"Why do you really need..............." Why this argument should never be answered. (WARNING- Rough language contained)
We hear it every day. Tax and spend liberals ask "Why do you really need to earn over a million dollars a year." Eco-nazis ask us "Why do you really need that SUV or pickup truck." Anti-gun people ask us "Why do you really need a ______________(fill in the blank with the style of firearm that is the flavor of the week to oppose)" Mayor Bloomberg tells New Yorkers "Why do you need a soda larger than 16oz?" And to be honest, ALL these questions deserve one, and only one, answer.
"It's none of your fucking business why I want it."
I am not under any obligation to justify my choices in life to anyone, and neither are you. If you want to eat a tofu burger, I'll never ream you out for it. Want to cram yourself into a Smart-4 Two car? Go for it. I don't mind picking them out of the grill of my F150. (That's a joke, lighten up already!!)((Although they DO tend to cut airflow to the radiator))And it's none of YOUR business why I want a Colt 1911A1, a Springfield Armory M1A, or a Thompson. But why, I hear you ask, should we never answer the question? It's simple. And I said so, the other day on NewsVine.
There is no need to justify what weapons you own. Any more than there is any reason to justify what type of computer you own, what type of book you read, what type of booze you drink, or what the sex is or number of partners you choose to sleep with. By attempting to present disarmers such as yourself with "legitimate reasons" for owning ANY TYPE of weapon, I would be buying in to your argument that there needs to be a reason to own it in the first place. And I do not.
So, the next time some left-wing loon demands to know why you want to own and carry a handgun, or some right-wing religious nutcase asks you why you choose to smoke pot or area gay or want to marry whoever you wish,you tell them "It's none of your fucking business why I want it." Or do it, or whatever. Because the moment you try to "justify it" or "Give a logical reason why you......" you have bought into their logic. You grant that you need a reason to excercise your rights. So, unless you actually believe you NEED a reason to excercise your rights, don't give'em one. I don't. Not anymore.
(The preceeding was a copy of a NewsVine article of mine from Sinday July 15th, 2012)
Preferred protocal for replying to this article- Please feel free to aim comments at the author any way you feel. I will respond as (or if) I choose. But play nice with others here, unless they are someone you are positive will not be upset by the language you use. Let's all try to be a little bit considerate. Myself included. However, the warning in the title should leave others prepared for ..... STRONG language!

Not you. So why bother replying? Not that I care if you do, just wondering why you bother. Betcha didn't even read the whole thing to see if there was anything there for you!
I suppose we get caught up in answering these questions to show ourselves and the world that we can articulate our reasons for whatever it is we do. Had I known that it would result in a debate to the deathagainst some holier-than-thou asshole, it would appear that your type ofresponse would be far more economical.
That said, there should be no reason to have to justify the rights that our country has already given us. And as far as the less-than-legal things are concerned, I would have to wholeheartedly agree that is nobody's fucking business.
Cheers!
John,
Neale is quite correct; you should read the entire article. Do not just apply it to guns though. There are many times when you might be asked "Why do you need" to do something or to be somewhere or to own something. If you find that the question is about something that you have a right to do, and is intrusive and agenda driven, then the correct answer should always be "None of your fucking business".
Neale ,
I hope you realize this is a 2 edged sword you are swinging . If taken to extremes it means you can't ask your wife : "Why do you need that $500 pair of shoes ?"
Fortunately for me, My wife would NEVER pay $500 for a pair of shoes. For a revolver, sure. But SHOES? Nope.
"Nobody asked me why I wanted a 30 round clip."
answer-
"IRS agents. You KNOW they hunt in packs!"
(Scuffs toe at the dirt) Awww, Shucks. 'Tweren't Nothin' but common sense!
Sounds like you have chosen well Neale ...
The only other concern I have is how you go about handling the financial decisions of your kids ... especially girl kids . I don't have any kids but from what I've seen girls can become a bottomless money pit very easily .
Let me tell ya a story, my friend........
We home school. One of the boys asked for the third new Video game in a month (at $65 a pop). So I explained life to them all the way I learned about money. My Mom dressed me from the Sears&Roebuck Back To School catalog, back in the 1970s. Four pairs of jeans- 1 green, 1 brown, one black, and one plaid. Usually, PASTEL plaid. four button down shirts. One green, one brown, one plaid pastel, and one white. Buster Brown's. It was horrible. Big collars, white tee shirts, hideous jackets she sewed herself. Come the end of school, cut the pants into shorts. I begged for several years for Levi's and flannel or denim shirts. Finally, early one spring, I asked what I could do to get her to buy me Levi's. "When it's YOUR money, Neale, you can wear what you want. When it's MY money, you wear what I want." Epiphany. At twelve, I learned that he who buys, decides. We were NOT well off. Dishpan soup, canning what we grew, make our own ketchup and spaghettis sauces, not because they were better, though they were, but because if we didn't, we didn't HAVE them. So, for our Bicentennial, 12 year old Neale went to work. Unknown to them, I borrowed $20 from Grampa and bought a lawnmower. all summer long, while THEY were at work, I mowed lawns around town. In a week, I paid Grampa back. He'd helped pick it out and showed me how to maintain and sharpen the blades, AND he kept his mouth shut, so I paid BACK $25. Come late August, I said to Mom "Take me to Sears to buy my clothes for school, please, Mom." She told me "Not til next week. I'm broke today." "But I'm not Mom, let's go!". Being a good Mom, and wanting to "teach me a lesson about cost", she complied. First, she asked for gas money. $5 gave her more than half a tank. We left, her looking slightly incredulous. We got to Sears, and I asked her where the Levi's were. She asked me "Do you know how expensive they are, Neale? You can get TWO pairs of Sears pants for one pair of Levi's." "Yeah, Mom. But Sears jeans are nasty. Levi's are COOL." So, to humor me, she let me pick out 4 pairs. Boot Cut Levi's. AWESOME! Next, shirts. 3 flannel shirts, black and red, blue and gray, green and black. One red denim shirt. Cowboy boots. socks. A 4 pack of colored pocket tees. We went to pay for them. The girl rang them up, and asked Mom for $120 +/-. and Mom told her with a wink, "Oh, I'm not buying these, HE is." Imagine the look in her eyes when I whipped out my wallet, extracted 7 $20 bills, and paid. From that day forward, I bought my own clothes unless they were presents. I began slipping money INTO her purse every time I could. by 14, I was paying board so I could eat more of what I wanted, and not be forced to eat all my pea soup because children were starving in China.
My kids asked why I told them this. My answer. "While I am the one paying, I'll decide when you can have a game. And the answer, today,is NO!!" ALL my kids know that when Dad or Mom want to give them a game, we'll tell them. Because we live in the boonies, they can't easily go earn money from the neighborhood. So they know that when they want something, they need to ask what they can do to earn it. Sometimes, theanswer "No need." And sometimes, it's extra chores. But they never have to justify it. They DO, however, have to earn it.
Great story Neale ! Thanks for sharing ...
I must ask a question, since you made a point of saying it. Why do you home school? Being both a parent and a public school teacher, I am curious.
As for making kids work for the things that they want, I am in total agreement. Kids need to know that they have responsibilities as well as what it takes to make a dime.
Uh Oh...... maybe I shouldn't answer!
The truth? It sure as shit ain't for religious reasons! It's for historical reasons. I collect old history textbooks. I hate the way they keep re-writing history every time some group gets offended at some point made in a textbook. I don't know if California still uses it, but in the late 90s, my Sister in law lived in LA. She is a liberal gun hating pain in the ass. She copied and mailed me a section of an eight grade text, dealing with the Bill of Rights. Every Amendment carefully explained. Except for #2. It was described as "An outmoded Amendment, whose need has been eliminated by the formation of the national Guard, and soon to be repealed."
Then, I got into a discussion with two teachers from our school district. A pair of idiots. I asked them questions that were part of teh curriculum I studied in school. Clueless. "We don't teach that anymore." Next, the school is 5 minutes away. and it takes 45-50 minutes each way to get there on teh bus. Last, in the three years prior to my oldest's scheduled first day of school, TWO of our bus drivers had alchohol related crashes. IN the bus. on the way to school.
Since I had honors English and History my entire school career, and my wife has degrees in biology, zoology, and math, we decided not to use the state-sponsored indoctrination centers provided for me for only $5600 a year in taxes. Remember, YOU asked!!
I did and your answer makes sense given what you told me. I thought that all of NY had local schooldistrictsthat they support and the parents are involved in. I picked moving to Roslyn because of their schools. They are ranked among the highest in the nation. The parents are part of the teacher picking process and make up the school board, which makes up thecurriculum. . We use "normal" social studies books, and our children have a debate team, where issues are present pro/con and winning is on how well they made their case, not by the favored issue of the moment. Their teacher who taught my kids government and economics was a conservative, who told the students up front about his view. He also invited open discussion on alternative views.
And I get all this for only $16,000 a year in school taxes, LOL! Hey, but I picked this school district, so I suck it up. It did my kids well, and they graduated with honors, and they will be attending Johns Hopkins this fall. They know that getting in is half the battle, staying in is the other half... time will tell.
Sure! More often than not, I am only curious why people do what they do. I don't tend to judge. My kids make their own informed decisions and often even though they are identical twins, they don't agree and they don't agree with Matt or me either. We taught them to be curious and to ask questions and to think.
They do. I spent 3 years of my life defending people against them in audits. Not fun.
It woulda been easier if you just shot'em. All it takes is a varmint tag.
Sure but then they smell up the landscape and no self respecting vulture will go near them. Not sure if it's because they don't like the taste or if it's professional courtesy.
So what did those damn Californians do? They let her move to Kalamazoo.
Ditto
Chances are the ones your son got are a hell of a lot better as well!
I have a buddy who fought in the Vietnam war, he has about ten Colt 1911's that he told me he bought for five bucks a piece from guys who were discharging!
Amazing.
The DHS just ordered over 500 MILLION rounds!
I just say, "Does it matter?" or something smartass [I know... Big surprise] like, "What leading brand toothpaste do more dentists prefer?"
And this is the way I'm teaching my kids @ 4 and 9.
I too have been working since I was a kid. Believe it or not... Since I was 7/8! I helped collect on the routes that my stepdad had to take over until he could hire someone else [he was a mgr for Detroit News/Freepress]. Then it was assisting his carriers on midnights on the weekends. Then it was a hostess at a local restaurant. Then fast food. Then the auto world.
When I was 16, the child support money from my dad was buying groceries for 5-6 people [and I hardly ate at home... didn't have time] and I paid $100/month to pay towards utilities. I like hot water and electricity. I'm spoiled that way. I'd save for what I wanted or needed. My 1st car was a 1984 Buick Century. It was rusted to shit and the only thing that really worked on that car was the drivetrain and wipers. But, I bought it, paid the insurance on it, it was all in MY name, I gassed it, repaired it, and sold it to a friend for more than I originally paid for it after putting 20,000mi on it!!!
The rare times I've borrowed money, it was paid back as soon as it was possible.
My children WILL have it easier than I did, but still will know what it is to EARN what they have, want, and need.
Easier said than done.
My first car, which I shared with two other dudes that we bought for $50, a 1953 Plymouth that burned oil like a drunk sucks down booze. We used to buy reconstituted oil (why don't they sell that anymore?) by the gallon for that old lady.
Took us all over Canada and the USA and, due to the forgetfullness of my buddy, threw a rod 100 miles outside Reno.
Three on the stick, 6 volt. Our 8 track was hooked to a loose 12 volt battery that we, ahem, borrowed from a construction site!
As it should be.
Which, results in them being part of the Y generation.
When kids ask Y, many times they come up with answers which a parent really, really doesn't like!
Ok. I should've said my PLAN is to have my kids have it easier than I did. That's part of the reason for me going back to school for further education. Hopefully I'll be ok on my own and not have to depend on my kids.
No! We like our guns here in MI!
I was paying for these things during the Carter Presidency. The TRUE worst economy since the Great Depression. 21% interest rates, gas going from .35/gallon to $1/gallon, with 6 hour lines fro gasoline and odd/even rationing.
My father made $70 a week, and decided to buy the company from his boss, AND the property from his father. Then he developed a hyperactive thyroid, got "Almost dead" for almost a year, nearly losing both AND their life's savings. Having a child aged 12 paying for his clothes was a help. Paying board at 14. When going to McDonald's once a year was the family "going out to dinner" night. It has since worked out, but there were a few years when things were tough as hell. By 1982, things were improving quickly. I HOPE my kids never learn these lessons quite that way, but with the way we're going, they are going to be thrilled we can grow most of our food if we wish/need to.
Then go to K'zoo and organize her deportation.
Terry,
If you give your children good foundations early in life, they will probably make the right informed choice. It might not be exactly the way we would have liked it, but it won't be that far off, either.
Personally, I think that's bullshit, but there you go!
I say that as one attempting to evade responsibility for what I have wrought!
I sure as hell hope that's not absolutely true, look around you Perrie, look who and what is raising this generation, scary, scary crap.
You mean the 30 percent teen pregnancy rate in our highschools, and the girls cutting English class to use their foodstamps to buy candy and soda? The ones demanding Uncle Sugar owes them healthcare, food, housing, clothing, and spending cash are the ones who either raise the next generation, or else their mothers, who raised these girls in the first place,get to make the same mistakes all over again.
It used to be that a girl pregnant in highschool was a slut, despised by most. Now, her friends are jealous because of all the "free" shit they get. Did you know that now it's considered "cruel" not to give welfare people "spending cash" they can use on ANYTHING? WE are buying these freeloaders cigarettes, booze, and lottery tickets!
We could always get her deported to NY (I've heard they'll let anybody in). Once Annette and her mother found out about that, you guys would be living in Michigan within 12 hours.
True, they let Perrie in! LOL
Me, I was bright, I got the hell out the first moment I could.
DO it!! NONE of us want to live near her!