The Constitution has only been amended 17 times since it was ratified. Does that mean the Founding Fathers were pretty thorough?
Think about it for a minute. We have a group of men who predated telephones, television, cars, computers, electricity, modern medicine, voting machines and teleprompters and they managed to write a document which has been changed only 17 times in 200 years. Actually the last Amendment was passed exactly 201 years after the Constitution was ratified (with the Bill of Rights in place).
That's actually astounding! And lets not forget that two of those amendments cancelled each other out!
When people start saying "but the Founding Fathers never had to deal with __________" I just laugh. They were actually pretty damned thorough, weren't they?
Oh, and you might want to take a look at the list of Amendments 11-27. Not many of them deal with freedom, or liberty (at least not after 1900). Most of them deal with picayune details.
Your thoughts?
Tags
Who is online
108 visitors

imo: they were guided by providence
Providence? Isn't that in Rhode Island????
They were guided by something - obviously not modern day "education"
Allowing for the Constitution to be Amended in this manner, is not only pragmatic, its visionary.
something others dont often think about . the constitution provides for 2 methods to amend the constitution , one is the congressional method , and all 27 amendments have come through that method from the first 10( bill of rights) to the 27th . the second method is through Constitutional convention , this method has been threatened a time ot two , but there has only ever been One Constitutional Convention , the one the Constitution itself came out of over 200 yrs ago.
Under the congressional method , congress gets to make the rules of government as they desire them to be , they can with the ratification process basically say how government will run and what powers the government has , under the convention method, the government and all its entities have no say or vote in what proposed amendments come out of convention , its after its approved by the delegates , Congress gets no veto , it goes directly to the states for ratification . the executive branch nor the judicial branch have any veto power either , nor do they currently have any roles other than like congress , to simply call the convention .
can anyone see or wonder why all the past 27 amendments used one method and not the other ?
Of course several of the amendments were introduced by congress only after they were threatened with constitutional convention
Egilman
The Constitution cannot be allowed to stagnate. The basic principals laid down in the 18th Century obviously didn't anticipate the America we now live in.
Would you still want to live under the 3/5th Clause? Or not electing senators by popular vote? Or male only suffrage? Or, worse, unlimited terms of office for Presidents as long as they can be reelected?
You might consider rethinking your position.
Terry... If the constitution doesn't need to be interpreted, then why the need for the SCOTUS to have to interpret the constitution and its amendments as it applies to laws that are put into effect by the other two branches of the federal government and laws put into effect by the states?
America will continue to evolve in it's thinking just as proven by the 18th and 21st amendments. The constitution and it's amendments are here to serve the people as they see fit as they move through time. By giving avenues to make changes to the constitution the writers of that document understood that change in America was inevitable. History has proven them right
Jefferson also wrote:
And this passage would assume that Jefferson was in the belief that the Constitution was a living organism adaptable as the needed for application as America goes forward into time.
I think we are on the same page here in that the Constitution does not need to be changed. The SCOTUS has the responsibility to ponder the merits and validity of laws against the INTENT of the Constitution based upon the language of the time of it's writing. That being said, it is clear that the framers of that document intended it to be simultaneously durable and malleable, thus amendable.
I'll probably be in a small minority on this one, but I think we should revisit the entire Constitution from the ground up - a full Constitutional Convention. The Constitution itself even allows for it.
In the last 50 years we haven't had one significant constitutional amendment except for lowering the voting age to 18 - and the change to lock Congressional salaries is a holdover from 200 years ago that to me doesn't qualify as a current amendment really. And there definitely are changes we should make.
The current Constitution has many problems based on radical population, ethnic, and technology issues. And I think our nation's in a major hairy slump to me this would greatly revitalize our country.
It would of course bring our polarization to an intense fever pitch. But if you read the history of ratification (which to me is much more fascinating than the actual Convention) we were definitely not lacking in that first time around.
If we revisit it, we can choose to keep the transcendent values that have served us all these years, but change what needs changing.
Part of the problem now is the Constitution is way too hard to amend and we really can't any more. I realize it was meant to be difficult but now it's virtually impossible.
I'd bet anything that in the next 50 years or maybe even 100, no meaningful amendment will take place that actually originated at or near our time. The voting age one will probably be the last one.
I have enough faith in us that I don't think we'd throw out what's essential. And we have a chance to really learn from what we got out of the Constitution these last 200+ years.
How do we follow something that isn't reflective of the reality of our lives? Not easily! Jefferson has that quote out there where we should have a revolution from time to time. We are way way overdue.
Good side point I like it - but back to the Constitution. I suspect based on the quote which is the one I remember that Jefferson would have preferred the Constitution a bit (well a lot) more amendable than it is now. And I strongly suspect he'd be advocating revolution if he saw what was going on now with all the corruption and polarization/inactivity we have.
Compared to that, a Constitutional Convention just might be the ticket. A revolution where people talk and argue and no one actually gets killed.
I realize we all have our list. One thing I'd like is a national initiative process where we can vote on a few of our people's interest each election cycle. It could go a long ways toward upending some of our corruption in government and today the government is undoubtedly very corrupt.
The valid rationale for not doing that in the late 18th Century is the obvious impracticality of voting nationally on an issue frequently given that sending a simple message 800 miles took 10 days. In the Federalist, Madison very frequently sells republican government for exactly that reason.
Today we don't have that obstacle. Our modern technology clearly gives us the ability to infuse a bit of actual democracy into the process - we don't want a lot because we generally don't have time to focus on public policy issues but a bit to steer government back when the people really care would be a major plus.
And yet today there's far less than a snowball's chance in hell we could ever amend the Constitution to do this even if almost everyone in the country wanted to do it. A handful of states and well directed special interest would stop it cold long before we ever got 3/4 of the current 50 states ratifying.
I'd strongly recommend if you ever get the chance to read the Anti-Federalist papers. The point of that is you'll see our citizens back then were scared and concerned about *exactly* the same things you say here and what I find amazing is the reasons for opposing the Constitution resonate as real concerns today.
It's also a great focus on the Bill of Rights - the original Constitution was ratified without one because Madison and company thought it was implied in the articles and the Declaration (of interest to me is Jefferson was adamant about having a bill of rights up-front but he was in France at the time). But Madison promised one after it was ratified and the new government kept their word.
If we ever did do a Convention, to me anyone that's currently in office or hasn't been out of office for at least 10 years would be automatically ineligible. Any lobbyist or CEO is definitely ineligible. And each state would pick delegates based on population and what we hope is a great resume and special wisdom and understanding like we got when we got the first one.
Oh - to your last point, I remember 1968 where there was clearly enough civil unrest the government was nervous. I see 2018 playing out that way the history is repeating. I also see the front line being working people who had a major fall due to our idiots in charge and as the years pass, they're going to get that much more ticked off. Not Republican or Democrat liberal or conservative, but just kicked around way too much for no good reason and pissed off.
You and I are on the same wavelength on this issue. Aside from the excellent rebuttal By J W Welch, there is one point I'd like to add.
The US Constitution has to be an inherently fluid document. Here's just one example; in Article 1, Section 8 , it specifically mentions a navy and an army but not an Air Force. Were the constitution as ridged as many perceive or want it to be, the inclusion of an Air Force would have demanded at least, an Amendment before it was legally accepted. This, of course, did not happen.
By having a "Living Constitution", he framers were able to craft a document that surpassed their idealistic imagination.
You dont know what youre talking about. Your reply is gibberish nonsense. Im referring as to by what authority was a legal government entity created. Fact of the matter is, many such laws, rights and practices exist without the express mention of them in the Constitution.
For example, where in the Constitution does it allow;
In civilized, academic or even informal discourse, there are different ways and tacts you could have used to respond to me. You could have;
You could have done more, but you didnt.
I got a kick out of your how arrogant. reply, which translates into how dare you contradict me.
Living Constitution v. Original Intent are legal theories where there is no right/wrong and the strength of an opinion only has weight dependent on the amount of critical thinking that goes behind it.
@ J W Welch: I would LOVE for the 17th Amendment to be repealled. But what you're missing is that some of us want the Constitution changed ONLY by Amendment, and not by passing unconstitutional laws that aren't challenged.
Electoral College? Try Article II, Section 1 Clause 2, 3, and 4
Freedom of Expression? First Amendment
Executive Orders - Article II, clause 1 - vests in the President the power to execute the instructions of Congress.
Shall I go on, or do you just want to go back and read the Constitution again?
And, of course my PERSONAL favorites which others seem to completely IGNORE, the 9th and 10th Amendments. So if you ask "where did that come from" maybe it's not an "interpretation" maybe it's just those simple instructions the rest of the idiots didn't "get". I'll put it in even easier words "if we didn't say up there somewhere that the Federal government can do something, THEY CAN'T"
Jefferson was first on the line to agree with you - but it changed when he became President.
He had a hard time justifying the Louisiana Purchase because the authority to do it did not (and still doesn't) exist in the Constitution. But he did it anyway. Granted it's interpretable as unconstitutional, but it would have been absurd not to do it. Jefferson was after a treaty (allowable under the Constitution) to negotiate passage on the Mississippi then got the opportunity to purchase the entire territory (not Constitutional) which was a gift impossible to refuse.
Us humans are infinitely good at rationalization. There's no avoiding it.
I get the gist of the comment here - but I'm overwhelmed by the drama and feel slimed.
that's a matter of opinion. The 17th in particular was useless, worthless and did nothing positive for the country at all. The amendment for the voting age was nothing BUT picayune. I reiterate, nothing but details. Nothing about liberty or freedom. (Did I mention there were Amendments about voting in the FIRST PLACE because the Fed Govt wasn't given that authority by the Constitution?)