Maryland proposal to claim copyright on students' work prompts backlash, legal review
Just another "logical" extension of the nanny state, eh?
According to a draft of the proposal obtained by FoxNews.com, "Works created by employees and/or students specifically for use by the Prince George's County Public School or a specific school or department within PGCPS, are properties of the Board of Education even if created on the employee's or student's time and with use of their materials."
So, if I was a teacher in Prince Georges public schools, they could confiscate my hand carved pipes if I created them to teach? My wood working?
Way to go government! Isn't this the very definition of communism? LOL, all belongs to the government, to the "collective."
I get such a kick out of folks who believe that there is no such thing as communism or communists any longer, especially in this Country. The word is just so 'passe," eh. Well, what is the old saying, "a rose by any other name...."
They just refuse to recognize what is before their eyes.
Tags
Who is online
131 visitors

This isn't aboutcommunismas it is about money. Teacher generated material makes big money. And I am sure that the stars of the student body does, too. The government wants that money, and as being a part of the system, they feel that they have the right to that money. I happen to feel otherwise, but this is no different from corporations.
My uncle worked as a design engineer for GE his entire career. In order to work for GE you have to sign an a agreement that anything you develop, even if it was on your free time, was the property of GE. How is that different? BTW, many of my uncles neat electronic toys that he made on his free time, GE made big money off of. They were petty enough to even take his computerized toy train command center and then sell it toLionel.
Of course it's about "communism" It's about the state asserting that all that is created by the teacher/student is the government's! Of course the government "wants that money." What the heck do you think communism is all about!
And those sorts of agreements are different Perrie as it is not government! Can you not tell the difference between government and private enterprise.
Note, I deal in employment agreements all the time and I don't think that the normal agreement is as you state. For example, such is tied to the business of the company. Here is an example:
So, if you work for GE and you make a wonderful manufacturing breakthrough in how to create pocketbooks, guess what, it's not GE's!
Note also, government employees ain't being paid for their intellectual property, they are being paid to teach! It is completely different when an employee is being PAID to invent! Or in your Uncle's case, to "design."
You can't see the enormous difference?
Actually, I can't. Not since SCOTUS ruled that corporations are individuals, thus giving them more power than the people. And who do you think will also benefit from a sweetheart deal with the government... the publishers, amazon in particular.
Perrie:
Let's take this one step at a time. Your employer can prevent you from exercising free speech, upon penalty of losing one's job.
The government, on the other hand, CANNOT! That would be a violation of the First Amendment. We getting there yet?
And if you work for the armed forces? Isn't that the government preventing you to free speech? How about the CIA or FBI? How is that different from working in a public school. Are they not the state's government agencies? The answer is yes they are.
Sure, there are, of course, limits to free speech, national security being one of them.
What about the rights of the student PErrie? How about their creations? The government is seeking to own them as well.
I take it you have no issue with that as well. AFter all, private corps take a child's work product, oh wait, no they don't!
Actually, now we come to the crux of it. No, they have right to take the students work. That is where the case lies and not with the teachers.
And for the record, I do have a problem with that. In this case, the schools and the government is there to serve them and not the other way around.
See for me when I look at government, the powers that be, will mix alegitimatelaw with one that is over the top. Here is a prime case of it. Another are bills that are passed with a good core and a lot of pork. I like to look at what is right in a law and what isn't. We just found it here.
Merci beaucoup!
Another example? The Patriot Act!
By the way, the groups seem to be rocking! I haven't paid attention to them but sure as hell will start to check them with a lot more frequency!
Well, teachers are compensated as well. HOWEVER (listening Perrie?), teachers do not have to sign employment agreements.
Well, this has happened for years and years and years.
As a student, I helped to write part of an academic paper on the geology of the Western KY Pkwy. My professor published it, and none of us that worked on it got any acknowledgement. At all. My name even listed as a contributor to a published paper would have made a big difference to me, starting out...
The stuff that I produce for work is copyrighted by work. However, I'm adding to it, and rewriting it for my own webpage. It will not be anything like the stuff I write for them.
"Works created by employees and/or students specifically for use by the Prince George's County Public School or a specific school or department within PGCPS,are properties of the Board of Education"
No, it is not the definition of communism, or even socialism. You make the great leap of faith, trusting that just because you say it, your readers will believe it. You fall short of your mark. It makes no difference if it pertains to a student, a teacher, a scientist or an inventor: In the normal course of business, anything which you create while under the employ of a company is the companies property if it has any resemblance to something that the company might be able to make money from.
I find humorous that what one finds commonplace in a capitalist business is called communist when attempted by a school board. I thought that they were supposed to behave more like a business to turn out principled little workers for the great capitalist machine. Best to get them used to the fact while they are young so they won't be causing any trouble, organizing against their own best interests and all.
And:
You forgot what comes after that clause. All you did was define a work product, you did not get around to the part that says what they agree to do with said product
Intellectual Property Rights. The Employee acknowledges and agrees that...
Here is the employee agreeing to something^^^^
...all inventions, technology, processes, innovations, ideas, improvements, developments, methods, designs, analyses, trademarks, service marks, and other indicia of origin, writings, audiovisual works, concepts, drawings, reports and all similar, related, or derivative information or works (whether or not patentable or subject to copyright), including but not limited to all patents, copyrights, copyright registrations, trademarks, and trademark registrations in and to any of the foregoing, along with the right to practice, employ, exploit, use, develop, reproduce, copy, distribute copies, publish, license, or create works derivative of any of the foregoing, and the right to choose not to do or permit any of the aforementioned actions,which relate to the Company's or the Company's Affiliates actual or anticipated business, research and development or existing or future products or services and which are conceived, developed or made by the Employee while employed by the Company and its Affiliates or any of their predecessors (collectively, the "Work Product")
This is all definition of what the employee is agreeing to do or not do with ^^^^^^
But you never told what the employee is agreeing to do or not do: Cede the rights to do all of these actions? Retain these rights? Can't tell from what you posted. Gosh, all that verbiage and still an incomplete sentence.
Is it wrong? I think it is wrong. Does it happen? Yes, everyday in the business world.
Note also, government employees ain't being paid for their intellectual property, they are being paid to teach!
Face palm....
Do you mean they are not under contract?
Note, students are REQUIRED to attend school. Note, students are REQUIRED to conduct projects.
I am afraid you are wrong. It is clearly the trend toward communism. Public schools are not, in connection with students, private employers.
Your assumption that it is the same shows how pervasive such leftist thinking is in this Country.
That's right. Generally they do NOT sign an employment agreement.
Other questions?
This happened at my university as well, and the professor was fired for theft.
A group of marketing students came up with a great idea in connection with a project. Prof then took the idea and sold it.
Scum.
The real issue, however, is the students.
Note, that's just a piece of shit prof you have there, that's it.
Students are not required to attend that specific school/district. They can legally attend other schools or be home-schooled.
Public schools pay their employees, just as a business does. Otherwise they would be known as volunteers. And it is precisely their intellect and use of the same that makes them a teacher. You cannot be much closer to intellectual property than that.
Note, also, that I said that I was against the usurpation of these rights by the school board.
A company board and a school board fulfill largely the same functions. I consider the distinction of public employees vs. private employees to be spurious and superficial.
Your assumption that it is the same shows how pervasive such leftist thinking is in this Country.
Thank you very much!
Yeah, and the sad part was that of all 3 of them in the geology dept., he was the best...
That says something, doesn't it?
He was never fired, but I felt cheated. it would have helped my career when I started out.
In college I had the greatest teachers and mentors. The Geophysics dept had multiple papers presented each year at the Regional GSA, and as a senior I had the opportunity of researching, creating and presenting a Poster session at the combined NE, SE GSA meeting. After the presentation, it was displayed in the Geology Building for several years. All students in the geology program were encouraged to strive for these presentations, and at Potsdam we had several presentations and/or papers given by students each year, the faculty and staff were there to help and advise and coauthor. Never were the students shut out.
That is what school is for. I feel horribly for you, Dowser.
Well, it was aggravating, to be sure. But, I survived. I am the only one of my class still practicing. Ha! Doing well is the best revenge!
This same professor was my adviser. He told me that I would never make it as a geologist, and to not even try. Piffle.
What an unmitigated ass.
His comment was a byproduct of the 'times'-- 1977. Most geologists felt that women had no place in the field. It was the prevailing attitude.
I survived. It was hard, but I'm still doing what I love!