╌>

A rock and a hard place

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  neale-osborn  •  14 years ago  •  61 comments

A rock and  a hard place

I'm not a huge fan of my former brother in law. Didn't like him in school, didn't like him when my sister dated him, didn't like him when they married, didn't like him when he left my sister and his son to "Find himself". So imagine my extreme distaste when I have to (sorta) support him. I think drug laws are wrong. PERIOD. Prohibition only does four things- Raises the street cost of whatever is prohibited. Creates a criminal class out of otherwise law-abiding people who wish to continue a formerly legal activity. Creates a powerful, rich, and often violent criminal class to fill that desire. And create a powerful, rich and often violent enforcement class to deny that desire.

My former brother in law just got busted with over a million in cash, 100 kg of pot for re-sale, and for money laundering. And the only thing I can say is "Why the FUCK did you risk jail time when you have a 11 year old son who needs a Daddy available. You may not be the best Daddy out there, but you ARE his Daddy." I don't care if he broke laws I find in-Constitutional. I don't care if he screwed the IRS out of taxes (YES, criminally obtained cash is STILL supposed to be declared and taxes paid on it!) I don't care if he had un-registered guns in the house. I only care that by doing this, the government thugs may take monies he paid to my sister and nephew (grudgingly, rarely on time, and penny-pinching though the payments were) under the RICO act, and he has deprived a wonderful kid of a Dad, unless the poor kid wants to visit him in a federal pen.

So, what do I do? I support his right to engage in this trade freely. I support his right to own guns without government permission. To the best of my knowledge, he did NOTHING violent during the course of these activities. For this, he has lost his home, his car, all of his money, his guns, his freedom, and what time he had to spend with his (admittedly estranged) family. I DO NOT, however, support his risking my sister's financil health, my nephew's mental and financial health, and whatever social stigma is sure to come once the boy's father's activities are common knowledge to his classmates. Yup, a rock and a hard place.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Here we totally agree!

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

First off, Robert, I tend to agree about his character. He has none. He's a person whp measures your value via your wallet. But his SON loves his dad. So I want the kid to have a father figure. as it stands, MY father is 74, doesn't likecommotion too much, and is in constant pain, so he's crotchety at best. And Dominic and my sister live on the same property. My father actually tries to be a male influence, but just isn't up to the task. I live 300 miles from them. I am there for Dom as much as possible, and I've offered summer on the farm anytime he wants it.

Fortunatley, on the shared custody thing, it took an act of god to get mike to spend more than daytimes every 2 weeks with his son, and never at the house. I'll give Mike the benefit of the doubt and pretend it was to keep Dom away from the drugs. But I doubt it. it's because he just doesn't have much interest in the kid.

I understand your point about laws. Here's the point, from MY viewpoint. Laws designed to fail, as ALL drug laws are by their very nature, should never be passed in the first place. Work on changing the reasons people do the drugs to excess if you want to battle the bad side of the so-called illicit drugs. As proven in the 1920s with the Volstead Act, prohibition doesn't work. All it does is create criminal classes to provide the prohibited product, whatever it may be. Of the 3.5 MILLION people in jail today, over 2 million are there for drug related offenses. At $35,000 a piece average cost for a year of incarceration, we'd save over $70 BILLION a year. Imagine the resources we could devote to solving the underlying problems leading to drug abuse if we simply HAVE to stop assholes from destroying their lives. I'm not a fan of drug cops. Big deal. my son wants to be a cop, and I support him. Cops generally speaking follow orders. Just like the military. Opposing this ridiculous War on Terror doesn't mean I hate our soldiers anymore than opposing our ridiculous War on Drugs means I hate our cops.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Well thought out, and well said.

Of course, being that I consider all taxation theft............Grin.gif

I might not totally agree on taxes raising the cost. But, to be honest, since 90 oxycodone cost (from the pharmacy at Wal Mart) about $40, and from what I can find out, sell for $5-10 A PILL on the street, I think the overall costs will STILL be cheaper for the people who use them, AND the taxes can be used to apy for problems caused by abuse rather than ME AND YOU paying for the problems.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

John,

Most of the people serving time on drug charges, are not big wig drug dealers, but addicts, who will come out and start using again. We waste millions of dollarsincarceratingthem. I'm all for getting rid of lawsprohibitingdrugs.

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   leonahardware    14 years ago

These kind of stories are really sad, and at the same time make me mad.

I would really like to be a pot head, but....I have children, and a job, and go to school. My son (15) is always asking me about the green stuff. I tell him that it should be legal, but as long as it's not, it's not worth it.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

I smoked it a bit when in my 20s. Then I decided I didn't like to be that mellow, so I stopped pot. Booze makes me hornier, and I need to sleep occasionally, so I don't have more than 2-3 drinks a year. Cigarettes raise your blood pressure. A BP induced stroke means "Never again" for cigarettes. Well, that and Annette would castrate me if I ever was dumb enough to smoke again.

Nope, MY vices are shooting, horseback riding, and sex with my wife. That'll have to do me!!Grin.gif

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   leonahardware    14 years ago

It should be legal, but not for children,

I agree with this to a degree. The agreement part is that drugs (green and white) are much more available to children than alcohol. Why? Because alcohol is a highly regulated, legal industry. In Oregon, it's only sold in state regulated liquor stores, with the exception of beer and wine, which is sold in every grocery store and convenience store. Drugs, on the other hand, are being sold by people that are already breaking the law and they really have no moral issues with selling to the underage crowd.

Something (this is only one out of many) that really upsets me about the drug laws is that if a child is caught with drugs, arrested and convicted of drug charges, they are not able to access financial aid (other than loans) for education. No grants, no tax deduction, nada! Not so with alcohol. Aaargh!

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   leonahardware    14 years ago

Booze makes me hornier, and I need to sleep occasionally, so I don't have more than 2-3 drinks a year.

Poor Annette! Only 2 - 3 times a year?Frown.gif JK

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Here's where things get........ sticky. There are 50 year old people who aren't adults yet. And 12 year olds who are. "Legal Adult" is a term I despise. Though it has no (current) legal existance, I prefer the term "Self Sufficient Individual".

What IS a Self Sufficient Individual? It is a person who has literally or figuratively stood before the community and taken responsibility for his/her debts, obligations, and decisions. Call it a universal Bar Mitzvah. "Today, I am a citizen, not a Child". Once this is done, while parents are still quite capable of aiding their child, they are under no LEGAL obligation to do so. The person who has done sois the sole responsible party for their actions. They can be sued, arrested, or rewarded for their actions. They are now adults. I am willing to bet that you are at the least uncomfortable with this. I am not putting you down for that, believe me. A little later, I'll dig out an article I wrote about "Legal Age of Majority". But for now, my company just showed up, so I have to finish checking my e-mail them go be a good host!!

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

24.gif Silly girl, getting hornier means that the 2-3 times a year I get to SLEEP are eliminated. "All sex and no sleep makes Neale a VERY tired boy!"

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

Im one of those Libertarian People mentioned several times in the threads above, who feel that the entire War on Drugs is nothing but a waste of time, money, and effort. The only reason for it to exist is for the revenue that is generated by it through fines and confiscation of money, and for the industries and professions that have sprung up because of it such as private prisons and rehab centers, and for the local, state, and federal employees continued employment in such jobs as guards, cops, ATF agents, and such.

I just dont see where the government has the right to tell a person that they can or cannot take certain chemicals into their body.

Caffeine? OK

Codeine? Only with a Dr.s script.

Nicotine? Sure, if you are 18.

Alcohol? Only if youre 21.

Cocaine? Oh, no. You cant have that. Its bad for you.

Marijuana? No, No. Its a gateway.

How does a person taking any of these affect any other person in the world? And dont give me the line about they hurt people when they drive cars under the influence, or they cant hold jobs or function in society because of their abuse of these substances. As long as I can buy beer at Wal-Mart, or Jack Daniels at the corner liquor store, these arguments just dont hold water.

For a moment, lets look at a scenario:

A cop is sitting behind a billboard on a dark country road. In the distance he sees the first and only car that he has seen in 4 hours, and the only car on the road. He points his radar gun at the car, and clocks it at 10 MPH over the speed limit. As the car passes by, he pulls onto the road behind it, and follows, noticing that a tail light is not working.

He flips on his red lights to make the stop. The driver dutifully pulls over, and stops, and the officer walks up to the window where he sees the driver and a known hooker, her still holding the money from their business arrangement.

He asks for license, insurance, and registration. The drivers license is expired, his insurance is out of date, and his registration has expired.

He asks the driver to step from the car. As he exits the car, the officer smells beer, and asks the driver to blow into the Breath-A-Lyzer. He blows a .10, which is above the legal limit.

He handcuffs the driver, and begins a search of the car, finding a loaded .38 hand gun, a half empty beer, 2 joints, 3 vicaden, and a small amount of cocaine.

The officer arrests the driver, calls a tow truck to impound the car, and transports the driver to the waiting jail.

Now what harm has this man really done? Has he hurt anyone? Has he infringed on anyones rights? Has he caused any economic damage to another party? Have any of his actions tonight had any detrimental effect on another partys life, liberty, property, health, welfare, or pursuit of happiness?

Has he done anything at all to actually deserve to be incarcerated?

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

No, not unless he gets in an accident. And I, too, am one of those "horrible anarchistic Libertarians".

Pleeased t'meetcha!

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

That's the whole problem. He has not been in an accident. He was not even driving wrecklessly. He was going faster than a sign said he should. That's what started the whole sequence of events. No wreck. No harm. No injuries. Nothing. Just going faster than .GOV said he was allowed to go.

We have ventured into the realm of Phillip K. Dick, and science fiction. We are anticipating crimes that have not happened.We are prosecuting Pre-Crimes, because it might happen. Did you ever read "Minority Report"? (The movie sucked. Tom Cruise Sucks. Read the book.)

We have devolved from a country of independent, capable people who declared our rights to aKing, and took themback unto ourselves,to a nanny / police state in which we have no rights unless .GOV allows us to have them, and we meekly give up more of them day by day.

And this is not a Red/Blue, Right/Left, Repub/Dem, Cons/Lib thing. It is every administration and every majority party that has held office for the last 75 years or more, just chipping our freedoms and rights away a bit at a time until we can't even put a fence around our back yard anymore without a permit.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Captain,

Love your Phillip K Dick reference. Made my day!

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

I'm here to please.

If I can make your day, then mine, too, is made.

Glad someone got it. 3.gif

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

We deserve the government we settle for. And this is what we keep settling for.

But that don't make it a good one, or mean that we have what we should have.

Only that the American peoplehave becometoo apathetic, lazy, uninformed and sheepish to do anything about it.

Otherwise, it would never have degraded to this.

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   leonahardware    14 years ago

Sorry it took so long for me to get back to this. Been busy playing in the desertGrin.gif

I am willing to bet that you are at the least uncomfortable with this.

That would be a bet that you would lose. From my own experiences growing up, I would have been much better off to have been able to make my own decisions at a younger age, and been held responsible for my actions. Same for my children. My boys (26 and 15) are both independent men. My 26 yo has worked from the time he was 12 and is now supporting 3 beautiful little girls. My 15 yo is making personal choices that aren't harming anyone (no, it's not smoking the green), but if he were caught, would cost ME a lot of money, time, and responsibility that I don't have and shouldn't have to bear. Then there's my daughter. At 23 yo she's still not ready to accept the responsibilities of adulthoodFrown.gif It's very frustrating for her very independent minded mother to see her like this.

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   leonahardware    14 years ago

In my mind, I've been toying with the idea of there being no crime unless there is a victim. I simply haven't been able to put it into the proper context like you have been able to do. Thank you!

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

So sadly true.Frown.gif

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Glad to lose that bet.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

There are, in fact, no "victimless crimes". And ALL true crime is property crime. It involves TAKING someone's property from them without their express consent. Women own their bodies. rape makes un=permitted use of her property. Property crime. A murder victim OWNS their life and body. The murderer stole them from the victim. Drunk driving is only a crime if you injure someone or damage property. Prostitution is a business deal, UNLESS the prostitute is forced into the trade, THEN it is slavery, a property crime.

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

In my own mind, and my humble (yeah, right. Humble old Pat 78.gif ) a crime is committed when one person infringes orviolates the rights of another.

In rape, murder, or robbery, the victim's rights are violated, because a woman has the right to choose who she has sex with, a person has the right to life, and a robbery is a violation of property rights.

If my actions have no consequences (adverse or otherwise)for anyone else on the planet (therefore in the universe as far as we know) then how have I committed a crime?

If a person has a few drinks, and has a wreck while driving under the influence, then someone's rights have been violated, whether they be in the damage inflicted uponthe other person'scar, or in injury to the other driver.

When a rape occurs, someone's rights have been violated, as the woman was forced to do something against her will.

Unless someone can show the actualharm of a person's actions, or how someone else suffered some type of damages due to his actions,I don't see how he can be prosecuted, and I don't see where a crime has been committed.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Here's another thing everyone tends to overlook. The "criminal repays his/her debt to society". How is that justice? The actual victim gets the shaft, society pays for the care and upkeep of the criminal, and somehow this pays the criminal's so-called debt to society. The debt is to the victim. NOT to "society".

What we need is a Victim's Justice System, rather than a Criminal Justice System. We need restitution made for crimes committed, rather than incarceration. Return your victim to the state in which they would have been in before the crime, or get the fuck out of our society. As in escorted to the border and booted out.

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   leonahardware    14 years ago

What we need is a Victim's Justice System, rather than a Criminal Justice System.

I like that idea! How would that work? We would still need the courts and attorneys and such, and they would need to get paid. Not arguing the idea, just looking at the reality of implementing.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

The guilty party pays for all.

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

One of the things I have long promoted was the scrapping of the "Innocent by reason of insanity" plea. In these cases, there is usually no dispute as to whether the party in question committed the crime. Most of the time, it is freely admitted. But they claim they are not guilty, because they weren't in their right mind at the time.

Since it is a foregone conclusion, usually to the point of admitting to the fact, that the charged party did in fact commit the crime, thento me, it is much more logical to have a "Guilty, but Insane" plea.

Then the only thing the court is deciding is whether you are fit for trial and punishment or not.

If you are found to be sane, you go to jail. If you are found to be insane, you go to an institution. The question the court has to decide is not whether you did it, but where you will spend the rest of your life.

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   leonahardware    14 years ago

I can't argue with that, but what happens when the guilty party is not able to pay for their crime? Again, not arguing the idea, just looking at some of the details and the questions that my mind conjures.

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   leonahardware    14 years ago

Isn't the wording of things interesting sometimes? The words take on a whole new meaning. Also, the idea of having the court decide "where you will spend the rest of your life", seems more efficient and appropriate.

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

The person who speeds while in possession of contraband is waving a red flag.

Why is it contraband? Who does it hurt? How are anyone's rights being violated by anything the person in my scenario possessed? How does the government have the right to declare some things contraband, and others not? This is your opinion and bias showing.

I would suspect that he is not operating with a clear mind when he should be trying to remain invisible to the police.

You would suspect. How do you know his state of mind? Who gets to decide whether a person's mind is clear or not? These are questions that are brought about by a nanny state. What qualifies you, or anyone else, to judge my state of mind from my driving by at 10 MPH over the speed limit, with a burned out tail light, while NOBODY else is on the road or being endangered by these actions? How can anyone make this statement? Suspecting something does not make it true.

It may be a symptom of his intoxication.

It may be a symptom of his intoxication. Who said he was intoxicated? I said he was over the legal limit. Levels of blood alcohol affect different people in different manners. The word intoxicated was not used in the scenario. Again, you are projecting your own bias and opinion into the situation.

He got caught because was not capable of clear reasoning, which is also why he should not have been driving.

You have evidence that he was incapable of clear reasoning? Was that presented as a fact in evidence? Again, your own bias. You are judging a persons capabilities of clear reasoning from seeing him drive by with a burned out tail light.

For people who believe in unlimited liberty, from guns to drugs, I would like to see an indication of the responsibility and judgement that should go along with any right and any freedom.

Have you read the constitution? There is no criteria for rights. You have rights, and they are yours to excercise, whether you can satisfy someone else's opinion of whether you deserve them or not. Why do you, or anyone else for that matter, deserve to have conditional approval as to whether someone else may excercise or possess their rights? WTF?

Does a person with guns, drugs, speeding, seemingly oblivious to those red flags, strike you as the poster child for unlimited freedom and liberty?

The person has done no harm to anyone. The person has done no damage to anyone's property. The person has not infringed or violated the rights of anyone else. The person has caused no harm to befall anyone. The person has not done anything detrimental to society. The person has not done anything seditious, evil, contemptous, nor harmful to any living thing. How is he, in your opinion, an example of why rights should be nullified?

It could just have easily been this scenario:

A couple went on vacation to a resort up north. The husband liked to fish, and the wife liked to read. One morning the husband came back from fishing after getting up real early that morning and took a nap.

While he slept, the wife decided to take the boat out. She was not familiar with the lake, so she rowed out and anchored the boat, and started reading her book.

Along comes the Game Warden in his boat, pulls up alongside the woman's boat and asks her what she's doing? She says, "Reading my book."

The Game Warden tells her she is in a restricted fishing area and she explains that she's not fishing. To which he replied, "But you have all this equipment. I will have to take you in and write you up!"

Angry that the warden was being so unreasonable, the lady told the warden, "If you do that, I will charge you with rape."

The warden, shocked by her statement, replied, "But I didn't even touch you."

To which the lady replied, "Yes, but you have all the equipment!"

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

CK- My brother from another mother. That was a perfect response. I can add nothing more.

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

Thankyewververmuch.

I just vented there for a minute. Can't understand how people justify the removal of rights unless thier own personal criteria are met to earn them back.

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

I don't think that anyone can judge someone's regard or disregard, or whether recklessness is present.

I never said that death has to be the result for a crime to have been committed.

I am not stating that reckless disregard is a right. I am stating that you deciding what is reckless disregard, or the state deciding what is reckless disregard, and prosecuting on themere potential for harmis wrong! Unless there is a result of that "reckless disregard" that is all that it is. POTENTIAL. The potential for harm exists in many activities, practices and products, but we do not ban them.

Again, you are stating facts that were not in evidence in the scenario, and therefore unknown to you or anyone else (reckless disregard) , and introducing elements that were not presented (schools, neighborhood streets).

I believe that, unless someone else's rights have been violated, harm has come to someone else, or to their property, property has been taken from a person without their consent, or damage has been incurred by a party who is not a willing participant in the activity that caused it, that no crime has been committed.

If all the things you mention above are actually crimes, then how come they cannot be prosecuted criminally unless they are actually witnessed by a police officer?

Why can you not file charges against someone for speeding in a school zone? Why can you not file charges against someone for speeding down your neighborhood street? Why can you not file charges against someone for driving while intoxicated?

Because they are crimes against the "State". Misdemeanors, that must be witnessed by the "State" to be prosecuted. What I am stating is that the "State" has no rights to prosecute a person for crimes that are percieved, created, and enforced by the state, because the "State" is not harmed, violated, nor damaged by these actions, therefore it is not a victim.

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

Again, you are putting your opinion where facts are not in evidence.

I do not agree that speeding is a crime. I do not believe anyone on this planet has the ability to determine that every driver has the abiliity to operate a motor vehicle safely up to and including a specific speed, and that above that speed lies inherent danger. I do not believe that driving 19 miles per hour keeps children safe, and that 21 mph puts their lives at risk.

I believe that unless I have caused an accident, I have operated my vehicle in a safe manner.

I believe that unless I have run over and injured orkilled a child, I have not run over and killed a child.

I believe that unless I have hit another car, I havenot hit another car.

I believe that the potential for an accident to happen is not a crime.

And I believe that those who desire to deem to place themselves in the position of being the grantor or revoker of rights, based upon their own opinions of "stupid, careless, or intoxicated" and see themselves as capable of interpreting another's care about and worthiness of liberty being "granted" their rights and liberties are, at heart, tyrantical,dictatorial, egomanical, and sociopathic.

But, that's just what I believe.

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

And, I must wonder, who was harmed? And how on earth you or anyone else is OK with a person being arrested for writing something, thinking something, or stating an opinion.

It is now a crime to make a statement? It is a crime to issue an insult? It is a crime to be stupid? It is a crime to say something, print something, think something?

April the 4th, 1984. To the past, or to the future. To an age when thought is free. From the Age of Big Brother, from the Age of the Thought Police, from a dead man... greetings.

Entry in Winston Smith'sJournal

1984, George Orwell.

Welcome to the machine.

Pink Floyd

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago
Why do you turn a clown who hangs his ass out into Thomas Jefferson writing to the King of England?

And why do you turn him into Hitler or Capone? If he was, indeed, merely a "clown who hangs his ass out" then why bother with him?

I again say, until he has done something, he hasn't done anything. He hasn't even attempted to do anything.

Saying it, thinking it, threatening it, insinuating it, wishing for it, hoping for it, wanting it, or talking about it is not doing it.

He committed a thought crime. Nothing more, nothing less.

When thinking becomes a crime, thought stops.

.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Democracy is based on the assumption that a million men are wiser than one man. How's that again? I missed something.
Autocracy is based on the assumption that one man is wiser than a million men. Let's play that over again, too. Who decides?

Robert A. Heinlein, who also said

Does history record any case in which the majority was right?

There are NO societal rights. ALL rights are the rights of individuals. They are NOT collective. They are NOT additive. 1,000,000 people who do not like nudity do not have the right to tell one person who does that he may not go about unclothed. They may have the power to do so, but they have not the right.

And therein lies the problem with the entire concept ot democracy. It presupposes that 10 people have the right to trample the rights of one. Might does NOT make right. It may well make possible, but it sure as hell does not make right.

Damn, guys! Whose cheerios did you piss in to get deleted??

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

I don't know how to move them, or I would have already. It was getting hard to find the

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Thanks for the heads up, Robert. I thought you guys had ticked off a moderator! Grin.gif

While I obviously disagree with you, I AM enjoying the discourse.

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

I don't know what happened above. I was trying to say that if I had known they could be moved, and how to do it, I would have done so myself, as it was getting difficult to find the correct reply button.

I don't have a problem with a civil law suit, or a restraining order being filed because of something like this. I don't have a problem with documenting and establishing that a threat has been issued or conveyed in some manner. I don't have a problem establishing that the person at whom the written or spoken threat was aimed is in fear, and intends on protecting themselves from that threat.

My problem is that you stated he was arrested, and thereforecould presumably face jail time, for writing something on the internet.

He didn't do anything. He didn't attempt to do anything. He didn't try to hire somebody to do something. He got arrested for thinking about doing something and writing about doing something.

If that is not a thought crime, I cannot fathom what would be. He was, according to you, arrested for thoughts and writings.

By definition, he was arrested to prevent a crime from happening. If that is, as I posted above, in the realm of Phillip K. Dicks' "Pre-Crime" what is it?

I say it again, when thinking becomes a crime, thought stops.

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

I'm not sure of your meaning.

I don't think the man should have been arrested. Period. A threat is not a crime.

You stated in the original post that he was arrested, and my post above is that if that is true, he was arrested to prevent a crime (the threatened assault), not for committing a crime.

I really do not care how the threat was conveyed, whether it was via writing, speech, through the mail, voice mail, text, or smoke signals. It was a threat, and nothing more. If he was, as you stated, arrested, he was preemptively arrested for a crime he had not committed, and thus my reference to Phillip K. Dick and "Pre-Crime".

If someone wants to record, document, and timestamp a threat in preparation for a possible self defense claim, I have no problem with it. If someone wants to take some type of civil action in the courts regarding a threat, I have no problem with that. But I do not think a person should be arrested for something that they have not done, and even if he has made a threat, he has not done anything except think about doing something and talk or write about doing something.

I feel the same way about conspiracy charges. Thinking about something, or even planning how to do something, is not doing it.

If thinking about committing a crime were illegal, there would not be enough jails to hold all of the criminals.

I hope that clears it up.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Most jurisdictions have, in fact, gone to "Guilty but Insane." FYI.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Great idea, KK.........except for one teeny little problem. Granting the state the power to execute criminals is not in my lexicon. I am TOTALLY in favor of the death penalty, but it needs to be carried out at the scene of the intended crime, at the hands of the intended victim or armed citizens preventing or stopping the crime.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

If the threat were credible, and the person was capable of carrying it out (IE present, with the means) he would be shot. Because the police are 30 minutes from me, I would only call them to clean up the mess.

Hey, YOU asked!!

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

I'd ignore it, and keep a weather eye out for him, and instruct my wife to do the same. And if he showed up, warn him to leave, maintain a close eye on him, and drop him in his tracks if he attempted to harm me or mine. Again, using your example of living 30 minutes away, he's as far away as the nearest cop. No need worrying about him or calling them, just excercise caution. Which I always do, anyway. He's not a threat, immediate or otherwise, until he tries something. The moment he does, THEN it is a legitimate threat, and is responded to with the level of force I deem necessary to protect my family. Since I am handicapped, it's going to be two in the chest. I can't outrun a small child.

 
 
 
CaptainKidd
Freshman Silent
link   CaptainKidd    14 years ago

^^^^ What he said. ^^^^

I've been in that position, and that's exactly what my actions were. Fortunately, the idiot didn't follow through and actually do any harm, as he decided that the pistol I was pointing at him was much more serious than any actual intent that he had to follow through with the threats he had made.

Neale, as you said earlier.

You do, indeed, sound like my brother from another mother.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Robert- a good question. and deserving of an honest answer. I do not hold with prisons. PERIOD. I hold with restitution, execution, or expulsion.

Restitution- returning your victim to the state he would have been in had you not committed your crime.

Execution- at the hands of the intended victim at the scene of the intended crime (or by a bystander coming to the aid of the victim), NOT BY THE STATE.

And finally;

Expulsion- A no-frills no expenses paid trip to the nearest border, and a firm boot to the ass over said border, for ANY AND ALL convicted criminals who either committed a crime for which they cannot make restitution (murder, or any other crime for which nothing physical was stolen and the victim will not accept cash as adequate recompense, possibly rape, kidnappings, etc), or they refuse to make restitution.

So, to answer your question, yes, to a large part, it IS because the threat does not merit stealing liberty to prevent action. I hope this answers your question fully. If not, I am here to answer further or to discuss it.

As an aside, you are being very polite on this topic, and I am enjoying the discourse. Unlike when someone here from the Windy City starts "discussing" things, even though it is obvious we disagree, you are keeping it all pretty above-board, and I appreciate it. While I have no problem slugging it out, I prefer people who converse rather than combat during a political discussion. Thanks!!

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

I'm going to ask an odd question. Why do you need a government? I will give you MY answer to what I require from a government after I hear yours (I know, but I don't want MY answer to color yours, and MINE has been pretty much identical for years, so your answer can't color mine! Grin.gif ) When I give you MY answer to this question, it will clear up a lot about most of your questions regarding my response.

As to your new question, I'll be blunt. I will never report anything to the police unless it is necessary for an insurance company to have a police report to settle the claim, or there is a body to dispose of. Or at the specific request of another, for THEIR sake. I WOULD, however, inform Joe of Fred's threats, and if Joe asked me to, repeat my information to the police to aid Joe. I have no right to prevent Joe from taking the steps HE deems necessary to protect his family or self. I would, most likely, refuse to testify in court unless Fred had carried out one or more things I had heard him threaten. Meaning, if Fred were arrested solely for the threat and not the act, I would refuse to testify. Is that what you wanted to know??

 
 
 
Kara Shalee
Freshman Silent
link   Kara Shalee    14 years ago

Wow, Neale, families, huh? This guy sounds like a real loser from the word go, and you seem to have known that. Yet I have to agree with you that as criminal activity goes, possession of marijuana is pretty low on the scale. I agree that violent criminal behaviour should be separated out from non-violent criminal behaviour. And also, that families shouldn't have to pay the price of either of the above. His 11 yr old is caught in the net. There's no escaping that. So, your sister, why does she have to pay for his actions? Due to being married to him? Wow, it seems like divorce might be a good idea here. Then again, you can't force that idea on anyone. What a mess. Sorry Neale, your nephew doesn't deserve such a thing happening in his young life. And your sister didn't deserve any or it. I hope she will get out of Dodge before further screw ups ensue. Because they will. Oh, this is really awful.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

They had been legally seperated for 3 years. he got arrested on a Friday, she filed the divorce on Monday. But the problem is, they were legally married when he committed the "crimes". Fortunately, it has developed that Mike had a legitimate job as well, and all her support payments came out of the account he had his paychecks direct deposited into, and nothing BUT his paychecks went in and nothing but his bills came out. So he can document that not one penny of the so-called illicit money went to her or the child.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Robert,

I was wondering when you were going to get into infrastructure. In a country that's 3000 miles wide, kind of important. Also, let's not forget the protection of our ports as well as theirmaintenance.

 
 
 
Kara Shalee
Freshman Silent
link   Kara Shalee    14 years ago

I guess this article is about two things here. I kind of focused on the family aspects. Of course we need government. The current issue seems to be how much of it and why, and how our tax money is spent. So, that's a pretty lengthy discussion.

Your brother in law just sounds like a scumbag, Neale, and for that I am very truly sorry. He has managed to screw you, his child, his wife, and Americans at large. Since he didn't feel that paying his taxes was important, and he doesn't feel that the laws on the books are important either.

So, this guy is a jerk all the way around. I DO NOT advocate that we don't need a government, and really, Neale, you had to be pretty angry when you wrote this. Who wouldn't be? I doubt very much that you are advocating for no government whatsoever, are you? I'm not you, so I'm asking. Situations like these from "family members", well they just hurt really bad, and I think you feel for his child and your sister.

The rest of us may feel that he doesn't have any rights, since he blew them off so easily. This guy isn't a good citizen, he isn't a model citizen in any sense of the word. And it's now affecting his family who may lose everything over him.

Again, I'm so sorry that you had to have this level of loser in your family, Neale. I hope it gets better, but it's probably not going to. Sorry you are going through this,

Kara

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Weelll, I don't want to upset you, Buuutttttt.... This was written 9 months ago, on NV. and I still mean it. I can think of onlyone single solitary thing the government does that cannot be done better by private enterprise. And it refuses to do that one single thing correctly. Protect our border. IF it needs protecting. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Robert,

What kind of work did you do, if you don't mind me asking? I am assuming from your comment that you are retired now.

It's like schools. When you have kids your school tax seems fairer than when you don't, or no longer have young children, from a purely selfish point of view.

True, kind of. Here on LI we have local school districts. We decide on the amount of tax we are willing to pay for education, The school districts that produce the best students often have the highest school taxes, but often along with that is ties home values. Where many parts of the nation were hit with majordepreciation in home values, we were not. My home is worth about what I paid for it still. So good schools do have a value at least here.

and think that government taking over schools has been disastrous

I agree. I think that school systems should be kept small and local with the community making decisions, not the government.

I'm really getting scared, Robert. We've been agreeing a lot lately.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Kara Shalee
Freshman Silent
link   Kara Shalee    14 years ago

Well, then Neale, you may get your wish after all. The alternative is a Corporate Raider type of take over. Are you for that?

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

How does buying a service you wish to buy from the company of your choice automatically turn into "corporate raiders"? I'mfairly sure, hell, I am absolutely positive, that eliminating government involvement in all these services will not lead to corporate raiders ruling all.

however, as it stands, I AM 100% positive that having the government able to compel participation in, and payment for, these so-called services is definitely not conducive to freedom.

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    14 years ago

Can I just come an punch him in the face?Grin.gif

For being

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

No,

Shit splatters, and I don't want you to get dirty........ well, unless I get to scrub you!!Grin.gif

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    14 years ago

I say legalize all drugs, and treat the user the same as someone who uses alcohol. If you don't drive drunk and are over 21, you can buy alcohol and drink it and get wasted by it, but as long as you don't harm someone while under the influence, it is legal. Make the same laws regarding drugs, sell them legally, tax them, and as long as the user harms no one but him or herself, leave them the hell alone. We have too many useless laws anyway... let's get rid of the ones that are costing more than they are saving and stick with the few that we really need.

Just my 2-cents' worth.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Neale Osborn    14 years ago

Not a fan of taxation...Grin.gif but otherwise, I totally agree.

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    14 years ago

I always love a good scrubbin.

 
 

Who is online