Nakba Day - The Ultimate Palestinian Tell
Israel declared statehood on May 14 1948. Being the Jewish State, they celebrate every year on the Hebrew calendar date - the 5th day of Iyar. In Israel, the celebration is equivalent to the 4th of July festivities that we partake of here in America.
May 15 is commemorated by the Palestinian people, and much of the Arab world as "Nakba Day". Nakba, translated from the Arabic, is "disaster" or "catastrophe". The day afterdeclaring independence in 1948, Israel was attacked by all of the nations surrounding her. Safe to say, Israel still exists. They won that war. The Arabs lost that war. They commemorate this loss every year.
So let's understand something, so it should be clear. If you commemorate a war that you lost, in an attempt to eradicate a country that just declared statehood, it's safe to say that you don't view this country as one that you are interested in making peace with.
It is difficult to show compassion for a people with this attitude. It's true that the nations surrounding Israel started this war. It's true that a large number of Palestinian Arabs became refugees. Many of them still consider themselves as such. It's true that we should show compassion. It is not true that we should engage these people so as to reverse the verdict of that war.
The commemoration serves as a reminder to the Arab world that they have unfinished business. This is a zero-sum game to them. Over the last 19 years, they have repeatedly refused to negotiate with Israel, and have repeatedly refused very generous unilateraloffers. They have been given land in the hope that it would result in peace. There is still no peace. Only yesterday, their "leader" Mahmoud Abbas accused Israel of "ethnic cleansing" in of all places, Jerusalem.
There is no partner for peace with Israel.Therefore, there is no one to concede anything to. There isno one to exchange anything with. There is no one to make compromises with.
Wake me when someone who means something shows up.

Happy Independance day Israel!
"Nabka day" huh. "We are losers day", or" fck peace, we want Israel gone day". How about "Eternal victim, arab excuse, neverending pestilence day"? Perhaps the UNwill make it an international holiday so all can join in with self-imposed refugee status and recive monetary aid fortheir bloated plight.
When you define yourself by your losses, you cannot help but be defined as a loser. The world grows weary of the whining, because now there are REAL problems in the world that must be addressed. There are too many authentic problems in the world to continue worrying about manufactured ones.
Come on Larry. You should know that right now the UN is too busy giving Mt. Rushmore back to the native Americans. When they are done with that, they will get to this pressing issue./sarc
It also freezes you in the position of never changing the status quo. If they want to help their people, peace talks should be the way to go. But they are mired in never forgetting the Alamo.
Very true. Like giving Mt. Rushmore back to the Indians. No seriously, the world hasn't been in such a bad place since right before WWII and the ME is in such flux that anything could happen.
Well when you think about it, the UN seems to want to redraw the sociological mapsfor a few places in the world.
The Mt. Rushmore issue is indicative of the UN's inability/unwillingness to handle the catastrophes that plague today's world. The Great Satan and the Little Satan are easy targets for an organization comprised mostly of 3rd world nations that have little or no regard for their own citizenry. By focusing on the real problems, they'd have to acknowledge the atrocities that they commit upon their own people.
Weak = Right and Strong = Wrong are what allow banana republic thugocrats to mislead bleeding hearts in developed nations, and allow their own ignorant populaces to blame someone other than the people that are actually brutalizing them.
Ok lets take it bulleted step by bulleted step then...
Disprove it.
The problems are that the cultural gulf between the european jews and the middle eastern arabs is too great .
There are almost no shared values .
Non-starter.
8 bullet points
Zero sourcing.
1 attempt at moral relativism.
FAIL
Hey Rich,
Can you enumerate the shared values between the Middle Eastern Jews and the Middle Eastern Arabs for me?
Let's make this as easy as possible, better yet:
Can you enumerate the shared values between the Middle Eastern Arabs and any group?
Well to be accurate , I put down "almost no shared values" because I wanted to leave open the possibility that there might be some . Frankly , I don't know of any . How about you ?
Well, that depends. If the Arabs are Christian, they have shared values with other Arab Christians.
If they are Sunnis, they have shared values with othe Sunni Muslim Arabs. I believe there are Sunni majorities in most of the Arab/Islamic states.
If they are Shi'ites, they have shared values with the Muslims of Iran, but Iranians are not Arabs.
That's what I got.
How 'bout you?
That sounds about right.
Uh ... lessee . The Arab Muslims believe in plural marriage . That makes them a little like the 19th century Mormons . Where else did they get into plural marriage ?
From the singular.
"So let's understand something, so it should be clear. If you commemorate a war that you lost, in an attempt to eradicate a country that just declared statehood, it's safe to say that you don't view this country as one that you are interested in making peace with."
I found that comment to be both profound and incontrovertible.
Gave me something new to consider.
Yup.
And the conclusions fairly chilly.
We would consider peace and security to be paramount, yet that does not seem to be the case in the minds of the Palestinians. The dynamics of this prioritization is freaky to me. The ideology is one thing, but the espoused hatred is detrimental to their own survival.
Walid Khalidi ( Arabic : , born 1925 in Jerusalem ) is an Oxford University -educated Palestinian historian who has written extensively on the Palestinian exodus . He is General Secretary and co-founder of the Institute for Palestine Studies , established in Beirut in December 1963 as an independent research and publishing center focusing on the Palestine problem and the ArabIsraeli conflict .
Not exactly an unbiased source or view either, Iar.
Iar,
I have read much on this topic, and what I have found, as with most things, that the view depends very much on who is writing it. Very few people come to these discussions without bias and this has been a real bone of contention for me. For every event there are two views... because like anything else there are two sides of the story and the truth lies somewhere in between.
But saying that Jon will not be satisfied short of "ethnic cleansing", is a huge jump in what he was saying, and very provacative. I reread what he wrote, and it just says that there is no peace partner there, based on his perception. And that is what this whole issue is based on... perception.
iarnuocon,
Whereas history is subject to interpretation and debate, current events are quite less so. There are various takes on "who's to blame" for the events of the last 100 years, which bring us to thecurrent situation. There are "perceptions" that color the views of those who stand on either side of the conflict.
What is not subject to debate is the manner in which the Palestinian people manifest their so-called desire for peace and statehood TODAY, and it is wrong, wrong, wrong on every count.
Rather than negotiate directly with Israel, they resort to end-runs for statehood through intermediaries, such as the UN, the ICJ and the "Quartet".
Rather than negotiate directly with Israel, they rile the world into BDS campaigns, which only result in greater exposure and success for Israeli products worldwide.
Rather than negotiate directly with Israel, they reject every overture for negotiations by placing "preconditions" upon every negotiation. What need is their for negotiation if one party gives things away prior to negotiation? What incentive does the enriched party have to agree upon anything if they are given a concession without negotiating? And what have the Palestinians ever offered? We hear about what Israel SHOULD do; what Israel should return and concede in order for the Palestinians to be satisfied. What will the Palestinians give? Another promise to put astop this and cease that?
Rather than negotiate with Israel, missiles continue to pelt Israelicivilian populations on a DAILY basis from the Palestinian territories. Hamas, the terrorist organization ruling Gaza, is still hellbent upon the destruction of the Jewish State. Just look at their charter. That has never changed, and rulers publicly state this desire even today.
So, rather than debate about history, understand that BOTH sides need to feel as though any agreements reached will be worth more than the paper they are written on. That is not a privilege limited to the Palestinian side.
Finally,try to resist the urge for namecalling. If you refrain from referring to me a hack from now on, I won't call you an asshole.
Thank you
As illustrated by your responses to my post, you suffer from the same problem that the Palestinians have. By equating what happened 60 plus years ago with today certainly has its parallels, but will not result in any advancement for peace. And you, like they will continue to not understand why they'll never get anywhere with their means to their desired end.
As for debating with you, we all have choices in the blogosphere. I'm sure there are people that appreciate your style of debate.
Good for you, and good day.
Iar,
If we want to dwell on the past 60 years, I can point to many times that the Arab populations had murder Jews in the region. The Grand Mufti was an allie of Hitler's. He and many other ME nations help Hitler prevent Jews from entering the region toescapethe "Final Solution", while there was mass slaughters of Jews in Iraq. So while it might have been "Collective Guilt" by the Europeans for WWII, there was no love for the Jews in that region long before WWII. There is blood on both hands, and to deny this is to deny the truth.
So where do we go? If the Palestiniansreally want a homeland for their people, looking back does no good. That is what the Northern Irish found out after how much blood shed? There was an offer made in good faith, during the Clinton years, the most far reaching one, and Arafat turned it down. If he really wanted what was best for his people, he would have excepted it. Israel had a much friendlier government at the time, and they all could have started to put their lives together.
I do believe in a two state solution. But to have that, you need willing parties. Right now, there are none on any side.
But at least Israel is smart enough not to have in their charter theannihilationof the Palestinians, which Hamas has. I will give Abbas credit for not going that route.
BTW this will be my last post on this thread. What I have found when talking about the ME, is most people have their minds very made up and there is no room for constructive dialog. So, feel free to answer my comment, but for me, this subject is a no winner.
~LINK with lots more~
Having read your other posts I don't think I will change you mind any iarnuocon , but this information is still worth posting.
You couldn't help yourself, could you?
The "stolen land" canard. Tsk, tsk. Even the Mufti of Jerusalem(!) admitted that the land was owned by absentee Lebanese landlords. The Zionists PURCHASED the land from the landlords. The lessees - the people that you so staunchly defend - had leased property. When the land was sold, it belonged to someone else, and those people decided to live on it and develop it.
You're not just any kind of asshole, you're a revisionist asshole.
I welcome you to engage in some self-copulation.
How's Newsvine, asshole?
Oh wait, you were shown the door there. We've had someone dumped from NT already.
Where will you go when you get thrown out on your ass here?
Must be a number of anti-Semite blogs that you can engage in your circlejerk with.
Peace and love to you.
Do you believe in Israel's right to exist and to self-determination iarnuocon ?
Here's some more from Israel's "partner in peace".
Ismael Haniyeh, the "Prime Minister" of Hamas, made a little speech today.
This is not a tell.
There's no ambiguity here.
How in the world does anybody expect for Isarel to negotiate with a group who's motto is to not recognize Israel?
It's pure lunacy!
I wouldnt say so. The bottom line is financial for Arabs also, which pretty much ties them to everybody else. However, the idiotic masses have been indoctrinated so thoroughly that rational consideration of the Israel question will never exist. Of course, the same could be said for the west also. Peace is a minority viewpoint.
Sure.
May I ask where/when you believe the conflict truly began?
Started a new post with your comment Iar as it looks like we could easily run outta room.
As to the imprecise wording, the Brits were attempting to keep themselves off the hook politically and then backed off of it somewhat; they werecontradictoryat almost every turn. Between the world wars it seems that many countries, Arab and non-Arab in the ME, began to suffer the consequences of not being totally honest in their dealings. Who woulda thunk it, dishonest politicians. Between the French and the English trying to govern what was leftover from theOttomanEmpire, there were many hard feelings because of botchedhandling. War sucks.
Beyond that, do you believe that it was right for the Jewish population to form anindependentcountry, or should they have just lived along side ofthe Arabs in Palestine?
One major difference between the jews and the arabs in that region is how much motivation there was to develop a nation as opposed to just a collection of tribes . Based on the culture of that region and the constant internal warfare it is not surprising that the neighbors interpreted the motives of the jews as being that of wanting to dominate the entire region [by conquest ?] . But was there any other way to proceed than declaring an independent state of Israel ?
Even though WWII was over, Jews were still fighting for their survival (at least in my mind I think I would have felt that way) and just like many other countries, had to face their discriminatory practices and change them eventually . I know that doesn't speak to the way that Arabs may have felt at the time ofIsraelcreating their own state, it was a reaction to the Jews nearannihilation. Especially since so many Arab countries went to war with Israel the very next day.
Ya know Iar, I am astaunchZionist. I'm not sure if we ever met on the vine, but I like you have had my fill of endless merrygorounds ofuselessbickering regarding this subject. It reminds me how very difficult actual negotiations must be. But I would very much like to find those areas of commonality in order to move the conversation into a productive area. If enough ideological opposites can come together with substantial concern and mutual respect, I believe it's possible to come to some conclusions that don't include trying to destroy one another.
I don't think so, given the situation.
Ya know Robert,
I get your ideology and I believe you get mine, 9o% of what you said I agree with.
and ...
I don't know if yourealize how correct you are when you say...
...in that I do mean that literally that I can well see how difficult actual negotiations must be if even blogging is so difficult.
I mean, I don't know,,,,... maybe it's because I am an American living in America and not Israel?
Or maybe it's because I am not a negotiator or politician.
Or possibly it's because I am a lowly blogger and I find itpossibleto just discuss.
...........
A blogger who I respect a lot reminded me of something a while back...
President Obama isn't going to be tuning into my comments before his pressconference. Neither the FBI or the Pentagon give a shit about my domestic or foreign policies. Good Morning America is going to sell coffee and Insurance regardless of my ideology.
And I reallylikethe fact that I can sit down with an ideological opposite and do something besides broadside each another. Just once. To at least try and first find where we agree and respectfully go from there; and, see at least where we go and how far.
I suppose i truly appreciate the the blessing of freedom that allows me to just explore ideas and imagine what it would be like if more would do so.
In addition to the ideas mentioned in the previous post, the job of bringing ideological opposites togetheris also made more cumbersome by those who promote the ideas that a)Israelis use victimology to further their interests b)that Israel stole land that i)they either purchased or ii)the previous conquerer (Britain) gave them, and c)marginalizing the acts of violence and murder that Palestinians are committing against the civilian population of Israel.
Mutual respect beginswith point and counterpoint, and keeping one's head in a debate that he/she truly wishes to engage in. I don't believe that name-calling at the outset will promote any kind of mutual respect.
Wow Larry,
What a perfect post.
Johnathan has been a bro for a few years now, I'm not going to get in between you guys duking it out.
Making me laugh isn't quite fair, but point taken.
[[The outside world, probably none more blithely and ignorantly than the US, is marvelously self-blinding to those things. "Oh yes, Islam and the people of Islam are completely capable of forming democratic governments that attract and support diverse beliefs and lifestyles."
Where?]]
Actually the answer to that is in Asia but not in the middle east .
And I see the possibilty to come to some conclussions; not all or maybe even a lot of conclussions, but some.Because at least that's a good place to start from.
I think that most who follow the Israel/Palestinian issue know pretty much where most ideologies fall and what is going to have to happen to move forward. But while true as a generalization, is not strictly true from individual to individual.What I am saying is that in discussion, even before compromise let alonea "no-fault"circle-jerk attitude, it would be benificial to see exactly where things line up and where they don't. I mean, I know I am not negotiating for the I/P peace, and it gives me the freedom to just explore what others are thinking about. It is my way of gaining new insightas well asstrengthening my own resolve.
I was thinking more about Malaysia than Indonesia . Oddly enough Indonesia is equitable towards homosexuals ...
I wonder which country is more prone to Islamic violence : Indonesia or Nigeria ?
I penned an article pointing out some factual data. Your first post accused me of lying. You offered nothing in the way of counterpoint, other than hurling canards, topped off with a personal insult. This isan article, designed to engage people in debate, and you chose a different course, over a number of posts, to separate parties.
And now the onus is on me to "walk the walk". I've got to reach out, and show that I'm a willing partner in this debate, even though I put out the text, and you took it as a flamethrowing challenge.
Shall I make concessions to you? Do you have any preconditions to this? Will you bestow "peace" upon me in exchange for this unnamed precondition? Shall I refrain from articles such as this, because it does not comport to the results of the "studies" you have engaged in on this topic since the 90's?
We all put our pants on the same way here. Nobody's special. Nobody's privileged.
Want a friend? Buy a dog.
Here's an interesting candidate for an Islamic democracy . They seem to have western values :
Iar,
If I am not notified, then I don't know what is going on in eacharticle. By the time I saw those comments, other nasties had gone back and forth, so I figured you all had gotten it out of your system. I just happened to catch that last round and being that this article has had enough problems, I figured I should reset the tone.BTW, Robert got scolded too. I'm calling them as I see them, literally.
I think the issue of hosting the flamboyant western decadent song contest says a lot about their permitting freedom of speech . If you're interested I willpost a link for some past editions of that contest . You can then judge for yourself .
OK , here is the reply :