Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Caused the Current Recession -- Obama Opposed Reform & Ryan Supported Reform
- WSJ REVIEW & OUTLOOK
- August 17, 2012, 6:49 p.m. ET
If Only They Had Listened
Ryan was a voice for Fannie Mae reform while Obama opposed it .
On July 27, 2000, a first-term Congressman from Wisconsin signed his name to the Housing Finance Regulatory Improvement Act. The 30-year-old legislator didn't have much company. Of 435 Members of the House, only 12 were willing to join Paul Ryan in sponsoring a bill to reduce the taxpayer risks at Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
Eight years later to the day, a federal bailout of the two mortgage giants was on its way to the desk of President George W. Bush. Almost $190 billion in taxpayer financing later, the toxic twins of the housing crisis maintain their massive role in mortgage finance.
On Friday, the U.S. Treasury said it is relieving the two government-sponsored enterprises of the requirement to pay regular dividends to taxpayers. Instead, the toxic twins will simply pass to the feds any profits they make. Fan and Fred's investment portfolios will also have to shrink more quickly, which is very good. But the deal suggests that they will continue to slap taxpayer-backed guarantees on mortgage bonds forever, or until there's a reformer in the White House.
If only there had been a few more reformers on Capitol Hill in 2000. Fan and Fred and their army of "affordable housing" lobbyists saw to it that the plan backed by Mr. Ryan never made the House floor. The bill would have limited the assets the toxic twins could hold, increased their capital, added new federal oversight, and removed their credit lines at Treasury.
"In order to maintain double-digit growth," noted Mr. Ryan at a 2000 Congressional hearing, "Fannie Mae will have to take on more and more risk" in order to "increase profitability to shareholders." He added, "This is not a mission of public policy."
As the government-fueled housing party heated up, Mr. Ryan continued to warn that many of Fan and Fred's profit-making activities carried little benefit for homeowners. In 2002, he sponsored a bill to remove the exemptions Fan and Fred enjoyed from the disclosure requirements in federal securities laws.
Mr. Ryan continued his sometimes lonely effort to reform the mortgage giants, for which he endured their usual political wrath. In 2008 he told us that Fannie once called every mortgage holder in his district, claiming falsely that Mr. Ryan wanted to raise the cost of their mortgage and asking if Fannie could tell the Congressman to stop on their behalf. He received some 6,000 telegrams. (See "The Fannie Mae Gang," July 23, 2008.)
Mr. Ryan's embrace of reform in his first term in Congress compares favorably to the efforts of a freshman Senator from Illinois in 2005. President Obama likes to pretend he was a warning voice in the wilderness because he later issued vague statements of displeasure once the housing market was already cracking.
What Mr. Obama doesn't say is that he failed to support any of the serious reform efforts to reduce the role of Fannie and Freddie in the mortgage market. The same is true of old Senate hand Joe Biden. Mitt Romney was never a Washington politician, so he can't be blamed for the legislative failures of the 2000s.
This history bears further study, as Mr. Obama repeatedly attempts to tie the GOP candidates to Washington's policy mistakes leading up to the financial crisis. In Iowa this week, the President said that Messrs. Romney and Ryan are proposing the same economic policies "that got us into this mess in the first place."
The truth is that the President who loves to talk about the "mess" he "inherited" did nothing to prevent it when he had the chance. In contrast, his opponent's new running mate was an early voice for reforms that might have helped America avoid it.

Theabove copyrighted article is presented under fair use guidelines.
FAIR USE NOTICE
This above Wall Street Journal editorialcontains copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. I am making the material available for news reporting, criticism, comment, and teaching purposes in an effort to advance understanding of international, political, human rights, economic, democracy, social justice issues, etc. I believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material herein is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for educational and research purposes. For more information go to:
If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner; The Wall Street Journal.
Following the Clinton dot-com bubble, and the ensuing recession, Pres. George W. Bush also inherited a Clinton real-estate bubble caused directly by the Democratic Community Reinvestment Act (CRA).
Barney Frank famously said he wanted Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to "roll the dice" in the name of affordable housing. He and Senator Dodd created laws that lowered lending standards, forced banks to lend with small or no down payments and, with ACORN's help, put pressure on them to do so. That directly caused the housing bubble, failed banking system and economic mess. The execs of Fannie/Freddie were Democrat politicians who had exorbitant salaries. One was Barney Frank's "partner."
Fannie and Freddie May funded the bubble and gave humongous donations to those congressmen who facilitated unrestricted mortgage growth. Dodd got the most and Obama was close behind him as the second largest recipient of the largess.
This is a good historical article about the contrast between the 2 candidates . Heads up : the WSJ article you published is not available on the front page you linked to .
And somewhere in this discussion is missing the fact thatfinancialinstitutions knowingly turned faulty mortgages, intofinancialinstrumentsand then sold them, bring on the banking crisis. This mess didn't happen from a singular bad choice, but from many.
Exactly.
Alsomortgage'sbrokers selling ARMs to people who didn't have a full understanding of what they were buying. And let's not forget the flipping craze, where people leveraged themselves with their own homes, to make money from the bubble. All of this happened due to lack of regulation. The housing bubble collapse along with the banking was far more complicated than one piece of bad legislation.
I showed it under Fair Use because you need to be a subbscribe.
If the Democrats had not fomented so many bad mortgages, in a misguided quasi-socialist scheme tomake so manyunqualified people homeowners, the faulty mortgages would have never existed. Obama and Biden aredirectly complicit while Bush and Ryan vainly attempted to restrict it with a Democratic Congress.
This is totally ridiculous. It's been going on for months. I would like to put this to bed once and for all.
Max... exactly what is it that you want John to say. There is no way to go back and look for comments, so let's put that aside.
Mike,
I agree. But Max wants some sort of proof, which is impossible to provide, given the limitations of our search engine. So I need to know what Max wants from John to broker a peace.
Or I could push you into the pool for being a nudnick.
Which isn't nice.
Which isn't right either. If someone called me a racist, I'd be damn pissed, and it doesn't hit home. It's the injustice of thatopinion, not that it hit home. It is damaging to ones reputation, and something said long enough can become a false truth in other's heads.
Look, from my perspective, I am trying to put this behind us, since it is a huge unnecessary disturbance to the group. If there is a way to get passed this, I wouldappreciateit.
Of the top of my head , I think the continuing issue is that John is quick to pull out the "racist" accusation ... too quick . I'm not sure he even understands what a racist actually is . I suggest that he defines what that encompasses . Then we might find some resolution .
Rich,
Actually, I just realized that this whole conversation doesn't even belong here. This article is owned by Len and if he comes back and asks me to remove it, I will.
Thank you John. It is deeplyappreciated.
[[Rich , I was in a race relations forum online just about every day for 7 years. I have forgotten more about racism than you have ever known.]]
I still don't think you know what the term means and would like you to give us your definition since you are so quick to pull out the "R" word . You use it . You should be required to define it .
[[If you habitually use race to form judgements about people, good or bad, you are being racist. ]] I can live with that description John . Thanks . The real issue is how do you determine if they are using that type of decision process ?
BTW as to my "non-answers" , you consistently expect every comment to be partisan . That's why you are so confused by mine .
Credit Default swaps are viable financial instruments.
If the ill-given mortgages hadn't caused a housing-price bubble that exploded you probablyy would never have heard of CDSs.
Your accusation is like blaming guns for criminality, or nuclar bombs for Iran.
Robert,
Please give me a link to this Fox video. It is a saver. I don't see why Johnn is still on the podium ignoring plain facts.
LOL, you actually wonder, just see the next post.
It's Wall Street (whatever the hell that is other than a place in NYC!) is the refrain, not the government insisting that banks, Fannie, Freddie make risky loans to horrific borrowers, it's all Wall St.
Because, Perrie, the government DEMANDED they make the loans and they (the government) knew they were toxic, but they were made to minorities, those without the ability to otherwise secure a real mortgage
and the government allowed them to be bundled to freddie and fannie so that the banks would continue to allow them to be made.
Those poor, poor mortgagees, right? Golly gee, they had no idea what an ARM was because they couldn't read, right?
Bull Perrie, they knew, they just didn't care.
And just what would make him think that? LOL.
Hell, you think everyone is a racist who doesn't kiss Obama's and the dem's asses.
Exactamundo.
Obama Sued Citibank Under CRA to Force it to Make Bad Loans UPDATED
Whoa ! That is a serious accusation Len ... very serious .
Terry,
You forget, I used to work for Pru- Bache. Most people don't know what the hell they are buying. No matter how many times I tried to expalin to people who wanted to trade in their standard whole life, which was making 5% for Universal life, which at the time was making 12% but tied toinvestmentreturns, that they could end up paying a lot more or loosing their policy, all they could hear was the advice from their friends. Then I get called into court to testify about unscrupulous practices. Good thing I had them sign my own wavier.
And when we bought our first 2 homes with 15 yearmortgages, all our friends and family said we were nuts. Well we rode that bubble, made a profit, had tons of money from the sale of our first 2 homes, and now live without amortgage. But hey, maybe that has something to do with the fact that I am a CPA with a minor in eco and Matt's degree is in Banking and Finance. Do we sound like a regular Joe or Jorgette to you? I think not.
LOL guys. But using that as a citing is kind of funny. No, it's not biased. Not in the least.
Here's a headline:
Obama made the earth stop turning. People die as they fall off. Film at 11.
Wait Len, let me get this. So the banks had to make up these uselessinstrumentsthat only made them a ton of money, because the socialist made them do it. That is just too funny.
Exactly.
Len, there weremultipleparties at fault here. Yesmortgageswere given to people who shouldn't have gotten them, but there were people who were leveraging themselves to the nth degree to flip, people buying ARMs who wouldn't know type of loan from another, and banks who found a new way of making money. It was a toxic mixture with blame to go all around.
And those are the facts.
Thegovernmentdidn't allow them, they did it without the government even knowing. In fact, Terry, you are making a good case for regulation.
You say it is biased . But if the banks were pressured to get loans out to sub-prime borrowers it is likely that a lot of them would have failed anyway , maybe not as many as failed due to ARMS but quite a few . If the banks were doing sure-to-fail loans why didn't the admin do something to stop them ?
Instead of beating around the bush and blaming financial institutions please recognize the core source of the problem: Fannie and Freddie essentially "bribing" legislators to loosen the mortgage requirements -- which they did. The consequentmushrooming demand for homesis what caused the real estate price bubble that had to burst. The following table lists Fannie/Freddie "donations to legislators in descending order. Note carefully who the top recipients were.
Recipients of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Campaign Contributions, 1989-2008 (Only recipients of over $20,000 shown)
Name
Office
State
Party
Grand Total
Total from
PACs
Total from
Individuals
Dodd, Christopher J
S
CT
D
$165,400
$48,500
$116,900
Obama, Barack
S
IL
D
$126,349
$6,000
$120,349
Kerry, John
S
MA
D
$111,000
$2,000
$109,000
Bennett, Robert F
S
UT
R
$107,999
$71,499
$36,500
Bachus, Spencer
H
AL
R
$103,300
$70,500
$32,800
Blunt, Roy
H
MO
R
$96,950
$78,500
$18,450
Kanjorski, Paul E
H
PA
D
$96,000
$57,500
$38,500
Bond, Christopher S 'Kit'
S
MO
R
$95,400
$64,000
$31,400
Shelby, Richard C
S
AL
R
$80,000
$23,000
$57,000
Reed, Jack
S
RI
D
$78,250
$43,500
$34,750
Reid, Harry
S
NV
D
$77,000
$60,500
$16,500
Clinton, Hillary
S
NY
D
$76,050
$8,000
$68,050
Davis, Tom
H
VA
R
$75,499
$13,999
$61,500
Boehner, John
H
OH
R
$67,750
$60,500
$7,250
Conrad, Kent
S
ND
D
$64,491
$22,000
$42,491
Reynolds, Tom
H
NY
R
$62,200
$53,000
$9,200
Johnson, Tim
S
SD
D
$61,000
$20,000
$41,000
Pelosi, Nancy
H
CA
D
$56,250
$47,000
$9,250
Carper, Tom
S
DE
D
$55,889
$31,350
$24,539
Hoyer, Steny H
H
MD
D
$55,500
$51,500
$4,000
Pryce, Deborah
H
OH
R
$55,500
$45,000
$10,500
Emanuel, Rahm
H
IL
D
$51,750
$16,000
$35,750
Isakson, Johnny
S
GA
R
$49,200
$35,500
$13,700
Cantor, Eric
H
VA
R
$48,500
$46,500
$2,000
Crapo, Mike
S
ID
R
$47,250
$40,500
$6,750
Frank, Barney
H
MA
D
$42,350
$30,500
$11,850
Bean, Melissa
H
IL
D
$41,249
$34,999
$6,250
Bayh, Evan
S
IN
D
$41,100
$16,500
$24,600
McConnell, Mitch
S
KY
R
$41,000
$40,000
$1,000
Maloney, Carolyn B
H
NY
D
$39,750
$16,500
$23,250
Dorgan, Byron L
S
ND
D
$38,750
$30,500
$8,250
Miller, Gary
H
CA
R
$38,000
$31,500
$6,500
Rangel, Charles B
H
NY
D
$38,000
$14,750
$23,250
Tiberi, Patrick J
H
OH
R
$35,700
$32,600
$3,100
Bunning, Jim
S
KY
R
$33,802
$29,650
$4,152
Stabenow, Debbie
S
MI
D
$33,450
$32,000
$1,450
Chambliss, Saxby
S
GA
R
$33,250
$22,500
$10,750
Menendez, Robert
S
NJ
D
$31,250
$30,500
$750
Enzi, Mike
S
WY
R
$31,000
$27,500
$3,500
Van Hollen, Chris
H
MD
D
$30,700
$11,000
$19,700
Landrieu, Mary L
S
LA
D
$30,600
$20,000
$10,600
Murray, Patty
S
WA
D
$30,000
$23,000
$7,000
Clyburn, James E
H
SC
D
$29,750
$26,000
$3,750
Crowley, Joseph
H
NY
D
$29,700
$25,500
$4,200
Sessions, Pete
H
TX
R
$29,472
$24,000
$5,472
McCrery, Jim
H
LA
R
$29,000
$26,000
$3,000
Hooley, Darlene
H
OR
D
$28,750
$19,500
$9,250
Royce, Ed
H
CA
R
$28,600
$4,000
$24,600
Renzi, Rick
H
AZ
R
$28,250
$28,000
$250
Lieberman, Joe
S
CT
I
$28,250
$11,500
$16,750
Baucus, Max
S
MT
D
$27,500
$21,000
$6,500
Moore, Dennis
H
KS
D
$26,550
$25,500
$1,050
Coleman, Norm
S
MN
R
$24,690
$12,000
$12,690
Matheson, Jim
H
UT
D
$24,500
$24,000
$500
Schumer, Charles E
S
NY
D
$24,250
$1,500
$22,750
Durbin, Dick
S
IL
D
$23,750
$14,000
$9,750
Rogers, Mike
H
MI
R
$22,750
$21,000
$1,750
Lynch, Stephen F
H
MA
D
$22,500
$13,500
$9,000
Rockefeller, Jay
S
WV
D
$22,250
$5,000
$17,250
Smith, Gordon H
S
OR
R
$22,000
$20,000
$2,000
Mikulski, Barbara A
S
MD
D
$21,750
$16,500
$5,250
McCain, John
S
AZ
R
$21,550
$0
$21,550
Spratt, John M Jr
H
SC
D
$21,500
$17,000
$4,500
Brown-Waite, Ginny
H
FL
R
$21,000
$21,000
$0
Davis, Geoff
H
KY
R
$21,000
$19,500
$1,500
Velazquez, Nydia M
H
NY
D
$20,750
$16,750
$4,000
Baca, Joe
H
CA
D
$20,500
$20,200
$300
Alexander, Lamar
S
TN
R
$20,500
$20,000
$500
Allard, Wayne
S
CO
R
$20,250
$0
$20,250
Neugebauer, Randy
H
TX
R
$20,000
$20,000
$0
Nelson, Ben
S
NE
D
$20,000
$19,000
$1,000
Total
$4,844,572
$3,017,797
$1,826,775
Len,
I am not saying that Fannies and Freddies were not mismanaged, but they were only part of the equation. You can't blame the whole mess on the democrats. It was a toxic swill.
As for campaign contributions, I am sure I can come up with any such list on questionable senators on a variety of ills in Washington. It doesn't mean anything in the scheme of things. I can show you at least 20 articles written by all kind of economists and they will all say, what I posted to you.
Here is a good overall summary of the events:
The True Origins of This Financial Crisis
By Peter J. Wallison from the February 2009 issue (American Spectator)
Excerpts:
As originally enacted in 1977, the CRA vaguely mandated regulators to consider whether an insured bank was serving the needs of the whole community. For 16 years, the act was invoked rather infrequently, but 1993 marked a decisive turn in its enforcement. What changed? Substantial media and political attention was showered upon a 1992 Boston Federal Reserve Bank study of discrimination in home mortgage lending. This study concluded that, while there was no overt discrimination in banks allocation of mortgage funds, loan officers gave whites preferential treatment. The methodology of the study has since been questioned, but at the time it was highly influential with regulators and members of the incoming Clinton administration; in 1993, bank regulators initiated a major effort to reform the CRA regulations.
In 1995, the regulators created new rules that sought to establish objective criteria for determining whether a bank was meeting CRA standards. Examiners no longer had the discretion they once had. For banks, simply proving that they were looking for qualified buyers wasnt enough. Banks now had to show that they had actually made a requisite number of loans to low- and moderate-income (LMI) borrowers. The new regulations also required the use of innovative or flexible lending practices to address credit needs of LMI borrowers and neighborhoods. Thus, a law that was originally intended to encourage banks to use safe and sound practices in lending now required them to be innovative and flexible. In other words, it called for the relaxation of lending standards, and it was the bank regulators who were expected to enforce these relaxed standards.
The effort to reduce mortgage lending standards was led by the Department of Housing and Urban Development through the 1994 National Homeownership Strategy, published at the request of President Clinton. Among other things, it called for financing strategies, fueled by the creativity and resources of the private and public sectors, to help homeowners that lack cash to buy a home or to make the payments. Once the standards were relaxed for low-income borrowers, it would seem impossible to deny these benefits to the prime market. Indeed, bank regulators, who were in charge of enforcing CRA standards, could hardly disapprove of similar loans made to better-qualified borrowers.
Sure enough, according to data published by the Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University, from 2001 through 2006, the share of all mortgage originations that were made up of conventional mortgages (that is, the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage that had always been the mainstay of the U.S. mortgage market) fell from 57.1 percent in 2001 to 33.1 percent in the fourth quarter of 2006. Correspondingly, sub-prime loans (those made to borrowers with blemished credit) rose from 7.2 percent to 18.8 percent, and Alt-A loans (those made to speculative buyers or without the usual underwriting standards) rose from 2.5 percent to 13.9 percent. Although it is difficult to prove cause and effect, it is highly likely that the lower lending standards required by the CRA influenced what banks and other lenders were willing to offer to borrowers in prime markets. Needless to say, most borrowers would prefer a mortgage with a low down payment requirement, allowing them to buy a larger home for the same initial investment.
The problem is summed up succinctly by Stan Liebowitz of the University of Texas at Dallas :
The point here is not that low-income borrowers received mortgage loans that they could not afford. That is probably true to some extent but cannot account for the large number of sub-prime and Alt-A loans that currently pollute the banking system. It was the spreading of these looser standards to the prime loan market that vastly increased the availability of credit for mortgages, the speculation in housing, and ultimately the bubble in housing prices.
Yep. Fo' shizzle.
Except for that whole nasty business of black men calling themselves niggers instead of calling themselves men. I could expound upon this quite a bit.
You guys stole your house?!? Now that explains the weird statue behind your pipe in that one picture....
Yeah, got to say, that doesn't go over big with me either, Peter.
Dang Randy,
I thought you were a 1%er when I saw your home. You just blew that. LOL!
Mike,
Home ownership is the way to go. It always has been. That is why people came to this country in the first place (after religious freedom). As the Irish put it, to own a piece of the old sod. If you find a home in an excellent location (remember the rules in real estate are, location, location, location), and you get one of these amazing low interest mortgages, in the long haul, you will have one of the best investments out there. The market is now! Every dime you spend on renting is thrown away. It could be used towards a home, something, especially in this market, will make you money.
As one of our former members explained a while back it was more the mortgage brokers than the banks who were behind the sub-prime loan mess .
Exactly.
Subprime Pioneer
Read more:
The banks were just a means to an end; the end being home ownership for those who cannot afford it. Pres. Obama has been pursuing that since being a community organizer and young lawyer.
"To those according to their need. From those according to their ability." It is a form of "sharing the wealth."
Here is a new article about when Citibank was sued in the 1990s for both redlining and being strict in granting mortgages.
With landmark lawsuit, Barack Obama pushed banks to give subprime l...
Published: 1:26 AM 09/03/2012
Read more: ...
Hey,
That's pretty cool. I think though it might fall short on location.
Good question! People here think they need more regulation and, it is not so much them, but the financial institutions that caused the problem with the securitized mortgage backed instruments. But that was exactly the purpose of Fannie/Freeie -- to securitize the mortgages and broaden the market. Here is Wikipedia:
The Federal National Mortgage Association ( FNMA ; OTCQB : FNMA ), commonly known as Fannie Mae , was founded in 1938 during the Great Depression as part of the New Deal . It is a government-sponsored enterprise (GSE), though it has been a publicly traded company since 1968. [ 2 ] The corporation's purpose is to expand the secondary mortgage market by securitizing mortgages in the form of mortgage-backed securities (MBS), [ 3 ] allowing lenders to reinvest their assets into more lending and in effect increasing the number of lenders in the mortgage market by reducing the reliance on thrifts . [ 4 ] For a comprehensive list of articles discussing Fannie Mae, see Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac:
Conflict of interest
In June 2008, the Wall Street Journal reported that two former CEOs of Fannie Mae, James A. Johnson and Franklin Raines had received loans below market rate from Countrywide Financial . Fannie Mae was the biggest buyer of Countrywide's mortgages. [ 66 ] The "Friends of Angelo" VIP Countrywide loan program included many people from Fannie Mae; lawyers, executives, etc. [ 67 ]
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have given contributions to lawmakers currently sitting on committees that primarily regulate their industry: The House Financial Services Committee; the Senate Banking, Housing & Urban Affairs Committee; or the Senate Finance Committee. [ citation needed ] The others have seats on the powerful Appropriations or Ways & Means committees, are members of the congressional leadership or have run for president.
2011 SEC charges
In December, 2011, six Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac executives including Daniel Mudd were charged by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission with securities fraud. "The SEC alleges they 'knew and approved of' misleading statements claiming the companies had minimal exposure to subprime loans at the height of home mortgage bubble." [ 68 ] Former Freddie chief financial officer Anthony Buddy Piszel, who in February, 2011, was CFO of CoreLogic , "had received a notice from the SEC that the agency was considering taking action against him". He then resigned from CoreLogic. Piszel was not among the executives charged in December, 2011. [ 69 ] Piszel had been succeeded at Freddie by David Kellermann . Kellermann committed suicide during his tenure at Freddie.
So who is going to regulate the regulators?
Helping the poor, a safety net, is a noble gtradition in this nation. However, there is help and there is HELP; and it depends on how you define "poor."
Upwards of the 50% of the population who today receive government benefits are beyond poor.
Too many of today's "poor" own homes, carss, TVs, computers, etc. The poor deserve medical treatment but not to see high-priced private doctors. They deserve basic necessities but not luxuries. Today's poorreceive free celphones and phone service. Can cars and one-family homes be far behind?
Len,
You had me on board until this sentence.
So a little poor girl shouldn't get the same treatment for her cancer as someone who has the money to pay for it does? So she dies by virtue of being born to the wrong family?
Mike,
In all seriousness, that above sign and the practice should be illegal.
I read your 2008 article and it is as faulty today as it was then. BTW, where did it get published, if it did, and what is your expertise in the mattrer? You evidently have not read all the evidence presented in this thread.
You assert that "only" 25 % of mortgages fell under CRA. That is a hell of a lot of mortgages and way beyond the margin that could tip the scales to the kind of faulty mortgageavalanch that resulted.
Of course it was not "only" CRA. Greenspan's effort too keep interest rates low too long after the dot-com bubble exploded contributed greatly to the housing price boom. But CRA, even being responsible for 25 % was a key contributor.
The CRA was passed into law by the 95th United States Congress in 1977 as a result of national grassroots pressure for affordable housing, and despite considerable opposition from the mainstream banking community. The CRA mandates that each banking institution be evaluated to determine if it has met the credit needs of its entire community. That record is taken into account when the federal government considers an institution's application for deposit facilities, including mergers and acquisitions.
The bill encouragedFannie Mae to enable mortgage companies, savings and loans, commercial banks, credit unions, and state and local housing finance agencies to lend to home buyers. It also encouragedFreddie Mac to buy mortgages on the secondary market and sell them as mortgage-backed securities on the open market.
Enter Bill Clinton
In 1995, as a result of interest from President Bill Clinton's administration, the implementing regulations for the CRA were strengthened by focusing the financial regulators' attention on institutions' performance in helping to meet community credit needs.
These revisions with an effective starting date of January 31, 1995 were credited with substantially increasing the number and aggregate amount of loans to small businesses and to low- and moderate-income borrowers for home loans. These changes were very controversial and as a result, the regulators agreed to revisit the rule after it had been fully implemented for seven years. Thus in 2002, the regulators opened up the regulation for review and potential revision.
Part of the increase in home loans was due to increased efficiency and the genesis of lenders, like Countrywide, that do not mitigate loan risk with savings deposits as do traditional banks using the new subprime authorization. This is known as the secondary market for mortgage loans. The revisions allowed the securitization of CRA loans containing subprime mortgages. The first public securitization of CRA loans started in 1997 by Bear Stearns. The number of CRA mortgage loans increased by 39 percent between 1993 and 1998, while other loans increased by only 17 percent.
Other rule changes gave Fannie and Freddie extraordinary leverage, allowing them to hold just 2.5% of capital to back their investments, vs. 10% for banks. By 2007, Fannie and Freddie owned or guaranteed nearly half of the $12 trillion U.S. mortgage market. Thus leading us to the problems of today.There were several failed attempts at reeform, the 2000 one that Paul Ryan endorsed and Sen. Obama opposed being just one of them.
In 2003 Pres. Bush again tried to increase regulation of the two agencies but the Democrats in Congress opposed it with Barney Frank again leading the charge, fearingthat tighter regulation of the companies could sharply reduce their commitment to financing low-income and affordable housing.
These two entities Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are not facing any kind of financial crisis, said Representative Barney Frank of Massachusetts, the ranking Democrat on the Financial Services Committee. The more people exaggerate these problems, the more pressure there is on these companies, the less we will see in terms of affordable housing.
Still again in 2005, following a Fannie Mae$10.6 billion accounting scandal, John McCain tried to steer the FEDERAL HOUSING ENTERPRISE REGULATORY REFORM ACT OF 2005 through Congress but the Democrats prevented passage.
Just like all other administrations, the effect of a presidency often isn't felt until after he leaves office. Clinton reaped the benefits of the Reagan/Bush era, and George W. Bush, and Barack Obama had to deal with the problems created by their predecessor.
Bulls--t is as bulls--t does and, in this case, it is all yours.
Len,
Like any story, there are two sides. Wiki put it best:
Both deregulation, and excess regulation, of financial institutions have been blamed for the late-2000s (decade) subprime mortgage crisis in the United States . [1]
Same events, very different causes, right? But can it be proved which is right, or maybe it's a bit of both?
That was an interesting article iar . But it did not say he gave them free cars . You really ought to read the links you post .
[[So a little poor girl shouldn't get the same treatment for her cancer as someone who has the money to pay for it does?]]
That's the way it works now . If you want to change it where is the money going to come from ?
Actually, the various proposed and failed reform acts were designed to increase regulation of mortgage lending because CRA lacked sufficient protection against misuse.
The bank problem was separate as they created financial instruments for bundled mortgages that were removed from the oriinal mortgages themselves in that many failed mortgages would sink the instruments but trading losses would not neccessarily sink the mortgages. It was the former that occurred and the banks entered crisis conditions.
I did not saythat free cars were given; merely speculating about where we might be headed.
But I am shocked Romney preceded my speculation with actualization. He claimed it saved money in the long run. I would have to check that.
I received a free college education and the government has gotten their costs back many times over in the increased taxes I pay. But that does noot mean applicationto everything is beneficial.
Same treatment but administered by a beginning practitioner,resident or intern; not by a Fellow with a six month waiting list of payers and who does not accept Medicaire.
Of course, presumably, the Fellow is more accomplished but all the poor cannot be treated by the Fellow while the other doctors have no patients.
I elaborated in a subsequent message (just above this one due to posts not being in chronological order). Tell me if I make sense.
Good morning iarnuocon,
I have been dealing with the issue and, by your personalizing it and attempting to demonize me, perhaps your name should be iarnuolib. Your criticizing the Wall Street Journal while citing the American Prospect, and Paul Krugman (a former Enron advisor) gives away your proclivities. The American Prospect is a monthly American political magazine dedicated to American liberalism . Saying that President Obama was not yet in the Senate in 2000 shows that, while you are capable of generating thousands of words quickly, you are not a careful reader. To quote my lead-in article:
"Mr. Ryan's embrace of reform in his first term in Congress compares favorably to the efforts of a freshman Senator from Illinois in 2005. President Obama likes to pretend he was a warning voice in the wilderness because he later issued vague statements of displeasure once the housing market was already cracking.
"What Mr. Obama doesn't say is that he failed to support any of the serious reform efforts to reduce the role of Fannie and Freddie in the mortgage market. The same is true of old Senate hand Joe Biden. Mitt Romney was never a Washington politician, so he can't be blamed for the legislative failures of the 2000s."
Nevertheless, I credit you with a strong if selective case and I have not the time or research facilities to respond to every sentence. This is a complicated issue and I never laid the blame solely on the CRA but also cited Greenspan's Fed's extended low interest rates as part of the cause and I readily agree that there were likely other factors too.
Following is part of an editorial in Investor's Business Daily, Community Reinvestment Act: Separating Fact From Fiction , in response to your post:
In light of the Obama administration's stated goal of expanding the CRA, separating fact from fiction regarding this issue is of towering importance to set the historic record straight and to prevent another financial calamity.
FICTION: Because the CRA was passed in 1977, long before the subprime crisis, it couldn't have caused the recent explosion in bad loans.
FACT: The toothless 1977 regulations fully expired in July 1997, when President Clinton rewrote them to toughen CRA enforcement as part of a crusade to close the "mortgage gap" between blacks and whites.
For the first time, banks were required to show results. One of the five performance criteria in the "lending test" the most heavily weighted component of the CRA exam was adopting "flexible lending practices" to address the credit needs of poor borrowers in "predominantly minority neighborhoods." Banks that didn't bend their underwriting rules risked flunking the exam.
Ex-Federal Reserve Board Gov. Lawrence Lindsey, a staunch CRA defender, acknowledges that the changes "did contribute to a downgrading of credit standards."
Under Clinton's CRA "investment test," moreover, banks for the first time earned CRA credit for purchasing subprime securities. A wave of these securitizations in the secondary mortgage market and on Wall Street began in 1997, which also happened to mark the start of the housing bubble.
Other changes transformed the once-dormant act into a weapon in the hands of Acorn, Greenlining and other shakedown groups who were quick to brand banks with prudent lending requirements as "racist."
Clinton empowered the groups by making their public comments about bank lending in urban areas a key part of CRA evaluations and giving CRA credit to banks that provided them grants and other payola.
FICTION: "Many of these (CRA) loans were not very risky," the FCIC report claims.
FACT: Studies show that CRA loans have higher delinquencies and defaults and act as a major drag on bank earnings. In 2008, CRA loans accounted for just 7% of Bank of America's total mortgage lending, but 29% of its losses on home loans. Also, banks with the highest CRA ratings tend to have the lowest safety and soundness ratings.
FICTION: Only 6% of subprime loans were originated by banks subject to the CRA, so the vast majority of risky lending was not tied to the law.
FACT: Among other things, the figure does not count the trillions of dollars in CRA "commitments" that WaMu, BofA, JPMorgan Chase, Citibank, Wells Fargo and other large banks pledged to radical inner-city groups like Acorn, Greenlining and Neighborhood Assistance Corp. of America (NACA) after they used the public comment process to protest bank merger applications on CRA grounds.
The CRA requires the Federal Reserve to consider the CRA performance of the bank seeking such approvals. It's the law's chief enforcement mechanism. And community organizers exploited it to a fare-thee-well.
All told, they shook down banks for $4.6 trillion in such commitments before the crisis, boasts a report by the National Community Reinvestment Coalition, or NCRC, the nation's top CRA lobbyist (which conveniently removed the report from its website during the FCIC hearings).
FICTION: The Fed "never considered pledges to community groups in evaluating mergers and acquisitions," the FCIC report claimed, failing again to tell the full story.
FACT: The Fed based its decisions in large part on input from CRA advocacy groups, who gave a thumbs up or down to the proposed mergers depending on how much the banks pledged in new urban lending. So these pledges were a form of ransom that banks paid to groups holding their expansion plans hostage.
"Banks had the impression that they could not obtain regulatory approval of a merger or acquisition unless they made all the advocates 'go away happy,'" said former JP Morgan Chase officer Mark Willis, as quoted in "The Great American Bank Robbery."
Don't take his word for it. Listen to Washington's top CRA lobbyist tell it.
"The federal agencies are required to consider public comments in issuing CRA ratings and rendering decisions on merger applications. Comments on a bank's CRA record often bolster the bank's performance," NCRC President John Taylor said in 2007. "CRA agreements are often negotiated between banks and community groups during the merger application process."
FICTION: "These commitments were generally promises by financial institutions to lend," claimed FCIC Chairman Phil Angelides, and they weren't necessarily fulfilled.
FACT: The NCRC said banks followed up on their commitments. A study by the Brookings Institution concluded that they "consistently" met their targets.
The University of Connecticut tracked $1 trillion in loan commitments pledged since 1993 and found that by 2000 the banks had made well over $600 billion of the loans.
FICTION: "These loans performed well," the FCIC report maintained.
FACT: Brookings found that the loan commitments were set aside for low-income minorities with "marginal credit scores" and posed a higher risk. They were even riskier than regular CRA loans, because the banks delegated underwriting authority to the nonprofit shakedown groups, which had no experience judging credit risk.
NACA thinks traditional underwriting standards are "patronizing and racist." It advertises that anyone "regardless of how bad your credit is" can qualify for the mortgages it's arranged through special deals with banks. Not surprisingly, one study found that its delinquency rates were eight times higher than the national average.
Banks reported delinquency rates ranging from 5% to 50% on loans made pursuant to their merger-related commitments.
Yet the FCIC refused to investigate the more than 300 CRA agreements that banks and community organizers entered into before the subprime bubble burst.
Despite repeated requests by Commissioner Peter Wallison, the panel never examined the performance of the trillions in loan commitments.
"Commission management constrained the staff in their investigation into CRA by limiting the number of document requests and interviews and by preventing staff from following up with the institutions," said Wallison, a former Reagan Treasury official.
Without seriously looking into the issue, the FCIC published a report absolving the CRA of any blame for the financial crisis.
Why would Chairman Angelides steer blame away from the CRA? Because he's a big fan of the CRA. And as California state treasurer, from 1999 to 2007, he steered billions in state funds into unsafe CRA mortgages securitized by Freddie Mac.
At the time, Greenlining advised Angelides on where to invest California state funds, even providing him with its own CRA report card on "good" and "bad" banks. He has also personally benefited from CRA projects brokered by his real estate development firms, according to "The Great American Bank Robbery."
As part of the CRA racket, Angelides should have been a witness in the crisis investigation, not its chief inquisitor. With the cover-up complete, he now hopes that CRA critics will go away.
"The debate about the role of the CRA should now be over as evidence presented in the commission's report is clear," Angelides declared earlier this month.
Sorry, sir, but the debate will end when the public has all the facts, not just your cooked report.
You are clearly a nasty person.;
Of course he's a nasty person, a bright, biased, nasty person, but still nasty.
As am I. As are, methinks, most of us when push comes to shove.
Well, except Perrie, I guess, she's an indie! (LOL, which means lib dem in real world speak!)
Perrie,
Just because it is not the COMPLETE and absolute ENTIRE reason, does not mean itwas not the predominant reason.
This reminds me of dems lying about the cost of medicare, and how it is so much less expensive than private insurance.
And to come to that conclusion they lie like hell, to the press (who eat it up) and to the American people! All so that the scum in office (and those living in Chicago of course) can be reelected and gain more power and wealth.
Dems lie! Pubs may as well, but nowhere near the extent dems do.
Planting Seeds of Disaster
Y ouve got only a couple thousand bucks in the bank. Your job pays you dog-food wages. Your credit history has been bent, stapled, and mutilated. You declared bankruptcy in 1989. Dont despair: You can still buy a house. So began an April 1995 article in the Chicago Sun-Times that went on to direct prospective home-buyers fitting this profile to a group of far-left community organizers called ACORN, for assistance. In retrospect, of course, encouraging customers like this to buy homes seems little short of madness.
Militant ACORN
At the time, however, that 1995 Chicago newspaper article represented something of a triumph for Barack Obama. That same year, as a director at Chicagos Woods Fund, Obama was successfully pushing for a major expansion of assistance to ACORN, and sending still more money ACORNs way from his post as board chair of the Chicago Annenberg Challenge. Through both funding and personal-leadership training, Obama supported ACORN. And ACORN, far more than weve recognized up to now, had a major role in precipitating the subprime crisis.
Ive already told the story of Obamas close ties to ACORN leader Madeline Talbott, who personally led Chicago ACORNs campaign to intimidate banks into making high-risk loans to low-credit customers. Using provisions of a 1977 law called the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA), Chicago ACORN was able to delay and halt the efforts of banks to merge or expand until they had agreed to lower their credit standards and to fill ACORNs coffers to finance counseling operations like the one touted in that Sun-Times article. This much weve known. Yet these local, CRA-based pressure-campaigns fit into a broader, more disturbing, and still under-appreciated national picture. Far more than weve recognized, ACORNs local, CRA-enabled pressure tactics served to entangle the financial system as a whole in the subprime mess. ACORN was no side-show. On the contrary, using CRA and ties to sympathetic congressional Democrats, ACORN succeeded in drawing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac into the very policies that led to the current disaster.
In one of the first book-length scholarly studies of ACORN, Organizing Urban America , Rutgers University political scientist Heidi Swarts describes this group, so dear to Barack Obama, as oppositional outlaws. Swarts, a strong supporter of ACORN, has no qualms about stating that its members think of themselves as militants unafraid to confront the powers that be. This identity as a uniquely militant organization, says Swarts, is reinforced by contentious action. ACORN protesters will break into private offices, show up at a bankers home to intimidate his family, or pour protesters into bank lobbies to scare away customers, all in an effort to force a lowering of credit standards for poor and minority customers. According to Swarts, long-term ACORN organizers tend to see the organization as a solitary vanguard of principled leftiststhe only truly radical community organization.
ACORNs Inside Strategy
Yet ACORNs entirely deserved reputation for militance is balanced by its less-well-known inside strategy. ACORN has long employed Washington-based lobbyists who understand very well how the legislative game is played. ACORNs national lobbyists may encourage and benefit from the militant tactics of their base, but in the halls of congress they play the game with smooth sophistication. The untold story of ACORNs central role in the financial meltdown is about the one-two punch to the banking system administered by this outside/inside strategy.
Critics of the notion that CRA had a major impact on the subprime crisis ask how a law passed in 1977 could have caused a crisis in 2008? The answer has a lot to do with ACORN and the critical years of 1990-1995. While the 1977 Community Reinvestment Act did call on banks to increase lending in poor and minority neighborhoods, its exact requirements were vague, and therefore open to a good deal of regulatory interpretation. Banks merger or expansion plans were rarely held up under CRA until the late 1980s, when ACORN perfected its technique of filing CRA complaints in tandem with the sort of intimidation tactics perfected by that original community organizer (and Obama idol), Saul Alinsky.
At first, ACORNs anti-bank actions were relatively few in number. However, under a provision of the 1989 savings and loan bailout pushed by liberal Democratic legislators, like Massachusetts Congressman Joseph P. Kennedy, lenders were required to compile public records of mortgage applicants by race, gender, and income. Although the statistics produced by these studies were presented in highly misleading ways, groups like ACORN were able to use them to embarrass banks into lowering credit standards. At the same time, a wave of banking mergers in the early 1990s provided an opening for ACORN to use CRA to force lending changes. Any merger could be blocked under CRA, and once ACORN began systematically filing protests over minority lending, a formerly toothless set of regulations began to bite.
ACORNs efforts to undermine credit standards in the late 1980s taught it a valuable lesson. However much pressure ACORN put on banks to lower credit standards, tough requirements in the secondary market run by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac served as a barrier to change. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac buy up mortgages en masse, bundle them, and sell them to investors on the world market. Back then, Fannie and Freddie refused to buy loans that failed to meet high credit standards. If, for example, a local bank buckled to ACORN pressure and agreed to offer poor or minority applicants a 5-percent down-payment rate, instead of the normal 10-20 percent, Fannie and Freddie would refuse to buy up those mortgages. That would leave all the risk of these shaky loans with the local bank. So again and again, local banks would tell ACORN that, because of standards imposed by Fannie and Freddie, they could lower their credit standards by only a little.
So the eighties taught ACORN that a high-pressure, Alinskyite outside strategy wouldnt be enough. Their Washington lobbyists would have to bring inside pressure on the government to undercut credit standards at Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Only then would local banks consider making loans available to customers with bad credit histories, low wages, virtually nothing in the bank, and even bankruptcies on record.
Democrats and ACORN
As early as 1987, ACORN began pressuring Fannie and Freddie to review their standards, with modest results. By 1989, ACORN had lured Fannie Mae into the first of many pilot projects designed to help local banks lower credit standards. But it was all small potatoes until the serious pressure began in early 1991. At that point, Democratic Senator Allan Dixon convened a Senate subcommittee hearing at which an ACORN representative gave key testimony. Its probably not a coincidence that Dixon, like Obama, was an Illinois Democrat, since Chicago has long been a stronghold of ACORN influence.
Dixon gave credibility to ACORNs accusations of loan bias, although these claims of racism were disputed by Missouri Republican, Christopher Bond. ACORNs spokesman strenuously complained that his organizations efforts to relax local credit standards were being blocked by requirements set by the secondary market. Dixon responded by pressing Fannie and Freddie to do more to relax those standards and by promising to introduce legislation that would ensure it. At this early stage, Fannie and Freddie walked a fine line between promising to do more, while protesting any wholesale reduction of credit requirements.
By July of 1991, ACORNs legislative campaign began to bear fruit. As the Chicago Tribune put it, Housing activists have been pushing hard to improve housing for the poor by extracting greater financial support from the countrys two highly profitable secondary mortgage-market companies. Thanks to the help of sympathetic lawmakers, it appearedthat they may succeed. The Tribune went on to explain that House Democrat Henry Gonzales had announced that Fannie and Freddie had agreed to commit $3.5 billion to low-income housing in 1992 and 1993, in addition to a just-announced $10 billion affordable housing loan program by Fannie Mae. The article emphasizes ACORN pressure and notes that Fannie and Freddie had been fighting against the plan as recently as a week before agreement was reached. Fannie and Freddie gave in only to stave off even more restrictive legislation floated by congressional Democrats.
A mere month later, ACORN Housing Corporation president, George Butts made news by complaining to a House Banking subcommittee that ACORNs efforts to pressure banks using CRA were still being hamstrung by Fannie and Freddie. Butts also demanded still more data on the race, gender, and income of loan applicants. Many news reports over the ensuing months point to ACORN as the key source of pressure on congress for a further reduction of credit standards at Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. As a result of this pressure, ACORN was eventually permitted to redraft many of Fannie Mae and Freddie Macs loan guideline.
Clinton and ACORN
ACORNs progress through 1992 depended on its Democratic allies. Whatever ACORN managed to squeeze out of the George H. W. Bush administration came under congressional pressure. With the advent of the Clinton administration, however, ACORNs fortunes took a positive turn. Clinton Housing Secretary Henry Cisnersos pledged to meet monthly with ACORN representatives. For ACORN, those meetings bore fruit.
Another factor working in ACORNs favor was that its increasing success with local banks turned those banks into allies in the battle with Fannie and Freddie. Precisely because ACORNs local pressure tactics were working, banks themselves now wanted Fannie and Freddie to loosen their standards still further, so as to buy up still more of the high-risk loans theyd made at ACORNs insistence. So by the 1993, a grand alliance of ACORN, national Democrats, and local bankers looking for someone to lessen the risks imposed on them by CRA and ACORN were uniting to pressure Fannie and Freddie to loosen credit standards still further.
At this point, both ACORN and the Clinton administration were working together to impose large numerical targets or set asides (really a sort of poor and minority loan quota system) on Fannie and Freddie. ACORN called for at least half of Fannie and Freddie loans to go to low-income customers. At first the Clinton administration offered a set-aside of 30 percent. But eventually ACORN got what it wanted. In early 1994, the Clinton administration floated plans for committing $1 trillion in loans to low- and moderate-income home-buyers, which would amount to about half of Fannie Maes business by the end of the decade. Wall Street Analysts attributed Fannie Maes willingness to go along with the change to the need to protect itself against still more severe congressional attack. News reports also highlighted praise for the change from ACORNs head lobbyist, Deepak Bhargava.
This sweeping debasement of credit standards was touted by Fannie Maes chairman, chief executive officer, and now prominent Obama adviser James A. Johnson. This is also the period when Fannie Mae ramped up its pilot programs and local partnerships with ACORN, all of which became precedents and models for the pattern of risky subprime mortgages at the root of todays crisis. During these years, Obamas Chicago ACORN ally, Madeline Talbott, was at the forefront of participation in those pilot programs, and her activities were consistently supported by Obama through both foundation funding and personal leadership training for her top organizers.
Finally, in June of 1995, President Clinton, Vice President Gore, and Secretary Cisneros announced the administrations comprehensive new strategy for raising home-ownership in America to an all-time high. Representatives from ACORN were guests of honor at the ceremony. In his remarks, Clinton emphasized that: Out homeownership strategy will not cost the taxpayers one extra cent. It will not require legislation. Clinton meant that informal partnerships between Fannie and Freddie and groups like ACORN would make mortgages available to customers who have historically been excluded from homeownership.
Disaster
In the end of course, Clintons plan cost taxpayers an almost unimaginable amount of money. And it was just around the time of his 1995 announcement that the Chicago papers started encouraging bad-credit customers with dog-food wages, little money in the bank, and even histories of bankruptcy to apply for home loans with the help of ACORN. At both the local and national levels, then, ACORN served as the critical catalyst, levering pressure created by the Community Reinvestment Act and pull with Democratic politicians to force Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac into a pattern of high-risk loans.
Up to now, conventional wisdom on the financial meltdown has relegated ACORN and the CRA to bit parts. The real problem, weve been told, lay with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. In fact, however, ACORN is at the base of the whole mess. ACORN used CRA and Democratic sympathizers to entangle Fannie and Freddie and the entire financial system in a disastrous disregard of the most basic financial standards. And Barack Obama cut his teeth as an organizer and politician backing up ACORNs economic madness every step of the way.
Stanley Kurtz is a senior fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Institute
Franklin Raines Criminal Enterprise and Barack Obama, His Accomplice
September 15, 2008
...
As an executive at Fannie Mae, Franklin Raines illegally coerced his employees to falsify accounting facts so hed get a maximum bonus. The government-backed firm used Enron-like fraud, in part at Rainess orders, to create the largest bail-out in US history. Raines had the whistleblower fired. From the Heritage Foundation:
From the ACU:
Now, this criminal is Barack Obamas campaign adviser. Only one member of Congress, Chris Dodd, received more kickbacks from Rainess Fannie Mae croniesthan did Barack Obamaover $120,000 in bribes.
Campaign Contributions, 1989-2008 ( source )
PACs
Individuals
Dodd has been in Congress since Moses was a baby. What did Obama do in 2.5 years to earn nearly as much cash from Frannie and Freddie as Dodd earned in 25?
Remember Countrywide? According to BusinessWeek Obamas financial adviser , Raines, was responsible for its demise, too:
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac control almost 50 percent of all mortgages in the United States. They were started by Democrats, protected by Democrat, funded by Democrats, and absorbed into the government proper at the behest of their paid hacks in the Democrat party. Conservatives have advocated the demolition of these twin towers of corruption, fraud, and bribery for decades. But Democrats blocked every attempt to even hold hearings on corruption in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
But where are the Congressional hearings? Where is the Department of Justice? Why arent Raines, Johnson, and Obama doing a perp walk on the evening news?
Because liberals OWN Washington. Obama will threaten, lie, and kill if he must to keep his sham campaign going. At this point, he must win to stay of prison.
I cannot believe that conservative bloggers and talk show hosts are staying away from this story. This should be the end of Barack Obama, particularly after todays disaster on Wall Street: Dow down >500, Lehman Brothers GONE, Bear Stearns GONE, Merrill Lynch GONE, Fannie Mae GONE, Freddie Mac GONE, AIG GOING, more to follow.
Lehman Brothers, too, contributed the lions share of its political donations to DEMOCRATS. Why dont you people rise up and demand some goddamn ACCOUNTABILITY! This isnt some little $10 million Chrysler bailout here. Were talking BILLIONS of STOLEN MONEY. Stolen by Democrats, for Democrats.
We could face an economic DEPRESSION because of Obama, Dodd, Biden, Frank, Pelosi, Kennedy, and the rest of the Democrat criminals whove destroyed the housing market, put families on the streets, and wrecked Wall Street through greed and avarice on a scale unseen since the Roman Empire!
WAKE UP AND TAKE IT BACK! Its YOUR MONEY .
Ill say it again without any fear of error: Franklin Raines is a criminal and Barack Obama is his paid accomplice. Prove me wrong.
*UPDATE 1/4/2009: Michelle Malkin has a wonderful post on original reporting by conservative bloggers . While this piece might not be original, the analysis certainly is. This is, as far as I can tell, the only graphical analysis showing that Barack Obama received more money from Frannie Mae and Freddie Mac crooks than any otherpoliticianwhen measured in dollars per day in office.
RADICAL IN CHIEF
Chapter 6 ACORN part III
Posted on September 2, 2012 |
This post continues the series of chapter summations of Radical-In-Chief by Stanley Kurtz. Today we cover the final portion of Chapter 6 which touches on President Clintons contribution to ACORN and his administrations assistance to ACORNs drive to dramatically increase the amount of outstanding mortgages to high credit risk housing buyers.
*****
RADICAL IN CHIEF
Chapter 6 ACORN part III
Bank Fairs were held where banks were asked to attend and interact with the communities they served. At these events the banks were asked to pledge to meet the reforms outlined by ACORN, i.e. to lower their standards set for mortgage qualification. Retribution fell upon those who declined.
In July of 1992, the delegation from Citibank left an ACORN Bank Summit Fair without agreeing to ACORNs terms. Within days, a group was organized that disrupted Citicorps headquarters in NY with songs and chants. Later, in August, officers and staff from Citibank-Chicago were invited to a gathering of about 400 people from the community. They were given prestigious seating on the stage in view of everyone in attendance. And then ACORNs banking specialist, Ernestine Whiting, took the podium and mercilessly berated the bankers sitting on the platform. According to Kurtz, the Citibank people were shaking in anger over the treatment to which they had been subjected. But it worked. Eventually Citibank relented and agreed to increase the amount of their sub-prime lending in accordance with ACORNs terms.
Bill Clintons appointed a man named Henry Cisneros as of Secretary of Housing and Human Development. Cisneros was one of the first Hispanics to be elected mayor of a large city. He knew ACORN well and was familiar with their confrontational tactics. In his first meeting with the organizations leaders he made it clear he had no problem with the aggressive tactics. In fact, unsolicited, he offered ACORN government funding. The meeting lasted an hour longer than scheduled, and that hour was devoted to exploring ways to channel money from the federal coffers to help support ACORNs activities.
Then in July of 1994 President Clinton met personally with a delegation from ACORN. The group found a receptive audience in the President as they explained that their agenda included expanding the reach of the Community Reinvestment Act to go beyond just the banks. They wanted mortgage brokers (as lenders) and insurance companies (as investors) to meet sub-prime quotas as well. ACORN had already convinced Allstate to put $10 million into the funding of sub-prime mortgages.
The author believes ACORN leaders realized their housing activities could contribute to a financial crisis of sorts, but it is doubtful any of them anticipated the extent of the mess that actually occurred. It is unlikely the creation of a crisis was intended, but should one occur it would be seen more as an opportunity than as a failure. Leaders Peter Dreier and Frances Fox Piven taught that any financial crisis is an opportunity to condemn capitalism as a failure and proclaim socialism is the solution.
What fiction? Are you defending ACORN's treatment of Citi or denying it? Were you there?
I'd like to know what the fiction was as well . But I suspect he won't be back to reply to that .
[[if you want me to go on record as saying that, although the cars themselves were free, Mitt's program did not actually dole them out, but rather "only" paid for insurance, inspection, excise tax, title, registration, repairs and a AAA membership for cars that other people donated to welfare recipients, I'm fine with that.
Which is pretty close when you think about it.]]
That's what you call close ? You can sit down now but do it gently . You wouldn't want to squash your brains ...
I don't know qabout pressure from ACORN but Obama definitely was about pressuring banks into writing failure prone mortgage loans .