╌>

Shell’s Arctic Challenger spill recovery vessel, plagued by even more setbacks.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  larry-crehore  •  14 years ago  •  9 comments

Shell’s Arctic Challenger spill recovery vessel, plagued by even more setbacks.

The Arctic Challenger has obtained Coast Guard approval to meet less rigorous weather standards than originally proposed. Now less than two weeks before drilling off Alaska's northern coast is due to begin, a series of troubling construction delays has left the Arctic Challenger without federal certification. The certification issue is the most serious Shell must confront if it is to successfully launch a exploratory drilling program, the first in Arctic waters in the past 20 years, Shell already has invested $4 billion in its race to drill.

According to Coast Guard officials on Thursday, several important systems remained to be installed before they could certify the oil spill containment vessel. Sources familiar with the multimillion-dollar refurbishing underway in Bellingham, Wash., said it was clear that the 38-year-old barge would not be ready for sea trials by July 23, a date recently set after a previous schedule was scrapped.

9242_discussions.jpg Arctic Challenger

Major safety and operational systems are still being installed, tested and certified, and required tests have not been performed by the shipyard, Cmdr. C.T. O'Neil, chief of media relations for the Coast Guard, said in a statement.

Systems such as the primary and emergency power, fire detection and fire extinguishing systems had not been completed, said ONeil.

The Coast Guard and the American Bureau of Shipping stand ready to conduct testing once installation was complete.

The Arctic Challenger is scheduled to float between offshore drilling platforms in the Beaufort and Chukchi seas and, in the event of an oil spill that couldnt otherwise be contained, deploy a large dome that would capture spilled oil from the top of the well, bring it to the surface and pump it into a storage tanker for removal. The U.S. Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement has said it will not issue final drilling permits until the containment system is complete, certified and ready to deploy.

Shell, did not say Thursday whether the latest delays would affect its drilling schedule. Its timetable had already been set back because of late winter ice in the region.

Shell spokesman Curtis Smith said Thursday, Its certainly taking longer than we hoped, I can say that were not going to rush this. Were not going to send a vessel thats not capable. So while it remains a priority and clearly something we need to have done before we commence drilling, were not going to cut corners and move quickly where it doesnt make prudent sense.

Sources familiar with the construction in Bellingham said four dual anchor winches, one on each corner of the barge, still are inoperable, and the anchors are not installed. In addition, company workers by midweek still had not installed an estimated 200,000 pounds in clump weights, the devices that would anchor the containment dome over the top of an oil spill.

Shell cleared an important hurdle in winning federal approval when the Coast Guard on July 13 accepted the companys argument that the Arctic Challenger should be certified as a mobile offshore drilling unit, in December, Shell had proposed certification under a stricter standard designed for stationary offshore oil platforms. That would have required engineers to prove the Arctic Challenger could withstand the battering of a 100-year storm. Shell subsequently said it would be more reasonable to consider the vessel to be what it is a non-stationary barge that can move out of the way when storms approach and proposed an alternative under which, as a floating installation, Shell would only have to prove it could withstand the winds and waves of a 10-year storm. This would require a less vigorous weather protection than floating production installations.

The Coast Guard's spokesman ONeil said Shell submitted a proposal which further explained the intended operations describing how the vessels mooring system must be agile to allow repositioning during a response to keep the workers on board out of harms way and proposed applying the 10-year storm criteria to the mooring design in lieu of the 100-year standard.

The 10-year benchmark is an industry-recognized standard for mobile offshore drilling units, ONeil said and the Coast Guard has agrees. Shell cannot demonstrate that the Arctic Challenger meets that 10-year standard until construction is completed.

All this comes on the heels of the 571-foot Noble Discoverer losing its mooring July 14, drifting extremely close to shore before it was towed farther off shore and re-anchored. Shell and the Coast Guard say an inspection of the hull by a remotely operated vehicle showed no signs of damage or grounding. Divers will take another look no later than July 20.

9243_discussions.jpg Noble Discoverer

Two Coast Guard investigators were aboard the ship on Monday during the divers' inspection and witnessed the live video feed,Coast Guard Lieutenant Jim Fothergill said.

"We are still reviewing the video. However, what I can tell you is that there is no physical evidence that suggests that they hit bottom," Fothergill was quoted as saying.

"We believe if they did ground, it was a very soft grounding."


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Larry Crehore    14 years ago

I'm not so sure that Shell should be anywhere near the arctic oil fields. They certainly are not giving us any reason to think they will have a safe operation.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

You'd think there would be something easier to deploy than a hardware dome ...

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Larry Crehore    14 years ago

My own opinion is that the Dome idea has little to no chance of containing any spill given the arctic seas in August and September. This is pure BS on the part of Royal Dutch Shell, and our government is going to give these morons a pass.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

You could be right ...

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Larry Crehore    14 years ago

I think Shell has a lot more work to do before they should be allowed to drill in Alaska.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Larry have to agree with you. I feel a sweet heart deal in this. That dome couldn't do a thing if push came to shove.

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Larry Crehore    14 years ago

I did a piece on Shell back in February of this year, here is an excerpt:

"Shell plans to use the Noble Discoverer to drill three exploratory wells in the Chukchi Sea, keep in mind this is the same company and ship that Secretary of The Interior, Ken Salazar just passed their emergency response plan. A plan based on a piece of equipment called a Capping Stack that acts as a blowout preventer to shut the well down in an emergency. This equipment would have had to pass inspection for the plan to pass muster. Big problem, the capping stack could not have been tested or pass inspection. Why you ask, the capping stack has not even been designed and built yet, so you see it couldnt have passed inspection but Ken Salazar passed their plan anyway."

Link to full article: Environmental & Alaska Native Groups Have Appealed Shells Arct...

If that doesn't sound like a sweet heart deal, I guess I don't know what does.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

This equipment would have had to pass inspection for the plan to pass muster. Big problem, the capping stack could not have been tested or pass inspection. Why you ask, the capping stack has not even been designed and built yet, so you see it couldnt have passed inspection but Ken Salazar passed their plan anyway."

Why am I not surprise? Gardisil the wonder vaccine to prevent HPV was only tested on a few hundered girls age 11-13 before the test was stopped because it was found to be unethical to test on that age group, since they were under the age of consent. But the drug comes out, with a big ticket price (3 shots at over $300 out of pocket to parents) and that is the age group that it's recommended for. I opted my daughters out, and my ped, although she thought the vaccine was a good idea, didn't say I was wrong with my logic. Merck found a cash cow.

Where there is a large profit margin, you always have to watch and listen. You smelled out this one, like I found Gardisl...

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Larry Crehore    14 years ago

Good to know about the Gardisil issue, my daughter is well past that but I have friends with young daughters and will pass that information on.

 
 

Who is online