╌>

Inspired by the comment of a Viner

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  neale-osborn  •  13 years ago  •  20 comments

Inspired by the comment of a Viner

How many times have we heard/read the line "Fine. If you want to excercise your 2nd Amendment rights to keep and bear arms, then get a flintlock musket. Because our forefathers couldn't possibly have foreseen fully automatic assault weapons!" (usually in a smarmy voice). I'm sure others have said similar things, but today, Jim Comfort said it so well, I have to copy it here.

If you want a forum with which to exercise your individual right to free speech, get off the internet and go stand on a stump in the town square.

How could we say it better. OF COURSE everyone knows our forefathers were innovators in more than politics. Ben Franklin "discovered" electricity and invented the Franklin Stove. During the Revolution, a British officer invented the Ferguson Rilfe, one of the first breech-loading rifles. Many different systems of multi-shot rifles and pistols were in production, and more innovation was on the horizon. The framers of the Bill of Rights had absolutely no reason to believe the evolution of personal arms was complete. Any more than they had any reason to believe the printing press and the town square stump were the end of the line for free speech. Or that redcoats kicking in a door was the ultimate invasion of personal space the 4th Amendment needed to protect against. Using the logic of "They only meant flintlocks" means that telephone calls require no warrant to tap, e-mails are not private, and automobiles are not protected against warrantless searches without permission "just because". Since they had no idea a doctor could remove a baby from a mother's womb WITHOUT major risk of the tansy killing the mother, abortion is not a right.

Those of you claiming that we only have a Constitutional right to flintlocks better watch out. WE can play that game if you want us to. And why wouldn't we, if you choose to assault the Bill of Rights and succeed? Once you kill off one part of it, the rest have no real relevance anymore. We might as well finish it off quickly, so we can move on to the next iteration of the American story. Because the first 230 years are finally over.

Personally, I'd MUCH prefer we follow the Constitution correctly. IF you don't like the 2nd Amendment for ANY reason at all, there is a very simple way to change it. It's called an Amendment. The 18th Amendment created Prohibition, making it the law of the land. The 21st Amendment repealed it. The ONLY Constitutional way to "control" guns is by an Amendment. Not by writing laws, Executive Orders, regulations, taxes, or bans. But you need 2/3rds majority of both the House and the Senate to pass it PLUS 3/4s of the states to ratify the amendment before it becomes law. Good luck on that! But it WILL negate all arguments.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    13 years ago

What do you have to say to that?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

I don't think that any later amendment has ever altered the Bill of Rights .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

I believe you are right, Rich. The Bill of Rights is like the 10 Commandments... so to speak.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    13 years ago

PLUS 2/3rds of the states to ratify the amendment before it becomes law. Good luck on that! But it WILL negate all arguments.

More than that Neale. It requires 3/4 of the States to ratify, with each State, no matter what the population, having only one vote. That means that only 13 States can say no, and it's dead.

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    13 years ago

You haven't been to Detroit and approached by a crackhead, have you? Having a concealed carry license is a good thing to have in situations like that.

The threat of getting carjacked with your children in the backseat? Um, yeah. I want to at least have the power to protect my children. I don't give a hoot about the vehicle. That's what insurance is for, but you bet your ass, no one will be driving off in my car with my kids in it!!!

I am a 5 ft nothing woman and have had to go to not so nice areas to have a job to pay the bills. Whether or not the other person has a gun, I can certainly still be threatened with death. I like my right to have my concealed pistol on my side. Crime rates (in MI) have drastically dropped since 2001 when Michigan loosened the laws on concealed carry.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    13 years ago

I love it. Even when I present the most simple AND accurate example of why the Colonial times vs today argument is irrelevant, someone drags out the same argument.

Let me ba as blunt as possible. Restrictions on free speech other than libel are unConstitutional. EVEN the old "Fire" in a crowded theater. Victims of this act can sue the Fier-shouter for damages, but Constitutionally speaking, laws preventing it are unConstitutional. The fact that the Founding fathers had no idea that 300 miles a day in a car was possible has ZERO to do with it. The fact that they never thought we'd ever be stupid enough to have a large standing army (the biggest threat to freedom, in their eyes, as a government can and will eventually use it against the people) does not negatethe most important in the amendment. BECAUSE there is a need for a well-trained (the meaning of regulated in 1792 as pertains to militias), the right of individual Americans (Repeatedly upheld as the definition of "The People") to own and carry weapons cannot be altered or removed (infringed) So, unless you want to log off and head for the village square (don't forget to get that unConstitutional permit first) and start speaking.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

[[Is there really a need for a tool which has the sole purpose of killing another human being? ]]

Killing , yes . Humans , not necessarily .

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    13 years ago

Well, guns make only one thing easier. Killing. That's it. Nothing else. Don't kid yourself that they are anything other than tools for killing.

Grae,

It is a most regrettable fact that sometimes people have to be killed (and not just by the police or military). I doubt that you'd have protested much if someone would have killed Holmes at the beginning of his actions in Colorado. It would have been regrettable but acceptable.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Oh, going to take your marbles and Go Home? I wasn't uncivil. However, YOU sure as hell were. Calling someone supporting a Constitutionally enumerated right a zealot is quite uncivil. Just emphatic, And it went right over your head. Whether the SCOTUS has upheld restrictions on free speech or not is irrelevant. MY point was that ANY restrictions other than against libel, is unConstitutional no matter the precedent cited. NO restrictions that are not listed in the Constitution or the Amendment is legitimate.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    13 years ago

But they CAN. Gettingan amendmentpassed to eliminatean existing amendmentwould be difficult, but if it passes, it stands. Even for the Bill of Rights. But I can't see all but 13 states ratifying the removal of ANY of them. That's why Obama and crew are so busy talking laws and executive orders and not mentioning amendments. Of course, the idiots in Washington forget that their actions are in direct contravention of the Constitution.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    13 years ago

But But But it doesn't say that!! It clearly states 3/4s!

Grin.gif

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    13 years ago

I knew I could count on the resident Constitution-hater to run his mouth.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    13 years ago

No, they may ban them but that does not make it Constitutional. Nice try. Just as Dredd Scott upheld slavery despite it's unconstituionality, just as Jim Crow laws were upheld by many different federal courts for decades despite THEIR unconstitutionality, courts violate the Constitution every day. And idiots will use that to justify further violations. That's alright. We, the intelligent, will continue to fight for your rights even if you don't want them.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Those of you claiming that we only have a Constitutional right to flintlocks better watch out. WE can play that game if you want us to. And why wouldn't we, if you choose to assault the Bill of Rights and succeed? Once you kill off one part of it, the rest have no real relevance anymore. We might as well finish it off quickly, so we can move on to the next iteration of the American story. Because the first 230 years are finally over.

Neale, this argument is seriously flawed and I'll specifically tell you why. While the Founding Fathers could not have specifically predicted the assault weapon, the internet, the nuclear weapon or any of the current technology and other developments, THEY ABSOLUTELY PREDICTED THAT LIFE IN AMERICA AND THE WORLD WOULD CHANGE!

And that is precisely the reason they authored a Constitution THAT CAN BE AMENDED! It was and is a LIVING DOCUMENT ...

The Constitution can be changed.

Amendment Process

The authority to amend the Constitution of the United States is derived from Article V of the Constitution . After Congress proposes an amendment, the Archivist of the United States, who heads the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA), is charged with responsibility for administering the ratification process under the provisions of 1 U.S.C. 106b . The Archivist has delegated many of the ministerial duties associated with this function to the Director of the Federal Register. Neither Article V of the Constitution nor section 106b describe the ratification process in detail. The Archivist and the Director of the Federal Register follow procedures and customs established by the Secretary of State, who performed these duties until 1950, and the Administrator of General Services, who served in this capacity until NARA assumed responsibility as an independent agency in 1985.

The Constitution provides that an amendment may be proposed either by the Congress with a two-thirds majority vote in both the House of Representatives and the Senate or by a constitutional convention called for by two-thirds of the State legislatures. None of the 27 amendments to the Constitution have been proposed by constitutional convention. The Congress proposes an amendment in the form of a joint resolution. Since the President does not have a constitutional role in the amendment process, the joint resolution does not go to the White House for signature or approval. The original document is forwarded directly to NARA's Office of the Federal Register (OFR) for processing and publication. The OFR adds legislative history notes to the joint resolution and publishes it in slip law format. The OFR also assembles an information package for the States which includes formal "red-line" copies of the joint resolution, copies of the joint resolution in slip law format, and the statutory procedure for ratification under 1 U.S.C. 106b.

The Archivist submits the proposed amendment to the States for their consideration by sending a letter of notification to each Governor along with the informational material prepared by the OFR. The Governors then formally submit the amendment to their State legislatures. In the past, some State legislatures have not waited to receive official notice before taking action on a proposed amendment. When a State ratifies a proposed amendment, it sends the Archivist an original or certified copy of the State action, which is immediately conveyed to the Director of the Federal Register. The OFR examines ratification documents for facial legal sufficiency and an authenticating signature. If the documents are found to be in good order, the Director acknowledges receipt and maintains custody of them. The OFR retains these documents until an amendment is adopted or fails, and then transfers the records to the National Archives for preservation.

A proposed amendment becomes part of the Constitution as soon as it is ratified by three-fourths of the States (38 of 50 States). When the OFR verifies that it has received the required number of authenticated ratification documents, it drafts a formal proclamation for the Archivist to certify that the amendment is valid and has become part of the Constitution. This certification is published in the Federal Register and U.S. Statutes at Large and serves as official notice to the Congress and to the Nation that the amendment process has been completed.

In a few instances, States have sent official documents to NARA to record the rejection of an amendment or the rescission of a prior ratification. The Archivist does not make any substantive determinations as to the validity of State ratification actions, but it has been established that the Archivist's certification of the facial legal sufficiency of ratification documents is final and conclusive.

In recent history, the signing of the certification has become a ceremonial function attended by various dignitaries, which may include the President. President Johnson signed the certifications for the 24th and 25th Amendments as a witness, and President Nixon similarly witnessed the certification of the 26th Amendment along with three young scholars. On May 18, 1992, the Archivist performed the duties of the certifying official for the first time to recognize the ratification of the 27th Amendment, and the Director of the Federal Register signed the certification as a witness.

And this is also not quite accurate ...

The ONLY Constitutional way to "control" guns is by an Amendment. Not by writing laws

There are other ways to "control" guns without violating the 2nd Amendment ... gun laws vary from state-to-state, city-to-city, etc. . You get the idea.

Here's one reason I fear the so-called "good guys" with a gun ... a hothead and an a-hole screaming his "points".

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Weeellll, As I said in the article, IF people try to use the flintlock method, we will fight fire with fire. As to state and local laws, they are not permitted to violate constitutional rights- hence Jim Crow laws are unConstitutional. Whether or not gun laws have been passed by state and local governments, and whether or not the courts have not struck them down, the laws are still unconstitutional. Just as a state may not make a law establishing a religion, they may not make a law infringing on our right to keep and bear arms.

Oh, and FYI- since over 34 states have passed Must Issue or Shall Issue laws in regards to their unconstitutional Concealed Carry licenses, violent crimes have fallen by 4 percent each year over the last 4 years.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Oh, and FYI- since over 34 states have passed Must Issue or Shall Issue laws in regards to their unconstitutional Concealed Carry licenses, violent crimes have fallen by 4 percent each year over the last 4 years.

I disagree with your cause-and-effect; the decrease in crime is more likely attributable to the increased use of cell phones both to immediately report a crime-about-to-be-perpetrated, a crime-in-progress being photographed or video-recorded ...

Does posting a sign at the doorway of a school or other public area ... a sign that says "NO GUNS PERMITTED" violate the constitution ... how about in an airport or on a plane?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

A 2nd Amendment Spokesperson.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    13 years ago

In answer to your questions- YES if by government decree, no if placed by the owners of private property. You see, private property is the SOLE place where another's rights are diminished. Because they are there upon the sufference of the owner. If the airport is government owned, then it is owned by ALL people, and therefore, the individual person may determine whether to carry there or not. Ditto for public schools. Airplanes are private property, and the owners of the plane are the determiners of weapon policy.

As to the cause and effect, Cell phones certainly contribute, but cell phones have been common for over a decade, while the freeing up of concealed carry laws has grown by leaps and bounde=s over the last 4 years. Also, the biggest cities have the most cell phone ownership. And the biggest cities with the harshest laws against concealed carry have the highest gun crime rates. Chicago, Washington DC, Newark, New York. Super strict laws against concealed carry, hundreds of thousands of cell phones, the highest murder rates by gun. Sorry, my friend, but I am not buying that one!Grin.gif

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Well, he's not far from the truth, but I'd much rather fight at the ballot box. AS someone else responded to the flintlocks and what the Founding Fathers could foresee,

"No, but they did forsee the current government. That is why we have the 2nd Amendment."

The 2nd isn't about hunting. It isn't about target shooting. It isn't about "what legitimate sporting purpose does this gun have". It's about, in the final interpretation, about our ability to repeat 1776 if necessary. And as in 1776, where the "legitimate" government had an army and overwhelming firepower, it was the private citizen with his privately owned weapons that won in the end. The Founding Fathers opposed large standing armies so that government could not use them against the citizen. They SUPPORTED citizen militias so that, in final dreadful extreme, they COULD be used against the government. I hope never to see the day when it becomes necessary to excercise that horrible final option. But I will not submit to being disarmed by a government that distrusts it's citizens so much that they choose to attempt to render them defenseless.

"You cannot enslave a free man. The most you can do is kill him." Robert A. Heinlein

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Frankly, I find YOU ridiculous. It's a pretty plain document, apart from a touch of flowery prose. And ANY doubts as to their intent is easily resolved by reading the writings of the framers and those who forced the framers to add the Bill of Rights. Sadly, some people think that rights can be done away with to suit the petty fears of losers, or to advance an agenda of "transforming America". But the ONLY way to do that is by Amendment. The powers of the three branches are quite specific. AND LIMITED.

 
 

Who is online

MrFrost


121 visitors