Are government benefits fueling US poverty?
Gee, come on, it's only those crazy, bible toting, gun loving, black hating red necks that think this way!
Ooops, maybe not. Maybe the dem/government plantation is real. Maybe folks just don't want to recognize reality, truth.
Romney later said his remarks were "completely wrong." But Ohio University economist Richard Vedder believes they were right.
He says an expanding system of government benefits has helpedcreate a poverty rate of 14 percent.
"They're actually creating a dependency on government, which is unhealthy both for the individuals involved and their children, and also for the broader society," he said.
Vedder said Department of Labor statistics show four programs in particular contribute to Americans' increasing dependence on government.
- Food stamps, or The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, as it's now known. Nearly 30 million more Americans receive them than in the year 2000.
- Social Security Disability: 3 million Americans received payments in 1990 -- today it's 8.6 million.
- Pell grants: 3.9 million students were awarded them in 2000. Today it's 9.7 million,even though nearly half of graduates work in jobs that require no degree.
- And extended unemployment benefits:26 weeks had been the standard -- today it's 52 weeks or more for many.
Vedder's blunt assessment rings hollow for Lennie Isabelle, a laid-off worker with 33 years of paralegal experience who now receives unemployment benefits that, she says, she hates collecting. "People are crying being unemployed. It's not helping the economy at all. When people are working, the country is happy," she told Fox News.
Tags
Who is online
131 visitors

Let's not forget the insurance companies. My homeowners just went up over $500 and I have never made a claim on it. Seems that they don't like to have to pay out for hurricane victims that already payunbelievablyhigh flood insurance rates. Might not be able to get those big CEO bonuses otherwise. My insurance over the last 7 years has more than doubled going from $1,200 to almost $4,000 a year. Gee, I wonder what that is doing to spending, which drives the economy and helps create jobs?
Fine with me. I'm all for it.
I's go further, cut Congress' pay, perks. Only have them in session for three months. They shouldn't have their own fricking planes, that we're paying for. They're not royalty.
Note, no one is "blaming" the poor for being poor. Hell, this guy is actually saying the government is creating the poor! You okay with that? And, know what, many times the 'poor' are poor because they're lazy shits. It's just a fact, sorry.
Do you not care about those who are stealing from those that truly need it? That's okay with you? Strange.
imo: one need look no further than LBJ's ground zero for "war on poverty": detroit.
it now has the same population it had 100 years ago
the "saftey net" has become another form of slavery
Very true.
And one in thirty Americans are on "disability". Some true Social Security Disability and a great many of them on Supplemental Security Income - which is probably the single area of entitlement that is truly "secure". You're right, once you're on it you have to be a complete moron to get thrown off.
So let me establish something in this discussion. We concur that there are those really in need, and those who are abusing the system, right?
Next..unemployment benefits.. they had to extend them, since the job market hasn'trecovered That is a fact. When it does, it should go back to the 26 weeks. This isn't written in stone.
Food stamps tie directly into unemployment. In most states, the unemployment benefits weekly max isn't enough to cover the cost of yourmortgage/rent,utilities, clothes, insurance (forget about it, if you need COBRA). Here is a complete list state by state:
The Pell grant statement doesn't even make sense. These grads are working and trying to going to school so that they can get a better job. When one fills out the FASFA to get the Pell grant, you have to include your current income. If they were makingsufficientincome, they wouldn't be getting the grant.
Social Security disability is probably the most legit gripe here. It is abused by many people who can work, but chose not to. Now not everyone is abusing it, but there should be better oversight here.
Oh, please. How about a lazy shit that even when offered a job, won't work.
And if you find truth offensive, sorry. That's your issue, not mine.
Oh, that is such sloppy thinking, and writing. Not, it's NOT a "fact" that they had to be extended. It's a "fact" they were extended, but the politicians didn't have to extend them, sorry.
And, IMO, they shouldn't have.
Then you're not thinking about it rationally. Sorry, as noted over 50% of the folks get jobs that don't require a college education. What is happening, and you have even stated this before, is that college is being used as a means to extend childhood (see my oldest) in many instances. Tough, the government should NOT be in the business of furthering such activities.
Note, so is unemployment. So are food stamps, disability is just another extension of the same attitude.
A lot of those Pell grants are going directly to people who are staying in school so they don't have to start paying back their student loans. I know people who tell me they will go to school as long as the government will give them the money!
It's really very easy to blame those "evil" insurance companies for making a dime in profit, isn't it? Nobody seems to understand that if they pay $500 a year for insurance for 30 years then had their home burn to the ground, they would STILL have paid far far less than the insurance company will pay them. I really hate when people blame insurance companies for providing such a necessary service and making a little bit of money out of it! Next people are going to start expecting the government to provide fire insurance free too.
Oh, and by the way Perrie, I don't mean to sound snide, but you DO know that that nasty flood insurance is GOVERNMENT insurance, right? your homeowner's is a private company but FLOOD insurance is the NFIP - National Flood Insurance Plan - that's right, FEMA
Yup. And then they will default when they finally get out and get a job and the government won't do a damned thing.
we don't "give" 41 billion to oil and gas or "give" 50+ billion to drug makers. You're talking about tax credits, deductions, etc. So lets talk about direct "giving".
Supplemental Security Income - 53 BILLION in 2013 to 8 million people. That's 8 million people who NEVER WORKED enough to qualify for Social Security Disability, but who are still sucking down my tax dollars. Oh sure, they are "disabled" yeah, right. I can give you a list of 10 psychiatrists right now who will certify that you have "bi-Polar" and are unable to work.
Food Stamps - $80.4 Billion in 2012. Here's a thought - maybe if we weren't spending $80.4 billion to give people food they could lower taxes and people could AFFORD the food. Or maybe spend $70 Billion on SNAP and $10.4 Billion on discovering the fraud.
Those are just two programs which are being widely abused. So, I have to ask why are the "poor" actually "poor"? Some work at it really really hard so they don't have to do really really hard work. I've had disability applicants tell me they spend their days finding ways to work the system. I wish they just spent their days finding work
I am not so sure that they may fuel poverty, but in many cases they seem tohave a tendancy to perpetuate it. The level of benefits at times exceeds what one may garner through a minimum wage position, thereby removing any incentive to drop offa government program and accept employment.
As a solution perhaps one should be forced to accept a low paying position and have the government subsidise the difference between pay and actual living costs, by those means the government is not picking up the whole bill and it places folks back into the work force.
By know means the ideal solution, but it is better than the way we seem to be going. The real problem isboth a lack of credible jobs and training for those that are available.My thought.
That doesn't make sense. In order to get the Pell, you have to be below a certain amount of income plus assets, and then you qualify for most schools for scholarships and work study, with the parents picking up the "parental portion". Have you ever seen the FASFA? I just had to fill out 2 of them, for my twins.
that's already happening.. it's called working at Walmart...
this is a real issue that needs to be dealt with and should be... but "robbing" the government happens on all levels it's just easier to wail on the poor as the bane of our evils...
and also wmo hating on democrats... they will always be theculpritof the woes in the US to the seeder it seems...
laws are mostly written by lobbyists and special interests... take forinstancefor-profitprisons. I believe in a couple stateregardlessif the prison is full capacity or not the contract is written the state gov. must pay it at 100% capacity... talk about stealing from the tax payer... yes we have issues with poor abusing the system.. we also have problems with corporation and wealthy stealing as well... it's all the way around....
Which is money not paid into the system...which isessentiallygiving them the money.
Please feel free to. I have 3 family members who are bi-polar and they all work.
I am sure that there is fraud going on with Food stamps, but your concept is flawed. Lowering taxes wouldn't affect people who really need the food stamps, since they fall below the tax rate and wouldn't be paying taxes in the first place.
I don't know how it works in other states, but in NYS you have to meet weekly with the benefits board after 3 months on the dole and you have to show that you have been out on interviews and if they offered you a job. So you can't be a lazy shit in NY.
that is just not true. many many people who fall below the tax rate do not work simply because it doesnt make sense financially to give up govt benefits in lieu of real work.
Ah, here we agree. In fact, I think it should be a crime like tax evasion.
If you are an adult your parents income is irrelevant. I am talking about adult students
Hey, Boudicea! Long time no see...
I'd like to point out also, that if we increase the minimum wage, we are going to be doing a grave disservice to a lot of people...they will receive a minor increase in their take home pay...and a drastic cut to benefits that are allowing them to survive on minimum wage as it is.
Hey, Merleliz, good to see you too.
A tax credit is a gift? Then I guess the 49% of American families who get it are just as much to blame as the corporations. And whatever STATES do for corporations is none of our business as FEDERAL taxpayers
Hm, I doubt if we're going to agree on much. What states do is NOT the nation's business. Perhaps you're forgetting the 10th Amendment to the Constitution.
The reason that there are more people on assistance is because there arent enough jobs, NOT because the assistance exists. The assistance has been there for decades, and the nature of it hasnt changed since Obama came into office. What has changed is the economy, because companies are outsourcing jobs to other countries. The companies who are doing the outsourcing are the ones fueling the poverty and the need for government benefits.
Yes, it actually is. The less you earn the more you get. Families who get their housing, food, medical care, transportation, phone, day care, higher education all paid for Rent going to work. They don't have to. If you got upwards of thirty thousand dollars a year or more NOT working would you give it up to take a thirty thousand a year job? Use some co Mon sense
Really? Prove it. Govt housing alone can be ten thousand or more. Food stamps? The family across the street gets 700 a month. How about those student grants? How about day care, do you think that is cheap? And let's not forget that ten or twelve thousand dollar a year "tax" refund
I seem to recall where some folks "earned" more than 42k. Not bad.
Yeah, well, thanks to Obamacare my health insurance over the past couple of years has damned near tripled!
Truth is offensive? That child was "born" into poverty because his or her mother elected to have him born into poverty!
So, yeah, decisions do have consequences, eh? I know it's tough to believe and I know many wish they didn't, but they do.
Note also, why do you think Obama and Imelt are buddies? Hmmmmm.
Sorry, but that is what we are being told. It's real, fact. Maybe the insurance companies are lying, but I don't think so. They are raising rates NOW to take into account the increased costs of the law as they phase in.
And some have ALREADY phased in.
The opposite is the case. The Wal-Marts of the country pay poverty wages forcing employees into food stamp eligibility. Thus the taxpayer subsidizes Wal-Mart, etc. to perpetuate the below poverty wage scale and life style.
Let them pay a living wage; that will make their employees more viable consumers, and where they consume, other jobs will be generated.
Perrie:
Please, disability rolls are at an all time high! Clearly people are asserting disability when they do not deserve it and the Obama admin is turning a blind eye.
And no, chances are that money wouldn't be paid in NO MATTER WHAT, which is what I find so hilarious about folks bitching about corporate "welfare." Fact is, they would just leave, incorporate elsewhere, move operations, etc. They have the ability to do that, and they do! As do the truly "wealthy" As usual, it's us, the middle class that gets hammered!
How is a tax credit a "gift?"
You don't get it do you. Merely because the government doesn't steal ALL the money doesn't mean that which they don't steal is a "gift!"
Most areas give tax breaks because they need the employment. You seem to forget what employment does for an area in tax receipts. Which is why states compete to lure companies to their states.
Fact is if Ohio didn't offer that, GE would not have relocated, or stayed.
You are merely arguing for all to be in poverty, why is that?
Yeah, dems are, in fact, the main culprit. Though pubs are gaining ground on them.
when you provide disincentives to produce, you are hurting this Country.
And that is what dems are doing. It is fascinating to watch the dems created entire plantations of voters.
Kind of like the matrix, all of those in little cocoons being fed, kept warm, by the government so long as they vote the right way.
Weird.
Hmmm, and why are companies outsourcing?
Yeah, like gun control measures prevent crime, so, in Chicago there is no gun violence any longer!
LOL.
Exactly, it is all about INCENTIVES! Government programs have, for decades, provide an incentive NOT to work. We all know the stories.
No one should be "given" anything. There should be some quid pro quo. Note, the idea of monetary payments for "necessities" is ludicrous given that such payments are, many times, not used for necessities at all.
Of course, we are not even talking about the "gray" market either.
Ah, sure A.Mac, let the government take over Wal Mart. Then watch costs sky rocket!
How's Obama doing with the price of gasoline? Talk about a regressive tax!
In the "government" benefits category and how folks (like moi) are just nasty, uncaring folks who really have no clue,
we have these little tidbits:
And this:
How can you NOT consider them social welfare? I never said all programs should be eliminated but damn, how unrealistic can you be? It is what it is. Oh and I forgot the 12,000 or so a yea for health insurance. Take your head out of the sand for a minute
Of course they are social welfare. They are transfer payments, aren't they?
Merely because you believe they are about the future of the Country, and even if you are RIGHT (which is debatable) they are still social welfare/transfer payments.
Straw purchases taking place outside of Chicago are most responsible for the preponderance of the hand guns which do the preponderance of the shootings there. No background checks = lots of straw purchases.
BUT THAT'S NO EXCUSE FOR THE MURDERING ASSHOLE CRIMINAL ELEMENT THERE; still, to not crack down on the straw purchases is almost criminal. And who stands in the way of that?
Crap, I forgot to add the monthly cash assistance. Well maybe that thirty thousand figure I guessed at was on the really low side
Who said anything about the government take over of Wal-Mart? I explained clearly who is subsidizing whom. Corporate welfare is the culprit but welfare going to the poor gets the blame.
Gasoline prices and the President?
You rally should watch more Fox News.
LOL. Obviously you have no grasp of reality. A rose by any other name is still a rose and a social welfare program for whatever purpose is still a social welfare program.
Talk about clueless, or possibly intentional obtuse!
Are you saying that, in fact, such programs are NOT social welfare? Are you saying they are not transfer payments?
The issue of their value is one thing, their character is beyond dispute, if one is honest. They ARE transfer/social welfare payments, period.
And what makes you think such welfare actually results in an educated population? If you wish to discuss that issue, fine. But that issue is NOT the issue of whether they are social welfare.
Your attempt to alter the issue is pure obfuscation.
So, I ask you, can YOU get any more clueless?
Some real information on this topic
"Indeed, federal welfare spending alone totals
more than $14,848 for every poor man,
woman, and child in this country. For a typical
poor family of three, that amounts to
more than $44,500. Combined with state and
local spending, government spends $20,610
for every poor person in America, or $61,830
per poor family of three."
"The American welfare state is much larger
than commonly believed. The federal government
alone currently funds and operates 126
different welfare or anti-poverty programs,
spending more than $668 billion per year.
State and local governments provide additional
funding for several of these programs
and also operate a number of programs on
their own, adding another $284 billion per
year. That means that, at all levels, government
is spending more than $952 billion per
year, just short of the trillion dollar mark."
And PLEASE don't blah blah blah about the source. You might not like the Cato Institute, but their information is indisputable, as are their conclusions