"There is nothing wrong with success. This country's great goal and great dream is the equal right of everybody to become as unequal as their own ability will make them." -Ronald Reagan 1977
The assumption, in Ronald Reagan's statement, is that folks have a problem with success. I don't know one person who has a problem with success.
To the contrary - most folks I know do the work of building "success" for themselves and by their own definition of the word. Following are just a few facts to consider:
A few thoughts about this idea of "success" in our culture:
1. Walmart fails to provide a livable wage and decent healthcare benefits, costing U.S. taxpayers an annual average of $1.02 billion in healthcare costs.
2. Walmart Heirs Worth Same Amount As Bottom 40 Percent Of Americans In 2010 :
3. American's don't have a problem with "successful business people", we have a problem with greed. We don't have a problem with "wealth" we have a problem with billionaires and major corporations using our tax dollars to subsidize their low wages. We have a problem with the selfish and the greedy in this country demonizing working people on public assistance and not faulting the source (poverty level wages and no health benefits in the work place). As an American, I am fed up with this idea that Progressives hate capitalism (we don't - I own and operate my own business, and am doing very well).
I'm fed up with this idea that Progressives hate "success" - whatever that is, I'm assuming Reagan meant financial success. I think we can all agree that most people do not define success in their lives based solely on wealth.
I'm fed up with this idea that Progressives do not value individualism and a strong work ethic. That we want people "dependent on the government".
I am a Progressive BECAUSE:
- I believe in people over corporations.
- I believe in our government is OF THE PEOPLE (not of the corporations).
- I believe the job of our government is to live up to the ideals written down in the Preamble to our Constitution
We the people of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice , insure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare , and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
- Our Government is designed to reflect the PEOPLE, it represents. As a Progressive, I believe public policy should reflect the PEOPLE of this country (NOT the interests of the top 1%, but the interests of the 100%, not the interests of corporations, but the needs and interests of the citizenry).
Conservatives love to demonize government - as if it is the source of all our problems. They forget (that for better - or worse) our government is a reflection of US - the PEOPLE. It is designed that way - it is the result of what we vote for, what our priorities are as a culture. WE the PEOPLE have a choice, if we exercise our right to vote - we have a choice whether our government will serve the top 1% or the 100%. We have a choice if our government will prioritize spending on things like:
- Health Care - our "job creators" have been doing a lousy job, so has the big "health care" industry. So do we trust huge corporations to do this right, or do we choose to take control of our own health care by using the vehicle we all have a say in - our government.
- Decent wages - again - do we let "job creators" do as they wish, or do we regulate them. History shows - if we give them their choice they'll do as Wal-mart has done and our tax dollars will go to public assistance for the working poor.
- Building our own country instead of waging war in another country. How many billions of dollars did we waste in Iraq, when we could have been building roads, bridges, schools, police and fire stations, parks, etc.. here at home?
As a citizen we have a choice. I believe in individualism, I built my life through a lot of hard work, perserverence, self-reliance and pure stubborness. I don't have a problem with financial "success". Many would look at my life and say I am "successful".
I have a problem with greed. I have a problem with poverty level wages and no health benefits. I have a problem with subsidizing greed instead of innovation.
I am a Progressive because Conservatism is not about individualism, or about "family values" or about pulling oneself up by ones bootstraps, in this country conservatism is about conserving the wealth for the top 1-2% of Americans - regardless the cost to our Country.
Hello John:
I don't know if it's "well spoken", but it is a rant I've been holding in for quite some time.
Thanks Savage Saint.
I have no problems with progressives. I have many problems with democrats and republicans, even with progressive in front of thee label.
BadFish - when you find a perfect party, or a perfect political system, or a perfect individual ... do let me know.
In the real world we are limited when we walk into the voting booth. And (most of the time) if I have to choose between a Democrat and a Republican (especially in WI), I'll choose a Democrat, and I won't apologize either. The Republican Party has been completely highjacked by extremists and - with very few exceptions - they've nothing to offer the average America.
I agree with about half of what you say. I support ideas, not parties. I support progress which I define as making something better. There are good liberal ideas and good conservative ideas. I want to hear a candidate tell me what he/she is going to do, not how bad the other candidate/party is.
I could cite a hundred but will not. I will not respond to anyone who says there are no good ideas from libs,dems,reps, cons.
I politely say your comment is no different than this.
I did not say there are none. I said I have heard of no honest black people.
each statements group smear millions of good people. A racist cannot be changed by facts. I would respond the same to one saying i never heard a good progressive idea. Ignorance can be corrected. Blind bigotry cannot.
Hello Red Shadow:
If you're not willing to cite 1 or 2 "good conservative ideas" for Bob, I would certainly appreciate you citing them for me.
I've voted for a few Republicans in my time, although (these days in Wisconsin) they are VERY hard to come by. I can think of only one - and he doesn't represent my district. In addition - he'd get my vote because he's standing up to the big money politics of Walker. He's not marching lock step behind Walker and the Koch brothers. He's listening to the people who voted for him in his home town district.
And you know what Walker and his Republican colleagues did to him. They rewrote his district, so now his chances of being re-elected are slim to none.
But... hey if you've any good ideas from today's consevative party - I'd be open to hearing them.
In Peace - Rose
"That is what a successful politician should do. Getting others to be a part and allowing true growth and success in their neighborhoods."
Exactly - I couldn't have said it better myself.
Nice canned, off the shelf rant BadFish.... You pretty much confirmed RG's last sentence.
The problem I have with progressives is that they do not take into account the reality of the situation.
You state in your article that you believe in people over corporations. Great, but then you demonize Wal-Mart for the fact that it does not provide a "livable wage." I could go on a long-winded diatribe over the semantics of your statement -- but you never cared to define what is meant by "livable wage." Do you have a definition you would like to provide?
But I digress...
Corporations are in it for the money -- that is a fact. Why did you start your own business, Rose Gardener? Based on what you said...for the money.
Do your employees share in your success? Or do you keep the owner's share for yourself? (Since it is your company.)
You said in your article that you believe in indiviudalism --
Yet, you want the government toprovide health care, you want the government to regulate salaries, and you want the government to provide employment
Where to begin ...
David - all it takes to address what a "living wage" should be is a small bit of googling. I'm not the one who should be defining a living wage. America has to have that debate. But.. let's at least start with a few FACTS:
We'll start with some FACTS Elizabeth Warren pointed out.
You say
Well once again, it's not hard to find reality. A simple google search gets one all the FACTS they need.
Following some FACTS from Business Insider:
Corporate Profits Just Hit An All-Time High, Wages Just Hit An All-Time Low .. there are several charts that should interest you.
And if business sources aren't your speed, you can check out the FACTS in this state-by-state map, Hours at Minimum Wage Needed to Afford Rent.
And if those facts are too much for you, the simple illustrations in this link may be of help: I'll quote it below - for those of you who prefer the FACTS without the picture illustrations:
And if those FACTS are not straight-forward enough for you, I took a grand total of 5 minutes to condense them into a table:
Year
Minimum Wage
Gas
Rent
1950
$3.10/hour
$0.27 or 22m
$42 or 56hrs
1960
$3.80/hour
$0.31 or 19m
$71 or 71hrs
1980
$3.10/hour
$1.25 or 24m
$243 or 78hrs
1990
$3.80/hour
$1.13 or 18m
$447 or 118hrs
2000
$5.15/hour
$1.49 or 17m
$602 or 117hrs
2010
$7.25/hour
$2.78 or 23m
$790 or 109hrs
You mention:
As I mentioned before. I don't have a problem with financial success (I don't know a Progressive who does). I have a problem with Greed. Not all, but many corporations (such as Wal-mart) are in it for EVERYTHING they can get. If they were allowed to use slave labor, they would do it. Again refer to these FACTS
Or you may want to refer to a few other FACTS - there's a table with that one as well:
Table 1: Income, net worth, and financial worth in the U.S. by percentile,
As I said before (and as illustrated above) GREED is the problem, not success, not making an honest profit... the problem in America today is outright GREED.
And if you think this corporate GREED isn't costing you money, don't kid yourself. Here are some more FACTS. Pertinent info follows:
You asked why I started my business. Your logic is so black and white. You think business ownership (and I'm a Single-proprietorship) is about money. Business ownership (for me) is about one thing and one thing only - taking care of my family. Does that include money, you bet it does, but it is not limited to money. Taking care of my family means not being greedy. Not sacrificing family time in favor of more work and more profits, not sacrificing my (gasp dare I say it - because you know - the conservatives have a corner on morality) moral values in favor of a profit. (For instance turning down a lucrative programming job because the database I'd be building would manage pay day loans. And yes - I've made several decisions like that over the years.) Taking care of my family - means teaching my children those values. That a pay day loan database isn't worth the income it would bring in. Taking care of my family means teaching my children the value of work for worthy organizations, this means I offer give up profit by providing reduced rates to non-profit organizations.
I also said in my article:
You may not like my reasoning. That is your choice. It is my contention that one can celebrate individualism and community. They are not mutually exclusive. Our Government is a reflection of us, the citizenry. (Or at least it should be, big money is doing it's best to make sure that our Government does NOT reflect the will of the PEOPLE. But that's another discussion). At any rate, ideally our Government should be a reflection of the American community. We get what we vote for. And as I said at the beginning of this paragraph, one can celebrate and honor both individualism and community. They are not mutually exclusive. I am very individualistic (my husband and children will tell you that - sometimes much to their frustration). But I am also very family oriented, community oriented. It is possible to be both and balance both, it does not have to be black and white.
@ Rose Gardener
Hey Bob
Thanks ...
Can you tell I'm a database programmer ....
But one does not have to be a database programmer to appreciate the value of FACTS. One simply has to get one's news from multiple sources and turn off FOX News.
Hello Egilman
Exactly - and for more recent models of this business type, one can do a bit of research into the approach of COSTCO :
Or Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
It is possible to turn an honest profit and still be a responsible business who pays its employees a fair wage and contributes to the community.
Thanks AeonPax
OK. Love the facts, but also loved what you did not choose to address as well...
As for the definition of a "living wage", you decided that it is a debate that America should have -- but one you could not state an opinion on. Why? Don't want to be tied into specifics over the numbers??
With the increase in the minimum wage, the cost of doing business has increased. That's a fact that will continue with every increase in the minimum wage.Remember when a McDonald's hamburger could be bought with the change you have in your pocket right now. Well, those days are gone, because workers are guaranteed a minimum wage. But, it is not a "liveable wage."
So, let's deal with some arbitrary numbers around a possible liveable wage, shall we?
The new proposal is to raise the minimum wage to $10.10 hour (or thereabouts). So, multiply that by 2080 hours and you would have $21,008/year. Then they have to pay taxes. So, for sake of argument, let's drop that down to $19,000/year.
Why stop at $10/hour? Let's make it $20/hour like the OWS protestors wanted. Realize that means the cashier who takes your order at McDonald's would be guaranteed approximately $40K/year if the minimum wage is $20/hour.
What would that increase do to the costs of your Big Mac? How about the costs of a gallon of gasoline to get that person to and from work? Hmmm...
You talk about there not being a liveable wage in the U.S. -- Wonder what the minimum wage is in another country...say China? ( ) FYI -- The highest one listed is $240 A MONTH .
Guess what, you have to make choices with what you earn. That's called life. If you don't like the amount you make, you do what it takes to earn more. It's also about making choices.
So Elizabeth Warren's hypothetical BS aside, who promised anyone that life would be free? Who promised anyone that if we make money, so do you? Wait...how many people have gotten raises? Oops, thereI go with those pesky facts. So, how many businesses reward their productive employees with raises? I have gotten one every year in every job that I have had. Why would a corporation do that? Wonder how many people have as well?
How many more lucrative jobsdid you choose to pass on again? Is that not a choice you made?
Youare attempting toabsolve the worker of any responsibility for their own actions or choices. I am not a businessman -- because I have no desire to work the long hours it would take. But I make the choice to be at my kids' practices, games, concerts, etc. Wait for it... and I work in the corporate world. Those greedy bastards...how dare they let me spend time with my family!! (Note sarcasm.))
You talk about how the poor have to work soooo many hours before they can pay for anything. Well, guess what, it is up to them to change their situation...not you and not me. They have to make the choice that they do not want to live in that type of situation.
Oh, wait -- public education is the stepping stone to a better life, isn't it? Isn't that free? On top of that, the poor would get free meals provided to them at school, because it is the right thing to do. How many job training programs are out there on the federal, state, and local level? According to Politifact, there are 47 job training programs on the federal level alone.
According to you, that is still not enough...why? What could more money do that has not already been done?
Without going into much detail in a public forum, I know about growing up poor. I grew up in the 'hood with the crack house across the street, prostitutes on the corner, and violence as a way of life. So, anyone wanting to blame corporations for being too greedy needs a reality check. Start your own business and make it work.
As for greed... it is soo subjective . A quote from Thomas Sowell --
Progressives clamor that corporations are greedy and they should have that money taken from them.Is that not by definition greed -- an excessive desire for wealth -- in this case someone else's wealth. Is this not hypocritical?
Another quote from Adrian Rogers --
Yet, amazingly -- that is what Progressives want to happen. Let us continue since you feel the government is the best vehicle for this --
What happens to the poor when they realize that they do not have to work for anything? What happens to the rich when they realize that everything they work for will be taken away from them because they are being "greedy?"
The hypocritical nature of this idea floated by progressives is astounding. What is even worse is that they believe that their form of "greed" is right. By the way, enrollment in social safety net programs is at an all-time high is it not? So, how's that greed working out for you?
Take the last election -- the progressive Obama and the capitalist Romney. Since your fond of googling, google the charitable donations of each. Which one actually gave away more money to charity? Feel free to share the numbers.
Let me guess...Obama is not as rich as Romney. What? A $10 million net worth is not being too greedy? Does Obama really need $10 million to live on? At least Kennedy had the decency to donate his salary to charity...
So, let's get back to the "greed" mantra --
Name one government program that has decreased its costs over the years...just one. Do realize that this redistribution of wealth is going to be a programthe size of the SSA, the IRS since it will impact every American.
*Jeopardy theme music playing while we wait for an answer*
Obviously, you will not find one. The government is not a business -- as most progressives will tell you -- the fact that we are $16 trillion in debt is irrelevant.
So, theProgressive solution is go after the billionaires because they are greedy. What happens when they are no more billionaires? The government will go after the millionaires because they are too greedy. What happpens when they are no more millionaires? Or do you think they would scrap a new "welfare" program that has thousands of union workers employed?
I think you get the picture.
What happened to the Social Security trust fund? The government (Democrat and Republican alike) have raided it to pay for other things...so, no, the government does not have my best interests at heart. That money was supposed to be for the people when they retire. Personally, I don't expect it to be there when I am old enough to retire.
So, no progressive every wants to say how much is too much when it comes to greed? (Didn't Al Gore make a killingwhen he sold Current TV to Al Jazeera?)Nor do they want to address what would happen when that still will not be enough money, because the government is NOT in the business of saving money.
----------
As for the pursuit of higher education, Zell Miller -- former Governor of Georgia -- started the Hope Scholarship program for all students that maintained a "B" average. Guess what happened in GA -- grade inflation.(I was a school teacher in GA for 10 years.) Number of kids who qualified has increased every year to the point that they had to change the rules --
How many of those failed to make it all the way through? Recent estimates have the dropout rate at 70% for those who receive the"free ride."
Just like life,attending college is a choice that individuals make -- which includes the costs. Using GA as an example, people need to realize that not everyone is college material. Just because progressives want the government to pick up the tab does not change things...
Well, actually it does...we would all get the privilege to pay for little Jonny to show that he is not college material.
The progressive solution is what?? Mediocrity for all!!
Think about what happened in Greece where the government guaranteed almost everything such as:
The article says You have a problem with "greed."
WHY is a person greedy for wanting to keep what they have earned, yet a different person is NOT greedy for wanting to take the fruits of someone else's labor for themselves?
Nice rundown on Greece, but America isn't Greece.... what's your point?
And yet, you have said nothing to respond to anything I did say.
As I said before, you are attempting to absolve the worker of any choice that they make. If you work at a job with a set salary, you chose to make that salary. The fact that the company has made more money is irrelevant. That is the point of business. If you do not like the salary that you have, do you not have the choice to look for another job. Do unions not choose to strike for higher wages and benefits?
The mechanisms are already in place...no need for the government to be any more involved than they already are.
Now, there are numerous companies that actually give their employees raises based on their performance -- is that not the company choosing to share the profits with the labor force? I noticed you said nothing in response to that.
Bottom line is "greed" is subjective. And like the hypocritical moralists they strive to be -- progressives think everyone should let them determine what greed is.
In order for the wealth to be redistrubuted in a "fair and equitable way", the assumption here is that everyone put in a fair share. What is fair and equitable? Are you willing to define that?
What about the fact that social safety-net programs have grown every year since their inception? Why is that? Why do people continue to live off these programs through good economic times and bad?
Is it because they are greedy? Is it because they have realized that progressives will ensure that they can indeed get something for nothing.
Yet, like the author, you seem to think we can. Making one group poorer does not make the other richer.
People are supposed to be compensated for what services they provide, right?
We have had Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security, and now we need Obamacare, Medicaid expansion, confiscation of all wealth above what is it now...250K a year...because the government that is $16 trillion in debt is better at determining what I do with my money than me?
Really, this is the BS progressives want me to think is correct?
I will have to get back to youon the similarities between the two...but how many things does Obama want to guarantee for Americans? Just like they did in Greece?
Obviously, progressives do.
So, how much is enough? How much money do I get to keep before I am just being greedy?
Yet, amazingly, no one is willing to define what a "living wage" is. So, what is the amount?
Do you subscribe to the idea thatmost OWS protestors put out there that the "living wage" should be guaranteed by the government regardless of employment?
I bet you folks in Rwanda would be thrilled to make $7.25/hr.
Why I'm a Progressive
because its the only 'religion' that requires blind faith for global warming?
Hmmm...social darwinism, you say. (Still won't define a living wage, huh?)
The following already exists:
And that is off the top of my head...
What else do we need? Also, neither you nor the author has responded to what I said about the worker's choice to improve their own lot in life.
I choose to subsidize the salaries of Wal-Mart and McDonald's employees by shopping there. Otherwise, it is up to the individual employees to determine if they are wanting to make more money -- whether it is there or somewhere else.
Comments are slow too post, ugh...
Now, you are talking out both sides of your mouth...
Keep as much as you can...but punitive taxes should be imposed...
So, if $23K/year is enough to be a living wage? Go to the other end...how much is too much?
Here comes the reality.
What happens to people's motiviation to succeed when they cannot earn more than your proposed ceiling? Progressives are saying that the government should take the money from the rich to redistribute to the poor -- whether or not they earned it.
What will happen when the productive people don't produce as much? Will the government scrap their new welfare program? Nope, don't think so. So, to ensure that they continue to fund their huge mandate -- they will have to lower what is considered "greedy."
This is what happened in countries like Greece, Spain, and the old Soviet Union...
@John Russell "Fairly" earned????? I'd say FAIRLY earned is anything that you have worked for OR that your parents/grandparents/great-grandparents, etc worked for. The word FAIR has no place here. It's the word EARNED that is operative
I don't have an answer for your question, so I will wait for you to finish your research so you can share your findings with us.
Wow - go away for a day and the thread explodes. I've busy day in front of me, so I'm going to post this once and then let it go for another day.
David Webb - you posted much - but in essence you stated your bottom line as follows:
Well economic greed in America is not so subjective as you might think it is. You labeled Elizabeth Warren's FACTS about worker productivity as BS.
And then say economic greed in America is subjective. Well -- there is a way to quantify the obvious. Firstly - productivity goes up because of workers are doing their jobs. The top echelons of corporate America cuts and cuts and cuts away at worker hours. In the retail sector (for example) a store or department manager is suppose to meet "staffing numbers". Those staffing numbers dictate how many staffing hours a department can use in a given week. Employees in those departments have to get the work done regardless of how many hours have been cut from the staffing numbers budget. So... in an effort to reduce labor costs, not only are the top execs cutting wages and benefits, they are also cutting staffing hours. The employees that are left have to increase productivity (get the same amount of work done - or more work done - in less hours).
Just because some number cruncher sitting at a computer cuts the staffing hours doesn't mean that number cruncher increased productivity. The ones who increased productivity are front-line employees figured out how to do more with less. That is by definition "increasing productivity". And what do front-line workers get for "increasing productivity"?
They get lower wages and lower health benefits. See the following :
That dynamic is greed - see the chart below - it's actually quite quantifiable. And it's exactly the reason voters rejected the proposed policies of Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan. Middle class workers, the working poor, they know when they're being squeezed. They may not be able to quantify it the way this chart does, but they know when they're doing more with less at work. They know when they're working harder, getting paid less and loosing health benefits. They know all this is happening while the people at the top of the Social Darwinist food chain rake in record bonuses, even as front-line pay and benefits are plummeting. The average worker knows greed when they see it, they don't need me (as a progressive to define it) they don't need someone like yourself telling them their definition of greed is "subjective". It may be semantically "subjective" to you, but to the front-line worker their definition of greed is realistically "subjective". They're the ones making do with less both in the work place and within their pay-checks.
David - your point would have validity if it didn't ignore reality on so many different levels.
Again - our Constitution is designed to benefit the CITIZENS of this Country - NOT the Corporations. So from that point alone, there should not be one corporate tax loophole anywhere. Corporations should get NO benefit from the Citizens of the United States of America (through our government) at all. ONLY fellow Citizens should be financially benefiting from a Government that is designed to be a reflection of us - the Citizenry.
Now - I'm a realist - and know full well Corporations will continue to benefit from my tax dollars. After all, they're the ones with the money to buy politicians. Still - at this point in American History - Obama is willing to talk aboutchained CPI for retirement EARNED benefits (a sacred cow to Progressives), but the extremist Republicans in Congress are not willing to even discuss one Corporate Tax loophole. When I see Conservatives addressing the Real budget problem, the Corporate Welfare in this nation, then I'll take them seriously.
As to Boudicea's comment:
I actually had to read that multiple times. Because I agree with you - just from a different perspective.
Indeed WHY is a person greedy for wanting to keep what they've earned????? When a front-line worker produces more with less time - why are they greedy for wanting to keep what they've earned through their own increased productivity????? I agree with you completely. It wasn't the number cruncher with the spreadsheet reducing staffing hours that increased output with less time. It's the folks on the front-lines who figure out how to do more with less that increase productivity - they've earned a right to better pay. But ... it's not what they're getting. They produce more with less and the powerful at the top keep the difference. As I said before - greed is quite quantifiable. Most conservatives just don't like the way it's quantified.
Einstenian Insanity:
I'm quite well aware of how productivity is measured. As I mentioned in my post - just because someone at a computer (like Romney) "shed jobs" (another word would be killed jobs - but that's not what we're discussing here) doesn't mean productivity increases. You said it yourself, how much profit is made per employee. Well that "profit" is made because employees on the front-line figure out how to do more with less. They have to, or their jobs will be the next ones "shed" or "killed". And I'm speaking from very personal experience here - I've seen it play out in the front-lines where my husband works.
So you can (and others) can have all the dictionary definitions of productivity you want. But I stand by what I said earlier. That makes no difference to the employees on the front-line. They know dang well what they have to do to keep their jobs, they have to increase profit with less staffing hours, less of a lot of other things too (like worker saftey for instance). And to them, measuring productivty means more work, less pay, less benefits, less safety and folks like Romney taking in huge bonsuses for front-line employees hard work. Corporate greed can very well be quantified, it can be tied directly to the profits gained from increased productivity going to people like Romney who cut away at staffing numbers with no concern for its impact on the front-line and sucking huge bonuses from the resulting profits (that were gained because front-line employees did the extra work).
As far as the specific tax holes mentioned above, I quoted one source (I could have quoted many more and anyone who pays attention to news knows this). My large point, and I stand by that as well is quite simple:
Corporate Welfare is a HUGE problem for our economy. Our Constitution does not include corporations as beneificiaries of our Government. It is INDIVIDUAL Citizens that our Constitution is designed to benefit.
And at this specific point in time, we have a President willing to put Chained CPI on the table, and an extremist Congress that is NOT willing to look at even one Corporate Tax Loophole.
Concretely speaking - it can be proven - in solid numbers, that the top 1% and major corporations (feeding the top 1%) have benefited greatly from trickle down economics. The American people have been lied to over and over again about Conservative Reaganomics, and finally they are waking up. They know greed when they see it, and it's not because Progressives "defined it" it's because they're living with it in their work places.
Beyond that nothing you pointed out changes one simple statement I made:
Corporate Welfare is NOT an earned BENEFIT like Social Security or Medicare. Corporate Welfare is a major problem. Expecting changes to EARNED BENEFITS for the Citizens of this country without addressing the very real problems of corporations sucking our economy dry with their off-shoring of both jobs and profits is off base (at best) - and down right greedy at worst.
As I said, Einstein, I'm a realist. I know it's not going to end, and quite frankly I don't believe it should end. I do think it is a HUGE problem and as I said earlier, not addressing Corporate Welfare and expecting mainstreet folks to take the hit through structural changes to Medicare and SS is plain wrong. And as I said, Obama is willing to put Chained CPI on the table, but where are the conservatives when it comes to corporate tax loopholes????
I don't have a problem with that. One other requirement should be (but it won't be because the Conservatives won't allow it) is that if you get any kind of government subsidy or benefit, you have to pay living wages. Because U.S. Tax Payers are subsidizing low wages, and that benefits corporations when it shouldn't. They're getting away with it and they know it.
I know you haven't, but many in this country do - on a regular basis. They are making it part of the overall conversation and it needs to be addressed.
On another note, when it comes to worker productivity, I want to make one other point. Earlier I said front-line workers were producing more because they were figuring out how to produce more profits with less hours and less of other things (like worker safety). That was only one observation.
In the bigger picture we human beings need to keep in mind what it is we are doing, why we are here, what we go to work for. Our constitution sets out very high ideals for "WE the PEOPLE". Really - sometime just look at the preamble alone and ask yourself how that fits into the daily life of building our economy...
Why do we want a healthy economy anyway??? We want a healthy economy for "WE the PEOPLE". Now think of this on a micro scale, because an economy is a lot more than moving money around.
Earlier I said my husband and I lived in 6 different communities in 10 years so he could move up in the retail corporation we were with. Well those communities were small rural communities. They had thriving main streets back then. I worked in main street, family owned businesses before we had children. The economy in those small towns revolved around the healthy main street businesses and a couple factories at the edge of town. Then there were the farmers, that came in and shopped in town.
That's all changed because:
Measuring these things on a spreadsheet - separated from the human cost - just the numbers and nothing else, doesn't begin to quantify what this culture has lost in the way of it's small town mainstreets, factories and family owned farms. It doesn't - if they only way we measure our economy is in dollars alone - then we are failing madly. Because we are not living up to the highest ideals of our constitution (nor the ideals of the human soul).
Nice article Rose.
I'm personally sick to death of hearing we have to destroy Social Security & Medicare - while simultaneouslyhearing that we can't increase minimum wage to a living wage. How in the world are people supposed to save for retirement when they don't even make enough to live on today?
Here's another one of those Conservative conundrums: How can minorities or low wage earners believe the new initiative by Conservatives when Conservatives are responsible for restricting voting by means of ID, polling machines, voting hours, etc.?
How can people who claim to want smaller, less intrusive government support policies that insert themselves into women's bodies/reproductive decisions and prevent loving people from getting married?
How can a Conservative live up to the creed while starting expensive, unnecessary wars costing the US billions in dollars and lives?
There are more examples of this kind crazy thinking of course. There are many ways to illustrate the incongruities modern Conservatives have boxed themselves into. It makes it relatively simple to justify being Liberal. Not because Liberals don't have some mismatching of their own, but because the mismatch on the Conservative side is so blatant and extreme.
Conservative ideas have been taken to excesses that depart from common sense. Some people would say Liberal ideas also have little to do with common sense. But if I'm going to err, I'm going to err on the side of compassion and benefits for the larger number of average people.
"Floating all the boats" by means of policy that favors the wealthy has not worked. It has caused a disaster. Our government seems to have tried all manner of policy to mitigate the effects of the recession .... except....fixes directed at the middle and lower class. How about we try something along those lines for a change.
You and I agree completely (both on minimum wage and on health care policy). When we had the health care debate, I was stunned that major business wasn't getting behind something like a "public option" or expanding medicare. If we had set up a sane system, we would have completely taken the health care "monkey" off business' back. I do think that issue has led to reduced hiring, low paying jobs, and part-time jobs. We should have set up a system where health-care was paid for the same way Social Security is paid for (through payroll tax deductions).
Whenever it was done, it needs to be UNDONE and quickly.
Your assessment is simplified. See the following article :
I was living in those small towns when Wal-mart first started hitting my home rural state. And that last paragraph is frightenly familiar. It's not just tax subsidies at a national level. There are enough of them at a local level to cause damage, as well.
In addition - I could go into how Wal-mart rigs the system and corners small producers so that they can't (or won't for fear of Wal-mart) sell to local retail chains. And Wal-mart is allowed to act that way - no-one dares to go after them. At least not in any community, or state I've lived in.
Again - when it started (at this point) is moot. Farm tax subsidies that destroy family farms and hurt our environment (you should see what those mega farms do to rural areas) should end. Those subsidies are costing our culture a lot more than money.
Again, I agree. I build databases for a living. Much of my work is building data analysis systems. Some people know that when your analyzing numbers you also have to account for the human impact. Others don't. Sadly (in my experience anyway) - the ones who don't think you have to account for human impact out number the ones who intentionally find ways to document human impact. My guess is Washington, DC isn't much different from my own personal observation.
krounded -
You make several excellent points. In time the pendulum should start swinging back to the left again. Personally I don't want it to swing too far to the left - there is extremism on both sides. But where we are at now is very destructive for our Country, and I just wonder how much more damage is going to be done before we get control of the rampant economic greed in America.
because redistributionism is great until you run out of other peoples money?
Yes. 'How can a Republican' is more accurate. Until we can get the terms unhitched - I'll just follow along with the article title.
Medicare is fine except it does not cover enough people. And by enough - I mean ALL. So we agree.
As for number 3.....The point was to drawn a comparison between the policies coming from the modern GOP. When people are making below poverty line wages and end up on aid, the government and tax payers are picking up the slack. The same people that pay those wages are the first to complain about the people on aid. It's stupid and the people doing this are obviously blind to what their low wage culture is doing.
You stated yourself that you don't pay subsistence wages. I'm sure there is something behind that, otherwise you would be trying to pay as little as possible and you would be able to get away with it. Since I've worked at these kinds of companies that pay very low wages, I've seen some of this mentality in action. It's really sad.
I'm not really sure that all $100/hr employees are generating $200 in cash flow. Some of these folks are just good golfing buddies. But if one is looking at the correct industries with high tech/high return - sure.
Yeah......Since we are almost out of poor/average people's money now - Since the Walton family has 20% of all the money, and 90% of the profits over the last 12 years have gone to the top earners........I'd say the redistribution to the wealthy has just about run the rest of the people out of money.
Bravo to you JoAnne for recognizing it!
Now when investors recognize that all the money that was supposed to grow the business, be devoted to R&D and be paid in dividends, has actually gone to buy one guy a bunch of fancy cars and swimming pools and nonsense financial exotics - everyone will realize that redistribution to the wealthy is not a way to sustain a healthy economy.
The poor and wealthy need each other in balance. It does not mean there are no longer Rich and Poor - it means there is a balance that supports a thriving economy. One of our problems now is that that this equation is out of balance. The wealthy are no longer part of the regular economy - they sucked all the money out and now they just sit on it and play politics.
You would not believe how many companies would not do that Einstein. (BTW...not many people realize it, but the tooling guys are the ones that really make everything run and they are smarter than most people. But I'm sure you know that.)
They would pay those tooling guy $35,000/yr no matter what their contribution was. Your idea is good, but I don't think many business owners would see it the same way.
EI - what do you think it's going to take to break the grid-lock?
I actually thought the election would help (naive I know). But - I had hoped with Obama's win and the election about how we handle the deficit and balance the budget - that the Republican's would let go of the Ryan Budget and come to the table.
But... that's not going to happen - at least not in the near future. Just today the House approved the Ryan Budget :
They know full well - it's going no place - and yet they still did it. ...
There is enough blame to go around, that's for sure. I could count on one hand the number of politicians that I respect. But the tea party contingent in the house takes the cake. And until that dynamic changes, the gridlock you speak of is going to continue.
I could be wrong - and if you think it can break another way - I'd be interested in your opinion.
There is so much focus on the deficit because it's something the tea partiers can use to obstruct what really has to be done. They are going after Social Security, Medicare and Obamacare. Today they passed a "stop-gap" measure that defunded Obamacare:
They are going for the throat of our Social Safety Net programs and they're using the deficit the same way the Bush Administration used "weapons of mass destruction". It's a way for them to get what they want.