╌>

Bath, Michigan, what happened on May 18, 1927

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  leonahardware  •  14 years ago  •  30 comments

Bath, Michigan, what happened on May 18, 1927

Bath, Michigan, is a farming community about 5 miles north of East Lansing. In the coming weeks we may be hearing quite a bit about this little community and how it relates to the tragedy of what happened in Newtown, Connecticut.

Andrew Kehoe (a farmer, a husband, a member of the community of Bath, the school treasurer, and tinkerer), being very unhappy with high property taxes, the ongoing illnesses of his wife, and the lack of prosperity on his farm, chose to take his angst out on this small community.

Monty Ellsworth, a butcher in the community of Bath, at the time of the explosions, wrote a book detailing this tragedy. Interviewing some of the neighbors of Andrew Kehoe in the place where he grew up, this is what he wrote:

Andrew Kehoe's mother died when he was quite young, and in time, his father married again. Andrew didn't get along very well with his stepmother. One day she went to town and returned about meal time. She went to light her oil stove, but someone had tampered with it and it exploded, saturating her with oil, and set her on fire. Andrew stood and watched her burn for a while and then he got a pail of water and threw over her. It spread the flames and made them worse. His stepmother died from the effects. The fire was extinguished before it burned the house. Andrew was only about fourteen years of age at that time. Although there was never any trouble made about it, the neighbors whom the writer talked with were of the opinion that Andrew knew something about what was wrong with the stove.

What I've discovered in the reading that I've done on this sensitive subject, is that there was denial of any issues related to Andrew Kehoe and his odd behavior. He had what we would recognize now as a definite mental illness or a tendency towards violent behavior. He abused his animals, and (imo) was abusive to his wife (that may explain her long stays in the hospital). He had a very difficult time taking responsibility for his actions, instead blaming his financial problems on the high taxes, and exaggerating his financial woes by not working his farm efficiently.

In thinking of the current tragedy at Newtown, Connecticut, I think it's important that we keep in mind that this is not a recent phenomonon with regard to violent acts on a large scale. We can discuss gun control till we're blue in the face, but until we address the mental health issues that surround these acts, we won't change a damn thing.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

Lets discuss this without talk of gun control. What I want to focus on is the mental health aspect of this tragic event.

Also, I certainly don't want anyone to think that I am trying to make the tragedy of what happened in Newtown smaller by focusing on Bath. That is most certainly not my intention. My thoughts, prayers, and tears are directed towards those that lost loved ones in that horrendous, violent act perpetrated upon their community.

 
 
 
lilgremlin
Freshman Silent
link   lilgremlin    14 years ago

The mental health aspect of these incidents is definitely a touchy issue as well. Not every person who is mentally ill or has behavioral issues will act out in this manner. But there is simply not enough done as far as awareness and treatment options/availability for people with these types of illnesses. One article I read mentioned that some of the largest mental health service providers in the US were jails. What does that say about our priorities when the only way to get remotely adequate help is to first commit a crime?

Another thing we do not discuss when it comes to tragedies like this is the initial security of places like schools. Schools used to be built with windows that had wire screens built into the glass. These types of windows are much more difficult to break in through. Why was this school built without those types of windows? How many more schools out there have a similar weakness? Why also did only two teachers know to not only lock the classroom doors but also to barricade them with desk and chairs? There are defensive measures that can be taken that are not terribly expensive to implement. Why do we not?

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

From the Blue Review:

Three days before 20 year-old Adam Lanza killed his mother, then opened fire on a classroom full of Connecticut kindergartners, my 13-year old son Michael (name changed) missed his bus because he was wearing the wrong color pants.

I can wear these pants, he said, his tone increasingly belligerent, the black-hole pupils of his eyes swallowing the blue irises.

They are navy blue, I told him. Your schools dress code says black or khaki pants only.

They told me I could wear these, he insisted. Youre a stupid bitch. I can wear whatever pants I want to. This is America. I have rights!

You cant wear whatever pants you want to, I said, my tone affable, reasonable. And you definitely cannot call me a stupid bitch. Youre grounded from electronics for the rest of the day. Now get in the car, and I will take you to school.

I live with a son who is mentally ill. I love my son. But he terrifies me.

Many years ago, I had a neighbor that had a son that was much like this one. His parents tried very hard to get the help that he desprately needed. It all came to a climax when one day, he had strung his little brother up in a tree in a (fortunately) failed attempt to kill him. The parents (my friends) had to get very firm with the state authorities in order to get the help for him that he so badly needed. It was very apparent that he could no longer be in the home.The state, however, would not listen to their pleas until something bad happened.

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

Hi lilgremlin!

Good questions, all!

What does that say about our priorities when the only way to get remotely adequate help is to first commit a crime?

I just wanted to highlight that question in particular. There is an underlying belief that all is well until it's not well anymore. Sadly, sometimes even when things appear ok, they are far from it. I would have thought that we would be further along in our ability to identify those that are at risk of committing these crimes. But then again, would that infringe upon their right to live as they chose? (Not the killing of innocents, but the ability to be in the community while having a mental illness) Tough questions.

 
 
 
lilgremlin
Freshman Silent
link   lilgremlin    14 years ago

That was the article I had read leona. Thank you for adding it in here. It is not so much that every person with a mental illness or behavioral disorder is going to go on to a life of crime and bad behavior. Some do, some don't. When they do, the consequences are tragic. There should be a pro-active mechanism in place for families of children (or adults) who exhibit early signs of extreme negative behavior that have not yet commited a violent crime. It should provide behavioral/cognitive therapies that can hopefully divert them from violent paths before it is too late and someone gets hurt. Incarceration after the fact is a band-aid and heaven only knows how big the wound is by that time. Certainly in this case the wound is enormous.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I read that "Letter toAdam Lanza Mother", too. It really hit a chord with me, for so many reasons.

I have dealt with violent children as a teacher. I have often wondered how many learned to keep their violence at bay. But that wasn't Adam. Quite to the contrary, he was a very quiet child. He had aspergers. I now worry for all those children who have that classification, since people instinct is not to think but to judge. Most children with aspergers are not violent. They are the opposite. And most often they are picked on by their schoolmates, and areostracized.

Our laws make it hard for a doctor to do something. They are only allow to report if their patient is a danger to themselves or to others. The ones that are a danger to themselves, are under reported, since the dr isafraidto breakconfidentiality. The ones that are a danger to society, rarely say that. The dr has to be good enough to observe subtle clues. Most are not and those that do, are afraid to get involved.

You may wonder how I know so much about this? I have a nephew who has aspergers and have many mentally ill people in my family. It is still one of the least treated or misunderstood diseases out there. The buggyman of them all.

We may never know whyAdam Lanza did what he did. We may never what his mother did or didn't know. All of his thoughts he might have kept to himself. And that is the worst part of mental illness. We are never privy to their internal dialog, themachinationsof sick minds. And when I say sick, I mean it like sick with MS. Until we come to terms as a nation that this is something we need to get our hands messy with, none of this will change.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Loughtner and even Cho of the VA Tech shooting both showed anti-social behavior that should have sent bells and whistles and flags to everyone. But the privacy laws prevented them from being reported.

Very true. I am not sure if they were under the care of a dr or not. But our current mental health privacy laws and laws regarding committing people to mental health facilities, is a result of the abuses of the 1960's, when all it took was 2 family member to commit someone. That put a lot of people in institutions that shouldn't have been. We need to find a middle ground between both.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Just how would you "address the mental issues that surround these acts," particularly where there have been no crimes or behavior which defines a person as dangerous prior to the acts?

These people often express their desire to do these acts long before. It's called the "Road to Violence" As a society, we should be allowing families and mental health workers more liberal reporting. Watch this video from 11:00 on:

First, a clear thinker who isn't burdened by political obsessions would act to provide protection in the schools, and only after that consider all the ways that they can lock up, monitor, build data bases, or otherwise restrict the freedom of millions of Americans.

What is better protection of our schools? Treating them like prisons? This school like most schools had a lock down policy in place. It had taught their children what to do in case of an attack. Many of our High schools have metal detectors. Do you actually think that any of that would have stopped this guy. What next? Armed guards? How many? 2.. 3 .. why are we turning our schools into prisons?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Exactly. From the article:

She said those with Asperger's tend to focus on rules and be very law-abiding.

My nephew is loved by his teachers at school because he is such a good boy there.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Micky,

I agree with your sentiment here. I have also been very open about the fact that there has been a lot of mental illness in my family and it worries me, that once again, this will make it harder on the mentally ill. It worries me that it will make it harder with kids who have aspergers. I believe that there should be a level of privacy offered to those in treatment so that we don't end up back in the 1960's. This is not an easily answered question...

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

Hi Robert. Thank you for your comments.

Just how would you "address the mental issues that surround these acts," particularly where there have been no crimes or behavior which defines a person as dangerous prior to the acts?

As I mentioned in a comment above....

Many years ago, I had a neighbor that had a son that was much like this one. His parents tried very hard to get the help that he desprately needed. It all came to a climax when one day, he had strung his little brother up in a tree in a (fortunately) failed attempt to kill him. The parents (my friends) had to get very firm with the state authorities in order to get the help for him that he so badly needed. It was very apparent that he could no longer be in the home.The state, however, would not listen to their pleas until something bad happened.

In this case the parents recognized there was an issue with their child, and firmly took action to protect themselves and their other son. We don't know what the outcome would have been had they followed the advice of the 'professionals', but I can't imagine that it would be good.

Keep in mind that the political hacks who light up the boards in these discussion would define as "dangerous," anyone who doesn't agree with them.

Who are the 'political hacks' that you speak of? I know of passionate people that hold firmly to their beliefs, but I haven't recognized any 'political hacks' in this discussion.

Let me see if I totally understood this.....

First, a clear thinker who isn't burdened by political obsessions would act to provide protection in the schools, and only after that consider all the ways that they can lock up, monitor, build data bases, or otherwise restrict the freedom of millions of Americans.

It sounds as though you think this is how a 'clear thinker' would make sure this doesn't happen in the future.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

What does that mean? I asked that people complete the thought.(s) Apply this to the actual case. Tell me how a massive intrusion of state or government mental health care workers in the lives of millions would prevent THIS particular incident of mass murders. Tell me that you trust the judgement of "case workers."

Robert, let's reread my sentence:

we should be allowing families and mental health workers more liberal reporting.

Where did I say government or social workers?

You want a case, I will give you one. I knew a girl from my school days. She went through a terrible divorce. She was in therapy. She told her dr that she hadsuicidalthoughts. She told her twin sister who told her mother. They wanted the Dr to do something. His call was that it was a "cry for help" and refused to have her committed for an evaluation in aninstitution. Since she was under the care of a dr. the family and an adult, the family couldn't intervene. She ended up jumping off of the Throgs Neck bridge. Now you have an example of the problem with our current system. The family should be able to report when they see a problem, even if they are adults and being seen by professionals.

First question answered.

Would some of those children have been saved if some of the teachers or staff were armed?

Teachers? OMG. And if they miss and hit a kid instead? Now we are suppose to teach and be body guards, too? And the answer to that question is only maybe. There is noanecdotalevidence of this anywhere.

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

Hi Robert. Again thank you for your comments.

I think the issue goes beyond simple case workers. As I mentioned in a previous comment (again), my friends had to really fight with the state to get any help for their son. Why?

I think I should mention that I in no way have all of the answers. This is, I believe, a website to discuss those things that interest us, or have caught our attention. Maybe I missed the part where it says that we should have all of the answers in order to discuss. If I missed that, forgive me. If it's simply not there, well then, let's discuss the issue and not make comments like:

I asked that people complete the thought.(s)

Would some of those children have been saved if some of the teachers or staff were armed?

Please, not in this discussion. I really don't want the discussion to be about guns.

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

I'm so glad that you are commenting on this article.

Don't paint us all with the same brush

That is exactly why I want to talk about this.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Robert,

As per usual, you try to goad me by making comments meant to insult. When you can get a handle on the actual discussion, I will answer you.

BTW... I noticed that you had nothing to say about my actual situation. Not shocked. When nothing to say deflect to insults.

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

Well, if that's your view, you're welcome to it, but this discussion isn't about that.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

OK this is what I was talking about with our national problem dealing with the mentally ill and the problems going forward for families who have mentally ill family members:

Visit NBCNews.com for breaking news , world news , and news about the economy

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

Thank you Perrie for sharing this. Smile.gif

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

I know that we've been talking alot about mental illness and how it played a role in this tragedy, but I haven't really heard yet if Adam Lanza was truly mentally ill. I've been searching and simply can't find it reported anywhere from a reliable source. Can anyone help a girl out?

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

Bruce, Thank you so much for this link. So...basically what I can come up with as a mental health excuse for this tragedy, is close to zilch. Maybe we'll learn more as we learn more details?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

What do you mean "lost post". Did the system eat it?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Institutionalizing people with Asperger's?

OMG...how horrible. I have to agree with you Robert. That would be just total ignorance.

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    14 years ago

Good article, leona. Comments are illuminating, too. This is all so difficult to understand and there will never be clarity in our minds about such things. Trying to think it through to some meaningful answer just isn't as easy as just saying "it was the devil" or simply "lock them up".

"One of the painful things about our time is that those who feel certainty are stupid, and those with any imagination and understanding are filled with doubt and indecision." ~ Bertrand Russell

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

Thank you Grump!

I can appreciate that quote. Thank you for sharing itGrin.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

Thank you for sharingGrin.gif

I saw that story yesterday and thought about posting it, but then was distracted by something. I'm glad someone else saw it.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

Here's a report about copycat threats ... scary stuff :

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

That is scary, considering the media coverage this tragedy has received.

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  leonahardware    14 years ago

Hi Neetu! I think it's important to remember that, while we seek solutions, we are not the professionals or the law makers. We are not the doctors or the lawyers. We are simply people trying to understand what has happened, and trying to protect our feelings and our homes from the onslot that we know is coming. I think we can agree that there is a problem....and from our experiences we know that most problems have solutions. Wading through trying to find the solutions that would fit our individual realities is really difficult. Definately not a 'one size fits all' kind of issue.

Thinking of the mental health issues that we have in this country, I am reminded of an occurence that happened in my community in the not too distant past. Some of the story can be found here. During the investigation it was found that the woman wasseriously mentally ill (I forget all of the details, but I remember much of the conclusion), and had notreceived enough help for her illness. As far as I know, not much has changed with regard to how our communitytreats its mentally ill.

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    14 years ago

Neetu, yup. Pretty much that's the way it is. But, we can not lock people up for what they might do, can we? No, not at all. There is no test, there is no way to know what someone might do and we can only rely on their past behavior. Unfortunately, that one piece of behavior that defines them as dangerous to society might be devastating.

 
 

Who is online




Nerm_L


119 visitors