We Are Bradley Manning
By Chris Hedges
I was in a military courtroom at Fort Meade in Maryland on Thursday as Pfc. Bradley Manning admitted giving classified government documents to WikiLeaks. The hundreds of thousands of leaked documents exposed U.S. war crimes in Iraq and Afghanistan as well as government misconduct. A statement that Manning made to the court was a powerful and moving treatise on the importance of placing conscience above personal safety, the necessity of sacrificing careers and liberty for the public good, and the moral imperative of carrying out acts of defiance. Manning will surely pay with many yearsperhaps his entire lifein prison. But we too will pay. The war against Bradley Manning is a war against us all.
![]()
This trial is not simply the prosecution of a 25-year-old soldier who had the temerity to report to the outside world the indiscriminate slaughter, war crimes, torture and abuse that are carried out by our government and our occupation forces in Iraq and Afghanistan. It is a concerted effort by the security and surveillance state to extinguish what is left of a free press, one that has the constitutional right to expose crimes by those in power. The lonely individuals who take personal risks so that the public can know the truththe Daniel Ellsbergs, the Ron Ridenhours , the Deep Throats and the Bradley Manningsare from now on to be charged with aiding the enemy. All those within the system who publicly reveal facts that challenge the official narrative will be imprisoned, as was John Kiriakou, the former CIA analyst who for exposing the U.S. governments use of torture began serving a 30-month prison term the day Manning read his statement. There is a word for states that create these kinds of information vacuums: totalitarian.
http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/we_are_bradley_manning_20130303//
Tags
Who is online
137 visitors

If you have the time read the whole article as IMO there is excellent insight into this tragic case. The author indicts both, the US Government forsuppression of information,and international media for complicity in abandoning coverage that may allow the public to make a more informed decision regarding how we conduct our foreign policy.
No matter which side of the fence you may find yourself on this issue, the article is highly interesting containing informative links.
Excellent find and article. Bravo!
I've had a 180-degree turn in my thoughts regarding Bradley Manning. He is on trial and will be found guilty of many of the crimes accused. In fact he has already entered a plea of guilty to many of the lesser charges against him which when sentenced, has him facing at least 20 years of imprisonment.
I well know what it takes to defend a nation having worn one of its uniforms. The military, and those civilians elected/appointed in their oversight make policies and take actions on our behalf that most of us don't have the guts to admit to, let alone act upon. Here is the crux of what is at issue. Bradley Manning did release classified information pertaining to military operations, and secrets of state. Yes, that classified information very well did compromise the safety of military personnel, and intelligence operations in foreign lands. For me though, as I start looking at that which was marked "classified" was done so as to preserve image and perception. It was marked "classified" to insulate those that allowed/authorized atrocities, war crimes, and murder to take place as acceptable collateral damage when they knew that their decisions would not be accepted in the light of public opinion.
I will continue to watch, listen, and evaluate what comes out of these proceedings. At this point I still hold that Bradley Manning is guilty of many of the charges he faces. But for me, it is becoming clear that what he will be found guilty of, is unjust. His guilt is really is ours for having turned a blind eye to policies and actions taken in our name that we ourselves would never in a million years approve of. We civilians bear the responsibility for every death involving our intelligence operations and military around the world. The question is, do we civilians have the guts to own up to our civic responsibilities. I think most of us in America don't.
1) If he exposed "war crimes", how come no one has been arrested and convicted? The use of the words "war crimes" is nothing more than dramatic effect to try and support this loser.
2) Manning only had 'secret' clearance. Hell, my daughters clearance is higher. He was a 35F. Basically a data clerk. He didn't have access to any top secret information, thus he didn't have access to anything that could be comsidered a "war crime".
3) He was demoted from E4 to E3 for fighting. He had a reputation for being verbally abusive to his female counterparts. Most pathetically, he gave HIMSELF the nickname of "BradAss".
4) He did nothing more than a data dump onto a thumb drive. Seems to me that most people interested in exposing "war crimes" would only download that information and not nonsense aboutluncheons, recreational events and meetings. What he did was akin to an electronic tantrum. Not nobility.
5) He took an oath. He is an embarrassment to the uniform.
6) Holding someone like thatup as a hero is truly comical.
Oops. Forgot one:
7) He threatened to commit suicide for dramatic effect while at Quantico and them whined like a baby when they put him on suicide watch.
Pat, I won't refute a single word of your post, because I could list a half a dozen just like what you described. Hes is definitely not to be put up on hero status either as he did break the law and should go to prison for it.
Like tail-hook, or the Iowa explosion, the Iraq invasion, or Pat Tillman's death, we have senior military and civilian government personnel that would appear to being complicit in the execution of their offices or willing to coverup the truth. In short, why? The release of the information needs to be investigated openly.
How would you have listed Daniel Ellsberg and the Pentagon Papers? I look at this as being much in the same vein. Since most of our news sources have stopped doing investigative reporting it is getting more difficult to get to the truth such matters. You are no different than I am Pat in that you want the truth.
Fly -
I will 100% agree that there are complicit SENIOR military and civilian government personnel. I also agree that there is massive disorganization, duplication of effort and unrealistic demands sent down to front line leadership to execute certain missions with no clear plan of attack. These senior leaders seem to think effective military strategy is simply to say: "Be like Nike. Just do it"
I also agree that it needs to be investigated AND fixed. But where I separate from you is that it needs to be investigated "openly". It needs to be investigated within the military justice system. The only thing "openly" does...as we have seen in the case with Manning, is provide fodder for the media and causes misguided people who don't know squat about the military, to put people like Manning on pedestals, refer to them as "heros" and distract from the larger issue. WHich is the internal mess at the Pentagon and the effect it has on our troops and their NCO's.
With all due respect and thanks for your service,I have also worn the uniform of my country for over 20 years. Regardless of why something was classified, this immature soldier decided all by himself to dump huge amounts of classified data illegally. He signed all the required documents to receive his clearance, to include the standard Non-Disclosure Agreement, which he voluntarily signed. There were many avenues available to him if he felt that there was wrongly classified data, to include his supervisors, the chain of command, the Inspector General, his congressmen and senators.
Classified data, original classification authorities, and deriviative Classifiying Authroities have very strict guidelines set by Executive Order on how and why something can be classified. He should have reported it, but it seems he satisfied his little man's ego by doing it this way. You can't unring the bell, unless your lawyers are as good as O.J.s were.
Being a Supervisor in the military in years gone by, I understand what you are saying, though it's very hard to evaluate and see the problems individuals are having. I had one troop that I kept very tightly under my thumb, though the powers above me kept him on board. Could he have done something like this? Sure-anyone can-but most of us have the moral compass not to do it.
Additionally, it's always a tough call for peope un-trained in Psychology to evaluate someone else-becuase referring them for that kind of counselling does have a stigma attached that stays in their jacket.....tough call.
Spikegary... I agree with you on virtually every point you make, and this kid needs to do time.
Given that you have done 20, I know that you have seen things first hand that should have brought down the careers of some senior officers, but were "glossed over" so to speak.
For me, it was the Iowa explosion. Once off active duty I did the active reserves and was joined by a Gunners Mate 2nd that had gotten off the Iowa six months prior to the explosion. Over beers I remember him saying that "the Iowa was going to get somebody killed in a big way one of these days.". His statement came to be true less than three months before the explosion that killed 47 sailors in turret #2. The Navy and the NIS fabricated the initial coverup Truett/Hartwig story to save brass-ass. The GMM2 called out the possibility of poor material condition of the powder, the loading equipment, and the lack of training as the cause of the explosion, long before the Navy decided to look for and report the truth.
So independent of the how and why, we have this information out there that needs/needed to be investigated and acted upon while Manning does time for breaking regulations.
Unfortunately, this thread has become a bust. The idea of actually READING an article and offering a critique of it has given way to the repetitious talking points of those few individuals whose minds are already made up.
Now fortunately, my perspective has not been tainted by the military mindset of strict, unquestioning adherence to codes and mantras, which I suppose is befitting the warrior-class elements of this society. While I am not a pacifist by any means, I do not align myself philosophically or morally with those who refuse to question orders and tradition.
Our nation was founded on disobedience to a lawful entity and as I stated in another thread, it takes a unique person of character to willingly sacrifice themselves for what they believe to be a greater good. While the information he provided was not especially groundbreaking stuff, he was able to bring to light our governments deep paranoia and fear of whistle blowers.
As the article sums itself up;
I see the need for closed investigations as well. But you ask anyone involved with elected officials, or that have been in the military. The first move in any instance of a crisis is to save brass-ass. I am almost ashamed to have to remind you of all the sham congressional and military investigations and hearings that we have endured in our lifetimes. I know you to be as sick of them as I am.
Agreed Mike.... He is going to get to pay cash for his lumps, and should.
But what do we do with/about the information that is out there?
AP.... From the day we raise our hands and say "I solemnly swear", we are constantly having to battle the conundrum of following orders and regulations while measuring them to be sure they are lawful. At times it can be quite stressful.
Manning has already pleaded guilty to a number of crimes, thus he will serve time. His act of releasing this information though has done a service to try to bring to light crimes done in the name of America that some are still trying to brush under the rug. Not too long ago I had this kid labeled as scum of the earth equal to that of John Walker and Aldrich Ames, but have stated that I have taken a 180 degree turn from there. Please be patient with some of us because that aforementioned conundrum still afflicts us.
FR sent.... I'd like to send you some information.
I think "any" is too far reaching of a generalization. There have been plenty of instances of top brass being thumped. We just don't hear about many of them because they are handled in closed investigations and not turned into a media circus like the Manning situation. I agree that what you say can and does happen from time to time...but "any" or "all" just isn't accurate. For all of it's faults, I trust the military justice system to handle issues of true "war crimes"...which is what Manning supporters are accusing in this situation.
I dunno. I know a certain little E4 that has managed to twist their panties in a knot for over 2 years now, simply by following the proper channels, being aware of her rights, using Congress to her advantage to strike fear in the heart of an Adjutant General, and causing them the ultimate pain of turning down their recent medical severance package and demanding an in-person hearing in Fort Lewis with the likely outcome (per JAG) of being reclassified back into an Intel. role.
She is a fine example that Manning could have achieved the results he claims he was after, had he followed the chain of command, proper channels and exercised the rights available to him rather than throuwing a cyber tantrum.
(Translation): "I don't know squat about the UCMJ, therefore, I am going to dismiss it as irrelevant."
Did not our fore bearers take that same oath to God and the King of England? Was their oath any less sacred than the one taken now?
It's the authors opinion....I agree with it, you don't. No problem.
As my service came well after what took place at Kent State, and My Lai, I can only guess when the services really started to push hard on the idea that it is the duty of those in uniform to disobey unlawful orders.
It was clear that they wanted us to think for just a second before acting on orders. For the ground-pounders, they at times don't have the luxury of that second to think about the order as lives hang in the balance. In fact, they are drilled to instantly respond when ordered. I think for many involved in close combat situations, this may be at the root of PTSD. They are ordered and follow the orders to do things that later they regret.
Those in uniform are not machines. And try try and want to do things right 100% of the time. But they are still humans that make mistakes in judgement, and have to try to live with those mistakes. Some don't. Suicide is up in the ranks of late if you haven't noticed.
Extremely well written and well thought out post. I only take slight issue with the above.
Fact of the matter is, we don't know that this is the reason he did what he did. Only that this is the excuse he's using.
I think it's important to look at a persons history leading up to their actions to get a clear picture as well. Consider it playing Devil's Advocate, if you will.
What do we know about Manning? We know he had several Art. 15's and should have been demoted a long time before he actually was. We know that he finally WAS demoted for fighting. We know that he had major issues with the military over DADT and was VERY vocal in his opinion, even to the point of disruption. We know he treated his female counterparts poorly.
So we have a guy who was pissed off at the military to begin with, had a previous history with insubordination and just got demoted.
That guy then does a complete data dump that includes such boring information as luncheon schedules (not just the things he claims he's trying to "expose") for the express purpose of turning it over to someone he knows has an axe to grind with the US, isn't a US citizen and runs a government leaks website.
In my estimation, if he was truly interested in exposing "war crimes", his first communication should have been to his congressman and launching a formal congresssional inquiry. That is well within his rights to do, they can't do anything to him for doing it, and people who can actually DO something about a "war crime" are notified.
The fact that he didn't take that route and chose the one he did, combined with his previous history, makes it look like he was merely trying to "get back at" the military for "wronging" him and it had nothing to do with his current claims of noble intent.
This guy was trouble from the get go. It's much more logical to believe this was just more of the same than it is to believe that he suddenly had a moment of enlightenment and wanted to do the "right thing".
Just for the record...no one suspected he was gay. He was extremely vocal and beligerent about it, removing all suspicion from the picture.
What I'm trying to get at is that those in uniform still have a conscious. Did what Manning know conflict with his conscious and his understanding of lawful orders?
I can't put him in the same category as John Walker or Aldrich Ames.
I know hindsight is 20/20...but what I find interesting is that if Manning had followed orders and followed proper protocol, not only would he have "exposed" sloppiness at the top, but he would now be serving as an openly gay member of the military because of the nixing of DADT, rather than facing the rest of his life in prison.
Just think....the man could be a REAL hero today. A gay soldier that exposed wrongdoing at the top levels.
Instead...because he decided it was all about him and getting "revenge", he opted to take the route he did and is only a "hero" to a handful of activist-wannabe's with no military background and an embarrassment to everyone else.
AP, I would also ask, did he read each and every document that he downloaded to evaluate the danger to others (particuarly his brothers and sisters in uniform) that might come from his releasing the documents? If so, where did he get the information and the maturity to verfiy and validate it wouldn't put others in danger? I have serious doubts that he did this.
You see, this is why we have rules (in the form or regulations and Instructions). There are avenues to address erroneously classified information-he seems to not have taken advantage of any of them, just setting himself up as judge, jury and executioner.
It's the only logical thing to assume, given his previous history, the fact that he chose data dump over proper channels and turning the info over to a leaks website owner. It's far more logical to assume it was revenge than it is to assume he had a moment of enlightenment to do the "right thing". You are assuming revenge WASN'T his motive.
I used "sloppiness" for lack of a better word, because "war crimes" isn't accurate, even though it's the word his supporters like to use.
Ad I already provided you the proper protocol he could have used to get better results, keep his ass out of jail and still have the results he claims he was after. But since he didn't utilize that path, then it's pretty obvious that it wasn't about doing whats right...or he would have DONE what was right.
He even went so far as to post pictures to Facebook of him holding signs that say "Demand Equality in the Battlefield" and openly criticizing his immediate leadership. That is belligerence and 100% against protocol.
Pissed? Sure. Openly violate orders, slam my C.O. on Facebook and start many disruptions myself including calling my female counterparts: "Nothing more than walking, talking c*nts?" Not so much.
He WANTED to be the poster child for gay rights in the military. And that's fine. He just didn't want any of the consequences that came with it.
Gay. In that environment at the time, of DADT, no one was allowed to ask the question. It was a taboo no one wanted to broach, as your career would go down the tubes just for violating that law.
I don't think he was an ideologue-he may be one now, I believe his lawyers assisted him on writing his statement to make him look like a freedom fighter, when in all reality, I believe he was an angry young man thathad a need to be noticed. This is just my opinion, of course.
I think you are 100% spot on target with your thoughts.
He didn't think this through to the endgame when he released the secure information. But his lawyers have done so for him. At this point, I think he is kind of a rag doll blowing in the wind.
He will spend time in Leavenworth to contemplate his actions.
My cynicism is not about the men and women in uniform, my objection is to the "business of war." I'm not totally naive about such things.
My baby brother is now a vet after spending close to 6 years in Afghanistan. He returned almost unrecognizable, physically and emotionally.
Then there is Carl, (Vietnam) in his mid 60's. He was a LURP and as he describes it, his unit went from spotters for gunships to glorified assassins.
Tong, same age group. A medic who tells me how cheap life was there...handed out "heat tabs" as candy to children.
and Kurt, (early 70's) retired colonel who never says much except when he's drunk (which is rare), and what he says I cannot repeat and cannot believe. Two words describes his tales....Unimaginable Horror.
History tells me Vietnam was unnecessary. Current events has showed me Iraq was unnecessary. Both wars, an inherent evil, perpetrated by politicians and corporations. And who pays the dearest price for their evils?
I haven't gotten around to posting any articles about the suicide rate among returning veterans although I am aware that the rates are unusually high....and there's a reason for that too.
If what Manning did changes the minds of even a few people about the utter uselessness of wars like this, then in my book, is he is a hero.
AP
I don't know if you have much time to read, or if you do, will read about history. One of the best books that helps to explain the global insanity we have been stuck in for the last 60 some years is The Cold War, a new history. by John Lewis Gaddis.
It is a quick read and provides one with a solid foundation as to why Korea and Vietnam came to be, and the involvement of the US in EVERY conflict around the world up to and through Iraq. In short it points out as to how we have been our own worst enemy by creating that which we fight against today. In some cases for nothing more than corporate profit.
I've got nephews that will never be the same after tours in Afghanistan. The wars have got to stop, but I fear the one with the Muslim sect will take generations till it runs it course as I don't see any way out of it diplomatically or militarily.
There have been many insightful, thought-provoking, comments in this thread, especially from those that have served in the armed forces. Not so much, those comments based on assumption and hearsay.
While the "chain of command" and "following of orders" seem to be the appropriate ethos for an efficiently functioning military, what dilemmas must arise for the individual wearing the colors to forgo his or her citizenly rights because he or she wears those colors.
Okay, I understand the rationale of the military code and its necessary adherence for the military. However, as a citizen I also realize that might does not necessarily imply right and that, when involved in a war where you're not wanted by those you're there to "liberate," perhaps discretion is the better part of valor.