╌>

DERSHOWITZ BLASTS ZIMMERMAN PROSECUTION: 'NOT ONLY IMMORAL, BUT STUPID'

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  wmolaw  •  14 years ago  •  46 comments

DERSHOWITZ BLASTS ZIMMERMAN PROSECUTION: 'NOT ONLY IMMORAL, BUT STUPID'

The arrest affidavit did not mention the photograph, or the bleeding, gashes, and bruises on Zimmermans head. Professor Alan Dershowitz of Harvard Law School stated upon release of the arrest affidavit that it was so thin that it wont make it past a judge on a second degree murder charge everything in the affidavit is completely consistent with a defense of self-defense.

After the release of the photo, however, Dershowitz went much further, telling Breitbart News that if the prosecutors did have the photo and didnt mention it in the affidavit, that would constitute a grave ethical violation, since affidavits are supposed to contain all relevant information.

Dershowitz continued, An affidavit that willfully misstates undisputed evidence known to the prosecution is not only unethical but borders on perjury because an affiant swears to tell not only the truth, but the whole truth, and suppressing an important part of the whole truth is a lie."

We know that prosecutors lie, that they hide evidence, both at the state and federal level. Seems pretty clear that this entire prosecution, bypassing a grand jury, bullshit affidavits, that this is clearly politically, and racially motivated.

After all, Zimmerman is a "white hispanic" so it's pretty clear he is racist. Aren't all whites, even if they are hispanic also? I wonder if that includes "white blacks" like our president? ARe they racist as well?

So many issues to ferret out, eh?

Link here


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   seeder  wmolaw    14 years ago

LOL, yeah, right.

Hmmmmm, let me consider this, Dershowitz, generally on the defense side of criminal trials, participates in one of the most successful criminal defenses in modern times,

and you think that makes him immoral?

Funny, most folks who have a clue understand that criminal defense lawyers protect all of us, not just their clients.

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    14 years ago

Funny, most folks who have a clue understand that criminal defense lawyers protect all of us, not just their clients.

Good point!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

I don't think you can characterize Dershowitz's position as "support for torture" . He was merely not paying lip service to the purist position that all torture is bad under any circumstance .



[[In a 60 Minutes report, Dershowitz tells Correspondent Mike Wallace that torture is inevitable. "We can't just close our eyes and pretend we live in a pure world," he says.

After the events of Sept. 11, with many al Qaida members in custody, Dershowitz says he wants to bring the debate to the forefront. He gave the "ticking bomb" scenario - a person refusing to tell when and where a bomb will go off as an example of the type of case warranting torture.]]

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    14 years ago

I agree with Senator Mccain that torture doesn't work and that someone being tortured will give you what you want to hear, making his information of no value. There are other ways tocollect information. Also agree with Mccain thatwater boarding is torture.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

So your saying that torture never works ? Are you really willing to take that position even in the above "ticking bomb" scenario ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[ First, Dershowitz's position is that torture is justifiable in some circumstance, thus he is arguing for its validity-- in other words, by definition he supports torture. ]]

This is a black/white way of classifying things . There are all kinds of grey areas in the middle but taking such a purist position just ignores them .

[[ "Interrogate" with all the "purpose" that you like. If you do not already know the information you're attempting to elicit, then ultimately other means must be used to verify the information you elicit. ]]

That depends on what you are trying to accomplish . If you are trying to establish a court case then I agree . But if you are trying only to stop a terrorist attack then any lead can be followed up immediately . These issues of immediate life or death consequences are a situation apart .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

If you're gonna fault Dershowitz for that minor "support" for the "ticking bomb" scenario then you are indeed a purist . Does that mean you have your head in the clouds or elsewhere ? Usually there is little difference ...

Likewise as to your observation about the Constitution . There are different levels of protection for US citizens and foreign nationals . There are down to earth reasons for that .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Rich, there was no reason for you to make that ass comment. Removed as a CoC violation.

OK Perrie . ,
I altered my comment . I think it now meets whatever standards you are using . But frankly I am not sure what your standards are anymore ...

Rich,

My standards are the CoC. Your current comment looks fine.

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    14 years ago

Senator Mccain understandsfully about what torture can accomplish and states that it doesn't work.

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    14 years ago

My only weapon against mytorturers would be my life which I with hate, would bestubborn to death. Alsoescapingtorture through death.

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    14 years ago

HRF Praises Senator McCains Stand Against Torture

Senator McCain stated that information provided by torture is deliberately misleading. Mistreatment of enemy prisoners endangers our own troops, who might someday be held captive

C. Dixon Osburn, Director of Law & Security at Human Rights First, praised Senator McCains comments: Interrogators and intelligence experts agree that torture is counterproductive, unreliable, illegal and immoral. Senator McCain knows from personal experience that no nation should ever condone torture.

Senator McCain stated on the floor of the Senate today, It is difficult to overstate the damage that any practice of torture or cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment by Americans does to our national character and historical reputation to our standing as an exceptional nation among the countries of the world.

McCain concluded, What is at stake here is the very idea of America the America whose values have inspired the world and instilled in the hearts of its citizens the certainty that, no matter how hard we fight, no matter how dangerous our adversary, in the course of vanquishing our enemies we do not compromise our deepest values. We are America, and we hold ourselves to a higher standard. That is what is really at stake

~LINK~


 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    14 years ago

As I understand it thePOW's gave up minimal information not ticking bomb information.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

No, it doesnt matter what the circumstances are. Torture is ineffective and morally reprehensible, as is support for it, under any circumstances. I can tell you that if you put a person in a situation like that, they will do anything to make it stop, and the truth isnt any certainty whatsoever. In fact, any truth that comes from torture is a lucky by product at best.

As far as Dersh's comments on Zim though, i tend to agree, as it pertains to tampering with or withholding evidence. That is unacceptable, and makes a farce of the entire system. Are people so desperate to vilify white people that they are willing to charge somebody with a crime when they already know he is innocent? Apparently they are just that desperate.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

I would say it is extremely easy to overstate the civilian casualties in war. You just did right here. I'm not clear on why you are indignant on the topic of McCain standing against torture. Should he just be cool with it like many of the members on this forum, who havent been in circumstances even close to those he experienced? Perhaps you know something he doesnt on the topic, but i havent seen it yet.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Peter, spot on.

Actually, we do have a member who can speak about this, from experience and he told me that it doesn't work. He went through many years of it in Nam. I will try to get him to say something about this, but the experience has left him with very painful memories and he finds it hard to talk about, but very upsetting to read.

Sometimes you have to walk a mile in someone else's shoes.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

"Estimates of deaths, from 1 to 5 million. It would take you about 2 seconds to check that out."

If i looked even more closely, i would have found out that it was a war, and people die in droves. Crazy, ay?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

*Yawn*

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Not really. You just arent making a solid argument.

From what i can tell, you are saying that somebody who was in a war, was a POW, and was tortured, has no credibility on the topic because he may not have had any sensitive information to reveal when tortured and because he was a soldier who might have killed civilians. What i am really reading is that McCain was a horrible person for having been a POW pilot, and that you are overstating civilian casualties as it pertains to his personal involvement in order to argue against him, for some reason i cant quite fathom presently.

I might have missed something though. Enlighten me if i did.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Can you show me how many people McCain was responsible for killing, and how many were civilians? If not, then it is your credibility that suffers, since it was your speculation that i was specifically taking exception to.

Anyway, let's see...a soldier does have a military responsibility, and it does not impugn his moral credibility whatsoever. Now in contrast, suggesting that torture is a temporary discomfort, which you did above, does suggest no moral compass or credibility.

Do you recognize the following?

(1) Persons taking no active part in the hostilities, including members of armed forces who have laid down their arms and those placed hors de combat by sickness, wounds, detention, or any other cause, shall in all circumstances be treated humanely, without any adverse distinction founded on race, colour, religion or faith, sex, birth or wealth, or any other similar criteria.

To this end the following acts are and shall remain prohibited at any time and in any place whatsoever with respect to the above-mentioned persons:
(a) violence to life and person, in particular murder of all kinds, mutilation, cruel treatment and torture;
(b) taking of hostages;
(c) outrages upon personal dignity, in particular humiliating and degrading treatment;
(d) the passing of sentences and the carrying out of executions without previous judgment pronounced by a regularly constituted court, affording all the judicial guarantees which are recognized as indispensable by civilized peoples.

Pretty cut and dry really.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

That sounds about right i would say.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

And after you killed a few thousand civilians, and your fellow pilots killled a few hundred thousand, then you can stay out of the pulpit as to lectures about the morality of inflicting temporary discomfort on terrorist mass murderers.

Okay, i am willing to move on from that. I get that you were generalizing in an attempt to bolster your point. Personally, i would have preferred actual fact if you are going to employ that tactic though.

Anyway, it is a moral issue. Warfare equals death. I'm sure everybody agrees on that point. Is killing a moral issue? Perhaps. I'm not sold on that per se. I would say that warfare is an eventuality that steps outside the realm of morality. Most wars are set along religious and racial lines in order to gain popular support. A total grey area in my opinion. The reason behind the conflict provides the moral basis or lack thereof for any armed conflict. The reason for a war may be immoral, but a soldiers duty isnt. There is a clear distinction in that regard. However, when a soldier goes off on his/her own, then moral issues surface.

However, morality is a subjective term anyway, based on the accepted morality of a society. In ours, and in the international community at large, any act designed specifically to maim or injure permanently, mentally or physically, is considered immoral, and is specifically handled in the Geneva Convention and international law. It has been accepted by almost everybody as immoral, and how could it not be? Would you want to be tortured? Probably not. I would bet you would be willing to face death to protect something you care bout though. There is the divide. People are willing to die for a cause, be it religion, country, family, whatever, but nobody fights with the acceptance of potentially being tortured.

So there is the subjective morality of it all.

Now the practical. You get no certainty of results from torture anyway, and, you allow yourself to become the same as the enemy you hate and loathe all in one fell swoop. You cant be free if you accept stripping the basic humanity of anybody, enemy or not.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

They dont seem to ignore it at all. They simply try to find acceptable solutions. Torture isnt one of those. It isnt a leftie/rightie thing anyway. McCain isnt a leftie. Nor are many, many who would agree that torture is unacceptable.

Really though, anybody who does think it's cool should be subjected to that "temporary discomfort" themselves, just to make sure their beliefs are as firm and strong as they proclaim.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

You make me uncomfortable like a person sitting next to a pervert would be uncomfortable. He doesn't shine as a beacon of morality either.



Is there a reason you are attaching the (im)morality of torture with the (im)morality of "perversion"? In what way does that apply here outside of presenting a poorly veiled attack on the character of a poster, with no evidence to support that attack? If Iar had a history of defined "perversion", then i suppose the point could be argued as valid, even though it would still be a subversion of COC here on this site.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

"should be subjected to killing just to make sure their beliefs are as firm and strong as they proclaim."

Subjected to the attempt. Done that.

Anyway, you arent even making apt comparisons. Try again.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

and that reason is what?

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

I dont think you really read what i said. Or at least, you didnt process it properly. That's fine though. As you say, another dead end.

Now, facing death is a different story. I would agree that people willing to send young men and women to their deaths should be required to face the same circumstances.

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    14 years ago

Sine when do we have the right to treat POW anyway we feelnecessary. There are rules stated in the Geneva Convention that we are members of that apply towagingwar. We areafterall a nation of laws are we not?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

If Robert is delusional enough to believe that opposition to torture makes one comparable to a "pervert" (and I'd suggest you admonish him on that Bruce, since the violation of the CoC in that suggestion isn't even marginal, but blatant)

Tit for tat is no excuse for the antagonistic use of profanity . I am deleting the profanity because you have stepped over the line

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

He's an idiot. I get them mixed up.



What he actually is, is a man who was tortured on and off for seven years. He isnt an idiot, but i would say he is a bit unbalanced, and that clearly is directly related to his time spent as a POW, as are some of his more prominent physical issues. The fact that he was a strong enough individual to retain some shreds of sanity, and cared enough to try to live as a public servant, whether or not you agree with his specific beliefs or policies, is a testimony to him and not a lessening of what he experienced. I doubt most would be so well adjusted after facing and experiencing such extremely adverse situations for such a very, very long time.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

I think you made a good point Robert . In fact it seems that this comment :

accused you [in an offhanded way] of being a "torture apologist" . That is what started the entire shitstorm which followed . However , I can't delete parts of that comment since it is germane to the discussion even if it might be inaccurate . I can't get into it more than that without losing some semblance of objectivity to do further moderating . [Does someone else want to take over the moderating of this thread ?]

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    14 years ago

Robert actually started all of that by comparing Iar to a pervert that makes him uncomfortable. Iar then later responded as detailed above.

Up until all that, i feel the conversation was going along quite well with differing points of view and a reasonable level of debate compared to what we have seen lately.

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    14 years ago

My point is that their torture and brain washing methods, I believe failed in the long run.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   seeder  wmolaw    14 years ago

Fascinating exchanges, when you take away the fluff.

Several interesting statements which deserve exploration.

By Iar:

1. Torture doesn't work. As Mike has pointed out quite clearly, it depends on what information you are seeking. Iar has, essentially admitted this in his last post. It may work for those who are just giving away money, or something of nominal to medium meaning to them, but may not work for something more important, their family, their religion, etc. It does seem to me, without discussing the ethical nature of torture, that coupled with extremely experienced interrogators (the guys who are supposedly able to tell who's lying when) and today's tech, that torture may well work better than we are told. A question arises, are we really being told of the available methods, both brute force and tech being used?

2. What is torture? Waterboarding is, sleep deprivation is not. Starvation? Deprivation of water? Placing a person who has severe acrophobia, in a completely open glass elevator 80 stories up? How about lying to the person? Mother being tortured, daughter kidnapped, etc. You get the idea. We can help, but only if .... How about pissing on their Koran? Or taking it away from them? The list, the range, goes on and on and on.

Did anyone even try to define "torture?" Or is that just an impossibility?

3. Constitutional protections should be afforded all persons, regardless of citizenship? Huh? Iar clearly you don't mean this. What I suspect you mean is that we should provide SOME of the protections to all of those individuals with whom we deal. Otherwise, you are on a slippery slope to nowhere. Not to mention the fact that if we allow OTHERS to treat persons in an unconstitutional manner and we have the capacity, ability to prevent that, are we not undertaking the action ourselves? Take that from an individual situation to a societal/country situation and the problem becomes quite clear.

4. If you don't believe ONE thing a person says/asserts, that vitiates all other assertions/statements/positions which that person can ever take. You don't really mean that, do you Iar? Seriously? Merely because you happen to disagree with Dershowitz on one issue, that means you will not listen to him on any other issue? Hate to say it, but that's plain dumb, and I'm sure you know it. Just evidences the polarization of our current society.

Each of these issues really deserves a thread of its own, no doubt about that.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   seeder  wmolaw    14 years ago

Lots of good issues, once you get past the sniping.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

You continue to characterize Dershowitz's statement as that he "suggested that torture could be moral" .
But that's not what he said :
[[In a 60 Minutes report, Dershowitz tells Correspondent Mike Wallace that torture is inevitable. "We can't just close our eyes and pretend we live in a pure world," he says.]]

Saying it is inevitable is not the same as saying it is the right thing to do . In the 1st case he could be saying that it should be avoided if possible but that it is going to happen anyway . It is the legal consequences of performing torture that are the issue .

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   seeder  wmolaw    14 years ago

Well, now you've added something, what does "within our purview" mean? In the discussion we were having before, it meant those which we have captured in war!

So, let's consider. The second amendment? You on for that? How about the fourth amendment? And tell me, how about the fifth amendment? Or, prior to capture, the 8th amendment? How about the 7th amendment? The list can go on and on.

As I said, you are not considering what you said.

Note also, I find it hilarious that so many folks read the word "person" in the context of the 14th amendment to mean, well, PERSON, but that many of those same folks read that same word in the context of the 2nd amendment as meaning a militia, LOL.

In what regard? In that you'd try to use the argument that extending constitutional protections to all individuals inside our country or under our control should justify imposing our constitution anywhere its protections are not offered?

Well, frankly you are altering your premise here, but even with your altered premise, you have no issue with rendition? Hell, we can all be and act like angels as long as you have no issue with rendition. Let someone ELSE torture, then kill the sob, someone whom WE turned the a-hole over to.

That China regularly violates our principles of individual freedom isn't an argument for invading China, nor an argument that we're violating our principles bynotinvading China.

Huh? Well, let me ask you this, given that should we just do business as normal with, for example, countries that clearly violate our principles?

Or should we at least take some stand, economic sanctions, etc., etc? And to put this in context, should we engage in rendition if we capture a terrorist which China is looking for?

Or name your country.

I'd suggest that if he were serious about his earlier suggestion that torture is legitimate, let's just put Zimmerman on the rack and see if he confesses that he shot Martin without provocation. And, of course, everyone here talking about how "torture works" should be happy at the inevitable end result of Zimmerman's confession as "the truth". Right? No?

Oh, come on, have to call bullshit on that one. NO matter how you try NOT to say it (you've already back tracked significantly!), there is a difference between an American citizen under US law, and one who is NOT and was captured on a battlefield in a war.

And, as I said, your position now that if you disagree with one area of a person's statements, then you disagree with them all, makes no sense and, frankly, is dumb.

Following your logic, everyone who disagrees with the mental gymnastics (and ethical ones as well) that Obama engages in, would be correct in determining everything that sob says/does is bullshit, a danger to our Country, etc.

Yet, you just ranted against this very issue a week ago! Come on, a bit of consistency here, and hell, I've even agreed with Obama on one or two issues, though it might take me awhile to come up with them.

Beginning to see the problems, here, or does it need more ink?

I would posit it does not need more ink, but more thought - on your part. Much of your posts on this issue seem knee jerk, which is not your usual persona.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   seeder  wmolaw    14 years ago

As far as I know, no one has tried to do so yet.

How can one discuss "torture" without a definition?

Or are we all going to pretend we are Potter Stewart?

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   seeder  wmolaw    14 years ago

True.

Iar, can you point us to where Dershowitz actually supported engaging in torture?

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   seeder  wmolaw    14 years ago

Damn, never even saw your reply! Sorry if I was duplicative.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   seeder  wmolaw    14 years ago

I operated from the understanding that most people have an inherent belief that torture means the intentional infliction of pain upon an unwilling participant for the purpose of eliciting information, confessions, or statements to be used as propaganda, or for the purpose of punishing the person so subjected.

I know you said "most" Iar, but just for the record, many torture others because they fucking enjoy it.

I have always laughed at definitions of "torture." Tell me, is being shot in the brain "torture?" Do we even know the relative length of time the person shot experiences? Is it possible the person experiences each Planck length of penetration as the .45 hollow point expands as it moves through their brain tissue?

And the holes in such definitions? Are such definitions mean to address individuals, or groups as a whole?

(2)severe mental pain or suffering means the prolonged mental harm caused by or resulting from

--(A)the intentional infliction or threatened infliction of severe physical pain or suffering;
--(B)the administration or application, or threatened administration or application, of mind-altering substances or other procedures calculated to disrupt profoundly the senses or the personality;


So, just threatening to shoot someone full of sodium thiopental is "torture?" According to this definition, it most certainly is, and the literature supports it.

And the UN definition is even more of a joke (considering that the huge majority of members of that bullshit entity pays no attention to it.
This part is especially hilarious:
or intimidating or coercing him or a third person, or for any reason based on discrimination of any kind,
Hmmm, so you have a terrorist and you tell that person that you will not allow his son to attend X school because his daddy/mommy is an islamic radical, and that is torture?
Of course, I understand that given the UN, if it's a western country, EVERYTHING is torture, if it's a third world shit hole, nothing is torture.
I operated from the understanding that most people have an inherent belief that torture means the intentional infliction of pain upon an unwilling participant for the purpose of eliciting information, confessions, or statements to be used as propaganda, or for the purpose of punishing the person so subjected
I like yours much more, as long as we limit it to physical pain.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

[[ Dershowitz's argument is formulated precisely with that end in mind. ]]

And you are basing that on what ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

Iar ; What is the source of that quote ?

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   seeder  wmolaw    14 years ago

Iar:

Don't take this incorrectly, but to say that such behavior is "immoral" is a bit bizarre, imo. Hell, we see much worse every day, who determines what is, or is not "moral?"

Legal, I'm going with you okay, but "moral?"

I also don't see where you are quoting anything where Dershowitz is actually supporting/advocating torture, just reality and making the best of a bad situation.

In my new book, "Shouting Fire: Civil Liberties in a Turbulent Age," I offer a controversial proposal designed to stimulate debate about this difficult issue. Under my proposal, no torture would be permitted without a "torture warrant" being issued by a judge.

An application for a torture warrant would have to be based on the absolute need to obtain immediate information in order to save lives coupled with probable cause that the suspect had such information and is unwilling to reveal it.

The suspect would be given immunity from prosecution based on information elicited by the torture. The warrant would limit the torture to nonlethal means, such as sterile needles, being inserted beneath the nails to cause excruciating pain without endangering life.

It may sound absurd for a distinguished judge to be issuing a warrant to do something so awful.

But consider the alternatives: Either police would torture below the radar screen of accountability, or the judge who issued the warrant would be accountable. Which would be more consistent with democratic values?

All he seems to be saying is that we know it is going to happen one way or the other, which, for purposes of argument, would be the best way to go?

So, again, I am not seeing where he says that such activity should be sanctioned, period.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

Iar ,

From that same source (written by Dershowitz) :

[[But consider the alternatives: Either police would torture below the radar screen of accountability, or the judge who issued the warrant would be accountable. Which would be more consistent with democratic values?

Those opposed to the idea of a torture warrant argue -- quite reasonably -- that establishing such a precedent would legitimize torture and make it easier to extend its permissible use beyond the ticking bomb case.

Those who favor the torture warrant argue that the opposite would be true: By expressly limiting the use of torture only to the ticking bomb case and by requiring a highly visible judge to approve, limit and monitor the torture, it will be far more difficult to justify its extension to other institutions.]]

That is a "rubber meets the road" argument . If you can't accept that as an honest attempt to deal with this difficult issue , it is only because your head is in some holier-than-thou cloud where reality does not intrude .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

Yes , I will answer your question . There are many situations where torture should not be applied , in fact the vast
majority of cases . Dersh's argument is that inexorable extreme pressure of certain situations should be codified
into law . That would mean the interrogators would be only be permitted to step over the line in the most extreme
cases . And only with the approval of a judge . This codification may end up only being a symbolic act since it might never be employed . But it has its value to those who are responsible for interrogations instead of leaving them to face consequences all alone .

US history is full of extreme situations in which civil liberties were temporarily put aside to react to potential dangers . Even the great Abraham Lincoln suspended the writ of Habeas Corpus during the Civil War .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

All right . To sum up my position : Law is not reality . It is a codification of a desired ideal . When shit hits fan what
often happens is that the Law is ignored . Later on , after the dust [shit ?] clears , some legal scholars start writing proposals for new code to cover the new situation . Big events like Enron , Lehman Brothers and 9/11 almost always result in new laws being written to cover what was done after the fact . That is the ugly reality .
We are still working out the details for 9/11 , GMO patents , and many other things .

 
 

Who is online



84 visitors