A Mysterious Patch Of Light Shows Up In The North Dakota Dark
This is odd. Take a look at this map of America at night. As you'd expect, the cities are ablaze, the Great Lakes and the oceans dark, but if you look at the center, where the eastern lights give way to the empty western plains, there's a mysterious clump of light there that makes me wonder.
What we have here is an immense and startlingly new oil and gas field nighttime evidence of an oil boom created by a technology called fracking. Those lights are rigs, hundreds of them, lit at night, or fiery flares of natural gas. One hundred fifty oil companies, big ones, little ones, wildcatters, have flooded this region, drilling up to eight new wells every day on what is called the Bakken formation. Altogether, they are now producing 660,000 barrels a day, double the output two years ago, so that in no time at all, North Dakota is now the second largest oil producing state in America. Only Texas produces more, and those lights are a sign that this region is now on fire ... to a disturbing degree literally.
This oil rush is so sudden, so enormous, North Dakota now has the lowest unemployment rate in the country. More than 41,000 workers got jobs there between 2008 and 2012. Only seven years ago, the U.S. was importing 60 percent of its oil. Now imports are down to 42 percent. The Bakken fields are helping to improve energy security.
On the other hand, says Peter Lehner , blogger for the Natural Resources Defense Council, every day drillers in North Dakota "burn off enough gas to heat half a million homes." North Dakota law says that flares are subject to taxes and royalties after one year, even if the gas isn't being sold, but critics suspect that the state keeps granting exceptions and state regulators seem less than energetic when farmers call to complain about poisons in the air and water. Many farmers in North Dakota can't prevent drillers from drilling even if they'd like to. Decades ago, energy companies bought "mineral rights" to the land below those farms so the companies can move in, create drilling pads where they please, move in trucks and workers, without the farmers' consent. In some places, North Dakota feels like Texas in the early 20th century, when cattlemen fought the oil men. This time its corn folks versus oil folks. Tempers are rising. Gas is burning. Drillers are drilling.
And North Dakota, on some nights, is almost as bright as the Aurora Borealis.

Related article... Oodles of Single Men May Not Be as Awesome as You'd Think .
There are big problems out west. I went to school for four years in Minot (met my beautiful bride there) and still have many friends who live in western North Dakota. Folks who have lived in these small towns for generations can't afford apartments that were $300 to $500, and that now go for over $3,000. Many of the new arrivals are unfamiliar with the conservative values and practices of the area. Crime has gone up and infrastructure is wildly under-developed for such a population.
I reallly hate to hear this. I know that ND is pretty desolate, but it still hosts lots of wildlife and people. It's a real shame that they are going to pollute so much!
Fracking is awful for the environment. Period. It may be 'good' in other ways, but it is AWFUL for the environment. And we really don't know what it is we're doing. In all honesty, oil companies haven't a clue what the results will be in the long run.
As a groundwater professional, whose life's work has been to protect groundwater and keep it fit for human consumption, I strongly oppose fracking!
Well ... I am hardly an expert on this subject but from what I understand , the problem isn't fracking itself . It is unscrupulous operators not allowing casement cement to dry completely .
Directional drilling not matching the dip and strike of the formation. Use of highly toxic chemicals and unbelievably high pressures. Toxic waste products dumped on the ground and in the air. Use of millions of gallons of water that must be disposed of properly and isn't. Blowouts. Contaminants crossing into non-contaminated formations via lineaments, fractures, faults, and variations in the formation that are unknown prior to drilling. Poor practices in both drilling and cementing techniques. Lack of sealant in the drilling and cementing fluids. Casing poorly seated. Effects of drilling noted several miles away. Contaminants escaping via old wells that no one ever closed.
Word games with "the well is 15,000' deep-- it's so deep it can't affect the ground water." No, folks, it's 1000' - 1500' deep and 13,500' to 14,000' long. In all directions. Big difference.
Lineament affects have been noted to 4000'. Personal experience there. The oil industry ignores lineaments. Yet, I've used them for 30 years to site wells.
And that is just the tip of the iceberg.
That's what I was referring to when I mentioned unscrupulous operators . That is not an inevitable part of fracking.
I've cleaned up the messes that oil companies have made for 30 years. I'd say not only inevitable, but guaranteed. They were made exempt from the Clean Water Act in the Energy Act of 199?. They don't have to follow ANY of the regulations that other people do, and if it costs them money, they won't.
I can't be objective about this. My job is to protect the groundwater. My professional life has been devoted to protecting drinking water supplies. I could tell you tales about oil company's standard practices that would make your hair curl... No joke!
I am not trying to be unreasonable, but everyone watches the propaganda on TV and believes it. The government looks at the money to be made, the brief boost to the economy and looks the other way at the environmental damage. I've SEEN the environmental damage, dear friend. First hand. Close up. We 'unofficially' tested several of the water wells near a site, too.
The crap they do is astounding. No wastewater treatment facility is capable of handling their hazardous wastes, and often it is dumped on the ground, or dribbled along dirt roads... The stuff they use on a regular basis is carcinogenic, teratogenic, and just plain poisonous. It is used in levels that are unsafe, and the dosages are deadly.I promise you that I'm not kidding.
I'm not being hysterical. They don't know what they are doing-- because they won't study the formations for the information they need. They will not complete lineament studies, because they don't want to know. There are many faults and things underground that do not appear at the surface, and some of the areas in my state where they are fracking is very complex faulting associated with the Rough Creek Fault. Nobody knows where all the faults are.
I promise I am telling you the truth as I know it.
From what I've read fracking has been done safely for decades . It appears that the problems with it have cropped up recently and it seems to be about operators who are in too much of a hurry ...
Fracking done prior to the mid 1990s only dealt with the introduction of TNT down the hole. Boom! and they were done. The explosion took place below the casing, (although sometimes, it blew the casing out of the hole, where it was set with concrete), and the explosion was contained to a very small area.
The problems of late are caused by the complex techiques of directional drilling and the introduction of toxic materials under high pressure to eat out the rock formations, opening up the pore spaces within theformations to allow the oil/gas to be extracted. Big difference, I promise you! The procedure covers a very wide area, and the pressure forces the liquid, propant, (what props the formations open), out to distances of 1-2 miles from the actual wellhead.
Do you see what I mean? The old fracking techniques didn't often work in lineaments, where the rock is already broken. In fact, the old TNT fracking often shut down the lineaments, as the explosion caused the formation to settle, shutting off the supply. But the injection of propants, (high silica sands and even plastic), under the extremely high pressures, props all that up, in a very permeable, highly porous way.
Fracking has been done for years and years, with few affects, except where the well casings leaked, pushing brine waters up toward the surface. There were few really toxic chemicals, and the pressures were no more than the normal drilling practices.
This new technique is the problem. Here is a picture that I drew, (yeah, I'm no artist), for a talk I gave to the water treatment operators and engineers last year. It may help to explain what I'm trying to say. Hope it helps to illustrate the problems. A PWS is a Public Water Supply well. You may want to zoom in to see the writings. Red means contamination.
So, what are the conduits for the rising contamination?
Well, I had a nice reply typed in, but hit the wrong key and lost it somehow...
Conduits that contribute to themigration ofcontamination: lineaments/fractures, faults, folding within the formation that causes more lineaments, and abandoned oil wells are the main conduits.
Lineaments/fractures are long, 40' - 100' wide, long zones of breakage, caused by a host of reasons, (differential settling of the formations, shattering caused by the formation of faults, result of older folding, etc.). They are anywhere from 3/4 mile to miles long. The larger ones show demonstrable effects up to depths of 4000'.
High angle faults, are breaks in the rock along a small point, but are miles long.
Abandoned oil wells are a huge concern here in KY. From the time oil wells were first drilled with cable tool rigs, to about 1970, it was standard practice to abandon an oil well by shoving a pine tree down in it. There were no laws or regulations that stipulated closing requirements. In many parts of the state, there are hundreds of abandoned oil wells. The latest official estimates, are 10,000 poorly constructed, poorly closed oil wells. Since records weren't kept until the mid-1960s, and the locations were a closely guarded secret, no one know where they are.
They are now fracking the same formations that were productive in the early years, where the abandoned oil wells are the most prevalent.These wells have already allowed brines to escape the formations and migrate toward the surface--Most of eastern KY have salt water/fresh water interfaces at very shallow depths. Anywhere from 25' to 60'.
They use about 1,000,000 gallons per fracking 'incident'. Of that, they recover 60% of the materials, so that makes 600,000 gallons of highly contaminated fracking chemicals thatshould be treated prior to release. But, no wastewater treatment plant can handle the chemicals in their treatment process, and very few have the resources to expand the plants. How is it disposed of?
The other 40% remains in the hole. 400,000 gallons in theformations. The material is still under pressure to migrate, as the oil/natural gas is under pressure to escape the formations.
The trouble is thatthe oil companies don't frack just once-- they frack until they get the production that is required to have aproduction rate capable of turning all this expense into a profit.
I've seen fracking sites that looked like a wasteland. Bent, blackened stumps of trees, pools of unknown gook on the ground, some of which steams long after it has been removed from the well, no life anywhere. It makes me sick.
Dowser,
I am so with you on this. Our desire to get off of Middle East oil has blinded so many to the dangers of fracking. I have done so much reading about this practice and the danger to ground water and to people, and it isundeniablehow dangerous it is to us in the long run
Here is a fire caused by fracking
Look at the size of that 'industrial complex'. It's about the size of a city block. PLUS, it is covered with gravel, a very porous material that is used to drain sites-- meaning there is nothing to keep anything that is spilled on the ground from draining through the ground to enter the groundwater.
Not to mention the air pollution. No one wants to think about air pollution. BUT, air pollution contributes to pollution of the groundwater, surface water, soils, etc. Every time it rains, the rain picks up these particles in the atmosphere and deposits them on the surface, where it either soaks in or runs off.
This is a nightmare of epic proportions...
Thanks for your expertise Dowser; our site is fortunate to have your insight and I appreciate it.
Western north Dakota is gorgeous;reallyasuperbly tranquil and pristine area. It actually looks like cowboy country in many places and the Badlands are one of our favorite vacation spots.
The wide open experience is awesome andhumbling. The farmers and folks who have lived there for many generations ...
...are now seeing a slow creep across the vastness
Lottsa money to be made sure.
Is there a consideration of the ultimate cost though?
I have always wanted to go there-- but never had the wherewithal, or the time. It is a beautiful, pristine wilderness. No more. The people that live there deserve better than this.
No one ever considers the cost to the environment, and the cost of one's long-term health in situations like this.
This is just like the BP oil spill. All that oil near the surface lost the volatiles very quickly. They didn't just disappear, they entered the air, and every time it rained, it rained a mess of benzene, toluene and other volatiles down on the ground. The birds knew enough to get out of the way of that-- but the poor aquatic sea life couldn't. Then, as if what they had done wasn't enough, they sprayed Corexit on the oil. A mix of soap and kerosene, diesel fuel, and other hydrocarbons. Millions of gallons of it.
Let's take someone with cholera and give them a good dose of smallpox, too, while we're at it. Oh, and instead of fixing the problem, let's crow on TV about how we've taken care of everything. Sure they did. They made sure that all the sea life on the Gulf sea floor died. UGH.
I have been hired by quarries that had gasoline oozing out of the walls, from a tank farm 2 miles away-- contaminant transport via lineament. I've worked on about 45 projects dealing with hydrocarbon contamination. Even after all the 'product' is removed, it is still in the soils and the sand and gravel formations or rock. One site, the gas/diesel/jet fuel had managed to fill the holes in the rock. Every time a good rain comes along, the water table rises, and flushes out more of it.
I have little time for oil company practices. To me, they all need to be made to drink the water they pollute. And BP? Oh my. They need to have their arms duct taped to their bodies and placed in a8' deep tank, about the diameter of an oil drum. Be sure to have a nice 6" thick layer of crude on top. Now, when the idiots, (that made all those bad decisions to save money on the specific sealants they didn't use), want to breathe, they can surface, poke their faces through the crude and gasp a breath. Just like all the dolphins, whales, turtles, and other sea life they murdered.
I have friends at Haliburton. I know many fine oil and gas geologists. Even they are dismayed at fracking... UGH! I'm sorry that I can't seem to be more reasonable about it. This is my hot button.
I'm still heartbroken over our gulf, and likely always will be. What does the sea floor look like now? I don't know, but I have a reasonable facsimile of what it will look like in a few million years.
I couldn't find my picture, but this will do...
Of course we are talking about BIG money here too. This from today'sHerald ...
...and of course these counties do need this money, just to try and keep up with demand being placed on them now; but, It is only a drop compared to what the oil companies are making. In the long run though, the local and state government will also keep their palms well oiled, and that is what allows for the run-away greed by these oil companies.
Oh yes, you are very right!
In the mid 1980's it was proposed that all the oil companies drilling in Alaska chiip in for a mobile spill cleanup ship. It would constitute a tanker large enough to suck up all of Exxon Valdez's spill and the contaminated sand and gravel, contain scientists who would measure the effects of the spill, wildlife experts who could clean up the birds and save what they could, etc. At the time, it would have cost a total of around $800 million.
Ok, so now, it would cost $3 billion. BP made 35 billion in the two years before the oil spill. I think they could all chip in together and afford it. But then, our president Bush, who owns OIL stocks, etc. gives them the green light to bypass the Clean Water Act. There is no way we're going to be able to cork the genie back in the bottle.
I sincerely hope this passes, as well as other legislation-- especially the one about if they ruin a water supply they must replace it with like quantity and quality. I don't care if it costs them millions and millions of dollars to truck in enough water to supply the people in the area. DO IT.
I'm sorry, Larry. I just can't deal with these yahoos very well. I can't ever say who I worked for, or much of what I did-- but all I can say is, most people have NO idea what it is like out there. No one reallyknows what it is like to stand in a city's well field, that is the water supply for50,000 people, and see theproduct sheen glistening on the ground.
Then, with a sinking heart, drive through the city, see the kids on the bus to school, and know that the Drinking Water Standards are doses safe for adults, not necessarily children for the long-term dosage. And what about all the dogs of the neighborhood? They're even smaller... and the birds? And the butterflies?
When I worked for cities, I always felt the weight of the whole place on my shoulders. It was up to me to either fix a problem, or find a solution. I had to find water, or fix what was there. I felt for each individual out there-- who had no idea I even existed. Their safety and well-being were in my hands. They never knew how much I cared about them, how much I worried over them, or how much I had to do good by them. No wonder I had a major heart attack at 46! I worried myself almost to death!
Thanks very much for your kindness and understanding on this article. Thanks to all who have responded so well, and who have helped.
At work today, I saw a beautiful hawk as it looked for a nice meal over our front lawn. Then, four propeller heads, (deer), stood out front and watched me, as I left my car... I'm so very grateful to work in a spot that is clean and safe. And it's up to me to keep it that way.
[[They made sure that all the sea life on the Gulf sea floor died.]]
That sounds like an exaggeration to me . Oil spills in the Gulf are not like oil spills in Alaska . The warm waters allow oil eating microbes to thrive ...
You are right, it was an exaggeration-- not all the sea life in the Gulf was killed. But, all the sea life on the floor of the Gulf within about a 5 mile radius of the spill was. Not to mention within the plume, and along the shore.
In the 1980s there was a study done about how much crude oil it took to kill some kind of clam that is fairly common throughout the world. I've read about the study since, and can look for it again... Anyway, they put a clam in a 100 gallon tank, where it was happy and healthy, and wired electrodes to it to measure its heart rate. Then they added one drop of crude oil to the water. 1 drop per 100 gallons. It took about an hour, but the clam died.
1 quart of oil contaminates 56,000 gallons of water above the drinking water standards set by the EPA for many of the components in the oil.Drinking water standards are set for humans, based on a one-time dosage, (not long-term), of average weight. The sea life along the sea floor, (mollusks, brachiopods, corals, echinoderms, etc.), weigh a lot less than we do, and injest the oil directly-- they are filter feeders.
About a year after the spill-- scientists went down in one of those little vessels like they used on the Titanic and filmed the carnage. They found that all of the sessile benthotic animals, (those stuck to the sea floor), were dead within about a five mile radius. Radiating outward from that demarkation, the animals were very ill, and some were dying. As they traveled away from the spill site, they gradually got to where most of the animals appeared to be healthy, but it was a long way.
The plume stretched for miles. All of the floating creatures, the plankton, jelly fish, etc., found near the plume, were also dead and lying on the sea floor.
The microbes are an effective way to remove smaller amounts of the oil. They are not effective on millions of gallons of crude oil. How many microbes would it take to eat 180 million gallons of oil? There simply hasn't been time, yet. And, even though the Gulf waters are warmer than those of the Arctic, at those depths, the temperatures are just about as cold as the Arctic-- light doesn't get down that far, and the vessel used to check all that out had to use lights to see.
One of my friends at the water company went to Florida this year on vacation-- Pensacola-- and brought me back a jar of the tar balls that are located about 3 inches below the surface of the sand on the beach. A layer of black, hard, sandy balls of tar, similar to bits of asphalt. That is what is left, after all the volatiles leave.
Tar balls are still found on Alaska's shore from the Exxon Valdez spill, over 20 years ago. It doesn't go away, dear friend. It just doesn't go away.
And now, it is in the food chain.
Dolphins are reported as having high incidents of birth defects, and low birth rates. Same for turtles, and other sea life. We will never know how many shore birds were killed, or the crabs or all the other shore life, because the bodies of everything was disposed of quickly and, if they counted, (which I'm sure they didn't), it was not publicized.
This will go on for millions of years, and will never be cleaned up. In fact, there is evidence that oil is seeping out of the sea floor around the blowout at a high rate-- the oil is migrating up from the formations below, around the casing, through the sands, and blobbing its way up to the sea water.
Some seeps are natural-- this one is purely man-made.
Update...
North Dakota Senate snuffs natural gas flaring bill
UGH.
The American Water Works Association just put out a 'white paper', sort of an investigative report, about fracking and public water supplies. I've got a copy and need to summarize it for here...
It seems a shame to me that they are just burning it off, and not using it for something.
Capitalism 101 get all you can every chance you can.
And I love it when conservatives try to tie the need for domestic oil production to the price at the pump. We are pumping more oil while domestic demand is down. All this is taking place while pump prices are bumping up toward record levels. Hmmmmm...... Sounds like standard supply and demand economics don't apply to domestic oil production these days now does it?
And anyone who believes that the XL pipeline will reduce domestic fuel prices is either not paying attention, or willfully ignoring the facts.