╌>

Questions from a Thoughtful Christian to an Atheist

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  malamuteman  •  14 years ago  •  20 comments

Questions from a Thoughtful Christian to an Atheist

This article was originally published on January 1, 2009

In another article titled, "How to get on and Atheist's good side", I was having a "discussion" with two Christians. One of them was exceptionally sure of the "rightness" of his beliefs, and frequently asserted the "wrongness" of those who were not like him. At one point this fellow's political philosophy was revealed when he said, "We [should] eliminate the adult terrorists and quit tolerating indoctrination centers of hate that they call Mosques." To which I replied, "Do the teachings of Jesus tell us to "...eliminate the adult terrorists and quit tolerating..."??? I thought he said things like "Turn the other cheek." and "Love your enemies." The Christian replied, "I am a Christian, not Christ." I assume this was his way of saying he is not perfect.

At this point he seemed to "bow out" of the conversation because he was having difficulty meeting my request for him to reconcile his political views with the teachings of Christ which he asserted were "the" definition of moral goodness. At the same time another Christian (I'll call her "Christianmom") entered the conversation by saying (along with several other interesting things), "To say "I'm not perfect" is a drastic understatement, but is never an excuse to not aspire to be more like Him [Christ]." I was very impressed by what Christianmom had to say, and struck by how very different these two Christians are. I recounted the discussion with the first fellow because the contrast between these two individuals so clearly demonstrates the difference between professing a belief and living it.

I exchanged several more comments with Christianmom resulting in the following list of questions which she posed to me. She did ask me not to answer the questions aloud, which I assume was her way of suggesting this topic was best kept out of the public forum. I hope she will forgive me for not respecting that request. I think these are excellent thought-provoking questions, and a great opportunity to inspire more respectful discussion and possibly even to learn something. I've given my answers to these questions, how do you answer them?

  1. What is the root of hatred?
    It seems to me that fear is the root of all hatred.
    New Answer: Insecurity, a specific form of fear, is the root of hatred.

  2. What is the root of envy?
    For some reason this question was more difficult for me to answer.
    It seems to me that dissatisfaction, disappointment, and desire spawn envy. Buddha said desire is the root of all suffering. So I guess that makes envy a form of suffering.

  3. Who do we value the most and why?
    The very nature of this question makes it inappropriate even to attempt to give a "universal" answer, so I want it to be clear that my answer is just that, "mine." The first answer that came to mind for me is, "I value those who value me." Because being valued by others is without a doubt my single greatest hunger. After thinking about this a bit more a better answer came to me. I see it as a better answer because it is less "selfish" (see my answer to #4) and actually incorporates my first answer in it.
    I value those who appreciate and value others.
    Why??? Other than the reason I gave for the more "selfish" answer I gave above (being valued by others is without a doubt my single greatest hunger), nothing comes to mind. I haven't figured out WHY I have this hunger.

  4. Who do we value the least and why?
    Again, the very nature of this question makes it inappropriate even to attempt to give a "universal" answer.
    Those who put themselves and their self-interest ahead of the needs and rights of others are least valued by me.
    Why??? Same as my answer to #3.

  5. Do people always measure you fairly?
    I am rarely privy to how I am measured so it is hard to say for sure, but I would guess that sometimes I am measured fairly and sometimes not.

  6. Do they measure what is on the outside or the inside (our behavior vs. our heart), and what is the true "you"?
    I am always measured by what people see on the "outside." How well that represents what is in my heart depends on how well I conveying what is in my heart which most definitely includes my "behavior."
    This question addresses the fundamental problem we have as sentient beings. Our thoughts and feelings are captive within us. Communication (which happens in many different ways) is how we transport our ideas and emotions to another individual. Many people do not know themselves very well, so what they communicate about themselves is not always a good representation of their "true self."

At Perrie's request I republished this article. THANKS for asking Perrie! I do think this article poses some thought provoking questions (Thanks to Christian Mom), and I hope you find some of my answers equally thought provoking. Please offer your own answers to these questions, or pose other questions you think are pertinent. I also hope you will respond to the answers I have given.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

Can anyone identify an act of love or human kindness that could not be extended in the total absence of organized religion ...

... without the downsides?

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    14 years ago

An interesting question A Mac!

I have a few thoughts...

  1. From my perspective love and kindness are common animal emotions and behaviors... They can be inspired by life experience without any teaching... religious or otherwise.
  2. I suspect that "downsides" are unique to every individual.
  3. Hate and cruelty are alsocommon animal emotions and behaviors... Curiously, these emotions and behaviors are sometimespromotedby people who claim adherenceto a philosophy or religion which purports the goodness of love and kindness.
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Mal,

Thanks for republishing this article. It is one that really goes to the heart of who we are. As I read the questions, I still struggle with the answers. I will do the best to answer them, the way that I understand them.

1.What is the root of hatred?

I would say that fear is part of the equation. But there is another factor to hate. We hate because we feel that someone has transgressed against us. This is a very personal form of hate.

2.What is the root of envy?

Pretty much what you said, that I would sum up in the word "Jealousy"

3.Who do we value the most and why?

Those that I love. We derive pleasure from them and they derive pleasure from us. They are there, when you need them, and in return you are there, when they need you.Reciprocityis the key.

4.Who do we value the least and why?

Those that I find no redeeming qualities in. That doesn't mean that I can't find value in a person that I disagree with. I am talking about core values. If a person has no honor, lies, is selfish, sneaky, self-consumed, arrogant, etc... those are the people I have no time for.

5.Do people always measure you fairly?

Sometimes yes and sometimes no. I think it's a matter of how well they have really tried to get to know me. Sometimes, I think that people judge one another by verysuperficialthings, like common interests or beliefs. That's a shame. I know of many people that I disagree with over such matters and really like a lot.

6.Do they measure what is on the outside or the inside (our behavior vs. our heart), and what is the true "you"?

What is in our hearts is not always conveyed to the outside world, but bottom line, we are judged by our actions and even more so, our interactions. I love my mother very much, but our dynamic together is awful. I think that this makes her think that I don't love her as much as I do. I try to be a fair moderator here on the site, but it may not seem to the moderated that I am. In the act of moderation, one always takes other factors into account, that the moderated might not know about. But bottom line, even though we know how we feel, others will always judge you by how theyinterpretyour actions.


 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    14 years ago

Hi Perrie,

...others will always judge you by how theyinterpretyour actions...

That is the big challenge of interaction... Knowing ourselves well enough so that what we try to convey (by our actions and words) end up being an accurate representation of who we really are... and then knowing that no matter how well we may represent our true selves... our representations are subject to interpretation(and misinterpretation) by others...

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Hate and cruelty are alsocommon animal emotions and behaviors... Curiously, these emotions and behaviors are sometimespromotedby people whoclaimadherenceto a philosophy or religion which purports the goodness of love and kindness.

This is because of fear. They feel that those who think differently from them, invalidates their beliefs, so they become fearful and hateful. There is no room to say, it's OK to believe as you do, I will behave the way that I believe is right.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

knowing that no matter how well we may represent our true selves... ourrepresentationsare subject tointerpretation(andmisinterpretation) by others...

This is true. It is also true that we can't always represent ourselves for various reasons. I may have to do something, while acting without full disclosure. This may be because of a confidence given, or because full disclosure would only make matters worse for someone else. It could be a matter of internal ethics that someone else doesn't find important or know about. It is always hard to convey our true self, since life gets in the way.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    14 years ago

Each of us is ultimately alone...

Absolutely!!! And that ispreciselythe point I try to make in my wordy descriptions about the difficulties of communication.

There is a separation between an individual and other individuals that is recognized in a way that other animals do not seem capable of expressing.

I think this is to some degree because "other animals" are usually focused on the basics of survival, whereas our (so called)superiorreasoning capabilities gives us other more superfluous things to think about.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    14 years ago

This is because of fear.

True! I think it is interesting to ponder what we fear, and why we fear it.

They feel that those who think differently from them, invalidates their beliefs, so they become fearful and hateful.

I also think that's very true... But ... If simply holding a differing belief "invalidates" someone else's belief, that doesn't say much for the basis of the invalidated belief.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Each of us is ultimately alone, and this sense of separation causes fear and envy.

John,I thinkthat actually,this leads actually toisolation.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    14 years ago

Actually Perrie, I think what John is saying (well... whether it is or not, it is certainly what I am trying to say) is that whether we like it or not, each of us travels trough life in the spaceship of our own body... our mind... the thing we think of as us, is captive withing that "body spaceship"... we send messages to each other (though our words and actions) across the void of space... but none of us can ever "truly" bring another individual into our own personal spaceship... and none of us can be sure that the messages we mean to convey are interpreted as we want them to be interpreted.

Kind of anesotericidea... but that is how I look at interaction with others.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I get that. I have often felt that way. We enter this world alone and leave it the same way. On that trip through life, we try to get across our inner selves to those around us. Even a forum such as this, is an attempt to get across who we are and what is important to us. That is why I enjoy these kinds of exchanges. It gives the people we interact with here, a bit of our inner workings and hopefully a better idea of who we are.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I've been thinking about this today. If you belong to a faith that says, what I believe is the only way to believe, then you will have fear and even hate for those who believe differently.

If your faith says, there are many paths to truth. This is the path that I take, but yours will get you there, too, then there is no fear, and the best of a belief system comes through.

But at the end of the day, an awful amount of religion is happenstance. We are just born into it, and never give it a second thought.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    14 years ago

If your faith says, there are many paths to truth. This is the path that I take, but yours will get you there, too...

Or perhaps one can even say, "I believe there is only one path, and it is my path. You are entitled to your path, even if I feel it is misguided... your path does notinterferewith my path, so I wish you piece and happiness on your journey.

We are just born into it, and never give it a second thought.

That problem exists in much more than religion. We see it everywhere... I think it would be good to see much more than one or two thoughts on any serious subject. In fact, I think it is good to be self-skeptical... continuously challenging and reviewing all of my beliefs.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

In fact, I think it is good to be self-skeptical... continuously challenging and reviewing all of my beliefs.

I agree, but I think that is where we get into that fear factor, especially for those with faith. To challenge those core beliefs, they might fear is to challenge the very underpinnings of who and what they are.


 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    14 years ago

Well... I gotta hand it to you for unmitigated candor Mike.

3)Who do we value the most and why?

Nobody. I don't value anything at all. Everything is worthless, everyone is worthless, and in the end, it will all equal nothing.

That was pretty evident from your first two answers... While I don't share your "everyone and everything is worthless" outlook, I do agree... "in the end, it will all equal nothing." Actually, I would say... In the end it will still be whatever it is... but there will be no one around to value it.

BTW- I am gullible... really really gullible... Anything that doesn't have a flashing neon sign on it saying, "This is a joke"... I take seriously... really.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Many different issues here Mal, and I sure as hell ain't one to take either position, atheistic or christian, for I am neither, I think.

But isn't this the main difference between the two?

Atheists believe ""in the end, it will all equal nothing."

And Christians (other religions, though not all) believe that there is something after the end, and that something is entered through some sort of "judgment."

I do think hate is rooted in fear, but mostly in physical fear. After all, as so succinctly put by Mike, we are animals and the one underlying, most basic need is for security from physical attack and/or death.

It's why politicians so often play on "security" to get elected. It is a basic fear. And one which is constantly manipulated by those who wish for personal wealth and power.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Mike,

Your so full of shit! LOL! You like people. As a matter of fact, you are one of the easiest going people I know. You just have your own code that you adhere to. But I know that you do value friendships and that you value your family.

Hey, but I don't want to ruin your tough guy image. So everyone ignore my last comment.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Now that is a very different answer...

atheistic or christian, for I am neither, I think.

That's because you grew up on Long Island. We all think we're a bit of everything, LOL!

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    14 years ago

Hi Terry,

Nice to hear from you...

or death

Death can come in may different ways... Fear of death by physical attack is compelling... compelling enough to inspire hatred... But... whether death comes by an attack or simply the passage of time... If someone takes comfort in the notion of an afterlife... then anything threatening that belief may beperceivedas an attack. As an atheist (technically an agnostic), I've discovered that some "believers" seem to be offended simply because they know I don't share their beliefs... as if I have somehow attacked them.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   seeder  MalamuteMan    14 years ago

Well... pseudo-morality doesn't sound real appealing to me either... but I am not exactly sure what it is... or what you think it is, anyway... Can you elaborate???

I really don't have a high opinion of people...

Also, you may have very good reasons for not having "a high opinion of people"... but I find that a curiously general... I am interested in why you feel that way, and if there are exceptions...

 
 

Who is online



84 visitors