Former "Student" Sues College for $1.3M over C Plus
I am sure that most of you have seen this story in the media and probably know that thankfully the court ruled against this frivolous lawsuit, though considering she filed the suit in the first place I am sure that there will be an appeal.
These types of lawsuits are the most significant problem our legal system faces.
We truly need to have a "loser pays all" law enacted to limit the frivolous law suites filed.
I found the following open letter to the student to bea little funny and mostly right on point
Dear Ms. Thode;
Oh boy, where to begin? Perhaps in early childhood? Thats when and where most of first learn that life is not always fair. We come to understand that sometimes all thats left in the box are the hated orange Popsicles, or that while our brother might have gotten the height in the family, we inherited Dads 20/20 vision. We learn that sometimes other people get things that we want and that theyre not obligated to share them. We learn that sometimes we receive rewards we didnt earn and sometimes we are denied achievements we feel are rightly ours by virtue of hard work and righteous conduct. In short, we learn life is not fair and life doesnt particularly care if you dont like this fact. Go ahead, ask it.
It seems you did not learn these lessons. In fact, it seems as if you reached the relatively ripe old age of 27 thinking that you were owed things on virtue ofbeing alive? wanting them really badly? yelling the loudest? because Mommy and Daddy told you so? Please let me disabuse you of this notion. Despite the fact that you received free tuition and on-campus employment as a result of the fact that your father is a professor at your alma mater, you are not owed anything by Lehigh University other than the provision of classes, learning resources, access to faculty and facilities in which to experience said learning and perhaps a student parking spot. You are not owed a degree, an A, a spot on the varsity soccer team or, sadly, a career upon graduation heck, you arent even owed a graduation if you dont meet your schools matriculation standards. Yes, its unfortunate that your C+ held you back, but the fact is that it is YOUR C+. The time and the effort that you have spent trying to have it expunged from your permanent record or upgraded could have been spent retaking the course in question and moving on with the career you claim you want so badly. You apparently want it badly enough to launch a lawsuit that casts skeptical national attention on your professionalism and the content of your personal character, but not enough to simply suck it up and do the class over again. Probably for free. This doesnt really seem like the type of judgment one would seek out in a therapist, does it?
In closing, Id urge you, Ms. Thode, to consider the advice youd give future patients. Are you going to suggest that Jane and John Doe look for scapegoats for their current woes? Are you going to encourage them to blame their parents, their partners or their bosses for the pain theyre experiencing? Are you going to recommend that seeking to extract their pound of flesh from these parties is a better approach to strengthening their mental health than doing the hard work of examining their own attitudes and behaviors and empowering themselves to make the needed changes? If so, there isnt a school in this land that should ever grant you a degree.
Best Wishes,
JMH
See entire article at http://www.forbes.com/sites/jmaureenhenderson/2013/02/13/an-open-letter-to-the-former-student-suing-her-alma-mater-for-1-3m-over-a-bad-grade/
Tags
Who is online
112 visitors

This young lady could do well to heed the advice of Erica Jong who tells us --
She got the C Plus, her actions and attitude resulted in here receiving the grade, not the professor, the college or anyone else.
I love it. I saw that, was going to post it, but decided not to. It will never cease to amaze me how greedy/self centered/foolish people are, especially those that are getting things FOR FREE!
Terry,
What is it about you and "Free". This isn't about free. This is about bad parenting. This generation of kids have been taught by everyone around them, that they are wonderful, no matter what they do. They expect things to go their own way, and when they don't, they have hissy fits like a toddler having a temper tantrum. Mommy and daddy probably made sure that all tantrums were given into.
This "Your Special" concept, that was supposed to build ego, instead has made spoiled brats.
All true. My only point re: free was to buttress your point! (You're a bit techy, eh?)
It's kind of like being starved, then complaining that the steak is slightly overdone and sending it back!
Or the stories we heard of the Katrina folks coming to Houston and whining because they were given water and turkey/ham sandwiches, and not soda and McD's!
It all goes back to those asshat psychologists that asserted lack of self esteem was the root cause for (insert whatever personality trait is undesirable).
In fact, it is now becoming pretty clear it is quite the opposite. But those dumb shit pop psychologists convinced the parents, who screwed up their kids.
Speaking of which, how are the twins doing? Acclimating better?
Terry
How true
Littlepersonal responsibility or accountability for actions being instilled in the youth of today by their parents or by society and they are poorer for it.
John
Or we can take responsibility for our lives, teach our children and grandchildren to do the same and try to fix the problem ourselves.
You make excellent points and I will check out the story you speak of I missed that one