Trains carrying more oil across the US as pipeline projects stall; experts fear major spill
community » Discussions » Category » News & Politics » Discussion » Trains carrying more oil across the US as pipeline projects stall; experts fear major spill
0
Category: News & Politics
Via: larry-hampton • 14 years ago • 46 comments
BILLINGS, Mont. Energy companies behind the oil boom on the Northern Plains are increasingly turning to an industrial-age workhorse the locomotive to move their crude to refineries across the U.S., as plans for new pipelines stall and existing lines cant keep up with demand.
Delivering oil thousands of miles by rail from the heartland to refineries on the East, West and Gulf coasts costs more, but it can mean increased profits up to $10 or more a barrel because of higher oil prices on the coasts. That works out to about $700,000 per train.
The parade of mile-long trains carrying hazardous material out of North Dakota and Montana and across the country has experts and federal regulators concerned. Rail transport is less safe than pipelines, they say, and the proliferation of oil trains raises the risk of a major derailment and spill.
Maybe this will create a demand for better railway infrastructure, more stringent inspections, better railway lines, AND better maintenance. aka: jobs.
We had a derailment in Louisville this spring, of hazardous chemicals. One man died when his torch ignited a giant fireball from the highly explosive materials inside. So, yes, railway derailments can be very dangerous, but are also more localized than a pipeline spill.
Frankly, a railway derailment/spill is pretty spectacular. As in Hard To Miss. Plus, a railway derailment has a finite amount of materials that can spill. While a pipeline can rupture anywhere along its length-- not always in highly populated areas, where it MAY be missed for a while-- not to mention that it has millions of gallons of materials that may be spilled, i.e. the entire volume of the pipeline. Plus, the materials inside the pipeline are under pressure, to get it to flow over all the hills.
I would surely hate to have to design a pipeline to cross the Appalachians, whereas train rails are already in place.
Pipelines are not well-watched and not always well-maintained, as they are underground for the most part, and they can create huge swaths of land that prevent the normal migration patterns of wildlife, etc.
I don't have an answer, but, as a groundwater professional, I'd rather see it transported by rail than by pipeline.
Thanks for your take on this Dowser . Can I assume that natural gas pipelines do not have the same potential for groundwater pollution as the oil pipelines ?
The train derailment here in Louisville this year involved only 5 or 6 cars out of a 110 car train, and only one ruptured. It was a mess, for sure, but nothing like a pipeline leak!
In general, the US needs much more attention paid to it's power infrastructure. We have thecapabilityto buildwind-farms but do not have the grid to take advantage of it. This issue of Pipeline orrailwayfor shipping fuel is only one part of a larger discussion; like Rich said above, this is a truly important topic and affects so many things from ecology and energy to politics and global positioning.
[[there is no instance (government or otherwise) that has the mission and the authority to "coordinate" across multiple state lines.
The "coordination problem" is serious, and as technology makes all domains of activity more and more interconnected, it will only get more serious.]]
This is a potential problem when an infrastructure is regulated within individual states . Such is the case for electric power grids . There is no simple way to coordinate all the states to accomplish this task . OTOH there are new technologies being researched which may indicate the need to wait till they are commercially available .Mandating an huge infrastructure such as this based on older technology would be expensive but not long lived [because it would need to be replaced when the new technologies became available ] .
To make a blanket statement that the US is incapable of constructing interstate infrastructures is clearly inaccurate . The 2 most obvious examples are railroads and highways . The US government used to have the means of accomplishing those tasks under the Interstate Commerce Commission . Thatcommission no longer exists largely because it had already accomplished its main tasks and had no new ones to occupy it .
"Many small railroads failed during the Great Depression of the 1930s. Of those lines that survived, the stronger ones were not interested in supporting the weaker ones.[10] Congress repudiated Ripley's Plan with the Transportation Act of 1940, and the consolidation idea was scrapped.[12]"
That is how the US dealt with uneconomic railroads in the past . To assume that HSR would be supported by sufficient ridership is not warranted . My best guess is that it wouldn't .
[[I think you are demonstrating, here, that "immediate return on investment" is a very bad way to evaluate national infrastructures.]]
"Bad" meaning what exactly ?
[[There is absolutely no doubt that the BosWash line would be heavily loaded from opening day.]]
Absolutely no doubt ? You are far too confident . What is your evidence ? What is the advantage to such riders when they can take their own cars ? They don't have to plan around the train schedule .
You seem to feel that the European culture is superior to American culture . I would not make such a simple value judgement . Each has its own advantages and disadvantages . There are distinct differences . That's what I was going for when I wrote this article/contest .
[[You're saying that Americans like danger and stress...]]
So all capitalist-based societies are confronted with the dilemma you have just laid out. The US, with a strong popular mistrust of government (although personally, I do not understand why ), does very little "central planning". So we get distortions like lots of petroleum being produced in an area that has no means for evacuating it... or (as you mentioned) nuclear power plants tied to a third-world power grid...
Most of the time capitalism works good for the US; imho the idea here is that customer demand would drive the energy sector indifferentmoreefficientdirections. Technology has leapfroggeditself so much that, it does make investors nervous; but, we do know that many of these long term investments will make more money once we have infrastructure in place. I keep going back to wind because to me it's a no-brainer.
Here's some information you might have missed during all the crazed fiscal cliff negotiations: As part of the financial deal, Congress extended tax credits on all wind energy projects through 2013.
That news was warmly welcomed by wind power developers -- many of whom rushed to complete wind farms and other projects in 2012 in case those subsidies ran out.
How important were those subsidies? "Just simply, 30% of the value of a project is derived from the tax credit," Florian Zerhusen, chief executive of WKN USA, a San Diego wind developer, told MyDesert.com . "That's what makes it so important, or you're making too low a return."
The American Wind Energy Association says about half of the 75,000 jobs in the nation's wind energy sector -- along with jobs at companies involved in the industrys supply chain -- would have been at risk if the tax credits had been allowed to expire.
This makes sense to me. Read the article and we see that all over the globe, wind is pickin' up speed! This is a worthy investment...one that will supply dividends.
In the shorter term though, we must take advantage of theresourcespresently used, without losing focus on the fact that they (oil, natural gas, coal or any other finiteresource) should be viewed in light of the fact that they are now only temporary fixes.
Frankly, I personally place energy in the top three concerns for the US. We need an all out blitz on solving our energy need, and that also calls for the same on the education front. From the top down a call needs to be made for smarterenergydriven by smarter education and students. Like a Manhattan project but on a nationalbusinessandacademiclevel..."priority one, solve the energy problem".
In general, the US needs much more attention paid to it's power infrastructure. We have thecapabilityto buildwind-farms but do not have the grid to take advantage of it.
What about solar-- does that have a future?
How about water-power-- inventing some device that harnesses the energy of the tides!
Also, in terms of "transport"-- rather than rail cars or pipelines, wouldn't the power generated by both of these (wind and solar) travel by means of high power electric lines? Wouldn't that be both cheaper and safer than either rail or pipeline required to transport gas/oil?
All options should be investigated, and vested where mostefficient. The safety issue is huge and anytime moving avolatilesubstance can be avoided, the better.
Maybe, maybe not. A lot of the keystone and other nearby pipelines go right thorough folks' farms andyard-space...having a terrorist sabotage pipeline on your land may very well be terrifying.
Not to mention the potential for largeeconomic,and lastingecologicalissues.
I think that solar is a really good answser for a lot of areas-- maybe not in Maine or even so much in KY, (we have a lot of rain compared to other places), and geothermal is also really good... We have a lot of rivers and streams and use a lot of hydroelectric power, which is, unfortunately augmented by coal burning.
I'm with you, all options should be investigated and no two areas are going to have the same solutions.
I know that at the water company, we are VERY concerned with the potential for terrorist attacks, as well as just general mischief. It is critical to the health of about 1,000,000 people that we be ever vigilant to protect the water supply.
In the long run, that kind of damage could be more terrifying and damaging than any 9/11 could be. Terrorism is meant to deprive a people from a way of life, and that would do the trick.
SOLAR energy currently provides only a quarter of a percent of the planets electricity supply, but the industry is growing at staggering speed. Underlying this growth is a phenomenon that solars supporters call Swansons law, in imitation of Moores law of transistor cost. Moores law suggests that the size of transistors (and also their cost) halves every 18 months or so. Swansons law, named after Richard Swanson, the founder of SunPower, a big American solar-cell manufacturer, suggests that the cost of the photovoltaic cells needed to generate solar power falls by 20% with each doubling of global manufacturing capacity. The upshot is that the modules used to make solar-power plants now cost less than a dollar per watt of capacity. This means that in sunny regions such as California, photovoltaic power could already compete without subsidy with the more expensive parts of the traditional power market. Moreover, technological developments that have been proved in the laboratory but have not yet moved into the factory mean Swansons law still has many years to run.
It is designed to make people fear for their actual lives .
Agreed.
The act of sabotage carried out in a more dramatic manner though (maybe blowing pipeline up in places) would certainly be perceived as a threat against life and limb. At least I would see it that way if on my property.
The issue is the number of people who would be put in fear for their lives . This kind of attack would probably result in no deaths and no injuries . It is property damage and ecological damage ...
[[I do agree, though, that eco-terrorism will come. I'm kinda surprised that it isn't already here.]]
I'm not . The terrorists understand the political ramifications . Hurting the ecology would offend their main base of supporting bystanders in the US and Europe .
[[One of these days, some young people are going to come to the conclusion that "the system" is going to continue to destroy their world... and therefore "the system" must be changed. Within a few years we will see violent action against "the system": Wall Street and Big Oil (like the XL Pipeline) will be at the top of the target list.]]
I have been watching a TV series about that idea , "Continuum" . It includes some sci-fi aspects but that is the topic .
The economic cost is not the only significant variable . Solar power still suffers from a low EROEI value . Until the cells get more efficient that problem will remain .
Something like a pipeline sabotage would sure create a political mess as well. Would it be considered an act of war, terrorism, hoodlum activity...?...interesting and scary scenario.
Some Frank Herbert and Orson Scott Card works touch on that as well. If ya think about it, we are on a crowded rock with dwindling resources. Resources we have been fighting over ever since we can remember.
Delivering oil thousands of miles by rail from the heartland to refineries on the East, West and Gulf coasts costs more, but it can mean increased profits up to $10 or more a barrel because of higher oil prices on the coasts. That works out to about $700,000 per train.
The parade of mile-long trains carrying hazardous material out of North Dakota and Montana and across the country has experts and federal regulators concerned. Rail transport is less safe than pipelines, they say, and the proliferation of oil trains raises the risk of a major derailment and spill.
This is an important topic . I'm assuming that it is the environmentalists who are holding up the pipelines ...
Maybe this will create a demand for better railway infrastructure, more stringent inspections, better railway lines, AND better maintenance. aka: jobs.
We had a derailment in Louisville this spring, of hazardous chemicals. One man died when his torch ignited a giant fireball from the highly explosive materials inside. So, yes, railway derailments can be very dangerous, but are also more localized than a pipeline spill.
Frankly, a railway derailment/spill is pretty spectacular. As in Hard To Miss. Plus, a railway derailment has a finite amount of materials that can spill. While a pipeline can rupture anywhere along its length-- not always in highly populated areas, where it MAY be missed for a while-- not to mention that it has millions of gallons of materials that may be spilled, i.e. the entire volume of the pipeline. Plus, the materials inside the pipeline are under pressure, to get it to flow over all the hills.
I would surely hate to have to design a pipeline to cross the Appalachians, whereas train rails are already in place.
Pipelines are not well-watched and not always well-maintained, as they are underground for the most part, and they can create huge swaths of land that prevent the normal migration patterns of wildlife, etc.
I don't have an answer, but, as a groundwater professional, I'd rather see it transported by rail than by pipeline.
Thanks for your take on this Dowser . Can I assume that natural gas pipelines do not have the same potential for groundwater pollution as the oil pipelines ?
only for air pollution, dear neetu. while highly flammable, natural gas may enter the groundwater, but it is nowhere as toxic, as far as groundwater.
I like THAT thought, very well!
Use natural gas for everything ...
That's absolutely right, Bob.
The train derailment here in Louisville this year involved only 5 or 6 cars out of a 110 car train, and only one ruptured. It was a mess, for sure, but nothing like a pipeline leak!
Just as long as we're not fracking for it, Sure!!!
In general, the US needs much more attention paid to it's power infrastructure. We have thecapabilityto buildwind-farms but do not have the grid to take advantage of it. This issue of Pipeline orrailwayfor shipping fuel is only one part of a larger discussion; like Rich said above, this is a truly important topic and affects so many things from ecology and energy to politics and global positioning.
[[there is no instance (government or otherwise) that has the mission and the authority to "coordinate" across multiple state lines.
The "coordination problem" is serious, and as technology makes all domains of activity more and more interconnected, it will only get more serious.]]
This is a potential problem when an infrastructure is regulated within individual states . Such is the case for electric power grids . There is no simple way to coordinate all the states to accomplish this task . OTOH there are new technologies being researched which may indicate the need to wait till they are commercially available .Mandating an huge infrastructure such as this based on older technology would be expensive but not long lived [because it would need to be replaced when the new technologies became available ] .
To make a blanket statement that the US is incapable of constructing interstate infrastructures is clearly inaccurate . The 2 most obvious examples are railroads and highways . The US government used to have the means of accomplishing those tasks under the Interstate Commerce Commission . Thatcommission no longer exists largely because it had already accomplished its main tasks and had no new ones to occupy it .
"Many small railroads failed during the Great Depression of the 1930s. Of those lines that survived, the stronger ones were not interested in supporting the weaker ones.[10] Congress repudiated Ripley's Plan with the Transportation Act of 1940, and the consolidation idea was scrapped.[12]"
That is how the US dealt with uneconomic railroads in the past . To assume that HSR would be supported by sufficient ridership is not warranted . My best guess is that it wouldn't .
[[I think you are demonstrating, here, that "immediate return on investment" is a very bad way to evaluate national infrastructures.]]
"Bad" meaning what exactly ?
[[There is absolutely no doubt that the BosWash line would be heavily loaded from opening day.]]
Absolutely no doubt ? You are far too confident . What is your evidence ? What is the advantage to such riders when they can take their own cars ? They don't have to plan around the train schedule .
[[My evidence is forty years of actual real-world experience in similar high-population density corridors.]]
I don't think your experience has been in the US . You don't understand our culture here .
[[Both "serenity" and "efficiency". No-stress travel where you can do effective work if you so desire. ]]
Serenity is not what Americans are about . Likewise for lack of stress .
You seem to feel that the European culture is superior to American culture . I would not make such a simple value judgement . Each has its own advantages and disadvantages . There are distinct differences . That's what I was going for when I wrote this article/contest .
[[You're saying that Americans like danger and stress...]]
Not like so much as tend towards .
Most of the time capitalism works good for the US; imho the idea here is that customer demand would drive the energy sector indifferentmoreefficientdirections. Technology has leapfroggeditself so much that, it does make investors nervous; but, we do know that many of these long term investments will make more money once we have infrastructure in place. I keep going back to wind because to me it's a no-brainer.
This makes sense to me. Read the article and we see that all over the globe, wind is pickin' up speed! This is a worthy investment...one that will supply dividends.
In the shorter term though, we must take advantage of theresourcespresently used, without losing focus on the fact that they (oil, natural gas, coal or any other finiteresource) should be viewed in light of the fact that they are now only temporary fixes.
Frankly, I personally place energy in the top three concerns for the US. We need an all out blitz on solving our energy need, and that also calls for the same on the education front. From the top down a call needs to be made for smarterenergydriven by smarter education and students. Like a Manhattan project but on a nationalbusinessandacademiclevel..."priority one, solve the energy problem".
The pipeline worries me because of terrorism. A well planned attack could dump millions of oil onto our land. A train load bad, but not asdevastating.
Clearly you don't understand the mindset of terrorists . Causing an oil spill is not a plan designed to produce terror.
What about solar-- does that have a future?
How about water-power-- inventing some device that harnesses the energy of the tides!
Also, in terms of "transport"-- rather than rail cars or pipelines, wouldn't the power generated by both of these (wind and solar) travel by means of high power electric lines? Wouldn't that be both cheaper and safer than either rail or pipeline required to transport gas/oil?
.
Absolutely.
All options should be investigated, and vested where mostefficient. The safety issue is huge and anytime moving avolatilesubstance can be avoided, the better.
Maybe, maybe not. A lot of the keystone and other nearby pipelines go right thorough folks' farms andyard-space...having a terrorist sabotage pipeline on your land may very well be terrifying.
Not to mention the potential for largeeconomic,and lastingecologicalissues.
I think that solar is a really good answser for a lot of areas-- maybe not in Maine or even so much in KY, (we have a lot of rain compared to other places), and geothermal is also really good... We have a lot of rivers and streams and use a lot of hydroelectric power, which is, unfortunately augmented by coal burning.
I'm with you, all options should be investigated and no two areas are going to have the same solutions.
I know that at the water company, we are VERY concerned with the potential for terrorist attacks, as well as just general mischief. It is critical to the health of about 1,000,000 people that we be ever vigilant to protect the water supply.
In the long run, that kind of damage could be more terrifying and damaging than any 9/11 could be. Terrorism is meant to deprive a people from a way of life, and that would do the trick.
[[Terrorism is meant to deprive a people from a way of life]]
I don't agree . It is designed to make people fear for their actual lives .
Agreed.
The act of sabotage carried out in a more dramatic manner though (maybe blowing pipeline up in places) would certainly be perceived as a threat against life and limb. At least I would see it that way if on my property.
Larry ,
The issue is the number of people who would be put in fear for their lives . This kind of attack would probably result in no deaths and no injuries . It is property damage and ecological damage ...
[[I do agree, though, that eco-terrorism will come. I'm kinda surprised that it isn't already here.]]
I'm not . The terrorists understand the political ramifications . Hurting the ecology would offend their main base of supporting bystanders in the US and Europe .
[[One of these days, some young people are going to come to the conclusion that "the system" is going to continue to destroy their world... and therefore "the system" must be changed. Within a few years we will see violent action against "the system": Wall Street and Big Oil (like the XL Pipeline) will be at the top of the target list.]]
I have been watching a TV series about that idea , "Continuum" . It includes some sci-fi aspects but that is the topic .
The economic cost is not the only significant variable . Solar power still suffers from a low EROEI value . Until the cells get more efficient that problem will remain .
Something like a pipeline sabotage would sure create a political mess as well. Would it be considered an act of war, terrorism, hoodlum activity...?...interesting and scary scenario.
Some Frank Herbert and Orson Scott Card works touch on that as well. If ya think about it, we are on a crowded rock with dwindling resources. Resources we have been fighting over ever since we can remember.