╌>

Critics blast NYC's anti-teen pregnancy campaign

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  summer  •  13 years ago  •  8 comments

Critics blast NYC's anti-teen pregnancy campaign

A new ad campaign against teen pregnancyin New York City has toddlers in tears and some advocates fuming over the harsh messages.

Dad, youll be paying to support me for the next 20 years, says one ad featuring a solemn-faced toddler, while another reads, Honestly Mom, chances are he wont stay with you. The ad with the teary boy says: Im twice as likely not to graduate high school because you had me as a teen.

http://todayhealth.today.com/_news/2013/03/08/17236466-critics-blast-nycs-anti-teen-pregnancy-campaign?lite


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Summer
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Summer    13 years ago

I don't find these ads offensive at all. Yes, they are blunt - but, sometimes blunt, honesty is needed.

I had my oldest son when I was young (I was barely 20 when he was born). It WAS hard being a young parent. I didn't have a lot of money, his dad and I split when I was pregnant with him (his dad however has always paid child support and been a part of his life).

Yes, there are those of us that have kids young that go on to do well for ourselves and our children. However, it is much more difficult than it needs to be - simply waiting to have children until you are financially and emotionally ready to have children makes having children sooo much easier, and better for the children.

 
 
 
Summer
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Summer    13 years ago

...

This one seems to be working. Sorry for the inconvenience. There is a video with in the article which shows more of the ad material.

 
 
 
Summer
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Summer    13 years ago

I think I fixed the link the main discussion above (and added it below also) - sorry for the inconvenience.

I'm not sure why the critics would complain over it. In the link I provided, there is a video. The video has a young mother (who was 19 when she had her son) saying that the ads "perpetuate a stereotype about young mothers" and that "some teen mothers defy the odds". Well, I think she actually stated a perfect reason for these ads - "some teen mothers defy the odds". There are SOME that defy the odds, but the odds are more in favor of what the ads describe as the reality of teen parents. While it's find to mentor teen parents to defy the odds, the point is to prevent teens from being parents in the first place.

 
 
 
Summer
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Summer    13 years ago

I absolutely agree. I think the reason that the stereotypes depicted in these ads are commonly true is not because the teen parents aren't trying to be good parents, but because they haven't grown enough themselves to parent successfully. They may love their children, but due to their own limitations of education, finances and experiences they have a harder time parenting their children - and the kids suffer as a result. I do think it's possible for teen parents to beat the odds.

Like you, I have had multiple sex education talks with my oldest son (my youngest still is too young for more than basic biology, which he's been told about also). I hope that my repeated talks will help prevent him from being a teen parent.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    13 years ago

My mother had twins when I was 14... best birth control on the planet... I would actually bring them with me to high school freshmen sex ed and let them tear the classroom to shreds letting everyone know that children are wonderful and beautiful... and expensive, time consuming, destructive, stressful, and should be better thought out than a few beers and no condom.

I can't fathom teen brains that think having kids is picturesque or beautiful all the time. It's an inconvienence, a stumbling block, and a real hard jerk into adulthood that most people can't cope with in a healthy way.

I think consequence driven campagns are the best. Why sugarcoat?

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

John,

The problem in Milwaukee is political. There is no empirical data to substantiate that. The political forces that spent those dollars want to take credit for something that at best, is coincidental.

For the last decade, Milwaukee has been launching massive ad campaigns bringing attention to infant deaths, especially due to co-sleeping. Not only has there been no change but the rate has accelerated.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Whatever works I guess however, all these ads run under the assumption that these teens can read. My experience is, there is a big problem with teens in general, minorities in particular...in urban areas, being functionally illiterate.

 
 
 
Disturbed Librarian
Freshman Silent
link   Disturbed Librarian    13 years ago

A new ad campaign against teen pregnancyin New York City has toddlers in tears and some advocates fuming over the harsh messages.

Somebody tell me why the ads have toddlers in tears. Are they serious? The only way those ads would put toddlers in tears is if the parent quoted the ad to them and told them something awful to go with it. I run a public library and the toddlers I see there can't read yet let alone understand the implications of a billboard ad. Sheesh.

I think the ads are appropriate, I don't know about effective.

 
 

Who is online







137 visitors