╌>

Analysis: Are Israelis tough enough for a long war with Iran?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  rescue  •  14 years ago  •  2 comments

Analysis: Are Israelis tough enough for a long war with Iran?

Prime Minister Netanyahu has been pushing for apreemptivestrike against Iran's nuclear facility, but is having to contend with a population that isn't supporting him.

Although the numbers are higher than before, only 25% of the Israeli population support the possibility of going against Iran alone.

Of course they won't be going it alone in all probability, as the U.S. will support Israeli's actions, even it it doesn't go with it initially. The conservative superhawks were strongly encouraging George Bush to make a preemptive strike against Iran during his administration. These are the same military advisers that Romney has chosen.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says that scenario would be "dwarfed" by the prospect of an Iranian bomb, which he describes as tantamount to a second Holocaust - language that seems to herald a Jewish call to arms

Martin van Creveld, a military historian who is critical of the Netanyahu government's Iran posture, posited a deterioration in Israel's fitness to confront an enemy state since it absorbed Iraqi missile salvoes in the 1991 Gulf war.

"More than 20 years of fighting the weak has bred in Israel a revolting blend of aggression and self-pity," he said, referring to outgunned Lebanese and Palestinians.

Taking on Iran would not be like taking on the Palestinians.

Defense Minister Ehud Barak estimates 500 Israelis would die should a strike on Iran, which denies seeking to develop nuclear weaponry, turn into a regional exchange of fire.

That number seems harshly conservative.

Israel's home front would bear the brunt of any reprisals from Iran, Lebanon's Hezbollah militia, Palestinian armed factions and perhaps Syria .

A sophisticated Israeli missile shield would fend off some salvoes, but those that get through could hit almost anywhere, potentially paralyzing the economy and filling bomb shelters.

Most recently, a retired chief of Israels internal security agency , akin to our FBI accused Netanyahu of misleading the Israelis about how effective an airstrike would be against Iran's nuclear facilities.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I think even the Israelis don't know what to do. On one hand, a nuclear Iran on their doorstep, is hardly what they want or can trust. On the other hand, I think the whole Israelipopulationknows what it's like to be in a war, since the last one was not so long ago, and that those numbers don't quite add up. The '67 war had:

Between 776 [3] and 983 Israelis were killed and 4,517 were wounded. 15 Israeli soldiers were captured. Arab casualties were far greater. Between 9,800 [5] and 15,000 [6] Egyptian soldiers were listed as killed or missing in action. An additional 4,338 Egyptian soldiers were captured. [7] Jordanian losses are estimated to be 6,000 [171] [172] killed or missing
and 533 captured, [7] [8] though Gawrych cites a number of some 700 killed in action with another 2,500 wounded. [4] The Syrians were estimated to have sustained some 1,000 killed in action. [173] 367 Syrians were captured. [7]

The Yom Kipper war in 73, played out like this:

Israel suffered between 2,521 [31] [25] [2] and 2,800 killed in action. [24] An additional 7,250 [295] to 8,800 [24] soldiers were wounded. Some 293 Israelis were captured. [296] Approximately 400 Israeli tanks were destroyed. Another 600 were disabled but returned to service after repairs. [33] A major Israeli advantage, noted by many observers, was their ability to quickly return damaged tanks to combat. [126] [297] The Israeli Air Force lost 102 airplanes: 32 F-4s, 53 A-4s, 11 Mirages and 6 Super Mysteres. Two helicopters, a Bell 205 and a CH-53, were also lost. [34] According to Defense Minister Moshe Dayan , nearly half of these were shot down during the first three days of the war. [29] IAF losses per combat sortie were less than in the preceding Six Day War of 1967. [298]

An Israeli Air Force Mirage IIIC. Flag markings on the nose credit this particular aircraft with 13 aerial kills.

Arab casualties were known to be much higher than Israel's, though precise figures are difficult to ascertain as Egypt and Syria never disclosed official figures. The lowest casualty estimate is 8,000 (5,000 Egyptian and 3,000 Syrian) killed and 18,000 wounded. [24] The highest estimate is 18,500 (15,000 Egyptian and 3,500 Syrian) killed. [25] Most estimates lie somewhere in between the two, with the Insight Team of the The Sunday Times of London claiming combined Egyptian and Syrian losses of 16,000 killed [2] and yet another source citing a figure of some 15,000 dead and 35,000 wounded. [27] U.S. estimates placed Egyptian casualties at 13,000. [132] Iraq lost 278 killed and 898 wounded, while Jordan suffered 23 killed and 77 wounded. [299] Some 8,372 Egyptians, 392 Syrians, 13 Iraqis and 6 Moroccans were captured. [296] [300] Arab tank losses amounted to 2,250 [27] [301] though Garwych cites a figure of 2,300. [28] 400 of these fell into Israeli hands in good working order and were incorporated into Israeli service. [27]

I am providing both sets of numbers to also show that they can be very hard core, if they feelthreatened. If there was another leader other than Imanutjob there, I would be more doubtful that they wouldn't go through with this. But this is a man who denies the Holocaust, and has spread unrest in the region, even among his own country men. Even the Saudis hate him, and are quietly siding with the Israelis.

I think we are living in very dangerous times.

 
 

Who is online


60 visitors