Enemies of the people (past criminals): Opinion
*Please note that this is my first attempt to post something around here and mistakes were not done intentionally especially if I posted this to the wrong place*
So VP Biden went to make recognition of the 1965 violent campaign of torture inflicted against American protesters in violation of not only the Constitution but the Geneva Conventions and the UN Convention against torture which the US is a signatory of. What we are doing is remembering the terrible injustice that so many suffered. But I believe that recalling those days are not enough. While we can see and hear the victims of state torture, we know that the enemies of the People are still out there. They suffered broken bones, psychological injury and public humiliation. I can't say if the evil men that tried to break the people's will have ever felt bad about it but that isn't important. Let's recall how Nazi criminals faced justice after their crimes even though the Geneva Conventions had not existed then. I believe that every one of those thugs should be tried for crimes against humanity in an international court and imprisoned for the remainder of their lives. If they do not surrender then they should be hunted down and brought to justice as fugitives of the law. Make an example out of them as enemies of the People. If the US can not support torture, they must prosecute them so people now can know that they will not escape justice. They will know that following orders isn't an excuse if even those only remotely involved would suffer.
I suppose that is all. Thank you for reading.
Tags
Who is online
134 visitors

Politics meant to deceive the people should be abolished. So should torture be made illegal. Those responsible for attacking citizens at Selma should be locked up now.
I agree that there should be punishment for the 'State Troopers' and 'Police' involved. (many of the so-called officers had been deputized that morning on "Bloody Sunday") It wasn't truly just the 'State' doing all the attacking, disgustingly enough citizens got into it, they just hid under the cover of being the 'law'. Following orders isn't/wasn't an excuse for them to try and make anyway... there were volunteers.
I believe that every one of those thugs should be tried for crimes against humanity in an international court and imprisoned for the remainder of their lives.
However, it wasn't a war, so the Geneva Conventions don't apply. If I understand the legalese right that is. Why would other nations be involved? At most it's an internal dispute in the States, and wasn't even a rebellion (if it had been a rebellion Geneva Conventions then apply). We don't try every violent criminal in the International Court. The Geneva Conventions aren't meant to overrule State Sovereignty.
Not to say it wasn't wrong. Also I believe that it makes the United States look bad to just let people get away with no consequences for that sort of thing. There should have been arrests and trials under United States law.
Theoretically Americans are supposed to do better than to let this sort of thing pass, especially in our own land.
I wish it would happen. I don't think it will happen, but I wish it would. But not just those that hold a position of power-- what about those torturers that go onto the Native American reservations to rape and torture them? They need to be brought to justice, as well.
But then, torture under the military was quite common under Bush. Maybe even under Obama. I don't know how we, as a country, got away with it.
Also, just as a comment, we pursued the criminals of Germany, but many of the war criminals of Japan were NOT pursued. In fact, a member of the royal family who was at least partially responsible for the Rape of Nanking may still be alive and well-- and unprosecuted...
It is a complicated issue, and why we let some go and some not, I don't understand.
I think the UN convention against torture should apply. I think they were terrorists and maybe armed resistance would have been justified.
Many war criminals get away with their deeds. The template of the past has been recycled and used once again with the newer regimes. Torture and attacks on protesters are not a thing of the past.
In WWII the Japanese had their R&D unit #731, which was tasked with biological and chemical warfare studies. From 1937 and each year on, this unit performed live experiments that sent at a minimum 600 Chinese men, women and children to their death. With the surrender of Japan, many of the scientist involved were made exempt from war trials as the US put them to use or at least their research into American biological and chemical warfare programs.
Dr. Wernher Von Braun, the man responsible for the design of the Saturn V rocket that got America to the moon was the same man that had designed the V2 rocket for Hitler in WWII. How much English civilian blood does he have on his hands? Nope, can't prosecute him. His research will gain our rocket program 10 years on the Russian.
Read the book, "The Plutonium Files" This book documents testing, much of it without the knowledge of its subjects, using radioactive materials on Americans as far as into the 1960s. Granted, in many instances, they were looking for a cure to cancer, and thought that radiation might be a magic bullet. But some of it was just bad science that we turned a blind eye to.
All of these programs could be justified in their days and were. When we look back on them today, yes they are horrible reminders of decisions made.
Take the dropping of the two atomic bombs on Japan. Looking back from our vantage point today, it is easy to see why some feel it was wrong to do so. I'm not one of those for the record, because I always view the decision from that time period, and not the present.
you're right-- and the atomic bomb thing, me too. I don't think we can second guess, because hindsight is always 20/20.
I think the UN convention against torture should apply.
That convention was adopted in the U.N. December 10th 1984 . The U.S. didn't become a signatory until 1994. The Selma to Montgomery Marches were in 1965. You want to prosecute using rules that weren't there until 19 years later; and weren't required to be followed by us until 29 years later?
I don't believe you can back-date terms and prosecute people for actions in the past under modern rules.
Armed resistance would have defeated the purpose and spirit of the protest.
Prosecute under United States law for aggravated assault/battery, possibly attempted murder, interference in voting rights, disorderly conduct, disturbing the peace, and conspiracy. I believe that things on the list were all illegal then as well as now. Any legal scholars out there know for sure?
There are probably some other charges we could toss in as well.
Prosecute the offenders under the laws of the time.
Polka you have only reinforced my notionas to whyI prefer the company of animals to humans.
I have always maintained the if the great philosophers of yore could come back and see how far we have come from a technological viewpoint they would marvel at the wonders we have created. When they saw how mired we remain in the human condition, they would surely weep.
What blacks were subjected to in this Country rivals the treatment of the Native Americans, both a black mark upon our collective history.
I believe we tried the Nazis after the fact when there were no Geneva Conventions applied to civilians at the time. Those thugs just like they did were responsible for crimes against humanity even though there was no war.
Every one of them should suffer life imprisonment.
As for armed resistance, it would at least kill enemy troops, force them into retreat and maybe even inspire greater rebellion...maybe even civil war....if the people had dared to take down the regime then we would have been free. It should have happened in 1941. It would have been a good thing.
What does any of that have to do with prosecuting criminals that beat American people?
I doubt the rate of death for US forces would have been that bad. I would guess we would suffer 75-100,000 with the Japanese suffering 2-3 million dead. Their tactics were about as complex as running at the enemy and screaming. No wonder they got slaughtered 3 to one even on the defensive. They were unfit for war and got crushed as a result. Through by the time we got to Tokyo, it would be Stalin lounging in the Emperor's palace.
Related -
I like the company of non-humans and good humans. Don't forget that humans are animals though. The human condition is artificial and will not last.
They way I have heard it put was it would have been a war of extermination. Allied troops fighting to live against an entire culture fighting to die.
You need to do some reading on the battles for Iwo Jima, and Okinawa which were nothing short of meat grinders. The Banzai charges were a thing that had been phased out by the officers once they saw that they were for the most part, ineffective.. The Japanese soldier was a product of their society in which surrender way a huge dishonor. The closer the allies got to the Japanese mainland, the more fiercely they fought.
Japan lost the war the day they bombed Pearl Harbor. They didn't have the capacity to go toe to toe with American manufacturing. Nobody did. Between our industrial muscle, and technological advances, Japan didn't stand a chance.
Yes, Nazis were charged for international crimes that weren't yet illegal when committed. So is not having a problem with that based on legal grounds or moral/ethical grounds for you?
I realize this might upset some people... As for the crimes Nazis were charged with... You know Constitutionally the United States shouldn't have supported the Nuremberg Trials?
"The crimes against peace counts of the indictment dealt with the German decision to "wage aggressive war." This was acknowledged by all at Nuremberg to be an "ex post facto" charge, meaning that the defendants were indicted for something that was not a crime until after they had committed it. Ex post facto criminal laws are completely impermissible under the U.S. Constitution; prosecution of the Germans for noncrimes goes very far towards undermining the legitimacy nof the Nuremberg proceedings."
From
There were already violations of the Hague Convention 1907, and of the first Geneva Conventions. Of course no one trusted the German people to punish the offenders... which if I understand the treaty were supposed to do so. Or not.
Question? Why wasn't anyone on the Allied side tried for war crimes?
We're not particularly consistent here. Legally, the charges weren't all fair; morally, I agree with the desire to punish the hell out of them. Just some food for thought.
As for the attackers in Selma... no, we can't try them in the United States for something that didn't exist as a crime at the time. It would be a violation of the Constitution Polka.
"No bill of attainder or ex post facto Law shall be passed."
and
"No state shall enter into any treaty, alliance, or confederation; grant letters of marque and reprisal; coin money; emit bills of credit; make anything but gold and silver coin a tender in payment of debts; pass any bill of attainder, ex post facto law, or law impairing the obligation of contracts, or grant any title of nobility."
They broke laws that were already in effect, they should have already been punished under those.
The protesters didn't want violence Polka. You seem to be missing the whole point of holding a protest in a non-violent manner. They weren't trying to destroy the government, but to change it.
Non-violence often takes longer, but is often more effective in the long run. Violent protests also have a tendency to escalate things, and not in a good way. They also lead toward vendettas, and it's much harder to settle things when people are going back and forth on who did what to who. Also... it puts the attacker totally in the wrong. It also makes the protestors less of a threat. More likely to gain a larger support base if you aren't attacking people.
Simply because the Allied side won the war. It doesn't make it right, but it is what is is.
The victors write the history books after all.