Why the Rich Don't Give to Charity
The wealthiest Americans donate 1.3 percent of their income; the poorest, 3.2 percent. What's up with that?
...One of the most surprising, and perhaps confounding, facts of charity in America is that the people who can least afford to give are the ones who donate the greatest percentage of their income. In 2011, the wealthiest Americansthose with earnings in the top 20percentcontributed on average 1.3percent of their income to charity. By comparison, Americans at the base of the income pyramidthose in the bottom 20 percentdonated 3.2percent of their income. The relative generosity of lower-income Americans is accentuated by the fact that, unlike middle-class and wealthy donors, most of them cannot take advantage of the charitable tax deduction, because they do not itemize deductions on their income-tax returns... http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2013/04/why-the-rich-dont-give/309254/
There's a church I know of in Milwaukee, that's in the demographically poorest area of the city. Once a week it opens it's doors and provides food, clothing and other necessities for any and all who come there. It is staffed only by non-paid volunteers. One thing unique about this place is that unlike any government sponsored program where one must fill out six pages of paperwork and get processed, all they ask for is a name. No one is turned away.
Because of that, it has no corporate or charitable sponsors or donations because it does not conform with the tax code laws. So, they depend solely on individual donations from the community, which translates into the poor helping out those whom are even poorer.
To be sure, the charities that are provided by corporations and philanthropic organizations are of great help, however they always seem to have too many strings attached and too often require the poor to grovel which robs them of what dignity and self worth they have left.
This report comes as no surprise, The wealthy love to publicize how generous they are and enjoy receiving awards at $100 a plate dinners honoring them.
It makes me sick.

I thought that this was a figment of my imagination as it has always seemed to me that the less folks have the greater they give. It is nice to see that observation actually reflected in numbers, although disturbing.
Aeon, this is beneath you. 1.3% of 100,000 is what, $1300? while 3.2% of $20,000 is $64. You KNOW that percentages are a ridiculous manner in which to base giving - just like taxes. I would venture to say that charities are more than happy to have the 1.3% over the 3.2%.
pretty simple: as the state expands, contributions to charity is reduced.
....thats why
I think you should read the article before jumping to conclusions. Now, aside from your arbitrary figures (the article does NOT mention any set income sum) the "top twenty percent" is an aggregate figure but the medium is well over $100,000 and represents 51% of all the wealth in the US. source: ...
Also, that article, written by Ben Stern, is based on his own research which has been published in a book; With Charity for All: Why Charities Are Failing and a Better Way to Give
" Slade.com " has done a good summary of that book.
The problem is, the "rich" do NOT give unless there is something in it for them, like a tax write off or a statue with their name on it.
Or perhaps they give anonymously.
That is an absolutely ridiculous statement AeonPax. Liberals are always claiming the Republicans are all rich and greedy and your statement falls right in line with that one.
Take this for example: A family making around $26,000 doesn't pay any Federal taxes and more than likely receives "Earned Income Tax Credit" up to $5900 keeping in mind they haven't paid a dime in Federal taxes.
Generally they are receiving Food Stamps as well, help on their heating bill during the winter and help on their cooling bill during the summer. May even get a free air conditioner or heater. Their children are completely covered for medical, school lunches and in some cases food to carry home after school.
Now let's look at that $100,000 family. They pay (since you didn't figure anything concerning mortgage deductions and such) $17,000 plus just in Federal taxes, plus State taxes. They don't receive any help from the government at all. They are totally responsible for their well being for themselves and their children. Let's not forget they will be responsible for all of their children's educational needs right on through college.
This family obviously is trying to take responsibility for themselves and probably have a home they are paying for as well as all the other expenses of food and environmental issues. They have another child and inherit another expense, while the other lower income family has another child and inherit a pay raise.
Envy should be directed more toward trying to improve ones life in order to raise their standard of living and make more money. We need help over here, since only 53% pay any Federal taxes.
By the way.....Republicans are known to pay more into charity than Democrats whether they are rich or poor. Your percentages and his book are more like some of the graphs even I've been guilty of putting in a comment. I can condemn your toe when you face is beautiful. In other words a graph or percentage like this is ignoring the total picture.
Unfortunately, as all your points are unprovable, I'll forgo the requisite of asking for said facts and thank you for taking your time to add your opinion to this discussion topic.
I do not know as they have to, I believe they should.
Only from my viewpoint: How much is enough? I am finally at that point in my life were from the materialI have more than I ever wanted or thought I would have (nope not amongst the rich). Why not put it back into society to assist those less fortunate, I certainly do not need more stuff. But I am somewhat of a minimulist and as I stated it is my own take.
Pretty typical.
Tax Table / Tax Bracket Rates
EITC, Earned Income Tax Credit, Questions and Answers
...
5 Facts About the Earned Income Tax Credit
...
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (Food Stamps)
Income Eligibility Guidelines (for free lunches in school)
The 47 percent: Here's who pays no federal income tax
In a blog released not long after its report , the TPC explained that "a couple with two children earning less than $26,400 will pay no federal income tax this year because their $11,600 standard deduction and four exemptions of $3,700 each reduce their taxable income to zero."
...
Don't let facts get in the way now.
You can take it from here.
Sorry.....have to get to work. Need to make a little extra to be able to afford to be charitable. Your author needs to write a book trying to help those in need to become more self-sufficient. That would be more of a charitable contribution to our society than promoting class warfare like the president does.
If you aren't poor John, what are you doing to help the poor? I'm working to make as much as I can. And in the process I'm paying a lot of taxes that are being used to support the poor.
How much would be sufficient of my pay would it take to satisfy you? I'm not berating the poor. I've been poor and never been rich.
My philosophy is I'm more than willing to help those that can not help themselves and at the same time I'm more than willing to help the poor that can help themselves do so. I'll carry your load forever if you are unable to carry it, but if you need help to get on your feet....then I'll do that. Then it's up to you.
Don't make a lifestyle of riding in the wagon unless you can't walk on your own two feet.
luther28....That's what charity is. You've explained it very clearly.
Charity is something that people give voluntarily, unless they view it as a COMMANDMENT.
The poorer strata of society are typically more G-d fearing and less atheistic than their more wealthy counterparts. Therefore, they are more likely to give, and more likely to give MORE.
Spaghetti Monsterrant isn't all it's touted to be...
flameaway.....Are you rich? I don't expect you to answer that question. I'm not rich. I just enjoy debates. No matter what time I start working, I have the same amount of work I have to finish. Start early....finish earlier. Start late.....finish later. Why don't you find something that you can do today to help the poor?
In order to avoid being too late.....got to go!
Sorry sixpack, none of what you posted proves a damn thing. I will however take this point by point by point and use your own words, for starters;
1) "A family making around $26,000 doesn't pay any Federal taxes"
Prove it.
2) "more than likely receives "Earned Income Tax Credit" up to $5900"
Prove it.
sixpack pulled that little ditty off this site; which he didn't even quote correctly. Besides, the author was not stating a fact, he was just making an example.
Thanks for the laugh EI.
sixpack,
I'm not even sure you read the entire article. It's NOT about the government per se, it's NOT about paying taxes and it's NOT about whether the poor deserved to be helped...it's about altruism. It states two facts; a) those who make less per capita income, give a greater percentage than those who make a lot more and b) those rich that do make big donations do so for public recognition and tax purposes.
Historically, the idea behind the rich helping the poor has nothing to do with religion, it comes from a concept called "Noblesse oblige"which strictly translated from French is "noble obligation" which derived from the middle ages ethical concept that with nobility (a social class which possesses more acknowledged wealth, privileges or eminence than members of most other classes in a society) comes "social responsibility."
While there are no longer "nobles", there still a class of rich and uber rich and as the article suggests, "that the wealthy may be less generousthat the personal drive to accumulate wealth may be inconsistent with the idea of communal support." In other words, the wealthy have become stingy.
The article asks more questions than it answers and it passes no judgement.
AeonPax... Do you know what the standard deduction filing jointly is for earned income (for EI)? It's $11,900.
Federal Standard Tax Deduction for 2012
The above is an approved IRS efiler provider. They know what it is. Now you know.
Then you have the two little children to make it a family of four. Each one of them gives you $3800 each for a total of $7600. Now here's what we do. We add $11900 and $7600 and the answer is $19500. Now if they make $20000 there is only $500 left to pay taxes on and if they make $26000 their is only $6500 to pay taxes on. According to the tax tables the taxes on a family of four with net earned income of even $6500 is 10% or $650. Now Earned Income Tax credit comes into play and with an Net Earned Income of $6500 this family qualifies for a refund of $5236 refund. So you see they may have a $650 tax liability, but they get $5236 minus the $650 paid to them as a refund, so they pay no Federal Income Tax and actually receive a check for $4586 paid to them. The link below verifies this information.
Earned Income Credit
Note:
The Earned Income Credit has no effect on certain welfare benefits. Any refund you receive because of the EIC will not be considered income when determining whether you are eligible for, or how much you can receive from, the following benefit programs:
So....that covers both of your questions and provides legitimate links to make it easier for you to understand.
later....six
I should have just ignored the whole thing. actually. It was meant to promote class warfare from the start. It wasn't a charitable article. It was dedicated to promote the hatred of the haves by the have nots you liberals just can't seem to get over. When I was growing up we had more respect for ourselves than there seems to be today. One man's investigation that the rich pay a lower percentage than the poor is a very narrow view of the overall picture here. When you are trying to make something of yourself and continually get condemned by those that have no desire to improve their lives or the lives of the poor, but rather promote class warfare instead, it just gets to be old news. The comment that you wrote that made me inclined to respond is on the first page
That was the ridiculous statement you made in my opinion. I should say for you to prove that, but you couldn't. And it makes you sick. Class warfare makes me sick. And as far as helping the poor, you aren't doing anything to promote that with that statement. Like I said, "I'm perfectly willing to help those who can't help themselves forever, but at the same time I'm perfectly willing to help those that can do so." But I will call you on promoting class warfare.I know too many people that started with nothing and would still have nothing if they listened and believed that.
Sixpackyoure quibbling and none of this has a thing to do with the article, however, since you are insistent..
Your example of a family making $26,000 a year ASSUMES its a family of four , which you did not state. Not all families have two children and not all families consist of two adults. Point is, considering all the other variables, you could say SOME families with an income of $26,000 a year pay no taxes, but not all. Even then what does that prove?
Next, you state
1) Generally they are receiving Food Stamps Oh really? So generally, what percentages of those making $26,000 a year do actually receive food stamps?
2) help on their heating bill during the winter and help on their cooling bill during the summer Percentages please?
c) May even get a free air conditioner or heater From who? What percentage? Some elderly and handicapped on welfare MAY qualify on specific programs not associated with welfare but as for the rest?
d) Their children are completely covered for medical, school lunches and in some cases food to carry home after schoo l a) Child medical care is a STATE/county issue, not federal, b) as far as school lunches go, you need some facts and c) I never heard of the federal government (or state) giving kids food to carry home.
Dont bother replying to these questions. My point is that your original post was nothing but right wing assumptions and stereotypes. .and none of that is germane to this topic.
Good idea.
That is since it was so ridiculous and only promoted class warfare and did nothing to help the poor realize their potential.
Listen..This Will Change Your Life
Then you can be as charitable as you want to be.
Thanks Screaming for Vengeance. AeonPax made the ridiculous statement at the end of AeonPax's article about the rich only being charitable when it benefited them at $100 a plate dinners and how it made AeonPax sick and that was my original dispute. I'm not asking you to be on my side or anything like that. Like AeonPax has requested my participation has ended after this comment. Thanks for calling me Six as well. Old habits just seem to be hard to break. I don't think I was ever called Six or Sixpick on NV by anyone other than friends. It was always Sixpack and I don't even drink. I don't know if you are conservative or liberal or anything other than those and I know I'm not a tax expert, but I'm against class warfare and there is way too much of it today.
AeonPax , from Mark Ch.12..
Sound familiar?
flameaway..... You know you and I are going to debate and I hope we can do it with civility in the future, but probably not at times. LOL. But that's OK. I want you to continue to just be yourself.
Here's an idea. None of us want to be condemned because of the success or failures we've had in our lives. None of us are perfect. I know I'm certainly not. This is not confession time for me, but if you have confessed in the past and found it beneficial for either you, others or both then I applaud you for doing so.
I think it takes a lot of courage to admit the things you, me or anyone else has done in his or her life they know were wrong. Now it is time to move on as you have.
I haven't read any of your articles, but I'm sure they were beneficial to you and others.
I remember when I was in school and sent to the principal for one reason or another. He gave me a piece of paper and just wrote crap all over it. It looked like crap. He then said, "This is today." Then he gave me another sheet of clean paper and said, "This is tomorrow". Then he took off his belt and whipped my ass. Of course he would be in jail today for doing that, but when I got home my dad had somehow received the news. He didn't give me a piece of paper. He just whipped my ass. LOL.
My whole thing is by promoting class warfare it is no different than promoting prejudices toward others. I just don't like it and think it isn't beneficial to our society.
I can't say I'm familiar with your quote but it would seem nothing has changed in 2,000 years as far as the rich giving to charity for the sake of being recognized for it.
Painting with a broad brush calling rich people stingy. I personally know a very "rich" family that is philanthropic as as a goal not a convenience. They intentionally remain out of sight because certain people dislike the power of money when used to actually do what big government claims as it's domain. There are others who use their wealth to gain political favor as we all must recognize and understand. There is a short read concerning wealth, power and society that I share often.
If you find yourself agreeing, great. If not, your view of social well being ought to have a foundation predicated on real life such as the Johnstown flood.
While the title of the article is confusing as it's rhetorical, the rich in fact do give...most generously I might add. A local college recently got a million dollar grant to establish fellowships in Mayan art studies, a clinic got $100,000 to change the carpeting in their waiting room (along with a plaque on the wall) and a well known foundation donated $250,000 to help local schools purchase up to date globes of the planet Mars. All quite worthy and very tax deductible endeavors.
Contrast that with the community families who anonymously donated some 400 pounds of canned and box food for a Boy Scout drive to help those who do not get food stamps, a bake sale that netted $150 to help the homeless and local area plumbers who frequently will not change for calls from the financially distressed elderly and by far, one can immediately tell, how much more generous and unconcerned about taxes the rich truly are.
There are far more than 1500 who have become the enemy within. In fact our lack of corporate control has allowed foreign influence to access every part, process, agency and main media outlets. You might guess this but since the founding this country has been under attack simply because it denies the wealthy the authority to control the public. Well, it used to.
Lamenting the Roman empire or just Nero ?
Most "giving" by "rich" people is a tax evasion. I had the fortune to have been close to a very wealthy family and at tax time there were two issues I shall relate to you. One, during the fiscal year the entire proceeds of a conglomerate went, as intended, into a foundation for charity distribution. It still does to this day and it's a lot of money. No income tax is paid thus. Two, the tax levy on the income from well earned corporate management usually was in the 20 million bracket. The money could either go to the government and be mostly eaten up by overhead, waste, fraud and political pandering or it could be divided up among the most efficient charities of their choosing. The Mrs. was usually allotted about 80% of the choice and was well versed in how to manage it. The remaining 20% went to create and improve local public facilities ie; library, ambulance/ EMT services, fire/ rescue, hospital and the direct hiring of people as well. I would encourage people to look before they leap in regards to measuring the use or abuse of wealth, taxes and intentions. We must discern good from bad. I know that the line between those two has been blurred.It must be defined to be able to discern the most basic principles of society and purpose of any government.
I thought that this was a figment of my imagination as it has always seemed to me that the less folks have the greater they give. It is nice to see that observation actually reflected in numbers, although disturbing.
Aeon, this is beneath you. 1.3% of 100,000 is what, $1300? while 3.2% of $20,000 is $64. You KNOW that percentages are a ridiculous manner in which to base giving - just like taxes. I would venture to say that charities are more than happy to have the 1.3% over the 3.2%.
pretty simple: as the state expands, contributions to charity is reduced.
....thats why
I think you should read the article before jumping to conclusions. Now, aside from your arbitrary figures (the article does NOT mention any set income sum) the "top twenty percent" is an aggregate figure but the medium is well over $100,000 and represents 51% of all the wealth in the US. source: ...
Also, that article, written by Ben Stern, is based on his own research which has been published in a book; With Charity for All: Why Charities Are Failing and a Better Way to Give
" Slade.com " has done a good summary of that book.
The problem is, the "rich" do NOT give unless there is something in it for them, like a tax write off or a statue with their name on it.
Or perhaps they give anonymously.
That is an absolutely ridiculous statement AeonPax. Liberals are always claiming the Republicans are all rich and greedy and your statement falls right in line with that one.
Take this for example: A family making around $26,000 doesn't pay any Federal taxes and more than likely receives "Earned Income Tax Credit" up to $5900 keeping in mind they haven't paid a dime in Federal taxes.
Generally they are receiving Food Stamps as well, help on their heating bill during the winter and help on their cooling bill during the summer. May even get a free air conditioner or heater. Their children are completely covered for medical, school lunches and in some cases food to carry home after school.
Now let's look at that $100,000 family. They pay (since you didn't figure anything concerning mortgage deductions and such) $17,000 plus just in Federal taxes, plus State taxes. They don't receive any help from the government at all. They are totally responsible for their well being for themselves and their children. Let's not forget they will be responsible for all of their children's educational needs right on through college.
This family obviously is trying to take responsibility for themselves and probably have a home they are paying for as well as all the other expenses of food and environmental issues. They have another child and inherit another expense, while the other lower income family has another child and inherit a pay raise.
Envy should be directed more toward trying to improve ones life in order to raise their standard of living and make more money. We need help over here, since only 53% pay any Federal taxes.
By the way.....Republicans are known to pay more into charity than Democrats whether they are rich or poor. Your percentages and his book are more like some of the graphs even I've been guilty of putting in a comment. I can condemn your toe when you face is beautiful. In other words a graph or percentage like this is ignoring the total picture.
Unfortunately, as all your points are unprovable, I'll forgo the requisite of asking for said facts and thank you for taking your time to add your opinion to this discussion topic.
I do not know as they have to, I believe they should.
Only from my viewpoint: How much is enough? I am finally at that point in my life were from the materialI have more than I ever wanted or thought I would have (nope not amongst the rich). Why not put it back into society to assist those less fortunate, I certainly do not need more stuff. But I am somewhat of a minimulist and as I stated it is my own take.
Pretty typical.
Tax Table / Tax Bracket Rates
EITC, Earned Income Tax Credit, Questions and Answers
...
5 Facts About the Earned Income Tax Credit
...
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (Food Stamps)
Income Eligibility Guidelines (for free lunches in school)
The 47 percent: Here's who pays no federal income tax
In a blog released not long after its report , the TPC explained that "a couple with two children earning less than $26,400 will pay no federal income tax this year because their $11,600 standard deduction and four exemptions of $3,700 each reduce their taxable income to zero."
...
Don't let facts get in the way now.
You can take it from here.
Sorry.....have to get to work. Need to make a little extra to be able to afford to be charitable. Your author needs to write a book trying to help those in need to become more self-sufficient. That would be more of a charitable contribution to our society than promoting class warfare like the president does.
If you aren't poor John, what are you doing to help the poor? I'm working to make as much as I can. And in the process I'm paying a lot of taxes that are being used to support the poor.
How much would be sufficient of my pay would it take to satisfy you? I'm not berating the poor. I've been poor and never been rich.
My philosophy is I'm more than willing to help those that can not help themselves and at the same time I'm more than willing to help the poor that can help themselves do so. I'll carry your load forever if you are unable to carry it, but if you need help to get on your feet....then I'll do that. Then it's up to you.
Don't make a lifestyle of riding in the wagon unless you can't walk on your own two feet.
luther28....That's what charity is. You've explained it very clearly.
Charity is something that people give voluntarily, unless they view it as a COMMANDMENT.
The poorer strata of society are typically more G-d fearing and less atheistic than their more wealthy counterparts. Therefore, they are more likely to give, and more likely to give MORE.
Spaghetti Monsterrant isn't all it's touted to be...
flameaway.....Are you rich? I don't expect you to answer that question. I'm not rich. I just enjoy debates. No matter what time I start working, I have the same amount of work I have to finish. Start early....finish earlier. Start late.....finish later. Why don't you find something that you can do today to help the poor?
In order to avoid being too late.....got to go!
Sorry sixpack, none of what you posted proves a damn thing. I will however take this point by point by point and use your own words, for starters;
1) "A family making around $26,000 doesn't pay any Federal taxes"
Prove it.
2) "more than likely receives "Earned Income Tax Credit" up to $5900"
Prove it.
sixpack pulled that little ditty off this site; which he didn't even quote correctly. Besides, the author was not stating a fact, he was just making an example.
Thanks for the laugh EI.
sixpack,
I'm not even sure you read the entire article. It's NOT about the government per se, it's NOT about paying taxes and it's NOT about whether the poor deserved to be helped...it's about altruism. It states two facts; a) those who make less per capita income, give a greater percentage than those who make a lot more and b) those rich that do make big donations do so for public recognition and tax purposes.
Historically, the idea behind the rich helping the poor has nothing to do with religion, it comes from a concept called "Noblesse oblige"which strictly translated from French is "noble obligation" which derived from the middle ages ethical concept that with nobility (a social class which possesses more acknowledged wealth, privileges or eminence than members of most other classes in a society) comes "social responsibility."
While there are no longer "nobles", there still a class of rich and uber rich and as the article suggests, "that the wealthy may be less generousthat the personal drive to accumulate wealth may be inconsistent with the idea of communal support." In other words, the wealthy have become stingy.
The article asks more questions than it answers and it passes no judgement.
AeonPax... Do you know what the standard deduction filing jointly is for earned income (for EI)? It's $11,900.
Federal Standard Tax Deduction for 2012
The above is an approved IRS efiler provider. They know what it is. Now you know.
Then you have the two little children to make it a family of four. Each one of them gives you $3800 each for a total of $7600. Now here's what we do. We add $11900 and $7600 and the answer is $19500. Now if they make $20000 there is only $500 left to pay taxes on and if they make $26000 their is only $6500 to pay taxes on. According to the tax tables the taxes on a family of four with net earned income of even $6500 is 10% or $650. Now Earned Income Tax credit comes into play and with an Net Earned Income of $6500 this family qualifies for a refund of $5236 refund. So you see they may have a $650 tax liability, but they get $5236 minus the $650 paid to them as a refund, so they pay no Federal Income Tax and actually receive a check for $4586 paid to them. The link below verifies this information.
Earned Income Credit
Note:
The Earned Income Credit has no effect on certain welfare benefits. Any refund you receive because of the EIC will not be considered income when determining whether you are eligible for, or how much you can receive from, the following benefit programs:
So....that covers both of your questions and provides legitimate links to make it easier for you to understand.
later....six
I should have just ignored the whole thing. actually. It was meant to promote class warfare from the start. It wasn't a charitable article. It was dedicated to promote the hatred of the haves by the have nots you liberals just can't seem to get over. When I was growing up we had more respect for ourselves than there seems to be today. One man's investigation that the rich pay a lower percentage than the poor is a very narrow view of the overall picture here. When you are trying to make something of yourself and continually get condemned by those that have no desire to improve their lives or the lives of the poor, but rather promote class warfare instead, it just gets to be old news. The comment that you wrote that made me inclined to respond is on the first page
That was the ridiculous statement you made in my opinion. I should say for you to prove that, but you couldn't. And it makes you sick. Class warfare makes me sick. And as far as helping the poor, you aren't doing anything to promote that with that statement. Like I said, "I'm perfectly willing to help those who can't help themselves forever, but at the same time I'm perfectly willing to help those that can do so." But I will call you on promoting class warfare.I know too many people that started with nothing and would still have nothing if they listened and believed that.
Sixpackyoure quibbling and none of this has a thing to do with the article, however, since you are insistent..
Your example of a family making $26,000 a year ASSUMES its a family of four , which you did not state. Not all families have two children and not all families consist of two adults. Point is, considering all the other variables, you could say SOME families with an income of $26,000 a year pay no taxes, but not all. Even then what does that prove?
Next, you state
1) Generally they are receiving Food Stamps Oh really? So generally, what percentages of those making $26,000 a year do actually receive food stamps?
2) help on their heating bill during the winter and help on their cooling bill during the summer Percentages please?
c) May even get a free air conditioner or heater From who? What percentage? Some elderly and handicapped on welfare MAY qualify on specific programs not associated with welfare but as for the rest?
d) Their children are completely covered for medical, school lunches and in some cases food to carry home after schoo l a) Child medical care is a STATE/county issue, not federal, b) as far as school lunches go, you need some facts and c) I never heard of the federal government (or state) giving kids food to carry home.
Dont bother replying to these questions. My point is that your original post was nothing but right wing assumptions and stereotypes. .and none of that is germane to this topic.
Good idea.
That is since it was so ridiculous and only promoted class warfare and did nothing to help the poor realize their potential.
Listen..This Will Change Your Life
Then you can be as charitable as you want to be.
Thanks Screaming for Vengeance. AeonPax made the ridiculous statement at the end of AeonPax's article about the rich only being charitable when it benefited them at $100 a plate dinners and how it made AeonPax sick and that was my original dispute. I'm not asking you to be on my side or anything like that. Like AeonPax has requested my participation has ended after this comment. Thanks for calling me Six as well. Old habits just seem to be hard to break. I don't think I was ever called Six or Sixpick on NV by anyone other than friends. It was always Sixpack and I don't even drink. I don't know if you are conservative or liberal or anything other than those and I know I'm not a tax expert, but I'm against class warfare and there is way too much of it today.
AeonPax , from Mark Ch.12..
Sound familiar?
flameaway..... You know you and I are going to debate and I hope we can do it with civility in the future, but probably not at times. LOL. But that's OK. I want you to continue to just be yourself.
Here's an idea. None of us want to be condemned because of the success or failures we've had in our lives. None of us are perfect. I know I'm certainly not. This is not confession time for me, but if you have confessed in the past and found it beneficial for either you, others or both then I applaud you for doing so.
I think it takes a lot of courage to admit the things you, me or anyone else has done in his or her life they know were wrong. Now it is time to move on as you have.
I haven't read any of your articles, but I'm sure they were beneficial to you and others.
I remember when I was in school and sent to the principal for one reason or another. He gave me a piece of paper and just wrote crap all over it. It looked like crap. He then said, "This is today." Then he gave me another sheet of clean paper and said, "This is tomorrow". Then he took off his belt and whipped my ass. Of course he would be in jail today for doing that, but when I got home my dad had somehow received the news. He didn't give me a piece of paper. He just whipped my ass. LOL.
My whole thing is by promoting class warfare it is no different than promoting prejudices toward others. I just don't like it and think it isn't beneficial to our society.
I can't say I'm familiar with your quote but it would seem nothing has changed in 2,000 years as far as the rich giving to charity for the sake of being recognized for it.
Painting with a broad brush calling rich people stingy. I personally know a very "rich" family that is philanthropic as as a goal not a convenience. They intentionally remain out of sight because certain people dislike the power of money when used to actually do what big government claims as it's domain. There are others who use their wealth to gain political favor as we all must recognize and understand. There is a short read concerning wealth, power and society that I share often.
If you find yourself agreeing, great. If not, your view of social well being ought to have a foundation predicated on real life such as the Johnstown flood.
While the title of the article is confusing as it's rhetorical, the rich in fact do give...most generously I might add. A local college recently got a million dollar grant to establish fellowships in Mayan art studies, a clinic got $100,000 to change the carpeting in their waiting room (along with a plaque on the wall) and a well known foundation donated $250,000 to help local schools purchase up to date globes of the planet Mars. All quite worthy and very tax deductible endeavors.
Contrast that with the community families who anonymously donated some 400 pounds of canned and box food for a Boy Scout drive to help those who do not get food stamps, a bake sale that netted $150 to help the homeless and local area plumbers who frequently will not change for calls from the financially distressed elderly and by far, one can immediately tell, how much more generous and unconcerned about taxes the rich truly are.
There are far more than 1500 who have become the enemy within. In fact our lack of corporate control has allowed foreign influence to access every part, process, agency and main media outlets. You might guess this but since the founding this country has been under attack simply because it denies the wealthy the authority to control the public. Well, it used to.
Lamenting the Roman empire or just Nero ?
Most "giving" by "rich" people is a tax evasion. I had the fortune to have been close to a very wealthy family and at tax time there were two issues I shall relate to you. One, during the fiscal year the entire proceeds of a conglomerate went, as intended, into a foundation for charity distribution. It still does to this day and it's a lot of money. No income tax is paid thus. Two, the tax levy on the income from well earned corporate management usually was in the 20 million bracket. The money could either go to the government and be mostly eaten up by overhead, waste, fraud and political pandering or it could be divided up among the most efficient charities of their choosing. The Mrs. was usually allotted about 80% of the choice and was well versed in how to manage it. The remaining 20% went to create and improve local public facilities ie; library, ambulance/ EMT services, fire/ rescue, hospital and the direct hiring of people as well. I would encourage people to look before they leap in regards to measuring the use or abuse of wealth, taxes and intentions. We must discern good from bad. I know that the line between those two has been blurred.It must be defined to be able to discern the most basic principles of society and purpose of any government.