╌>

WOO-HOO! Victory For Gun Owners & The 2nd Amendment!

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  pat-n2  •  13 years ago  •  26 comments

WOO-HOO!  Victory For Gun Owners & The 2nd Amendment!

The so-called "assault weapons" ban can safely be declared dead. Even Feinstein admits it! What makes this so delicious is that she was sunk by one of her own. Harry Reid!

Assault Weapons Ban D.O.A.

Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.) said on Monday that a controversial assault weapons ban will not be part of a Democratic gun bill that was expected to reach the Senate floor next month.

After a meeting with Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) on Monday, a frustrated Feinstein said she learned that the bill she sponsored which bans 157 different models of assault weapons and high-capacity ammunition magazines wouldnt be part of a Democratic gun bill to be offered on the Senate floor. Instead, it can be offered as an amendment. But its exclusion from the package makes what was already an uphill battle an almost certain defeat.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

This is a happy day for the 2nd Amendment.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

It is a political reality that we haven't yet had enough mass murders with assault weapons to convince lawmakers to prohibit the weapon.

If you freely admit that the percentage of firearms crimes committed with these 'scary looking guns' is miniscule, then why do you want to ban them in the first place?

Isn't it cool that Harry Reid rejected Feinstein's bill? I never thought I'd say this...but "Way to go, Harry!!"

 
 
 
David Webb
Freshman Silent
link   David Webb    13 years ago

From the U.S. Archives ( ) --

A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

Hmmm...I guess the key word in this text is "infringed."

According to Dicitionary.com --

verb (used with object)
1.
to commit a breach or infraction of; violate or transgress: to infringe a copyright; to infringe a rule.
verb (used without object)
2.
to encroach or trespass (usually followed by on or upon ): Don't infringe on his privacy.
So, not only do we have the right to bear arms, the government cannot take that right away. So, a total gun ban is actually unconstitutional.
As for gun control...common sense should tell you that is not going to work either. Mass murderers have no respect for the law any way. That is why they are called mass murderers.
 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

pat , Im just sitting back and waiting to see what they "think" they can get through . an outright ban on certain makes was unattainable even in the presnt political climes . but nothing says they cant piecemeal with amendments , now do i think they might propose and get magazine limits? possable , but they will have to think about and contend with just how fst thoe items have beenflying off the shelves , and since they are not distinctively numbered , easily manafactured , and lets not forget people arent exactly buying them just to turn them in in the future because of governmental dictat the probability they can get them is miniscule only those tht agree and are inclined to obey the law if it becomes law will do so . so they have to consider a grandfathering which makes present ones legal to posess ( IMHO the doom of any such ban anyway). another thought i have that raises a question for our pro gun control friends is , an obscene amount of money is spent by the gun rights advocates in pursuit of what they like , they have that disposable income to do so , what exactly happens when that money is no longer being spent and placed into circulation with banning legislation? is it expected that disposable income will be spend in other places ? places more in line with a certain political and socio agenda? or as one person stated , taxed 9 actually double taxed if this is the case)simply because its surplus and the individual doesnt nessisarily need it but using it for socio problems would take the bite out of a segment of societies part of the "bill"and make them have to pay less if anything? Dont know about anyone else , but i paid taxes on my income , whats left over ,it use to generate interest ( again generating taxes on the interest only , not the principle)by virtue ild allow the bank to use it to fund the making of loans and investment . that doesnt happen anymore because i have the supposed right to free association. i get to choose just as everyone else does when and where my funds are used . so even freeing up that money spent in the firearms industry doesnt mean those that have it will spend it where some of our friends would like . say hello to your economic waco.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Mark -

Here is the text of a letter I received from Senator Grassleys office today. It might give some clues about next steps. It's lengthy, but worth the read.:

-----------

Thank you for taking the time to contact me with your concerns regarding gun control legislation. I am grateful for the opportunity to hear the concerns of Iowans.
I understand you have concerns with S. 54, the Stop Illegal Trafficking in Firearms Act of 2013, that was reported out of the Senate Judiciary Committee on March 7 as amended. I too, shared your concerns with the original bill that Senator Leahy introduced. I expressed those concerns to Chairman Leahy before the Judiciary Committee meeting.
One of the concerns I raised with the original bill would have made it a federal crime to transport two or more guns if that person knew that the result would be a violation of state or local law. It would have created for the first time a situation in which violation of a state criminal law was an element of a federal offense. The legislation that was reported out of committee on March 7 eliminated all references to state and local laws. In addition, it does not contain provisions pertaining to mental health examination.
Other changes that were made to the bill at my urging were to clarify that intent is necessary to commit the crime, change the gift exception, and harmonize the bills various penalties. Compared to when S. 54 was originally introduced, it is now directed only at illegal straw purchasers, not all transfers on behalf of another. This allows people to buy for people as part of a legitimate business, or legal private sales. These changes protect the rights of law-abiding citizens, in ways that were not protected in the original legislation.
Additionally I submitted an amendment to S. 54 that was adopted by the committee. My amendment requires the Attorney General, Deputy Attorney General, or Assistant Attorney General for the Criminal Division to sign off on law enforcement operations where Federal Firearm Licensees <x{(}>(FFL) are directed or enticed into selling firearms to individuals the Justice Department believes are purchasing guns on behalf of another for illegal purposes. The amendment also required that in these instances, the Justice Department have a plan that includes sufficient safeguards to prevent firearms from being transferred to third parties without reasonable steps for law enforcement to interdict the firearms.
This amendment is a direct response to the Departments failed operation Fast and Furious. We all know the fatally flawed operation allowed nearly 2,000 firearms to fall in to the hands of criminals and the drug cartels. Some of these weapons have been found at crime scenes, including at the murder of Border Patrol Agent Brian Terry.
Unfortunately, these firearms will continue to surface at crime scenes for years to come and will take the lives of countless individuals. Fast and Furious is a black mark on the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms <x{(}>(ATF) and the Justice Department for decades.
While investigating, we learned that the tactics used by ATF in this flawed operation were disclosed to the Assistant Attorney General for the Criminal Division as part of wiretap applications. Those applications contained a detailed description of these flawed tactics of letting guns walk from gun dealers, into the hands of known or suspected straw purchasers. My amendment will ensure better oversight by requiring explicit written authorization for these types of tactics.
While working on the investigation of Fast and Furious, several whistleblowers expressed their concern of the gap in the federal criminal code to enforce gun trafficking. I have a strong belief in law abiding Americans Constitutional right to possess firearms. However, it is important that people who have forfeited their right with criminal acts and violence not be allowed to possess firearms.
S. 54, as reported out of the Judiciary Committee, would amend the United States Code to make it a federal offense to knowingly purchase a firearm for, on behalf of, or with intent to transfer it to any person who is prohibited by federal law from possessing a firearm. The prohibition shall not apply to any firearm that is legally purchased by a person to be given as a gift or to be given to a winner of an auction, raffle, or contest that is in compliance with federal laws.
The bill only applies to people whose conduct is already illegal under current law. It has no effect on anyone who obeys existing laws and no effect on their Second Amendment rights. Section 922<x{(}>(d) of Title 18 of the United States Code already makes it a federal criminal offense for any person to sell or otherwise dispose of any firearm or ammunition to any person knowing or have reasonable cause to believe that such person falls within one of nine categories of people who are prohibited from owning guns. Under current law, the person who provides the gun to the prohibited person must know or have reasonable cause to believe the person is a prohibited person. Currently, section 922<x{(}>(g) provides that it is unlawful for the same group of prohibited people to ship, transport, or possess a firearm or ammunition. Nothing in S.54 changes that existing legal standard.
On trafficking, the bill provides that if someone provides two or more guns <x{(}>(currently, it is one) to someone they know or ha[ve] reasonable cause to believe is a prohibited person under federal law, they commit gun trafficking. Similarly, if a person prohibited under federal law receives two or more guns, knowing or hav[ing] reason to know that the receipt of the guns violates federal law, they commit the crime of gun trafficking. Thus, the bill simply raises the penalties for already prohibited transfers and receipts where more than one gun is involved.
The straw purchasing part of the bill also tracks current law. Section 922<x{(}>(c) of Title 18 currently prohibits a licensed firearms dealer from selling a firearm to a person who does not appear in person at the licensees business premises. And the bill provides that a person cannot knowingly purchase or attempt to purchase a firearm from a licensed dealer on behalf of another person, that is, for someone who does not appear in person at the dealer.
The straw purchasing part of the bill that applies to private sales also tracks current law. The bill prohibits straw purchases by people with clean records on behalf of people who are already prohibited from owning guns under federal law. The sale must be made knowing or having reasonable cause to believe the person is prohibited, which is the same standard as current law. The bill does add one new category of prohibited person, selling to a person who intends to use or sell the gun in furtherance of a violent crime or a drug crime, or who intends to sell the gun to another prohibited person. That is what straw purchasing is, and only criminals, not law-abiding gun owners, engage in it. Again, the bill contains no provisions at all on the subject of mental health examinations.
Some of my colleagues still believe the bill needs more work to resolve outstanding issues between now and when the bill goes to the floor. That is something I hope will happen. I expressly conditioned my vote to allow the bill to proceed to the floor on assurances that work would continue on the bill. By reporting the legislation out of committee we can have the opportunity to have a larger debate and address concerns with the bill. I will not vote on the bill when the full Senate considers it unless I am completely assured that no innocent conduct would be criminalized.
With the adoption of my amendment and the changes to the original legislation I believe this legislation can reduce illegal trafficking of firearms and prevent crimes being performed with illegal firearms.
Due to my strong conviction to the Second Amendment I oppose Senator Feinsteins Assault Weapons Ban. The legislation raises constitutional concerns that arise in light of the Supreme Courts decision in District of Columbia v. Heller. Additionally, I oppose the universal background check bill. Recently, the Deputy Director of the National Institute of Justice wrote that universal background checks can be enforced only if there is gun registration. I oppose gun registration and believe expanded background checks would not deter prohibited persons who now avoid background checks.
Again, I want to thank you for taking the time to contact me with your concerns with gun control legislation. I want to reaffirm my commitment to honoring the Second Amendment and protecting law-abiding Americans right to purchase and own firearms. I agree that overly restrictive gun control does very little to deter criminals. It does however, do a great deal to limit the ability of law-abiding citizens to defend themselves. I am committed to making sure that people who illegally use firearms to commit a crime cannot have access to firearms and serve the maximum sentence so they cannot pose a threat to society.
Please do not hesitate to contact me in the future with any questions or comments you may have.
Sincerely,
Chuck
 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Now on to better ideas for controlling gun violence.

Yep. Many of which are outlined in Grassley's letter above.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

mental health parameters

That's where it needs to start, IMO. Especially given the mental status of many of the recent mass murderers.

While I often find myself disagreeing with Lindsey Graham, I think he nails it with this statement:

I believe that the best way to interrupt the shooter is to have a mental health system that actually records and enters into the database people who should not be able to buy a gun,

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Oh don't get me wrong i totally agree with that statement. I'm just concerned what will eventually define mental health issues that would prevent one from owning a firearm

With all of the over-the-top legislation being proposed, I understand your concern completely.

We're pushing for something here in IA that I think is fair. The individual has to be officially mentally adjudicated before they can be denied a permit. In other words, Billy Joe can't go down to the local Sheriff's office and say: "I don't think you should give Earl a permit because I think he's crazy". It has to come from a medical professional, willing to give sworn testimony that the applicant is not mentally qualified to own a firearm and could have a proclivity toward violence.

But none of that really matters until we can get the HIPAA requirements changed so there is more open reporting and these things show up on background checks to begin with.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

While I wholeheartedly agree that gun safety needs to be a part of every gun owners responsibility, and every child needs to be taught gun safety in some capacity, I don't agree that such sweeping measures would have an effect on crime. What purpose would it serve to force a couple in their 70's with no kids in the house, to remove the rifle they have mounted above their fireplace and put it under lock and key?

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

barb i can agree with what you have said on principle , but i have to ask, as far as training goes , what level should be acceptable ? i can use my own experiences as an example . I grew up around firearms when it wasnt exactly a pc issue , firearms safety was paramount in my upbringing , i then entered military service as what some branches call an MP , mine was more along the lines of nuclear and aircraft security but i was also crosstrained to do law enforcement ans Swat. I carried every single day while on duty , and had to qualify to show proficiency with a number of different weapons systems , now i did that for 10 yrs with semi annual and periodic training requirements , after i got out , as my children became old enough to hunt , i went through the hunter safety classes with them ( sort of a bonding thing so to speak so that they were not going through it alone ) so what levelof training would be considered enough?and whom exactly would be considered proficient enough to conduct this training?

as for storage requirements , that could lead to a constitutional issue . I wont get into the particulars of my storage but , what i do have is considered enough that if i chose to i could posess class 2 and 3 (fully automatic)weapons , i just dont see the need to jump through the hoops to posess them the government has in place . safes are of course a good idea , but not everyone can afford one that might be affective , so is one priced out of owning a firearm because they cannot meet someone elses storage requirements? triggerlocks also is an individual choice of the person not society IMHO. when it comes to locks , im reminded about something my departed grandfather use to say , all a lock does is deter an honest person and keep them honest and law abiding , in all other cases , all a lock does for the dishonest is possably slow them down enough to stop them or make the likelyhood they get caught increase .

i dont think there is any one size fits all because we all face different sets of circumstances , but discussing the issues is always a good thing . we just cant make anyone agree with our own particular take unless they agree with us to begin with .

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

My congratulations to you, Pat N, and to all your assault-weapon advocate buddies, and the NRA. I must say that if I were ever to move to the USA, which is HIGHLY unlikely, I would never leave home without wearing a bullet-proof vest and a helmet, put steel shutters on my windows, and if I'm not permitted to keep a tank on my front lawn, I would put a machine gun nest on my roof.

My God, what a way to live....

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Why would you do that, Buzz? As long as you don't look like a wild boar, you have nothing to fear from me. Smile.gif

Same with 99.9% of legal gun owners in the country.Just like any coutry...it's the criminals you have to worry about.

BTW...did you know I can blow a bigger hole in someone with a shotgun and I don't even need to be all that accurate to do it? It's also heavier and has more of a recoil than an AR-15. No one was talking about banning shotguns. I wonder why? Maybe it's because they don't look scary enough.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

actually buzz , ownership of a tank is not restricted , anyone can purchase one through DRMO sales , as well as a wealth of other armoured type vehicles if they can afford one and so desire , as for the bulletproof vests , well they arent really bullet proof , and some municipalities( usually the ones that have higher instances of gun violence and not with the supposed assaultweapons) restrict ownership of those to only authorized individuals , sorry but no machinegun nest on the roof , but with the proper licencing and taxes paid you could if you pass the BGC posess one but first yould have to become a naturalized citizen in order to do that .

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

I wouldn't get too excited...... I rather put my faith in sleeping with a rattlesnake than putting my trust in Harry Reid. He took a bill that was written to help returning vets receive help with their mortgage and simply said delete this and replace it with this which was rejected by the majority of Americans and passed anyway. And now we have a monster money eating healthcare bill to deal with. I wouldn't trust him when he says it will not be included as an amendment with the exception he knows he has too much money coming his way from supporters of the guns to go against them. That's the only reason Harry Reid, the muti-millionaire on a Senators salary may not put it in as an amendment. But I still don't trust anything coming from that lying slime bag and all his make believe friends that seem to keep coming up with no names.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Where do you live Buzz?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

It seems to me all of these people keep using the term assault weapon. They don't even know the meaning of the term. I don't know if they have just been brainwashed or born without one, but it seems all common sense was left on the table at birth.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Me? Dramatic? To be or not to be. That is the question.

Well I've seen a lot of rankings from many sources and the USA wasn't number 1 on any of them, except it does lead the world on obesity.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Most of my life was spent in my native land, Canada, but for the past little while I've been an expat living in China.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Hyperbole? Me? I told you fifty million times I don't exaggerate.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

There is no "right" to own any weapon under the sun, and one day this will be reflected in law , also.

In this country there is. There are plenty of communist countries. Please move to one that already exists instead of trying to turn mine into one.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago
sure was a surprise on the obama news network this morning, not one person on msnbc mentioned this died in the DEMOCRAT CONTROLLED COMMITTEE. all they went on about:mika, joe, broakaw, and some other lib lackey was that "congress" defeated it. even had a clip of 'now its out, romney paid no taxes...the sequester (that obama came up with) caused marines to blow themselves up' reid blamed it on "congress"the libs lie so much, why dont they just admit they are ALL on the obama payroll?
 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Reid decided as a strategic political decision

So let me make sure I understand. If Harry Reid stands in the way of the assault weapons ban going to a full vote, it's a *strategic political decision*.

But if a republican stands in the way of an assault weapons ban going to a full vote, they are *obstructionists*.

Does that about sum it up?

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

Pat , hate to say this but the bell on this MIGHT have been rung too early.

each session of the senate gets to make up its own rules as to how the senate will vote during that session at the begining of the yr , which is why the searchlight dingbat got grief when he let the filibuster stay as is and didnt change the filibuster rules .

from what i have read so far , all it would have taken for the DiFi bill to make it to the floor was a unanimous vote to allow it , but , if just one senator voted no , it would take a vote of 60 members of that house , they claim to have 40 votes , 40 is not 60 so it would have died . Now if this added as an ammendment to say leaheys BGC bill, then the rules could say it needs a simple 51 vote majority to be attatched as abill and a simple 51 vote majority to pass the senate , the devil is truely in the details and the details is the senate s own rules on voting . Remember pass and deem?

I know i wont be holding my breath.

 
 
 
Pat N2
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Pat N2    13 years ago

Yeah. The same thoughts have been running through the head of the pres. of the coalition I volunteer for. He hit me today with crafting a new e-mail alert for our advocates to send to our two Senators.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

Pat interesting development I just read about over on Johns article , Shame on U.S. .( dont know if i am allowed to refer to another talkers article ) but what i found is pertainant here as well.

Seems ole chucky Schummer( the schmeckle) background check bill is in search for a new republican partner , Colburn of OK backed out of that bill. the info is buried in the article and is a link from there , seems the impasse was storing the BG information ( can we say backdoor registration ?) something else to keep an eye on me thinks .

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

Mike , actually everything you mention is already part of the BATFE form 4473 , all that info is there and has to be kept in a dealers "bound book ". when the dealer goes out of business , those forms are then sent to the BATFE and they send them to WV to be put on fiche .right now they have to work hard to find just the first purchaser ,they of course already have manafacture records and distributor records , as well as records of sales from dealers . currently by law , the BG check information has to be desroyed if not immediately , within 7 days since they have all those other ways to trace and track the firearms . now if a state government wants to impliment a registration system thats fully within the powers granted the states , and usually thats someting the voters in each individual state should decide as it is now . NY may feel registration is required , montana or some other state may feel that its not required . thats up to the resident of the staes ,not some person that doesnt live there .

 
 

Who is online






166 visitors