╌>

Compromise- A Word Most Foul to Those of Us With Principles (reprint of my Sept, 2011, NewsVine article, for John Russell)

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  neale-osborn  •  14 years ago  •  31 comments

Compromise- A Word Most Foul to Those of Us With Principles (reprint of my Sept, 2011, NewsVine article, for John Russell)

Lately, the news has been full of demands that the Republicans "compromise" with the Democrats. Of course, the Democrats never volunteer to compromise with Republicans, do they? Now, while I'm not a fan of EITHER major party, if there were only two of them and no other options, I'm farther right of Republicans on most fiscal issues, and left of Democrats on SOME social issues. Fortunately for me. I have no need of a partyto belong to, so compromise ain't-a-gointa happen. Compromise is the single biggest evil there can be in politics. Well, if you actually have principles, it is. You want examples?? I've got a million of them, but here are a few to chew on.

We'll start with Obamacare- ENTIRELY un-acceptable. Read the 10th Amendment to the Constitution. Go ahead, I'll wait for you! What, you couldn't find it? Okay, I'll save us BOTH some time- http://www.ratical.com/co-globalize/BillOfRights.html

Here is a link to the entire Bill of Roghts (BoR, for the rest of this article)because we're going to need it! The 10th amendment specifically states that if the Constitution does not specifically grant a power to the federal government, or specifically denyaower to a state government, the federal government is denied that power. The federal government is not, anywhere in the Constitution, permitted to require individuals to purchase ANYTHING. Therefore, the federal government cannot requiree individual mandate (no matter what the SCOTUS said) that is the backbone of Obamacare. Now, the individual states are not prohibited from doing this, so the Massachusetts healthcare law is Constitutional as long as it does not violate the Mass. STATE Constitution. (This, unfortunately, gives that idiot Romney a pass on Romneycare) So, ANY compromise that allowed Obamacare to function at a federal level violates the 10th amendment, and therefore is a violation of my principles of adherence to the Constitution and Constitutional law. Now, there are those who support Obamacare (about 30% by most polls). There are another 15-20% who want to see changes made, but are opposed to at least a portion of it.The other 50% of us want it gone, lock, stock, and barrel. We hate it, period.Some for the same reasons I do, others for their own reasons. But here's the big question IF Obamacare violates your principles, why the hell would you bother to compromise to make it less of a violation. It's like being pregnant- Either you are, or you aren't. There's no such thing as "a little bit pregnant", and there is no such thing a a LITTLE violation of your principles. Not to me.

Now, on to one of my biggest bugaboos. Victim Disarmament Laws (what those of you who support violating the 2nd Amendment call "gun control laws"). Remember the link to the BoR? Go read the 2nd Amendment. I'll wait! Got it? Cool. So, who are "the People" so mentioned? Each and every individual American Citizen. The Supreme Court said so, as early as this-

"The words 'people of the United States' and 'citizens' are synonymous terms, and mean the same thing. They both describe the political body who, according to our republican institutions, form the sovereignty, and who hold the power and conduct the Government through their representatives. They are what we familiarly call the 'sovereign people,' and every citizen is one of this people, and a constituent member of this sovereignty. The question before us is, whether the class of persons described in the plea in abatement compose a portion of this people, and are constituent members of this sovereignty? We think they are not, and that they are not included..." ( Dred Scott v. Sandford , 60 U.S. 393 [1856])

"The People" is referring to individuals. NOT states, the federal government, nor government employees only. So, now you're going to bring up the "well Regulated Militia". First, what is the definition of a militia? NO, it's NOT a bunch of survivalist whacko's plotting to verthrow the government or re-enslave blacks or purify the "white race". Nope, those may be CURRENT definitions of the militia, but they are definitely NOT the definition in the terms of the day. See this- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Militia_ (United_States) . Here's the relevant part:

  • The reserve militia [3] or unorganized militia , also created by the Militia Act of 1903 which presently consist of every able-bodied man of at least 17 and under 45 years of age who are not members of the National Guard or Naval Militia. (that is, anyone who would be eligible for a draft ) [2]

    Today, this would be automatically expanded to include women, who are no longer banned from the rights of full citizenship, as they were in the 1790s, and it would include blacks, who weren't even human at that time. So, having shot down two of the three arguments to allow these Victim Disarmament laws, we move to the final roadblock. "Well Regulated" Again we must go to the definition of the times. Go here: http://www.constitution.org/cons/wellregu.htm .

    The phrase "well-regulated" was in common use long before 1789, and remained so for a century thereafter. It referred to the property of something being in proper working order. Something that was well-regulated was calibrated correctly, functioning as expected. Establishing government oversight of the people's arms was not only not the intent in using the phrase in the 2nd amendment, it was precisely to render the government powerless to do so that the founders wrote it.

    So, with all these precedents and definitions to back up the 2nd Amendment, the compromises of the NRA to help "lessen the severity" of Gun Control laws or to help ban certain types of ammo and weapons, or to push for Concealed Carry Laws violates the Constitution. Again, compromise is evil- the federal government cannot "control" that which "shall not be infringed." And, since the states cannot violate the Constitution, THEY can't license guns, or control where they may be carried, or control HOW they may be carried. And, the last-ditch efforts of the Victim Disarmament people is "Well, they couldn't foresee high-capacity handguns and machineguns, or they would have written the 2nd Amendment differently. THEY meant only flintlock rifles." Nope. They said "ARMS". The definition of the times is here: http://dictionary.die.net/arms .

    1: weapons considered collectively [syn: weaponry , implements of war , weapons system , munition ]

    I think that sums it up, don't you??

    Let's pick one more area where "compromise" is (me being sarcastic) "Oh so necessary" in order to be "reasonable". Economic Justice (also known as "Social Justice"). The government "re-distribution of wealth. " What it actually is is the government confiscation of private property without recompense. Remember that pesky Bill of Rights? Re-read the 5th Amendment.

    No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the militia, when in actual service in time of war or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use without just compensation.

    Where is the "just compensation" for taking what one person owns, inherited or earned, in order to give it to others? Again, there isn't a Constitutional justification. Compromise IN ANY FORM violates my principles, and it won't happen.

    Now, I'm sure there are those out there sharpening their keyboards and preparing to justify compromising my principles on one or more of these instances (or others!!). Have at it!


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Got it?? I hope so!!

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

No sweat off MY back.

However, I stand firmly behind everything I have written. And I, for one, have no problem with an argument. I would suggest that compromise is what is insane. And, being sane, I choose not to compromise on principles. On anything else, sure. But not on principles.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Neale,

Each thinking individual has their own principles that they live by. Aparadoxto your theory is that there are those out there that principle is to compromise. I happen to believe that there are some issues that I am willing to compromise on, while others not. But issues and principles are also not the same thing. For instance you call gun ownership a principle. It isguaranteedin ourConstitution, and I it is my principle to treat that document with respect. But the issue of how far that right was meant to go, to me is an issue an not a principle.

There is a difference.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Iappreciatethat John.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Well, we disagree there! LOL It is pretty simple. "Shall not be infringed" is pretty specific. It doesn't say "may be infringed if enough people agree" THAT requires an Amendment. Which will never pass, when you consider that 34 states have passed "Must Issue laws for concealed carry" and another 3 have Constitutional carry.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

So you don't want to "argue" but you wish to point out things you disagree with. I chose a case describing what the term "the People" means. AND I deliberately chose Dredd Scott for exactly the reason you said. Although only one of literally thousands of SCOTUS decisions where the term "the People" was a relevant part of the decision (one of the latest being Heller V DC), it is proof that the SCOTUS cannot actually be used to determine Constitutionality of a law, because they upheld that a slave is property.

As to ANY Supreme Court justice saying he upholds restricting weapons, see the aforementioned Dredd Scott decision. It proves the SCOTUS human.

SHALL NOT BE INFRINGED was put there on purpose.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

TheConstitutionis always being clarified. That is what SCOTUS does. At one time a black man was only 3/4 of a person,interpretedfor the time and he became whole.

A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

The question can be, what are considered arms? The question can be did it apply to only Militias? So where for you it is an absolute, for others it may not. For you it is a principle, for them an issue. There are many such debates in what is Constitutional, again hence SCOTUS.

BTW, please don't read this any anything about my specific POV about guns. It's just for discussion sake.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Are you still here?

Ever have a teacher who uses an example to make you think? If you think me incapable of that, you don't give me enough credit. I home school 4 smart kids, who don't WANT to study sometimes. I do things like that all the time, because they LOVE to "catch Dad making a mistake." 9 times in ten, it wasn't a mistake, it was to make them think. Then,Frown.gif , occasionally, I actually DO make a mistake. This was NOT a mistake. On NV, someone used almost your exact argument to try to catch me. If it wasn't on purpose, why is it still here?

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Did I publish my Bill of Rights series here?? if not, read the article above, where that very topic is discussed.

"Arms are all weapons. 90% of the cannon used in the Revolution were privately owned by the leader of the various militias who came to participate in the revolution. The term "Arms" is ANY AND ALL weapons. Otherwise, they would have used the term "Small Arms" which is any weapon portable by one man without using a beast of burden or mechanical transport to move. Small arms means Rifles, pistols, shotguns, sword, knives, clubs, bows, light machine guns, and "assault weapons". It specifically excludes pintle mounted machineguns, cannons, etc.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

So damn true.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

No, there won't be "Constitutional" restrictions. There are already UNCONSTITUTIONAL restrictions, but just because the Supreme Court (still as fallible as they were in 1853) rules things like the restrictions (or Obamacare) Constitutional, it doesn't mean they are.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

There can't be. But JR will totally ignore that simple fact, AND tell me (again) how he isn't going to comment here, then proceed to tell me why I'm wrong and how he's right, and how I'm an idiot who doesn't bow down before the lord Obama and worship at the Democrat altar, while surrendering all my rights to my lord and master, The Federal Government.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

John,

What happened to leaving the article? I thought it was a good idea. I see you are beginning to loose it.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

It dpesn't. But he'll claim "well regulated" means restrictions. He won't read the definitions supplied (with links) above, relevant to the time the BoR was written. He will, again, ignore historical context. My guess is, he has no idea what a "faggot" was before it became a pejorative. Or "fag". Or "gay" so he won't realize that language changes over time. To properly interpret ANYTHING you need the historical context.

If, in 1787, I asked you for a faggot, you'd go and collect a bundle of sticks suitable for using as kindling for the cook fire.

In 1930, if I asked you for a fag, you'd reach into your shirt pocket, extract a Lucky Strike or a Camel, and give me a cigarette.

In the "Gay Nineties", there weren't a lot of homosexuals running around. It meant Happy.

In 1787, well regulated meant in working condition. NOT licensed, restricted, and prohibited.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Let him stay. I like hypocrites.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

you haven't rained on MY parade. But you HAVE placed your own foot firmly in your mouth and swallowed. Twice.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

It IS so much fun, though, having a battle of wits with an unarmed opponent, isn't it, Max?Grin.gif

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

But HE thinks he HAS answered. His stock answer is " I said so, you don't know what you're talking about, and the majority has the right to trample YOUR rights."

Of course, if the majority chooses to trample HIS pet right, whatever that may be, THEN he'll screech a different tune!!

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Start with Ethan Allen and the Green Mountain Boys. Work from there. I'm on the way out for the weekend, so there will be no more responses til Sunday evening at the earliest.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

Neale ,

[[he won't realize that language changes over time. ]]

That is a very useful observation . And the terminology of what includes armaments also changes over time .
Surely you can't expect anyone in the "militia" to be allowed to have a Sherman/Abrams tank , can you ?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Actually Max, I think the question you pose is really dependent on whether or not you view the Constitution as a living document or one written in stone. I happen to see it as a living document, that has to stay up with the times, but keep it's heart and soul intact. This is not an easy balancing act. But that is why cases get passed to SCOTUS and why we have had amendments.

I personally don't see how our founders could possible written a document that is perfect for all times. They couldn't see every eventual innovation or the society's changes. But hey, that is just my POV.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

I sncerely wish that a person as inherently ignorant as you are would keep your promises to go away and stay away. You keep insisting that people follow your interpretation of the Constitution rather than the words AS WRITTEN, and the reasons the people WHO WROTE THOSE WORDS GAVE FOR INCLUDING THEM. I couldn't give a flying fuck whether they bled Washington to death. Comparing apples to oranges does not mean you can squeeze an apple and get orange juice.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Rich- WRONG!! I DO support our right to own a Sherman tank. And in fact, I know a guy who DOES own one. Legally.

Let me be so fucking blunt even JR can follow this-

I do not consider the government to have the right to own ANYTHING it trie to prohibit me from having the right to own. (Note- having the right to own something does not mean that the government must provide it to me. Ditto for food, shelter, and healthcare.)

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Again, you blindly accept as the final word the group of black-robed supreme beings who gave us such astoundingly Constitutional rulings as Dredd Scott. I sincerely hope you remember this crap when some asswipe in black rules that the government has the right to monitor and censor your internet postings, or to license your use of the internet. How about when the Republican party manages to get control, and passes laws prohibiting any mention of homosexuals unless you are raiing against their immoral and godless ways. We'll all laugh our asses off when you then screech about their bowing to political pressure.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    14 years ago

Thixologist,

Essentially correct with only one little exception. Thomas Jefferson had no hand in writing the Constitution. At the time it was written, he was the Minister to France and was in Paris. Mostly it was Washington, Madison, Hamilton and Franklin who did it.

 
 
 
thixologist
Freshman Silent
link   thixologist    14 years ago

Jefferson based his contributions to the VirginiaConstitutionon what he called "ancient principles". These timeless precepts are as valid today as they were 3500 years ago. Among them is the capacity or "right" of a person to defend themselves (individually) and by extension, their collective communities. This model was used by Madison and company when the us constitution was written.Perhaps a rereading of the federalist v antifederalist papers, the Magna Carta, and the levitical law will elucidate those who argue with Mr Osborn.

Neale, After 20 years, i no longer have any propensity to help those who will not help themselves. When the tyrant ascends power, he will have the blessings (votes) of many of his subjects. They, too, will face the same situation as Rev Mueller did after the night of the long knives. "...when they came for me there was no one left."

The well meaning but misguided folks here who think it cannot happen forget that Hitler was elected aschancellorand Cabba was elected to the Ogburo before both of them became the most reviled dictators of the 20th century.

Y'all have a nice day.

Edited to correct a mistake as identified by TTGA below. Thanks TTGA

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

As always, when challenged, thixologist comes through with flying colors. As you did in Trinidad, so do ye do in NewsTalkers. Much better.

I, too, am displeased with the thought that the government will eventually attempt to remove the 2nd Amendment. I have no intention of complying with such activities if they occur. The really sad thing is, I remember Pastor Martin Niemoller. So, keeping that in mind, I tend to defend the rights of Sheeple as well as the rights of the People. And, should the time ever come when we must once again water the tree of Liberty with the blood of tyrants and patriots, we know the sheeple will support the government, then try like hell to get THEIR beliefs into whatever founding documents the winners, the People or the Government, then create.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

The reserve militia[3] or unorganized militia, also created by the Militia Act of 1903 which presently consist of every able-bodied man of at least 17 and under 45 years of age who are not members of the National Guard or Naval Militia. (that is, anyone who would be eligible for a draft)[2]

Today that definition would be considered sexist [against? males ] ... even though they continue to form the majority of the military .

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Males are STILL required to register for the draft at 18. Women, of course, cannot be drafted. Sexist? definitely. Government slavery? definitely.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Dunno. Drunk that day?Grin.gif Grin.gif

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Grin.gif Grin.gif

 
 

Who is online