9/11 terrorist attacks that claimed the lives of nearly 3,000 people.
Kara Sands, of Corpus Christi, Texas, took to her Facebook and posted photos of the test administered byFlour Bluff Intermediate School. The test reportedly covered content in a video fifth-grade students watched in class.
Of all the questions about the 9/11 attacks, Sands was most disturbed by question three:
Why might the United States be a target for terrorism? The answer? Decisions we made in the United States have had negative effects on people elsewhere.
The school was using the stunningly controversial lesson, a part of Safari Montage, to supplement the controversial CSCOPE curriculum system that has come under fire recently , Sands told TheBlaze. CSCOPE also includes lessons asking students to design a flag for a new socialist nation and calls the Boston Tea Party an act of terrorism.
Im not going to justify radical terrorists by saying we did anything to deserve that over 3,000 people died, Sands told KRIS-TV .

This is American education?!
No wonder we are turning out so many lousy students.
I'm totally disgusted by this. I am utterly shocked. I'm even more shocked by the state that this was in.
like denying the democrats blocked nearly all anti-discrimination legislation since the civil war, the re-writing of history, and dept of ed. brainwashingcontinues.
no shock here.
Are you saying that we should teach our children, who probably aren't even old enough to remember 9-11, that Islamic terrorists attacked and killed 3,000 American civilians because we deserved it? How else are we to interpret teaching 5th graders...Decisions we made in the United States have had negative effects on people elsewhere. ?
Actually, I'd call it an act of revolution. We soon thereafter freed ourselves from British rule, much due to the economic oppression, that the Tea Party act reflected.
Damn.. Sorry about that. I am going to report this link now.
True; yet used successfully to equate modern Islamic terrorists (and their "plight") with those involved in the American revolution.
Which question?
As the title says, 5th grade.
Ok, first of all, this was not a case of "valid to look at the broader issues of what would motivate someone to commit terrorist acts", it was blatantly telling 10 year old kids that Americans were killed and deserved it because of poor choices...and then testing them on it to make sure they responded correctly.
Second; this is a discussion that adults still argue about and yet, we allow our schools to teach such a biased moral lesson? It's beyond pathetic.
Terrorism/revolution, that's just semantics.
No it's not in it's purest form of those term.
Terrorism is an act of violence by a group with a specific agenda.
Tim McVeigh was anti government. His act of terror was to disrupt government. Terrorism is supposed to make it hard to declare an act of war back.Terrorism is usually done to regularciviliansto frighten them into moving in a certain direction.
Tim McVeighs act didn't provoke or inspire anyone into overturning the government.
9/11 was anunusualact of terrorism. They didn't think that we would take the war to them. We didn't the first time, or the bombing of the Cole or theEmbassies. The WTC, finally pushed us over the edge that made it an act of war. But that isn't the usual way it goes.
This is a link from the article.
CSCOPE: Exposing the Nations Most Controversial Public School Curriculum System
I did not miss that in the reading, it appears though that you are also saying that the answer ...Decisions we made in the United States have had negative effects on people elsewhere....would have been correct if it was fill in the blank?
No it's not one sided, yet that IS what these kids are being taught. The reason we may be attacked by terrorists is because somebody, somewhere in the world doesn't like us Because of "our poor choices", and gives credence to the idea that we deserved it.
Kids especially think this way. These lessons and the tests that go along with them, are pointing the finger at the US instead of the terrorists who use religion and violence to achieve political ends.
History is written by the winners not the losers...
There isnt a single country/government or people who havent made mistakes... the USA is included in that.
As to the article, the questions are not grade appropriate... those sorts of things arent wrote memorization... they are things that you reflect on as an adult... some college kids arent even mature enough to really THINK about those topics constructively.
On the other hand, historical brain washing should be a crime. I like a good Washington cherry tree choppin'tale as good as the next person, but that crap shouldnt be in history books at any age. The dissolutionment of children is equally inappropriate.
flameaway,
I'm in agreement with your general assessment.
"Peoples History" was a game changer for me too along with "Fire in the Lake", "A Bright and Shining Lie", "Dispatches" (Highly recommended!) and a bundle of other ones.
Have you read "The People's History of the Civil War: Struggles for the Meaning of Freedom" by David Williams. Nice little preface by Zinn.
best to you
Unfortunately, Terrorism and civil disobedience have the same meaning to our government today. Keeping this in mind, it is probably good not to forget they can execute "American terrorists" on American soil now.
I disagree. When presented in the way it is, there is only one right answer, one the test is assuming would have been "learned" while watching the video. Why would the answer not be "because Islamic terrorists are opposed to America's Ideas"? Or, "They told us they would finish the job and 9 years later they did", or " Because the US believes in Religious freedom, freedom from violence anddiscrimination and Islamic terrorists do not, and hate us because of it"?
there was obviously no valid discussion about any of these items and/or where shunted under the rug in favor of a more "desirable" answer.
These are young impressionable minds who will and do, absorb this. When they teach their own kids about America being attacked by terrorists are they going to be teaching them " well honey, we made some poor choices and we want to make sure not to piss off Islamic terrorists"; because, THAT, is the lesson being taught.
Ok, I think we agree basically about the lesson in some regards. I was not equating your responses, I was equating thereferredto test and lesson.
I would say that it isindicative, as are some past curriculum choices, of aninabilityto properly secure decent,efficientcurriculum for our public schools, that avoids this type of moralizing. This curriculum in particular doesn't even appear to try and be non-biased.
How many times a day could youwaterboardhim, before he dies from it?
And that is exactly what this "lesson" does.
The Boston Tea Party was civildisobedience By the root of the word, it didn't bring terror to the king. It just pissed him off and cost him a lot of money. But it did have an agenda... to get a message that taxation without representation wouldn't be tolerated.
A very biased book, presenting a view of the world from an extremist political view.
Useful, perhaps, if you want to get some insight into how the ind of a political fanatic works. But other than that...
Perhaps we're making a big todo about nothing. This is middle school and presumably the students will get some information later on that helps them make a more informed opinion.
I'm a whole lot more concerned the kids get a solid education on all subjects than nitpicking one multiple choice question.
I'm feeling too lazy to google it (and I forget what I learned about it in school), so I'll just ask you---how many people were killed? Of those, how many were civilians-- or were only members of the British military killed? Were any civilians killed? How many were tortured? Or otherwise seriously injured?
IMO that seems to be strange criteria for deciding whether an action is terrorism or not.
Do you really go by that criteria: whether or not an action is justified?
(If someone on NT calls someone an "idiot"-- it might indeed be justified. (No-- I am not advocating doing that!
) But what if its not justifiable-- is it then an act of terrorism?
Or?
Why do you assume that the two are mutually exclusive?
IMO, some revolutionaries engage in terrorism, some are non-violent.
or-- what about non-violently picketing?
Or-- handing out political literature?
And legitimate gripes about what the Ottoman Turks did before the Brits. And, in "Palestine", what the Jordanians and Egyptians did in Gaza and the West Bank during the Egyptian and Jordanian occupation of those areas.
(Interestingly, you only mention the US and Britain. Why?)
Well, I have similar gripes about what they did there. (and what all the colonial powers did in so many parts of the Middle East, and Africa, and...).
But-- I don't use that to attempt to justify terrorism. I am not an advocate of "two wrongs make a right"....`
I wonder-- how long are some of these 3rd world cunntries goinng to uuse what happened in the past to justify not only terrorism-- but also useit to justifynthe backwardness of their countries?
As a "defined concept"? OK, I'll bite. If it is indeed, as you claim, a"a defined concept"-- then what is the definition of terrorism? (No goggling allowed-- at least until later
.
Are you claiming, then, that by throwing some Tea into the water, the revolutionaries (AKA terrorists?) had the King of England quaking in his boots? That the British soldiers were now living in great fear of the Americans...just couldn 't wait to get on a boat to escape back to the safety of England??
I think the most important piece of legislation was The Civil Rights Act of 1964:
You got me curious about how the 2 parties lined up in the vote, so I googled it:
If we accept that as the definition of terrorism-- then how would that be different than legitimate acts of war-- conventional war?
IMO, its important to distinguish between regular acts of war and terrorism (but there's a lot of disagreement about what violent acts are terrorism and what are not). `
Exactly. Its actually quite similar to saying that any women who is raped deserved it, that its her fault because she must've been dressed "Provocatively" (or, sometimes, that it is always the womens' fault because she acted provocatively).
The generic term for this specific type of faulty logic is called "blame the victim".
And, BTW, its one specific category of a larger phenomenon that's become increasingly common now-a-days-- the belief that people are not responsible for their actions:
So what? In any act of violence there are two sides to the story. The perp always has a reason why he did it.
Yup. Here's another act of violence. And nce again, there are two sides to the story. as always, thhe perp had a reason for his actions (in this case it was because he didn't get any money):
Teenage Thief Shoots A Baby In The Face Because Mother Had No Money To Give Him
Two sides to the stry. The perp has a reason for his actions.
Now-- the $64,000 question: how important do you think it is that the motives of the perp here be taught and discussed in schools so the kids understand his reason for doing this?
So by that definition-- was using A bombs on Japan terrorism-- or simply a military action? The Normandy Landing? Israeli attacks on Gaza? Bombing Germany? Bombing North Viet-Nam? The fire-bombing of Dresden? The war in Iraq? Drone strikes in Afghanistan? Egyptian violence against demonstrators?
Theres something missing from the story-- detail. In 2010, the Texas Bd. of Ed made some huge changes to its social studies curriculum. From the NYT:
(The Board) approved a social studies curriculum that will put a conservative stamp on history and economics textbooks , stressing the superiority of American capitalism, questioning the Founding Fathers commitment to a purely secular government and presenting Republican political philosophies in a more positive light.
Its hard to be believe anyone slipped in test questions or lesson plans that dont skew to the right. Additionally, a number of schools in Texas and NC are buying into American History lessons crafted by Charles Koch and his astroturf Bill of Rights Institute. For example, the Inst. points to Angelina Grimke as a political and religious figure who is finally getting the recognition she deserves. Truthfully, I never heard of her.
Kids are receiving mixed messages and they dont know what to make of our history thats become so partisan and unrecognizable.
Occupying Mecca and Medina...?
No way!
Their Apartheid regime doesn't allow infidels there at all!
When I walk into a voting booth I have an agenda. And I have written letters to my congress-person person-- letters advocating my agenda.
The fact that US troops were in S.A. as invited guests of course meant little to Bin Laden as he had already determined that his homeland had become reprobate, and didn't know what was good for themselves.
Misunderstood and a product of his harsh environment, it's our fault that he made the choices he did.
Nice video Saint, just peeked and will put that on my watch-list for later today (at work). National Geographic puts out some excellent stuff.
Seems like a perfectly reasonable question to me.
I really can't understand how people want to teach critical thinking if you can't challenge thoughts, however minimally this does that.
I think that a lot of us miss the mark when discussing events that occurred in our lifetime because our perception is colored by our own personal bias. It is quite obvious that this parent, and anyone else who finds question #3 offensive, is responding to a gut feeling rather than thinking about the issue.
Why might the United States be a target of terrorism? Answer: Decisions we made in the United States have had negative effects on people elsewhere.
Just where is the call, as Sands claims, for her to justify the act of terrorism? Implied in her comment is the rationalization that we did not deserve to be attacked, when the question poses no suchquandary. Also implied in her comment is the idea that it is not possible to relate the causes of terrorism to anything that we may have done. This attitude is neither helpful nor accurate, and promulgates the chest thumping, jingoistic ideology that the United States can do no wrong.
Also, the presentation of this article on the website, as well as the website itself, is slanted towards that very bias.
When you are asked to pick the best answer, yes multiple choice tests do test applied critical thinking. It may be basic critical thinking, but you have to start somewhere. I.E., When asked to choose from a given set of alternatives which one best suits the problem posed, that is critical thinking, all boiled down, yet nonetheless critical thinking.
As far as age appropriateness goes, I think it is absolutely ageappropriate, in that it doesn't ask them to delve into the more complex how and why, but merely gives a general, "We may have upset someone along the way." The idea that we may have upset people seems to not resonate with the woman in the article, and I would say that it is her critical thinking skillsthat need brushing up.