╌>

Chicago Teachers Union Willing to Screw the Kids - What Else is New?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jonathan-p  •  14 years ago  •  51 comments

Chicago Teachers Union Willing to Screw the Kids - What Else is New?

We've been aware of it for more than 30 years; America is falling behind because we don't educate our children to the degree that we need to. We can't compete in the world as we used to, because other nations get it. They place their kids first in education.

Chicago is not unique, but the timing is not opportune. The city offered them enough money, keeping the teachers of Chicago amongst the most highly compensated in the nation. But there's more;the teachers don't want to be held accountable for the quality of their product. They won't go back to work if they have to be judged on how well they do their job. Ain't life grand, when you can mail it in for 30-plus years, and collect your nice fat pension? And if the kids aren't equipped to pass high school or college, so what? "I want mine", they declare, and the union is only too happy to accomodate them.

The President sits in favor of both sides. Huh? Well, he's got 2 of his buddies in the ruling body of Chicago, including Mayor Rahm Emanuel, former Cheif of Staff. So he's supporting them, right? Oh, but ifhe's supporting them, how can he also support the union? That's the body that stands at odds with the city. Can you support the union AND the mayor at the same time. I have a feeling someone's going to explain to me how you can. Hhhhhmmmm, should be entertaining.

So, we are creating another generation of Americans who will no doubt need to rely on the government for their subsistence. Rather than correct a system that benefits everyone but the kids, we pour more aid in for those who don'tstrive for excellence, and create the opportunity to burden our Federal budgetwith more welfare for the soon-to-be undereducated.At lease the teachers will be happy. After all, that's what's most important.

Right?

Right?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

The new system would eventually use students' standardized test scores as 40 percent of a teacher's yearly evaluation. Teachers who don't improve their students' test scores would be fired.

Union supporters argue that evaluating teachers using tests can be tricky, and that this "value-added" measurement can be volatile and inaccurate. Additionally, teachers who have a high proportion of poor students may have a harder time lifting their kids' scores than teachers who work in affluent districts. (About 80 percent of Chicago students qualify for free or reduced federal lunches.) As many as 6,000 teachers would wrongly lose their jobs under the system, says Chicago Teachers Union (CTU) President Karen Lewis. "Evaluate us on what we do, not the lives of our children we do not control," she said while announcing the strike, according to Reuters .

Jonathan,

As a retired inner city teacher (Oceanhill-Brownsville, Brooklyn) I have to tell you, that although I am very much for teacher evaluations, test scores alone is not a fair way to judge performance. Do you know if their classes areheterogeneouslygrouped orhomogeneouslygrouped? If the arehomogeneouslygrouped, as a teacher you can end up with a bottom class, and they will never improve. That is the ugly fact of life. When I sent these kids out for evaluation to our team, out of a class of 30, I would get anywhere from 15-20 of them that were evaluated as having borderline "normal"intelligence, and either need full out special ed, (but we didn't have the budget for it) or resource room. Their test scores never improved as they could not retain the information.

Test scores alone don't give the full picture of a teachers job. There should be pop in active teacherevaluation, lesson plan evaluation, and test evaluation. I have no problem with getting rid of a bum teacher, and they are out there, but to do it by test score alone, isn't fair.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    14 years ago

Perrie,

While I agree with what you're saying, this should not be a bridge of this proportion to gap.

The simplest thing to do is evaluate them for 3-5 years, establishing rolling performance data. This would subject the data to less extreme fluctuation, while making it possible to predict demographic trends on a district-by-district basis. As you copied yourself from the Yahoo article, test scores only account for 40% of the performance measurment anyway.

John,

When we attempt to develop a system that everyone agrees upon, we end up with a rather diluted effect. You cannot make everyone happy; but, if you foces on the success of the children, there is no doubt as to who will come out on top.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    14 years ago

Hey J(a),

Your posts do identify a certain strata of the student body, but I'd have to say a minority of that body. When measuring the success of a teacher, what they seek to measure should not be ABSOLUTE results, but COMPARATIVE results, and there can be no basis of comparison until they BEGIN measuring those results. Furthermore, measuring from year to year is not a useful measure of performance; if they could institute measures for rolling 3 year performance, the data can be helpful in measuring a variety of trends - not just teacher performance.

We do this in private sector in order to remain competetive. The time is long overdue to be competetive in the education system, because we're competing with the entire world, and THEY'RE not compromising, are they?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

The proof is in the pudding; our kids have been falling far behind for a while now. If the American public education system was handled like any otherbusiness, it would have been revamped years ago; instead, we have allowed politics andgreed to hinder our own children's/country's future. It's our fault as parents, educators, and public officials. We should be ashamed. We shouldmake gettingour educational systemon track a top,top priority.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    14 years ago

Assuming that you teach in the same neighborhood to the same grade, you absolutely can measure those results. And, as stated before, if you use a composite of rolling instead of single years, you can glean lots of useful information.

The tests are in fact not being used as the only benchmark. The particulare proposal for Chicago only attributes 40% of the perfomance metric to the tests.

J(a), right now there is NO criteria for competence in the school system. There are teachers who hide in the system for decades, cheating our children. They have de facto tenure, and they're not worth a damn. There are young, energetic men and women who are fresh out of college, armed with a greater desire and competence to do the work. Part of doing a better job is knowing that you have a standard to live up to. There is no such standard today.

None.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    14 years ago

Correct, John.

And, as such, they will most definitely be judged accordingly. If a neighborhood 4th grade has a high rate of failure, they will be judged differently than a magnet school. But there has to be some kind of measure of success.

My point is this:

If a school is in a war zone, the test results will show that, and the municipality will know that there are other measures needed to improve the NEIGHBORHOOD, so that in a given period of time, they will help the SCHOOL to do what it needs to do to improve. There's always the need for an efficient manner of providing services to a community. If the community if given the right attention, the residents of the community, in increasing numbers, will respond positively to that attention, INCLUDING giving greater attention to education.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I totally agree Larry. But it is a very complex problem. The fix isn't just test scores, it's many more factors than that. Environment, the system itself, the teachers, the administration, the parents and the students which are an unknown factor. To fix the system is to evaluate all of this.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Jonathan P,

You keep talking about rolling years. Well I taught bottom 4th grade for 3 years in a row, before they gave me a top 4th. My ratings would have stunk. But then it was followed by 3 years of top 4ths and my numbers would have looked wonderful. I didn't do a darn thing different. It was the factor X, the students ( and please add in there the lack of a home system) that made the difference. There is more to teacher performance then just tests. Their needs to be these other evaluations. When a business sees a performance problem, they do an analysis of why. If quotas are not met, they look into if it is amanagementproblem or a warehouse problem. They just don't look at the numbers and start chopping off heads.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

True.

That's what I mean byIt's our fault as parents, educators, and public officials. Fixing our educationalapparatus has got to be a top 3 priority; it is the solution to our energy crisis as well, part of the reason I think it is extremely important to fix it.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Agreed!

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    14 years ago

When a business sees a performance problem, they do an analysis of why

How do they know they have a problem? They look at results. How do they look at results? THEY MEASURE PERFORMANCE. If it's not the teachers' fault, it's not their fault. I agree. I agree. I agree.

But they still have to have their performance measured. And again, it's not the only measure proposed.

I understand the need for fairness; nothing is worse than being blamed for something that's not your fault. But there's too much protection for teachers, and not enough for the children, and by bending over backwards to make sure that each and every teacher is protected from some inefficiency in a rating system, we ignore the children a little bit more, and the problem of subpar teaching perpetuates. That's my point. We can't afford to protect inferior teachers under the auspices of "it's not their fault", because these protections insulate them from any form of criticism. There is no responsibility being assigned to the teachers for our continued slide as a nation. When we stop protecting them, we'll figure out who deserves protection, and why.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Love theexplanation, LOL

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Jon,

I don't disagree with you that we shouldn't be protecting subpar teachers. They are a disgrace to the profession. But maybe the issue here is using tests as the unit of measure. It is an incomplete picture, no matter how they would like to say no. What I am saying is what needs to be put on the table at negotiations is 3 factors, tests,surprisein class teacher evaluations, and lesson plans. That provides a full spectrum of a teacher's performance. And the union shouldn't have a problem with that.

I am all for getting rid of the dead wood, but I am not for burning the house down.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Quite simply, you can't "fix" this issue until you "fix" the parental side of the equation.

Period, end of story. Note, it's not OUR fault as parents, it is the fault of the parents of the under-performing students.

When you have parents who not only fail to motivate their children to learn, become engaged in school but, many times, actually seek to demotivate them, you have issues.

So, in many city schools we are paying folks $100k or more a year to be babysitters for 6 hours a day, nine months a year.

Sound worthwhile to you?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Well Terry, you won't get a lot a flack from me on that topic. When I had a bottom class, on open school night, I would be lucky if 6 or 8 parents would show up (despite the fact that I always had cake and coffee for the parents).

When I had a top class, Open School Night I had a full house and not enough cake or coffee.

And there is the difference.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Spend an hour in an inner city school ...

... if you can last that long.

Jonathan, you may possibly understand the following analogy ...

"Making bricks without straw."

The disparity in the lives of school children is wide ... children coming to school from homes in which there are no books, illiterate or semi-literate parents, drug and alcohol use, violence ... they enter 35-40 at-a-time into classrooms.

Walk a mile in a teacher's shoes ... then compare the test scores of the students whose teachers made bricks with and without straw.

Test scores as a sole means of accountability is arbitrary.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    14 years ago

When's everyone going to stop talking about the worst classes and the best classes in the system?

When's anyone going to acknowledge that there's a large majority of students that fall into the "average" category?

Can we just dance around this for another 30-40 comments, so as not to address a major factor in the education of our children - THE TEACHERS???

Or do we just get to talk about the "impoverished masses" of children, as if they make up the lion's share of our young population?

Anyone wanna take a shot?

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    14 years ago

AMac,

What percentage of our school children fall into this category?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Can we just dance around this for another 30-40 comments, so as not to address a major factor in the education of our children - THE TEACHERS???

Other than the demagoguery orchestrated by right-wing politicians, private and parochial schools looking for voucher money, charter schools (public money) and home schoolers, what DIRECT EXPERIENCE do you have that makes you castigate teachers in general?

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    14 years ago

I'm so naive.

I wrote an article, staying as close to the facts as I could, without inserting a political bias. I was just attempting to forge a discussion about the PROBLEM, and see if we could find a grain of an idea.

And we almost made it, didn't we?

The direct experience I have is that of being a parent to 3 children who attended schools.

My wife is a schoolteacher.

We socialize with a number of teachers.

I am acquainted with people on my city council.

I am acquainted with a union official.

I think that's just about every angle, AMac.

The good teachers know who the good teachers are. They know who the bad teachers are. The local city council knows who the good and lousy teachers are. Hell, even the union rep knows who the good and lousy teachers are.

It's unanimous, AMac. No one wants to fire teachers, no matter how incompetent they are, because it will "upset the apple cart". The inertia monster strikes again.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Jonathan,

If you're asking the question you lack the empirical information to come to any definitive conclusion.

One violent, disruptive student can divert an entire class from a learning environment to a keep-the-lid-on-first environment. Public school systems often reduce standards for promotion to keep rolls down ... to save money ... then, as kids go through the system with deficiencies, teachers receiving them, say, in 8th grade, are expected to teach reading and math at the 8th grade level, to kids who have 2nd grade skill levels!

The only ones making noise about this fraud, are teachers and their unions.

And still, most inner city public schools still succeed with the majority of students.

In 1978, I was teaching biology and general science in Philly's junior high schools ... the school district had a "promotion policy" -- pass 2 majors and 2 minors and you're promoted! So, pass Social Studies and Science (2 majors), Gym and Hygiene (2 minors) ... and you're promoted.

Translation ... fail English, Reading and Math ... (the other three majors) ... promoted!

After eleven years of teaching under such conditions, I took it upon myself to write letters-to-the-editor when Philly had two major newspapers. One newspaper (The Philadelpha Inquirer) wouldn't touch my letters, but the other (The Philadelphia Bulletin) ran every one and eventually gave me an intermittently-appearing column.

I caught hell from the School District of Philadelphia ... my first editorial ran with the headline ... "WHEN GRADUATION IS A FRAUD!" I was force transferred from my school ... but they couldn't fire me because my union contract guaranteed a "due process" and the district knew the newspaper would rip the district apart!

I went on Philly talk radio (WWDB-FM) and at first (before I started with the Bulletin), appeared as "Mr. X"! Once the editorials started (written under my real name), I appeared many times on talk radio, also under my real name.

The District made nice ... although it would not overturn my transfer ... and the bullshit "promotion policy" continued.

In recent years, local papers here run stories regularly about administrative cover-ups of school violence ...

I'll see if I can find you some links.

"Bricks without straw" -- and be held accountable for the brick tally and quality.

You haven't been there and you really don't know.

...

...

...

Do a Google search ... see for yourself.

Here's one for you.

The School District of Philadelphia refused to pay Workers Compensation at 100% salary for teachers physically disabled while breaking up a student fight. The District said that it was no different from an "injury" on the job which paid only a fraction of the salary for a teacher disabled by a fall, etc..

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    14 years ago

So we still can't discuss the majority, can we?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

And the school districts will sometimes manipulate/falsify the statistics ... surreptitiously "directing" teachers to teach-to-the-test who risk insubordination charges if they don't comply.

And there are more overt indiscretions.

BRICKS WITHOUT STRAW>

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

The good teachers know who the good teachers are. They know who the bad teachers are. The local city council knows who the good and lousy teachers are. Hell, even the union rep knows who the good and lousy teachers are.

And teachers can be fired (even tenured teachers) as long as there is due process and the burden of proof is satisfied; such cases sometimes go to arbitration which is binding.

How 'bout incompetent city council members? They get to hang around until the next election ... or three.

It's unanimous, AMac. No one wants to fire teachers, no matter how incompetent they are, because it will "upset the apple cart". The inertia monster strikes again.

That's inaccurate ... a generalization, and, as I just explained, not true.

I told the truth and you decided it was "political bias." You're not biased?

I'm guessing your wife does not teach in an inner city school ...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

If you can define and identify with demographic certainty, "the majority," we can discuss it.

You seem to believe that the majority of public school teachers are incompetent (unless I read you wrong). If that's where we start the discussion, you're then not qualified to be a viable contributor to the discussion.

And if you think you can have a realistic discussion about public education without bring in the political implications, you are naive.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    14 years ago

AMac,

My point is that everyone is complicit in the perpetuation of this mess.

I told the truth and you decided it was "political bias." You're not biased?

My bias liesin favor ofthe children, who are apparently GROSSLY underrepresented in this debate. When you make statements like

Other than the demagoguery orchestrated by right-wing politicians

you don't display a full willingness to address the problem, as you expend energy to take a pot shot at HALF the political problem. Clearly, credit belongs EVERYWHERE in this mess.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    14 years ago

I don't know where you got the impression that I believe a majority of public school teachers are incompetent. Perhaps you can point out where you acquired your opinion.

I began the discussion as the defender of the children. The first line of defense is in the home. We cannot regulate the quantity or quality of childrearing; therefore, the additional burden is placed on the NEXT line of defense, which is the teaching corp. This CAN be regulated and monitored. It's THAT important. Base on that, I was attempting to initiate a discussion based upon that. I know that politicians mismanage the situation. I know the unions mismanage the situation. I'm not attempting to lay blame, as everyone is responsible. I'd just like to see the kids get a better deal, and it seems like a long way off.

We'll never catch South Korea, for sure. I'd like to see us climb the ladder to a more respectable level, given our alleged resources.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Jonathan wrote,

you don't display a full willingness to address the problem, as you expend energy to take a pot shot at HALF the political problem. Clearly, credit belongs EVERYWHERE in this mess

Did you miss the part where I risked my job and took on a major school district for its fraudulent promotion policy?

My point is that everyone is complicit in the perpetuation of this mess.

Of course the blame goes across the spectrum ... but it's the teachers who catch all the hell and bad press and attacks from politicians (often politicians whose family members and contributors run CHARTER SCHOOLS)! Another post I'll tell you about the Governor of Pennsylvania and his finger in the charter school money pie.

My bias liesin favor ofthe children, who are apparently GROSSLY underrepresented in

Everyone who thinks he knows where to lay the blame says that ... INCLUDING SOME REAL TEACHERS' UNION HYPOCRITE "LEADERS" -- that's another story I could tell.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

I don't know where you got the impression that I believe a majority of public school teachers are incompetent. Perhaps you can point out where you acquired your opinion.

What's your article's headline, Jonathan?

Chicago Teachers Union Willing to Screw the Kids - What Else is New?

The Chicago Teachers' strike at this time is both ill-advised but possibly a strategic necessity.

We cannot regulate the quantity or quality of childrearing; therefore, the additional burden is placed on the NEXT line of defense, which is the teaching corp. This CAN be regulated and monitored.

Parenting ... good, bad or indifferent usually involves 1-4 children ... show me a public school teacher with a class of 1-4 children. Teaching is not parenting and to hold a teacher accountable for someone else's bad parenting is rather unfair and unrealistic.

I'd just like to see the kids get a better deal, and it seems like a long way off.

We'll never catch South Korea, for sure. I'd like to see us climb the ladder to a more respectable level, given our alleged resources.

So would I ... the priorities of this country and those of many so-called "parents" is a huge problem ... maybe insurmountable.

I mean you no disrespect, Jonathan ... this is a hot topic and I've been fighting both school administrators AND UNIONS for reasons on which you and I agree.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    14 years ago

I have to say that the work stoppage is a major irritant, especially since they were negotiating, and both sides admitted that they had made great progress. If they're being honest about that, I can't see why the stoppage was necessary. They can't be endearing themselves to the public with this move. G-d knows the parents are pissed.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    14 years ago

Hi Perrie,

You said "40 percent." That is not using test scores exclusively.

The Wall Street Journal pointed out that, according to the union's own figures, the average Chicago public school teacher makes $71,000/year PLUS pensions and benefits worth at least $15,000 more. That comes out to $86,000.

The median Chicago household income in the private economy is $47,000.

The city offered 16 percentover four years but the union is striking for 29 percent.

Chicago schools are among the worst in the nation with a graduation rate of 55%. Only 6% of these children get college degrees -- 3% of black and Hispanicstudents.

President Obama, who spoke out for the Wisconsin teachers before it became evident that the governor would win the recall election, is voting "Present" on this one.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

Ok, I can hang with ya on that wmolaw,,,not all the parents, just the loser parents that don't give a shit. I also agree that is part of the equation that can't just be "fixed". That will never change.

There used to be a time when communities and neighborhoods were so close-knit that children in need many times were taken in or helped with their circumstance. Not by the government or any official entity, but by our own concerned citizens.There still are people places like that.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

There should be warnings, then fines when the parents of chronically disruptive student raise hell in a public school. Private and parochial and charter schools can boot them ... and where do they land ... in the public schools!

This should be done with clear protocols and good judgement; some students have serious emotional problems and home situations that defy repair; but other students and other homes can be shown the handwriting-on-the-wall.

It ain't like the old days; these days, a parent entering a school building and assaulting school employees, vandalizing their cars and/or making terroristic threats ... is fairly common.

And those who believe that schools must be responsible for filling the gaps created by bad parenting, cannot reasonably be vocal against providing resources to satisfy that objective.

When politicians try to lay the ills of a society on teachers ... that's bullshit. I proposed the following when going up against Philly's public school administration -- one that has been proven to cover up and mis-report incidents of violence and vandalism ... as follows:

1) On a monthly basis, school employees should record all incidents of assault, terroristic threats, rape (yes, rape!), theft, vandalism, weapons, etc., and send these to a designated neutral party ... not school administration/not teachers' union.

2) These statistics should be published full-page in the local newspapers and on-line, broken down by schools AND BY THE CITY COUNCIL AND STATE LEGISLATIVE DISTRICTS IN WHICH THOSE SCHOOLS ARE LOCATED.

Surprise ... no takers. I got it out on radio talk shows, but the major news outlets wouldn't touch it.

The reason ... many of these politicians rail against the public schools and teachers, have not the political balls to call out bad parenting, AND OFTEN ARE INVOLVED WITH CHARTER SCHOOLS IN WHICH THEIR FAMILY MEMBERS AND CAMPAIGN DONORS HAVE FINANCIAL INTERESTS OR JOBS!

In 1978 and after, I went public with the dishonest promotion and other policies of the School District of Philadelphia WHILE I WAS A TEACHER IN THAT DISTRICT! (Somewhere in this thread are some of those details). In my teaching career in Philly public schools, I broke up many a fight, disarmed a few "students," criticized in newspapers and on radio talk shows THE CHAUFFERED LIMOUSINES HAULING SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS' ASSES AROUND WHILE TEACHERS WERE BEING LAID OFF TO SAVE MONEY!

And, I chose to teach the most problematic students ... I even taught in one of Philly's disciplinary schools.

AND MY KIDS LEARNED!

You want to talk public schools with me ... good. But first let go of the bullshit from the politicians in bed with the fuckers who denigrate public schools and teachers so they can PRIVATIZE THEM AND MAKE PROFITS!

I'll tell you the good, the bad and the ugly ... but, if you haven't been there, drop the demagoguery you've been fed, then ask direct, unloaded questions and I'll give it to you straight.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Yup.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Have to admit Mac, you did bring politics into it.

Especially as we watch greedy teachers going at it in Chicago!

I just love the contradictions here, Emmanuel denigrates Wisconsin for not having the dough, but when he doesn't have it, well, that's a MUCH better reason!

That's what happens when you have public service unions being able to strike, the politicians will give in because they can just kick the can down the street for 8 years or so, and leave the shit house for the next Mayor!

Such unions should not be allowed to strike, period.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Some, not many. Look at the difference, John Kennedy, "ask not ..." Today's dems, Sandra Flake "what the government must do for me."

Cannot anyone see the stark difference? Guess many dems can't, or they don't care, because they are getting free shit too and don't want THEIR gravy train to stop.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Guess many dems can't, or they don't care, because they are getting free shit

I don't get any free shit ... but I'll acknowledge or debunk a list of such free shit if you post it ... but it has to be a list of specifics ... no stuff like "welfare" or "food stamps" because red states get more of those than blue states ...

So, direct me to the gravy train and I'll see if it's on-track or just a demagogue trolley.

BTW ... health care for Ms. Fluke et al isn't free ... the PPACA/Romneycare addressed the free rides ... and if we took the profit out of "for-profit health care" and went to single payer, we could eliminate waste, obscene CEO pay, claim-denial departments and, take it off the employer who could then profit more and hire more.

Be happy to show you the single/payer/universal plan that the chicken-shit-in-bed-with-the insurance-lobby-dems-and-republicans haven't the balls to pass unto law.

Just ask.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

You know A.Mac , I grew up on Long Island. When I grew up if a kid went to private school it was because he had behavioral problems. Hell, it was a scarlet letter to say you went to a private school!

Today, in many cities, if you have the dough you really need to send your kid to a private school for their own safety and for the ability to actually learn!

So many schools have done away with tracks, etc., etc.,. teaching to the LCD instead of breaking students out into appropriate levels. Some schools, especially in conservative areas are making a comeback with "AP" classes, but that is, frankly, just not the same.

ALL kids are pushed to college, which is ludicrous. All colleges are now (many) are the eleventh and twelfth years of what high school used to be.

My Mom taught troubled kids her whole life, and had at least two broken bones to show for it, not to mention innumerable bruises, etc. Yet, all of us kids (one of four brothers) had to be sure not to let her take our stuff and give them to her kids!

Unfortunately, kids need parental guidance. And if there is none, then, if they are to have ANY chance, they need SOME form of guidance (big brother, etc., etc., etc). Most, however, don't get it, and so fail and become a worker on the welfare plantation.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Free shit, is free shit, no matter which 'type' of state gets it A.Mac.

I am pointing out the stated differences between today's dems, and the dems of Kennedy's time.

Who would most likely now be called right wing tea party trash by most dems!

I don't get any free shit ...

Sure you do A.Mac. Roads, the clean air you breathe, the safe water, etc., etc. You really aren't reading up on your dem playbook! After all, you didn't really EARN anything!

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Not only that, they will have teachers THAT OUTRIGHT CHEAT!

Is happening here in Atlanta. In fact, a teacher that was given awards for her ability, even by the feds, turned out to be cheating and is now being criminally prosecuted! She was changing the answers on the tests so that her "kids" tested WAY high, and she got the kudos for it!

Scum.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Terry,

We're not so far apart on this.

ALL kids are pushed to college, which is ludicrous. All colleges are now (many) are the eleventh and twelfth years of what high school used to be.

Not all kids are pushed to college ... and too damn many aren't pushed to anywhere but the world ... and without basic reading and math skills! First, we have to stop exporting both white and blue collar jobs; public schools in conjunction with manufacturers, etc. should collaborate personnel and resources to train kids for jobs they can graduate into!

As for my bringing politics into this discussion, it has lots to do with public education. School Boards are loaded up with conflict-of-interests frauds with no background in education! They sit on boards primarily to steer maintenance, supply and other contracts to their political backer/entrepreneurs thus taking resources and viable school personnel away from children.

Welfare is a business in America and a permanent underclass is part of the plan. Divide and conquer. Many on welfare are encouraged to beat the system and, out of ignorance and laziness, never try or care to break out.

There are "victimcrats," those who are advocates for the free-riders and who exploit the system ...

And there are victims ... real victims ... guys who lose their jobs -- who pack up their bosses' factories, get shown the door and see their jobs go to China ... and those who go bankrupt because of catastrophic illness and a pre-PPACA health care system that fucked them over.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Or when you have cheating ass teachers who don't mind screwing the kids for their own self aggrandizement!

Note, I'm talking Public Service unions. They should not be allowed to strike. Hell, even George Meaney didn't think they should be able to strike!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

I am pointing out the stated differences between today's dems, and the dems of Kennedy's time.

In Kennedy's time we didn't export middle class jobs and close American factories.

Roads, the clean air you breathe, the safe water, etc., etc. You really aren't reading up on your dem playbook! After all, you didn't really EARN anything!

Roads are in disrepair because Republicans filibustered and/or would not bring to a vote, Obama'a highway/jobs bill.

Air is full of shit from Koch Brothers and other polluters who have purchased the Tea Party and will take the Republican Party to extinction.

Ditto the water polluters.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Not only that, they will have teachers THAT OUTRIGHT CHEAT!

Is happening here in Atlanta.

I'll wager that the cheater(s) was surreptitiously or otherwise directed by school administrators to "do what she had to do" to make the school/system look good. The kudos are part of the bullshit facade.

The cheating is unethical if not illegal ... it's wrong. And if I am correct about this being a directive off-the-record ... WAGER ON THAT ... then the teacher faced the dilemma of "cheat or be charged with insubordination" (on a phony incident).

Terry, you have not been where I've been ... much of what is chastised regarding public education is valid, much is not. And even some of the valid criticisms are not because of incompetent teaching, rather, administrative malfeasance and misfeasance.

Do we have a bet?

Students arent the only ones caught cheating recently. Georgia Governor Nathan Deal announced that dozens of Atlanta public school educators falsified standardized tests or failed to address such misconduct in their schools in the 2008-2009 school year. The state's report indicated there was a climate of cheating and performance-at-all-costs during the tenure of former Superintendent Beverly Hall -- a charge Hall has denied.

The state's report indicated there was a climate of cheating and performance-at-all-costs during the tenure of former Superintendent Beverly Hall -- a charge Hall has denied. Investigators said 178 teachers and principals working at 44 schools were involved in the cheating scandal. The educators, including 38 principals, were either directly involved in erasing wrong answers on a key standardized test or they knew -- or should have known -- what was going on, according to the governor's office.

Six principals declined to answer investigators' questions and invoked the Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination, but 82 of the educators admitted their involvement, the report stated. Some of the teachers could face criminal charges.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

A bet on what?

I'm not even saying you are wrong.

Award-winning gains by Atlanta students were based on widespread cheating by 178 named teachers and principals, said Georgia Gov. Nathan Deal on Tuesday. His office released a report from the Georgia Bureau of Investigation that names 178 teachers and principals 82 of whom confessed in what's likely the biggest cheating scandal in US history.

Here's a link to the story!

...

"When test scores are all that matter, some educators feel pressured to get the scores they need by hook or by crook," says Mr. Schaeffer. "The higher the stakes, the greater the incentive to manipulate, to cheat."

So they screw the kids, and cheat for their own self aggrandizement.

The issues with public education are so numerous as to almost be without end, but the MAJOR one is lack of parental involvement/give a shit!

You don't see this crap in schools/areas where there ARE PARENTS (note plural) who give a shit about their kids. They are squeaky wheels and this crap can't get by them.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

That is the number one reason.

that screaming at the unions really doesn't accomplish anything,

Let me reiterate my position again, public service unions, ANY public service union should NOT be allowed to strike, period, end of story. The conflict of interest is far too grave and, IMO, those who disagree are asshats on that issue.

Most states that are not run by unions do, in fact, prevent such strikes from occurring, and that includes the Feds.

So, two different issues, imo. The asshats (or as Iar would call them, douche weasels) striking now are just greedy shits who care only for themselves.

I do, however, take a certain glee in seeing Emanuel get his come uppance:

Chicago mayoral candidate Rahm Emanuel is taking aim at Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker for his handling of the state's budget crisis.

Emanuel, a former aide to President Obama and President Bill Clinton, is the front-runner in today's mayoral race in Chicago .

In an interview with CNN , to air at 7 p.m. ET today, Emanuel said Walker has not been handling a dispute with unions in a "cooperative" way with "understanding and respect."

So, asshat Rahm, how's that "cooperative" way with "understanding and respect" working for you now?

LOL, funny as hell!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

The bet is/was that the teacher did not initiate the cheating ... that she was directed/coerced/ by administration to cheat under fear of facing trumped up insubordination accusations.

So they screw the kids, and cheat for their own self aggrandizement.

Totally agree.

The issues with public education are so numerous as to almost be without end, but the MAJOR one is lack of parental involvement/give a shit!

Totally agree ... but there are still the majority of kids in public schools who do well despite their disruptive peers and the awful parents.

You don't see this crap in schools/areas where there ARE PARENTS (note plural) who give a shit about their kids. They are squeaky wheels and this crap can't get by them.

Another way of saying the same thing.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Let me reiterate my position again, public service unions, ANY public service union should NOT be allowed to strike, period, end of story. The conflict of interest is far too grave and, IMO, those who disagree are asshats on that issue.

Agreed with the condition of mandatory, binding arbitration when a neutral third party declares an impasse based on a definitive protocol. Sanctions must be in place and executed for violations of the arbitrator's decision.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Well, I'm not a real supporter of arbitration, certainly not in the areas I practice and in the way there is no appeal, even if the arbitrator is flat out wrong on the law.

 
 

Who is online