Kansas Democrats force amendment to include lawmakers in welfare drug tests
Democrats in Kansas were unable to kill a Republican bill to drug test welfare and unemployment recipients, but they were successful in adding an amendment that would require lawmakers to also face testing.
Democratic state Sen. Oletha Faust-Goudeau, who opposes drug testing, said that she wanted to make sure that lawmakers would be subjected to the same rules if the bill does end up passing.
Whats good for the goose is good for the gander, Faust-Goudeau explained, according to The Kansas City Star . - http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/02/28/kansas-democrats-force-amendment-to-include-lawmakers-in-welfare-drug-tests/#.US-RJ7n6BZs.reddit
The practice of of forcing people whom are on "General Assistance" to take drug tests is wrong on many levels. Aside from it being dehumanizing and prejudicial, it is based on a wholly biased notion without one shred of statistical evidence to back it up....a familiar Republican ploy also used to restrict voting.
Kudos to the Kansas Democrats for forcing their own states politicians to take this test.
Tags
Who is online
134 visitors

I love it. Every politician at every level, state and federal should be required to take drug tests.
To have a security clearance in the military, you have to go through urine analysis and stay clean. Why should lawmakers that deal with confidential and higher security material not have the same requirements?
Why is it "dehumanizing and prejudicial"? People have to pass drug tests to get jobs, why the hell shouldn't welfare recipients have to?
Finally. A dem I can agree with. (someone check the temperature in hell)
The rest of the country has to do a drug screen for employment. No reason politicians shouldn't either. Especially since our tax dollars pay their salary, making them really no different than welfare recipients.
I don't care who it is. Welfare recipient. Politician. Military member. If my tax dollars are paying for their life....they should be tested. And if they fail that test, my tax dollars should be taken away from them.
It is about damn time!! All politicians and all of those that get government assistance should be drug tested. Employees get drug tested at random, politicians are employees of the people, they should also get random drug test.
Agreed. Although, I don't quite understand the authors position that it's "dehumanizing and prejudicial" for welfare recipients, but not for anyone else.
Mike my suggestion would be that if a politician fails a drug test, itshould trigger an automatic recall vote. The state or district then has the opportunity to replace said violator. There probably should be some criminal penalties associated with it too, or at minmum the state or district should be able to fine the violator to recoup some cost of the recall election.
I need to open a drug testing facility in Kansas... if they dont default on their bills (Kansas that is).
Mike from what I can figure out about the bill- for politicians, it is a 90 day suspension, until he/she completes an inpatient rehab. 1 year of bi-weekly drug screening,a positive result is immediate removal from office without the possibility to be elected to public office again.
1 - Your analogy is "Apples and Oranges". Aside from the fact that tens of thousands of jobs do not require a drug test as a term and condition to gain employment (this includes professional, administrative and skilled jobs) applying for government benefits is a different animal. As there are no statistics to warrant drug testing for General Assistance, there are also a host of other benefits and legal mandates people apply for that are not tested such as scholarship, research grants, Veterans benefits, drivers license, small business loans, Medicare, Social Security, etc.
2 - Florida spent a few million to deny 2.6% of all applicants for General Assistance.
3 - To paraphrase the late great Louis Armstrong;
"If you has to ask the question,you ain't never gonna know the answer."
Not only all that, but the fact is they added on to the bill as well as those who get money from the government.. those in power and also live off the same tit will also have to be tested. I have always held.. . "do not hold a standard to anyone if you, yourself, are not willing to hold it". If they are trying to stop "drug use" on gov. money, then politicians should also be willing to be drug tested. I, as a tax payer, don't want to support any drug habbit. End of story. You can not have it both ways.... either you test everyone that gets tax payer money or you test no one.. aside from the decree of a private company wanting that done.
I agree, but remember not all employment requires a drug test so I find that part of the statement silly. That is up to the company, they may decide, but I do agree if they want to drug test anyone recieving tax dollars.. the politicians should be first in line.. or else give up any pay.
Innocent till proven guilty? or is this another american tradition out the door?
AMEN......wish we could get this passed in SC!
Dylan,
Thank you for your thoughtful , i nsightful , earnest reply. I shall try to to answer your queries in a logical fashion.
1) It seems you object to the word " dehumanize " which I used properly and in full context with the matter at hand. Should you click on the above word, you will find many sociological, philosophical and psychological factors involved, not least of which is " State-organized dehumanization has historically been directed against perceived racial, ethnic, national, or religious minority groups " which has a direct relation to this topic.
While dehumanization is a subjective concept, meaning it's open for interpretation, I stand by my use of the word which is to deprive a person of human qualities such as individuality, compassion, or civility and in this case, for no other reason than a suspicion...which many see as being racist.
2) I might ask you to prove this so-called " OVERWHELMING support for pre-employmentand post employment random drug screening " but as none exists, I shall forgo that. Instead, I will enlighten you as to the real and legal reasons employers use drug testing; a- Increase productivity, b-decrease preventable accidents, c- lower the employers liability, all of which are sound reasons I agree with.
There is a law called the Drug-Free Workplace Act of 1988 which is administrated by the Department of Labor but applies only those companies with federal contracts and even then, is limited to specific jobs. Private companies who do not have federal contracts but wish to advertise themselves as having a " drug free " are encouraged to enroll in the program.
3) " This bill has a LOT of community support in Kansas ." - Define " a lot? "...on second thought, never mind. I'll just say " if a million people do a foolish thing, it is still, a foolish thing. "
4) Why is it wrong on so many levels? For starters, it's unconstitutional . Also, as I stated before, while there is a logical and legal reason for employers drug testing, there is no logical, practical or legal reason to test all people for obtaining general assistance.
Unbeknownst to some people here, on 02/26/2013 the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously upheld a lower courts decision to halt a Florida law that imposed a mandatory drug test on all state applicants for welfare benefits. See the decision here: The next step is the Supreme Court.
This decision will have an effect on the Kansas bill, should they decide to make it into a law.
The politicians should be the first ones in line for pay reductions during the Sequester. Another topic entirely (I know), but just one more example of the double-standards politicians avail themselves of.
I'll admit, my opening statement was sophomoric but it did provoke a response out of you which shows you as you really are....full of hubris.
Rather than refute anything I stated, you went off in a rant about my writing style. All's more the pity. When confronted with facts, you go on the personal attack. I think that's called deflection.
If you want some intelligent discourse, you're going to have to come up with something better than your usual convoluted ad hominems. I presented my opinions backed by facts and you offer some obnoxious rant.
I made my case quite clear. When you ready to discuss this in a civil manner, please contact me.
Hope this measure also includes testing for alcohol.
Here is what I do not get. Kansas Repubs added an amendment to use all of the designated welfare monies to pay for the drug of welfare recipients. And, when that money runs out--they'll take cash from the general fund. WTF?
As someone that has received assistance in the past (and my boys still are on Medicaid while I'm finishing school - just a little over a year left), I have no problem with being drug tested in order to receive assistance. I do not find it dehumanizing or prejudiced in any way. I needed a lot of assistance after my divorce - the taxpayers assisted me greatly. There are requirements in order qualify for assistance - if one of them is passing a drug test, so be it.
I have been drug tested for employment in the past, for entrance into medical school. In fact, for medical school I had to be drug and alcohol tested.
Missouri recently did a similar thing - drug testing of welfare recipients. They did there law a little different. A drug test is required for all welfare applicants. If the test comes back positive, the applicant has a choice - go to rehab (pd for by the state) and continue to receive the welfare, or decline rehab and the welfare will be declined. There is follow up with this also, if a person does go to rehab, they will be randomly drug tested while on welfare - if at anytime they test positive (after having completed rehab), they will lose their welfare benefits. The thought process is this - IF they can get the person off drugs, then the person will be better able to land a job that will get them off welfare. Their plan will cost more up front (for those that test positive and opt to go to rehab), but, IF it works, it will result in a more employable workforce and perhaps less drug-related crime. Time will tell if this actually works - I hope that it does.
tesla013: I do entirely understand what you are saying. There are certainly drawbacks to drug testing (whether it be welfare recipients or for employment).
It is very expensive - and fiscally, that makes it hard to justify, especially when so few are actually positive. On the other hand, I can understand why taxpayers don't want to pay to help support someone that is using drugs.
I wouldn't have challenged this if you had said subsidies. But you said tax incentives and write-offs.
Generally, tax incentives are put in place by the government in order to incentivize business to do something they normally wouldn't do, but aren't required by law to do.
For example, there was a tax incentive a couple of years back. For every Iraq or Afghanistan vet a company hire, they would get a $2,500 tax incentive.
If I'm hearing you right....if the government dangles a tax incentive in front of a company to hire certain minorities, use greener processes, contribute more to the community, or whatever...it is your belief that the owner of that company should be forced into random drug testing for doing those things.
So....where exactly is the incentive to do these things that the government is offering the incentive for in the first place?
Though I am against any and all forced drug testing, I can still appreciate the irony of this legislation.
I used to feel that way, too. Until a driver for a company that I worked for killed a family of 4 with his semi truck while zooming on meth.
Well the jury is out on this one. I have to take a drug test for just about ANY job I try to get. Yes, a drug test for the right to work my ass off for a living. So, would it be terrible to force people to take a drug test to get MY TAX DOLLARS for no work at all? And, if I have to take a drug test and welfare recipients have to take a drug test, why not force a drug test on those people who are passing laws to make sure the rest of us have to take a drug test???? What's good for the goose.
Now, that being said, I do not believe in drug testing for ANYBODY. It is a violation of privacy
No one likes to hear about such tradegy, especially when someone abuses their personal freedom by putting others at risk. I just think it's always worse not to err on the side of liberty. We can "but what if" ourselves out of any freedom if we try hard enough. Liberty comes with a cost, sometimes very high. But I believe profoundly that it is preferable to punish those that abuse their liberty than to take it away altogether.
Actually, I am currently looking for a job and three executive search firms I contacted ALL require drug testing before they will even send you on an interview. There are virtually no jobs in this country that don't require a drug test.
@tesla - The point about prescription drugs is SO true. Ever see someone whacked out on methadone? Xanax? Valium? They can't even form a coherent sentence sometimes, but would pass a "drug" test.
There's a major point missing here. What is the purpose of these tests? Why, to exclude POOR people from stealing government money, of course. Rich people don't apply for welfare, poor people do. That costs a few double digit millions. Contrast that with the suits on Wall Street and the banks, that are stealing three digit billions , something's missing here.
Getting back to drugs...if the people whose tests that came back negatives, were giving the option of entering government sponsored programs, to help them kick the habit....I'd agree with testing, but unfortunately, that is not the case.
This Calvinistic religious crap about punishing the lazy poor, is so hypocritical in the face of the real crimes going unpunished, I can see why religion is taking a dive in the US.
In Missouri, those that come back with a positive drug test are provided an option: rehab (at the states expense) and they can continue to be eligible for welfare; or they can opt out of rehab at which point they would not be eligible for rehab.
There's a lot more to it than that, Chucky. Because of so many accidents caused by drivers that were higer than kites,the government now mandates that every driver undergo a complete physical to maintain their CDL. That not only includes drug testing, but blood pressure, cholesterol, etc.
The latest thing to hit the industry is this Administrations CSA requirements.It's new safety standards. One of the categories is "driver fitness". So not only do they want to make sure you aren't zooming on drugs, they are penalizing these gainfully employed, tax paying, middle class workers if they are too fat or their blood pressure is too high.
If they can do it to taxpayers, I see no reason why they shouldn't do it to the people those taxpayers are supporting. Welfare recipients and politicians alike.
I assume you meant positive and not negative in the above sentence?
It should be deemed uncontitutional (unreasonable search & seizure alone!!)What does receiving unemployment benefits have to do with this issue anyway - these people get sicker by the minute, they waste taxpayers dollars meeting about redefining the definition of rape, cutting funding to Embassies and Consulates (and then complain when people get killed), think that gerry-rigged political processes give them a mandate and then spend the rest of the time trying to roll back constitutional considerations of those people they don't like - the a**hats for purity need a refresher course in JESUS!
I'd have no problem with it if people who run around with nooses, calling the first lady fat and how they want to murder heror who act as if this country were theirs (alone) to start with - were in the next stale peeing away!
Better yet EVERY PERSON on Wall Street or working as an upper echelon within a BANK were peeing in cups as well - considering the degree of harm they've caused an are still causing.
I also have in my life have been on public assistance and can tell you they have many procedures and restriction for the little they give you - as those who don't know presume that said people are living it up on oodles of $$$ etc. - It comes down to "you are your brothers keeper" and there was no reference to drug testing being required to prove it!!!
I stand corrected. Thanks for that information Summer.
Your point is well taken.
No problem - I believe that Missouri's law is unique in this though - which is unfortunate.
For someone with a job and insurance, seeking medical help with an addiction is no problem. For someone poor, it's a whole different ball game.
Yes, there are people, whose exact numbers have never been determined, who will abuse their general assistance and spend it on drugs. However, not all people who take controlled substances are addicted and many who are, still spend their assistance money on what the law intended.
When addicts are cut off from funding, how do they survive? It's called crime and it is a massive problem in today's society. Which is the worst evil, stealing from the government or stealing from the people in their community?
I think the government should at least attempt to help addicts break their drug cycle. If they don't, who will?
There is a HUGE difference between "Farm Subsidies" and "General Assistance".
While I totally understand what you are saying, rehab is expensive. Many people - whether on assistance or not - fail at ending their drug use when they do it on their own; most require some form of detox and/or rehab to complete this. Those that are poor often don't have the funds to pay for detox/rehab - without assistance of some form.
I'd rather pay for assistance for a short time - with the requirement that they successfully complete rehab (and remain off drugs while receiving assistance), and get their life back on track, than pay for them for a life time (whether it be continued need for assistance or through the criminal justice system).