Can sex between brothers and sisters ever be normal?
I really find this fascinating. Somehow, this psychiatrist is willing to take a stand with incest, but not other sexual "aberrations?"
Here's the director of the film "Yellow", a film about adult incest, speaking:
According to Cassavetes interview with The Wrap , I have no experience with incest . . . . We had heard a few stories where brothers and sisters were completely, absolutely in love with one another. You know what? This whole movie is about judgment, and lack of it, and doing what you want. Who gives a shit if people judge you? Im not saying this is an absolute but in a way, if youre not having kids who gives a damn? Love who you want. Isnt that what we say? Gay marriage love who you want? If its your brother or sister its super-weird, but if you look at it, youre not hurting anybody except every single person who freaks out because youre in love with one another.
Hmmm, sound familiar?
But, here's the doc.
With this declaration, Cassavetes misses an inherent reality about human beings and joins the ranks of those whose ignorance of psychological truth (thats right, truth, not flabby, toxic relativism and malignant narcissism) imperils our children under the guise of freeing them.
Heres the truth: When sisters and brothers have sex with one another they are not expressing genuine romantic love; they are expressing long-forged, pathologically fractured boundaries that existed in their family of origin. They are manifesting roots deep in soil that was fouled at some point. They are enacting a drama that is really about having grown up in a household or in households that unleashed inappropriate, toxic sexual impulsesalways, in my experience, because one or both of the siblings was exposed to child sexual abuse or was suffering with a severe mental illness.
Tell me, do you think what he has to say would be far off what others said fifty, 80 years ago re: homosexuals?
Moreover, if history is any help he may well be wrong.
An Incest taboo is any cultural rule or norm that prohibits practices of sexual relations between relatives. All human cultures have norms regarding who is considered suitable and unsuitable sexual or marriage partners, and usually certain close relatives are excluded as possible partners. Little agreement exists, however, among cultures about which types of blood relations are permissible partners and which are not. In many cultures, certain types of cousin relations are preferred as sexual and marital partners, whereas others are taboo . Sometimes relations between clan -members are excluded, even when no traceable genealogical relations exist, while members of other clans are permissible irrespective of the existence of blood ties. Many cultures allow sexual and marital relations between aunts/uncles and nephews/nieces. In some instances, brother-sister marriages have been practiced by the elites with some regularity
Is it a "cultural" thing? Should we be respective of other cultures? Is our culture any better than someone else's? (sound familiar?)
Moreover, the definition restricts itself to sexual intercourse; this does not mean that other forms of sexual contact do not occur, or are proscribed, or prescribed. For example, in some Inuit societies in the Arctic, and traditionally in Bali , mothers would routinely stroke the penises of their infant sons; such behavior was considered no more sexual than breast-feeding. [5] [6]
Interesting isn't it that as one barrier is pushed, torn down, then folks go after the next, and they will go after the next, and the next.
Until, there are no barriers, anything goes.
Consider that result? What would our society look like at that point?
Food for thought, has the "acceptance" of "alternative" lifestyles resulted in an overall societal negative?
I wonder if there are any sociologists, honest, objective, sociologists that have considered this issue.
A still from the film Yellow

Well, since I am here waiting for you to explain what you can't cut and paste.. I'll throw in my two cents.
You kind of mixing many things together in the same pot.
Sex between biological siblings is just wrong. It's a taboo because it makes bad biological sense. It often produces weak children and increase the risk of genetic disease. It didn't become a taboo for no reason, just as incest is ( defined as parent/child... which is also very mentally damaging). There have been cases where adopted children have gotten married. I guess I personally find it odd, since to me, unless they were much older when they were adopted, the parents did something wrong in raising these kids.
Mixing homosexuality into this is odd. Gay peopleexist. Gay men are gay by their biology. This is who they are, and can't be changed any more than you can change the color of your skin. Therefore, isn't an aberrant behavior, like incest, but who they are at the core of their DNA andoccursin all animals in nature. It is not even close to the sociological weirdness of incest.
As for this being passed of as "Falling in love", I think that's nuts.
As tosocietalbarriers, I think some tend to evolve and others are there to protect the species.
You are one sick puppy, but that was funny, have to admit!
Perrie:
Maybe three hundred years ago, I don't think that holds up really now given the disparity of the gene pool. Got a link?
Not proven with certitude. Even if it were, many would think that one is "fated" to love the one they love.
Are you sure that is just not your prudishness speaking? Come on, as noted in the Wiki article, been happening forever. Some cultures more than others. Are you saying that such cultures are wrong in that?
No one seems to address the more important issue, eh?
The thing about incest....it's all relative.
Anyways, I know I read years ago that children of incest only stand a 1% increase in their chances of being gifted with birth defects. I think alot of the hubbub comes from repeated ancestral incest. At that point, the gene pool has no choice but to weaken.
At least, that's what I tell myself at night, because:
The closer the kin, the deeper it goes in...
Basically, what I'm saying is it's relatively no big deal
*Badadum!*
Yup! It's so much easier when you go straight to the science of this:
I find that last part of the comment very interesting. Although they are saying that it is unhealthy, we have to take culture into consideration. Isn't that where you were going?
You should buy this book. It keeps Matt working, LOL!
Terry, you have to read my posts from last week. MRI studies clearly show remarkable difference is brain structure in Gay men from straight men. MRI's don't lie. I don't understand the last part of your comment about being fated to love.
Not at all. And just because it has been happening forever doesn't mean that it's healthy. But as I implied earlier on, I could understand adopted brother and sister getting married, especially if they were adopted at an older age.
No. I get it. You want to know if we havedescendedinto an anything goes society. It's not an easy question to answer. We are a global society now, so we get introduced to many other cultures. There is going to be some cross over. Whether this is good or bad, only time will tell.
Spot on about psychiatry,Feronia. I have dealt with the truly mentally ill, and making up new conditions to justify bad behavior, is just more PC crap.
Sure it's "normal" if you're a pagan.
Anything is normal for pagans.
Bioethics Prof. Peter Singer of Princeton considers sex between humans and animals (bestiality) all right; more moral than eating them.
...
But Rick Santorum was condemned for predicting that homosexual marriage would lead to other sexual aberrations.
One is a behavior and the other is a state of being. Homosexuals are different biologically. Their brains are constructed differently thanheterosexualbrains. It would be like asking a person to change colors. They can't.
Oursocietyhas a long list of things that I don't like. I you can't blame them all on gay marriage, for goodness sake. They are people. They are here. This is how they were put together.
Mike,
The above situation is just nutty from the get go and should have never been allowed to happen. But it is hardly an excuse against gay marriage. And it is so wrong to say that the LGBT community wants incest. You can't even back up that silly claim.
I think it is valid to say that the LGBT community wants far more variety of all types in the sexual expressions of society .
That is because Santorum is a homophobic religious nutjob jackass.
So do straights. Everybody wants more variety.
I just watched a video recently where a chimp had sex with a frog.
[[So do straights. Everybody wants more variety.]]
I can't speak for all straights but I want less variety .
Less variety? I honestly cant conceive of that, because, as a single man, less variety equates to what? Honest question.
[[less variety equates to what?]]
Less STDs . Honest answer .
How many do you have?!?
None ... and I want to keep it that way . When I was a lot younger I went out with someone who later contracted herpes when she briefly went back to her ex . There is still no cure for herpes . That was a close call ...
Okay. You said she contracted herpes AFTER you dated her, which doesnt qualify as a close call since you were never at risk.
I guess a person could shut themselves away from the rest of the world, but otherwise, there is always risk regardless of what you are doing or where you are doing it. That applies to everything in life. In your example, you were freaked out by an STD that is contracted by kissing somebody BEFORE they happened to have contracted an STD. Think about that. That is what I call unreasonable fear.
So, what does a single man do to avoid STD's aside from stay single and die lonely? Honest question.
Homosexuality was a taboo ( in some cultures) out of ignorance. No one knew that gay men.(and notice I say men, since the gay brainstructurehas only been shown in men). We know better now. You know there was a time when blacks were thought to have sub-parintelligence, too. Ignorance is no excuse for what you are uncomfortable with.
We already know how polygamy went over in this country. And while we are talking about it, how about the fact thatmarriageis supposed to be a value, yet daily, people step out on their mates. Acceptable?
Just so over the top and not a clue to the fact that it has nothing to do with being gay and everything to do with the need to dominate. And implying that gays want that is totally unreal.
I agree with Perrie here. Using logical fallacies and over the top imaginary scenarios to argue a real world point dont work well. They are funny, but have no credibility as it pertains to the topic at hand.
Even if homosexuality is biological, and that is arguable, it does not follow that it should be normalized by legal marriage.
People have all kinds of inborn urges that may be harmful to society. Jews traditionally refer to such as an "evil inclination." This fact was evidentover 5000 years ago because the Bible reports God telling Adam's son, Cain:
Sin crouches at the door; its urge is towards you, yet you *can* be its master (Gen. 4:7). That homosexuality is sinful is clear from Lev. ch.18, onabhorrent relationships including both incest and homosexuality,which is read publiclyin synagogues on Yom Kippur, as well being a cause of God's destruction of Sodom.
Lev. Ch. 18 ends with the admonition:
But you must--- not do any of those abhorrent things, neither the citizen nor the stranger who resides among you, for all those abhorrent things were done by the people who were in the land before you, and the land became defiled. So let not the land spew you out for defiling it, as it spewed out the nation that came before you. (Lev. 18:27-28)
Yeah, that whole post is crap. Simply ridiculous, fearful, misinformed bullshit. In fact, here is a tribute to the post in question:
Taxpayer dollars is the least of it, though that is the best argument in Massachusetts. It is normalizing abnormality.
Or as NY Democratic Senator Pat Moynihan said, "We are defining deviency downward."
That's an excellent question . All I can say with certainty is that there is no cure for viruses once you have already contracted them . And even the vaccines to prevent them are not in the offing [with one minor exception , HPV ] .
BTW , if that girl had not revealed to me that she had contracted herpes [I took her out one more time] I would have contracted it too .
It is true that once you contract an STD, you are fairly screwed, and not in a good way. However, you really only have two choices....celibacy or sexuality. To an extent, you always are playing the odds, whether walking down the street or having a sexual encounter. The odds are always stacked heavily in your favor, but there is always an element of risk in everything we do.
It is up to the individual to determine what degree of risk is acceptable to them and interact the best way they can with the world around them. Fair enough?
Len,
This isn't an impulse. It is how they are made. I assume you like woman. Do you think that something can make you change that? And by calling it an evil inclination, is calling gays evil, which is pretty nasty. You think anyone wants to be gay? Just look at those words and know that the answer is no. I know too many gays to know that they wish that they were not gay, and they are not evil.
And a 5000 year old text has no relevance to what we now know. They had no MRI's. They were going on by what they felt they understood. What the majority of people were. Is the Curse of Ham relevant? Is it a curse to be black? Wool and linen blends a problem, too?
Alleged deviancy is a matter of interpretation. The less attached you are to bullshit ideology, the more you realize that many things that are considered deviant really arent. They are simply devices used to push you in whatever direction your masters see fit...and like good little sheep, you follow.
Len,
You are using the words normal anddeviancyasinterchangeableand they are not.
Perrie, you should know that just like Jews are hated for "killing Christ", women are hated for the "original sin" and ejection from Eden. You really cant rationalize with religious whack jobs. That is why I prefer mocking them instead.
You now what gets between your mother and your sister? Your sheep.
It's more complicated when your sister IS the sheep....
Taboos eroding. That is true.
However, I dont watch Showtime personally.
Not "normal and deviency:" abnormal and deviency!
They are not exact synonyms but it is fair to say thatboth words apply to homosexuality and incest; though gayactivists would violently disagree.
A census taker comes to a door of a home when he hears sounds from the back yard. He goes into the back yard only to see a woman having nooky with a sheep. Horrified, he goes to the front door and rings the door bell and is greeted by a young boy. The census taker asks the boy if that is his mom in the back yard and the boy shakes his head yes. Then he asked "Doesn't what your mom is doing bother you?" to which the boy says "Naaaahhhhh".
I think Mike has brought up a significant fact that needs to be addressed .
I can't believe you just called gaysdeviants and put it on a par with incest. OMG, I am speechless.
You should watch "Sister Wives". Quite enlightening.
okay, this is interesting. ofcourse the sex incest relationship is abnormal. but according to the confession from a source I read ... actually, It does more enjoyable and could be emerging a great sensation of it! mmm so delightful, that's what people said.
Good grief hestamdi ... what does Islam say about this practice ?
I'm not. I can tell that Len brings ONLY this type of intellectual and moral b.s. to the table. "They are not exact synonyms but it is fair to say that both words apply to homosexuality and incest; though gay activists would violently disagree." Actually, it isnt "fair" to say and is both dishonest and disingenuous. Anybody who thinks otherwise is an "activist"? Yeah, it's really the opposite...you are an "activist" with an evil and immoral view of things. It's the type of thought process that leads to beating your wife and kicking your dog as well. Pathetic.
Seems to me that the studies (without having read the book) are conducted in highly endogamous groups, which have been that way for some time so OF COURSE the gene pool is already highly inbred.
Well, seriously, my real question went a bit deeper. I really don't care what others do, have never really cared what individuals do in their private lives as long as their fist does not meet my nose.
But I do find it interesting on a societal level that, without research and just from the view point of a person that has lived through the fifties, to today and has kept abreast of most events, that as we turn into an "anything" goes society, our strength, cohesion, productivity, all fall.
In short, our Country becomes weaker, and weaker.
Is there a correlation? Don't know, but it would seem to be so.
Singer also is one of the few pro abortion writers/professors who has some consistency. At least he admits that there really is no difference between a fetus at 23 weeks or so and a baby, born, or even an older child who cannot care for itself.
This is the slippery slope. Don't know if it is the result of "homosexual marriage", for I don't think that. Instead, I think it is slowly becoming societal, if X is not wrong, then how can one logically and consistently say Y is?
That's the issue, and is the issue with bestiality as well, as it is with pedophilia (which some docs are now saying may have a "genetic" component to it!)
Not proven, not proven by a long shot Perrie.
What about pedophilia, some docs are now saying that has a genetic component. Is that now analogous to homosexuality and, thus, okay?
As I stated, it is a question. I think that the homosexual "link" has been more of a construct created BECAUSE those doing the research wish for the result to be what they find!
It's a greater issue, however.
Rag on that statement all you wish, but there is truth in what Len says. Many believe that those who are violent are that way because of genetics. Does that mean they should be allowed to be violent or, as Len suggests, they should have to stifle their "genetic predisposition?"
Your "mocking" is, in fact, showing your ignorance.
The science is not in as to what Perrie, or you I assume, are postulating.
And even if it is correct, consider the science on other "abnormalities" (for no matter what anyone says, homosexuality on a societal scale is an abnormality) and their genetic bases?
Does any abnormality get a pass because it has a genetic basis? Because that person is "born" that way?
Seems odd, especially if that abnormality is something you would disagree with, eh?
That's Mike's, and my point. You say it's "nutty," but it is clearly NOT! In fact, it is so NOT nutty, that a judge has ordered you and me to pay for it?
He's not saying the LGBT community wants incest. What he's saying, is just where does it stop?
You have drawn an arbitrary line in the sand, while we all know now that arbitrary lines have no meaning in this society.
How about find a woman who is disease free, that you love, and the two of you don't have sex with others outside of the marriage?
Or, a good looking german shephard, whatever, eh?
Perrie, as we have discussed, and there was an article I posted, there is more and more evidence being aggregated that pedophilia is, in fact, genetically based.
What happens if that becomes a fact?
YOU say they are "over the top," and I bet 80 years ago someone saying homosexual marriage would be approved of was "over the top."
You are merely commenting from a very limited construct so as not to have to address the issue.
Or the show "The New Normal"
Folks just have their own sacred cows that they wish to remain sacred,
but once any SACRED cow is taken down, ALL of them are at risk.
Why would you say that? "pedophilia" was for centuries an accepted sexual outlet. Why do you think such won't come back?
I find it fascinating that so many are really closing their eyes on this one.
Huh, I would suspect that "definitional" issue is bullshit.
So, what the hell is "pedophilia? Under 11? As I said, they are merely trying to get around the issue through definition.
Interesting article, by the way.
Very true. Many try to assert that such acts aren't "deviant" because they are genetically based. Thus, somehow, they are "normal." Of course, under the definition of "deviant" (in a statistical sense) there is no doubt but that they are "deviant."
When reviewed through a morality glass, that is the issue we are discussing, eh?
Huh, statistically homosexuality is, in fact, "deviant." How can you dispute that?
As to whether it's on a par with incest, that's what we are discussing, right?
[[Why do you think such won't come back?]]
The answer to your question is possibly the increase in STDs .