When There's a Heartbeat: Miscarriage Management in Catholic-Owned Hospitals
As Catholic-owned hospitals merge with or take over other facilities, they impose restrictions on reproductive health services, including abortion and contraceptive services. Our interviews with US obstetriciangynecologists working in Catholic-owned hospitals revealed that they are also restricted in managing miscarriages.
Catholic-owned hospital ethics committees denied approval of uterine evacuation while fetal heart tones were still present, forcing physicians to delay care or transport miscarrying patients to nonCatholic-owned facilities. Some physicians intentionally violated protocol because they felt patient safety was compromised.
Although Catholic doctrine officially deems abortion permissible to preserve the life of the woman, Catholic-owned hospital ethics committees differ in their interpretation of how much health risk constitutes a threat to a woman's life and therefore how much risk must be present before they approve the intervention.
Nontreatment, Delays, and Transport of Patients
Obstetriciangynecologists working in Catholic-owned hospitals described cases in which abortion was medically indicated according to their medical judgment but, because of the ethics committee's ruling, it was delayed until either fetal heartbeats ceased or the patient could be transported to another facility. Dr P, from a midwestern, mid-sized city, said that at her Catholic-owned hospital, approval for termination of pregnancy was rare if a fetal heartbeat was present (even in people who are bleeding, they're all the way dilated, and they're only 17 weeks) unless it looks like she's going to die if we don't do it.
In another case, Dr H, from the same Catholic-owned hospital in the Midwest, sent her patient by ambulance 90 miles to the nearest institution where the patient could have an abortion because the ethics committee refused to approve her case.
She was very early, 14 weeks. She came in and there was a hand sticking out of the cervix. Clearly the membranes had ruptured and she was trying to deliver . There was a heart rate, and [we called] the ethics committee, and they [said], Nope, can't do anything. So we had to send her to [the university hospital] . You know, these things don't happen that often, but from what I understand it, it's pretty clear. Even if mom is very sick, you know, potentially life threatening, can't do anything.
In residency, Dr P and Dr H had been taught to perform uterine evacuation or labor induction on patients during inevitable miscarriage whether fetal heart tones were present or not. In their new Catholic-owned hospital environment, such treatment was considered a prohibited abortion by the governing ethics committee because the fetus is still alive and the patient is not yet experiencing a life-threatening pathology such as sepsis. Physicians such as Dr H found that in some cases, transporting the patient to another hospital for dilation and curettage (D&C) was quicker and safer than waiting for the fetal heartbeat to stop while trying to stave off infection and excessive blood loss.
Dr B, an obstetriciangynecologist working in an academic medical center, described how a Catholic-owned hospital in her western urban area asked her to accept a patient who was already septic. When she received the request, she recommended that the physician from the Catholic-owned hospital perform a uterine aspiration there and not further risk the health of the woman by delaying her care with the transport.
Because the fetus was still alive, they wouldn't intervene. And she was hemorrhaging, and they called me and wanted to transport her, and I said, It sounds like she's unstable, and it sounds like you need to take care of her there. And I was on a recorded line, I reported them as an EMTALA [Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act] violation. And the physician [said], This isn't something that we can take care of. And I [said], Well, if I don't accept her, what are you going to do with her? [He answered], We'll put her on a floor [i.e., admit her to a bed in the hospital instead of keeping her in the emergency room]; we'll transfuse her as much as we can, and we'll just wait till the fetus dies.
READ MORE: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2636458/
Tags
Who is online
107 visitors

My son was born in a catholic hospital. They treated me very well. Of course I didn't have any problems either though.
I guess that means you can do what you want then.
Well I think that should be the ideal situation. I wouldn't want to go to a hospital that was only interested in saving one or the other. I personally would rather my baby be saved than me. I realize that choice is not for everyone, but it is my choice.
That's ok Robert! No problem. I mainly just wanted to state my opinion.
This is a tricky one for me Rescue as I have strong beliefs on this one. So I am only going to state how I feel and what I would probably do, not how someone else should feel and what they should do.
First of all I only consider it a miscarriage if the body gets rid of the baby. Otherwise it is an abortion in my eyes. In the above case where the baby is in the vagina, I'd say it was a miscarriage. The baby just hadn't come out all the way yet. The fact that there was a heartbeat saddens me though. In that case if it were me, I would ask them to take the baby out, and I would pray for a miracle. (I know a baby that young cannot survive. That is why I would pray for a miracle.
) I'm not trying to condone what this hospital did. I'm just saying that it should be left up to the mother to decide. Not the hospital. Now having said that, I still do not condone abortions. I just can't. Which brings me back to what I said earlier about how I would choose the baby's life over my own. I do not think a baby without a mother is a good thing at all. However, I believe when we are going to have a child it is our duty as a mother to protect that child. I would just have to trust that my family would do a good job of raising the child.
I'm going to your hospital!