The Lament of Missed Opportunities by Jonathan Walters
Over the last few years, it has become apparent that we have some extremely serious economic issues. We have a battle for the voice of the nation that has descended into a lot of name calling, right up to the top on both sides of the aisle, and at the same time, we have economic issues that threaten to destroy the nation, and the global economy at the same time.
Yet at the same time, we have absolutely no recognition that anyone of note has a clue about what is really wrong. To use an electronics term, we have an extremely high level of noise, but very little signal. As an engineer, one of the most important aspects of my job is to understand the problem, because if you dont understand the problem, exactly what and how are you going to solve it.
An anecdotal example of this is when I was working at a very well known software company more than a decade ago, and we had two lead developers working on different parts of the system we were building. One developer could fix defects in about 10 minutes, the other developer would usually spend about a day fixing each defect. The real difference however is that the 10 minute fix usually didnt fix the problem, in fact it often compounded the problem. As a result not only did this developer end up having to constantly try to address the same problem over and over again, the developer ended up actually having to deal with about 5 times as many defects, for something that actually was a smaller part of the application itself. The developer that took time to understand the problem and resolve the real problem however rarely if ever had to revisit any problems, and also had FAR fewer problems to resolve in the first place.
Now the irony of this is that the developer that spent the 10 minutes fixing problems, believe it or not, always received better reviews from management. Why? because on paper, it looked as though productivity was higher. More problems were resolved in a shorter period of time. You have to love irony!!!
What does this have to do with the economy and the future of our society? Well the simple fact is that our nation has spent so much time and energy complaining about all these problems we have in government (all levels), and the direction of our society is taking, and the solutions that most are advocating really seem to ignore what the real problem really is.
This isnt a left/right, democrat/republican issue. NEITHER party seems to have an understanding, and based on what the people are shouting about, they dont want to have an understanding. Actually I should modify that a little bit. I have talked to people from both parties that do actually seem to have an understanding of what the issues really are, from a short and a longer term perspective, but the optics and the politics prevent them from actually advocating discussion of any real solutions.
In particular, here are a few items which outline exactly what I mean.
Medicare/Health Care
In this post PPACA world, we continue to have many discussions about health care, the costs, and every time an issue related to this comes across my plate (unfortunately that is far too often because this is one of my responsibilities at my company), I lament the missed opportunity that was the PPACA.
Now I dont want to get into the constitutionality aspect of this, because quite frankly, it makes no difference to me. I never thought that the PPACA was unconstitutional, and most of all, never wanted it to be struck down, because that would have been the worst thing to happen. It would have let Congress off the hook for the pile of rotting pig faeces that is the PPACA. Its not that the PPACA is on the whole bad, or even good, it is that it really does very little to either make the situation worse or better. The good things in it are generally offset by the bad things in it.
For the year and all of that political capital spent, that is in my mind disastrous. I often hear that the PPACA is just a start. Sorry folks, after spending a year, with all of that acrimonious debate, the PPACA is what we are going to have to live with (that would have been the case regardless of whether it was struck down or not), a do nothing bill that in the end is going to make the health care dilemma in this country fester. The only people that are going to pay for this are the people of this country, through lower job creation and higher insurance costs (compared to just about any other comparable country).
Why did it happen this way? Well the root problem was the mission statement that came from Obama. In it, the primary objective wasnt to fix the health care systems problems, it was to insure everybody, completely ignoring the fact that the problems in the health care system are the REASON why people are not insured.
An example of this myopic view is that health care costs in Canada, the UK, France, Germany, etc.. are all at least half of what the costs are in the US as a share of GDP. That is, in the United States, health care eats up 20% of the GDP and in those other countries, it eats up between 8 and 12% of GDP. That means that in the United States, per person, health care costs twice as much as those other countries (and gets worse results but that isnt the topic of this article).
Did ANYONE ever ask this question. If we bring the cost of health care from a systemic perspective to a figure more inline with those other countries, would we have a problem of 30% of our nations population being uninsured? Would we have a problem of companies offshoring if our health care costs werent so out of line with our nation competitors? Would we be struggling to come to terms with Medicare and the upcoming depletion of that portion of the trust, if our health care costs were in line with other nations?
Again, we have, as a nation, because of optics, chosen to treat the symptoms of a problem, and not the root causes of the problem, and as can be shown, those root causes have an impact on MANY aspects of our economic and social well being, and yet we choose to ignore them. We choose to go after the optics, and in the end we not only dont solve the problems, because we have spent so much political capital on the fatally flawed solution that is the PPACA, we let the problem fester, making the problem worse.
LOST OPPORTUNITY: If we actually took steps to fix the health care system in this country, we could have accomplished the following:
1) Reduced pressure on Medicare/Medicaid spending by lowering expenditures and getting the same, if not better results.
2) Reduced cost pressures on employers, namely small and medium sized employers where the cost of health care is extremely onerous, thereby increasing their profitability, and in itself encouraging job creation.
3) Increased tax revenues. Health insurance for companies is a tax deduction. If the cost of that health insurance (which is related to the cost of health care) was dropped by 50% (I would say that 40% is a more realistic ball park figure), that would decrease the tax deduction available, and increase tax revenues to the government.
Now this isnt rocket science folks. Most of this is actually common sense, but because we refuse to do anything but look at the optics, we refuse to actually look at where the sources for our problems reside.
Economic Recovery
Now here is something that seems to be frustrating everyone, and with good reason. We are stuck in a cycle of low demand that is preventing any form of a real economic recovery from the effects of the 2008 real estate bubble implosion (while the bubble may have burst in 2008, the causes come from lost opportunities to correct the problems over the previous 6 to 8 years, with some of them stemming from before that -- Long Term Capital Management anyone).
In essence, what we are in right now is essentially the opposite of the stagflation situation from the 70s, which, likewise, was largely a result of the policies from the Johnson administration in the 60s. Yup folks, nothing in macro-economics is short term in nature, like it or not. In the 70s we had high growth, but also high inflation with an extremely low spread (net gain). Today we have almost no inflation, but we also have almost no growth either, which results in an extremely low spread (net gain).
Now before we continue, I must come out and say flat out, that I am a fundamentally a Keynesian. I believe in the basic concepts of what Keynes wrote about. However, having said that, I do NOT believe in what the term means today. The basic concept of Keynes was that the government should in general be counter cyclical to the economy. So if the economy is growing, then the government should be reigning things in, and if the economy is contracting, that government should be increasing spending. That is a VERY sound concept. However there have been many structural changes in our economy since the early 30s as well as some context to what Keynes was writing about, that make what has become of Keynes to be totally inappropriate for our economy.
Both political parties are guilty of this, however, the Republicans have been the worst offenders over the last 30 years. While the Democrats are lambasted as tax and spend, there IS at least balance to what they propose. For the positive impact on spending, there is the negative impact of the taxation.
With the Republicans however, who can be described as borrow and spend, there is no balance. The party quite frankly has NO PROBLEM with spending money, as long as it is their constituency that they are spending the money on. Medicare Part D (sorry republicans, that is a republican program, look at who voted for it if you dont believe me), all about spending, nothing about paying for it. That just saddles the future with our spending. If that was investment, that would be fine, but Medicare Part D isnt an investment. Wars of choice in the middle east arent an investment, tax cuts paid for by debt isnt an investment if those tax cuts arent targeted to investment. That is reality. (This however goes back to optics. Making it look like we are actually doing something useful, when the reality is all we are doing is digging a deeper hole)
Now getting to our recovery, I have absolutely no issues with the following measures, TARP, the Stimulus, the auto bailout, and other one time measures. They were put in place to deal with very specific economic issues that if those issues were not stopped in their tracks would have put us into dust bowl depression like conditions. They were one time expenses, that do not contribute to the year over year deficit.
Now what I DO have a big issue with, and this is where Congress comes in, is that after these one time measures were enacted, absolutely NOTHING has been done to try and fix the economic issues of the nation. Where is our needed industrial policy, where are the programs coming that will work to resolve the problems that face this nation. If we resolve those problems, guess what, tax revenues go up and expenses go down. Instead, we are fighting to create minimum wage jobs (all in the name of small business promotion), which do nothing to solve the fundamental economic issues that we face as a nation.
One estimate that I have seen is that the United States has lost more than 50% of its manufacturing capacity over the last 30 years. Is there anyone that is really concerned about that (I dont know many economists that are, which is really strange in my mind actually).
We are treating the current economic problems as though they are financial, and while the stock market problems in 2008 may have been the visible effect of the malaise, it isnt the problem. The stock market is right back up to where it was, are things really any different? Nope, because the problem isnt financial. The problems are much more fundamental, much more core to our economy, yet we have done NOTHING to try and fix those problems. Congress is even begging the FED chief to do more to fix the economy, essentially abrogating their responsibility for the economic well being. If there is any reason to fire every single member of the legislative branch, this to me is it. And no, we dont want to hire/elect short sighted tea partiers who are as much focussed on the optics as anything else, we need real people who are interested in real solutions.
As it is, we have to live with the status quo, running trillion dollar deficits for an economy that just doesnt want to work. Congratulations americans (on both sides of the aisle), you have, for reasons of optics, not only screwed over your own economy, but that of the entire world, for which it has taken stewardship after WWII.
Lost Opportunity: The complete ineffectual nature of the current US government, so focussed on optics, and not on problems, has basically delayed any form of recovery. While the Obama administration has successfully stopped the bleeding, it hasnt even really proposed anything that would move the country forward (Romney doesnt have any ideas either, so this is NOT a statement in support of Obama, in fact Romneys solutions are the same tired ideas that got us into this mess in the first place). The lost opportunity is that we havent moved forward, yet we continue to spend a trillion dollars a year in order to keep the economy from collapsing.
Investment/Taxes
We have a LOT of noise in the conversation about taxes and in particular about the so called overtaxation of job creators. In many cases, we have the call to reduce upper income taxation rates because then that money can be channelled back into creating jobs.
Well, and I say this as one of those upper income job creators, I call 100% bullshit on that (excuse my language there). My company, which employs about 200 people, with about another 150 on contract working on new business, currently has no income tax liabilities whatsoever.
Why? because we are losing money. There are quite a few reasons why we are losing money, pretty much ALL of which are related to external factors. So the question there is, in my anecdotal scenario (of which MANY small businesses are affected by), exactly how is lowering my companys or my tax rate going to do ANYTHING to help the economy.
The ONLY people that will benefit from lowering the tax rates are the people that dont want to create jobs. End of story. The way the tax system is structured right now, it is actually a disincentive to creating jobs and an INCENTIVE to destroy jobs. This has nothing to do with personal tax rates, or corporate tax rates, which are among the lowest in first world nations (if people want to compare the United States with China so be it, but quite frankly, I dont believe that comparing the country with what is largely a third world nation is all that useful, and tax rates in China are by and large NOT competitive with the US, but that is another issue for another article).
One of the things that a tax scheme (the overall structure of taxation and the rates that are levied) needs to accomplish is that it needs to encourage, though a balanced tax system, the types of economic activity that can pay for the countrys infrastructural needs (both tangible and non tangible) and help to push the investment and economic development in a direction that will promote the continuation of economic and national success.
So when we have a tax scheme that discourages investment, and discourages jobs, and discourages economic development, what we end up with is what we have today, an economy that is increasingly dependent on paper profits, increasing economic disparity, and the level of social unrest that is only going to increase.
Now for my company, myself and my business partner dont need to fight for investment capital for our current operations, but we are STILL under the guns when it comes to justifying our companys existence. We are losing money, largely due to continued effects of the 2008 crash and a health care cost explosion (NOT related to the PPACA by the way), and the only real solution is to get out of the industry we are currently in. That unfortunately is going to require economic growth. We cant expand our business any further unless we have a market to expand into. The economy is stagnant, so our losses will continue. We dont have to worry about the short term capital needs because this is our second longer term business investment and we have far more than enough capital to sustain our operations for a few years. Whether we do, that is a different story. We dont owe our employees anything from our previous business, and fortunately they dont expect it (shocking for a union company isnt it).
Other companies however are not in the same situation. They have to fight for capital in an economic and taxation environment that discourages investment, and quite frankly discourages real business activity, in favor of paper businesses (yes Bain is in that category). Now I am not writing this to vilify those businesses. We as a society have encouraged this, by the nature of how our system has developed. Until we as a society stop fiddling with marginal issues (like the tax rate on the highest tax bracket), we will continue to have these issues.
Does anyone think that Mitt Romney really cares about the income tax rate for the upper tax bracket? No, he doesnt. Why? because he doesnt make anything that is considered Earned Income. His entire income is based on Investment Income, which is generally taxed as capital gains.
Does anyone think that letting the Bush Tax cuts expire on that upper income tax bracket is going to have ANY impact on tax revenues for the government? (well it will but really the only people impacted will be sports stars and entertainment personalities, in other words, very few). It wont. Why? because all it will take is a quick little jot by a tax accountant and that income will now be considered capital gains, and taxed accordingly. I am personally in that tax bracket, and it would take me less than 10 minutes of a discussion with my accountant to make that change to how I compensate myself.
But hey, the optics sure look good. Lets stick it to the rich guy, knowing full well that the impact that this would have on the rich guy is about as minimal as you are going to get. Hell, this might actually REDUCE government tax revenues, because many of those that havent been tax planning in the past, will now actually be encouraged to change how they pay themselves.
What is the fix? we need to revamp the tax system completely, but in particular, we need to remove the capital gains tax treatment. If we need to balance that out (because removing that exemption would be a MASSIVE influx of tax revenue) by reducing the statutory tax rates, so be it. The core problem however is that our tax system is completely unbalanced, in favor of economic activity that does harm to the economy and it discourages economic activity that benefits the economy. Lets start talking about that, instead of the cosmetic crap that we discuss today.
LOST OPPORTUNITY: If we fix the tax system, fix it so that it encourages economic growth, a LOT of our complaints about economic growth itself will go away. If we change the tax system so that it encourages real investment, not just paper investment, we will, over the longer term, correct many of the structural issues we face.
Conclusion
We can find this same pattern in many other areas, job promotion (the promotion of subsistence jobs), illegal immigration (dealing with the much more difficult problem of the immigrants themselves rather than the reason why they are coming here in the first place), etc...
What is the solution, I dont know, it is quite honestly extremely frustrating, but the people are just as guilty as are the politicians. The people are demanding that we deal with spending, rather than the reasons why spending is out of control, the people are demanding that we create jobs, without asking what kinds of jobs are being created, the people are demanding that we deal with the fact that they are lacking in health insurance, without asking why do people not have health insurance, and most of the time, this screaming is ideologically based, and not pragmatically based.
What needs to change are our attitudes towards how the country is run, what the country needs to grow our economy, and that change must come from within us, we need to challenge ourselves, and not lay blame on others that have ideological differences, because alas, they are just doing the same thing that everyone else is doing.

These are 'big picture' issues that deserve more than just bandaids. Let's work at making our politicians accountable by looking for long term solutions rather than feel good solutions that actually compound the problems.
I think most of us have identified the issues.
The only true, rational solution would require that the truth be told, and NO politician in our current system will do that.
Frankly, we need to get rid of all our politicians. We need to cut our federal government by 80%, for when you have a powerful, centralized government, then you have power hungry asshats such as all of the current politicians that reside in D.C.
We need to pay our politicians almost nothing, institute term limits, and prevent them from becoming lobbyists. We need to stop giving them perquisites that even CEO's don't get. In short, we need to, once again, make service as a representative a "sacrifice," not a sinecure.
And we need to change the franchise, make it so that only those who have some skin in the game can vote.
I would go with a minimum of two years of military service, extendable to an indefinite period of time if we are in a war.
But, frankly, ain't never going to happen without a revolution.
"We need to pay our politicians almost nothing, institute term limits, and prevent them from becoming lobbyists."
Out of that statement I think 'prevent them from becoming lobbyists' is the most important. However, that doesn't fix any of the issues addressed in the article.
Well, it may. I don't think one thing will fix the noted issues.
If we get rid of corrupt, greedy politicians, at least to the extent possible, then we might actually go a long way to resolving many of the issues you note.
A quote from Thatcher comes to mind,
That's the real threat to our liberty, our Country, our way of life. Those who are dems, on the left, wish for everyone to be equal. For that to happen, however, would REQUIRE that everyone be equally poor except, of course
THEM!
See dachas and other perquisites provided the communist party leaders while the "workers" were starving.
Leona,
I just had a chance to read through the article. It's really good.. I will get back to it after I go to the dentist.
Robert,
Well, do you think the franchise needs to be changed?
If so, how do you believe would be the best way to bring such change about?
If not, why not?
I commend you forusing the systems approachthough it would have been better to have divided your essay into shorter pieces; perhaps into parts. As it is it is too onerous to respond to easily.
Off the top of my head I note that many economists consider Keynsian economics a bust. Aside from that a case can be made that the expenditures of the last three years were more corporate cronyism than Keynsianism. Where are the parks, dams, bridges and highways as in Roosevelt's term? Most of the trillion was wasted on Solyndra-like polliticalsupporters of the president.
On health care, I agree with your critique but think a better solution is too begin anew. Also, 30% uninsured is a lot higher than the 30 millionthe PPACA supporters claimed. Besides, of these 30 million, perhaps half do not mind being uninsured. So a 2000-page bill was forced that will affect 300 million to help15 million. That is not an engineering-style solution. (I am an engineer too.)
No one, yet, knows what Obamacare will bring.
I can tell you, however, that as the owner of a small company, our health insurance premiums have increased over 50% because of Obamacare.
Another way this admin is trying to destroy small businesses so only HUGE megacorps and the government will continue to exist, hand in hand, enslaving everyone.
Robert,
Actually freaky. I agree with you again.
John,
Human nature, whether it be an individual of the individuals who make up a company, success is the max. of profits. It is why capitalism works. It is why the USSR really rotted out from the inside. It is why China might be adictatorship, but has become quite capitalistic. Without incentive for success, people have no incentive to do better and become the DMV.
Len,
Friedmanist consider Keynsian economics a bust and vice versa.Trickledown economics was as much of a bust as any Keynsain economics. In truth, the economy runs best on a mixed market approach. When you go to either extreme, something goes astray.
Great article and I think quite spot on. Points to consider:
Revamping the healthcare industries and not health care.
Revamping our tax code, especially removingcapitalgains.
Both parties areguiltyof the mess we are in today. But they will only be taken care of, when they stop pointing figures at each other, and at least attempt to work together. Right now, the only thing they do, is keep their jobs and all the perks, while not really caring what the American public really wants.
I too thought it was a fine article . But next time do as Len suggests . Divide it into several smaller articles .
The following copyrighted article is presented under fair use guidelines; statement at end.
The Man Who Saved Capitalism
Milton Friedman, who would have turned 100 on Tuesday, helped to make free markets popular again in the 20th century. His ideas are even more important today.
By STEPHEN MOORE
It's a tragedy that Milton Friedmanborn 100 years ago on July 31did not live long enough to combat the big-government ideas that have formed the core of Obamanomics. It's perhaps more tragic that our current president, who attended the University of Chicago where Friedman taught for decades, never fell under the influence of the world's greatest champion of the free market. Imagine how much better things would have turned out, for Mr. Obama and the country.
Friedman was a constant presence on these pages until his death in 2006 at age 94. If he could, he would surely be skewering today's $5 trillion expansion of spending and debt to create growthand exposing the confederacy of economic dunces urging more of it.
In the 1960s, Friedman famously explained that "there's no such thing as a free lunch." If the government spends a dollar, that dollar has to come from producers and workers in the private economy. There is no magical "multiplier effect" by taking from productive Peter and giving to unproductive Paul. As obvious as that insight seems, it keeps being put to the test. Obamanomics may be the most expensive failed experiment in free-lunch economics in American history.
Equally illogical is the superstition that government can create prosperity by having Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke print more dollars. In the very short term, Friedman proved, excess money fools people with an illusion of prosperity. But the market quickly catches on, and there is no boost in output, just higher prices.
Next to Ronald Reagan, in the second half of the 20th century there was no more influential voice for economic freedom world-wide than Milton Friedman. Small in stature but a giant intellect, he was the economist who saved capitalism by dismembering the ideas of central planning when most of academia was mesmerized by the creed of government as savior.
Friedman was awarded the Nobel Prize in economics for 1976at a time when almost all the previous prizes had gone to socialists. This marked the first sign of the intellectual comeback of free-market economics since the 1930s, when John Maynard Keynes hijacked the profession. Friedman's 1963 book "A Monetary History of the United States," written with Anna Schwartz (who died on June 21), was a masterpiece and changed the way we think about the role of money.
More influential than Friedman's scholarly writings was his singular talent for communicating the virtues of the free market to a mass audience. His two best-selling books, "Capitalism and Freedom" (1962) and "Free to Choose" (1980), are still wildly popular. His videos on YouTube on issues like the morality of capitalism are brilliant and timeless.
In the early 1990s, Friedman visited poverty-stricken Mexico City for a Cato Institute forum. I remember the swirling controversy ginned up by the media and Mexico's intelligentsia: How dare this apostle of free-market economics be given a public forum to speak to Mexican citizens about his "outdated" ideas? Yet when Milton arrived in Mexico he received a hero's welcome as thousands of business owners, students and citizen activists hungry for his message encircled him everywhere he went, much like crowds for a modern rock star.
Once in the early 1960s, Friedman wrote the then-U.S. ambassador to New Delhi, John Kenneth Galbraith, that he would be lecturing in India. By all means come, the witty but often wrong Galbraith replied: "I can think of nowhere your free-market ideas can do less harm than in India." As fate would have it, India did begin to embrace Friedmanism in the 1990s, and the economy began to soar. China finally caught on too.
Friedman stood unfailingly and heroically with the little guy against the state. He used to marvel that the intellectual left, which claims to espouse "power to the people," so often cheers as states suppress individual rights.
While he questioned almost every statist orthodoxy, he fearlessly gored sacred cows of both political parties. He was the first scholar to sound the alarm on the rotten deal of Social Security for young workersforced to pay into a system that will never give back as much as they could have accumulated on their own. He questioned the need for occupational licenseswhich he lambasted as barriers to entryfor everything from driving a cab to passing the bar to be an attorney, or getting an M.D. to practice medicine.
He loved turning the intellectual tables on liberals by making the case that regulation often does more harm than good. His favorite example was the Food and Drug Administration, whose regulations routinely delay the introduction of lifesaving drugs. "When the FDA boasts a new drug will save 10,000 lives a year," he would ask, "how many lives were lost because it didn't let the drug on the market last year?"
He supported drug legalization (much to the dismay of supporters on the right) and was particularly proud to be an influential voice in ending the military draft in the 1970s. When his critics argued that he favored a military of mercenaries, he would retort: "If you insist on calling our volunteer soldiers 'mercenaries,' I will call those who you want drafted into service involuntarily 'slaves.'"
By the way, he rarely got angry and even when he was intellectually slicing and dicing his sparring partners he almost always did it with a smile. It used to be said that over the decades at the University of Chicago and across the globe, the only one who ever defeated him in a debate was his beloved wife and co-author Rose Friedman.
The issue he devoted most of his later years to was school choice for all parents, and his Friedman Foundation for Educational Choice is dedicated to that cause. He used to lament that "we allow the market, consumer choice and competition to work in nearly every industry except for the one that may matter most: education."
As for congressional Republicans who are at risk of getting suckered into a tax-hike budget deal, they may want to remember another Milton Friedman adage: "Higher taxes never reduce the deficit. Governments spend whatever they take in and then whatever they can get away with."
No doubt because of his continued popularity, the left has tried to tie Friedman and his principles of free trade, low tax rates and deregulation to the global financial meltdown in 2008. Economist Joseph Stiglitz charged that Friedman's "Chicago School bears the blame for providing a seeming intellectual foundation" for the "idea that markets are self-adjusting and the best role for government is to do nothing." Occupy Wall Street protesters were often seen wearing T-shirts which read: "Milton Friedman: Proud Father of Global Misery."
The opposite is true: Friedman opposed the government spending spree in the 2000s. He hated the government-sponsored enterprises like housing lenders Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
In a recent tribute to Friedman in the Journal of Economic Literature, Harvard's Andrei Shleifer describes 1980-2005 as "The Age of Milton Friedman," an era that "witnessed remarkable progress of mankind. As the world embraced free-market policies, living standards rose sharply while life expectancy, educational attainment, and democracy improved and absolute poverty declined."
Well over 200 million were liberated from poverty thanks to the rediscovery of the free market. And now as the world teeters close to another recession, leaders need to urgently rediscover Friedman's ideas.
I remember asking Milton, a year or so before his death, during one of our semiannual dinners in downtown San Francisco: What can we do to make America more prosperous? "Three things," he replied instantly. "Promote free trade, school choice for all children, and cut government spending."
How much should we cut? "As much as possible."
Mr. Moore is a member of the Journal's editorial board.
FAIR USE NOTICEThis message contains copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. I am making the material available for news reporting, criticism, comment, and teaching purposes in an effort to advance understanding of international, political, human rights, economic, democracy, social justice issues, etc. I believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material herein is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for educational and research purposes. For more information go to:
If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
Len,
I could find the exact same kind of article on Keynes without trying. It's just an opinion like every other opinion in economics, because no matter how much all of us who got a degree in it, would like to believe, economics is not a real science. You can't predict human behavior in the market place. The economy works on mixed markets, which is why it is so hard to define. That is the bottom line. But if you need me to find an article like that on Keynes I will.
The problem is not in the theory, but in application.
The supporters of both of these theories are academics. They're Ph.D's in their field, and they're economists. It combines to create a rather arrogant person, unwilling to flinch off their selected orthodoxy.
When you're 80 yards from the hole, you can use 3 different clubs. If you're in taller grass, it's one. If you're in the sand, it's another. If you're on the fairway, still another.
Keynsian economics for RIGHT NOW is misapplied, because it is creating a zero-sum result, without accounting for the level of debt we have. Keynsian WORKS, in a more healthy environment, which we are clearly not in right now. Friedman NEVER works for people who don't want to make sober, adult decisions that might have a negative impact on their ability to be re-elected. Friedman doesn't work for people who are too lazy to get off their ass and go looking for work. The cheats ruin it for everyone, and account for a tax bite bigger than anyone would care to tax the 1%. And Friedman knew it all along.
May his memory be a blessing.
Forgive the formatting of before. I simply did a copy/paste from a pdf file. It has been corrected. Let me know what you think
From a friend.
Hi RGS!!!!
I know it's a bit much to swallow at once. However, it was written to be published as one. If the formatting was distasteful, please accept my apologies and know that it has been touched up.
Hi Perrie,
Here is one on Keynes:
Sorry for using the Journal so much but they have incisive thoughts.
The following copyrighted article is presented under fair use guidelines; statement at end.
The Cliff the Keynesians Built
Temporary tax cuts created the fiscal threat to growth.
'A stimulus program should be timely, targeted and temporary."
Lawrence Summers, January 29, 2008
Well, well. So the folks who have run U.S. economic policy since 2008 are alarmed about the peril of the 2013 "fiscal cliff." Too bad they didn't worry about that when they were creating the very ledge they now lament.
The latest warning comes from the Congressional Budget Office, which estimated in its mid-year budget outlook Wednesday that the economy will return to recession in 2013 if taxes rise and spending falls on schedule in January. "Such fiscal tightening will lead to economic conditions in 2013 that will probably be considered a recession," say the CBO sachems, "with real GDP declining by 0.5 percent" from this year's fourth quarter to the final quarter of next year and unemployment rising to about 9% from 8.3%.
Yes, a year of falling output would "probably be considered" a recession, especially if you are one of the 9% jobless.
Related Video
Editorial board member Steve Moore on whether the fiscal cliff could cause the U.S. to fall into recession. Photos: Getty Images
One point to keep in mind is that CBO's economists are as true-blue Keynesians as exist on the planet. Like the Obama White House and Treasury, they believe in the "multiplier" that $1 of federal spending somehow creates $1.50 in greater GDP. Thus they plug large spending cuts into their economic models, and, presto, they find a recession.
One remarkable (and highly dubious) note in the CBO report is that the budget gnomes predict a big surge in tax revenues in 2013to 18.4% from 15.7% of GDP despite the recession they also predict. CBO simply doesn't think taxes matter much to taxpayer behavior, so it applies the higher rates to its current predictions of income and pretends revenues will roll in like the tides. But this will be a fantasy if enough Americans find ways to hide their income or work less, or if they simply earn that much less thanks to the recession.
The larger policy point is that this is the fiscal cliff the Keynesians built. The 2008 quote above from Larry Summers, the Harvard economist who later became President Obama's chief economic adviser, sums up the mindset that has dominated policy for most of the last decade and especially since 2008.
Rather than provide predictable, consistent policy for the long term, the Summers-Obama-Geithner-Krugman theory goes that government should jolt the economy with spending and tax cuts that are targeted and temporary. The jolt will drive the economy out of recession, rapid growth will resume, and the wizards of Harvard Yard can then tell us the precise moment when the stimulus can be withdrawn and taxes should rise again.
Or, if the jolt doesn't work, then order up another jolt, which makes the tax cliff even steeper.
The last decade has provided as clear a market test of this proposition as one can get. First, the Bush Administration had to accept a temporary window for its 2001 and 2003 tax cuts to pass the Senate's crazy budget rules. Its tax rebate of 2001 was such an economic bust that without the more ambitious and better designed 2003 tax cut Mr. Bush might not have been re-elected. But even the 2003 cut had to be temporary to pass Congress.
Then came the Summers-George Bush-Nancy Pelosi $168 billion tax rebate and spending stimulus of February 2008. That goosed GDP for a quarter as temporary consumer and government spending showed up in the national accounts, but growth quickly sputtered even before the autumn 2008 financial panic.
Enlarge Image
President Obama with Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner, left, NEC Director Larry Summers, right, and Budget Director Peter Orszag, far right.
Then came the $830 billion stimulus of February 2009, followed by other "targeted and temporary" measures like cash for clunkers and the first-time homebuyer's tax credit. GDP rose modestly as the economy recovered, albeit at a historically slow pace considering the depth of the recession. The rate of growth has since sputtered in each of the last three years.
That didn't stop Mr. Obama, who tried still another temporary tax fix after Republicans captured Congress in 2010. He agreed to extend the Bush tax rates for another two years, but only in return for an additional temporary payroll tax cut for one year. When that didn't spur faster growth in 2011, the President demanded and won another one-year payroll-tax extension for 2012. First half GDP growth this year fell again to 1.7%.
***
So here we are now facing the expiration of all of these temporary measures at the same time. And that's not all. You have to add the higher tax rates that Mr. Obama has proposed in his budget, such as the 30% "Buffett rule" tax rate on capital gains. And don't forget the new 3.8% surcharge on investment income that is part of ObamaCare and also starts in January.
The nearby table (Len note: Not available) compares current tax rates with those that arrive next year with the tax cliff, as well as Mr. Obama's budget proposals and Mitt Romney's tax reform plans. Mr. Romney is proposing an across-the-board rate cut, while Mr. Obama would keep rates the same only for those earning less than $250,000. Everyone else would see a huge tax increase, one of the largest in history.
Republicans are pointing to the CBO report as proof of Mr. Obama's policy failure, and it is. But rather than gawking at the potential for another recession, they ought to explain the folly of "temporary, targeted" tax and spending stimulus. The fleeting tax elixir does little to change incentives to work or invest because everyone knows its impact is temporary. It also creates tremendous uncertainty as expiration nears, which can also harm incentives and growth.
The problem is political, but more important it is intellectual. The Keynesians and their allies who have dominated tax policy for most of the last decade (the 2003 bill excepted) need to be exiled back to Harvard, Princeton and Wall Street. And the Romney-Ryan Republicans need to understand and not repeat the Bush mistakes of 2001 and 2008.
Instead of "timely, targeted and temporary," tax policy should include lower rates (and fewer loopholes) that are applied as broadly as possible and are permanent. These were the principles that guided the Reagan policy of the 1980s, and they need to be revived.
Copyright 2012 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved
FAIR USE NOTICE
This message contains copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. I am making the material available for news reporting, criticism, comment, and teaching purposes in an effort to advance understanding of international, political, human rights, economic, democracy, social justice issues, etc. I believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material herein is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for educational and research purposes. For more information go to:
If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
Jonathan,
Oy, I must be talking aforeignlanguage here. I am not promotingKeynsian economics nor Friedman. I am saying that in the real world, mixed markets is the way it works.
Friedman is good for big business, but not for the average working Joe. Keynsianhas can inhibit growth with too much government intervention. But in harmony they can work well together... hence mixed markets.
I am not shocked by your love for Friedman. He's been berry berry good for you. But not so much so for all those jobs who's were shipped off shore.
And the fact that you blessFreedman'sname, only shows how unbiased you are on this subject.
Len,
I am not surprised that you pick WSJ. They love Friedman. It is the paper of big business. Not that there is anything wrong with big business, but they are going to promote the economics that works the best for them. If I put up 10 articles by Paul Krugman, you would say, oh of course, he's theeconomist of government control. Both my and your statement would be correct. But what I actually said is that mixed markets is how the economy really moves. It's not all one or the other. Each provides a specific function an economy.
I would love every American company to have every job domiciledin America. But how can you be a leader in a global economy that way? As a capitalist society, how can you blame companies for putting out the same product for less by offshoring? How can you accept our government charging a higher corporate tax rate than our foreign competitors pay in their home countries?
Keynes is good when the cupboard's full. The cupboard's empty.
What grade did you teach?
Hayek on Keynes (1978)
Not as dramatic as your entries but quite informative I thought .
That does not surprise me . The masses do have a habit of distorting theories over time . The issue today is the choice of reducing the deficit or stimulating the economy . But it is possible that stimulating the economy briefly could result in increased tax revenues . It is the ratio that is in question ...