╌>

Logic and the gay marriage issue

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  petey-coober  •  14 years ago  •  134 comments

Logic and the gay marriage issue

Is it possible to have those 2 together in the same sentence ? I think the answer is yes . Now you get to witness the spectacle of someone who is usually logical [me] go bonkers on a public forum . Or so you think . Now , believe it or not , I'm going to explain the connection .

First of all we need to define the traditional concept of what marriage is . Marriage is an institution that was established to provide for the nurturing of children . It has been established by practically all religions for that purpose . OK , having established the original purpose , what has changed since then ?

Clearly there has been a lot of change . For one thing the zero growth movement has taken hold as a major belief system in the US , if not all of Europe . That means that there is much less populating going on at this point . There is the perception that birthing children is much less of a social goal than it used to be . As a result it is also the perception that having the birth parents raising their children should not be given the same import that it used to have .

Up till that last perception , everything was well established and fact based . But the assumption that having the birth parents raising their own children is not as important is simply not based on any solid facts . It is , in other words , a bias against birth parents . There , I said it . It is a biased POV .

Now I have not had children myself so I can't speak from actual experience . But from my POV there is an instinct involved . I realize that we modern 21st century humans are not supposed to have any instincts . We are supposed to be fully "programmable" to accept whatever our society decides is right for us . But I don't believe that is accurate nor is it being true to our "authentic selves" , whatever that means .

The reality is that parents do want to raise their own children , and to do it in the way that they want . And that is why the expansion of the definition of marriage to include gay couples intrudes upon married couples with children , couple which are becoming an endangered species . If there is one thing you can say about gay couples it is that they are incapable of having their own biological children . So why include them in an institution which was established to raise children ?

Here are the objections I am anticipating :

But don't gay people have rights ?
Yes , they have rights . As to the issue of partner benefits which are only permitted to married couples , there is no reason that could not be established legally by some sort of civil union status .

Don't gays have the right to raise children ?
Not their own full biological children . They can't have them , biologically , except for the mother . In other words , they can only have half of the genetic makeup of the parents . But if you think all fathers should have their family influence diluted , then proceed with this biased plan .

What's so special about having a monogomous parental couple ?
I'm not going to answer this ...

How about gay adoptions ?
I think I'll just waffle on this issue . Let the individual states decide .

OK , that's all I've got . Did I leave anything out ?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

Up late and watched "Red Eye" last night; some of the same points brought up and was intersting as a couple of the guests were gay (Do we have any gay members on NT's?). While most gay folks I know are for legal unions,some don't care as much about the marriage distinction. Those who do care would say that not allowing marriagebut instead equating a civil union, is descriminnatory. While some of us heterosexual marriages may feel thatour role as a parents is not seen as important as it once was, imho the role of a loving parental unit is the most important in any context, regardless of sexual persuasion.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[they want to force not only acceptance, but also respect. You can't force someone to respect your position, although you can force them into legally accepting it.]]

That sounds like a very perceptive explanation for the motives of the gay community .

[[The fact is, the designation of who can be married is arbitrary. Otherwise, polygamy would have to be legal and children could marry one another ( and adults could marry children) and you or I could marry our widowed mother. So it will always be arbitrary.]]

Some of that is accurate . Certainly preventing the legality of polygamy is merely part of our European tradition . There may be deeper issues here but I am not prepared to explore them . But feel free to explore further if you like .
However , the rest of that may be established principle in many religions . I am no expert on religions but there are admonitions against incest as well as restrictions on the age of consent and marriage in many cultures . I think Islam may be different ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[Those who do care would say that not allowing marriage but instead equating a civil union, is descriminnatory. ]]
I think what John had to say about that in the above comment gives a good explanation for the motives .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Apparently you are offended by my little article . OTW you wouldn't start out by calling it nonsense . Your counter arguments are illogical . Would you like me to point out where and embarass you or do you want to step back and and save yourself that embarrassment ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

John ,

I would very much like to hear the response to your points . In the meantime I will elaborate on the so-called logic from iar :

[[the fact remains that in every single civilized society today, marriage has no such "purpose". ]]

That's rather irrelevant . Religions can force many things on its believers but it can't force reproduction . In any case declaring out loud that the only purpose of marriage is reproduction would probably have the opposite effect . But to deny that the near universal institution of marriage had no motive to provide for the children of such unions is just weirdness .

As to the zero growth movement , it is no coincidence that populations in the western nations started to decrease after it came into vogue . It represented a departure from the old style "be fruitful and multiply" of the old religious influence . Incidentally , I'm not saying it didn't have some value . What I am saying is that its influence went too far . There is actually a danger that many populations who follow its "preachings" are going to become extinct .

[[How do you leap from "birth parents raising their own children should not be accorded the importance it used to have" to "birth parents raising their own children should not be accorded any importance"?]]

I made no such assertion . That was a feeble attempt at reductio ad absurdum . You are grasping at strawman arguments here ...

[[Are birth parents scorned and discriminated against for their heterosexuality, suffer any ill effects imposed by society as a result of their decision to breed, or otherwise experienced anything resembling bias ]]
Yes . There are some government interferences in the parenting process . And they are getting worse all the time .

[[you've simply failed to establish that married couples with children should be treated differently and better than anyone else.]]

WTF ?! They are definitely treated differently than those without children . They are subject to interference [called intervention] by the social services departments at the state , county or city level . Many couples live in fear of losing their kids because they don't fit the "norm" . That norm was established by Lesbian influenced social "scientists" . There is a pattern of reverse discrimination here .

As to what you said about civil unions , was that supposed to be an argument ? Seriously , what was that ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[Succinctly-- procreation is not necessary for marriage, nor is child-rearing;]]

It's not necessary but it is always a possibility . And that is a clear distinction between hetero couples and gay couples .

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

I think John's respect comment is correct much of the time. In general the issue of biological children hit's pretty close to home for many people, none more so than for gay couples...it can also be a point of contention as it is with most couples. That's why your argument is interesting. The traditional family unit has been our species mainstay for rearing children. Even though untrue, some gay folks would also interpret the discussion as an attack on their ability to raise children.

Our societies are changing. For good or ill, we are not the same country we were 50 or a 100 years ago. The traditional family is no longer. Our progression as we mature, is to struggle with these types of questions concerning our relationships and it's dynamic in a culture. Your self-proclaimed bias mentioned in the article is matched by bias on all sides, Gays and straights.

If our hearts and our technology are balanced well enough, perhaps the next "perception" will not include anything that even remotely resembles our traditional forms. But until then, we are going to struggle with different sexual orientations.

Just wait until robots for sex become mainstream, now THAT will be a conversation!

:~)

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[the assumption that having the birth parents raising their own children is not important is simply not based on any solid facts]]

Man ! I am sooo incorrigible . OK , I corrected that in the article . Better ?

[[To claim that "the" purpose of marriage is child-rearing is, itself, weird.]]

The social import of such conventions as marriage was critical in older societies which had religions to represent those social goals . I am only referring to the purpose from the position taken by religions and those older societies .
I am not saying that is its only purpose . Couples may have other ideas but those ideas do not require marriage [for the most part] .

[[You claimed that gay marriage "intrudes" on straight marriage. Then you suggest that "civil unions" would be acceptable. ]]

There is nothing overly abstract about this . If married heteros feel the need to separate themselves from the gay community then why shouldn't they do it that way ? Other than the financial arrangements any status that is accorded to married people would be the only advantage . And since they could at any time , have children then IMO they deserve that extra status for having that level of possible commitment . Again , you cannot say the same for gay couples . They could not ever expect to have children .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

That is correct in the abstract sense . The only thing is that the lack of perfect predictability of medical science means that there will always be some doubt . Most couples that have been declared infertile will probably stay that way but there are exceptions that happen . And from the POV of the couple , they don't know which group they are in.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Larry , [[In general the issue of biological children hit's pretty close to home for many people, none more so than for gay couples...]]

I suppose that future advances in reproductive science could make it possible that lesbian couples could have the genetics from 2 women combined
somehow . But in the meantime , there is nothing stopping those couples from having children from sperm bank donations . As to the male homosexuals , it is unlikely that will change in the near future .

[[The traditional family is no longer.]]

It is certainly less common than it used to be . But there is no reason it couldn't change back towards what it used to be .

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

I can only speak towhatI perceive, but my guess is that homosexuals feel that any otherterminology would be seen by society as less. It goes back to your respect comment.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Counter points:

Marriages between a man and a women arent required to offer up children as validation of that fact.

Marriages between a man and a woman may result in adoption, either due to fertility issues or simply a desire to help other children have a family life

It is an issue of respect. Marriage might have been defined the way you have stated, but the world has changed. Those married couples back then were often more than simply couples. They often included a favored wife and several lesser wives (concubines). Gays are human and deserve all rights and privileges accorded to humans. All other debate is pointlessly ridiculous since it always comes down to that one simple fact regardless of personal opinions. Gays are in fact just as human as anybody else and are entitled to the same rights and privileges. Anything less is diminishing and demeaning to us all. I'm sure some of you remember when blacks were not considered human. When women were considered less than human. Although people like to say this isnt a civil rights issue, it IS at its very core exactly that...a CIVIL RIGHTS issue.

I must therefore conclude that your presentation was not in fact logical regardless of how it was presented Rich. Sorry.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

There is an interesting dichotomy there IMO. While people may not have any hostile feelings towards gays, it also makes absolutely no sense to "protect" something that doesnt require it at all. In what way does a gay couple being married sully the concept of marriage? I feel that opposition to something like that does equate to at the very least bigotry. Maybe not direct hostile hate, but certainly bigotry. Otherwise, it simply would not matter. So the dichotomy is that people dont believe they are booted and yet act in a bigoted manner with regards to this topic. There really is no logical reason to be opposed or offended by gay marriage. Anybody trying to infuse logic into the illogical is not being honest with themselves, at best.

Anyway, not an attack on you John. I respected what you said yesterday, but i dont agree with the qualifiers.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

D'Wayne ,[[Gays are human and deserve all rights and privileges accorded to humans. ]]

Yes , they deserve the privilege of having a full genetic offspring ... except
they can't have that . They can only have half of the genes of the couple if the couple is lesbian . And if they are males they can't have anthing without "borrowing" the womb and eggs of some woman .

[[All other debate is pointlessly ridiculous since it always comes down to that one simple fact regardless of personal opinions]]

Your argument was pointlessly ridiculous for the reasons I have stated .

In fact the entire argument that gays are equal in every respect to heteros is silly . Gay male couples are not even close to the same as lesbian couples . So the concept of "gay" is not a single concept . It is a duality .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

So you are saying that the differences between gays and straights are what allow us to limit their civil rights.

I'm not seeing the logic Rich, unless the logic is that since we arent all the same, we should all be afforded the same rights and privileges. But then, we would need to address the rights of every demographic....blacks voting? No sir. They just dont have the same cranial capacity as whites do. I can go down the list and find a reason to segregate and dehumanize anybody and any group. I would not be right morally or ethically in doing so though.

Logic: human is human. Nothing else matters when discussing any subset or demographic. The same opportunity for all, or why even bother?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[what allow us to limit their civil rights.]]

What civil rights ? This is a status issue and nothing more . As I said in my article civil rights and financial issues are made equal by allowing for some kind of civil union .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Gonna agree with you there, Larry.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Everyone has the right to purchase a spot of available land if they so choose and can afford it. Not even close to a good point, although the part about the definition of marriage being arbitrary is true. However, since the act of marriage provides the full benefits allowed for civil unions, and is necessary to claim them, it does become a civil liberties issue when only one demographic (gay) is being excluded from it. That is where it goes from availability to bigotry.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

You cant force the population to respect or accept blacks, muslims, atheists, mexicans, christians, and so on, but they are all afforded the same rights. The only group for whom legislative discrimination is allowed/accepted/enforced are gays.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

What civil rights indeed. Gays are definitely not given their due amount of such.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

I dont know if forcing respect is true for any but the most outspoken. I do know that there is a clear difference between owning land and marriage. Again, you do actually have the right to own land. Nobody is denying your right. However, there is a price tag....it also costs money to get married, but not everybody is allowed to spend it.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[What way? By pretending that gay marriages "intrude" on their own relationships? Because it isn't true, that's why.]]

According to you it isn't true but according to 31 separate state referendums , the voting public does feel that it intrudes . That would be 31 rejections of gay marriage and 0 acceptances .

[[Now you're simply being obtuse. Since I know, personally, several gay couples with children, your attempt to claim the high ground for straight couples falls more than a little flat. Some would say that it borders on being willfully ignorant.]]

And I think I can guess they were lesbian couples , right ?

[[You're going to great lengths to use "children" as an excuse to denigrate families whose parents happen to be of the same sex, by pretending that such a thing isn't possible, despite the evidence.]]
[[You're going to great lengths to use "children" as an excuse to denigrate families whose parents happen to be of the same sex, by pretending that such a thing isn't possible, despite the evidence.]]

As I said previously , it is only possible to have half the genetics of the lesbian couple per child . So I stand by that statement . And let me add that the only way a male homosexl can have children is by "borrowing" the womb and egg from some woman .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[Why does the State have the authority to decide who is married in the first place? Who gave that to the State?]]

The electorate gave that to the state . And in 31 separate state referendums voters rejected the concept of gay marriage . There were none that accepted gay marriage . Does that tell you something ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

I would like to screw the 1st hot woman I see in the middle of main street during the day . I feel so diminished by not being allowed to do that . But I'll get over it ...

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

and that is logically the same as wanting to marry your loved one.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

[[The traditional family is no longer.]]

It is certainly less common than it used to be . But there is no reason it couldn't change back towards what it used to be .

I believe that we are in between phases. Our technology will allow us, in only a few generations, to direct our own evolution. How are we going to define ourselves as a species, let alone familial units? We grasp at thestabilityour evolution has provided thus far, and grapple with the reality that we are moving into an uncertainty, of our ownchoosing.

I mean how are you going to explain to children that their pet robotic dog is not real, while Grampa is real regardless of the fact that half of his biological being is man-made or grown? We have some very serious issues to face in the near future.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Have you ever been to a male gay rights parade ? That is almost exactly what happens at those events ...

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

and basically every festival, parade, concert, etc...ever. It seems humans enjoy festive occasions and find people they find attractive during such gatherings. Point?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

So you haven't been to a male gay rights parade . You have no idea what happens there .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Have i not been to one, or do i simply understand it has zero relevance? When you were at a gay parade, what did you observe? Floats?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[What I would like to see is the State and Federal government tax an officially sanctioned marriage certificate at 100,000 dollars apiece.]]

Have you got any idea how much hosting the typical upscale wedding costs these days ? You might be close .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Was that supposed to make me feel guilty ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

I observed assless chaps in the middle of the street and all that goes with that ... in public .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Good comment . Neither the law nor sexuality keep up with the technology . I really need to do an article about just such an issue .

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

That would be a good one. There are so many aspects that most of us never think of.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

Well just an illustration but your point is taken.

People are slaves to technological advancement.

And have been ever since they figured out that a rock could kill prey or spark a fire. Perhaps that's when humanity was exiled from paradise?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    14 years ago

Really nice link there John. I agree with much said on it.

But I believe that it is our creation, our responsibility. Rather than abhor and forget it, we need to tend to it's stewardship.

I think this also aptly illustrates what I am saying. Ourrelationshipwith technology will define us and all our relationships, like it or not. It is going to be a painful and bumpy ride but worth it if we have the heart.

Humanity's final test.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Marriage is an arbitrary term. If you are atraditionalMormon or Muslim, that means more than one wife.

The point is everyone does not have every right imaginable.

Any right that is granted to anyone byvirtueof being human, is a right that that should be granted to all humans.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Then you can't have affirmative action or minority or women's set asides. You could not have any tax breaks or any government programs for one group of people that were not provided to everyone. There are restrictions or qualifications for virtually everything that every government federal, state or local does.

Then the inverse is true. That people can be kept as slaves. That children can be raped. That woman can be stoned. What you are talking about are rights given to us by a government.

Jefferson was clearer about this:We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.

What we are talking about is liberty and the pursuit of happiness that was endowed to us by our "creator".

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

But you have reverted to the government, and a stupid contest that man made. Not theesotericideal that Jefferson was talking about. The freedom to go about our lives without intrusion of others beliefs on you.

The word "Marriage", is not a fixed thing. It is different things to different societies and faiths. To be so ridged about a word is to deny this. Being gay is as old as mankind. it's about time that we just really get used to the idea, that they are not going anywhere and wanted to be treated with the samedignityas any other human.Marriageis one of those.

As Peter said "Human is human"

If you prick us, do we not bleed?
if you tickle us, do we not laugh? if you poison
us, do we not die?

Human is human.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

I dont know what goes with assless chaps....flannel perhaps? I am no fashionista though. Could be silk for all i know.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Rich,

I don't see how D'Wayne's comment is supposed to make you feel guilty. I think all he is saying is what I've been saying. The most discriminated group throughout history have been gays, with the exception of lepers.

All you have to do is look at all thesereferendumsabout gay marriages to know this.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Ah, sorry, it is NOT a "legal contract." That term implies that the parties are able to contract on terms which both agree.

Which, of course, they cannot! If they wish to be "married," they must agree to the terms the government places upon them, not that which they "contract" to.

So, please, to call marriage a "legal contract" is wrong, false, and bs.

It is my belief, however, that is exactly what it should be!

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Iar:

There you go. Wish that same standard could be applied to other areas of life as well.

Of course, you do understand that given the current posture of our religiously based government/ society, being "married" does, indeed, affect others.

Which is why I say this is entirely economic. Just another burden on the tax payer. And why should a tax payer have to pay for something which that person feels is entirely perverted and against their "God."

Which is why the government should get the hell out of marriage, except to the extent they enforce all contracts.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

John:

Societies have found values in many things which all should hold in disregard.

Take a look at the tribal practices of many Islamic countries?

Human sacrifice?

The list, of course, can go on and on.

Society is not always right.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Here's the solution, folks.

Take the economic incentives out of being "married."

It really is that simple. For that is, imo, why most gays wish to have the right to marry, for the dough.

And there can be no doubt but that our government provides bennies if you are married.

Take out the bennies, and the issue goes away.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Iar ,

[[gay folks aren't going to suddenly become straight because those relationships are "promoted", and gay marriage doesn't detract from the promotion of straight marriages.]]

No one can stop women of any sexual preference from having children . But the issue is of what influence the "sperm donor" has on the raising of said children . Marriage is a way of promoting and encouraging that relationship .
And lesbian marriage is just another step towards the marginalizing of the legal status of committed fatherhood .
It implies that "there is nothing special about the relationship between a father and his biological children" .
But that has been the main basis of marriage ever since it was "invented" . It gives a special legally recognized status to men who choose the commitment of taking care of their families .

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

I DESTROYED their arguments about the priest abuse and showed the equal occurrence of child sex abuse in other institutions. Destroyed them.

John, how do you "destroy" the "arguments about priest abuse" by showing that there are other sick shits in the general population?

I am sure you know that makes no sense. Merely because there are other sick shits, does not make the sick shit priests any less sick.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Ah, I see. You weren't defending the priests themselves, but the Church, as a whole.

The Church does have certain issues to answer to, however, given their defense of certain pedophiles for years, and even decades.

But that can, and is, being addressed through litigation, eh?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Iar ,

That was an interesting and unexpected article . So there is a history of acknowledgement of homosexuality in the Catholic Church .... hmm . I guess I shouldn't be surprised by that given more recent developments .

[[First, the argument was that the purpose of marriage is child-rearing, and that society must give preference to heterosexual couples because only they can have children. Shown that this is incorrect,]]

You did ? When did that happen ?

[[now your ploy is to claim that the purpose of marriage is to encourage fatherhood?]]

If you take the time to think about it [instead of concentrating on clever sniping phrases] you would realize those are closely related motivations . Sure , one can sire children without any further involvement like many in the animal kingdom but somewhere back in the remote past , the religions figured out that it is better to get the father involved in the process . And that connects with the idea of creating more faithful to follow in the religious path of the parents . Are you saying that encouraging the involvement of the biological father is not a useful goal ??

[[That comment shows a breathtaking degree of ignorance of the myriad styles of both marriage and parenting that the human species has exhibited down through the ages. In the first place, in the cases of heterosexual marriage, the institution has conferred a special legally recognized status to women, not to men; and in the second, myriad examples abound of cultures in which marriage isn't intended to confer any particular status of "father" on men.]]

Actually , it really doesn't matter about all of the variations which have occurred throughout the ages . What matters is what the US has based its concept of marriage on . And that is just as I described .

[[That gays get married hasn't impacted my relationship with my father in the slightest, nor, I suspect, has it impacted your relationship with yours.]]

I have no idea . He passed on long before this became an issue . As to calling that a red herring , there is something fishy about that response . The simple fact is that in the US , today , voters are rejecting the concept of gay marriage [even the less objectionable lesbian marriage] . They are doing it for some reasons . I have attempted to uncover what those motives are . In the meantime , you seem to be set on denying that this rejection has even occurred . When is acceptance of reality going to set in ?

[[In the first place, in the cases of heterosexual marriage, the institution has conferred a special legally recognized status to women, not to men]]

That is becoming more equal over time . Granting of alimony is based more on income than anything else . Child custody is another matter .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Surrogates can get real messy. Contracts must be drawn, or the mother can make off with the offspring.

Woman have the upper hand in this issue. I've never seen a guy running after a woman for some lost sperm. In fact, it's rumored that they don't mind giving the stuff away ;-)

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

It's true. In fact, we would prefer if you simply kept it all. we really dont even want a drop of it returned to us please.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Tina ,

When I said it is unlikely to change in the future I meant the whole thing , not just the technology . Male homosexls tend to be non-family oriented . I doubt that will change any time soon .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

"Male homosexls tend to be non-family oriented "

I would like to see where you find validation for that claim. From what i have seen of homosexual males, the above statement is false.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

This one is an old article :


Things may have changed somewhat since then due to the aids epidemic . But maybe not :



http://www.discussionworldforum.com/forum/archive/index.php/t-2374.html" target="_blank"> ....



...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Here's some more :





 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Okay, the first article was complete b.s. and total conjecture. I looked through five of the articles you posted, and they all discussed promiscuity, which has nothing to do with family at all. I know you are trying to tie it to relationships with gay partners, but that isnt the meaning nor defining characteristic of family. Additionally, the studies do not account for any parallels such as the lack of ability to marry your partner, which is an ingrained socail commitment issue, nor heightened stress levels from any number of sources, from bigotry to fear etc...since i could easily state that gays have an elevated level of daily stress over straights of the exact same demographic, it is np stretch that there would also be a heightened level of sexuality.

Regardless though, all you really did was prove that you feel promiscuity is a core family issue. I would ask how many straight couples in a marriage or committed relationship also are promiscuous, or stray if you will? I would hazard a guess and say it is a very high percentage, not at all out of line with the same in gay relationships.

Since the central point of this article is logic, i must ask you provide logical arguments as the basis for your point in this debate/discussion. Logic has been curiously lacking on your end so far. Rather than actually hash out why it is somehow acceptable to oppress gay males, you continue to throw tangents out there. They end up as logical fallacies, and while that is a fun tactic in actual debate where your opponent has to respond immediately, in this venue where the opposing viewpoints are offered as much time as necessary to consider the posts, logical fallacy becomes a poor tactic indeed. Assuming it was intentional to begin with.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I would like to see where you find validation for that claim. From what i have seen of homosexual males, the above statement is false.

I would actually say, based on my own experience that in many ways they are better parents than the straight ones that I know. They go through so much introspection, to make sure that they are doing right by their children.

I think what you will find Rich, is that this topic changes it's perspective with every 15 years of age. That is the only constant here, other than gays have alwaysexistedthroughout mankind.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Okay, the first article was complete b.s. and total conjecture.

Apparently you didn't read it at all . Here is an excerpt from it :

Perhaps the most thorough study of its type, the Kinsey Institute study of homosexual men in San Francisco, presented in the book by Bell and Weinberg, Homosexualities, A Study of Diversity Among Men and Women3, reported the following:

43% of the white male homosexuals surveyed estimated they had had sex with 500 or more different partners -28% with over 1,000 partners

79% said more than half of their partners were strangers -- 70% said more than half of their sexual partners were men with whom they had sex only once.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[I would actually say, based on my own experience that in many ways they are better parents than the straight ones that I know. They go through so much introspection, to make sure that they are doing right by their children.

I think what you will find Rich, is that this topic changes it's perspective with every 15 years of age. ]]

Are you saying that there is less promiscuity among the H. males than there used to be ? Try reading some of the link material .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Once again, you are deflecting. The whole premise you are putting forth is that promiscuity means no family values. Remind me, what were the average ages of the people studied? Were they younger perhaps? Would you object to presenting a logical case for why gays should face oppression. Something reasonable...anything that might justify the premise of this entire article? I feel like we have been wasting time here talking about meaningless points centered around alleged logical arguments presented in your article content. The issue is clearly one of oppression, the suppression of rights, and the tacit if not direct approval of such by many people including you Rich. Trying to rationalize by simply stating that you are being logical does not even come close to making it actually logical.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

It seems clear to me that Perrie is stating that different age groups have different levels of promiscuity. I am saying that talk of promiscuity is a b.s. attempt at deflection.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[The whole premise you are putting forth is that promiscuity means no family values. ]]

In the extremes of such behavior I would say that such people are putting themselves and their families at risk .

[[why gays should face oppression. ]]

What oppression ?

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

and this applies to approval of the suppression of rights how?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[I am saying that talk of promiscuity is a b.s. attempt at deflecton.]]

Are you also saying that there is no connection between promiscuity and the transmission of STDs ?
And that there is no connection between anal sex and the transmission of STDs ?

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

I am saying there is no connection between any of that and the right to get married.

i am also saying that you are stereotyping gays when in fact all people have the risk of getting an STD. It was widely reported that Alexander the Great had syphilis. How many years ago was that again? STD have been and will continue to be a fact of life, gay or straight...and they will continue to have absolutely nothing to do with the right to get married.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

And what I am saying is that people who have frequent promiscuous anal sex with strangers are risking their health and possibly their life . Draw your own conclusions . Or don't if that is your choice .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

I have drawn the conclusion that you consider gays to be a demographic that needs to be suppressed, oppressed, or outright eliminated. You dont feel they deserve the same rights and privileges you yourself are allowed to enjoy, and you also for some vacuous reason feel superior to them. However, you have actually categorized yourself as less than worthy of respect due to willful and seemingly proud stereotyping and bigotry. Am I wrong?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

You will draw whatever conclusion you are going to . What I say has zero effect on that . You can't even distinguish between extreme high risk behavior and those with more self control . People like that have a serious problem .

If you are so concerned about them what are you doing to help them overcome their problem ? I am going to guess that you don't think they even have a problem . Is that right ?

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

"If you are so concerned about them what are you doing to help them overcome their problem ? I am going to guess that you don't think they even have a problem . Is that right ?"

What problem? That you feel all gays are promiscuous, and their means of demonstrating their love doesnt appeal to you? You do realize that gay men also use condoms right? That your stereotypical fears have more to do with an era where there was no real education on HIV/AIDS because relatively few people knew about it until it became an epidemic? I can easily tear down these false arguments you are making Rich. The ease of which it can be done is kind of making me feel a little sad in truth. But more than that, what really is sticking here is the fact that you are refusing to address the core issue of your own article, which is the supposed logic behind suppressing peoples rights. You have exhibited selective bigotry, and are not only unabashed by that fact, but seem to revel in it a little. It is clearly drawn from fear, and maybe even a personal experience. Cant say for sure, but your anger towards gays is definitely misplaced, and uncharacteristic for a man who singularly prides himself on his logical mind.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[Marriage (in all its shifting definitions throughout the ages) has had at its core the main purpose of creating normative and/or legal obligations between the individuals involved, and setting the obligations and responsibilities both owed to and by the communities in which the marriage took place]]

Good description . And that might be the point of the recent anti H marriage laws . The communities involved do not feel that the gays are contributing to those mutual obligations and responsibilities .

[[This is why even in societies in which paternity of any offspring is entirely uncertain, marriage still exists-- for example, polyandrous groups in Nepal and Tibet, or "secondary marriage" societies in Nigeria and Cameroon.]]

OK , you know more than I do about the anthropology of different old social structures . Does it matter in the here and now ? Does any of that explain why there is so much antipathy against H marriage now ? Is there anyone who thinks a polyandrous social structure would be an improvement to what we have now ? If so what are your reasons ? I have my reasons for thinking it is not a beneficial idea .

BTW , I grant that marriage is about a lot more than getting the biological father involved in the nurturance of the children . But I do think it was a major factor in the structure of marriage as we currently know it .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

In case you hadn't noticed I was addressing Max's point about about someone being "flawed" . That is not the same issue as someone who has had a medical procedure done . But by all means , enjoy your red herring . Pardon me if I don't partake ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[despite Rich's pretense, people don't see "having biologically produced children which are the union of the genetic material of the two partners" as the sole purpose of marriage (or even the
main purpose of marriage).]]

Thank you ever so much for dictating to all people in the US what they think the main purpose of marriage is . I am sure they will humbly bow down to your seizing of power . Yet I know I won't .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Did you even read the studies you linked to ? That second one , for example , has some essential info in it that everyone should be aware of and adjust their behavior accordingly :

For example , "recent evdence suggests that male-to-female transmission of HIV may be at least 20 times as efficient as female-to-male transmission ."

Here's another important one :
"HIV transmission through receptive anal intercourse is generally believed to be more efficient than vaginal intercourse ."

If you can't perceive the dangers implied from that info about anal sex [which is the focus of male H sex] then your head is buried firmly up your own ass .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Actually Rich, that should be said for you. You keep trying to drive home a point that has absolutely nothing to do with marriage, as is discriminatory besides that. You fail to present your case in any sort of logical fashion, and for some reason, seem stuck on the notion of anal sex, which presumably you dont partake in (although i am beginning to believe that perhaps that wasnt always the case, and that you are burying some deep emotional scars on the topic).

We are in EPIC FAIL territory now.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[So you're saying that what people feel is true makes it true? ]]

Talking about truth when the issue is the voting public is a waste of energy . The only truth is what is decided by said votes .

[[you are directly insulting our marriage.]]

Feel free to be insulted . There is more involvement of the male with children when he knows they are his issue . Deal with it .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Would the phony social issue be the acceptance of bigotry as long as it is only geared towards the gay community? Trying to marginalize something doesnt alter its actual importance.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[You keep trying to drive home a point that has absolutely nothing to do with marriage]]

Just because you don't get the connection , it is not my problem . I would take the time to explain it but it is clear by now that any thing I say will just be met with more negative aspersions cast upon my motives and morality . You're on your own .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

"Just because you don't get the connection , it is not my problem . I would take the time to explain it but it is clear by now that any thing I say will just be met with more negative aspersions cast upon my motives and morality . You're on your own ."

If you were planning to develop a connection, you would already have done so. Any aspersions cast upon you were made possible directly because of your inability or unwillingness to articulate your position. Perhaps that might actually make you look worse? I dont know.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[I decline to pursue your Red Herring. Let's stay focused on the issue of gay marriage.]]

You were the one who brought polyandrous social structures . If that is a red herring it belongs to you . Since you are ducking that question , I feel free to duck yours . Enjoy the silence of your making .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

I'm not sure if I made this clear before but I am not trying to say that is the only purpose of marriage , What I am saying is that it is part and parcel of the social contract of marriage and therefore needs to be allowed for in the definition of marriage . Are you implying that having children out of wedlock is a better arrangement ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[Frankly, one would think that-- given the apparent dangers of anal sex-- anyone horrified by the specter of HIV, as you appear to be, would be advocating for the promotion of monogamous gay male relationships, and thus for gay male marriages.]]

Yup , I am indeed horrified by that specter . Aren't you ? And there are a whole slew of other STDs as well . The problem as I perceive it is that many male H's are quite possibly incapable of maintaining monogamous relationships . As such they present a danger of spreading such diseases to the mostly monogamous hetero couples . It doesn't take much to slip up to contract such diseases from those who are not careful about their sexual practices .
And it is not just sex . It is also those who share hypo needles and then have unprotected sex .

As to butt sex , feel free to bugger your partner . I choose not to .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

"The issue is the rights of the people involved, not what we call it".

I quite agree . How about the rights of the people to protect themselves against STDs ? To me that trumps some minor concern over marriage for a group which has little interest in it .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Impossible standards of moralizing : the meme of the left .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Rich you wanted the facts on STD's here they are:

Notice that the highest rate of STD's are not HIV and in the straight community affecting mostly woman.

Syphilis affects the male gay community at a higher rate than the general community.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

In my experience [I'm a lot older than you] the perception of the dangers of male H sex is real . And your persistence at calling me bigoted is nothing more than ageism . You are the bigot here .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

It may not be part of the agreement between particular partners but from the POV of society the issue of the care of children is paramount . Just because some couples [many couples ?] choose not to have kids does not mean the foundation for marriage can exclude that issue .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Apparently they won't thank you ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

I tell ya what Im a gonna do . I'm gonna pursue the issue you brought up but now refuse to discuss .
Why polyandry is a really bad idea for this period in history :
There are more variety and prevalence of STDs now that at most prior periods in history . Therefore having one woman being the object of affection for multiple male partners is a very dangerous practice for the health of that woman . And since such women are likely to be the progenitors of the group that means health effects for future generations as well . This is not a red herring as claimed . It is merely an extreme example of the dangers of STDs on the populace both present and future . Add to that what would happen if one of the males in that polyandrous group was a bisexual or an IV drug user and the danger vastly multiplies . That danger is even worse if a male is both bisexual & an IV drug user .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[in what way are these dangers any different than in roughly half of the so-called monogamous heterosexual marriages in which one or both partners seek sex with individuals outside the relationship?]]

They are of higher risk if the individual they interact with is :
a] someone who shares hypo needles
b] a male H. who receives anal sex from multiple strangers
c] someone who does both [worst of all]

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[Last time I looked, the majority of hysterectomies weren't undertaken for kicks.]]

Irrelevant and still a red herring , one that is starting to stink badly ... fishbreath

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[there is no requirement that couples be fertile, no test to ensure that fertility, and no rescinding of marriages because of an absence of offspring]]

I completely agree . But nevertheless all marriage definitions need to allow for that possibility and maybe even encourage fertility . If there was no such inclusion , the believers of the world would be discouraged from reproducing . As it is there is a drastic decline of white and black populations in the west [I'm not sure about Asians] . Something really needs to be done to reverse that trend or they will go extinct . But I guess you are unconcerned about that .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[you feel all gays are promiscuous]]

Actually I haven't said anything of the kind . In fact I am making a distinction you don't seem to even recognize .
Gay is a silly term . I am strictly addressing the subject of male homosexuals . They are the group that tends to be more promiscuous and that takes high risk behavior . And I have never once said all of them do that . I would have said that earlier but I was disinclined because of the constant meaningless cries of "bigot" from you .

[[their means of demonstrating their love doesnt appeal to you?]]
I admit freely to that . That is the subject of this thread . Do their means appeal to you ?

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Actually, their level of risk is always the same. I am sensing an anal fetish somewhere up in this jizzoint.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

You need to stop projecting your fantasies on others .

Also the level of risk is substantially greater in the case of someone who receives anal sex . I excerpted from a previous medical research link from your buddy Iar to that effect . You really ought to read what he posts . He is very knowledgeable .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Which fantasies?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

It's interesting that you have no interest in some medical research on this very subject . But then you are not a "research" kind of a guy are ya ? In fact your comments strike me as scatterbrained and offensive . In any case your continued cries of bigotry are an example of ageism .Comment removed for CoC violation

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

I'm not clear on where claims of ageism is coming from, having never mentioned anything regarding age, nor having even hinted at it. Clearly, age is a topic of concern for you, although i am not seeing how it is applicable here outside of you providing another excuse for deflecting and rationalizing your own hatred and bigotry. If anything, i suppose i do applaud your dedication to not addressing the singular topic of discussion here. It must take a lot of effort on your part to continue to post while also continuing to ignore the topic of your own article. Then again, i can understand why you would continually attempt to divert attention away from it, since the concept of logical bias has actually been show for what it really is...a logical fallacy.

What else you got? The anal sex schtick has been played out, and has only served to bury your contention further. Better for you to simply disclose why....comment removed as CoC violation . At least that way you can recapture some shred of your lost integrity.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

I'm sensing that I touched a nerve when I poo pooed [pun intended] anal sex . Perhaps you partake of that with the little woman ? Who the fuck am I to point out the dangers of that ...

As to ageism , I am a product of the era I grew up in . Expecting me to share your provincial worldview and
sense of invulnerabilty is exactly ageism . I'm an old guy . I've never tried to hide that . Your "contribution" to this convo has been repeated accusations of bigotry . In fact you just did it again . More ageismcomment removed as CoC violation

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

I'm sensing that I touched a nerve when I poo pooed [pun intended] anal sex . Perhaps you partake of that with the little woman ? Who the fuck am I to point out the dangers of that ...

Not really. I just dont believe you have any credibility. We were talking about gay marriage, and all you bring up to try and substantiate your anti gay, comment removed for CoC violaion, opposition is anal sex. That is the entire basis for your opposition to gay marriage, as you have presented it in pretty much every post you have made. I just thought you were capable of crafting an intelligent argument worthy of debate, but instead, you continue to focus on anal sex, which decidedly has nothing to do with the right for gays to marry.As to ageism , I am a product of the era I grew up in . Expecting me to share your provincial worldview and
sense of invulnerabilty is exactly ageism . I'm an old guy . I've never tried to hide that . Your "contribution" to this convo has been repeated accusations of bigotry . In fact you just did it again . comment removed for CoC violation!
So, let me see if i understand you correctly. You are blaming your bigotry on your age, and thus have concluded that if i point out your bigotry, then i must be bigoted towards old people. Another logical fallacy, and quite convoluted at that. I mean, that has got to be one of your worst, and you have had many lately. If you really analyze what you yourself wrote, you would see that the ageist bigotry also falls squarely on your shoulders. It isnt my fault that you blame your age for inability to address your irrational hate. So, I'll ask again, what else would you like to put forward to validate the suppression of the of gay rights?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

If you are so enthusiastic and unbigoted about anal sex , then I suggest you get involved . Stop being a damn hypocrite and get busy .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Are you even reading anymore? Just curious. You have ditched logic, debate, and reason. What is left for you except to hang your head in shame, or simply acknowledge you are full of it? Just curious. If it was me in your shoes, and i knew everybody was reading your babbling, i would be embarrassed, and would just apologize. My advice....leave and come back later with something worth discussing. Something which you actually have some real knowledge of.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

If you don't think I have any credibility , why are you wasting time on my thread ? I encourage you to leave .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Nah. You asked for every bit of this. Why would I leave now? This discussion has yet to reach its full potential. Unless you feel so backed into a corner that you have no recourse but to quit. In which case, there would no longer be anything to talk about, lol.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

OK , I'm telling you to leave .comment removed as CoC violation. Get off now .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

I insist on moderation. Contact any of the other moderators. Until then, i refuse your request and your demand.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

If left leaning thinkers didn't have the bigot club they would have no punch at all . It covers up so many inconvenient truths . For one thing , there is hypocrisy . They pay lip service to the idea that they are completely comfortable with male H expressions of sexuality . But this is clearly not true for the public at large . The Hollywood media output is startlingly lacking in equality when it comes to visual presentations of such public [or even private] displays of affection .

There is a simple reason why that is the case : the public does not want to see such displays . They are so turned off that they avoid a movie like Brokeback Mountain in droves .
Likewise the future output of the stars and the director do not persist in similar undertakings . For example Heath Ledger's next role was an attempt to distance himself from that image completely . In it he played Casanova . Likewise Jake Gyllenhaal and Director Ang Lee shifted directions radically after that box office flop .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[Meanwhile, Rich has divorced himself so thoroughly from reality that he isn't even bothering to maintain the facade that he ever had a logical argument against gay marriage, at all.]]

I see you have fallen back on generalities to launch personal attacks . That's because you have nothing to hit with anymore . So I tell you what I'm a'gonna do . Tomorrow when there are enough members here I'm gonna go launch a brand new thread . Let's see how you do when you're on the defensive ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

For some reason the system wouldn't allow me to remove this comment. I have taken great care in removing only the most inflammatory words. Concepts can be called bigoted, but people can't. Please remember that going forward. PH

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

It certainly can be. I would also say that bigotry often hides behind tradition.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

I admit freely to that . That is the subject of this thread . Do their means appeal to you ?

Do I find gay sex appealing? Not particularly, but I'm also not gay. What I do find appealing is the right for people to express their attraction and or love in whatever way suits them best. What happens between two consenting adults is their business alone.

That, however, has nothing to do with the topic of gay marriage whatsoever.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[What I do find appealing is the right for people to express their attraction and or love in whatever way suits them best. What happens between two consenting adults is their business alone.]]

You are saying that society should have no input whatsoever into the nature of social relationships ?

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Yes. As long as it is between consenting adults, nobody should be able to say otherwise.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Was that comment directed to me ?

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

I think there may be some confusion since Perrie didnt add her own comment. On the surface, it would seem like you had written it, even though there is a PH at the end.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

and people dont have to have those things if they are disinclined. They dont however need to be projecting that onto others who might prefer to live as such.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Iar,

I miss spoke. It was 2 am an I was pooped. So let me clarify. You can call people's statements bigoted but you can't call a member a bigot, as that is name calling.

Have I clarified my self?

And no need for the snarky "right as always", since I have never said that I am always right.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

OY! It was to my comment that I made at 2 am, last night.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Again, i think he thought it was Rich. Dunno, but i think so.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Well... Iar can set the record straight then.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

I would like to see him take his foot out of his ... keyboard . He thought it was my statement and couldn't wait to heap subtle sarcasm thereupon .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

I don't think you've thought this through very carefully . I suspect that you haven't thought about it at all but
merely read something somewhere which sounded good to you . There are already many statutes on the books about these issues . They are in almost every state and for valid reasons .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Your suspicions are unfounded, and you have continued to provide no logical reasons for your own suppositions. Were you ever going to honor the very title of your article and apply logic to this? Truth. You cant and wont because the very notion that a person could be denied the rights of their citizenship for no reason other than consenting sexual preference is not logical, and is deeply rooted in bigotry.

It's not like we're talking about rapists, pedophiles, or other sexual situation that dont consist entirely of consenting adults. We're talking about something that each person feels and/or chooses for themselves, whether actual choice or genetic. IF, just IF, you Rich, felt a level of bigotry towards gays for any reason, it would certainly cloud and directly taint your judgement on the topic. You might seek any argument to try and validate the suppression of citizenry. You would not however be able to do so with any logic or validity. That is the actual bottom line, and rather than get defensive and try to divert and distract by going off on irrelevant tangents, it would be nice to hear the actual reason why you dont feel adults should participate in acts of mutual consent without all the other b.s that has accompanied your position so far. Just a straight out honest, "this is directly why i dont believe in extending ALL rights and privileges offered to citizens to ALL citizens." The honest answer would be refreshing.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[It's not like we're talking about rapists, pedophiles, or other sexual situation that dont consist entirely of consenting adults.]]

No but we are talking about things like incest and public sexual activity . Those are statutes in just about every state and these are activities between consenting adults . You , therefore cannot say that all consenting sexual activity is socially accepted .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Iar,

First, sorry to hear that you were in the hospital. I hope that it wasn't anything serious.

It has been a long established rule, that there is to be no name calling. At the end of the day, it does little to forward a dialog, and causes articles to derail and fights. This is no different than the other venue that we all came from. You can name the action, but not the person. Make good arguments, back up your facts and let the reader make up their own mind.

Oh, and sorry for my comment about being snarky. I thought you had directed it to me.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

No, we are discussing gay marriage. Incest and public sexual acts arent even an issue here, nor are they tied to gay marriage whatsoever. Are you ever going to answer the question i posed to you or are you going to continue to dodge the real issue at hand? I'm starting to believe that you have had some gay experience that messed you up and made you incapable of dealing with this topic rationally or with any intellectual integrity. Maybe i am wrong though.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

Interesting writeup . I didn't realize they were bisexual characters . I expect there would be far less public acceptance had they been 2 flaming gays . If they were there would have surely have been sex scenes instead of just cuddling . And then there would have been far less public acceptance . So when are we gonna' see a sequel ? Never ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[As long as it is between consenting adults, nobody should be able to say otherwise.]]

Those are your words . But the governments of nearly every state do not agree . In other words there is precedent for the government interfering in the sexual activity between consenting adults . The gay marriage issue is just one more . Deal with it .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

So, the entire basis for your argument is:

1: Anal Sex

2: Promiscuous Anal Sex

3: Ass-less chaps at gay parades

4: Governments have said it shouldnt be allowed.

5: AIDS must be a greater problem in the gay community than anywhere else (factually incorrect btw)

6: Brokeback Mountain didnt make as much money as some other movies have

I dont believe i have forgotten anything here. Oh wait...

7: Due to your advanced age, you arent required to change what might be considered bigoted views, because you are old and should be allowed to enjoy your prejudice.

Okay, now, i believe i have gotten it all jotted down. Of all of those, the only one slightly on topic is the fact that gov't often presumes to legislate alleged morality. However, I would bet everything I have and ever will have that you will argue against gov't policies that offend your sensibilities. I am sure there are many examples to be found. Probably need look no further than Obama. In fact, didnt he just have something to say about gays that you dont appreciate? The thing is Rich, government is mutable and malleable. The fact that it sometimes caters to the ignorant masses doesnt indicate that it is correct in doing so. Wasnt there a time when legislation was against blacks voting, women voting, etc...? Governments has condoned slavery and torture more often than not throughout the history of an. Should we be cool with all that? Because that is the basis of your last argument....if governments are cool with it, then it must be right and proper, and who are we to suggest otherwise?

You still havent answered my question, and that FACT is clear to anybody reading this, which also makes it clear that you are exhibiting no ties to honesty or integrity. In fact, i would say the latter two are noticeably absent from this discussion. Would you care to rectalfy, oops, i mean rectify this situation by simply answering my questions, or are you going to continue to desperately avoid doing so?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

You claim that I am dodging your questions and requests for clarification . I tried directly answering you quite a while back . I posted numerous links to do exactly that . But all you did was dismiss my efforts . You offered NO evidence to the contrary . Apparently you think that your OPINION means more than linked evidence .
Not only that but when I reply directly to your faulty thinking you consistently ignore it . See my reply above to your ridiculous dangerous philosophy that :
[[As long as it is between consenting adults, nobody should be able to say otherwise.]]

In all the time I've been on NT I have never seen you post evidence to explain your opinions . OTOH you feel free to consistently reject other people's linked evidence . So , why in the hell do you think I am going to take your repeated question seriously ? You do not give serious comments nor do you respond when someone puts in the work to answer you . You are dismissive . You lack the interest or ability to do the work for a real answer . Your main approach is to declare your opinion as if that is enough to convince without ANY supporting evidence .
Anyone who has that ridiculous philosophy you espoused above is dangerous both to himself and to his associates .

In conclusion keep talking past me . Keep pretending that your unsupported opinion has any import to anyone else . Keep ignoring my replies . And keep pretending that this is a "meaningful" dialogue . Keep pounding out your accusations about my motives and integrity . Just don't expect to get a response to your one-sided questions . Also don't expect me to waste more time on this frivolous non-dialogue .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Yes, Dangerous. As is gay marriage apparently. You actually never answered anything. You simply went on a tangent about how unhealthy and unclean homosexuality was. Not once did you truthfully broach the actual topic of gay marriage, and you didnt even bother to tie your arguments together. They were simply knee jerk comments wherein you described the reason for the bigotry you already admitted to. Of course, you diverted even as you admitted it by claiming that pointing out that fact was "ageism", a laughable notion which you also initiated, since nobody really knows how old you are anyway, or at least, you have never been forthcoming with that information. For all i know, you are actually a twenty year old homosexual who engages in self loathing.

Ask anybody who has read this thread what they think about your little presentation on logical bias and see if anybody has concluded that you have even addressed the topic of gay marriage, much less engaged in any sort of honest discourse. You will be highly disappointed in the response you receive.

Anyway, feel free to dodge. I am going with my two working theories: either, you are a 20 something self loathing boy toy, or a senior citizen who was formerly a gay rape victim. I'll roll the dice.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Petey Coober    14 years ago

It is a complete waste of time talking to D'Wayne . He persists in making disparaging comments about my ideas . That would be OK but he also attacks my character and motives .

Meanwhile he persists in expressing dangerous philosophies that all consenting adults should be able to do anything they want sexually , even though there are restrictions in every state about what is permitted and have been for many years . There is no sign that will change at any time in the future , nor should it .

Comments are now closed because of the complete degeneration of this thread into personal attacks on me.

 
 

Who is online