Obama and hope
There has been quite a lot of rhetoric written about Pres Obama on both sides of the political spectrum . The following rant is going to be this indy's attempt to cut through that rhetoric and get to the underlying reality of Obama the man and the president .
First of all many on the right have been calling Obama a traitor , a communist [or at least a socialist] and naive or politically inexperienced . How much of this is true ?
I don't see any intentional thoughts or acts of traitorism in the man , nor do I see a communist .However , I do perceive that his original message of "hope and change" is based on the expressions that fill the mind of the young and naive . Such people believe that hope really is the answer to every problem both social and political as well as national and international . And that is where the difficulties start to occur .
Not only is hope the supposed answer to domestic issues but also international ones , even those of the Muslim world . But the stark reality of the Muslim world , especially the middle east is that hope means more fundamentalist religion will enter the picture . That is what has arisen as a result of the Arab spring in several countries . In other words the American concept of democracy based on separation of church and state has been dealt a severe setback in that region [if it ever had a chance at all] .
To be fair to Obama he has attempted to compensate for his initial mistake of extending the message of hope to the Arab Muslim world [as demonstrated in his famous Cairo speech ] .
He has since expressed a more definite support of the US main ally in the middle east , Israel . However ,
all he has accomplished by that is undercutting all the middle eastern political capital he thought he was creating there . In fact his poll numbers have fallen off drastically in the Arab middle east .
http://www.pewglobal.org/database/?indicator=1&survey=14&response=Favorable&mode=chart
In the meantime fundamentalist politics have drastically increased there . In balance I don't see how one can classify this as a positive outcome for Obama . Other results in that region include the liberation of Libya from Qdaffi and the creation of the new country of South Sudan . I'm not sure if the former is positive on balance .
It appears to be encouraging more fundamentalist Islamic government and Sharia law . The latter may prove to be the lone positive result of the recent changes in the middle east .
So much for the universal message of hope globally . How about the question of his socialist tendancies ?
Here again there was the youthful foray in that direction . It was expressed first in the Van Jones mess , the so-called "green jobs" czar . Obama had to fire this guy quickly due to his clearly socialist views . And that was the beginning of Obama's job creation problems which have plagued the economy since before he took office . I'm not certain if the health care plan would fall under that category or not but there is some controversy about forcing people to join it . Perhaps others would like to address that issue .
OK , that's all I have for my initial foray into national politics . If you want to comment on this topic I will insist that you stay on topic . The topic is a discussion of Obama and not other candidates . Do not talk about Romney , Ron Paul or even Mr. Arnold Ziffel .
If this subject proves fruitful , I may repeat the process for Romney even if he doesn't have a record in national politics . Thanks and let's keep it above the belt , OK ?
Tags
Who is online
70 visitors

Thanks for the opening salvo Kommander Mike . If I'm not mistaken some of those campaign promises are better left undone [in your opinion] . Gitmo for example ... As a result can we chalk up some of those to youthful enthusiasm ?
Good question ... I'm going to think about that .
Well ... to be fair about this no one has for a very long time ... that I can think of . Can either of you ?
John ,
I asked to not go on the attack mode by mentioning other candidates . But you can't seem to do that even once .All I'm asking is that you address the issues I wrote about . Do you think my observations were accurate or not ?If not why not ? Can you do that ?
Also feel free to answer the points raised in the other comments .
OK , since you stayed on topic this time :
All I am saying above is that Obama's youthful message of hope has made things worse in the middle east .They are now rebelling against their dictator leaders and forming islamist governments . The dictators held that religious extremeism in check but not any more .
Not so John . If you want to attack his premise , have at it . But if you can't do that without attacking the right then there is something wrong with your thinking processes ... seriously wrong . BTW , I don't necessarily agree withany of Mike's comments .
I'd like to thank John Russell for his last few comments . He stayed on topic and actually contributed some points of value . This is actually starting to sound like a discussion instead of the usual partisan brawl .Let's try to continue on that path . At this point I'd like to respond to a few points raised in a few of the comments .
[[I'm not even sure what the purpose of this thread is. ]]
OK , I'm going to expand on that further .
[[First of all , and most obviously, the US has no right, legal or moral, to interfere in the domestic affairs of another sovereign nation. We certainly wouldn't like any other country trying to come here and affect our internal doings.
Secondly, when a tyrant like Mubarak or Gaddafi is oppositionless, so to speak, we can offer him aid and even some protection without risking any immediate consequence. Once revolution in the streets has begun, it is too late. Siding with either of these two would have damaged US interests in the region beyond anything that has happened now.]]
The first paragraph I'm going to take issue with . If one looks at the history of the US relations with Islamic countries one finds that it began with coercive action on the Islamic side . The Barbary pirates captured US sailors who were not engaged in hostilities and basically held them for ransom . At the time Thomas Jefferson and John Adams were involved in the negotiations . Jefferson being young and idealistic wanted to start a war but the older more knowledable Adams overrode him and decided to pay the ransom at least until the young nation could build a navy of sufficient size to deal with the threat . [Let me know if you want a link.]
The same pattern has been repeated numerous times throughout history ... extortion organized at the country level against anyone unfortunate to be in the wrong place at the wrong time . This includes actions against US citizens hiking near the border of Iran and Israeli soldiers captured and held for ransom by the Gazans . This kind of behavior is part of their culture in the middle east . That is why I cannot accept the moralistic approach you espouse . There is no symmetry in belief about human rights in comparing the Arabs to the US ... or to Israel .
The second paragraph is a good point expressing the critical nature of timing in such conflicts . But a knowledgeablepol would not have let things degenerate to the point they did in Egypt . The reason that there was a rebellion in Egypt was the oldest reason of all ... lack of food . Wheat prices had shot up due to some new type of plant disease which had struck the region . The resulting wheat shortage sent food prices through the roof and brought about widespread hunger in that region . So ... for a few [million ?] bushels of wheat we could have avoided the problems that occurred in Egypt . But there was no anticipation of the potential problems . The rebellion in Tunisia should have been adequate warning of what was coming . But the Obama administration took no action . As a result we lost our power base in that country now and possibly forever for not coming up with a little wheat . This does not reflect well on the administration in terms of anticipating disasters before they happen and taking action to prevent them .
So how was the bus ride ... from beneath the bus I threw you under ?
Grandma ... I was wondering what happened to you !
[[Better to bring everyone home.]]
It's a good thing your policy was not followed in the days of the Barbary pirates . The young US navy took them on and defeated them bringing an end to their extortion . The result was a flourishing of trade in the Mediterranean .
I believe the UN Patriot Act more than offsets the Weapons Ban expiration.
Steve ,
Those would be laws that are not binding on US citizens ... right ?
I remember watching Obama's inaugural address and one of my co-workers asking me what I thought. I replied, "He said all of the right things, we will see whether any of it actually happens."
I could say the same about just about every President. Hope is one of those words that carries so much in connotation, but is so ephemeral as to be meaningless.
Congress is where the real power lies; unfortunately, most people don't realize that because they know nothing of their history or the structure of their government.
The people got what they voted for.
Thanks for your perspective Steve .
[[Hope is one of those words that carries so much in connotation, but is so ephemeral as to be meaningless. ]]
I have taken that thought one step futher . I am saying that in some circumstances hope can actually cause more problems instead of less [especially in the case of the Islamic middle east] . That was my thesis here and I have seen no evidence to reject it .
So , rather than addressing my thesis , all you do is attack my objectivity and credibility . Get on topic . The topic is NOT me .
Iar,
I think the point of this article is for both Republicans and Democrats to make their best case. But only John has done his best here and stayed on topic from the left. I encourage you to do the same, as indeis are reading this article, like me.
Well finally someone came in here to defend Obama . That was what I was hoping for when I wrote this but until you showed up there has been a lack of such defense . As usual you have prepared a thoughtful fact based comment interspersed with your personal attacks [but disguised as sarcasm so as to avoid CoC violations] .
In response let me save us both some time by agreeing with 2 through 6 plus 8 & 9 as meaningful accomplishments .
Not to fault Obama for #1 but it still may not save the Euro union . I am not looking to find blame for that mess so I will give him a pass on that issue . After all the outcome in not in his hands , it is in the hands of the German government .
As to #7 , I'm not so very sure the fallout from that will be beneficial to the west aside from freeing up some oil for European consumption . It has promoted additional support for the spread of Sharia law and moving Libya further from a western style of organization . It has promoted the joining of mosque and state rather than their separation .
As to #10 , I'm not nearly as confident of that as you seem to be . But by all means support that statement with evidence . BTW I can't help but notice you completely ignored the one major conclusion I did arrive at . I sought for and found IMO something substantive . In fact I think the issue of what was not done before the Arab Spring in Egyptwill go down in history as Obama's biggest failure on the foreign policy front . I will therefore take the liberty of repeating myself to emphasize the point you have so studiously ignored :
[[But a knowledgeable pol would not have let things degenerate to the point they did in Egypt . The reason that there was a rebellion in Egypt was the oldest reason of all ... lack of food . Wheat prices had shot up due to some new type of plant disease which had struck the region . The resulting wheat shortage sent food prices through the roof and brought about widespread hunger in that region . So ... for a few [million ?] bushels of wheat we could have avoided the problems that occurred in Egypt . But there was no anticipation of the potential problems . The rebellion in Tunisia should have been adequate warning of what was coming . But the Obama administration took no action .]]
That was a MAJOR foreign policy failure . There is no other way to look at it .
There is no veiling on my part at all John . I am definitely in favor of dictatorships to deal with ME Islamic radicalism . That has been our tradition in the US for decades now . From my POV it is for their own good . If left to themselves most Islamic states degenerate into battling tribes . Somalia and Afghanistan come to mind . The one major exception to this was Iran . But Persia was a major empire before it was defeated by the Greeks more than 2 millenia ago ... so they do have some experience with organizing themselves .
BTW you make it sound like dictatorship is a universally bad thing . But it is a fact of life for many of the oil soaked countries of the middle east . Think about that the next time you get into your car ...
Once again John Russell feels [he always feels , never thinks] the need to make a personal attack on me . No wonder he got banned from that other place ...
Maybe I am out of my mind but that is better than being a complete hypocrite . You are dependent on oil for all of your transportation needs and you have been all of your life . That means you support that dictatorial system the US has had in place for more than a half century . To you it is a game to make liberal noises about human rights but the bottom line you don't want to look at is ... oil means dictatorship . It has for a very long time now . The reason for that is dictatorship is stable for a longer time than Islamic tribal warfare .
I actually hope that Iraq succeeds as a democracy but I am not holding my breath on that . If they do it will have been the first ever real democratic major oil exporter . I am tempted to say that Iran is that way but based on their last election and their close joining of mosque and state I do not think it is accurate . Also I am not looking forward to Iran getting the bomb . Are you ?
Incidentally Egypt was a civilization but it was never an empire . That is a big difference .
[[But what makes you think a dictator could last forever?]]
I never said forever . That is your mental gymnastics trying to find fault with what I said . I am telling you how it has been for more than a half century . It has always been dictatorships . Pretending it has not is just hiding your head in the desert sand ...
[[Your complaint that it represents the joining of mosque and state (something not yet evident) is particularly ironic given the strong tendency of conservatives in America to join church and state, and given the numerous western countries with official religions.]]
Don't include me in the group of strict conservatives . I am an independent who leans a little to the right .
[[The facts of the matter are that Libya has opportunities it never had before, that it's quite possible that electoral representative government will curb fundamentalism]]
Yes it has opportunities but that's all it has . Anyway thanks for the interesting link . In time we will all see what transpires in Libya .
[[Regarding the "foreign policy failure" of Egypt,it would be difficult to pay attention to "the major conclusion" you DID arrive at when it is entirely absent from the article that you wrote. You'll have to pardon me for not sifting through each of your comments looking for a conclusion to which to respond]]
OK , fair enough .
As to your new points , here are my responses in sequence :
1 . [[We have no moral or legal right to interfere in the domestic affairs of a sovereign nation. ]]
Since this is international politics , talking about morality or even legality is moot . It is the middle east so oil is inevitably involved . That is plenty of motivation as far as I'm concerned . Wars have been fought over oil and will continue to be . To pretend that is trumped by morality is hypocritical .
2. No circular reasoning involved . There is FOOD involved . That shortage trumps everything else .
3. See # 2 .
[[the declaration that it was "a MAJOR foreign policy failure" seems driven a lot more by your antipathy toward Obama than by an actual analysis of the situation]]
That is not my attitude towards Obama and it never has been . My very 1st article in that other venue was a piece lauding Obama for his Cairo speech . That said I don't see how anyone could fail to see the connection between food and revolution . To see a food crisis coming and not attempt to avert it for a regional ally is inexcusable . Your diversions into complexity are an exersize in mental masturbation . FOOD trumps all other issues . Hungry people revolt . Anyone who denies that is a fool . And I fault Obama , the man who gave that friendship speech in Cairo , for abandoning Egypt in her hour of need .
John ,
[[When interpreting something like the Egyptian upheaval, people tend to project their own passions on to the screen.]]
That could only have been written by someone who has never experienced real hunger ...
Likewise , you also exclude any arguments which don't support your original POV . At least I read what you had to say and explained the reasons for my disagreement . But all you have done is ignore my argument and negatively characterize my entire decision process . That is not honest dialogue . Give me a counter-argument , not a raspberry ... but you are incapable of thinking at all . You will only accept something written by some media blog which has a built-in bias .. the very thing you accuse me of .
[[Rich, your anti-Obama articles are as regular and inevitable as the tides.]]
Actually this would be the 1st that I can recall which is on the anti-Obama side of things . So unless you can refresh my memory about those missing articles [there are none] then you are simply making shit up .Now that is what you do " as regular and inevitable as the tides" .
[[But I applaud your willingness to come down firmly on the side of empire, and drop the pretense that you have any respect for or commitment to the ideals upon which America was founded.]]
Thanks much . And I applaud your refusal to see your own hypocrisy . You depend on the use of oil every day of your life . But that doesn't stop you from wearing blinders to the dictatorships which supply most of it and the way all of our leaders kowtow to these dictators . And you never complain about them ... imagine that ...HYPOCRITE !
I gave you a counter to that argument which you ignored . Right back at ya buddy ...
[[Rather than me wasting a lot of my time sifting through everything you've said about Obama, Rich, why don't you set the record straight.
List your take on the positive accomplishments of the Obama administration. ]]
As I have said numerous times in the past I am an idependent . As a result I have not gone out of my way to look at such accomplishments . Nor have I done that for other candidates from other parties .
However , the very 1st article I wrote on the Vine [you know , that place you were banned from ?] was a piece praising Obama for his Cairo speech . It included a link to the video of the speech . However I have since had a change of heart/mind about POTUS performance in the region , as I explained in a prior comment .
As to your devotion to escaping oil use , that's all well and good but it has little to do with your comment about my "willingness to come down firmly on the side of empire" .
We all show such willingness by participating in this economic machine called America even if some of us are not consciously aware of it . That includes you . Your hypocrisy is in accusing me of supporting empire when you do as well even if it is passive support . But don't let that stop you from blathering on endlessly about "commitment to the ideals upon which America was founded" . Your supposed devotion to ideals without even a nod of recognition to the realities of the petroleum economy is just what I said : hypocrisy .
There was an article from the Economist a while back that went into details about that wheat farming disaster in the region . I'll see if I can find a link to it ...
[[Given that I try to pick the candidate least likely to support that bullshit]]
Hmmm ...like George W. Bush ? After all he was the one who got us involved in Iraq . And he even managed [along with Halliburton] to set up an actual voting democracy there . Yes , by all means support more such candidates ... but I don't think Obama will be attempting that .
OK , here is the Economist link I was referring to :
It presents some background about the problem in agriculture in that region . Notice that the Sudan was affected by wheat rust . Since Egypt imports much of its wheat that is going to have a major effect .
Then here is a link which directly discusses the issue :
and here is another relevant link :
I am not going to disagree that there are more factors than food involved in a revolt . But it does determine the timing of the revolt . If conditions are ripe for a revolt then hunger will trigger it THEN . When you have a dictatorship it is an inherently unstable situation BUT it can last for quite a long time . Mubarak was in power for many decades . Then all of a sudden there was a revolt . Why ? HUNGER . That was the only factor which changed .
One more thing : this is the middle east we are talking about . That has been one of the more stable governments in the region . Dictatorships seem to be the "rule" in that region , not the exception .