Anti-Zionism: Generally Accepted Expression of Anti-Semitism
As defined by Wikipedia, Zionism is a form of nationalism of Jews and Jewish culture that supports a Jewish nation-state in a trerritory defined as the land of Israel. I do not completely support this definition, but for the sake of a more efficatious article, I used a more "neutral" source to define Zionism.
There are a great number of critics of Israel (shocking, I know) who profusely declare that they have no qualms with the Jewish people, but are notheless anti-Zionist. They call into question the legitimacy of their acquistion of territory at every turn. They call into question the legitimacy of their means and ends of defending themselves against terrorism. They call into question the sincerity in their desire to make peace with those that live around them. And all through their challenges, they profess to have no issues with the Jews; they claimit is a "political issue" through and through. This, despite the fact that the country was conceived and created by Jews.
To put it as politely as possible, their claims are specious. By the definition alone, you cannot be one without the other. I'm not seeking to rehash these dissimulative arguments; no, I'm only here to provide you with an illustration of another public official who will no doubt deny he ever made the statements he made, or claim that the reporter changed his words, or perhaps was even "taken out of context".
We can never know what people say behind closed doors, but we are too often "treated" to reports of conversations, discussions and public declarations that give us more than enough proof of which end is up. These comments are often excused or written off as "isolated incidents, not indicative of the general state of thought". That worked the first hundred times. We're in the thousands now.
Please enjoy the following article. It is the most current illustration of this behaviour.
http://www.hindustantimes.com/world-news/RestOfAsia/Iran-VP-says-Jewish-law-book-to-blame-for-drugs-trade/Article1-879413.aspx
Tags
Who is online
71 visitors

Rahimi sounds like he might be jonesing for his next hit but his dealer ain't coming through. And why in the world would anybody attend aninternational anti-drug conference in Tehran? Really, just retarded.
Iran has historically been a major grower of poppies, and a number of their government officials have profited from this.
Perhaps he is deflecting his nation's complicity in the worldwide problem.
The fact is that he used an international forum to blame Israel for yet another of the woes that world is experiencing. He was not censured by the body, and tens of millions of people worldwide will have yet another canard to spew when villifying Israel.
And the band played on...
If for no other reason, I'd be compelled to visit just to rent a car, park illegally in the area for my entire stay, and claim diplomatic immunity when they tried to collect.
A little NY humor there...
On a more serious note, the UN should relocate to a country whose mores it corresponds to more closely. Maybe France, Norway, Somalia...
Obviously, Iran needs to teach a little more geography, since they seem to have located Mexico, not Israel
But seriously folks.....
It is possible tocriticizeIsrael and not be an antisemite, Jon. It is only when a pattern of behavior that emerges that I wonder. No nation is above criticizim, but when you hold Israel to a different standard to every other country in the world, well then I would say your problem is not with Israel but Jews.
What I found the most unnerving was the fact that he literally placed the blame on Jewish Scripture! Revolting.
There is no manner of criticism currently leveled at Israel that passes your test.
None whatsoever.
Israel is NOT above criticism. They have not handled themselves in an ideal manner through many of their trials. There is room for improvement along many fronts. But ALL of their problems exist in the context of conflicts with other parties, and these other parties are not held responsible for their own actions. In fact, many of their most heinous actions are lauded by their own. The world turns a blind eye, and the band continues to play.
It is not possible to publicly CONSTRUCTIVELY criticize Israel.
Not when Vice Presidents of neighboring countries spew the shit they do in UN sanctioned conferences.
Did you notice which tractate of Talmud he cited to back his comment?
Me neither. And you never will, because he's talking out of his ass. But don't worry. Tens of millions of loyal followers worldwide will take him at his word.
If you are talking about the usual host of characters at the UN, you are right. If you are talking about people talking among themselves, I would have to disagree.
I don't understand this statement. Please clarify.
It is Iran we are talking about here. Are ya shocked? They go to the LouisFarrakhanschool of antisemtisim. Fed a daily diet,guaranteedto grow proper antisemites.
Well that's the point isn't it?
Because some can talk outta their asses all day long, not be held responsible for it, and incite all kindsa hatredamongtheir heated masses. Thecanardsyou mentioned above, multiply like rabbits.
When people speak amongst themselves, they can speak constructively if they choose to do so. The highest level of conversation you can engage in is one where you can discuss ideology and execution of policy without having to waste time answering to canard.
Perrie, it is not possible to publicly CONSTRUCTIVELY criticize Israel because the folks that would end up joining you in agreement are only too happy to pile on the one-sided double-standard bullshit. There would be no "meeting of the minds" in the constructive sense. There would be no admission of deficiency on the other side of the conflict. There would be only more of the usual. Not constructive. Not solution-seeking dialogue, except for Israel putting down its arms, and opening its borders. That's a solution all right. A final solution, if you ask me.
Not constructivein any way.
That people would pile on is certainly true. However, public criticism of anything worthy of criticism is valid whether others try to pervert it or not. It's kind of a double edged blade to state that no public criticism of Israel is constructive. It takes thing too far the other way in my opinion.
I take Jonathan to mean that the conversation may or may not be worthy, it's that the pervasiveness of bias makes it utterly impossible to be constructive. Not that as a declaration, but as an observation.
D'Wayne,
I think it's helpful at this point that we all need to be reminded that criticism used to have a useful function. The purpose of criticism is to point out the shortcomings of someone/something, and then to offer a solution/remedy so that one could improve themselves.
That is no longer the main purpose of criticism. The main reasons why people give criticism today is that it gives them an ego boost with a sense of power. You can elevate yourself in two ways; you can either raise yourself up by improving on your talents, abilities, knowledge and character, or you can put someone else down and climb over them.
If you look at the quality of criticism that Israel receives, there is no design to improve the situation; it is only to kneecap them so that eventually their enemies can step over them. There is nothing constructive about the criticism. And those that perpetuatethis strategyrefuse to believe that this is a completely ineffective means to an end. When you boil an egg, it hardens. The longer you boil it, the harder it gets. They've held them in the fire for 3,300 years. Do you really think that a public statement of pernicious falsehood by a top government official will cause Israel to pause and say, "Hey! That guy's right. We will lay down our arms"? Do you think that the MSMs non-coverage of rocket fire into Israel is constructive? D'Wayne, do you know how many rockets have been fired into Israel THIS YEAR? In 2012? Why don't you know? Because nobody is reporting it. Because it's not germain to the miguided goal of the world, to force Israel into making bad decisions, so that we can show everyone that we're not Islamaphobic.
It's a product of many things, not the least of which is the new, wrongheaded use of criticism. All it does is rile people up more than they already were. Nothing comes of it but more criticism and more canard and more hate.
BTW, 420 rockets have been fired into Israel so far this year. All targets were civilian.
So you are saying that because Israel in in a perpetual state of warfare, that it should not be criticized when the criticism is valid? Because maybe enemies of Israel might use such to their advantage? Not a solid foundation for an argument. Basically, you are saying (as i understand it) that it is unacceptable to criticize Israel publicly because it might strengthen their enemies causes, or because enemy criticisms are simply lies veiled under such auspices.
By my mind, there is both. Enemy lies and valid concern regarding some of Israel's choices. Neither should be ignored. Simply saying that they have been hardened by 3000 years of fire is also not a good argument.
Now, as an aside to all this, I am currently reading "Moses and Akhenaten". Pretty fascinating topic that you might consider reading as well Jonathon. Doesnt broach the topic of modern day politics or warfare, but rather focuses on clarifying dubious historical facts regarding Moses by identifying the true timelines for major historical events centered around him.
We need to hear Shelley's choice of fav hairy man in this location :
[One of the choices is Chuck Heston as Moses .]
Jon,
I get what you are saying... but there are just people who understand the situation there, and when Israel makes a mistake, and it has, criticism is the only way that improvements can be made. Now I do realize that there are those who use their criticism to hide their hate, but that isn't true for the most part, here in the US. It's criticism for criticism sake that serves no purpose, and therefore is probably to stir up hate. Still, no one is above useful criticism, even if we fuel those who do have hate in their hearts. The right thing to do, is a constant.
Babylonian Talmud, Masechet Brachot 31A-B
Eli said to her, 'How long will you make a drunken spectacle of yourself? Sober up!' Rabbi Eleazar said: From here we learn that one who sees a companion doing something inappropriate must let them know (rebuke them).
I have long said it is better to make a drunken spectacle of oneself than a sober spectacle ...
D'Wayne,
I think I gave the wrong impression. "Unacceptable" is not the right word. More like "fruitless". When Israel makes a move worthy of criticism, they are well aware of it, because there is internal conflict to a great degree, and also a VERY open and free media that has no problem exposing anything - even before checking facts (thank you, Ha'aretz). Criticizing Israel is like criticizing the US, or UK or any other open society where all events are bared to the public at large. Israel's enemies do not afford their citizenry the same scrutiny of themselves, and therein lies the crux of criticism issue. Israel's enemies are not aware of theplus side of the ledger, and are provided with a distorted picture of theminus side. Palestinian families do not know the good Israel does until one of their little ones has a heart condition that requires surgery. When they all get a free trip to an Israeli hospital, and witness the recovery of their baby, they get their first taste. The people of Syria don't know that one of the Israeli Supreme Court Justices is an Arab. The Egyptian peasantry doesn't know that there are several Arab MKs in the Knesset. They know apartheid, which clearly doesn't exist. They know open-air prison, which is purely false. They know "stolen land" and "right of return" and other canards. But they don't know the truth about their own country and they don't know the truth about Israel. So it's fruitless to offer a hand, when you know it be spit upon.
Perrie,
How 'bout finding me the Talmudic referene to our Iranian VPs statement?
Jon,
LOL... that would mean that he didn't mean it to be antisemetic, which of course he did. I am talking in generalities here. Not your specific example, which of course, does make a point.
But the aboveexplanation to D'Wayne is well thought out, and I'd have to go along with it.
Well at least you have a good excuse.
Middle eastern countries can get away wit chit that other countries can't . That's because they have leverage [translation : oil ] .
Yeah , but if the west didn't need their oil [that includes Europe] we would just withdraw from the middle east completely . If we stopped buying their oil , revenues would dry up and no one would waste their time there .
It's only the presence of oil that makes Europe concerned about this region . It's been that way since WWII when the combatants needed oil to wage war .
That certainly makes more sense when presented in that fashion.
D'Wayne,
This is a tough subject for me. I have to gather my thoughts, and then start typing. I read what I write, and edit. I read again. And edit again. I have to measure what I say, because it's quite obvious who I'm defending. I have to choose my words to make an objective case. I chose this example, because it addresses one morsel outof an entire buffet. When taken oneissue at a time, this is a no-brainer. It's when you're assaulted with half a dozen aspects at once that you - and many others like you who are trying to actually learn something about this issue - throw your hands up in frustration and don't know what to think.
I appreciate you hanging in there. You're a rare bird.
Islam has only been a faith for 1500 years and Europe has been fighting with since the first Crusade, which is about 1000 years ago. Last evasion into Europe was the Moors, about 711 and booted in 1492.
For that reason, I'm going to agree with Rich. If there was no oil there, we wouldn't give a chit. Just look at Africa, Muslims killing Muslims, killing Christians and no one even know or cares about it. Why? No natural resources we need.
Excellent conversation.
IMHO, the shiekhs see their one last chance for world dominance; and, they plan on riding the Caliphate toget it done. Their only real source of large wealth is oil, and they know that it is only a matter of time before alternative fuel sources are developed and cut them off at the knees. It's now or never for Arabia, and they know it. These clashes have been going on for quite a while, the oil only exacerbates the situation.
I totally agree Larry!
Robert ,
[[Power, control of trade routes, control of commerce, access to wealth. Insert... salt, gold, snails, spices, tulips, silver, lumber, poppies, oil....whatever. To state that "without oil, nobody cares," is a narrow vision of history, and a narrow prediction of the future, particularly in congested, contested strangle points and crossroads. Like those that exist at the Gates of Hercules, the Straights of Hormuz, the Bosporus, and the Suez and Red Sea. Many more in other parts of the world.]]
Actually , most of the commerce in one of those choke points is involved in the moving of petroleum . Crude oil flows out and refined fuels flow in . That would be the case any time access to the middle east is involved . Sure the Suez is a multipurpose trade route . Most of those others are also involved with trade to multiple regions . The 1 exception is the Strait of Hormuz . The simple fact is that the rest of the globe could cut off the entire middle east from world trade and not miss it . The 2 exceptions to that are petroleum and Israeli products ...
Too true, just read this one not so long ago...
No problem. You've taught me some things over the years, and I am always interested in reading your viewpoints. I dont always agree, but I'm always willing to look at them with an open mind. More often than not though, I do agree with your posts, especially with regards to the Middle East.
Of course.
With a swimming pool I hope.
Actually, they have a lot more to worry about with a perfect redheifer...
Then build the swimming pool.
Oh yeah, forgot about that.
Hey, build theheifer a pool too!
It's the least we could do for the gal!