Is the Battle Flag More Fun?
Why is the left is so intent upon removing the Confederate battle flag from public display? After all, everybody knows that outside a handful of skinheads, people dont display the Confederate battle flag in order to celebrate Americas original sin. Were long past slavery. Well, not the race hustlers like theyre going to put yall back in chains Joe Biden or his boss not to mention perennial White House guest and tax cheat Al Sharpton and spiritual counselor to presidents Jesse Jackson. But, by and large, everybody else is past slavery.Then theres the point where the campaign may backfire indeed, wind up infusing the Confederate battle flag with a new and more powerful meaning. After all, theres a towering example in what happened when the Confederates, refusing to leaving well enough alone, fired on the Stars and Stripes at Fort Sumter.Yet the left is resolved. And the real reason is not all that difficult to puzzle out. Indeed, Richard Fausset puts his finger on it at the New York Times (July 7, 2015) when he writes that the Confederate battle flag is a revered symbol, not only of the Confederate dead, but of a unique regional identity.That unique regional identity is a fork in the liberals eye. Liberals have somehow gotten their teeth into the idea that if they can destroy the Confederate battle flag, it will go a long ways toward getting the South to shut up, to abandon that unique regional identity. Not all at once not even the most fervent de Blasio supporter or dug in Marin County Socialist would hope for that. But at least start chipping away at the Souths pantheon of heroes, its foundation myth, its speech, its cooking, its music, its literature, and its engrained and peculiar affection for the Christian religion and ornery individuals.But much more importantly, ever so much more importantly, liberals hope that if you take that flag away, the South can be made to begin shedding its abiding esteem for bravery, property rights, guns, business, and traditional families.Because that vibrant culture offers an attractive alternative civilization to the one the liberals have been so carefully crafting elsewhere. There is a windowless box theyre trying to get every American inside, with no heroes except those designated by Washington, no competing allegiances like church or family, no other way to live except by fawning dependence, no enterprise except what is sanctioned and intensely regulated. The whole ruled by an elite.Liberals problem with America is that theres no secret police or hired mercenaries, as there were in Russia, to drive people into the box. People have to walk in on their own. And, drawn by government benefits or the jealousy liberals forever inflame, many have.But its not enough, because as hard as liberals have tried to drape the box in bright colors, it doesnt look as though theres a whole lot of happy going on in there. Indeed, the sight of it produces an ever widening split between red and blue states and counties a division that actually has more people on the red side of the divide than the blue, and so may end the liberal ascendancy.Because the red side, typified by the South, is a lot more fun.Thats the rub. As a Christian, you take to heart Christs admonition in the Sermon on the Mount that life is good and God the Father sent it to you to enjoy, which is why Gospel music and country music, the music of the South, are so intertwined. And while the South is labeled the land of guns by liberals, what it actually is is the land of socials and singing. And the special joy and attraction of the South are that unlike those people in the box, whose children go one way while they go another, the Southern social is first and foremost a childrens crusade after church, at tractor pulls and rodeos, parades and memorials, tailgating football games, high school football games.Southern men dont fuss over gear and then posture fly fishing; they bass fish or shark fish with their sons and daughters and grandparents. Same with shooting. The same in a very special way with hunting. New York State once commissioned a study on why people hunt. It turns out theres a number of reasons, but heading the list is culture. In one anecdote a man explained that years after his dad passed on, hell set up in the woods and still get the scent of my father.In the South and West, and in many counties in the North, life is all about the scent of your father.Visit one of the huge country western bars. To the disgust of liberals, the young people there seem to want to grow up to be just like the older folks theyre dancing next to. And you cant stop them.And thats why liberals want to kill the Confederate battle flag.Read more: http://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2015/07/is_the_battle_flag_more_fun.html#ixzz3gzXn6nOo Follow us: @AmericanThinker on Twitter | AmericanThinker on Facebook

Miniter said, " Indeed, Richard Fausset puts his finger on it at the New York Times (July 7, 2015) when he writes that the Confederate battle flag is a revered symbol, not only of the Confederate dead, but of a unique regional identity.
Undoubtedly, this flag has become almost a vague -- ever shifting -- floating signifier since the Confederate surrender. As Wikipeidia tells of its history atop the South Carolina State House, " The Confederate battle flag was raised over the State House on April 11, 1961 at the request of Representative John May , ostensibly as a part of opening celebrations of the Confederate War Centennial , according to Dr. Daniel Hollis, an appointed member of the centennial commission. Many historians point out that the appearance of the flag likely had a more nefarious purpose: to symbolize Southern defiance in the face of a burgeoning Civil Rights Movement . In March 1962, lawmakers passed a resolution directing the flag be flown over the State House. [42] [43] [44] As Time magazine later noted, the move was a states-rights rebuff to desegregation. -
By coincidence, the Confederate War Centennial occurred at about the same moment when the African American Civil Rights Movement was in full bloom in the South, so the "signifier" was not entirely vague in the minds of Civil Rights activists and African Americans, who did not generally buy the notion that the flag was merely a matter of honoring the Civil War dead..., or celebrating a unique regional culture -- its music and cuisine, etc.
It is, after all, the Confederate Battle Flag, and any attempt to completely re-brand it as a mere and innocent symbol of a unique regional culture runs up against that fact. It was the flag of a slave-holding and racist regional culture. And if Southerners want a flag to represent their unique culture without having it also signal and signify whitesupremacy, they will have to do a little reading up on semiotics prior to designing a new Southern flag.
Just what is your beef withsecular progressive liberals, anyway? I mean, the real ones, not the made up, imaginary ones.
Let's take it one word at a time.
What makes these things evil?
Let's start with the word "secular".
Would you not have the United States of American be a secular government? That is, would you replace this secular government with a religious state -- with a state religion? Would you have The South secede from the Union and form a church state?
Great article Jefferson. Too bad the northern states didn't put a flag up every time they ran a black out of town or a state. It's not necessarily the northern states but the progressives who have been trying forever to trick people into walking into this box without windows or even a way out.
As far as I'm concerned, you're wrong.
Cerenkov :
James.... Surprise!!!! We don't have any slaves in the south. Life is better for blacks in the south if appears as you see they seem to be much more dissatisfied in the northern states. Maybe you should take the time to open that mind of yours and realize we all have played a part in slavery as Dowser said. No one's hands are clean. We've admitted it was bad and we know there were many more slaves in the south than in the north, but did you know the slave market was financed by the wealthy families in the north? They've been financing terrible things long before they set up banks that took people's gold to secure it and gave them paper money many years ago. They made a fortune on the housing bubble. They've been behind many of the atrocities throughout history.
And when slavery was abolished the north didn't want any of them in their cities or states. Laws were made up to keep the north white. The south took pride in taking care of the older slaves who were unable to work any longer, while the north took no such pride in doing so.
You should really take the time to read the link I put up on an earlier comment and click on some of the links on the left side. It will enlighten you if you are a person of integrity and honesty as to the truth of the matter and you may not have such a one-sided point of view. It's futile to waste any time on some. Don't remain ignorant of the facts any longer than you have to do so.
Here is the link again. You can start here and click on the links on this page.
You want to know specifics, then read all the links on this page and that will give you plenty enough information. Remember, all of our forefathers lived during that same period of time.
And the west is covered in those links as well.
Reply by Sixpick :
"James.... Surprise!!!! We don't have any slaves in the south."
Sheesh. I didn't even read any further than these snide and condescending words before having to point out that -- if you want to actually COMMUNICATE --, snideness and condescension is not a good way to begin an opening paragraph with your interlocutor.
Okay, I'll now read on.
" ...and you may not have such a one-sided point of view."
I read on, and yet the snide condescension continues.... Sheesh.
Why in the hell do you guys pre-suppose that I'm not open minded and interested in the truth?
I never did such a thing. I merely said only that the Confederate Battle flag is not an innocent symbol of the good people of The South. I've looked into it carefully, and that flag rather obviously cannot be stripped entirely of the meaning it held upon its creation. The majority of people seem to agree with me on that point. Not that that makes me right, of course. But it's worth noting.
Sorry James. Just guess I'm a little tired of the seemly desire of the Progressives to subjugate the culture of the South.
Mississippi
[Copied by Justin Sanders from "Journal of the State Convention", (Jackson, MS: E. Barksdale, State Printer, 1861), pp. 86-88] A Declaration of the Immediate Causes which Induce and Justify the Secession of the State of Mississippi from the Federal Union.In the momentous step which our State has taken of dissolving its connection with the government of which we so long formed a part, it is but just that we should declare the prominent reasons which have induced our course.
Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery -- the greatest material interest of the world. Its labor supplies the product which constitutes by far the largest and most important portions of commerce of the earth. ....
Excerpted from:
Also see:
Celebrate your Southern culture by wearing hooped skirts, drinking mint juleps and having a bowl of black eyed peas with cornbread on New Years day, (one of the thingsmy family does),orchose any other of the other thousands of ways that are out there.
Celebrate your German culture by wearing lederhosen, eating bratwurst and dancing to Polka music.
However, when you raise the Confederate battle flag, (first raised in treason by folks that didn't want to give up their right to own black folk and then a second time when many of those same type of folks didn't want to have to sit next to the now freed black population), or you march under your oversized German swastika battle flag, don'ttry and act surprised when you getsome push backfrom thegeneral community because you're choosing to rally around symbols that highlight the ugliest parts of the culture you are claiming to venerate.
XXJeferson, If what you claim is true, you'll be needing to counter these claims here.:
Just saying so does not make something true. Arguments ground in facts, not wishes.
Confederate battle flag, like Nazi swastika, is offensive emblem of hateful cause
I guess this means you'll never see black people with a confed flag ? Are you sure ?
Take a poll amongst African Americans and find out how many of 'em fly or wear that emblem of white supremacy. You will find a tiny, tiny fraction who do. There are some rare exceptions to the rule -- as with most things.
In defense of Confederate flag, frequent Fox News guest claims Civil War wasn't about slavery
I don't give a shit what the history books say the Civil War was about. I know, from family history, that not one of my ancestors fought under the Stars and Bars or the Battle Flag for slavery. They fought because they felt the Union was taking advantage of them. The taxes, the tariffs, the hoops they had to jump through just to eek out a living for them and their families.
So all you sanctimonious fucks who have never lived in the south, and never grew up listening to the stories about poor dirt farmers in the deep south...Kiss my Red Neck Rebel ASS.
Hi Bruce.
I believe you are very sincere about your views about the causes of the Civil War, and what you believe folks in the South fought for -- and about. So I am going to promise you right here and right now to journey with you as far and as deep as is necessary for us BOTH to learn what each of us can and should learn about the causes of that war.
I'll explore the question with an open mind; I promise
Are you in?
Here's one thing I strongly suspect. I strongly suspect -- at this early state in my research -- that an elite upper class of Southern slaveholders manipulated a lower class of non-slave-owning (even poor) Southerners to take up arms against "The North" for reasons other than the ones the "wealthy" elite really had in mind -- which are reasons having to do with the pocket books of the rich, elite slave owners, not the common Southern woman and man.
Let's see if I'm right?
The South still lies about the Civil War
In an ongoing revisionist history effort, Southern schools and churches still pretend the war wasn't about slavery
TRACY THOMPSON
I'm betting you pretty much nailed it. When you look into the causes of civil/social conflicts you're always lead back to money/power.
This article is essential reading for any honest inquiry into the question as to why poor or non-elite (e.g., non-slave-owning) white Southerners would have fought for the cause of continued slavery and white supremacy.:
Why Non-Slaveholding Southerners Fought
ADDRESS TO THE CHARLESTON LIBRARY SOCIETY, JANUARY 25, 2011
BY GORDON RHEA
...
Read along, Cerenkov. We shall see if historical fact trumps mere "opinion".
Seems to be so, Pat. Over and over again, doesn't it?
This may help us to locate the real "enemy" (if indeed anyone is ever our enemy) in future (or current) conflicts.
"Follow the money," right?
"Let's us get them over there to fight our battle for us."
Here is your problem James. You're reading articles and blogs posted by people who did not LIVE the life then, nor live within the South now. And I'm not talking about Charleston, or Charlotte, or Birmingham, or Atlanta or Nashville. I'm talking about the deep south. Leesburg GA. Chatham GA. Griffin GA. The small towns that are so small they don't even rate a Walmart. Towns with little or no Internet access, not because it's unavailable, but because there's no interest.
What do you call the conflict of 1861-1865?
"What do you call the conflict of 1861-1865?"
I call it the Civil War, or the American Civil War, though I do so with full acknowledgement of the irony of thejuxtapositionof the words "civil" and "war". I call it this because this is the general convention, and for no other special reason.
"You're reading articles and blogs posted by people who did not LIVE the life then, nor live within the South now."
Are you honestly suggesting that people who did not live in the deep South back in the days of he war, or who don't live there now, cannot form sound, rational, informed perspectives on the nature of that war or the current symbolic meaning of the Confederate battle flag?
Reply by XXJefferson#51 :
"Do you consider the Americans living in the south in 1860-1865 to be comparable to or as bad as Nazi Germany?"
Both the similarities and the differences are striking. Comparable? Of course! Though many important differences exist, both societies perpetuated atrocities against certain non-white racial groups which they justified on the basis of the presumed supremacy of whites.
I hardly think it is at all necessary to in any way document the central fact of racism in the Confederate States of America. The very core and heart of the Confederacy was a racist policy. Period. End of story. ... so it should be obvious that the Confederate battle flag was a racist flag. The ONLY question is ... Can that flag have been stripped of its originally intended racist symbolism. My answer to this questions is: no. It cannot. And the whole world is waking up to this fact now -- finally.
Yeah, the USA had a long history of racist policies prior to the war, leading up to the war, and even into the war. This is a good and valid point. Thanks!
During the war, the USA was beginning to retreat from racism and slavery. It was far from perfect, but it had begun a process of ending slavery -- which the Confederacy was so offended by that it went to war with the USA, after secession.
The Confederate States were utterly committed to maintaining the racist policies which the USA was beginning to turn away from. Indeed, this "turning away from" was the principal cause of the war.
American Anti-Slavery and Civil Rights Timeline
Timeline compiled by V. Chapman Smith
-- excerpt --
1857
This was a VERY short time before the Civil War began in 1961, and is an example of the correctness of those who say that the USA was very much a racist nation just prior to the War. As a matter of its laws, the USA was very much a racist nation leading up to and well into that war.
However..., the USA was taking gradual steps away from slavery and racism -- and the Confederacy would not have it.
My ancestors and all the way up to my grandfathers and grandmothers called it the "War of Northern Aggression".
So yeah, I'm saying if you didn't live it, or live IN IT, you can't form a sound perspective.
Bruce T.: "So yeah, I'm saying if you didn't live it, or live IN IT, you can't form a sound perspective. "
That is simply ridiculous.
You're basically saying people with a Ph.D in History, even specialists in the Civil War, if they don't live in the deep South, must necessarily be ignorant on the Civil War ... While you, yourself, are an expert -- because you live there, and your ancestors lived there.
That's like saying none of us know anything at all about the moon, as none of us live on the moon.
None of us here know anything about China, either, unless we live in China.
Now I see why so many folks in the forum just ignore whatever you say.
Moon Cheese proof!:
Yea, wellmy Grandmotherwould tell we kidsthe story of how sheonce saw her mother,a young girl in during the war, break down and start crying while she was brushing her hair one day.
When Aline, my grandmother, asked what was wrong and her mom admitted it wasjust a sad memory. Seemsthat before the war she hadnever had to brush her own hairbecause that hadalwaysbeen doneby the familieshouse slaves and she was struggling with whatshe had lost during her childhood.
That side of my family once owned a large plantation in Hot Springs, AR, which they lost because of the war.
Around 1870 thatpart of the family moved to Texas, setting down roots ina little town halfway between San Antonio and Nuevo Laredo.
After I out grew my Roy Rogers cowboy hat I preferred to run around the woods wearing my "Johnny Yuma" rebel cap.
Myfamilies Southern and Texas roots run pretty deep and we always called it a"Civil War". None of that bull hokey, "War of Northern Aggression", nonsense.