The Second Amendment is not intended to protect our right to hunt ducks.
Someone left the following comments on an article I wrote about gun regulation
All of the gun control folks just do not see the second amendment as being on a par, or more important, than the other amendments.
I always find it fascinating that those who scream that abortion is a Constitutional right (with which I pretty much agree, by the way), denounce the right to bear arms.
I replied
I am one of those "gun control folks" of which you speak... but I do not see the Second Amendment as less important than other amendments. Your assertion implies there can be no "gun control" without also diminishing the standing of the Second Amendment. I don't share that view.
I am also someone who supports legal and safe abortions (I would not characterize myself as someone who screams about Constitutional rights). I have never "denounced the right to bear arms", and in fact I support that right. Again... you erroneously equate any sort of gun regulation with denunciation of the right to bear arms.
As with all the controversial issues of our time, it is when we boil things down to their bones that we see the real points of contention. I think it would be very nice if we would all start speaking clearly and forthrightly about our ideas... instead of wrapping our ideas in language we hope will make them more palatable to people who might not otherwise find them appealing. In the case of guns, it is the purpose for bearing arms that is the crux of the issue. I heard a "no gun regulation" proponent express the pivotal issue very succinctly... he said, "The Second Amendment is not intended to protect our right to hunt ducks." Anti-regulation advocates speak of their need to defend themselves and their families from thieves etc. A reasonable purpose I would say... although I am not sure high capacity semiautomatic weapons are needed for such a purpose. Anti-regulation advocates also speak of needing those weapons to hold a potentially tyrannical government at bay or even to rise in revolt against such a government. I'm pretty sure those are the primary purposes for which the Second Amendment was created.
Now we get to the real crux of this issue... Our country is ideologically divided... perhaps more severely so than it has ever been ( the 1860s may have been worse ). There may not be anyone in our country who is completely satisfied with our government, but the vast majority does not feel it is in imminent threat of tyrannical oppression by the government. Still, there are many people who are so dissatisfied with our government that the armed revolt "option" feels like the last bastion for their ideology. Some of those people probably feel the need to exercise that option may well be imminently necessary. On the other hand, people like myself (and there are many) feel that as great as our ideological difference may be, armed warfare is a patently absurd way to resolve those differences.
So... perhaps many people who fervently guard their "right to bear arms" by refusing to accept any sort of gun regulation are actually saying, "I find many of the things I am being forced to accept so repugnant that armed revolt is the only option left to me." Those of us with a different ideology find that reaction incredible... and we often say so... denigrating those who are different from us... and that denigration does not help us resolve our differences. Denigrating those who are different and pretty much everyone does it only widens our ideological chasm. I have been beating the compromise drum on many issues for years. I truly believe compromise is the only way to heal the gash in our nations heart. Unfortunately, there is a faction in our country that proactively rejects compromise. What remedy do those people seek??? The Second Amendment???
I want to make a point that goes to the issue of revolt against a tyrannical government. Lets take "socialism" as an example. There are many people in this country who want some form of socialism ( me included ). Some know this very consciously, others want this but don't realize what they want could be labeled as socialism. There are still others who view any form of socialism as utterly unacceptable. If people who oppose socialism rose in revolt against socialist policies favored by a majority, they would not be protecting themselves against a tyrannically oppressive government so much as waging civil war on their fellow citizens.
Okay I agree The Second Amendment is not intended to protect our right to hunt ducks. I wonder How many Second Amendment advocates will say that amendment grants us the right to wage civil war???

I truly believe compromise is the only way to heal the gash in our nations heart.
I do not necessarily ascribe to your underlying premise Mal. Although we hear about the incredible divide day in, day out, I am not altogether certain that we are anymore divided today than in years past.
Terry,
Perhaps so... Whether we are more divided or not is not the most pertinent point raised in this article. The point made at the end of the article regarding the difference between revolting against a tyrannical government and waging civil war against fellow citizens is the "underlying premise" of the article. I think you are bright enough to see that. Have you nothing to say about that???
@Mal:
I guess my point is why do you assume any divide needs to be healed? Conflict provides for advancement. So far we have not seen a revolt against fellow citizens for their beliefs. Nor have we seen one against a "tyrannical" government, though it may well happen if the government keeps on the way it is keeping on.
What I think is that all believe "their" time is the worst, etc., etc., when it is not. It may be different, but not worse. And the damn site is so slow and glitchy, it's not really worth posting.
Will try back later Mal.
,
Oh... So I guess we have been under tyrannical oppression since the time The New Deal was implemented... Hmmm... I thought tyranny would be worse than it actually turns out to be...
Does the Constitution prohibit Socialism??? I thought the Constitution gave us the opportunity to establish laws by majority consensus. Of course all our laws must adhere to the provisions that are explicitly set forth in the Constitution... but I am not aware that it prohibits any sort of economic policy. Let's not forget that one of the big objections inspiring the revolutionary war was...
"No taxation without representation" NOT "No taxation... PERIOD"
Good point Mal. No, the Constitution does not prohibit socialism as an economic scheme. Of course, the Constitution also does not allow for judicial interpretation/review of the Constitution either.
But I understand your point. Here's the rub, and what I think Bruce means, the means to attain socialism results in a trampling of individual rights guaranteed by the Bill of Rights.
We see this in the challenges to ObamaCare and other socialist policies.
As I tried to say Terry... Delving into whether or not "our time is the worst" is a bit of a straw man. If you want to say that it is more or less the same or different or whatever... fine, whatever you say.
I am trying to address the "right to bear arms for the purpose of opposing a tyrannical government" claim that many Second Amendment advocates make. I assert that those Second Amendment proponents look at policies implemented with the blessing of a citizen majority and then mis-characterize those policies as government tyranny. Whether or not those disgruntled citizens take any sort of action with the "arms they are bearing" is really beside the point. They use their mis-characterization to justify their need to have those arms, they say they are willing to use those arms for a purpose they believe is justified but is in fact false, and their actions, if undertaken, would be very consequential... so brushing that possibility aside because it hasn't happened yet... well, that seems like a good way to avoid having a meaningful discussion.
A while back I listened to an interview of Ayn Rand by Mike Wallace in which she asserted that majority rule is fundamentally unfair. I have always felt that some consideration should be given to the needs and wishes of minorities in any society, but I don't think it is unreasonable or unfair to bias policies toward the wishes of the majority. When the minority responds to the results of majority rule by saying they will oppose it as tyrannical government oppression... that's a problem.
I think this business of changing blog handles on a whim sucks... I suppose it is everyone's right to do that... but I think it's confusing... Thanks for hanging on to wmolaw, Terry!
What individual rights does Obamacare trample???
Well, first amendment, for example. I would also argue 4th amendment rights given his position on allowing unmanned drones over US airspace. The list goes on.
Aren't they individual rights?
Ayn was right, majority rule IS unfair. Hence, the "representative" in "representative democracy."
This is where we differ, it would seem. I would pay MORE attention to the the rights of the minorities than I would to the rights of the majority.
The majority does not need assistance in keeping or exercising their rights, the minority do.
What did Popeye say, "I yam who I yam and that's all that I yam!"
Same to you. I too don't like the handle changing, i'm too easily confused!
Mal! Glad to see you here, even though on this particular issue we are antithetical in point of view.
The Second is to protect us from Evile Ducks and, to put aforementioned ducks on the menu.
I don't think the push to further restrict liberty is making use of serious critical thinking. I don't even think it is the right discussion to be having when it comes to putting a damp on violence in our country. It is the shallow, naive and easy non solution to a problem that lies far deeper within our culture than The Bill of Rights. It is a Scoobie Doo band aide on a sucking chest wound and says more about the current war on the poor than delivering a viable answer to a serious problem.
Best to you and yours and again, glad to see you around!
"In religion and politics people's beliefs and convictions are in almost every case gotten at second-hand, and without examination, from authorities who have not themselves examined the questions at issue but have taken them at second-hand from other non-examiners, whose opinions about them were not worth a brass farthing." Mark Twain
First amendment... on Obamacare??? What... Are you talking about the contraception thing??? Where I come down on that is, if you are a religious institution getting the benefits of a non-profit religious institution and adhering to the responsibilities that go with such an institution, like not promoting a political agenda, then I think it is fine to get an out from such things on religious grounds. That said, it is very difficult for me to understand ANY argument against contraception (religious or otherwise, but then are many religious ideas that I have difficulty understanding). If ordinary for-profit business get to play the religion card, then anybody can get out of just about anything... That is totally dysfunctional. In that case we might as well not have any government.
I am not too keen on the drones myself... but as far as I know that doesn't have anything to do with Obamacare... I would never say that President Obama is everything I want...He is just the closest thing I could get in recent elections to what I DO want (Bernie Sanders is a bit closer to my ideal). But... I would certainly never describe President Obama as a tyrant. Furthermore, there may well be justifying factors for the drones that need to be kept secret for the safety of the country.
I find it hilarious that folks who support Obama and are anywhere near honest, will say "I am not too keen" or "I have concerns." Instead of, the guy is a damned murderer, purposefully assassinating individuals and killing innocents in the process,
which you would have said if it was a pub.
As to the first amendment issue, just giving you an example. Because you don't agree with it, doesn't mean it isn't a Constitutional abrogation. Courts have agreed it is, others haven't. We shall see how it shakes out. My only point was that Obama's actions affect/impinge/restrict Constitutional rights in every step.
Socialism does that Mal. ANY form of political enterprise which foundation is government control does that. Whether it be socialism, fasism, or communism.
Does anyone know what the definition of "tyranny" really is? This is from Websters Online Dictionary:
Interesting post. Having been born in the early '50's, I cannot remember a time when we discussed the tryannical actions of the government over dinner, or even out for drinks, dinner, as I grew older.
And we talked politics all the time, every night.
As they say, the greater the power, the more the corruption. And I believe that is why we are seeing so many disaffected people. The government has too much power, it's just that simple. Especially the federal government.
Right to bear arms yes right to bear arms of any type no. When the second ammendment was written there was no standing Army or National Guard or City and State Police with special units to handle hostage situations.So the implementation at least The well Regulated Militia would insinuate state or federal oversight. You cannot regulate a miitia without the Government Invovement be it Federal or State.
Who regulates theseMilitia these small groups of marauders wanna be who hurtle up and down back roadsin their jeeps or jacked up pickup trucks drinking beer are racing to know where. Are these Militia Regulated no not at all. The Majority of these new semi automatic gun owners belong to no millitia they are owners with little or no training. Gun safety training is not required to own a semi automatic Weaponor 30 shot magazines or even larger, ammunition you can buy a thousand rounds at a time or more. What do we plan on taking over the City police, State Capitols, Washington D.C.. Stamp out unwanted Religions, scare people away from the voting booths. Are we gonna back up the Army, Marines, Navy andAir Force. Just what are these unregulated Militia and Home owners with Semi automatic weapons going to do. Walk the streets in their neighborhood Wait in school parking lots weapons at the loaded and ready state.
The more weapons in just any ones hands those who take tranquilizers those who are alcoholics those with mental instability but never have been institutionalized these are very likely to be your gun owners they are insecure scared of sounds in their house, shadows passing buy their windows, kids ringing their door bells are they part of a gang. All these kinds of people are out there and armed and dangerious. Ready to kill remember when you ring a door bell or someone rings yours. Remember those people who peek out of a window by sliding the corner of the curtain aside when you knock on their door. They may well be armed Glenn Beck and his ilk told them to be scared of the Government.
<sigh> Look, this has been dealt with. Okay, it does not mean what you think it means!
Wrong, it means efficient. Think clocks!
Why are people so scared of law abiding citizens having weapons? Clearly "gun control" does not stop gun violence, so just what is it that you folks are after?
You seem to forget that it is a CONSTITUTIONAL right!f Why is it that folks forget that. Tell you what, when you are no longer allowed to criticize the government, then let's talk about what you wish to have happen to the second amendment.
The Affordable care Act is to insure everyone has insurance like other first world countries. I realize we are quickly trying to drive the economy down by tax deferments for companies to ship jobs overseas. Is that a Socialost act no, how about a terrorist act. The rich put their money in safe tax havens where they don't pay taxes on it. Thats an Anti American Act maybe that is a Communist actits not an American Act.
Social programs do in and of them selves make them Socialist. Affordable care act is just what the words say no more no less. A F F O R D A B L E C A R E !
One of the duties of our democratically elected, representative form of government is to protect our citizens from the bad aspects of capitalism while preserving the good. Unfortunately, the corporations who own many of our elected officials are getting their way all too often, and it is the everyday citizens that are paying the price.
All due respect, but that is quite the hysterical rant. I have a Sport Utility Rifle myself. I've shot competitively with it in the past and mainly shoot paper for accuracy these days. Quite Zen like in its appeal, if you ask me. It has been a handy varmint rifle to have on the ranch as well. Lumping all folks involved in the shooting sports in the same group as a tiny minority of malcontents is disingenuous at best.
As far as those Militia folks go, well, for the most part, these are not scary or insane humans. I tend to gravitate to the boonies and live in spots where this sort of thing is not ubiquitous, but not uncommon either. I have met a number from coast to coast and they are pretty benign. They seem to believe that they are filling some sort of patriotic need and are generally pretty affable. I had a group here in NC ask me to come out and "train" with them. I politely declined as I don't generally care for groups but it was somewhat illuminating. These guys, and gals, knew my political perspective was quite antithetical to theirs yet they were amenable to having me mingle. Of course, it might have been like that Ice T movie where he was used as prey for rich white hunters.....
Anyhow, the only group of those folks that caused me trepidation were the Aryan Whatevers up around Idaho way. Those are sad, tragic and, quite possibly, dangerous kids. Other than that they have all been the same goobers you work with in rural volunteer fire operations.
I just don't think there is cause for abject fear and trembling. The vast majority of firearm aficionados are just regular citizens. Not people to fear.
best atcha
"Tolerate my hobbies, and I'll tolerate yours."
Let's concentrate on that statement for a minute. Does anyone argue that the purpose of the Second Amendment was NOT to make sure every family could hunt ducks, but to ensure that never again would the Colonist ever be placed under the heel of a tyrranical government? Even if it were of their own making? Now since this is a bit of a delicate debate, weshould take the time to do this in logical progression. This is point 1.
Point 2 ould be do you really think that the Colonist had any intention of having a standing army that was better equipped than they themselves were? Let's keep in mind that the Second Amendment states "arms" without ANY limitations. This was not an oversite by any means. There were indeed horrible weapons at that time which would do justice to our comparing a single shot musket of then, to a full-auto machine gun of today. There were weapons that were filled with grapeshot and cannon balls that were fragmentary and yet these were not "banned" from ownership. Even though these weapons of "mass-murder" were known, and often banned from public display, there were NO restrictions placed upon their ownership.
Point 3 is that only a fool would willingly handicap himself in a battle of life-and-death. This is why the term "Arms" was used instead of "firearm", or "cannon", or "pistol" when the Amendment was added. These people were surrounded by "primitives" using bows and arrows, hand axes, and such and were well aware of the tremendous strides thatthey had taken in rising above these primitive "arms" culminating in giving themselves dominion over the indigenous population of their new land. Again, they knew that just as the bow had given way to the flintlock, so to would the flintlock give way to something better. They did not limit themselves to simple rifles and arms of the times, they gave themselves the Right to bear ANY arm needed to keep that possibillity of a tyrranical government from rearing its ugly head.
Point 4 would be that the only limitation implied upon the Right to Bear Arms is that of what the individual can afford to purchase. Nowhere does this Amendment state that every individual has the Right to be provided by the government with whatever arm they choose to bear. IMHO, if you can afford to buy it, become "well-regulated" in its use (meaning well trained in its use, care, and operation) then by God you have the Right to own it if you can afford it! This is indicated simply by the very important closing of that Amendment where it says that the Right to bear Arms, SHALL NOT BE INFRINGED! That is a pretty strong limitation placed upon the Federal Government.
Point 5 would be that until the Marshall Court put out the SCOTUS decision that the Federal Government was the final word in all matters, the States were free to place their own limits on what was considered acceptable terms under which a person could excercise their Rights in public. It was after this that we saw limitations placed upon our Constitutional Rights by the Federal Government and IMHO, was the major cause of the Civil War. When you seek to strip people of their freedoms they were promised, you can expect some serious blowback. As I mentioned in a previous post, just about every one of us can point at something or other in the last 50 years that we felt was an over-reach by the Feds. How much longer will the people continue to allow this to happen?
My guess is until they have nothing left to lose and according to the statistics, nearly a quarter of Americans are either there already financially, or nearing it quickly! Once they have become homeless, jobless, and alone, they have nothing left but a miserable life to look forward to. Many would rather die than live that way.
Christopher Dorner would probably agree...
Excellent comment FlyNavy!
Terry,
If I thought of him as a "damned murderer" I would have described him that way. Thanks for your gracious acknowledgment of my thoughts.
Unregulated capitalism has unequivocally proven it will not self-regulate, and worse yet it rejoices in its ability to exploit and abuse.
Here is a very simple question... I hope you will provide a simple straightforward answer Terry...
You want unfettered capitalism, I want democratic socialism. Is there a place that is more or less half way between those things where you and I could happily coexist??? For my part of that answer I say, "Yes... I would be happy to accept half of each."
Yeah, sure it is. My health care premiums (and those of the other 8 folks in my firm) have increased over 300% in the last two years.
You call that affordable? Right.
What you mean to say is "affordable" for those who refuse to pay for their health insurance and so others have to pony up for them. Were there inequities, sure. Guess what, there still are. Guess what, there will always be.
The only time and place we are all "equal" is when we shuffle off this mortal coil.
I do find it fascinating though to watch those who lauded this legislation start to scream like stuck pigs when its effect begins to slam them!
Just how big a gun or how many shots persecond is enough. How about land mines they are relatively simple to make. It does not say efficient anywhere I can find how about a reference. Regulated - efficient?????? Not according to Webster.
Webster Regulate To direct or control in agreement with rules or Laws.
Webster Regulation A principle, rule, or law for controlling behavior. A governmental order with the force of law.
In many cities now police are out gunned according to reports. I know it has happened here in Ohio where the crooks had automatic weapons and bullet proof vests and the cops did not. Not a pretty sight. Crazy kid in Theater semi Automatic weapon bullet proof vest. I would guess that NRA and some gun owners see this as a wave of the future. Also as you say to take on the military and police if they feel the need. One group that felt the need was it in Michigan they were trying to ambush police at a funeral. I don't understand the need for semi automatic and automatic weapons unless a rebelion is in the back of your mind. I own a shotgun. Shoot targets on ocassion. Bow hunt.
Well, as stated, the second amendment is not about shooting ducks.
I was going to write an article about this issue, but decided not to. But a question might be in order:
Is there any set of circumstances which would cause you to join a potentially violent revolution against our government?
Yeah I've heard that argument put forth before and it makes so much sense that those afraid of a tyrranical government would want that government to regulate their ownership of arms??? Or mayge, just maybe of course, they were using THIS definition of "regulate" when they wrote that phrase (from some guy by the name of Alexander Hamilton ) :
As you can see, nowhere doeshe mention laws regulating what arms may be possessed, but rather that in order to be "well-regulated" the militia must train together at least once or twice a year.
Are you denying he was? What would you call a racist brutal police force if not oppressive? I do not condone his actions, but I can identify with how he must have felt when the same people charged with protecting the citizens from the criminal element were in some cases worse than the criminals themselves. Attempting to expose them had cost him his career in the military, his career as a police officer, and his family. Do you deny his status as a "victim" of injustice because of his subsequent reactions to it?
Yes....
If in the 2012 elections there had been multiple occurrences of vote tabulation error at the hands of Diebold and other voting machine programming that would have sent the election decision to the SCOTUS again. Especially if it had taken place in either Florida or Ohio, and if the SCOTUS ordered anything other than another vote to be held given a 5-4 decision.
Our vote is the only thing that holds the plutocracy embraced by the GOP at bay.
Yeah, I have been proselytizing the re-framing of this debate from the get go. In my opinion the 2nd shouldn't even be in the game when we are trying to find an answer to violence in this country.
Americans aren't too interested in answers that take hard work, time and dollars. Critical thinking does not seem to be a common trait expressed within this debate as it now stands.
Go figure.
True, very, very true. Typical of the approaches to almost all issues that need addressing in today's world.
There was a wonderful article written by a very old Austrian woman about how her country was taken over by the Nazis.
She is really something. Of course, 99% of the people who believe in the lefty way of life, that government is always working FOR the citizens as a whole, do not and will never believe her.
"I find many of the things I am being forced to accept so repugnant that armed revolt is the only option left to me"
That is brilliant and it is true. That is exactly how I feel. And you wonder will I, as a Second Amendment advocate say that it grants us the right to wage civil war? Absolutely it does. You suggest that if the "minority" who reject socialism rise up against the "majority" they wouldn't be protecting themselves against a tyrannical government, but rather from their fellow citizens. What you missed is the fact that the form of government we have - A Republic - is not intended to allow the majority to make "the rules" but instead is specifically intended to protect the rights of the minority. So, in essence, if "the majority" decide that they are going to ALLOW our government to ignore the Constitution then they are, in effect, fair game for revolt.
Because politicians lie.
Because all recognize there must be a government to avoid anarchy, but they understand that there is a fine line between a government and a tyranny.
That governments and those involved/elected will ALWAYS seek to secure more power and wealth unto themselves. If left unchecked, they will become tyrants.
There are more alternatives than an omnipresent, nanny, cradle to grave government, or anarchy.
Hi Neetu,
My question is this... If what you want and what I want are very different things... How do you propose for us to live together peacefully in this country???
The only solution I can think of is compromise...
The following is copied from a comment I left in another article:
I feel compelled to quote something I said in one of my articles nearly 4 years ago (which I have quoted dozens, perhaps hundreds of times)...
Perhaps the central point of every controversial article I have ever written can be described as a PLEA for compromise and cooperation. Whether it is on the issue of guns and whether or not they should be regulated, or how we are taxed, how much we are taxed, and what those tax dollars are spent on, or climate change, or environmental and resource abuses, we are, as Terry says in the comment above this, "polarized." I gotta tell ya... It looks to me like there are many of people in this county who want it to be polarized. I call that... "civil war."
Hero? Not hardly. I've publicly denounced his reaction time and again as you well know. I am also basing my opinion of LAPD on multiple accounts posted on news sites and social media sites such as YouTube, and all it takes is a simple phrase entered into a search bar: LAPD brutality. Speaking of ducks; if it walks, talks, and acts like a duck...