Fact Check: First Lady's False Fairy Tale of Struggle
Fact Check: First Lady's False Fairy Tale of Struggle
First Lady Michelle Obamas pitch to voters last night relied on the premise that she and her husband understand what it is to struggle to make ends meet. She spoke movingly about their early years--about how a young Barack Obama drove a car that was rusted out" and found his furniture in a dumpster, how they both came from families that had to scrape by. Her fairy tale--however well-delivered--was one great, big, colorful lie.
http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2012/09/05/Fact-Check-Michelle-Obama-s-False-Fairy-Tale-of-Struggle

Len,
I dumpster dived for my first apartment and I drove a rusted out ChevyBiscayne for 2 years , that if you took a right turn and you had something in the trunk, you didn't after you finished the turn. I had to take out loans when I wanted to go to Hofstra. At that time, my parents didn't have much. Would a similar article be written about me? Probably. I really dislike political pettiness, and that goes both ways.
Yes, but you all dislike political pettiness against Dems far more than Reps, 'cause we lie and you don't, right?
How DARE we speak against the First Lady, wife of The One!
It was a more persausive speech because she's a better fucking liar.
Right?
Right?
John,
I believe you left something out after your statement.
Maybe 'neener neener neener'
Jonathan,
OMG, I never expected a comment like that from you.
First of all, I have never called Mitt a liar. So I don't know where you come off saying that to me. I usually stay away from these political discussions so that I can moderate them without bias being claimed. This one happened to get me, because her past is much like mine and because I really didn't see it as a major discussion point.
Second, I don't care that she's the first lady. I care about the facts. And if you are going to call her an F'in liar, then back it up.
So...
Wrong!
Wrong!
True, a much scummier liar as well.
Did she mention all of her years in the Reverend Wright's church?
All you have to do is read the article.
It's bullshit to assert that, somehow, they were deprived. If anything, they lived the life of the top 1%, God forbid anyone would mention that!
Tell me Perrie, just how many poor, down and out folks can get into Harvard Law?
Terry,
I did read the article, and it has zero back up. And this line cracked me up:
My father in law is an interviewer for Harvard Law, and there is no way to buy yourself into Harvard Law. Back in their day, they might have been able to come in under affirmative action, but even now that is no longer on the table.
Well I can tell you that Johns Hopkins quite a few. My daughter is rooming with a girl who got a full ride on them. And a friend of theirs who comes from a single mother, got a full ride from Columbia, so I'm guessing that it's also true for Harvard.
LOL, no way to buy yourself into Harvard Law!
You crack me up, think TEDDY! Hilarious! And then when he got thrown out, he bought himself into UVA!
Hell, Obama couldn't even WRITE ENGLISH!
That was really funny Perrie.
"Zero back up?" Do you dispute any of it? LOL, you're getting like so many others, you just don't want to have facts provided to you unless they are vetted by folk in whom you believe.
Sheesh.
LOL, I love it. If we can't get her on her family background, we'll get her on her church.
OK Terry, there you got me. It's a scummy church.
You mean some liars are scummier than others? That's news to me.
Perrie,
They're the same age as we are. They were right in the wheelhouse of the affirmative action recruitment. Lovely, "clean and wellspoken" African Americans (got that from our Vice President) with good grades bumped 2 white people with far higher exam scores from going to Harvard.
And the rest is history. He brought his anger and arrogance and Marxist tendencies to Washington and VOILA!, toilet nation.
Well, you have to admit, he had a lot of help from voters that also wanted this nation to go into the toilet.
And he is still getting that help!
You know Perrie, anyone that doesn't think it matters that she and her racist hubby went to that church, with that reverend, with whom they were great friends, for so long, doesn't matter,
are blind and so biased as to make it not worthwhile even discussing political matters with them.
Pure and simple!
Of course some liars are scummier than others.
AS we have seen on this site, those from Chicago are scummier than any other liar. Clear fact.
Terry,
I thought you thought he was a Kenyan. I'm confused. But I don't approve of Rev. Wright either. He is a racist.
A liar is a liar. They are both equally scummy... and you are coming close to a CoC infraction there, Terry. Please don't tread over the line.
Hmm, me, thinking he was a Kenyan?
If you think Wright is a racist, how can you NOT think Obama and Michelle are also racists?
Pure, utter, suspension of rationality is the only way one can come to that conclusion!
Funny, those who follow a racist are, by definition, racists. Would you say that only the LEADERS of the KKK were racist?
LOL, how hypocritical so many are when viewing Obama through their prism of color.
I just did a check on google and this nada on Michelle Obama's past. Here is what the Washington post had to say about the speeches under fact checking:
Fact checking the opening night of the Democratic convention - The ...
Hello John,
The article I posted did not say that Michelle was "upper class." It was deceptive about her but not about the president and you did not say it was.
I independently checked out Michelle and BO.
I checked out her bio and the Breitbart piece is unfair to Michelle though not about BO.She grew up in a working-class family and attended public schools for bright students; only in this sense were they elite.She had a leg up but it was earned.Both went to college and law school probably on loans and partial scholarships. While Michelle was evidently bright I suspect Barack went through largely on affirmative action because his grades are locked up and he became Harvard Law Review editor without ever having written an article. Barack had a broken-up family butwas supported by his affluent grandparents and attended private schools.
Michelle's Family Background:
Born to Marian and Fraser Robinson, Michelle had two early role models in her parents, whom she proudly identifies as 'working class.' Her father, a city pump operator and Democratic precinct captain, worked and lived with multiple sclerosis; his limp and crutches did not affect his abilities as the family breadwinner. Michelle's mother stayed home with her children until they reached high school. The family lived in a one-bedroom apartment on the top floor of a brick bungalow. The living room - converted with a divider down the middle - served as Michelle's bedroom.
The fact is that though Michelle may have had "humble" beginnings, she jumped on the gravy train as soon as possible. What was that job for which she did nothing but got paid 300k or so, kind of like Obama today?
Frankly, I think they both hate America, IMO.
Hi Perrie,
You have nothing on me. My parents were immigrants and myfather was a waiter. My family was on welfare when I was a child, and I lived in a low-income housing project. Before that we lived in tenements on the lower east side and the Bronx. While I had part-time jobs from age 14 I did not own a used car till I began working after college. If I could not go to a free college, CCNY, I would have not gone at all.
I idolized Adlai Stevenson as a first-time voter and always remember him saying that the trouble with too many people who grew up the hard way is that they forget the lesson of their experience. I resolved not to forget and was a Democrat till Sen. Lieberman lost his primary. I then decided that was not my party any more and changed my registration to Republican. The Republicans are economically and socially where the Democrats were in the last century. The Democrats have gone too far left economically and socially for my taste.
No one cares about the process but if he had poor grades, which are a deep dark secret, and was a law review editor withhou having ever written an article, isn't that germane?
You are a spinner par extroardinaire.
What is the UCC?
The church was worse than racist. There are videos of Wright on YouTube for all to see. He preached "God damn America," for instance,and gave an award to Farrhakan.
1978 is 34 years ago and the Mormons deserve credit for changing their policy, not condemnation. To change it there had to be a majority that favored it and pushed for change years earlier.
At least you did not accuse Mitt of polygamy.
Wright's church has not changed yet as far as I know so do not equate it with LDS.
What "unethhics" are you talking about? Do you actually believe those Obama ads?
Why is that Randy? Honestly, if Romney had been a member of the KKK up until he was running for president, would you
see raising that issue as a "sad and pathetic" thing to do?
Your bias is showing Randy, zip up your fly!
All fact checkers are lying Perrie. There was a great article on that, I posted it I think.
They too have agendas. Is there anyone who doesn't nowadays?
And don't say yourself! LOL
Yessirreee, those pooh black folks, right?
Sigh, will the left never, ever get over their racism?
Grifters are grifters, no matter their race.
By the way, did you see my link to a .95 caliber weapon? Man!
Len,
I won't play who had the worst childhood. But I will say this. Both parties have gone to far to the extremes and I find that deeply disturbing. Look at the content of this entire discussion. It's full ofrhetoricand name calling, and I blame the extreme factions of both parties for that. They fear monger and that brings out the worst in people.
Both parties are flawed. It's actually time for a third party in my opinion. It would keep all of them more accountable and at least stop this pendulum ride that we are on. Nothing really changes, since sooner or later each party knows they will get back into power.
Wait, Breitbart the author of the above article has no agenda, but the WP does? The article called them out. Breitbart just took a cheap shot in the dark.
And yes I do have an agenda. Truth, or as close as I can come. I posted an article that called the dems out with real facts. I'm not saying they are perfect. But I hate it when pettiness rules the day and that article was petty.
But you know what they say about repeating a lie....
Google Michelle Obama fact check and see how many right wing online blogs and publications ran with it, whether it was true or not.
LOL, Nice pitch Terry!