Via: larry-hampton • 14 years ago • 11 comments
United Technologies, a major defense contractor, and two of its subsidiaries on Thursday acknowledged covering up the illicit sale of sensitive military software to China technology that the country later used to develop its first attack helicopter.
Federal prosecutors announced criminal charges against the firms and a fine of more than $75million for what they called a violation of U.S. export laws. Justice officials said the software sold to China posed a risk to American troops overseas and U.S. allies.
The Justice Department will spare no effort to hold accountable those who compromise U.S. national security for the sake of profits and then lie about it to the government, Lisa Monaco, the assistant attorney general for national security, said in a statement.
Connecticut-based United Technologies, which reported net sales of $58billion in 2011, will pay the fine, along with Pratt & Whitney Canada and Hamilton Sundstrand Corp., as part of a settlement for lying to the government and delaying their disclosures about the illegal exports, officials said.
Here are the particulars of the scheme, according to the Justice Department:
During the development phases of China's Z-10 program, each Z-10 helicopter was powered by engines supplied by PWC. PWC delivered 10 of these development engines to China in 2001 and 2002. Despite the military nature of the Z-10 helicopter, PWC determined on its own that these development engines for the Z-10 did not constitute "defense articles," requiring a U.S. export license, because they were identical to those engines PWC was already supplying China for a commercial helicopter.
Because the Electronic Engine Control software, made by HSC in the United States to test and operate the PWC engines, was modified for a military helicopter application, it was a defense article and required a U.S. export license. Still, PWC knowingly and willfully caused this software to be exported to China for the Z-10 without any U.S. export license. In 2002 and 2003, PWC caused six versions of the military software to be illegally exported from HSC in the United States to PWC in Canada, and then to China, where it was used in the PWC engines for the Z-10.
According to court documents, PWC knew from the start of the Z-10 project in 2000 that the Chinese were developing an attack helicopter and that supplying it with U.S.-origin components would be illegal. When the Chinese claimed that a civil version of the helicopter would be developed in parallel, PWC marketing personnel expressed skepticism internally about the "sudden appearance" of the civil program, the timing of which they questioned as "real or imagined." PWC nevertheless saw an opening for PWC "to insist on exclusivity in [the] civil version of this helicopter," and stated that the Chinese would "no longer make reference to the military program." PWC failed to notify UTC or HSC about the attack helicopter until years later and purposely turned a blind eye to the helicopter's military application.
HSC in the United States had believed it was providing its software to PWC for a civilian helicopter in China, based on claims from PWC. By early 2004, HSC learned there might an export problem and stopped working on the Z-10 project. UTC also began to ask PWC about the exports to China for the Z-10. Regardless, PWC on its own modified the software and continued to export it to China through June 2005.
One thing that has not been mentioned is that UT programmers know the back doors into that software . As a result they can defeat it . The implications are profound for being able to sabotage a war machine by installing a computer virus .
Fines
I guess that'sok but doesn't go far eough. This is a traitorous act; hangingsare called for imho.
Here's another link with more info...
Here are the particulars of the scheme, according to the Justice Department:
One thing that has not been mentioned is that UT programmers know the back doors into that software . As a result they can defeat it . The implications are profound for being able to sabotage a war machine by installing a computer virus .
Thanks Rich, that lends some realinsight.
So do you think that it is possible to root out and defeat theseback-doors?
It is possible but it might take as much work as writing one's own software . What would be the point ?
Ok, gottchya.
I assume that means that that software is still vulnerable.
Good.
You know for a change, you use the term traitorous act in an appropriate manner, and I totally agree with you.
Perrie,
Yup, I don't use that termloosely. These A-holes sold out their country and families for money. It doesn't get much worse than that.
No it doesn't.
Can we do that anymore?
Interesting Rich