Someone PLEASE explain this one to me.
Let me preface this by saying I don't support the NRA. They do more harm to the pro-gun movement by collaborating on the creation of gun laws. I do not support public schools. I believe them to be liberal indoctrination stations, little more than state mandated jails for the young. It is the duty of parents to provide for the education of their children, not to simply surrender control of their children for 8 hours a day to teachers the parents did not select. I home school. I am not a christian. I am, in fact, an agnostic at most, an atheist more likely. I am the type of Libertarian the Libertarian Party hates. I am vehemently in favor of eliminating 99% of gun laws. So, now you know where I stand. I am NOT going to discuss gun ownership here. That is fodder for another article. Arguments over whether people should be permitted to own guns are off topic and will be deleted by moderators if the poster persists. Stick to the question asked, please. Now, to the question I need answered.
Would someone PLEASE explain to me why it is an evil thing to suggest we need armed guards in all public schools. Please note- I don't necessarily mean POLICE guards. Just trained, armed guards. It can be teachers, janitors, volunteers, security guards from private security services, or even National Guardsmen doing their 2 weeks a year. We do not have a problem with armed guards in banks and armored cars. We don't have a problem with armed guards at our courthouses and public buildings. We don't have a problem with armed guards at our airports. But we DO have a problem with armed guards protecting our most valuable possessions~ Our children. I am an armed American. I have a CCW. I have training in the use of firearms, in proper concealed carry, and when NOT to use a weapon. I paid for it myself, because I feel it is necessary if I am going to carry. I got the training years ago, when I lived where it was not required to get a license to carry open, and easy as hell to get a CCW. Now, where I currently live, I needed nothing but a Hunter Safety card and references to get my CCW ( which is more than I think is permitted under the 2nd Amendment, but I digress). I carry quite often. Even though I homeschool, I would volunteer a day or two a week to stand guard over your children. I wonder why so many of you consider this somehow abhorrent. Our money, our court system, our government buildings, and our president are somehow more worthy of the expense of protecting than your children are.
- Please tell me why!!!

Keep it polite.
Neale my friend, I think the biggest deterrent to having armed guards in schools is a two part answer. One it would cost on average every year about 7 billion dollars to pay guards to watch over our children, the tax payers are already screaming over the amount of taxes they pay, even though they are the lowest in years, and the Republicans will never agree on a tax hike to cover this expense. Second, I've mentioned this before on another site, having teachers, janitors, or any members of a school carrieing weapons would only make our schools less safe because of the wild west effect, a gun man shows up at the school fully loaded and ready for a fight and all heck breaks out, more people would be killed in the crossfire than would be saved.
There is a third reason, this has already been tried in Colorado, at Columbine before the killings there, they had a sherriffs deputy stationed at the school the day of the shooting, he was ineffective because of the fact he couldn't get a clean shot at the shooters without hitting one of the many innocent bystanders at the school. Any other situation at any other school will end the same way as this one did with an armed guard there, or, like I said above, someone will get killed by the guard that the guard is trying to protect, because the guard won't be as well trained as a police officer.
I do think new problems would probably arise from having armed guards in schools, but I'd rather see them in the schools anyways. I think that they would give everybody there at least a fighting chance during one of these events.
'I' see nothing wrong with having an armed guard watch over our children. At our elementary school we already have VFW volunteers watching over the crosswalks before and after school....no reason that couldn't include 'guard' duty for the in between time.
I am in a unique position where I work because I get to converse with many members of the community. It's absolutely amazing to me how many of our citezenry is already armed (legally carrying with a CHL). Many of those that I've spoken with would likely be very willing to volunteer to watch over the children.
I understand your last point. But the first is irrelevant. Cost is NEVER a consideration when it comes to our children. I have 4 kids, and each one is worth more than a billion dollars. We'll pay billions for schools to feed children, but not to protect them? And the Wild West Effect is, pardon my french, my friend, bull. Do you realize the Wild West wasn't? The vast majority of western towns were safer than eastern ones. Rape was almost unheard of. A woman could walk from home to the bank carrying a sack of gold, and arrive safely. And teachers and staff, trained (the NRA will do it for free, THAT'S something they do well), are going to fire primarily when it is safe. Is an armed guard the be-all and end-all to school safety? Of course not, There is no such thing a safety. never has been, never will be. Even if we were to somehow totally remove all firearms from America, there will always be dangers for our children. But if ONE mass shooting is reduced by the application of lead to chest of a psycho like the one in Connecticut (he would want me to mention his name, but I won't), I would consider that a plus.
As to Columbine- sorry, but it's a non-starter that we tried it once and it didn't work. IF he'd had a shot and taken it, the death toll would have been reduced. The fact that he held his fire is actually a refutation of the whole innocent bystander argument, in my opinion!
Thanks for a great post.
Bruce- I do NOT advocate arming ALL teachers. ONLY those willing to go through the necessary training AND accept the responsibility of what carrying a handgn means. The only thing worse, to me, than denying people the right to responsibly carry is to force people who are uncomfortabledealing with a gun to carry one. Nicely posted, Bruce. Thank you.
Personally, as an anti-government Libertarian, I agree. MY choice would be volunteers from the community, trained at either their own cost or from school budgets, doing the job. Well said, but I wanted (kinda) to avoid the entire "Government Conspiracy" meme.Then again,as Axelrod said, "We can't let an opportunity go to waste!"
I would prefer a certified and armed police officer in the school - a law enforcement officer. If a teacher were to be armed, I would prefer that teacher be required to be attend the local police academy and become a certified police officer with all the training (and all in service training)that the local police officers receive.
From my POV your comment gives good motivation to deploy non-lethal force in schools . Can you find similar fault with the use of rubber bullets [for example] in schools ?
Well, the Israelis have been killing protesters with rubber bullets for years, for starters. Then, you have the simple defense tactics (for the bad guys) of simply wearing heavy clothes and a motorcycle helmet, and suddenly, the only up side of the guards' presenceis that by pissing off the perpetrator, it gives them a non-child target. An idea that sounds good, until you do a little research. In another couple days, I'm going to give MY biggest opposition to armed guards in school. But I want to see if anyone else comes up with it first.
Hey, it's MY article, I can be mysterios if I want to! Thanks for coming by.
My not being familiar with the use of rubber bullets does not offer dispute to the principle of deploying non-lethal force . There must be some other variety which can be deployed ...
And Grump who would pay for this training and arming of the teachers? I was listening to Lawrence O'Donnel the other night andhe said that according to the numbers it would cost over 7 Billion dollars to put one armed guard in each of Americas schools, so, considering this were would that money come from? Congress refuses to increase taxes, the only form of revenue a government has.
Warmer.......warmer.......
I was honestly not being a dick with that, PnG. Non-lethal always sounds great in theory, but rarely works as well in field conditions. Partly because bad guys can basically "practice" the experience (hell, dumb college kids do the same thing- that's why I know that tasers hurt, but I can function under the influence of one taser, but not under two at the same time- don't ask!
). My fear, when it comes to non-lethal weapons, is the time necessary to change fron non-lethal to lethal when the non-lethal doesn't do the trick. If you think of a good method, I'd be happy to research it and see what's up with that method. I'm always interested in new methods of fighting crime.
Not quite true- how about we CUT spending on wars and welfare, and invest it on kids?
Even warmer! In fact, you're getting hot!
I never said nor implied you were being ... obstinate . Thanks for the info . How about the use of bolos to trip an attacker ? There ought to be some way to launch them from a weapon ...
Galen, that is not what I recommended, is it. Have teachers get qualified as police officers. That would not be as expensive as having a cop in every school. Of course, the person who wants to kill a lot of folks would just choose a different target, right. Day care. McDonald and so on. We get the protection we pay for, don't we? People bitch about high crime rates but will not fund the police department in their town. That makes no sense to me.
Oh, I KNOW you didn't say it, but I needed to be sure because when I read MY post after editing was no longer possible, I thought that it could read that way.
My biggest problem with N/L weaponry is teh danger it can put the utilizer in if/when it fails. But it is still something to consider, I guess.
The single biggest problem is, to have enough cops to make people "safe" you need a police state with a 50/50 ratio of cops to citizens. The single biggest deterrent to crime is a fear of your victim. And criminals only fear a victim who ISN'T a victim, but rather a capable person, ablr to defend themselves.
Grump, don't you think it will cost something to send each and every teacher to the Police Academy, or to require them to take weapons training? Also, don't you think that a teacher will want hazard pay if they are required to act as security at a school on top of teaching the kids? At some schools teachers are required to pay for extra teaching materials just to do their jobs.
They are our kids. We need to cut somewhere else, and protect the future of America. Cut welfare, cut military spending, cut the DEA, TSA, DHS, BATFE, FBI, NEA, BLM, BIA, or something else from the alphabet soup in DC.
Hell, cut out ALL foreign aid until OUR country is taken care of. Stop funding the UN, and giving them free rent and parking.
GM,
There's a lot more to being a police officer than just weapons and the ability to respond to dangerous situations. None of the rest of it is required to protect children. If teachers don't want to do so as needed, they can go out and get jobs that actually require them to work for a living. I've been both a teacher and a police officer, and can tell you that neither job requires a great deal of talent in anything except being politically correct.
Don't get me going on that cosmopolitan progressive sewer on the East Side of Manhattan. A more arrogant, law-ignoring bunch of thugs I cannot imagine.
I'm gonna let YOU take the heat for this one!
I'm one of the biggest arguers against the pussification of America's youth!
(Runs and hides from the gals!)
I don't have a reason why there shouldn't be. My husband would be more than happy to take that job for the school my children attend. He's unemployed and has a concealed pistol license. I think it's a fine idea really.
Make them cook bacon naked.
Can I lick.... Oh, wait! you said make THEM cook the bacon naked. NEVER MIND!!
Guess that depends on where you live. There aren't enough PO's to handle the crimes in southeast MI.
Or how about STRONG women handling it all??? Hm?
Sounds about right to me.
I don't need no strong wimmin- I wears da pants in MAH fambly- Mah wahf said Ah kin!
link?
We already have armed guards watching over our kids in the streets! They are called "policemen" and "policewomen"-- and yes, they are armed. (Of course they also watch over adults as well. Paid for by taxpayer dollars).
Now (something I wasn't aware of) many of the Israeli "rubber" bullts are actually rubber-coated steel proectiles, which obviously would nat be as "less than lethal" as straight rubber. It seems the British were bigger users of rubber bullets to cause death than the Israelis.
And they are NOT in our schools. And actually, I don't want uniformed cops wandering our schools. They already spend enough time doing warrantless searches of school lockers. I'd much rather see the armed people being teachers and staff, trained solely to defend their charges.
Yeah well... I'm the one makin the money for my household! I get to wear the pants... WITH the guns on my belt!
Here's the thing with comparing Israel with the United States, here in the States our police aren't armed as well as the general population, except for a few select units like SWAT, the Israeli police are armed almost, probably as well as the Army there, they have to be because, they are taking on Hesbola, and other terrorists on a daily basis. Were we need to be is in a place were we aren't dealing with folks who are barracaded in their homes with weapons that are superior to the weapons that our police carry, and unfortunately that is were we are, the people the police go after are better armed.
The US police have shotguns, AR15s, high-capacity handguns. As do many US civillians.
Israeli police have Uzis, handguns, and Galils (the Israeli weapon equivalent to our M16, the military AR15). And since ALL civillians did time in the Israeli military, and most take home their military weapons, so do they.
OK , so rubber bullets are not perfect . But their rate of lethality is fairly low so the odds of killing a bystander with them is also low That is a definite improvement over regular bullets .
A logical conclusion, but (sadly) not quite right. At least, from what I've read about them! The problems are threefold, according to research I did for a report on them (in 1992, in gunsmithing school).
First and foremost, people tend to aim less with them, causing far more bystander impacts, where a lot of the fatalities occur.
Because they are "non-lethal" many of those wo DO aim with them tend to aim for headshots, where they are the most dangerous.
Third, (and scariest) they are far more likely to be fatal to children, due to their more fragile bone structure, and thinner thoracic cavities. ust as a fastball to the chest kills a few Little Leaguers every year, the impact of a rubber bullet on a child can stop the heart. And their more fragile skills are far more likely to suffer penetration than an adults.
Rubber bullets are for riot work only, and less than satisfactory than would be otherwise thought even for that. But a VERY good question.
[[First and foremost, people tend to aim less with them, causing far more bystander impacts, where a lot of the fatalities occur.
Because they are "non-lethal" many of those wo DO aim with them tend to aim for headshots, where they are the most dangerous.]]
Those could be corrected with training .
As to the greater susceptibility of kids that is still better than regular bullets . If I had a kid in school I would still prefer guards armed with rubber bullets to regular bullets . But that is an important point . Thanks for the explanation ,
Anytime. And I understand the concept. But for ME, IF someone is armed when a man walks in to a schoolwith a bunch of weapons and begins shooting at MY kids, I want the defender to have the best ammo possible to stop the bad guy dead in his tracks.
I understand your POV . I am thinking about the public uproar that will happen if a kid is killed by a stray bullet from a defender .
I expect there would be less resistance from the public to rubber bullets in schools . That will hold until an incident happens in which they prove to be ineffective . Can I assume that the range of rubber bullets is much less than for rifle rounds ?
Rubber bullets with the steel core have effectively similar ranges to their regular counterpart. Handgun rounds (what an armed defender like a CCW-holding teacher would have) also have less range than a rifle round. Here's what I fear from a rubber-bullet using armed responder in a school situation. I'll pretend it's me as the responder.
John Psycho comes down the hall, and I see he's got two long guns and at least one pistol visible, but none are "at the ready", meaning I have the chance to apprehend. Being a decent guy who really doesn't want to kill anyone if I can avoid it, I draw, aim, and announce. "Drop your weapons!" The bad guy is pumped up on adrenaline, and goes to point a rifle at me, and I fiure two to the chest. The rubber bullets both hit him, and hurt like hell. But being effectively ust two massive punches to the chest, they stun but do not drop him. he manages to go through an open door, out of my sight. I know that room is empty, so I am not concerned about hostages, but I know the room has a back entrance, and I don't want him loose in the school. I quickly dial 911 on my cell, alert the police, and proceed. Suddenly, I see that he is hiding right behind the door. I know that if I don't stop him, he may get to all the kindergartners down the hall from the back door. I know my .357 magnum revolver is quite capable of shooting through the door he is using for cover. I aim carefully, and fire the remaining 4 shots through the door, to hit him center of mass. He hears the click of the hammer when I pull the trigger the fifth time, and he steps out from behind the door, and shoots me three times in the chest with his rifle. My dying thought is "SHIT!! Rubber bullets don't penetrate oak doors. Those poor children are doomed."
I would hate for children to die because I had limited myself to rubber bullets.
I do not claim to have ALL the answers. But one answer I do have is that the only way to stop a bad person with a gun is to have a good person with a gun at the same location. ( Just because wayne LaPierre said it doesn't mean it's wrong!) What's the best solution? A time machine that allows us to prevent firearms from being invented? I doubt it. Banning guns? Hasn't worked for Washington and Chicago. So, for me, it HAS to be armed Americans willing to take the training necessary to defend your kids in school. I home school, yet I'd cheerfully volunteer to do it for the children of others. And I know LOTS of gun owners who would do the same. Even for free.
Thanks for the narrative . That explains what is involved . I would think that a 357 mag would be the last weapon you would want to use in a public building . Stray bullets go through walls & doors ... they can hit innocent bystanders in other rooms .
One more thing : Going for a chest shot in that circumstance is not a good strategy .
That would be a good point (about .357 mag) IF one didn't plan appropriately AND have excellent aim. Just as in my home, IF I wasn't loading rubber bullets in the school (and I wouldn't, the rubber bullets would only be carried if that were the law) I would load Glaser Safety Slugs. They do not penetrate wood, metal, or two layers of drywall, being basically small pellets on an epoxy matrix. They do an incredible amount of damage to flesh, but they break up in structural materials. But I ALWAYS carry a speedloader of standard .357 mag for important spots. My gun sits next to my bed, with a speedloader next to it, and a small tactical flashlight. IF I were doing guard duty in a school, the gun would have the Glasers and a speedloader of standard rounds for a tactical re-load.
I know many people probably find my thought processes paranoid. But I don't think so. Any more than having a fire drill every few months at home, smoke and CO alarms in several spots, and several fire extinguishers scattered through the house. And believe me, when you heat with a woodstove, the smoke alarms are the cause of a few heartattacks! LOL I have 4v kids and an elderly mother in law living under my roof. And I plan to keep'em for a LOOOONG time. So we practice what to do in a fire, where to meet after we evacuate, what to do if we suspect an intruder, what to do when we stay out late and return after the family goes to sleep, what to do if we are ever out, and drink without a Designated Driver, hell, what to do if the horses get loose. We make the planning fun, but everyone knows it is serious at the heart of it.
At the base, carrying a gun is not for everyone. I oppose mandatory arming as much as I oppose mandatory DISarming of citizens. Guns are tools. Just as some people cannot cut ac straight line with a circular saw, some cannot shoot a gun. Some people know they'd never use it, and if they know that, then they are at more risk fromtheir own gun than they are from a badguy. Think of what carrying a gun means. Do you believe you will use it if needed? Do you think you'd be the type to threaten someone with it? Do you believe you will safely store your weapon when not carrying it. EVERY time you take it off? Will you take the time to get the training to use the gun correctly, to hit your target every time, and most important, when NOT to draw it? All of these questions are ones no one but you can answer. And answer them you must, or do not carry to begin with.
I didn't realize those safety slugs were available . I'm guessing that the regular .357 ammo does not offer a hollow point option .
[[At the base, carrying a gun is not for everyone .... Will you take the time to get the training to use the gun correctly, to hit your target every time, and most important, when NOT to draw it? All of these questions are ones no one but you can answer. And answer them you must, or do not carry to begin with.]]
Good points .
Glazers are round-nosed to permit better feeding in semi-auto pistols.
As to .357 mag- they are available in round-nosed, Semi-wadcutter (tapers to a flat point) full wadcutter (flat the entore width of the round, primarily for target use) and hollowpoint- either fully jacketed, meaning no lead visible, and the bullet is copper clad or jacketed, lead HP- meaning an all-lead bullet with a hollow in the nose, and semi-jacketed HP- meaning the bullet has a copper jacket that comes about halfway to the tip, with lead showing and a hollow point.
They feed exellently in my 1911.
Another thing to consider with non-lethal projectiles...If the bad guy is armed with the real lethal projectiles and high on some kind of illegal drug substance. He is not going to let a little thing like a rubber bullet stop his rampage. No, imo rubber bullets would only piss him off.
There are well documented cases where the cops confront a suspect stoned to the gills. Some guys have been tasered as many as 17 times before giving up.
...
...
If I were confronted with a bad guy out to kill me I want to put him down, fast and for certain before he can do the same to me.
Personally, I prefer armed guards in our schools. Keep in mind, The lovely daughters of Obama attend a fancy private school that has ELEVEN armed security guards and will soon add another. Are your / our children any less deserving of protection?
Oh so true.