Education: WHY??? by C. Jonathan Walters
This was written by my friend C. Jonathan Walters. He gave me permission to reprint it here. The original can be found here .
I recently had a conversation with someone who was, in part, looking for a a position to work for me as an assistant (to try and take some of my own workload), and the topic got into matters not quite related to the job and into something a little more conceptual. In that conversation, this person stated (paraphrased), we need to get rid of programs like the space program, and scientific research programs and put that money towards educating children.
That conversation got me to thinking about why it is that education is important, not just the economic benefits, because those are obvious, in todays world, if our children are not educated, then we really dont have a future economically, not in this global economy where other nations are devoting more and more resources to the education and advancement of the future generations.
No, what got me thinking wasnt just the economics, but the reason why we educate, that of expanding our minds, our souls. If we have nothing to aspire to, then why should we care whether evolution or creationism is being taught in schools, why should we care if our children even understand who Newton was, the accomplishments of this great man (who was also a devout christian I might add for those that are religious), why should we not aspire to take what this giant has done and stand on his shoulders, as he has stood on the shoulders of those that were great before him.
What this person completely ignores in that comment, is that without things like the space program, without things like the national research council coordinating research and development in both the pure and applied sciences, ALL government programs mind you, what reason exactly would our children have to learn, to become interested in the sciences, in those fields that we as a society need to move forward.
While this particular person was, through other pieces of the conversation, on the left side of the political aisle, this is a matter that just seems to be lost on so many that are on either side of the aisle. From those that think that the paltry amount of money that goes into the US Space program (a rounding error in US budget talk) should go to consumption welfare spending, to those that are on the right that think that NASA should be subsumed into the defense department, because you can never have too much defense spending, and turned into a secret program, what just seems to be apparent is that so many of us have just completely lost sight of the big picture, the WHY???
To inspire is to encourage, and there is so much that inspiration can accomplish that money alone can never hope to accomplish. Without that inspiration, is it any wonder that americans more and more today find the vapid accomplishments of an athlete far more inspirational than that of an astronaut, or a scientist that makes a groundbreaking discovery. Is it any wonder that our educational standards in this country have been on the decline for a generation or more. This is something that money cant solve. You cant just spend money and fix a problem with education when our children have nothing to inspire them.
We need the space program (both manned and unmanned) more than ever, we need anything that can and will inspire our children to become the future of this society, because if we dont, the only thing our society will become in the future, is an 'also ran', economically, socially, influentially.
Tags
Who is online
70 visitors

Thomas Jefferson, "if a nation expects to be ignorant and free, in a state of civilization, it expects what never was and never will be."
Leona,
You have touched on two topics that I am very passionate about, education and the space program. I have to run right now to take my daughter to the dr. (I've been doing a lot of this lately, as they are turning 18 and need all kinds of girl check ups before going off to college), but I will be back to this for a very long post. Stay tuned!
I look forward to it!
I totally agree.
At the beginning of the Cold War the US government decided to strongly support education in mathematics, and science. They developed and implemented educational structures beginning in the elementary schools all the way up to the universities. We are no longer in the Cold War, so the government simply quit giving so much importance to education. Oh they may talk about how education is declining, and pass legislation like NCLB, but it does nothing to truly improve our educational environment.
Are you speaking of researching style of education or real "research", as in those departments at the university level that research disease and global warming and such?
I wasn't sure what you meant by social engineering so looked up the definition. Everything I found had to do with gaining the confidence of a weakened person in order to obtain information that they wouldn't share under normal circumstances. If that's what you meant, have I got a story for you....
When my youngest son was in the third grade the school showed a video that was about a young boy that had been molested. The parents were not given the opportunity to approve this movie. Afterwards, all of the children were to spend one on one time with their teacher so they could "tell" the teacher of any of their worries (get my drift). It was a complete fishing exhibition.
Other than the mandatory testing because of the NCLB, what else is bs in education?
True. I don't think enough history is taught. And when it is taught...it's in the context of how 'great' the dead white guys were.
I don't see anything wrong with extra events that teach of things that aren't touched on in the class. But I believe these things can be presented through the parent organizations better than through the school curriculum.
Absolutely! One thing they've gone away from is memorization of math facts. I recall going in groups to the gym for practicing of the multiplication tables. They don't do much in the way of repitition any longer, so many students are falling behind because they are too slow.
Great article!
We are inspired by our explorations and discoveries; they encourage a desire to continue. Actually been thinking about this a little more lately as I am hearing more about these "project" type schools, their value and success. Kids learn best when they are actively engaged in their own learning and dreams spur that on. I say more, not less, to our nation's scientific endeavors; as well, our children need to be fully active participants...
Hi Larry!
Totally!
In general education should be (IMHO) a natural progression born out of curiosity. I also believe that another large componentlacking is our closeness to nature. Read this book Last Child in the Woods a few years ago and it makes compelling case for something called Nature deficit disorder ...
Generally speaking of course. LOL
I remember actually being locked out of the house for several hours every afternoon. Not as punishment, but for the benefits of the fresh air and 'play time.'
It's my belief that children are lacking the ability to lose or fail. Most of the team sports for smaller children in my area don't keep score. They want to foster a sense of 'team' and cooperation. That's all well and good, but what about our most fundamental nature of competition and winning? We can't learn to be winners if we've never experienced being losers. Children, especially need these skills in order to be competitive in their adult years. And we all know (or should know by now) that it's real tough out in the world.
Learning about the natural environment is imo a necessity to the continuation of our species. Not speaking from an environmentalist standpoint, simply from a survivalist's view. Which, I suppose, could be the same thing.
True.
Yet beyond that what we are is a direct result of our evolution with other creatures on this blue planet. I think an argument can even be made that science itself is initially a study of the natural world. How many generations of children do we have living in America, who have nearly no respect for their surroundings, let alone their natural surroundings.
We have been learning from nature for thousands of years, it's part of our make-up. We have not reached out into space because we have an innate knowledge that it is necessary for our species growth, but simply because we are curious and desire to know.
I'm sure it's not simply an argument, but a fact.
And that curiosity can and should be developed not just through our daily experiences, but through our educational system as well.
I've wondered if the condition called ADHD could be treated by giving the boys involved some "nature" time .
I truly believe that much of what the educators call ADHD is nothing more than extreme boredom. With all of the television, video games, hand held devices, etc that stimulate their brains almost nonstop from the time they get up in the morning to the time they go to bed, it's no wonder they get bored in the classroom. It's not moving at video game speed.
That is one answer.
Also, to look at is the lack of attention given to the extremely bright children in the classroom. The educators (keep in mind I'm not trying to vilify them) have to keep the pace slow so that all of the children can keep up. That's another dilemma that is keeping many children from reaching their full potential.
Call it overstimulation or call it boredom, the cause and effect is the same.
Hi Jonathan!
It's good to see you!
This is a discussion about education...right? So...teaching my sons to go to the bathroom. "If you shake it more than twice, you're playing with it." End of lesson.
And as a mother, I can say...."Read the above lesson." LOL
Sooo.. Much to say on this topic as I am a teacher, who has kids and who's dad worked for Grumman and help designed thestabilizersfor the LEM (LunaModule).
Education is always one of those topics that people get so passionate about so I am taking the risk and diving right in. First dumping more money into education isn't going to fix what is wrong with it. You don't have to end the space program to help education. In fact, ending the space program has killed the level of interest in science that we had when we were going into space. Children learn by doing (always doing first) and seeing examples of science, not an abstract of science. When we ended the space program, all that was left of interest was looking up and asking some questions. How sad.
So how do you fix education without dumping more money into it? Scale it back! Sounds counter intuitive, but let me explain about how we do it in most of NY (this does not happen in NYC or some very rural areas of upper NY). We have schools that are local districts. Each district is usually defined by a town. So I live in the Town of Roslyn, my schools are ran by the town of Roslyn. This makes for a smaller administration, so less money wasted on that. Each year, a school budget is put forth to the members of the town. A town can vote the budget down, and there is a re-vote with a revised budget, or pass the budget. People without kids vote on the budget as well as those with kids in the system, since this directly affects their school taxes. Schools that don't produce results i.e. percentage of kids going to excellent schools, will have their budget voted down, and things are reexamined. Those that are doing fine, and who's budget are not bloated, will pass. People don't mind paying a bit more in taxes, since their property value is a tied to school performance. In a greatdistrict, you will pay higher taxes, but your home is worth more, too. It's a win/win.
Now that is only part of the equation. What can we do away with. 1. Tenure. It stinks universally. If a teacher is doing a bad job, they should be fired. 2. Merit pay. On the other hand, if a teacher is truly excellent, they should be rewarded. 3. Over testing. The idea that "no kid left behind" would result in smarter kids if we tested our kids to death, is bizarre. All you have done, is taught kids to take specific types of test, and wasted a bulk of the school day doing this. Now I am not against testing to see thatacademiclevels are being met at specific points in the educational process, but not every year in 3 different subjects. It's nuts and it takes away from 4. Critical thinking skills. The over testing process has made children learn "facts" instead of learning reasoning skills. They don't know how to come to a conclusion on their own, nor do they know the questions to ask. This leads me to what has popped up from time to time... which I call "school indoctrination". Some school systems have anindoctrinationplan. Teaching about civil rights within the context of history is great. Having kids be told what right or wrong ideology wise, not so great, made worse by removing reasoning skills (critical thinking) from the classroom. I am all for gay rights. It has a place in discussion in high school, in a civics class or in debate, but throwing at them "I have Two Mommies" when they are 6, not so cool. Children that age, don't have the critical thinking skills to take it all in and talk rationally about it. If you have a teachable moment: i.e., a classmate has two mommies, then you can discuss the fact that indeed there are all kinds of families, and let the kids ask the questions without feeding them the info of the moment.
OK... I think I have blathered on enough.
LOL, YES! As he says, "I built the damn thing, I'll call it what I like". After years of seeing it spelled that way I'm an old dog not so good with new tricks.
But you are right, without a subject having purpose, kids have no interest in learning it, especially a subject likecalculus. Keeping subject relevant, keeps interest, even in tough ones likecalculus.
On a totally different not, welcome to NT, Jonathan! I am the go to person here if you need any help with anything. I had this teachable moment to tell you that if you go into settings on the upper right hand side of the page under your name, you can give yourself an avatar.
[[I can tell you this much, without a purpose, calculus is a dreary subject.]]
Speaking for myself , I enjoyed the study of calculus even without a clear goal in mind . Now diff eqtns was another matter .
That said I think I agree with the general concept you are expressing ...
Diff Eq is indeed the heart of the study of analyzing variation in processes . It's too bad I had such a lousy prof. for that course . Also having the Vietnam War breathing down my neck didn't help either ...
Often the circumstances of your life have a big influence on how your application of knowledge ends up . In your case you were following a dream . I'm glad it worked out for you ...
Sorry Jonathan,
Most folks come here not knowing how to find stuff on the site. No harm no foul?
Windows NT ? Don't give me nightmares !
Now that sounds interesting. What does your company do?
He, he...we're gonna get along just fine!
:~)
Just being in contact with the world around us as easy as getting on-line yet as difficult as putting the electronics aside long enough to just "go outside and play".
Actually, an I-Pad in the forest is quite a cool deal too!
You are a cruel man ... very cruel !
Perrie, Thank you for your thoughtful reply to this article. It's nice to have an informed person (at least someone with some level of sensibility) take the time.
I would say that much of that interest was because of the level of coverage that the space programs of yesteryear were getting. After a while the interest wore off, but it shouldn't have lessened the level of educational support that was given to the schools during that time.
I don't think having computers in classrooms is helping the children learn by doing. They are replacing real education with computers. Not to say that computers are bad, they do have their place, just not in many of the educational aspects of a children's learning process.
I mostly agree with that statement. What I would find disheartening is a budget committee wanting to make cuts, cutting from the top in order to save money, and hiring a younger, less experienced group of teachers.
Very strange indeed. As they have been teaching to the test, they have gone away from some very basic fundamental learning tools, like memorization.
And someone else in this discussion called it 'social engineering.' I think it's a way bad way to go about things.
That's a really hard one. We don't have any really good 'Superhero's' right now. I don't think we've had any in a long time.
Sadly, that's been taken to extremes lately.
For keeping track of all the cool discoveries. Here's a great example of that now.
I couldn't help myself. LOL
I've no idea what it is, but it looks really neat!
And that is why having something like the space program is soooo important for our future. If we had not had the program for you to dream on when you a child, would you have had the motivation to learn and do in order for you to be who you are today?
Exactly!~
This is true, but how is this different than say the business world? But to counter this, every year a teacher has "performance write-ups". If suddenly they get a poor write up after years of good ones, and it happens to be during a time of fiscal hardship, there should be a way to grieve this, say to a panel of parents. No parent would want an excellent teacher being ditched for two bad ones.
Sorry it took me all day to get back to you, but I got unexpectedly busy at home.
As far as the religious fundamentalism goes, I think they are simply getting louder. I don't think we have more people involved in religion. As a matter of fact, I think it's just the opposite.
It could be a group article? That would be a good question for Perrie.
I'm actually not sure what Jonathan is talking about...really. Whatpermission? Anything posted in the forum is a NT article up for discussion. Group articles stay in the groups, public or private.
I think it comes with the penis. Oooops
Did I say that out loud? LOL
It should be treated differently than the business world.It's very difficult to count the number of neurons that are manufactured inside a childs head while in school, although they can look at test results. In the business world, the dollar is the bottom line, not the number of neurons produced.
True that!
I must be getting tired, because it took me reading this sentence three times (even after I replied) to understand what it was you were speaking of. I just reviewed our emails...being the old lady I am (not really, but we'll go with this for now, I am a grandma after all) I thought maybe I had goofed. I didn't actually specify which article I wanted to post first, but then we had some back and forth on the last sentence of "this" article.
Does this ring any bells? During my review of our emails, however, I see that I didn't correct the correction correctly. LOL
My bad Perrie. He was confused for a moment. Hopefully I straightened him out.LOL
OK.. but I am totally lost, LOL!
What else is new?
Hi Bob! Nice to see you here
Can you flesh that out a little bit? It may mean different things to different people. I know that in the school district here we have people go into the classrooms and observe the teachers. I'm not sure how effective that is at making sure the students are learning what they should be, but it does give a view of how well the teacher can 'manage' the students.
As I read this, it occurred to me that the next teacher may be a good judge of how effective the previous teacher had been at fascilitating the learning processes of the students. Not saying we should do away with testing, because it does have a place, but using the evaluations of the next teacher to help determine the effectiveness of the teacher under evaluation.
That is a distinct problem. But how can we interest the students enough to think of their future? Sometimes they need to be led to discovery. A little of my own experiences:
As an 8th grade student, I scored excessively high in the standardized tests. In the 99th percentile in most subjects. The class counselor, tasked with interviewing all of the students, called me to his office and asked me what I wanted to do after I graduated high school. Being a typical 14 year old, and only interested in what was right in front of me, I told him I wanted to be a 'makeup artist.' He offered no alternatives, didn't let me know that I was capable of really great things. I spent all of 3 minutes with him. I can look back and know that, for him, it was a lost opportunity. I'm not laying all of my problems on him, but somehow I can't help but think that if he would have taken a few more minutes of his time, it may have had a huge affect on my outcome.
I do as well. Just throwing ideas out there, and maybe a good one will stick.
I think they already do this, just not the tests that are 'state approved.'
Some children have to learn the hard way. My youngest son is a good example of this. Really bright young man, 15 years old. He tested the highest in his middle school on the standardized tests that are administered through the state. I've done a lot of things with him. Enrolled him in some 'fun' activities through the university, taken him to KSC for a week of 'discovery', talked to him about his limitless opportunities until I'm blue in the face. And what is he doing? Barely getting by with D's and C's. I've spoken with a couple of his teachers and they all agree that he needs a motivation, but everything that's been presented to him has been rejected. He doesn't want to go to college. I'm afraid all he wants to do is become (ooooh, I can't say it, because it would be speaking ill of his father, and that's not allowed!).
I think it's the budget limitations. In 2009, I took my son to the Kennedy Space Center for a week. We participated in what was called "The Astronaut Training Experience." One of the things they talked about was the need for engineers. And this program was one of those ways to garner interest and education incentives. We now hear reports about how our US industries are hiring engineers from outside of the country because there aren't enough within the US to fulfull the need.
There are programs around, usually thru the universities, for the younger children, but they are typically invitation only type events. I would like to see them more in the classrooms for all of the children.
That begs the question of how to convince/encourage the children to see beyond their little worlds?
I as a teacher, used to explain why we need to learn something, as apracticalapplication. Why it's important to speak and write proper English to get a job. How math skills help in the same why. As a sex ed teacher, I would explain to them how having a baby young, can ruin your life. I would talk to the girls about what boys "really want" and why they should say no, for as long as they can. That having a child makes it hard to go to college, and if they got pregnant that they shouldn't expect the boy to stick around. Talk about self esteem. With the boys, I would bring in a Matt to talk about what a real man does,which is being responsible for their actions. How hard it is to be a good father. How you don't want to do this when you are young, because it makes it harder to go to school. These are but a few of the ways you can break the cycle.
And Bob... this came from a fence sitter!
First, he wanted to be in the Air Force. So I encouraged him to participate in the Civil Air Patrol, and had him look at JROTC programs.He lost interest after 3 months.
During this time his grades and behavior in school turned toxic, and the school asked me to 'find him a different educational opportunity.' It didn't help at all that this was at the same time his father was taking me to court for custody.
I had a conversation with my history professor (I'm a college student). He's retired and teaching part time. He shared with the class that he, and his children, had all dropped out of high school when they were 16. They all later went on to get their college education and have been successful, productive members of society. I asked him what that looked like? His analysis that he shared was that, particularly now, a high school diploma is only useful if one is expecting to get into a prestigious university right out of high school. A GED and self motivation will take anyone wherever they want to go. As in, acceptance to a community college, which can be used as a spring board to a four year institution. I agree with the main premise, but I certainly wouldn't want that to be the only option. So...I spoke to my son about that option. He seemed accepting of it at first. That takes us to the current situation...
He wants to continue to attend high school, even graduating. I would like to see that as well. His older siblings graduated, and I don't think he likes the idea of being the 'odd man out.' However, he has also stated that he doesn't want to attend college. That bothers me a lot! With all of this, I'm just about at the end of what I can do or say as a parent. All I can say about the situation right now, is that I will be available for any of the choices that he makes. I may not be completely supportive, but I will always be his mother. I do find some consolation in that whatever he decides to do, he'll do it well.
That's where it's headed, I'm sure.
I often wonder why that is. My sister and I ruminate over our children and how we are similar or different from them often. One thing that we, as adults, have a hard time with, iswhen we were young, everything was soooo easy for us. All of the tasks that we were given (speaking of school here) we excelled at, and were generallyat the top. As we got older and things became more difficult, it seemed particularly hard on us. Not because we weren't capable, but because (conclusions from our ruminations) we didn't learnhow to do the hard stuff when we were younger.
Finding common ground can be difficult. I'm glad it's recognized when it happens.
Wow! 11 years old. Sometimes I wonder at the realistic nature of our child labor laws. Many times they're good, in that employers cannot take advantage of our youth. But sometimes they seriously hinder the 'real life' development. If a child is capable, and willing,of performing certain duties, I think they should be given the opportunity.
My older son began doing odd jobs when he was 12. Mostly landscaping....but then that grew to doing painting, roofing, and general carpentry. It wasn't so much the skills that he was learning, as the work ethic. I'm sure that I, as the parent, and those that hired him broke a few rules in the process, but he is a very productive, tax paying member of society. And I couldn't be prouder of him! Would that be the case if he hadn't started so young? Maybe, maybe not. But it sure didn't hurt him.
My younger son, on the other hand, is more an example of...
[[The USA is the richest country in the world.]]
Not on a per capita basis and not on a median income basis ... Do you know differently ?
Awesome and I have no Idea either!
:~)
Was just in Indiana visiting my folks and even though the crops are toast (literally fried) the woods are hanging in there and alive. Used a cool birding app on my i-phone but the same app was especially good on my brother-in-laws i-pad.
That's intriguing. I'll have to look into it.
Oops ... looks like my experiment got out of the laboratory . That is the world's first zebra bug , a genetic experiment I have been working on [insert mad laughter here] .
Yup, tis true; and, defines the issue for me.Great conversation here!
:~)
Bob ,
Here is what you said in a previous comment :
[[If the wealthy paid their fair share, there would be NO question of money. The USA is the richest country in the world... but cannot supply education and health? When all the other, less wealthy ones, can?]]
What you are suggesting is confiscating the wealth of the 1 % ers against their wishes . What you don't seem to comprehend is that many of the 1 % can just pick up their wealth and leave the country . What happens then ?
Bob ,
You are using words which have no meaning unless they are defined in detail . What does "fair share" mean ... exactly ?